7/30/2016

ChooseYourBestPneumaticCylinderSensorHere

EE World Online Engineering White Papers DataSheet PRO MCAD Central

SEARCHHERE

July 29, 2016

HOME

VIDEOS

ARTICLES

SUPPLIERS

3D CAD MODELS

WEBINARS

LEADERSHIP

ENGINEERING RESOURCES

Home > Design World Articles > Choose Your Best Pneumatic Cylinder Sensor Here

EVENTS

Enews Sign Up

Choose Your Best Pneumatic Cylinder Sensor Here

April 19, 2010 Design World Staff : 0 Comments

By Jack Moermond, Product Specialist, Balluff, Inc. Florence, Ky.

In the field of automation, pneumatic cylinders need reliable sensors to detect piston position. Check out the pros and
cons of these most widely used sensor types before you buy.

Design World Digital Edition

Cut-away view of a pneumatic cylinder shows a magnetic ring for energizing magnetic field
sensors.

When used as prime movers, pneumatic cylinders are durable, relatively inexpensive, and simple to apply. In order for
a pneumatic cylinder to work in a control system, however, discrete sensors are needed to deliver electrical signals to
a controller to report the pistons position. One kind of sensor uses external electro-mechanical limit switches or
inductive proximity switches to detect metal flags on the moving parts of the machine. The disadvantages here
include the cost and complexity of the brackets and hardware, the difficulty of making adjustments, and the larger
size of the overall assembly. Also, the external hardware can be damaged and misaligned during normal use or
accidental impact.
A more widely used method has magnetically actuated switches or sensors mounted on the sides of the cylinder or
placed in a slot on the cylinder body. Sensors can detect the magnetic field of an internal magnet on the moving
piston through the aluminum wall of the pneumatic cylinder. The magnetic sensors typically detect end-of-stroke in
either direction, however, multiple sensors can also detect several discrete positions along the length of a cylinder.
Reed switches:
The simplest magnetic-field sensor is a reed switch. It contains two ferromagnetic nickel and iron reed elements in an
evacuated, hermetically sealed glass tube to minimize contact arcing. When an axially aligned magnet approaches the
switch, its magnetic force closes the reeds. The magnet typically generates at least a 50 Gauss force to overcome the
return force or spring memory of the reed elements.

Browse the most

current issue of Design
World and back issues in
an easy to use high
quality format. Clip,
share and download
with the leading design
engineering magazine today.
ViewBackIssues

Subscribe

Forum for Electronics

Covering Microcontrollers, DSP, Networking,
Analog and Digital Design, RF, Power Electronics,
PCB Routing and much more

Reed Switch

http://www.designworldonline.com/chooseyourbestpneumaticcylindersensorhere/

The Engineering Exchange is a global educational

networking community for engineers.

1/4

7/30/2016

ChooseYourBestPneumaticCylinderSensorHere
networking community for engineers.
Connect, share, and learn today

Tweetsby@DesignWorld
DesignWorld
@DesignWorld
Importantfactorstoconsiderwhenchoosinga
#rotaryindexerow.ly/RoC0302EGnz

Reed switches are the least expensive and simplest type of magnetic field sensors. Magnets
on the pistons activate the reed switches when they are in close proximity.

Reed switches are inexpensive, require no standby power, and can function with both ac and dc electrical loads.
However, they are relatively slow, so they may not respond fast enough for some high-speed applications. Since the
switches are mechanical devices with moving parts, they have a finite number of operating cycles before they
eventually fail. Switching high-current loads can further reduce life expectancy. Also, low-cost reed switches
occasionally deliver unwanted, multiple switching points as the twin lobes of certain magnets pass by. Lastly, reed
switches installed in high shock and vibration applications may experience contact bounce or even physical damage. In
many automated factories, hundreds of reed switches are a major source of unplanned downtime; failures can occur
hourly and represent a continuous maintenance headache and lost production.

Embed

ViewonTwitter

DesignWorldNetwork
493,958likes

Hall-Effect sensors: Hall-Effect sensors are solid-state electronic devices. They contain a voltage amplifier and a
comparator that drives a switching output. In operation, a steady dc current passes through the thin Hall-Effect chip.
The electrons distribute uniformly across the element; no potential difference develops between the output
terminals located on opposite sides of the chip. But, when a radially oriented magnet approaches, its field, which is
perpendicular to the current vector in the Hall element, forces the electrons toward one side of the chip. This
unbalance generates a V drop across the Hall-Effect element proportional to the strength of the magnetic field. The
sensor output switches on when the generated voltage reaches the comparators threshold.

LikePage

1friendlikesthis

Hall-Effect Sensor

DesignWorldNetwork
15hrs

Couldyourcompanyoperatewithout
itsdata?http://ow.ly/f64Q302EK2D

Couldyourcompanyoper...
Whatdothesenameshaveincommo...
DESIGNWORLDONLINE.COM

11

Comment

Share

Design World
Follow
GMR sensors comprise a ferromagnetic material that changes resistance in a magnetic field.
This property lets it trigger an electronic circuit under sufficient magnetic field strength.

+1

+ 2,821

...

Since Hall-Effect sensors are electronic devices, they have no moving parts. Unlike a reed switch, their response time
does not depend on magnetic forces overcoming mechanical inertia. They operate faster and resist shock and
vibration better.
However, it might not always be easy to upgrade from reed switches to Hall- Effect sensors, because the magnetic
field orientation of a cylinder designed for reed switches may be axial, compared to radial for a Hall-Effect sensor. So
the Hall device may not operate properly when activated by an axially oriented magnet.
Furthermore, Hall-Effect sensors typically have comparatively low sensitivity; the magnetic field strength must be in
the order of 30 to 60 Gauss. Some cylinder magnets designed to work with reed switches are simply not that strong.
Finally, some inexpensive Hall-Effect sensors can switch twice because they detect both poles of the magnet, not just
one or the other.

http://www.designworldonline.com/chooseyourbestpneumaticcylindersensorhere/

2/4

7/30/2016

ChooseYourBestPneumaticCylinderSensorHere

AMR sensors: Another type of solid-state, magnetic-field sensor is called an anisotropic magnetoresistive or AMR
sensor. Its operating principle of is simple: the sensor element changes resistance in a magnetic field, which in turn,
changes a bias current in the sensing element. A comparator circuit detects the change and switches the sensors
output. Compared to Hall-Effect sensing technology, which generates a tiny V -level signal, the magnetoresistive
element responds with a more robust 3 to 4% change in bias current. This has better noise immunity and experiences
less false tripping.

GMR Technology

GMR sensors comprise a ferromagnetic material that changes resistance in a magnetic field.
This property lets it trigger an electronic circuit under sufficient magnetic field strength

Magnetoresistive sensors are about 200 times more responsive than a typical Hall Effect sensor to a given magnetic
field strength; the practical magnetic field strength required to operate a magnetoresistive sensor can be as low as 15
Gauss. Improvements in magnetoresistive technology now let these sensors detect both axially and radially
magnetized magnets.
In addition to the rugged solid-state construction, magnetoresistive sensors have better noise immunity, smaller
physical size, and lower mechanical hysteresis (the difference in switch point when approaching the sensor from
opposite directions). Quality manufacturers of magnetoresistive sensors have overload protection, short-circuit
protection, and reverse-connection protection. Unlike Hall Effect sensors, magnetoresistive sensors do not double
switch, because their higher sensitivity lets them remain in the on state as the low-strength portion of the magnetic
field passes under the sensor. Hall-Effect sensors are less sensitive and will often drop out when they sense a
weaker portion of a magnetic field located between two stronger areas, then switch on again when the field strength
increases.
Leading magnetoresistive sensor manufacturers have developed weld-field immune versions that can operate reliably
in ac welding fields as strong as 200kA/m. They are not electrically damaged nor will they generate false signals. Many
of these welding sensors are available with metallic housings to further guard against hot weld spatter that would
melt a plastic-bodied sensor.
GMR sensors: The most up-to-date magnetic field sensing technology is called giant magnetoresistive or GMR.
Compared to AMR technology, GMR sensors have a more robust reaction to the presence of a magnetic field, at least
10%.
Due to their high sensitivity, less physical chip material is required to construct a practical GMR magnetic field sensor.
So, GRM sensors can be packaged in much smaller housings for short-stroke cylinders, extremely small-bore cylinders,
or miniature pneumatic grippers. Higher-quality GMR sensor manufacturers also add advanced output protection
circuits such as overload protection, short-circuit protection, and reverse connection protection.

Speak Your Mind

http://www.designworldonline.com/chooseyourbestpneumaticcylindersensorhere/

3/4

7/30/2016

ChooseYourBestPneumaticCylinderSensorHere

Name *
Email *
Website
POSTCOMMENT

Solar Power

EE World

Print Subscription

Solar Power World reaches executives,

managers, engineers, installers and
technical professionals involved in the

EE World Network of sites feature industry

experts covering product news and
reviews, EE video, how-to articles, best

Stay Informed. Stay Smart. Stay Ahead.

You're invited to qualify for the fastest
growing design engineering publication on

design, manufacturing, development, and

installation of solar power projects.

practices in electronics design and

electronic datasheet resources.

the market today. Click button below for

additional information.

Visitwebsite

Visitwebsite

Design World
>> Advertising
>> Contact
>> Engineering Jobs
>> Site Map

New/ManageSubscription

Privacy Policy. Copyright 2016 WTWH Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

http://www.designworldonline.com/chooseyourbestpneumaticcylindersensorhere/

4/4