Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
* *
Do Thi Thanh Ha
1
UNIVERSITY OF LANGUAGES AND INTERNATIONAL STUDIES
FACULTY OF ENGLISH LANGUAGE TEACHER EDUCATION
* *
Do Thi Thanh Ha
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS………………………………………………………………i
ABSTRACT……………………………………………………………………………...ii
LIST OF TABLES……………………………………………………………………....iii
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS…………………………………………………………...iv
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
1.1. Rationale……………………………………………………………................1
1.2. Aims of the study……………………………………………………………...1
1.3. Research questions…………………………………………………………….1
1.4. Significance of the study………………………………………………………2
1.5. Scope of the study……………………………………………………………..2
1.6. Organization of the study……………………………………………………...2
2.1. Introduction……………………………………………………………………4
2.2. Use systems……………………………………………………………………4
2.2.1. Four use system…………………………………………………………......4
2.2.2. Five use system……………………………………………………………..6
2.2.3. Six use system………………………………………………………………8
2.2.4. Seven use system…………………………………………………………..10
2.2.5. Eight use system…………………………………………………………...13
2.2.6. Nine use system……………………………………………………………15
CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY
3.1. Introduction…………………………………………………………………..19
3.2. Participants…………………………………………………………………...19
3.3. Data collection instrument…………………………………………………...19
3.4. Data collection procedures…………………………………………………...22
3.5. Data analysis procedures……………………………………………………..22
3
CHAPTER 4: FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION
CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSION
APPENDIX……………………………………………………………………………........43
REFERENCES………………………………………………………………………….......47
4
STATEMENT OF AUTHORSHIP
I hereby state that I: Do Thi Thanh Ha, 06.F.1.E12, being a candidate for the
degree of Bachelor of Arts (TEFL) accept the requirements of the College
relating to the retention and use of Bachelor's Graduation Paper deposited in
the library.
In term of these conditions, I agree that the origin of my paper deposited in the
library should be accessible for the purposes of study and research, in
accordance with the normal conditions established by the librarian for the care,
loan or reproduction of the paper.
Do Thi Thanh Ha
Signed: ………………………………………
Date: ………………………………………...
5
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This graduation paper could not have been completed without the help,
encouragement and support from the people who deserve my gratitude, respect,
affection and appreciation.
First of all, I would like to express my great gratitude to Mr. Pham Xuan
Tho, my respectful supervisor for his careful reading, useful and critical
comments and continual guidance during the time of writing my thesis. His
contribution played an integral part in the completion of my graduation paper.
Without his help, I could not finish this study on time.
I am also greatly indebted to all the teachers in Faculty of English
Language Teacher Education, University of Languages and International
Studies. Vietnam National University, Hanoi for their devotion……Thanks to
them, I have been well-equipped with necessary knowledge and skills which
help me a lot in my study as well as my career in the future.
I wish to thank all of my friends in group 061.E12 as well as those in
Faculty of English Language Teacher Education, University of Languages and
International Studies. Vietnam National University, Hanoi for their support and
encouragement.
My great thank is also given to 150 10th – grade students at Thang long
High school, Hanoi for their willing participation in the study. I highly
appreciate their love for me, their enthusiasm and effort in doing the test..
Finally, my deepest gratitude goes to my family for their great love,
support, comfort and constant encouragement in the hardest times, which gave
me enough strength and determination to fulfill this graduation paper.
6
ABSTRACT
This study is conducted to discover how Vietnamese high school students
master four uses of the English Present Simple Tense and which is the most
problematic use to them. The data collection instrument was a written test
consisting of three tasks done by 150 10th – grade students at Thang Long High
school, Hanoi. The findings pose that the Vietnamese high school students in
this study was quite good at using the PST, and in the four uses, Use 4 (Future
meaning) is the most difficult to them, next came Use 1 (General truths,
permanent situations and fact) and Use 3 (Perceptions, thoughts, feelings or
acknowledgement), and Use 2 (Repeated or habitual actions) is the easiest.
7
LIST OF TABLES
Table 2: Numbers and percentages of correct and incorrect answers for Use 1 in
three tasks.
Table 3: Numbers and percentages of correct and incorrect answers for Use 2 in
three tasks.
Table 4: Numbers and percentages of correct and incorrect answers for Use 3 in
three tasks.
Table 5: Numbers and percentages of correct and incorrect answers for Use 4 in
three tasks.
Table 6: Numbers and percentages of correct and incorrect answers for four uses
in three tasks.
8
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
PST: Present Simple Tense
U: Use
I: Item
T: Task
9
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
10
knowledge and clearer understanding of the PST from the different views of
different linguists. Secondly, the findings of the study will help find out the
most effective ways to teach and learn this tense in Vietnam. Last but not least,
the study may be a useful reference material for both teachers and learners who
want to do further research on this tense.
11
CHAPTER 2. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1. Introduction:
In this chapter, the uses of the PST will be reviewed. Some justifications
will be made before a semantic system of the PST in English including four
main uses is created. It will be used as the theoretical framework for this study.
12
4. Describing series of events: demonstrations, commentaries, instructions,
stories.
E.g. First, I take a bowl and break two eggs into it. Next, Leed passes
Taylor, Taylor shoots - and it’s a goal.
How do I get to the station? –You go straight on to the traffic
lights, and then you turn left.
So I go in to the office, and I see this man.
As can be seen that Use 1 should be divided into two separate uses (to
talk about permanent situations, and things that happen regularly or repeatedly)
to avoid the learners’ confusion. Moreover, in Use 3, the structure “Why don’t
you…?” can also be used to ask for more information besides making
suggestions, and thus, it should be included in this use.
Like Swan (2005), Bourke (2001) also presents four uses of the PST.
According to her, the PST is used:
1. To talk about people’s routines and habits
E.g. David goes for a run every morning.
We always spend the summer in Greece.
2. To talk about things that are permanent or always true, and in zero
conditional sentences
E.g. The office opens at 8.00 every morning.
Water boils at 100ºC.
If I say I love you, I mean it.
3. To talk about official scheduled or timetabled events, e.g. train timetables,
television listings, etc.
E.g. The train arrives in Newcastle at 8.28.
The film starts at 7.
4. With certain verbs, e.g. agree, believe, feel, hate, hear, know, like, love,
prefer, see, smell, taste, understand, etc.
E.g. She doesn’t understand the question.
Not: She isn’t understanding the question.
13
I don’t believe in life after death.
Not: I’m not believing in life after death.
Two differences can be observed here. First, while Bourke (2001)
separated the first and second uses, Swan (2005) groups them together and in
Use 2, Bourke (2001) also mentions the use of zero conditional sentences.
Second, in Use 4, Swan (2005) talks about the use of the PST in series of
events, whereas Bourke (2001) gives a list of verbs used in the PST instead of
the PCT. Although Swan (2005) also mentions some verbs used “around the
present” in his note, this is not so clear and detailed as Bourke’s (2001).
2.2.2. Five use system
Murphy (2001) divides the uses of the PST as follows.
1. To talk about things in general
The PST is used to say that something happens all the time or repeatedly or that
something is true in general.
E.g. Nurses look after patients in hospital.
The earth goes round the sun.
I usually go away at weekends.
2. To say how often things are done
E.g. I get up at 8 o’clock every morning.
Robert usually goes away 2 or 3 times a year.
3. In phrases like: I promise, I agree…
E.g. I promise not to tell him.
I agree with you.
4. To talk about timetables, programs, etc. (for public, transport, cinema, etc.)
E.g. My train leaver at 11.30, so I need to be at the station by 11.15.
What time does the film begin this evening?
5. To talk about people if their plans are fixed like timetables, but the
continuous is more usual for personal arrangements
E.g. I start my new job on Monday.
14
We can see that Murphy’s (2001) system of uses is similar to Swan’s
(2005) above when his Use 1 talks about general things. Furthermore, Use 1 and
Use 2 seem to overlap to some extent. Additionally, Use 3 is not very clear
when it only mentions two verbs “agree” and “promise” while many other verbs
are also used in fixed phrases and structures to talk about the present. Besides,
Use 5 appears to be confusing when he talks about people’s plans and
arrangements at the same time.
Like Murphy, Adamson (2001) also presents five uses of the PST though
there are some differences in his ideas. According to him, the PST is used:
1. To describe the habits and routines
E.g. What do you usually have for breakfast?
I usually eat a carrot and drink a glass of cold water.
2. To describe a series of happenings
E.g. First, you peel an onion and slice it, and then drop the slices into
hot oil and cook for two minutes.
3. To express an opinion and feelings
E.g. Do you like this necklace?
4. For events in the future which are part of prearranged programs or timetables
E.g. That film comes to the theatre this summer.
5. In negative questions with “Why” to ask for information or make suggestion
E.g. Why don’t you like her? (Ask for information)
Why don’t you come and see us? (Make suggestion)
It can be easily seen that Adamson (2001) completely ignores the use of
the PST to talk about general truths or facts even though it is the most common
use of the PST. We can also find some differences between the two linguists’
systems of uses. The first difference is that Adamson (2001) includes one use of
the PST to describe a series of happenings and another use with “Why” to ask
for information or make suggestion, whereas Murphy does not. The second one
is Adamson (2001) generalizes Use 3 of the PST, while Murphy (2001) only
lists some verbs relevant to this use of the PST.
15
2.2.3. Six use system
According to Eastwood (1996), the PST is used for:
1. Thoughts and feelings
E.g. I think so.
I like it.
2. States, things staying the same, facts and things that are true for a long time
E.g. We live quite near.
3. Repeated actions
E.g. We come here every week.
4. In phrases like: I promise, I agree, etc.
E.g. I promise I’ll pay you back tomorrow.
5. In a negative question with “Why” to make a suggestion
E.g. Why don’t we go out?
6. For the future when we are talking about a timetable, usually a public one
E.g. The new term starts next week.
Close (1979) also gives account of a six-use system of the PST.
1. All or anytime not separated from the present
E.g. Paint contains a certain amount of lead.
The Rhine flows between Germany and France.
2. The present period as distinct from the past
In this case, the speaker may be thinking either of an activity that
continues throughout the period or of a whole series of acts performed
throughout the period.
E.g. I live in the country.
We all speak English at home.
3. The present moment
E.g. This tape- recorder is easy to work. Watch what I do. I switch it
on, press this button and it starts. (1)
16
Switch, press and start refer to momentary acts considered as completed at the
moment of speaking. In (1), they are examples of a momentary present,
whereas in:
E.g. I (always) switch off all the lights before I go to bed.
Switch and go are examples of habitual present. The habitual present is often
reinforced by an adverb of frequency, though such adverbs can also be used
with the progressive.
4. The present moment: Declarations
E.g. I declare the meeting open. (formal remark by Chairman)
I pronounce you man and wife. (at a wedding ceremony)
We gladly accept your offer. (declaration of acceptance)
5. Future time, in temporal and conditional clauses
E.g. Mr X will telephone you as soon as he returns.
The police will take your car away if you park it there.
The meeting will be held out of doors unless it rains.
6. Past time, in newspaper headlines, sometimes in narrative and usually in the
synopsis of a novel or a play
(1) Earthquake rocks Nicaragua. (Headline)
(2) Tom stands up on the coach and looks back at his father’s figure.
(Narrative)
(3) That night Romeo sees Juliet alone in her balcony. (A play)
The newspaper article under the headline as in (1) would report the
incident of the past tense, (2) illustrates the use of the so-called HISTORIC
PRESENT; and in a synopsis as in (3), each new development in the story is
usually recorded in the PST.
2.2.4. Seven use system
Alexander (1980) mentions seven basic uses of the PST.
1. Permanent truths
E.g. The sun rises in the East.
Summer follows spring.
17
Gases expand when heated.
2. “The present period”
E.g. My sister works in a bank.
3. Habitual actions
E.g. I get up at 7.00 every morning.
4. Observations and declarations
E.g. I love you, I hate him.
It says here that you are fined.
5. Future reference (for timetable, etc.)
E.g. The concert begins at 8.00 next Friday evening.
6. Instructions
E.g. First, you weigh the ingredients. Next,…
7. Commentaries
E.g. Decker serves to Lance, he shots.
We can see that it would be better if Alexander (1980) grouped Use 6
and Use 7 together because they are both talking about a series of events.
Parrot (2000) shares the same view with Alexander (1980) when he
provides seven uses of the PST for the teaching purpose. According to him, the
PST is used:
1. To talk about repeated events
E.g. I get up early.
He also adds that adverbs of frequency and expressions of repeated time are
often used with this use of the PST.
2. To talk about general facts
E.g. Ice melts at 0 degree Celsius.
18
3. With state verbs referring to state, even when they are temporary, these
include verbs grouped under the following topics.
Existence be, exist
Mental states believe, doubt, know, realize, recognize, suppose,
think, understand
Wants and looks want, like, love, hate, need, prefer
Possession belong, have, possess, own
Senses feel, smell, taste
Appearance appear, look, seem
E.g. I don’t understand.
4. With perception verbs
In this use, he notes that perception verbs (e.g. hear, see, feel) were found
listed with stative verbs. However “can” and “can’t” tend to be used with those
perception verbs more often than the PST.
E.g. Can you hear anything?
5. In running commentaries
Sports commentators use the PST in “running commentaries” on
broadcast sports events. The PST helps save time when the action is fast.
E.g. Chang serves to Sampras and runs to the net.
6. In past narrative
In exceptional circumstances, we can also use the PST to refer to past
time. We sometimes use this tense instead of the Past Simple Tense to create a
sense of immediacy in certain kinds of informal, spoken narrative such as comic
and dramatic story– telling.
E.g. So this man walks into a bar and takes out a gun…
7. Verbs which change things
We also use the PST in making pronouncements which actually change
something. This involves a restricted number of verbs (e.g. arrest, baptize,
declare, pronounce) known as performative verbs.
E.g. I pronounce you man and wife.
19
With this use of the PST, we generally have to have some special authority to
perform these actions.
As can be observed from the two authors’ classifications, except some
similar uses, they have different basis for distinguishing the uses of the PST.
2.2.5. Eight use system
Thomson and Martinet (1987) distinguish eight main uses of the PST.
They are described as follows:
1. The main use of the PST is to express habitual actions;
E.g. He smokes.
Dogs bark.
Cats drink milk.
The PST is often used with adverbs or adverb phrases such as always, never,
occasionally, often, sometimes, usually, every week, on Mondays, twice a year,
etc.
E.g. How often do you wash your hairs?
I go to church on Sundays.
It rains in winter.
or with time clauses expressing routine or habitual actions. Whenever and when
(= whenever) are particularly useful:
E.g. Whenever it rains the roof leaks.
When you open the door a light goes on.
2. It is used, chiefly with the verb say when we are asking about or quoting
from books, notices or very recently received letters.
E.g. What does that notice say?- It says, “No parking”
What does the book say? - It says, “Cook very slowly.”
I see you’ve got a letter from Ann. What does she say?- She says
she is coming to London next week.
Shakespeare says, “Neither a borrower nor a lender be.”
Other verbs of communication are also possible:
E.g. Shakespeare advises us not to borrow or to lend.
20
A notice at the end of the road warns people not to go any further.
3. It can be used in newspaper headlines.
E.g. MASS MURDERER ESCAPES.
PEACE TALKS FAIL.
4. It can be used for the action or narrative.
This is particularly useful when describing the action of a play, opera, etc. and is
often used by radio commentators at sports events, public functions, etc.
E.g. When the curtain rises, Juliet is writing at her desk. Suddenly the
window opens and a masked man enters.
5. It can be used for a planned future action or series of actions, particularly
when they refer to a journey. Travel agents use it a good deal.
E.g. We leave London at 10.00 next Friday and arrive in Paris at 13.00.
We spend two hours in Paris and leave again at 15.00. We arrive in Rome at
19.30, spend four hours in Rome.
6. It must be used instead of the PCT with verbs which cannot be used in the
continuous form, e.g. love, see, believe, etc., so that we can say I love you but
not I am loving you.
7. If it is used in conditional sentences, type 1.
E.g. If I see Ann, I’ll ask her.
Unless you take the brake off, the car won’t move.
8. It is used in time clauses
(a) when there is an idea of routine:
E.g. As soon as he earns any money he spends it.
She takes the boy to school before she goes to work.
(b) when the main verb is in a future form:
E.g. It will stop raining soon. Then we’ll go out.
= when it stops raining, we’ll go out.
It is said that Thomson and Martinet’s (1987) classification is detailed but
quite complicated for the learners to memorize; they may solve this problem by
grouping some uses together.
21
2.2.6. Nine use system
Sinclair (1990) gives an account of nine uses of the PST as follows.
1. To talk about the present moment
1.1. Thoughts and feelings at the present moment, or immediate reactions to
something
E.g. I’m awfully busy.
God, he looks awful!
1.2. Physical feelings
E.g. I feel heavy.
My stomach hurts.
1.3. Physical perceptions such as seeing and hearing with the modal “can”
E.g. I can see the fishing boats coming in.
I see a flat stretch of ground.
22
7. In commentaries
E.g. Andy Gray takes the ball up field again. He turns, shoots- and a
fine save from Grobbelaar.
8. In reporting
E.g. I’ve never been greyhound-racing myself, but they tell me it’s a
fascinating sport.
There are some fine railings in Westminster Abbey, I hear.
9. In commenting with performative verbs such as “admit”, “promise”, “reject”
or “enclose”
E.g. This, I admit, was my favorite activity.
I enclose a small cheque which may come in handy.
Despite of the fact that Use 1 is described very clear and easy to
understand when it is divided into three sub-uses, it cannot be denied that
Sinclair’s (1990) classification poses the same problem as Thomson and
Martinet’s (1987) owing to its length. As a result, Sinclair’s (1990) is too
detailed for learners to have an overview and master the main points in the uses
of the PST.
As we can see, the linguists above have different views on the uses of the
PST. However, their semantic systems include the following four commonest
uses of the PST:
1. General truths, permanent situations and facts
E.g. The sun rises in the East and sets in the West.
Air consists mainly of nitrogen and oxygen.
Oil floats if you pour it on water.
He works in a bank.
2. Repeated or habitual actions: with adverbs of frequency such as always,
usually, often, rarely, seldom, sometimes, every day/week/month, occasionally,
once a week, etc.
E.g. What do you usually do every night?
I rarely go away at weekend.
23
How often does Jane go to the cinema?- Twice a week.
3. Perceptions, thoughts, feelings or acknowledgement: with the verbs grouped
below:
Existence be, exist
Mental states believe, doubt, know, realize, recognize, suppose,
think, understand
Wants and looks want, like, love, hate, need, prefer
Possession belong, have, possess, own
Senses feel, smell, taste, see, hear
Appearance appear, look, seem
E.g. Do you see that man over there?
I smell something burning.
I don’t understand what he is talking about?
This house belongs to the Smiths.
4. Future meaning: with events that are part of a fixed timetable, programme
or a plan, usually a public one.
E.g. The train leaves Lyon at 8.00 and arrives in London at 12.00.
What time does the lecture begin?
This semantic system will be used as the theoretical framework for the
present study.
24
CHAPTER 3. METHODOLOGY
3.1. Introduction
In the previous chapter, different views of several linguists about the uses
of the PST were reviewed. To address three research questions and achieve the
aims mentioned in Chapter 1, a study was conducted among 150 EFL
Vietnamese high – school students. Details of the participants, the instrument,
the procedures of data collection and data analysis are given below.
3.2. Participants
The study was conducted among 150 students of Year 10 at Thang Long
High School in Hanoi. These students were randomly chosen to ensure the
objectivity, validity and reliability of the study. They have been studying
English since they were at Year 6; therefore, they must have had the basic
knowledge of English grammar in all the main aspects, namely relative clauses,
voice, reported speech and tenses, especially the PST.
25
3.3.1. Task 1.
Task 1 consists of twenty test items. In each sentence, the participants
were required to supply the correct form of the verbs given in brackets. There
were sixteen items requiring the PST of the verbs in brackets (four items for
each use) and four items for the PCT. The four test items for the PCT were
added to make the test more natural.
Eg: How often you (read)………………………….a newspaper?
3.3.2. Task 2.
Task 2 also includes twenty test items. In each item, four options
corresponding to four tenses of the same verbs are given. The participants were
asked to choose the most suitable verb tense by circling one of the four choices.
In this task, the right forms of the verbs were in the PST and the PCT with
sixteen items used in the PST (four items for each use) and four items for the
PCT for the same reason mentioned above.
Eg: The café opens/ is opening/ opened/ will open tomorrow morning.
3.3.3. Task 3.
Task 3 requires the participants to make twenty sentences from given
keywords. The participants had to use the correct tenses of the verbs to make
complete sentences.
Eg: The curry/ taste/ salty.
26
The distribution of test items in the three tasks is given in Table 1.
Task
Task 1 Task 2 Task 3
Tenses/ tense uses
Simple
Items: 3, 8, Items: 7, 10, Items: 2, 4, 13, 17
Tense
Use 3 17, 20 13, 16
27
3.4. Data collection procedures
The procedure of collecting data is divided into three stages.
Stage 1:
All the tasks of the test were designed. The test were piloted by the
supervisor and some non- respondents to avoid ambiguity, misunderstanding
and redundancy.
Stage 2:
In this stage, copies of the test were delivered to 150 chosen participants.
They were free to ask any questions and the researcher was always ready to
answer all the questions. The participants were given 45 minutes to do the test
in class. They were not told that the test aimed at the uses of the PST and not
allowed to use reference materials including dictionaries.
Stage 3:
The completed test papers were collected and marked.
28
CHAPTER 4. FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION
In this chapter, the three research questions of the study will be addressed
in turn. In the first place, the results of the test will be presented. Then they will
be discussed with the relevant examples from the collected data to gain the
“panoramic picture” of the uses of the PST by Vietnamese high school students.
29
4.1.1. Use 1 (General truths, permanent situations and facts)
Table 2 presents the numbers and percentages of correct and incorrect
answers to each test item for Use 1 in the three tasks.
Answers Total Correct answers Incorrect answers
2 150 120 80 30 20
Table 2: The number and percentage of correct and incorrect answers for Use 1
in three tasks.
30
As can be seen from Table 2, the Vietnamese high school students in this
study were very good at using Use 1 of the PST with over 90% of the answers
being correct.
There are 9 test items in which they got 100% correct answers. They are:
I.11, T.1: Tom isn’t lazy. He (work)……………. hard most of the time.
I.16, T.1: Air (consist)…………….mainly of nitrogen and oxygen.
I.2, T.2: Vegetarians don’t eat/ aren’t eating/ didn’t eat/ won’t eat meat.
I.4, T.2: Bees eat/ are eating/ ate/ will eat honey.
I.15, T.2: Cuckoos don’t build/ aren’t building/ didn’t build/ won’t build nests.
They use/ are using/ used/ will use the nests of other birds.
I.20, T.2: Rice doesn’t grow/ isn’t growing/ didn’t grow/ won’t grow in cold
climates.
I.8, T.3: Most/ children/ learn/ speak/ 1 year old.
I.11, T.3: An interpreter/ translate/ one language/ another.
I.19, T.3: The moon/ go/ round/ the earth/ 27 days.
This can be explained by the fact that these test items are all about general
truths, and they are common sentences used in real life. In addition, one item
includes the adverbials most commonly used with the PST, namely “most of the
time”.
For the remaining items, the Vietnamese high school students appeared to
have problems with:
I.2, T.1: The weather generally (get)…………………..hot in July and August.
I.6, T.1: Oil (float)……………..if you pour it on water.
I.3, T.3: If/ heat/ water/ 100 degrees Celsius/ boil.
As for I.2, T.1, all thirty students giving wrong answer to this question
used the PCT. Therefore, the sentence was written as “The weather generally is
getting hot in July and August.” This may be because they usually see the verb
“get” commonly used in the “- ing” form. In addition, they might think “July”
and “August” in these sentences refer to “July” and “August” of this year, a
31
point of time in the future, without paying attention to the adverbial
“generally”.
In I.6, T.1, most of the students who got this item incorrect used the verb
“float” in the Future Simple tense. Hence, the sentence became “Oil will float if
you pour it on water.” They might have done so because they thought that this
was a conditional sentence type 1 instead of a zero conditional sentence in this
case.
For the same reason, in I.3, T.3, all 50 participants who gave wrong
answers to this item used the Future Simple tense and the sentence was written
as “If you heat water to 100 degrees Celsius, it will boil.” whereas the right
answer must be “If you heat water to 100 degrees Celsius, it boils.
32
4.1.2. Use 2 (Repeated or habitual actions)
Table 3 presents the numbers and percentages of correct and incorrect
Table 3: The number and percentage of correct and incorrect answers for Use 2
in three tasks.
33
As can be seen from Table 3, Vietnamese high school students in this
study seemed to have fully mastered this use of the PST with 100% of the
answers being correct. For this use, they had all twelve right answers. They are:
34
4.1.3. Use 3 (Perceptions, thoughts, feelings or acknowledgement)
Table 4: The number and percentage of correct and incorrect answers for Use 3
in three tasks.
35
As can be seen from Table 4, the Vietnamese high school students in this
study seemed to be very good at using this use of the PST withv98.3% of the
answers being correct. The participants got 100% of their answers correct in
now.”
All ten students who answered this question incorrectly used the verb
“remember” in the PCT instead of the PST. They may have seen the word
“now” and came to the conclusion that the sentence must be : “Yes, I am
37
4.1.4. Use 4 (Future meaning)
Table 5 presents the numbers and percentages of correct and incorrect
answers to each test item for Use 4 in the three tasks.
4 150 120 80 30 20
18 150 120 80 30 20
Table 5: The number and percentage of correct and incorrect answers for Use 4
in three tasks.
38
As can be seen from Table 5, this use of the PST seemed to be the most
difficult for the participants of this study with only 990 correct answers out of a
total of 1,800, accounting for 55.5%. The incorrect answers could be classified
Group 1 includes:
66.7% and 80% of the participants giving incorrect answers used the
instead of the Present Simple tense, and this implies that the participants might
have associated the words “next” and “tomorrow morning” with future time
reference.
39
66.7% of the participants who had wrong answers also used the Future
Simple tense or the structure “be going to do something” instead of the PST.
This might have resulted from the fact that they thought those events would
happen in the future with specific points of time (12.00, 8.00, etc.)
In conclusion, it can be seen from the data presented above that the forth
use of the PST (Future meaning) is the most difficult for the Vietnamese
learners of English in this study and the second use (Repeated or habitual
actions) is the easiest for them.
40
4.2. The third research question:
3) How well can Vietnamese high school students master the use of the PST
in general?
Table 6 presents the numbers and percentages of correct and incorrect answers
to each use across three tasks.
41
Total Task 1 Task 2 Task 3 Total
Use answers
tasks
U1 1,800 530 88.3 70 11.7 600 100 0 0 550 91.7 50 8.3 1,680 93.3 120 6.7
U4 1,800 420 70 180 30 400 66.7 200 33.3 420 70 180 30 990 55.5 810 44.5
Total 7,200 2,120 88.3 280 11.7 2,200 91.7 200 8.3 2,170 90.4 230 9.6 6,240 86.7 960 13.3
Note: CA: Correct answers, ICA: Incorrect answers, U1, U2, U3, U4: Use 1, Use 2, Use 3, Use 4.
Table 6: The number and percentage of correct and incorrect answers to four uses in three tasks.
42
As can be seen from Table 6, the Vietnamese high school students in this
study seemed to be quite good at using the PST. Altogether, they got 6,240
correct answers out of the total 7,200 responses, accounting for 86.7%.
Nevertheless, they were not equally good at four uses. It can be seen from the
results that they were better at using Use 1, 2, and 3 with 93.3%, 100% and
98.3% of their answers being correct respectively. However, they did not use
Use 4 very well with just 55.5% of correct answers for this use.
43
CHAPTER 5. CONCLUSION
44
5.3. Implications for ESL teaching in Vietnam
In teaching the uses of the PST to Vietnamese high school students, each
use requires the teacher to explain and design relevant activities for students in
order to help them master that use.
Use 2 does not pose problems, as time reference, specifically the adverbs
of frequency, are often used. These adverbs are quite familiar to Vietnamese
high school students. Nevertheless, so as to make sure that students thoroughly
understand how to use these adverbs, several activities may be designed and the
activity below is an example.
45
Activity: How often do you do each of the following? Put a tick in the right
column. Then compare your answers with a partner’s.
Get up early
Go to the
cinema
Watch TV
Listen to
music
……….
In teaching the third use of the PST, it is of great importance that the
teacher should provide students with the verbs only used in the PST, not in the
PCT. They are classified into a number of categories like verbs of existence,
verbs of mental states, verbs of possession, verbs of senses, and verbs of
appearance. Some examples should be given in each group of verbs.
The most problematic use of the PST is Future Meaning as this use does
not appear with the support of any adverbials. The best way to help learners
avoid making mistakes in this use is to help them learn how to recognize future
meanings can be expressed by present tense form in English. Specifically, the
PST is used in this case to talk about a public timetable, a programme or a plan,
usually a public one. It should also be pointed out that personal prearranged
plans must be expressed using the PCT.
In summary, the optimal way for learners to master the uses of the PST is
to give them more time to practice, (there is a saying that “Practice makes
46
perfect”) especially in contextual situations where they can learn how to
associate the form with its meanings.
47
APPENDIX
ENGLISH TEST
48
Exercise 2: Circle the best answer.
1. The café opens/ is opening/ opened/ will open tomorrow morning.
2. Vegetarians don’t eat/ aren’t eating/ didn’t eat/ won’t eat meat.
3. He leaves/ is leaving/ left/ will leave home at 8.00 everyday.
4. Bees eat/ are eating/ ate/ will eat honey.
5. Nicky thinks/ is thinking/ thought/ will think of giving up her job?
6. Why do you walk/ are you walking/ did you walk/ have you walked so fast
today? You normally walk quite slowly.
7. Do you recognize/ Are you recognizing/ Will you recognize/ Did you
recognize that man?
I think that maybe I have seen him before.
8. The train leaves/ is leaving/ has left/ will leave Plymouth at 12.00.
9. Tom never does/ is doing/ did/ will do any work in the garden. He always
works/ is working/ worked/ will work on his car.
10. I won’t tell you my secret unless you promise/ are promising/ promised/ will
promise not to tell anyone.
I promise/ am promising/ promised/ will promise.
11. This is our itinerary. We leave/ are leaving/ left/ will leave home on the 8th,
arrive/ are arriving/ arrived/ will arrive in Paris on the 9th, and spend/are
spending/ spent/ will spend a day there.
12. What time does the conference begin/ is the conference beginning/ have the
conference begun/ will the conference begin?
13. Do you love/ Are you loving/ Did you love/ Will you love him?
No, I just like/ am liking/ liked/ will like him very much.
14. We usually grow/ are growing/ have grew/ will grow vegetables in our garden
in summer.
15. Cuckoos don’t build/ aren’t building/ didn’t build/ won’t build nests. They
use/ are using/ used/ will use the nests of other birds.
16. The milk smells/ is smelling/ smelled/ will smell sour. Do you keep/ are you
keeping/ have you kept/ did you keep milk a long time?
17. He often drinks/ is drinking/ drank/ will drink coffee, but today he drinks/ is
drinking/ has drunk/ will drink tea.
49
18. That film comes/ is coming/ has come/ will come to the cinema next week.
19. I can’t understand why he is/ is being/ was/ has been so selfish. He isn’t
usually like that.
20. Rice doesn’t grow/ isn’t growing/ didn’t grow/ won’t grow in cold climates.
50
13. You/ understand/ what/ teacher/ say?
…………………………………………………………………………………
14. Everyday/ population/ world/ increase/ 200,000 people.
…………………………………………………………………………………
15. The meeting/ begin/ 8.00.
…………………………………………………………………………………
16. Jane/ rarely/ go/ work/ bus.
…………………………………………………………………………………
17. Today/ Jess/ seem/ not/ happy.
…………………………………………………………………………………
18. The next bus/ leave/ station/ 12.00.
…………………………………………………………………………………
19. The moon/ go/ round/ the earth/ 27 days.
…………………………………………………………………………………
20. Normally/ I/ start/ work/ 8.00/ this week/ start/ 7.00/ because/ we/ busy/ the
moment.
…………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………
51
REFERENCES
52