Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Correcting Improper
Performance of
Direct Fired Heaters
A practical, step-by-step approach for finding the
root cause and troubleshooting burner problems
Babak Maghbooli and Afshin Bakhtiari
Tarahan Naftoon Arya Engineering Co.
Hamidreza Najafi
Farayand Sabz Engineering Co.
39
39
Unsteady flame
pattern
Undesirable flame
height
Erratic flame
Pulsating flame
Cloudy flame
Non-definitive shape
Short flame
Flame flashback
Yellow
Luminous yellow
Electrical problem
Excessive firing
Long flame
Luminous blue
Undesirable fuel
gas flame color
Problem subcategory
Improper draft
Problem
category
Root Cause
Troubleshooting actions
Feature Report
A-1
Go to Point T
in Figure 8
Yes
II
Yes
Is burner tip
damaged?
Yes
III
No
Is burner tile
Go to Point BT
in Figure 9
Yes damaged?
No
No
Yes
Figure 3. Troubleshooting
algorithm for unsteady flame
pattern (Part 1)
Yes
No
Yes
Seek
engineering
consultancy
No
Seek
engineering
consultancy
End troubleshooting
procedure
A-2
Figure 4. Troubleshooting
algorithm for unsteady flame
pattern (Part 2)
II
I- Cloudy flame
II- Non definitive flame shape
Yes
1
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
Is burner tip
damaged?
Yes
No
Seek
engineering
consultancy
Go to Point T
in Figure 8
Yes
Seek
engineering
consultancy
End troubleshooting
procedure
41
II
I- Long flame
II- Short flame
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
Is burner tip
damaged?
Yes
Yes
Yes
Go to Point T in Figure 8
Is burner tip
damaged?
No
No
Yes
Go to Point DT in Figure 8
No
Yes
Seek engineering
consultancy.
End troubleshooting
procedure.
Figure 6. Troubleshooting
algorithm for flame lift off and
flashback
Yes
II
II
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
Go to Point DT
in Figure 8
Seek engineering
consultancy
End troubleshooting
procedure
42
Yes
Yes
Yes
Low excess air or low draft can cause non-suitable flame shapes. Measure fired
heaters draft and excess air. In case of low excess air or low draft, adjust damper
and registers.
Feature Report
Yes
Is your problem solved? See also: How to adjust draft and excess air? (Reference 1)
No
Check burner tips. Are they installed according to the burner installation manual?
If not, correct burner tip installation angles.
Yes
Go to Point DA
in Figure 8
Yes
Yes
Go to Point T
in Figure 8
A practical example
No
Figure 7. Troubleshooting
algorithm for flame impingement
Seek
engineering
consultancy
End troubleshooting
procedure
E-1
Yes
Yes
Please specify
your mechanical
problem:
Burner tip problems
P
No
II
DA
III
Done
DT
No
Yes
No
Seek
engineering
consultancy
See also:
How to solve burner plugging problems?
(Point P)
Figure 8.
Troubleshooting
algorithm for
mechanical
problems and
damages (Part 1)
Seek
engineering
consultancy
End troubleshooting
procedure
43
E-2
III
BT
In case of improper
flame pattern, long
time flame impingement to tiles, can
cause tile damage.
Solve flame pattern
problems.
No
Is your problem
solved?
No
Yes
No
Is your problem
solved?
Thermal shock
caused burner
tile damage,
revise operating
conditions and
avoid thermal
shocks.
Yes
Go to Point E-3
Do you
experience
rapid temperature change
in fire box?
If you experience
refractory damages
and downfalls, falling
parts of the refractory
can damage burner
tiles. Seek engineering
consultancy and ask
inspection engineer
to find the cause
and solve the problem.
Done
Yes
Done
Analyze fuel
If pilot ignites by means
composition. In case
of automatic electrical
of Improper fuel
ignition system, first
composition (according
become sure that
to design conditions)
system works properly.
or high content of
If any electrical
problem exists,
No impurities, pilot tip
can plug frequently.
eliminate it in first step.
Clean tips and revise
fuel composition.
Is your problem
solved?
Is your problem
solved?
Yes
No
No
If you experience
regular refractory and
burner tile damage,
broken tiles or
refractory pieces
can plug pilot tips.
Solve this problem.
Is your problem
solved?
See Also: How to
solve damaged tile
problems? (Point BT)
Yes
Yes
Yes
E-3
End troubleshooting
procedure
Yes
The fuel
ring of pilot
is choked,
clean fuel
ring and try
to ignite
No pilot again.
Is your
problem
solved?
No
Seek
engineering
consultancy
Yes
Yes
No
No
Seek
engineering
consultancy
F-1
Feature Report
Specify your fuel type
II
I- Gaseous fuel
II- Fuel oil or combination firing
Go to Point F-2
in Figure 11
Yes
1-Luminus blue
2- Yellow
3- Dark orange or brown
Yes
3
No
Seek
engineering
consultancy
No
No
Yes
Go to Point T
in Figure 8
Is burner tip
damaged?
No
Seek
engineering
consultancy
Yes
End troubleshooting
procedure
No
Yes
1-Luminus yellow
2- Dark orange or light brown
Yes
Yes
No
PA
Done
Yes
No
No
Seek
engineering
consultancy
Yes
Yes
Figure 11.
Troubleshooting
algorithm for
undesirable flame
color (part 2)
No
Done
End troubleshooting
procedure
Chemical Engineering www.che.com May 2013
45
Feature Report
G
References
Yes
End troubleshooting
procedure
Yes
Go to Point P
in Figure 8
No
Yes
Seek
engineering
consultancy
No
No
Computerized algorithm
Acknowledgment
A computer program (computer wizard) was developed based on logic described in Figures 3 to 12. By using
46
No
The authors wish to thank the help and contribution of Mr. Alan Cross. He gave us the motivation
for preparing and submitting our experiences in
the current article.
Authors
Babak Maghbooli works as
a member of the research and
development team of Tarahan Naftoon Arya Engineering Co. (No.75, Radafzoon
Street, Tehran, Iran; Email:
maghbooli@xthermo.com).
With more than six years of
experience in the field of tuning process fired heaters and
troubleshooting their problems, he has provided consultancy services for more than five petroleum
refineries in the field of troubleshooting, maintenance and analyzing mechanical and thermal
behavior of fired heaters and boilers. He also
has practical and professional experience in the
field of process simulation and developing rootcause analysis procedures for chemical process
problems. He is an advanced VBA programmer
and has developed many process simulation solutions in MS-Excel for various consulting projects. Maghbooli holds a B.Sc.Ch.E. degree from
Arak University.
Hamidreza Najafi works
as the head of the research
and development team of
Farayand Sabz Engineering Co. (No.117, Somaye
Street, Tehran, Iran; Email:
hrnajafi@xthermo.com). He is
a professional object-oriented
programmer and his main
interest is developing simulator packages for industrial
processes by means of modern programming techniques. With more than
12 years of experience, he has practical and
professional experience in the fields of thermal
radiation especially for design and simulation of thermal cracking furnaces and process
fired heaters and also development of chemical
kinetics and thermodynamics framework for
simulator software. He has provided numerous
solutions for process problems in these fields for
various oil and petrochemical companies. Najafi
has a B.Sc.Ch.E. degree from Sharif University
of Technology and a M.Sc.Ch.E. degree from
Shiraz University.
Afshin Bakhtiari is founder
and CEO of Tarahan Naftoon
Arya Engineering Co. (same
address as Maghbooli; Email:
abakhtiari@naftoonarya.
com). With more than 12
years experience, he has provided numerous solutions for
process problems of different
petroleum and gas refineries.
His company has done more
than three consultancy projects for troubleshooting process fired heaters at
three different refineries and has also developed
simulator software for process fired heaters.
Bakhtiari holds B.Sc.Ch.E. and M.Sc.Ch.E. degrees from Tehran University. He has also served
for two years as the head of the project management team of the National Iranian Gas Co.