Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Interpellation questions:
1. Do you know that Quezon City, Manila City and Makati City are
the top 3 richest cities in the Philippines according to the
Department of Finance Bureau of Local Government Finance
2015 data?
2. Do you know that those Cities mentioned are also included in
the 2015 list of top 10 cities with the highest registered index
crime rates according to the Bureau of Police?
3. So with the 1st two questions asked, do you agree that there is no
direct relationship between economic progress and registered
data of crime rates?
4. Are you aware that Davao City is the top 4 City with the highest
index crime according to the latest data of Philippine Statistics
Authority posted on their website which is a 2014 data?
5. But are you also aware that Davao City is considered the 4 th
safest City in the whole world according to survey site
Numbeo.com in 2015?
6. So with the 4th and 5th questions asked, do you agree that there
is no direct relationship between peace and order and,
registered data of crime rates?
7. Do you have any historical proof to show that death penalty has
lessen crime rates over the past decades?
8. Do you know there was none because there is no clear cut
evidence that death penalty is the solution to decrease crime
rates?
9. Are you aware that it was during Benigno Aquino III where we
dont have death penalty, the Philippines has experienced the
highest economic growth for the past 6 years?
10.Have you already experienced losing an immediate family
member because of a murderer?
11.Therefore, you dont have any idea how painful it is to
experience such tragic event?
Well, I will tell you, there are no enough words that can explain
when our family lost my brother because of a murderer but I will
tell you, despite of our deepest grief and immeasurable sorrow
we never succumb to the temptation to take revenge because
the only thing that will comfort a family who lost a dear loved
one are the words of God and nothing more.
It is only when you experience where you can best present facts and it
is only facts of history where we can understand the glimpse of the
future.
Ladies and gentlemen, this is Pauline August Fernandez, on the side
negating the issue of death penalty restoration in the Philippines.
The negative side of the house will present 3 main points on why we
negate on the issue of death penalty:
-
expensive;
The second speaker of this side of the house will talked about
the issue of death penalty does not deter crime effectively
Give me some proof that the Philippines has enough resources or even
just a budget that would support your claim that the Philippines is
capable of pursuing death penalty as capital punishment for heinous
crimes and if ever you have it their please at some point present facts
about the sustainability issue of death penalty with regards to the
current Philippines economic situation, then maybe you can at a little
way convince me to support your side of the house or simply show me
any reliable proof of that warehouse of money that the Philippine
possesses specifically for the restoration of death penalty.
Well maybe you can argue that it is cheaper to do away and be done
with a criminal rather than to house and feed them for the rest of their
natural lives.
Well I will lay down the facts of my research that aside from your
barbaric point of view IT IS NOT cheaper because the general
statistics showed that the death penalty is three times more expensive
than life imprisonment.
Most of these costs occur in every case for which capital punishment is
sought, regardless of the outcome. Thus, the true cost of the death
penalty includes all the added expenses of the "unsuccessful" trials in
which the death penalty is sought but not achieved.
Moreover, if a defendant is convicted but not given the death
sentence, the state will still incur the costs of life imprisonment, in
addition to the increased trial expenses.
Well, let us consider that scenarios presented with a shorter period of
time were millions of pesos were already incurred. Then how about the
long number of years before a case here in the Philippines is settled.
For the states which employ the death penalty, this luxury comes at a
high price. I cant imagine how the Philippines could sustain such cost.
According to an article wrote by Ron Gluckman (during the reign of
death penalty here in the Philippines) which won an award for
Excellence in Reporting from the Society of Asian Publishers.
IN THE PHILIPPINES, inmates pay for their crimes in many ways. Aside
from serving their sentence in prison, the inhumane prison cell itself
(Well, I can attest to that because I, myself had a chance to visit a
family friend who was been charged of a felony and was later on
discovered that it was just a mistake of identity) and the long number
of years before a case will be given a final decision by the Court.
Everything is available for a price. According to Maria Diokno, head of
the Free Legal Assistance Group (FLAG), which handles most last-ditch
appeals for condemned men "These are all poor people in Death Row".
Father Silvino "Jun" Borres, director of the Philippines Jesuit Prison
Service, calls the Row a "home for the poor." A survey showed that
mostly in the Row earned less than $6 a day when they were arrested.
Three-quarters of them were farmers, truckers, laborers and so on. Few
can afford the 1,500 attorneys charge to attend the death sentence
hearings.
about half its time on death penalty cases. Many governors spend a
significant percentage of their time reviewing clemency petitions and
more will face this task as executions spread. As John Dixon, Chief
Justice (Retired) of the Louisiana Supreme Court, said: "The people
have a constitutional right to the death penalty and we'll do our best to
make it work rationally. But you can see what it's doing. Capital
punishment is destroying the system."
If I may borrow the words from James Ellis "Whether you're for it or
against it, I think the fact is that Philippines simply can't afford it."