Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
PowerSystemwithVariableSpeedWind
TurbineandDieselGenerationUnits
Y.Hu1,Z.Chen2
SchoolofEngineeringandAppliedPhysics,Glyndwr,UK
DepartmentofEnergyTechnology,AalborgUniversity,Aalborg,DK9220,Denmark
1
2
y.hu@glyndwr.ac.uk;2zch@et.aau.dk
Received31May,2013;Revised20July,2013;Accepted5October,2013;Published20January,2014
2014ScienceandEngineeringPublishingCompany
Abstract
used in autonomous systems. However, the
availability of renewable energy sources has strong
Thispaper presents a power system consisting of wind
daily and seasonal patterns. For a wind turbine, no
turbines,dieselgenerationunits,andenergystoragesystem.
output
power guarantee can be given, because days
Both wind turbines and diesel engine adopt variable speed
with wind speed lower than the cut in speed of the
operation mode;and power electronic interface are used for
the generationunits which provide flexibleand wide range
wind turbine may occur, resulting in no power
of control on the power. The system configuration,
generation. Therefore, hybrid power systems, such as
characteristics, operation principles are presented. The
wind turbines, diesel units, and/or energy storage
controller and control strategies are discussed. The
devices,couldbeachoiceoftheelectricitysupplyfor
simulationstudies have been performed and the results are
remotelocations[Stavrakakisetal.(1995),Kariniotakis
presented.
et al. (1995), Dokopoulos et al. (1996), Infield (1996),
Keywords
Iglesiasetal.(2000),Philipson(2000),Karketal.(2001),
Muljadietal.(2002)].
Dispersed Generation; Diesel Generation Unit; Wind Power;
EnergyStorage;PowerElectronicInterface
Introduction
At present, a common way to supply electricity to
remote loads is to use a diesel enginegenerator set.
However, diesel fuel, like other conventional energy
sources, such as oil, natural gas, coal and nuclear, is
finiteandgeneratespollution.Cleanrenewableenergy
sources for example, solar, wind and wave, are
abundant energy source globally, and have obvious
advantages of benefiting the environment, therefore,
the use of renewable sources is actively promoted to
meet environmental goals and to provide longterm
energy security. In recent years, the developments of
renewableenergyhaveattractedsignificantattentions,
and have been advanced rapidly, in particular, wind
energy is the most competitive renewable energy
sourcedelectricity generation approach and the
globally installed wind power generation capacity is
increasedquickly.
Whilewindturbineshavebeenintegratedintopower
systems in large scale, they may also be conveniently
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
P o w er
E lec tro n ic
In terface
thedieselengineneedstokeepthespeedconstantdue
totherestrictionoftheoperationfrequencyoftheload.
However, a diesel engine would have high rate of
consumption at a constant speed with a light load, a
minimumloadabout40%oftheratedcapacityisoften
recommended by the manufacturers. Hence, a power
electronic interfaced variable speed system is
considered.
The power electronic interface decouples the
frequencyofthegeneratorandtheconnectedload,so
thatthespeedofthegeneratorcanbevariedtoreduce
thefuelconsumptionandemissionlevel.Additionally,
the frequency decouple enables a normal permanent
magnet (PM) generator to be used instead of a field
excited synchronous generator, while voltage
controllabilityisstillheld.
D iese l E n g in e P M
G en erato r set
PM G
Wind turbine
P o w er
E lec tro n ic
In terface
Modular
rectifier
S y s te m lo a d
Id
DC/DC
converte
V d,r
Wind
Vd
Converter
Vc
V d,i
Modular PM
generator
E n erg y
sto ra g e
sy stem
DC/DC converter
switching signal
generator
FIG.1SCHEMATICSOFTHESTUDIEDAUTONOMOUSPOWER
SYSTEM
Thewindpowerconversionsystemconsistsofawind
turbine, a generator and the associated power
electronic converters. Various types of generators can
be used for variable speed wind power conversion
systems; andthe modular permanent magnet
generator (MPMG) [Spooner et al. (1996)] is taken in
this study. Several types of power electronic
conversion systemsfor the MPMG have beenstudied
[Chen et al. (1998)], one of the reported interfaces
[Chen et al. (2001)]is used for this study as shown
schematically in Fig. 2.The power electronic interface
includes the modular single phase diode rectifiers
[Chen et al. (1998)]shown in Fig. 3, a boost type of
dc/dc converter and a voltage source converter (VSC)
as illustrated in Fig. 2.The dc/dc converter keeps a
required dc voltage at the dc input of the VSC which
injects power into the ac system at a constant
frequency.
Inadieselgenerationsystem,thegenerationunituses
a normal permanent magnet (PM) generator, which
doesnothaveanexcitationcontrolsystem,sothatthe
requirement on the maintenance is reduced, but the
terminal voltage cannot be controlled like a field
excited synchronous generator. Furthermore, if a
synchronous generator is used, the generator may be
directlyconnectedtotheacload,thenthegovernorof
Id
VSC switching
signal generator
FIG.2SCHEMATICSOFTHEWINDPOWERCONVERSION
SYSTEM
e
ig ,1
Id
rg
rg
ac
ac
Vdc
en
rg
L
C
ac
FIG.3MODULARCONNECTIONOFSTATORCOILAND
RECTIFIER
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
voltagewithdesiredmagnitudeandfrequency.
Theenergy storage devices are used in the hybrid
generating system to level out the erratic differences
between the generation and load consumption. The
energystoragedevicescaneffetivelyprovidepowerto
meetsuddenloadincrements.AsshowninFig.4,the
energystoragedeviceisconnectedtotheregulateddc
link with a bidirectional dc/dc converterwhich
controls the direction and flow of the power of the
energystoragedevice,i.e.itscharge/discharge.
D ie s e l E n g in e P M
G e n e ra to r s e t
PM G
Speed
c o n tr o l
(2)
S w ith in g
c o n tro l
FIG.4SCHEMATICSOFVARIABLESPEEDDIESELPM
GENERATORSYSTEM
FIG.5TYPICALCPCURVE
FIG6POWERWINDSPEEDCHARACTERISTICS
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
FIG.7WINDPOWERGENERATORRECTIFIER
CHARACTERISTICS(POWERANDVOLTAGEINVARIABLE
SPEEDZONE)
(a)Characteristicofpowerandspeed.
(b)Characteristicofcurrentandspeed.
FIG.8DIESELENGINEOPERATIONALCHARACTERISTICS
DC/DCConverters
ThreeDC/DCconvertersareusedinthesystemforthe
wind turbine, diesel generator and energy storage
systemrespectively.
1) DC/DC Converter for the Wind Power
Generator
V d.rec .
V dw .vsc
FIG.9NONISOLATEDBOOSTDC/DCCONVERTERFORWIND
TURBINE
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
dieselengineasshowninFig.13.
FIG.10SWITCHINGDUTYRATIOOFBOOSTINWINDPOWER
GENERATION(MAXIMUMPOWERCAPTURE)
Pref
Power
Speed
regulator
Switching signal
generator
Vdw,ref +
-
DC/DC
Boost
Vdw.vsc
Voltage
Controller
Vdw.vsc
FIG.11CONTROLSYSTEMFORTHEBOOSTINWINDTURBINE
SYSTEM
V d .r e c .
FIG.13SWITCHINGDUTYRATIOOFCHOPPERINTHEDIESEL
ENGINESYSTEM
AcontrollerforthechopperisillustratedinFig.14.
Theinputtotheswitchingsignalgeneratorconsists
of two components, one is from the PI controller
output, and the other is set on the basis of the
relationship between the reference power (speed)
and duty ratio (the voltage) shown in Fig. 13. The
PI controller generates a correction component for
the switching signal generator to hold the dc
voltage at the desired reference levelunder a
varyinginputdcvoltagecondition.
3)
V d d .v s c
FIG.12NONISOLATEDBUCKDC/DCCONVERTERINDIESEL
GENERATIONUNIT
DC/DCConverterforEnergyStorageSystem
Pref,D
Power
Controller
Vdd,ref
Switching signal
generator
DC/DC
Chopper
Vdd.vsc
Voltage
Controller
-
Vdd.vsc
FIG.14SWITCHINGDUTYRATIOOFCHOPPERINTHEDIESEL
ENGINESYSTEM
Thecircuitconfigurationsandcontrolstrategiesof
bidirectionaldc/dcconvertershavebeendiscussed
in literature [Hunter et al. (1994)]. This paper will
not discuss the details of bidirectional dc/dc
converters.
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
DC/ACConverters
The two dc/ac converters in the system are used
respectively for the wind power conversion system
andthedieselgenerationunitwiththeenergystorage
system.Thefunctionsoftheseconvertersaretodeliver
theactiveandreactivepowertotheconsumerwiththe
required voltage magnitude and frequency. The
voltage source converters (VSC) can be a simple two
level converter as shown in Fig. 15 though complex
convertertopologies,suchasmultilevelconvertersor
multimodule converters, may be used depending on
the required power level. The two VSCs may have
different control strategies; and the VSC for the wind
power conversion system may only be required to
transfer active power in one direction, i.e. from the
windturbinetotheconsumer;however,theVSCused
for the diesel generation unit with the energy storage
systemmayneedtotransferpowerinbothdirections.
As usual, PWM switching strategies can be used for
bothdc/acvoltagesourceconverters;andacfiltersare
connectedattheacterminalsoftheconverterstolimit
the harmonic generated by switching the
semiconductors.
V dc
V ac
FIG.15DC/ACINVERTERFORGENERATIONSYSTEM
INTERFACE
id*
u d*
*
u abc
u q*
iq*
u abc
L
ud
id
iabc
iq
FIG.16CONTROLOFVSCSYSTEMFORPOWERINJECTION
WindTurbinePowerControl
The available power that may be provided by the
wind turbine depends on the wind speed, and
therefore, varyingwith the wind speed. The variable
speed wind turbine can operate at an optimal tip
speed ratio for the optimal power capture until the
machine reaches the rated condition then the input
power will be limited by a pitch control system. The
pitchcontrollerofthewindturbineisillustratedinFig.
17. Similar to a grid connected system, the pitch
control system will regulate the wind power input to
the system and limit the power when wind speed is
toohigh.
ref
FIG.17BLOCKDIAGRAMOFPITCHCONTROLOFTHEWIND
TURBINE
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
withnonlinearsystemsinceanaccuratemathematical
model is not required. These advantages have made
fuzzy logic become very useful in control techniques
inrecentyears,especiallywhenthecontrolledsystem
isdifficulttobemodeledusingformulas.
SpeedControlofDieselGenerationUnit
Dieselenginesystemisanonlinearsystem.Inadiesel
enginesystem,therearemanyfactorswouldaffectits
operation[Grzesiaketal.(1998),Haddadetal.(1984)].
Due to so many factors affecting the operation of the
diesel engine, a fuzzy logic control method is more
effective.
Actuator
Generator
speed
Fuzzy inference
Fuzzification
Dieselenginesystemisanonlinearsystem,thereare
manyfactorswouldaffectitsoperation[Grzesiaketal.
(1998), Haddad et al. (1984)]. Considering the non
idealfeaturesofthesystem,suchasnonlinearityand
powerloss,speedcontrolsystembasedonfuzzylogic
features more effectiveand robustic. The block
diagram of the diesel generation system is shown in
Fig. 18.In the diesel system, the power generation
reliesonthefuelinput.Theprincipaltaskofthespeed
controller is to control the fuel input, therefore the
output of the controller is the control signal to the
actuator.
Defuzzification
Thecontrolsystemofdieselunitconsistsofthespeed
controller and the power electronic controller. The
speed controller adjusts the fuel input to meet the
demands of the system power balance under the
variationsofwindpowergenerationandsystemload.
While the control system for the power electronic
system controls the dc/dc converter to provide the
voltage source converter with an almost constant dc
voltage input and it also controls the converter to
produce a threephase voltage output with desired
voltage amplitude and frequency. Furthermore, the
power electronic control system is coordinated with
the speed control system to minimize the transient
disturbance.
s ref
s/t
Diesel Engine PM
Generator set
PMG
FIG.19BLOCKDIAGRAMOFTHEENGINESPEED
CONTROLLERWITHAFUZZYLOGICCORE
Power
Electronic
interface
NB
Actuator
dynamics
ref
Fuzzy
Speed
Controller
+
-
NM
NS
Z 1
PS
PM
PB
Xmax
Power
Controller
Xmin
Pref,D
FIG.18BLOCKDIAGRAMOFSPEEDCONTROLOFTHEDIESEL
ENGINE
FIG.20SEVENTRIANGULARMEMBERSHIPFUNCTIONS
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
Speed control
system
Rectifier
DC/DC
Windturbine
Energystorage
Mode1
operation
Mode2
operation
charging
Mode3
operation
discharging
Mode4
operation
charging
operation
Mode5
operation
operation
Mode6
charging
operation
Dieselunit
Mode7
operation
s1
s1,
s1
s2,
s2
s1
s2
s2
L ,
L 1
L 2
PWM
Converter
L oad 2
Energy
storage
system
FIG.22BLOCKDIAGRAMOFTHEEXAMPLESYSTEM
DC/DC
PowerControlinSteadyState
Energy storage
control system
FIG.21BLOCKDIAGRAMOFADIESELGENERATIONUNIT
WITHCONTROLSYSTEMS
Operation Modes
The main task of operating an autonomous power
systemistokeepthepowerbalancewithgoodpower
TABLE1OPERATIONMODES
L oad 1
Power electronic
control system
Diesel engine
PM generator
system
quality.Moreover,inthediscussedsystem,asmuchas
possiblewindenergymaybeutilized,sothatthefossil
fuel emission can be minimized. The operation
strategyforthestudiedpowersystemneedstocontrol
the wind turbine, the diesel generation unit and the
energystorageunitrespectively,andalsoperformthe
coordination among these power supply units.
Depending on the level of the power system load,
variousoperationmodesmayexistaslistedinTable1.
Twoofthesteadystatestudiedcasesarepresented.In
thepresentedcases,thewindspeedisshowninFig.23.
The wind turbine VSC is controlled to deliver active
power into the system with a unit power factor. The
VSC of diesel unit/energy storage provides the
reactive power required by the system and keeps the
system voltage within the required range. There is a
loadreductionat12secondsofthesimulationtime.
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
FIG.23WINDSPEEDFORCASESTUDY
Fig.24showstheresultsofthefirstcase,andthewind
turbinedeliversallavailablepowerintothesystemi.e.
thepoweroutputisnotlimitedbyapitchcontrol.The
diesel unit with energy storage system takes both
generation and absorption modes to balance the
systemload.Fig.24(a)presentsthesystemvoltagesas
marked in Fig. 22, and it can be seen that the load
voltage is kept almost constant, while the terminal
voltage of the wind turbine varies in order to deliver
the power generated by the turbine. Fig. 24(b) gives
theactivepowerofthesystem.Sincetheactivepower
of the wind turbine is not limited, the wind power is
possibly higher than the load consumption, and then
the energy storage system can be charged,
whichcorresponds to the period that Ps1 becomes
negative. The system reactive power is shown in Fig.
24(c),anditcanbeseenthatthereactivepowerofthe
dieselunitisequaltothereactivepowerconsumedby
the load while the reactive power from the wind
turbineiszero.
The second case is shown in Fig. 25. Here the power
from the wind turbine is limited so as not to exceed
thepowerconsumedbytheload;whichcorrespondsto
the situation where the energy storage device cannot
takemoreenergy.Therefore,thepitchcontrolisused
to reduce the power of the wind turbine. Fig. 25(a)
presentsthesystemvoltages.Again,itcanbeseenthat
the load voltage is kept almost constant. Also, the
variation of the voltage at the terminal of the wind
turbine is reduced in comparison with the previous
case, since the peak power is limited. Fig. 25(b) gives
theactivepowerofthesystem.Sincetheactivepower
ofthewindturbineislimited,thewindpowerisequal
to the load consumption in some periods, then the
VSC of diesel unit/energy storage system works as a
reactive power compensator to produce reactive
poweronlyasshowninFig.25(c).Again,thereactive
powerfromthewindturbineiszero.
(a)systemvoltage(case1)
(b)Systemactivepower(case1)
(c)Systemreactivepower(case1)
FIG.24CASEOFENERGYSTORAGESYSTEMTAKINGPOWER
FROMWINDTURBINE
(a)Systemvoltage(case2)
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
(c)DClinkcurrent
(b)Systemactivepower(case2)
(d)DClinkpower
FIG.26SIMULATIONRESULTS(RMSVALUES)
Thepresenteddynamicstudycasesarefocusedonthe
system behavior of diesel generation unit and its
controlsystemunderaloadincrease,whichresultsin
that the loading level of the diesel generation unit is
doubled.
(c)Systemreactivepower(case2)
FIG.25CASEOFWINDTURBINELIMITINGTHEOUTPUT
(a)Machinespped
(b)systemvoltages
10
PowerControlofDieselSysteminDynamics
Beforetheloadchanges,thedieselsystemoperatesat
aspeedof0.45pu;at2.0secondsofthesimulationtime,
a load is switched in. Assume that the needed power
due to the load increase is to be carried by the diesel
engine, therefore a new reference speed is generated
bythecontroller,andthenthefuzzycontrolleradjusts
the speed of the diesel unit. The generator speed is
increasedandstabilizedatthenewreferencespeedas
shown in Fig. 26 (a). It can be seen that the fuzzy
controllerworkswellinthespeedcontrolofthediesel
generation unit. Since the generator is a permanent
magnet machine, the generated voltage is in
proportion to the speed; whichcan be clearly seen in
curve 1, Fig. 26 (b). Also the dc voltage at diode
rectifier terminal, curve 2 in Fig. 26 (b), presents the
same pattern. The curve 3 in Fig. 26 (b) is the dc
voltageattheVSCterminal.Itcanbeseenthatthedc
chopperquicklyrestoresthevoltagetotheratedlevel
though the generator voltage is still in variation. Fig.
26(c)showsthedclinkcurrent.
Figs. 27 and 28 present the system waveforms in the
states before and after the load disturbance. Fig. 27
shows the waveforms at the lower power level
operationconditionbeforetheloadincreases.Figs.27
(a)and(b)arethegeneratorvoltageandcurrent,Figs.
27(c)and(d)arethevoltagesourceconvertervoltage
andcurrent,andFig.27(e)isthedclinkcurrent.
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
doubledinFig.28.Itisalsonotedthatthevoltageand
current contains harmonics at the generator side due
tothecapacitivetypeofdclinkofthedioderectifier.
PWM phase voltage waveforms at the ac terminal of
the voltage source converter in Figs 27 (c) and 28 (c)
havethesimilarpatternandmagnitude.Itcanbeseen
thattheaccurrentisdoubledbycomparingFig27(d)
withFig.28(d).
(a)Generatorvoltage(beforeloadincrease)
(b)Generatorcurrent(beforeloadincrease)
(a)
Generatorvoltage(afterloadincrease)
(b)
Generatorcurrent(afterloadincrease)
(c)loadvoltage(beforeloadincrease)
(d)loadcurrent(beforeloadincrease)
(c)
loadvoltage(afterloadincrease)
(e)DClinkcurrent(beforeloadincrease)
FIG.27SIMULATEDWAVEFORMS(BEFORELOADINCREASE)
(d)loadcurrent(afterloadincrease)
(e)DClinkcurrent(afterloadincrease)
FIG.28SIMULATEDWAVEFORMS(AFTERLOADINCREASE)
11
ElectricalEngineeringResearchVolume2,2014
Thedccurrentsbeforeandaftertheloadincreasesare
given in Figs 27 (e) and 28 (e) where the switching
ripples and the increase of the transferred power can
beobserved.
Conclusions
The paper presents an autonomous power system
consistingofthewindturbines,dieselgenerationunits
and energy storage devices. Both the wind power
generatorandthedieselgeneratorareconnectedtothe
ac load system through power electronics interfaces
and operate at variable speed so as to maximize the
wind energy capture and minimize the diesel fuel
consumption.
The system characteristics are presented and the
operation schemes are discussed. The control system
and control strategies are developed and a fuzzy
diesel powercontroller isused.Both steady stateand
dynamicstudiesareperformedbysimulation.
The simulation studies have demonstrated that the
studied system can effectively provide good quality
power to the customers in the autonomous power
system and that the quick control ability of the
converters plays a key role in improving the system
dynamic performance and enhancing the system
stability.
REFERENCES
turbines
systems
interaction.
Part
II:
Power,VariableVoltageDCPowerSources,IEEProc.
Generation,TransmissionandDistributions,Vol.148,No.
5,September2001,pp.439447.
Chen, Z.; Spooner, E.; Grid Interface Options for Variable
Speed,PermanentMagnetGenerators,IEEProc.Electr.
Power Applications, Vol. 145, No. 4, July 1998, pp. 273
283.
Dokopoulos, P.S.; Saramourtsis, A.C.; Bakirtzis, A.G.;
Prediction and evaluation of the performance of wind
diesel energy systems, IEEE Transactions on Energy
Conversion,Vol.11Issue:2,June1996,pp.385393.
GrzesiakL.W.,Koczara,M.,daPonte;Novelhybridload
adaptivevariablespeedgeneratingsystemInternational
SymposiumonIndustrialElectronics,1998.ISIE98,July
1998,pp.271276.
12
3,2000,pp.16631665.
Spooner, E.; Williamson, A.C.; Directcoupled, permanent
magnet generators for wind turbine applications, IEE
Proc.Electr.PowerApplications,Vol.143,No.1,January
1996,pp.18.
Stavrakakis, G.S.; Kariniotakis, G.N.; A general simulation
algorithm for the accurate assessment of isolated diesel
wind turbines systems interaction. I. A general
multimachine power system model, IEEE Trans. on
EnergyConversion,Vol.10,Sept.1995,pp.577583.
WindDieselSystems,EditedbyR.,HunterandG.,Elliot,
CambridgeUniversityPress,1994.