1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

Like

Share

search...

ArithmeticAptitudeDataInterpretation
LogicalReasoningVerbalReasoningNonVerbalReasoning
GeneralKnowledge
SudokuNumberpuzzlesMissingletterspuzzlesLogicalpuzzlesPlayingcardspuzzlesClockpuzzles
CProgrammingC++ProgrammingC#ProgrammingJavaProgramming
MicrobiologyBiochemistry
BiotechnologyBiochemical
Engineering
Electronicsand
CommunicationEngineering
CivilEngineeringMechanical
EngineeringChemical
EngineeringNetworking
DatabaseQuestions
ComputerScienceBasic
ElectronicsDigitalElectronics
ElectronicDevicesCircuit
SimulationElectrical
EnigneeringEngineering
MechanicsTechnical
Drawing
PlacementPapersGroupDisucssionHRInterviewTechnicalInterviewBodyLanguage
AptitudeTestVerbalAbilityTestVerbalReasoningTestLogicalReasoningTestCProgrammingTestJavaProgrammingTestDataInterpretationTest
GeneralKnowledgeTest
DataStructuresOperatingSystemsNetworkingDATABASEDatabaseBasicsSQLServerBasicsSQLServerAdvancedSQLServer2008JAVACore
JavaJavaBasicsAdvancedJavaUNIXUnixFileManagementUnixMemoryManagementUnixProcessManagemntCInterviewQuestionsTheC
LanguageBasics.NETInterviewQuestions.NETFrameworkADO.NETASP.NETSoftwareTesting
Home
Aptitude
LogicalReasoning
VerbalAbility
GK
Puzzles
Engineering
Interview
OnlineTest

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?
@:Home>GroupDiscussion>PoliticsDiscussionRoom

Pointstorememberbeforeyouparticipateinthisdiscussion:
Assume,youoneofthememberofarealgroupdiscussion.
Taketheinitiativetoparticipateandcontributeyourthoughts.
Expressyourpositiveattitudetowardsprovidingthesolution.

Shreyassaid:(Wed,Dec24,201402:04:04PM)

Friendsletsnotforgetthatdictatorshipisallrelatedtoskillofconvincingpeopleinonedirectionandnomatter
thenwhatcomesinitsway,butlookingatIndiaacountrywhohasshownhowpeoplecandevelop,inspiteofthe
differentculturetraditionsanditshugepopulation,wherepeoplehavedifferentopinions.
Inmyopinionwesetarealgoodexampleforworldtoseehowdemocracycanbepracticedwithoutbeingaffected
byanybarrierandforthatIthinkIndiadonotneeddictatorshipitshappybeingdemocraticandinfutureitwill

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

1/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

showwhydemocracyisgoodforit.
ManyofmyfriendswillsaythatwhywestillnotdevelopedbutmydearfriendsIwillaskyoutobepatient
becausesomethingswhichhavethousandsopinionsneedtimebutdon'tforgetthefruitofpatienceisalways
sweet.
Ratethis:+13

Chrissaid:(Sun,Nov30,201412:17:49PM)

Ifyoulookaroundtheworldtoday,thereisnosinglecountrywhowasdemocraticbeforethecountryis
developed.
Allcountriesaredevelopingonewayanothercomparedtoitsowncountryvertically.However,ifyoucompared
laterally,thendemocracydoesharmtherateofthedevelopmentasittakestimetoreachaconsensus.
Remember,whateverthepolicyordecisionsmadebygovernment,therewillbeobjections.
Whateverpolicyorgovernmentmadewillharmsomepeople,thequestionsis"willitbenefittomajorityorwhole
nation".
Ratethis:+5

Rjsaid:(Mon,Nov17,201410:49:28PM)

DictatorshipiswhatIndianeedsrightnow.
ThepresentformofGovernmenthasdevastatedtheentirenationbothsociallyandeconomically.Afterlosingthe
majorityoftheresources,itspointlesstobelievethatsubstantialamendmentscanbemadetobringthenation
backtotrackinpossibletime.
Dictatorshipontheotherhand,iflaiddown,hasitsownbenefitsandconsaswell.Noformofgovernancecanbe
explainedastobethebestforcurrentIndiaaschallengesaregettingpileduponeuponanother.
Whiledemocracyhasbeenaroundthecornerforafewdecadesnow,layingdownthefoundationforanewform
ofgovernanceshouldbeapproachedrationallyfulfillingtheneedofthehour.
Peoplecanderivemanyexamplesofnationsunderstabledictatorshipandalsobelievedtobeasasignificant
factorintheirdevelopment.
Rememberguys.
"Toomanycooksruinthefood"whereas"Allittakesisonlyonemantobringthenecessarychange".
Ratethis:+7

ShreyaInamdarsaid:(Sun,Oct12,201408:13:26PM)

ItsGoodtohavesuchdiscussions.Butfriendsdonotice1pointhere.Itisthesame"we"goingtoelectthe
personforboththecases1)Dictatorship2)Democracy.
Dictatorshipcouldbemoreefficientonebutontheotherhanddemocracyplaysakeyrole.
Dictatorshipwillleadto"progress"ofcountrybutDemocracyleadsto"Better"country.
ProgressandBetterwhichmeanthesameagain!ifactuallyconcentrate.BecomingPuppetstothepolitical
leadersisinourhands.Asitis"we"whoareelectingthem.IthinkwhatIndianeedsisnotwhetheritis
democratic\autocratic?Ratheritcouldbebetterifthereexitsmutualunderstandingbetweeneachwhichisalmost
adifficultthingtoimplement.Firstchange"U"thensay"society"becauseultimately"SocietyisagainU"!wecan
seeBetterIndiaorautocraticIndiaonlywhen1)EverychildtooldisEDUCATEDwithEMPLOYMENT2)Eliminating
thePOVERTYwhichwearestudyingfromLKGto10inschoolsbutyetnooneanalyseit!
3)FinallystoppracticingVIOLENTMETHODS.Notnecessarytomentionaseveryknowwhattheydo!
Ratethis:+19

Nishasaid:(Mon,Sep29,201403:55:25PM)

Nodoubt,dictatorshipismoreefficienttypeofGovernment.Thedictatoristhemasterofhisownwill.Hisorders
arethefinalorders.Noonecandarerefusetocarrythemout.Whenanationisdowncrushedadictatorcertainly
helpsitisrisinghigh.Throughheavypenaltiesandpunishments,hefreesthecountryofallcorruption.Inwar
time,nootherGovernmentissoefficientasdictatorship.
Butdictatorshipcannotlastlong.Itisverydifficulttogetagoodsuccessortoadictator.Einstein,thefamous
scientist,onesaid,"Dictatorsofgeniusaresucceededbyscoundrels."Germanybecameaterrortotheworldin
thedaysofHitler.TurkeywasrevolutionizedandmodernizedbyMustafaKamalPasha.Butafterthem,their
countriesagainfellindarkness.Further,asthedangerofgoingonawrongpath.Thereisnocheckonhispowers.
PeoplecannotcriticshimorchangetheGovernmentthroughconstitutionalmeans.Theycannotexpresstheir

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

2/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

viewsfreelyorpasstheirlifeinthewaytheythinkbest.Theyhavenorights.Theymustobeythedictatorblindly.
Manisthusreducedtothelevelofadumbanimal.
Hencedictatorshipcan'tbethesolutionofIndia.Wedon'tneedtochangetheformoftheGovernmentbutwe
needtoreformit.
Ratethis:+19

Nehasaid:(Sun,Sep21,201405:20:20PM)

Hifriends,
Iwanttoaskaquestion:Howwouldyoufeelifgovernmentorderyoutoleaveyourallyourbelonging?Youwill
belootedinamoment.Thatswhatadictatordoes.Theyonlythinkofdevelopmentofcountryinmaterialisticterm
notofcommonpeople.Canyoulivewithoutfreedom?ofcoursenot.SoforacountrylikeIndiawhichishaving
diversityinlanguage,religionetcDictatorshipisnotarightchoice.Insteadtheexistinggovernmentshould
undergoessomereforms.Someofthemareasfollows:.
1.Decisionmakingprocessshouldbeaccelerated.
2.Effectivelawsshouldbemadefast.
3.Judgementshouldbemadelesstimeconsuming.
4.FeelingofPatriotismshouldcomeineveryIndianheart.
5.Everyoneshouldtrytodoreformatgrasslevel.
Thisseriesisendless.IfIcontinuethisitwilllooklikeexistinglawofIndiangovernment.Sostopsuggestingand
startimplementing.
Ratethis:+46

Idhayamsaid:(Fri,Sep19,201408:19:42AM)

Hiall,
Indiaisandemocracycountryeverybodyknowitafterfreedom.Wearefastgrowingeverythingincludecorruption
alsobutwenotfelldown.IndictatorshipIndianoonewillgiveguarantytothiskindofimprovement.Examplewe
takeourneighbourcountrypakistaninthatcountrychangedemocracyanddictatorshipalsostillthatcountry
struggletogetimprovement.Myconcludeisdemocracyisgoodforournation.
Ratethis:+6

12

Rakshithasaid:(Tue,Sep16,201407:28:04AM)

Hellofriends,
NowadaysIndiansneedaluxuriouslife.Everybodyarerunningbehindmoney.Andalsotheybecomelazyand
don'twanttowaitforgettinganything.Theyneedeverythingtobeinstant.Thisleadstocorruption.Ifeveryonein
Indiarealizethatthenwecanchangeourcountry.Moreoverweneedagoodleaderratherthanadictator.Ifa
leaderisgoodthenautomaticallyhe/shecanchangethesociety.
Ratethis:+23

Mmrsaid:(Wed,Sep10,201405:32:40PM)

HelloEverybody,
It'sverygoodtohavethistypeofdiscussion.Wecommonmanarenotgettingproperplatformtoparticipatein
suchaimportantissue.InmypointofviewIndiabeingaMultireligion,multilingual,Multicaste,Multibelieve
Nation.SokeepinginmindthissocialfactorsIcanstronglyrecommendDemocracyinIndia.OfcourseOnething
hereIcanpulloutthatIndiahavelostitsluster&shiningduetosomeantinationalintruders.Thisintruderare
nothingbutthegroupofpeoplewhoaretryingtopolarizethesocietyinthenameofreligionandcasteandsome
howsuccessfultoapprehendthesocietyinthelineofhatevenomandtrytodictateinIndiansoil,probablyhave
forgottenthePastHistoryofbloodshedthathasbroughtthenationintodivision.Asweknowwehavevery
stronglawsbutwearenotabletoimplementthisinoursociety.Ouryouthhasbecomethetoysinthehandsof
SocalledSaviourofCountry.Wehavetochangetheattitudeandunderstandourcapabilitiesandthenonlywe
willbeabletobegovernedbyapopularDemocraticGovernment.

Ratethis:+12

PankajKumarKushwahasaid:(Wed,Sep10,201412:03:06PM)

InmyOpinionthereisnoneedsadictatorshipforIndiabecauseonesinglepersonhowcanmanage1.5billion
population.Sodemocracyismuchbetterthandictatorship.Weonlyneedstochangethemindsetofpeople,
mindsetofsociety.Wehavetounderstandourdutyandshouldtrytomakebettersystemnotdestroythesystem.
Weneedtoknowourrights.Weareresponsibleforcorruption,wemakecorruptthembecausewedoesn'tknow
ourright.SoforseeingabetterIndiafirstwehavetobebetterotherwiseanygovt,anysystemwillnotwork
smoothly.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

3/22

1/21/2015
Ratethis:+19

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

Gauravsaid:(Fri,Sep5,201411:02:14PM)

Helloeveryone!
AsIndiaishavingmanycultureandreligions,sogivingallpowersandrightstoasinglepersonalwaysleadsIndia
toaunbalancedsituation.AsthereisacastsysteminIndiasothatpersonwillalwaysbebeneficialforhiscast.
Soinmyopiniondemocracyisbetterthendictatorship.
Thankyou.
Ratethis:+4

PrathmeshShenoysaid:(Wed,Sep3,201406:54:32PM)

IthinkthecountryneedsmetoruleitandmakeitadevelopedcountryIcan'tseemycountrymensufferingIwant
togivethemwhattheywantthatisdevelopmentpleasesupportmemycountrymenIwillrestoreyourfaithI'm
nottalkingtoyouasanormalpersonbutasadictator.
Ratethis:+4

24

PrathmeshShenoysaid:(Wed,Sep3,201406:42:56PM)

IbelieveourcountryisinevilhandsofcorruptminsterswhothinkweareblindIbelieveweneedastrongdictator
whowilldealwiththesetraitorswithironfistandshallkillanypersonwhostandsagainstcountryweneeda
dictatorwhoshallalwayscreatefearinantisocialelementsandmakestrictrulesandregulationsforpeople.
Democracyisaenemyofourcountryweneedastrongleaderonlythenwecanmakeprogress.
Iwanttotellmycountrymenastrongleaderisborninourholymotherland.
AndIbelieveweshouldSupporthimheisnoneotherthanme.
Ratethis:+3

30

VarunSrivatsasaid:(Fri,Aug29,201405:21:31PM)

Indianeeddemocraship.WhatIwantisthatIndianpeopleshouldgetjusticeandourleadersshouldgetfull
freedomtomaintaincountryasIndiaispopulatedcountrysomakingpoliciespassingbillisnotaneasyjobtoour
leadersalltheirtermwillbespentinpassingthebillsoIndiashouldgetdemocrashipwhereadictatormakesthe
decisionandhisdecisionisfinalsodemocratoristherightpersonforIndia.
Ratethis:+2

Kingelsaid:(Wed,Aug27,201409:42:33AM)

HelloEveryone!
Inmyopinion,Indiaisacountryofdiversecultureandreligionswhichisoneofthepivotalfeatureofourcountry&
inthiscasetoGiveasinglepersonallthepowerstotakedecisionforallofthemwillnotbetenable.Democracyis
thebestformofgovtsuitstoourcountry.ButTheformofgovtwillnotdecidethefutureofourcountry.Theneed
ofthehourisEDUCATIONforALL.
ThankYou.
Ratethis:+15

Torpedosaid:(Thu,Aug21,201402:29:08AM)

Dictatorshipwillleadyoutoprogress,butitsnotsuitableforIndiawherewehavesomuchdiversityofculture&
themindsetofbeingruledbyareligiousperson,willnotatallworkwithIndia'sdemography!Itsmorelikelyto
igniteacivilwar.DemocracyisthevitalpartofIndiaanIndiansystemswhichempowerseverycitizenwithspecial
righttowardsmakingIndiaabetterPlace.DictatorshipwillleadIndiaintoadarkfutureofnofriendlycountries
arounditsborderIndiawillnotbeabletoretainthesustainability.Dictatorshiphasitsowndownpoints,asa
singledictatorcannotunderstandandleadthemassofIndiaandtheminorcommunitieswillfeelleftalone.
Ratethis:+5

YuvaSatyasaid:(Tue,Aug19,201402:08:38PM)

YesIndianeedsadictatorship.OursocietyisaPUPPETinthehandsofthesocalledpoliticalleaders,theyrunthe
societyaccordingtotheirrequirementsifitbenefitsthem(theirpockets)theyjustdoitatthecostofeven
numerouslives.TheantisocialelementsarenotjustthebarricadesforIndia'sdevelopmentbutaretheroot
causeforIndiatodescend.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

4/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

Allthiscomestoanendonlywhenthereisastrongruleofadictator.Hisinstantandstrictrulesimprovethelaw
andregulationsofthecountry.
Ipreferforitandawaitforittohappensoon.
Ratethis:+9

Gowthamsaid:(Sun,Aug17,201410:26:50AM)

Indianeedsdictatorshipbecausedictatoristheonlypersontochangethelawandhewillsuitablejudgementto
rapistsbysentencingthemtodeath.AsyouknowRajivgandhiwasassassinated.Thecourtisstillthinkingto
sentencethemtodeath.Thecourtisnotabletogiveproperjudgementtoavictimswhokilledtheprimeminister.
Thenhowcanbelievethelawhelpsacommonman.IamreadytobecomedictatorbutIamwaitingfor
opportunity.
Ratethis:+19

Vikrantsaid:(Sat,Aug16,201412:57:58PM)

IthinkIndianeedsademocrashipi.e.acombinationofdemocracyanddictatorship.Inthisformofgovtsome
issuessuchaslawmaking,crime,armedforcesarehandledthroughdictatorshipandotherissuessuchas
educationarehandledthroughdemocracy.Simplyspeakingdividealltheissuesintotwo.
Ratethis:+6

RishabhAgnihotrisaid:(Fri,Aug15,201404:00:43PM)

NoIndiadoesnotneedadictatorbecauseIndiaisacountryofvariedculturesandreligionsandtothinkthatone
personcanmakelawsforallofthemunilaterallyisabsurd.WhatIndianeedsisastrongleaderwhocantake
toughdecisionsandcanconvincetheparliamenttorallybehindhim.Thiswillgiveriseogooddecisionmakingand
willalsokeepthespiritoffreeIndiaintact.
Ratethis:+19

PranayDuttasaid:(Fri,Aug8,201402:50:52PM)

AsofwhatIndianeedstoday,itisnothingotherthanastrongdictatorwhocantakedecisionsinstantly.
Today,weliveinasocietyfullofantisocialelements.Evenifsomeofusdareandspeakagainstit,ourvoiceis
oppressedbythepowerful.But,whoarethesepowerfulpeopleandwheredotheycomefrom?
Well,theyarenothingbutordinarypeoplewhoareveryclever.Theyusetheweaknessofthecommonmasses
cleverlyagainstothersinaveryefficientmanner.Indoingso,they"ROB"therightfullyearnedmoneyofothers,
throughwhichthiswholesystemruns.
Itisacommonpracticeinhumanbehaviourthatpeoplerespectandfollowtheordersthosewhomtheyfear,like
weallfearTheAlmighty.Ifthisruleisappliedtooursociety,thenthereisnolaworperson,assuch,todaywhom
thepeopleareafraidof.Robbers,culprits,dacoitsandmanyotherantisocialelementsaretodayroamingfree,
causingharmtoothers.Hadtheybeenafraidof'LAWandORDER',ourcountrywouldnothavebeenwhereweare
today.Thelawmakingbodyourcountryalsodoesn'twanttomakestrictlawsbecauseifsomeonefromtheirside
isaccused,thentheywouldalsohavetofacecharges.
TheJudiciaryofourcountryisalsoverylenient.Ifsomeoneaccusedofaveryseriouscrime,likemurder,isabout
tobehanged,TheSupremeCourtorTheHighCourtoftherespectiveplaceputastayorderonit.Thisisthe
reasonwhythefamilyofthevictimof16/12rapecaseisstillawaitingjustice.TheassassinatorsofShriRajiv
Gandhishouldhavebeengivendeathbynow,butstilltheywereletoffandtheirpunishmentchangedtoLife
Sentence.Touristsarealsonotsparedmanytimesinourcountry.Thiswouldnotonlyleadtothedegradationof
ourcountry'sreputation,butourTourismsectorwouldbeworsthit.Veryshamefulforourcountry.
Now,comingto"Dictatorship".Yes,dictatorshipistheworstformofgovernment,butstilltheneedoftimeforIndia
isdictatorship.Adictator,whocanmakestronglawswhocanrevolutionizeourcountry,ismuchrequired.Adolf
HitlerhassaidinhisautobiographyMeinKampf"Iamthankfultothatperiodoflife(whenhewasinVienna)
becauseithardenedmeandenabledmetobeastoughasIamnow.IamgratefulthatIwasthrownintoaworld
ofmiseryandpovertyandthuscametoknowthepeopleforwhomIwasafterwardstofight."Thelawsmadeby
thedictatorwouldbeverystrict,therebycreatingfearinthemindofculpritsandhelpindecreasingthecrimelevel
ofourcountry.
Weshouldalwayshopethatoneday,ourthisdreamshallcometrue.TheyouthofIndiahasthecapabilityto
accomplishthisfeat.
Ratethis:+8

Madurisaid:(Sat,Aug2,201411:21:17PM)

Hi,
InmyopinionIndiadoesn'tneeddictatorship.BecauseIndiahasalargestdemocracyandourdemocracydefines
allthefundamentalrightsofeverycitizeninIndia.Butifdictatorshipistheirthenthepersoncanmoreintention

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

5/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

towardsthepeople.Thereforeourdemocracyisneededwhichmayhelpallthepeopletochoosetheirleaderon
theirownorinterest.
Thankyou.
Ratethis:+4

Amarsaid:(Fri,Aug1,201408:19:31AM)

Inmyopinion,DemocracyisthebestformofgovernmentIndiacanhave.Indiaisthemostdiversecountrywhere
peopleofmanyreligion,language,cultureetclive.Thesehavevariedinterestswhichnosinglepersoncan
entertain.
Indemocracy,everycommunityhastheirrepresentativesinthegovernmentwhofightsfortheirinterests,thus
everybodyhastheauthoritywhichmakethemsatisfied.
Iknowthatdespitedemocracywehavenotbeenabletoachievewhatwewantedbuttheunity,fraternityand
peaceinthecountryisduetothedemocracyandifwewantthecountrytoachievemoresuccessthenwe,the
peopleshouldchangeourattitudeandholdaccountabilityasitisultimatelythepeopleofourownsocietythatare
takingthedecisions.
Ratethis:+5

Elinasaid:(Wed,Jul30,201409:33:47PM)

Hi,Iwouldliketoexpressmyopiniontooaboutthistopic.
Whentoomuchofpowerisconcentratedinonehand,itgenerallyleadstomisuseofsuchpower.Dictatorshipis
exactlythat.Onepersoncaninitiateachangebutunlesseveryone'willingly'followsit,thechangeisjusta
dormantoneorfutile.Andforcingapersonisnotanoption.Dictatorshiprepresentsallthat.Moreover,itisnot
necessarythatthedictatorwhosegonnacomeuphasacompletelypureintention.Thus,thesolutionofIndia's
increasingcrimesandcorruptionisnotdictatorship.
Democracy,withoutadoubt,isthebestformofgovernmentbutjustselectingapersonandhandingthemsome
powerandhopingthattheywouldchangeorendtheentirenation'sgriefisjustpathetic.Theycouldjust
formulatelawstobuildadreamnationbutwithoutthecooperationofcitizenslivinginit,itisanimpossibletask.If
thecitizensrefusetofollowtheirdutythenIdoubtthepoliticalleader(withnomatterhowmuchaclearintention)
couldn'tbringaboutanychange.Thetaskofbettermentofnationliesinour(citizen's)handandnotsomerandom
personweselecttohandoverthedutyofhandlingthenation.Theyaredoingtheirdutyandweshoulddoours.
Anddictatorshipisdefinitelynottheanswertothechallengesthenationisfacing.Atyrannicaldictatorcoulddoas
muchasthepoliticalleaderalbeitwithmuchmoreforce.Butitwillultimatelydoasmuchgoodasthepresentgovt
isbecauseultimatelythechangemoreincitizen'shandthaninleaders.Leaderscanguideusbutunlessthe
citizenstakeituponthemselvestofollowtheguidanceitisasgoodasacandlewithoutmatches.
Ratethis:+9

Sathyasaid:(Fri,Jul4,201404:43:57PM)

DictatorshipisnotnecessaryformodernIndia.AsgovernmentofIndiahasframedtheconstitutioninsuchaway
thattherewillbeensuredsecurityforallcommunitiessuchasminoritieswomenandchildren.Thereisastrong
defenceforcesagainstcorruption,andotherbacklogsinIndia.StillsomehurdlesarearegoinginIndia.
DictatorshipisnotinusefulinanymannerinIndia.Becauseitisundertheruleofamonopolyandhewilldoashe
likes.Ifheisagoodmanwecanadjusttohim.Butwhenheiswickednoonecanadjusthim.Inthecaseof
yemenwhoruledugandaacountryinafricaandhitlerwhoruledGermanythishashappened.Inademocratic
countrylikeIndiathegovtisbythepeopleforthepeopleandtothepeoplesopeopleshouldelectaresponsible
andcourteouspersontorule.
Ratethis:+20

SreeramVariyamsaid:(Wed,Jul2,201410:16:44PM)

Firstofall,Indiaisademocraticcountryanddemocracyhasbeendefinedas"ofthepeople,bythepeopleandfor
thepeople".Sothepoweriswiththepeopleandifthereisaprobleminademocraticcountryitisthefaultofthe
people,ForexampleweallmakeabigfussandcomplainthattheroadsaredirtyinIndia.Whoistheonedirtying
theroad?Isitthegovernment,noit'susthepeople.SobasicallytheproblemwithIndiaisthatthecitizensare
misusingthefreedomgiventothepeople.SoIstronglybelievethatIndiaisneedsadictatorshipforafewyears
tillTheIndiansbecomesdisciplined.
Ratethis:+37

13

Kartikaysaid:(Sat,Jun21,201408:59:01PM)

Eventhoughwetakealotofprideinsayingthat"Indiaistheworld'slargestdemocracy",theoutcomeofthis
formofgovernmenthasbeenfarfromsatisfactory.Inflation,scamsandscandals,lowergdp,risinglevelofcrime,
allthesehavetornapartthecountryandledtotheloweringofmoraleofthecitizens.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

6/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

Asissaid"Toomanycooksspoilthebroth",themayheminIndiaisaclassicexampleinsupporttothis.Ourso
calledworthydemocrats,thepeoplewhomwepinourhopesupon,areoftenunabletoreachtoasatisfactory
decisionontopicsofnationalinterestandhaveadividedopinion.Incaseofapersonhavinganautonomous
authorityatleastwewouldbeservedwithconcretedecisionswhichwecouldchewuponandwouldyieldresults.
AtLeasthewouldnotsitmumwhileourterritoryisbeingseizedbyour"neighbors"butwouldtakeaction.
Thecurrentformofgovernmenthasnotyieldedanypositiveresultsandwestillremainathirdworldcountry.
Changeistheonlyconstantandweshouldbemorereceptivetoautocraticformofgovernmenttoo.
Ratethis:+15

Rimpasaid:(Wed,Jun11,201406:06:28PM)

No,accordingtomyview,Indiaisademocraticcountrywheredifferentracesanddifferentcastetakesbreathin
thiscountry,ifdictatorisexistinthatcountrythentheintegrityandthesovereigntyofthecountrywillhamperand
itwillleadtoaconflictamongthepeopleduetoallottingofonlyoneleaderwithoutpeople'spermission.Itmay
happenthattheleaderwhichisnominatedmaygiveimportancetothispeopleandhemaybehavinglikeanhilter.
Ratethis:+9

ShashankKumarsaid:(Tue,May20,201403:33:47PM)

HiFriends,IamShashank.Thistopicsoundstobeaveryinterestingone.
Ipersonallyfeelthatthegivingthecountry,especiallylikeIndia,whichisdiversifiedinitseveryaspect,tothe
handsofthedictatorislikenothingbutinvitingtheproblemsyourself.Someofmyfriendsthinkthatyesthe
dictatorshipisgoodasthedictatorisfreetotakethedecisionsfirmlyandwillbeabletoeradicatetheproblems
likecorruption,terrorismbutwouldhappenifhehimselfterrifiedthecountrywithhisacts.Onecan'timaginewhat
wouldbethepicofIndiathen.Idoagreebutthathealsomaybebestandcantakethecountrytozenithheights
ofsuccessbutthentothispointIwouldliketoquoteanEnglishproverb.
"Twoheadsarebetterthanone".
Soinsteadofchoosingthedictatorweshouldtrytobearesponsiblecitizenfirstandthenweshouldalsotrytoto
electabestcandidatepossible,notfromselectedlist,i.efromlistavailabletoyou,butfromthelistwethepeople
ofIndiathinkshouldbe.
OnlyafterthenwecanthinkofaglorifiedIndia.
Thankyou.

Ratethis:+49

Apexasaid:(Sun,May11,201401:13:03PM)

Theonlyreasonwhywecanpost/commentonanythingisbecauseofthedemocracyinIndia.Everyideology
comeswithbenefitandflawssododemocracyanddictatorship.
Ifwewantdictatorshipweallshouldbereadytonottoraisevoiceagainstanything.Nochoices,noprotest
againstlowwagesgiventolabourersetc.Stayinginademocraticcountrywecannotimaginehowdoesitfeel
livinginacountryfollowsdictatorship,lookatmiddleeastcountries!.
TalkingaboutmyselfIamproudtobethecitizenofasecularcountrywhereifIwantIcanmakechangesin
politicsbecausedemocracyallowsmetodoso.
Ratethis:+24

Rajsaid:(Fri,May2,201412:12:16AM)

No,allthatIndianeedstobeasuperpoweristhattheeducatedpeoplelikeyouandmeshouldunderstandour
responsibilitywellandcontributetoitsprosperitybyourdeeds.Hadwebeenrealisingthissincewegotfreedom
thescenariowouldhavebeenquitedifferent.Wecallnamestothepoliticiansandsaydamnthingsaboutthem
andescapeeventhemostimportantroletobeplayedasacitizenofademocracyVOTINGjustonthepretext
thatallthepoliticiansarethesameandwewillnotvotetoany.
Whilesayingsowedonotrealisethatthisisourvotewhichcouldmakethedifferencebecausewewillalwaysbe
choosingalesserevil,eveniftheassumptionofallthepoliticiansbeingeviliscorrect.
Ifwewouldbechoosingtheleastevilsinceourindependencethebestevilwouldhavecomeoutbynowtorule
thecountry.Thisiswewhowastemostofthepreciousresourcesofthecountrywhicharenotinabundanceand
leavetheweakersectiondeprivedof,forinstance,drinkingwater,electricity,cookinggas,fueletc.Etc.Thebold
andclearquestioninfrontofwetheintellectandeducatedpeopleisWHOGETSDIRTYTOCLEANTHEHOUSEOF
OUROWN.Infacttheweakeranduneducatedsectionofoursocietyisnotevenawareoftheresponsibilitiesofa
responsiblecitizen.
Sohowcanweexpecthimtohavelesschildrenandnotincreasethealreadyburgeoningpopulationofthe
country.Againthisiswewhocaneducatethematleastasmuchasitisnecessarytoreadandwrite.Dowenot
encounterinoureverydaylifeatleastonesuchilliteratepersonwhocomesacrossourroutinelifeandwecan

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

7/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

educatehim/her?
Ratethis:+6

Devashissaid:(Sat,Apr19,201406:04:09AM)

INDIANEEDSADICTATOR.
Whilewetalkofdictatorshipwealwaystendtothinkandgiveexamplesofnazisandfascistsetcbutthinkofthis,
ifwetalkaboutvotingarightcandidatetopowerwhycan'tahonestpersoncometopowerbyhimselfandlead
byexamplenowthatsapossibility.DemocracyisnewtoIndiaanditsjustfewdecadesoldandlookatits
condition,peoplehavelostfaithonthegovernmententirely.Weareadeadlymixofpeoplewhowerenever
meanttoremaintogetherButallweneedisacohesiveforce,aforcesopowerfulthatwillnotonlybinduswith
fearbutpeace,stabilityanddevelopment.ThedictatorshipinIndiashouldbelikeasfollows:
1.Therevisedconstitutionwillbetheonlyholybookoflaw.
2.Apartywithnationalisticprogrammesandnohiddenagenda.
3.Noreservationsbutinsteadrobustfacilitiesandtalentdevelopment.
4.Governmentalparticipationbasedoneducation,experienceandlikenessofpublic.
5.Noappeasementpoliticsbutyesthehinduismshouldbetaughttotheworldasthisistheonlylandforhindus.
6.Auniformcivilcodeandcooperativeparticipationfromgrassrootlevels.
7.Everythingthatisantinationalshouldbebanned.
8.Sanskritshouldbemadecompulsoryatschools.
9.Asinglepartyinwhichanyonecanparticipate.
10.5yearelectionswillstillbeconductedbutwithrevisedandbestelectionprocedures.
11.Revisionofauthorityandsimplergovernancemechanismsinplace.
12.Growth,prosperityandcityhygieneshouldbefirstonagenda.
13.Religiousandculturalorganisationsshouldbemonitoredandanyhatepropagandashouldbemetwithstrict
punishment.
14.TheglorydaysofIndiashouldbebroughtbackwithefficientandhonestgovernanceandfullpublic
participation.
Icanwritemanysuchpointsbutattheendofthedayitsournecessityandourdesperationandfrustrationwith
thecurrentstateofaffairsthathasledustofindthebestwaytodriveournation.Andlastbutnottheleastisn't
itthatoursocalled5yeargovernanceisactuallyTEMPORARYDICTATORSHIP.THINKABOUTTHAT.ANDYESIFYOU
HAVEN'TFIGUREDOUTYETASTOWHODICTATESYOUNOWFINDOUTWHOYOUARENOTALLOWEDTOCRITICIZE.
..PEACE..
Ratethis:+36

14

Ajaisaid:(Fri,Apr11,201411:33:56AM)

DictatorshipisnotacorrectsolutionofIndia.
Youseeninworldeverycountrynowwantdemocraticsohowwewantautocracy.
Eliminationorbananythingisnotasolutionwhilechangingtheconditionandmakeasystemgoodbydoingany
thingisasolution.
JustlikesomepeopletalksifIndiahavepowerinpresidenthandandarmyhandthenitisgood.Butyouthinkthat
iftheyaredoingsamethingorevenworstthingthenwhatwouldhappensinsteadofthatwhateversystemis
theremakeittransparentbetter.
Ratethis:+5

Bhanusaid:(Sat,Apr5,201403:24:35PM)

InMyopinion,Indiayesdorequiredictatorshipinasomesense.Inlastfewyearswehaveseenthatthegov.Has
failedonmyfrontseitheritbeeconomic,healthcareordefense.Wereallyneedastrongleaderatthecentrewho
cantaketoughdecisionsoneveryfront.Democracywithastrongandtoughleaderisfarmuchbetterthanpure
dictatorship.
Ratethis:+20

Balasaid:(Sat,Apr5,201404:10:49AM)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

8/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

ItisverynicetoreadallyourideasonwhetherIndianeedsaDictatororDemocracy.
FirstthingweshouldunderstandthatDictatorcannotbeelectedorinstalled.Heemergesfromthe
situation/problemandtakecontrolofthecountry.Ifheisgoodthecountrywilldefinitelybenefitfromit.Otherwise
likemanyAfricancountrieswhichareunderdifferenttypesofDictatorssuffer.
OnethingIfailedtounderstandwhyallthesepostsfailedtomentionthecurrentsituationofDictatorshipinAfrica
whichwillprovideuswithmanycues.
Ratethis:+3

AnilGargsaid:(Tue,Apr1,201411:59:34AM)

Hifriends,Iamanil.ThistopicofwhetherIndianeedsdictatorshipisaseriousone.So,wemusttakeadequate
stepsregardingthismatter.
InmypointofviewthereisnouseofdictatorshipinIndia.Indiaisavastcountryanddifferentpeoplehave
differentneeds.Soitisdifficultforonepersontounderstandtheneedsofallthepeople.
Itisnotrighttoimplydictatorshipbylookingattheothercountries.Americaisdevelopedbecausetheyareused
todictatorshipandthereproblemsaredifferentandtherepopulationisalsoverylessascomparetoIndia.
DemocraticgovernmentisthebestforthecountrieslikeIndia.Onlythingthatisrequiredisthattheleaderswhich
areselectedshouldworkproperlyandfaithfully.
THANKS.
Ratethis:+46

KshitijKumarsaid:(Wed,Mar12,201403:15:17PM)

Well,Iseethatdemocracyisthebetteralternativeagainstdictatorship,asbecause.
1.Adictator,willhavehisownviewofcountry'soveralldevelopment,whichmightnotsuiteveryone'sneed.Worst
casescenariowouldbethatheshallplanonlyforhisbenefits,ortoimplementhisagenda.Beside,weshallnever
knowwhetherthedictatorthusinstalledinhis/herpostwouldactuallyworkforthedevelopmentofthisgreat
country?andhewillnotbeaccountabletoanyone.
2.Evenifdemocracygetscorrupted,itneedsthesupportofthepeopleinordertosurvive.So,evenifonemakes
falsepromisesinordertowoovoters,he/shestillmusthavetodosomethinginordertogetreelected.Inother
way,democracyensuresthedevelopment,inspiteofhowfastorslowitis.
Soifyouanyproblem,choosearightrepresentativewhoishonest,empatheticandcanmakeandimplement
strategiestoimproveourlives.
Ifyoudon'tfindanyone,BECOMEONE.

Ratethis:+10

Sudhanshusaid:(Fri,Mar7,201410:39:48PM)

Itisnomatterthatwhetheritisdemocracyandautocracyitisgoodgovernmentwhichmakesthedifferencebutif
wetalkaboutIndiathenImustfavourautocracybecauseIfeelitcandosuchthingwhicharenotdonebyour
democracyevenin60yearIwanttonamedthencorruption,reservations,communalriot.Ifpowergoesinone
handheisallowtodoonehandandforthatnooneclaimforthat,taketheexampleofchinawhenheseethat
overpopulationheimplementedtheonechildpolicyatthesametimeIndiaalsowanttoimplementtwochildpolicy
buthecouldnotdobecauseofdemocracybutchinaimplementbecauseofsemiautocracy,thattypethingsIwant
toexpress,thankyou.
Ratethis:+10

Kushnabhsaid:(Thu,Mar6,201401:24:36PM)

Helloeveryone.
Inmyopinion,thewaypoliticsisdoneinourcountryisnothinglessthanadictatorship.Itislikedictatorshipfor
fixed5years.
Indemocracy,peoplehaveasay,representativeshavetoimplementthedesiresandneedsofpeople.Butinthe
politicalscenarioofourcountrythatisnotthecase.Representativesactlikeanythingwithoutcaringfortheneeds
ofcommonman.
HencewhatIwanttosayisthatdictatorshiplikeruleisalreadytherewhichisincapableofgoverningourcountry.
Whatweneedisdemocracyinitstruesense.
Ratethis:+9

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

9/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

AditiKharesaid:(Fri,Feb28,201412:03:45PM)

AccordingtomyviewsIdon'tseeanybenefitsinswitchingfromdemocracytodictatorshipbecauseitsnotthe
governmentwhichisresponsibleforthedownfallofhumanity,itiswethecitizens.
Soinordertomakeourcountrygoodenoughallweneedisourincreasedresponsibilityandproper
understanding.
Ratethis:+3

Rakeshsaid:(Thu,Feb27,201402:06:36PM)

Beforespeakingaboutdemocracyordictatorship.Iwouldliketohighlightfewhypocriticalmentalityofweindians.
1.Whodoesnotgivetheirtaxontime?
2.Whoabuseswomen?
3.Whoisresponsibleforchildmarriages?
4.Whobuysblacksimsandmoviedvdsetc.?
5.Whooverdrinksalcoholandsmokesandtakedrugs?
6.Whogivesmoneyundertable?
7.Whobecomesdistrictofficers,policeofficers,andofficersofvariouspublicservicedepartment?
8.Whoemployschildreninhotelorathomeasservant?
Toallthesequestionstheansweristhesame"itiswecommonpeoplearetheonewhodoit"andnotthe
"government".
FromwheredoestheMLA'sandMP'scomefrom?ofcoursetheydon'tcomefromhellbutoncetheyusetobe
commonpeoplelikeus!
Andinfuturewewillbetheonewhowillrulethegovernment.
Blamingorchangingthegovernmentmaynotbeasolutiontoourproblembutchangingourselvesandbygivinga
bitextratimeforourcountrycandevelopIndiawithin5years!yes!Imnotkidding!
Theonlysolutiontoourproblemis1.Changeinmentalityofourpeople,2.Andbecomeabitlessselfish.
THAT'SALLISENOUGHTOCHANGEOURCOUNTRY!(myspeechwasquitelong.Sorryifyouallgotbored).

Ratethis:+57

Binusaid:(Fri,Jan31,201405:01:25PM)

Hi.
Ijustwanttosaythataftersome65yearsofdemocracyinourcountry.
Arewesatisfied?
Havewestopfightingonthenameofreligion,caste,creedetc?
Isthereanygrowthineconomy?
Isthegdpisgrowing?
Areweabletohaveacontrolovercrimerateinourcountry?
Areweabletosaveourpeoplefrombeingbeheadedbypakistanarmy?
ANDTHESEALLQUESARESTILLHEREINDEMOCRATICGOVERNMENT.SOWHYNOTWESHOULDGIVEACHANCETO
THEDICTATORSHIP?
Mightpossiblewewillhavethesolutionforourproblems.Aswearebearingtherepercussionsofthisdemocracy,
sowecanbearofthedictatorshipalso.
THANKYOU.
Ratethis:+25

11

ShouryaSodhanisaid:(Sun,Jan26,201411:00:05AM)

Ademocracyisliterallydefinedasbythepeopleandforthepeople.Ademocracyhelpsthecitizensofanation
stayinvolvedinthehappeningsoftheirnationandelectthegovernmentthattheyfeelwillbethebestforthem
andalsogivesthemasenseofresponsibility.Theoneswhoarefordictatorshipsmightsaythatthegovernment,
likeinIndiamayturnouttobecorruptanddisastrous.
Buttherewillalwaysbesomeone,someonelikeArvindKejriwalforIndiawhowillattempttosolveourproblems.
Inadictatorship,iftheruleriscorrupt,thecitizenswouldn'tevenhaveanychoicetoreelectanotherleader.Even

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

10/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

iftheyattemptanyrebel,theywillonlyfaceseverepunishment,maybeevendeath.So,IstronglyfeelthatIndia
needsastrongandintelligentleaderratherthananoppressivedictator.
Ratethis:+9

KaranBalajisaid:(Sat,Jan4,201409:07:26PM)

HelloguysIamkarandictatorshipisactuallyhorriblebutitcanbeusedinIndiatosolveoureconomicproblemby
aselflessleaderwhoshouldallowreferendumprocessandifhegotanonconfidencevotehemustbereplaced.
Ofcoursewegotawegotalotofgooddictatorsinourcountry.Ourbharatmatahelpedtoachievewhatany
countryhavenot.Iamsuredictatorshipcanbeusedingoodwayonlyforaparticulartermtillourcountrybecome
adevelopedcountry.Thenagainwecanswitchovertodemocracy.
Ratethis:+14

DemocracyIndia
SingerIndia
LibertyIndia

Mohitsaid:(Mon,Oct28,201303:42:09PM)

Dictatorshipwillbreeddevelopmentthoughstraightforwarddecisionmaking:Adictatorbeingtheallpowerful
headofthestatewillfacenooppositionfromotherpartiesasinademocracy.Hewillthushavecompletefreedom
toexecutehisdecisionswhichmightbreeddevelopment.
Bettercontrolthevariablesofhumandevelopment:OneofthebiggestexamplesisChina(aCommunistcountry)
wherethepopulationhasbeenbroughtundercontrolbythegovernment,throughtheonechildnormpolicywhich
isvirtuallyimpossibleintheIndiandemocracy.
Dictatorshipisamoreeconomicinstitution:InacountrylikeIndiawherepovertyisalingeringproblem,itisbuta
luxurytospendlakhsonasingleelection.Dictatorshipisthusafarmoreeconomicinstitution.
Dictatorshipsregimescanbeapathforcountriestomoveonfromcivilwarsandfocusondevelopment:China
canbeusedasanexampleyetagain,asthecountryhasbeenalmostabsolutelyinsulatedfromwarsandterrorist
attacks.
Dictatorshipshaveflexibilityineconomicpolicythatbreedsgrowth:Democracycanoftenstagnateeconomic
development.AnexampleisWestBengalwheretheTatagroupcouldnotestablishtheirfactoryinSingurdueto
stiffresistancefromtheoppositionpartyinthegovernment.
Dictatorshiphelpsachievesocialstability:Yesitdoes.
Thelongerlastingandbiggesteconomicmiracleshaveoccurredunderdictatorships:AnexampleisHitler'sreign
inGermany."TheNaziscametopowerinGermanyin1933,atatimewhenitseconomywasintotalcollapse,with
ruinouswarreparationobligationsandzeroprospectsforforeigninvestmentorcredit.Yetthroughan
independentmonetarypolicyofsovereigncreditandafullemploymentpublicworksprogram,theThirdReichwas
abletoturnabankruptGermany,strippedofoverseascoloniesitcouldexploit,intothestrongesteconomyin
Europewithinfouryears,evenbeforearmamentspendingbegan".
Dictatorshipbreedsorder:InacountrylikeIndiawherelawandorderisdisruptedtimeandagain,dictatorshipis
definitelygoingtohelpout.Eveninthe21stcenturyIndianwomenarevulnerableandrapeandmolestation
casesarereportedthroughoutthecountryfromupscaleDelhitotheremotevillagesofBurdwan.Indianeedsa
reallystrongleaderwhocanmakethecountrysafeenoughforourwomentomovearoundfearlessly,withtheir
headsheldhigh.
Dictatorshaveincentivestopromotedevelopmentanddiminishsocialdifferences:Alotofreadersmightstillbe
optimisticenoughtofeelthatdemocracywillspellbetterdaysforIndia,butasayouthfrustratedwiththecurrent
situationofmycountryIfeelthatwereallyneedachangeanddictatorshipmayjustbethewayoutforabetter,
brighterIndia.

Ratethis:+66

10

Ashcoolsaid:(Fri,Sep27,201303:09:13PM)

Indianeedsademocraticdictator.WhatImeantosayisthatwedefinitelyshouldbegovernedbyademocratic
system(likeitisnow),buttheprimeministerofIndiashouldbecharismaticenoughtotakedecisionsinawayin
whichadictatorwouldhavetakenthem.
Noonecanpressurizeadictator,similarlyourprimeministershouldalsoleadusfearlessly.Thereshouldnotbe10
differentpeopletryingtoinfluencehim.Heshouldhavethegutstotakedecisionsfearlessly.
Soinshortweneedtohaveademocraticsetupinwhichthechosenleader(theprimeminister)shouldfunctionas
adictator.
Ratethis:+34

Hbksaid:(Mon,Sep23,201310:23:58PM)

WhetherthedemocracyisbestforeverycountrybutitsnotworkingwellforIndia.Causesarenotonlyour
corruptedpoliticiansandleadersbutalsothewholesystem.BritishruledoverIndiabutafterindependencemany
ofthethingareasitis.Forexampleourrailwaydepartmentisoneoftheworldslargestdepartmentanddoing
verywellbutitcanbebetterthanthatandnothinghadchangedsincetheindependenceinrailwaysdepartment.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

11/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

ItsoundsgoodThegovernmentforpeopleandbythepeoplebutinactualitisnotworkingwellforIndia.
Ratethis:+8

Aniruddhsaid:(Fri,Sep20,201310:43:27PM)

WhatIndianeedsisadictatorship?
Thisisaquiteserioustopic.Democracyversusdictatorship.Firstofallweneedtounderstandthemeaningofboth
thetermproperly.Democracybasicallymeansagovernmentwherepeoplechooseleadersbyvotingwhereasin
dictatorshipthereisasinglepersonwhomakeallrulesnogovernmentnopartiesnoconstitution.
See,supposethereisacycleandabike,thepersonwhoisdrivingcycleisgoodindrivingandcandriveinany
kindofroad.Andonewhoisdrivingabikeisnotabletodriveproperly.Whatwillhappen.Theonewhoishaving
gooddrivingskillswillwin.
Similarlywhetheritisadictatorshipordemocracy,itdoesnotmatteratall,providedthattheonewhorunningthe
wholesystemshouldbeabletomakerightdecisionsandhaveskills.
WealwaysblameourgovernmentanddemocracyfortheconditionofIndiabutwecanalsoseethatwhen
pakistanwasbeingruledbyadictator,theconditionofpakistanwaspoorer.
Ratethis:+19

Vinay.H.Ssaid:(Fri,Sep6,201303:45:00PM)

Hifriends,
IthinkDictatorshipcannotleadIndiabetterthanthedemocraticgovernment.Ourgovernmenthasfine
infrastructurewhichwillleadtothebettermentofthesocietyifwefollowitsincerely.WeIndiansareverywell
awareofdictatorshipruleanditsconsequenceswhicharesobadthatIdon'tthinkanintelligentmanorevena
illiteratemancaneverthinkofadictatorruleagaininIndia.Thereisjustaneedofremovingcorruptionfromour
countryandalsoweshouldchangeouroldpolicies.ItisnotarightdecisiontostartdictatorshipinIndiaaswe
don'tknowthatdictatoriscorruptedornot.Indiansshouldchangetheirmentality,Inspiteofcommentingon
systemweshouldthinkofimprovingit.
Ratethis:+10

Aakritisaid:(Tue,Sep3,201303:10:13PM)

Hello!friendsIamjustconcludingthatwhobothersforthecountryeveryoneisbusyinmintingmoneybyhookor
bycrookandincreasingthebankbalanceandanywaysourcountryisgovernedbythealmightyandwillcontinue
likethisonly.Itisirrelevanttosaywhetheradictatorcomesordemocracy.Hence,inmyopinionthereisnouseof
givingargumentseitherfordemocracyorfordictator.
Ratethis:+7

26

Sanjibsaid:(Mon,Sep2,201309:41:56AM)

NodoubtdemocracyisthebestformofgovernmentButintoday'ssituationitistotallybaseless.Fromtopto
bottommoreorlesseveryoneiscorrupt.Nodoubttherearesomegoodthinkingpeople,buttheirpresence
amongthosegiantcorruptpeopleminimizetheirallgoods.Ifsomehowtheytrytoprotest,theyhavetoleavethis
world.That'swhythereisaneedofagood,powerful,welleducateddictator,whoaccordingtosituationcould
bringsomedrasticchanges.
Ratethis:+10

ManishVermasaid:(Sat,Aug17,201312:27:07AM)

Inmyopinion,Indiaisademocraticcountry.Indiaisknownfortheirintegrityinallovertheworld.Indianeeds
dictatorstotellabouttheirfinancial,economicalandbusinesscondition.CitizenofIndiashouldhavetherightto
decidethedictators.BythiswayIndianpeoplecanknowaboutthecountryi.e.what'sgoingon.What'stypesof
problemourcountryfacingtoday.Andwhat'sthecountrygrowthallthis.Soweneedadictatorsinmyviewwitha
verysimpleandhighthinkingnature.
Ratethis:+5

JacobJheraldsaid:(Mon,Aug5,201312:18:00AM)

InmyopinionIthinkwedon'tneedacountrywhereeveryonediscriminateseachotherbystate,Religion,Caste
andcolour,Ithinkweshouldusethebritishpolicy,Dividethecountryintoindependentcountrieslikemaratis,
Tamils,Punjabislikethat,Believeitornotwedon'tcareaboutthiscountryifwehadthenourcountrywouldhave
neverbeenlikethis,Wehaveeverythingandyetwehavenothing.
Ratethis:+5

24

AtoshiSharmasaid:(Thu,Jul18,201312:22:06PM)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

12/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

Consideringthistobearatherserioustopic,I'dliketosaypeopleareentitledtotheirownopinions.I'venoticeda
lotofpeopleseemtosaywhatweneedisnotadictatorbutaresponsibleleaderwhowilltrytotakeintoaccount
theviewsofthepublic.
MightIadd,there's1.3billionofusinthisgreatnationandI'dsaymostpeoplesharethementalityoftheir
ancestorswholivedundertheBritishrule,whichisnamelylackofdevelopmentisthewayoflife.Weclingonto
meaninglesscustomsallinthenameofreligionandlikeitornot,itisthesecustomsthatcurbdevelopment.How
isanyonetotaketheviewsofthesepeopleintconsideration?
AlsoIfeelIndiansingenerallacknationalpride.Wesufferfromadeepinferioritycomplex,beitourskincolour,
ourlanguageoranythingtodowithIndia.Whydoyouthinkthefairnessindustryissorampant,orthefactthat
peopleseekforeignmadegoodsratherthanindigenousgoods,trytospeakbrokenEnglishnotfortheloveofthe
language?Ithinkweneedasemidictatorifthereisanysuchthing,someoneboundbyconstitutionyetfirm.
Ohandonelastthing,ourconstitutionneedstochange.WearestillfollowingtheBritishprinciplesofsuppression.
Ratethis:+11

Vjsupernadosaid:(Thu,Jul11,201306:18:11PM)

AdictatorshipisaviceforanydevelopingcountrysuchasIndia.ItisimportantthatIndiagetoveritsownsocial
andculturaldifferencesovertime,andthroughmultiplegenerations.TheCommunistdictatorshipinChinafor
examplehascreatedsignificantsocialdisorderduetotheCommunistparty'sobsessionoverquickdevelopment
withoutregardtooldhistoricalconflictswithinChina.Ofcourse,Chinarightnowseemstobetheeconomictigerof
Asia(andtheworldonthatnote),butassomeexpertsfear,assoonaseconomicgrowthslows,andpeoplestart
questioningthegovernment,Chinacouldpossiblyfaceadeadlycivilwarifitcontinuesit'spathofdevelopment
withoutregardtothepast.
Thetruthis,thereisnosuchthingasdevelopingoverdivisivehistory.Capitalismandeconomicdevelopmentcan
onlydiverttheattentionofpeopleforsolongbeforeoldfrustrationsareawakenedandreleased.Dictatorships
historicallyhaveonlybeenabletofindlegitimacyinfastpacedeconomicgrowth(especiallyinoursecularworld).
Thus,theproductisaforcefulgovernmentthatcoercespeopleintoignoringtheprobleminsteadofsolvingit.Itis
forthisreasonwhyviolentcivilwarsausuallywitnessedinpostdictatorshipnationssuchasYugoslavia,Somalia,
Russia,etc.Itisforthisreasonthatdictatorshipsonlygivetheillusionofsolvingsocialproblems,while
democraciespeacefullysolvesocialandculturaltensionthroughevendevelopment,andadeterminationtocoexist
withthesurroundingworld.
ItistellingthatmanyIndiansareimpatientwiththeslowprogresstheIndiangovernmentistakingindeveloping
andovercomingsocialtensionitisevidentinthefactthatmanyIndianswouldconsideradictatorshipasaviable
option.SomelooktocountrieslikeAmericaandsay,'whycan'twefixsocialconflictliketheycan?'Thisisdueto
thefactthatwesternnationshaveshorterhistory.Indiaisacountrywhoseproblemscomefromitseonsold
historythus,properlyfixingoldsocialproblemswilltakemuchlonger,aspeoplehaveanaturalattachmentto
historyandculture.
Properdevelopment,socially,economically,politically,andtechnologicallymustoccuratanevenpace,otherwise
Indiansriskloosingtheirnationalidentity,similartothefixtheChineseareinrightnow.Althoughhistoryis
frustratingtomanyforitsinconveniencesthathinderdevelopment,wemustbringclosureonthehistorybehindus
inordertoreachthefuture.Ignoringthepastwillonlyreawakenitinamoreominousforminthefuture.Thisis
theproblemthatnationsintheMiddleeastfaceafteryearsoffastpacedregimessuchasthatofShahRezain
Iranthathavepavedoveroldculturaldifferencesinsteadofresolvingthemhasbeenreleasedintheformof
radicalIslamandradicaltraditionaldictatorshipsthatarenowdestroyingalltracesofprogress.
Longterm,ifIndiawishestodevelopoutofthepast,theymustwaitandallowtimetodictatetheeventual
rejectionoftheold.Itisannoying,butpeoplemustbepatientyoucan'thavedevelopmentnow,ittakesyearsto
doitcorrectly.

Ratethis:+11

BandanaMankotiasaid:(Mon,Jul8,201305:29:26PM)

ThereisnoneedofdictatorshipinIndia,onlyadictatorcannotchangetheconditionofIndia.Thereisaneedof
good,educatedandresponsibleleadersandcitizensdespiteadictator.BecauseIndiaisthecountrywhere
peopleofvariousreligionslivetogether.Theyallhavetheirownthinking.Andonlyadictatorcannotchangetheir
thinking.Itneedssomeleaderswhohavethevisionforthewelfareoftheirpeople.Weshouldcomeforwardand
helpineradicatingthesocialevilsi.e.corruption,dowrysystem,illiteracyetc.
Ratethis:+17

Suhailsaid:(Sun,Jul7,201307:29:09PM)

Hifriends,IamSuhail.ThistopicofwhetherIndianeedsdictatorshipisaseriousone.So,wemusttakeadequate
stepsregardingthismatter.
IwouldliketosaythatIndianeedsnotdictatorbutanhonestleaderwhowouldbewiseenoughtotakecareof
thefutureof1.2billionpeople.Whochoosetheirleaderswithutmostfaith.
Inelectionsweelectsomanyleadersandmajorityofthemaredisappointingso,howisthiswiseenoughto

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

13/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

entrustonepersonwithsuchgreatresponsibility.
Dictatoralonecannotdecidewhatisrightandwhatiswrong.Ourleadersshouldbegiveneducationstoteach
themhowtobecomecivilized.Sothattheincidentofwatchingpornduringassemblywouldn'toccur.
AtlastIwouldliketosaythateverybodyshouldcontributetoournation.Meregivingopinionsain'tgoingtowork.
NotonlyleadersbutifalltheIndiancitizensconsiderIndiaastheirmotherlandandthepeopleastheirbrothers.
IamsurethatIndiawillemergeasagreatnation.
Remembercharitybeginsathome.
Ratethis:+24

Mohanasaid:(Sat,Jul6,201311:48:30AM)

WestudiedinourschooldaysthatIndia'sunityindiversitybutIndiaisindiversewithlotofreligionsandbecause
ofthisitisnotmaintainingunity.FirstIndiahavetoforgotabouttheworddiversethenonlytheunitycanbe
propagated.Forthisaperfectdictatorisneededwhowillstrictlyprohibitsthepeopleortheministerswhousethe
namereligionforhisownbenefitsforwhomthepeoplegetattractedtowardshimandblindlyelectedhim.The
dictatorshouldhaveallrightsontheministersandthedictatormustbeperfectfist.
Ratethis:+6

Theonesaid:(Mon,Jun24,201309:45:33AM)

Whenyoulookatthepolitician'sthathavebeenrulingIndiasinceitsindependenceyouwillrealizethedisease
theyaretoIndia.TheonlywaytogetridofthiscorruptioninIndiaistohaveaclearmindedandgoaloriented
dictatorworkingforthepeopleofIndia.
Adictatorwhowillholdallofthesepoliticiansresponsibleforallofthedamagetheyhavecaused.Thedictator
shouldstartbyacquiringalloftheblackmoneyheldbythesepoliticianswithforceandimprisonthemifnecessary.
Secondorderofbusinessshouldbetocrackdownonthepoliceforce,allofthecorruptpoliceofficersshouldbe
disbanded.Thedictatorwithallthepowerheldwillnothavetobendtopressurewhereprofitisconcerned,
providingallIndianswithamenities.
Thepoorwouldnotgohungry.Infrastructurewouldbedeveloped,andtherewouldbeahugeeconomicboost
consideringcompanieswouldbeabletoinvestinIndiawithouthavingtofirstpaythechiefministersofthe
respectivestatestodobusinessintheirstate.

Ratethis:+6

Qwertysaid:(Thu,May2,201311:26:24PM)

IndiadoesneedaDictator.
Notmatterhowmuchyouargue,Indiaisandneverwasunited.RightfromtheMoghulEmpiretilltodaythis
countrywasandisfightingamongsteachother.MaharashtrianandnorthIndians,MuslimsandHindus,openand
obcsscdalitsandalltheotherpettyfights.
Thiscountry'sgovernmenttakesintoaccountthereligiousandculturalfactorswillmakingdecisions.Eventhough
itswrittenintheconstitutionthatIndiaissecularstate.
Yes,theculturaldiversityiswhatmakesIndiasounique,butitisprettyuselessinmattersofgovernance.Trying
topleasethemajoritybyplayingintotheiremotionsandsupportingtheirreligiousandOrthodoxideasjusttoget
votesisprettyshitty.
Fightingoveradecadetodecidewhethertobuildashittytempleorashittymosqueonashittypieceofland.
Thatshowourgovernmentwastetimeandresources.
ThisgenerationisgoingtofacethethirdworldwarandI'mverysorrytoinformthatourcountryisnotprepared.
Weneedsomeonewhowillputalltheuselessideasandvaluesinrearviewandtakethiscountryforward.
SomeonewhowillmakeIndiasogreatthatitwillstrikefearintheheartsofChinese.Theusawillnotlookatus
ascallcenterhub.Someonewhowillusethemostimportantresourceinourcountry,the1.2Billionbeatinghearts
andunitethemtoformarespectedandfearedsuperpower.
Ratethis:+65

13

Manishsaid:(Thu,May2,201312:55:24AM)

IfeelIndiashouldgoforwardfordictatorshipaswehaveseenconsequencesofdemocracyfromtoptobottom
everyoneiscorruptandevenifsomeofustrytochangethatitwon'tchangeandinsteadwewillchange.Inshort
ImeantosaygivingpowertofewlikeAnnaHazareandhisfewmembersinformofdictatorshipwillnotonlymake
themonlytomakedecisionbutwon'tallowcorruptiontospreadorchangetheirthoughtstobecomecorrupt.
Ratethis:+14

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

14/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

Shivisaid:(Wed,Apr24,201311:25:25AM)

WellIdon'tthinkthatIndianeedadictator.WeneedaleaderwhohaveavisionforIndia.
Ratethis:+17

17

Pranavpsaid:(Wed,Mar13,201303:01:42AM)

WhatIndiareallyneedsisnotthecurrentdemocracynordoesitneedadictatorship.
Thecurrentdemocraticsystemisafailuresincethecitizensusuallyvoteforapersonwhoisagoodliaroractually
speaksthetruthbutchangesduetotheothercorruptedpoliticiansaroundhim.Thisiswhatleadsthecurrent
democraticsystemtobeafailure.
AdictatorshipmightworkoutinIndia,butthecitizenscannotbesureaboutthedictatormakingthecountrya
betterplaceormakingitworseforhisownbenefits.Sowhytakethechanceswithdictatorship.
Now,whatwereallyneedisacompletedemocraticsystem.Asystemwhereeveryonegetstovoteoneverything
thatshouldhappenorshouldnotinthecountryofIndia.Thissystemwilldefinitelyworkbutsomeonewillhaveto
comeupwithaplantomakethiswork.
Inthefuture,IamthinkingofcomingbacktoIndiafromwhereIliverightnow.ComebacktoIndiaandtryto
becomeapoliticianandhopefullyonedaythepresidentsoIcanmakethisplanasintheaboveparagraphwork.I
havebeenplanningallofthisforalongtime.OnceIdobecomethepresident,Iwillexecutemyplantochange
thecountryforgood.Myplanisbasedonchangesthatcanbemadeinrealityandnotjustthoughtaboutinone's
mind.ItwilldefinitelytakeyearstochangeIndiafromwhatitisnowtoabettercountryforall,butitisnot
impossible.
Thankyou.

Ratethis:+17

KanadanteMayavadenusaid:(Wed,Mar13,201301:55:39AM)

Iwouldliketosupportthetopic.Whateverthepointsmyfriendshavecommentedonisquitetrue.Indiaisknown
forSocialistic,DemocraticandRepublic.ButIdofeelthattheconceptofdictatorshipwasnottakenwhenthey
wereframingtheconstitutionduetotheadverseeffectofdictatorshipinGermany.
AnyonewhowanttotalkabouttheIndianpoliticsincurrentsituationwoulddefinitelysaythatdemocracyinIndia
isdefinitelynotworkingwell.ButstillIndiaisavastcountryandconsideringthedevelopmentIndiahasshown
fromthetimeofindependenceiswaypastmanycountries.Wecannevercompareourcountrywithothercountry
becauseofthedifferenceindatesoftheirindependence.Insixtyyearsofindependencewehavedevelopedso
muchthatwearecompetingwiththedevelopednationssuchasAmericawhogotindependencewaylongback.
Theneedfordictatorship,ifitisthereisallbecauseofthepoliticiansanddictatorshipseemstobetheonlywayto
comeoutoftheworstsituationcreatedbythepoliticians.Whynotwethinkaboutaddingtheconceptof
dictatorshiptoourconstitutionandgivingmorepowerstothepresidentthanprimeminister.Afteralldictatorship
meansoneman/womanrulingandourpresidentofIndiaisconsideredasthekingofthecountry.
Bysupportingforthetopic,fewmightsaythatifatalldictatorshipcomesintoexistencethenthedecisionstaken
forIndiawouldbeaccordingtothemindsetofonesinglepersonwhichisneverinacompromisingstand
consideringthebillionsofpeoplelivinginourcountry.Butdon'tyouthinkthatifatalladictatorischosenthenhe
wouldbetheonewhohasallqualitiesofagoodleaderincludingastablestateofmindrequiredtotakethemajor
decisions?
FinallyIwouldliketoconcludethattheconceptofdictatorshipshouldbeconsideredintheconstitutionandbring
uponsomechangesthat'sbetterforthedevelopmentofthepeopleandhencethecountry.
Ratethis:+14

Sagarsaid:(Fri,Jan18,201302:10:00PM)

Inmypointofviewweneedagoodleaderitmaybeagooddictator.Ifwethinkaboutourancientdaysweare
ruledbykingstheirwaslesscrimewashappenedinoursocietybecausewearefrightentokingssotheirless
crime.
Ratethis:+13

Rishabhsaid:(Fri,Dec21,201209:12:22PM)

Theimmediatesolutionisarevolutionwiththesupportofthepeopleandarmy.Byjustcriticizingthesordidstate
ofIndiawon'thelp.Parliamentshouldbedisbandedsinceinfightingamongpartiesjustslowsdowndecision
making.Thedictatorshouldpasslawswhicharestrictandforcethepolicetodotheirdutyforthewelfareofthe
state.Corruptpoliticiansandcriminalsshouldbesenttothefiringsquadifnecessary.Graduallyheshouldappoint
afewotherministersandreturntodemocracybutoneinwhichthepoliticiansaregenuinelyconcernedaboutthe
welfareofthenationandbehaverespectfullyandinadignifiedmannerinparliamentandnotresorttopersonal

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

15/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

arguments.
Ratethis:+18

Upendrasaid:(Wed,Oct31,201207:13:04PM)

OurIndiangovernmentshouldpassordersofmaintainingcleanintheirsurroundings&governmentsaidtoremove
blackcoversforcarsbutonthepolicevehicleitselfismaintainingtheblackcoversourgovernmentsystemmustbe
changed.
Ratethis:+10

12

JiteshNavlanisaid:(Sat,Oct27,201211:08:06PM)

Dictatorshipcanonlybelongtothecountrywhereinthecultureissame,peoplehaveonestateofmindand
peopleknowonelanguagetospeak.Indiaissuchadiversecountrywhereevery10kmthelanguagechanges
followedbythefood.So,IndiaitisnotpossiblethatcountryshouldneedadictatorshipratherIwillsaywecan
havealeaderwhohasavisionfortheIndiaandthepopulationofIndia.
Indiaisademocraticcountryandithastobedemocraticanythingwecandoisincreaseofeducationtoilliterate
peoplesoastoletthemknowthathowmuchpowereveryindividualcarriesinIndia.
Talkingaboutchinawherepeoplehaveoneculture,languageissameandevenpeoplehavesamestateofmind
theredictatorshipcanruninahighcontextwithhighinvolvement.
So,counteringtheargumentthatIndiagotindependencebeforechinabutstillnodictatorshipisinplacewhatI
believeisIndiaasacountryonlybythepeopleforthepeople!
Ratethis:+36

13

PoojaWantisaid:(Sat,Oct6,201205:53:42PM)

Hello,Iaminthefavourofdictatorship.Democracyisforthepeople,ofthepeopleandbythepeople.Butcurrent
situationhaschangedthisdefinitioninforthepoliticians,bythepoliticiansandbythepoliticians.Isaiditbecause
whentheelectionshappenthattimeallleadersbehavelikeagodforthepoorpeopleandtheinnocentand
illiteratepeoplebelievethemandgivetheirpreciousvotetothatcorruptleader.Thecurrentsituationourcountry
canimproveonlybythevisionary,strongandgooddictator.WeshouldlearnfromChinawhichisdeveloped
beforeIndiawhileChinagotindependentafterIndia.
Ratethis:+48

Ajaysaid:(Fri,Oct5,201208:09:11AM)

Inmyopinionneitherdictatorshipnorcurrentgovernancesystemwouldgodomuchbetter.Theonlythingwe
needisabloodrevolutioninthenameofourcountrysovereignty.Itcouldtakebloodofourbrothers,relatives
andmanymore,butitwoulddefinitelybebestforourgenerations.
Ratethis:+2

29

SubrahmanyamCsaid:(Mon,Sep3,201209:31:33PM)

Thereisnowaytosatisfyeveryoneinthiscountry.Democracybecameuseless.Whatthecountryneedavisionary
leader.Wedon'thaveproperdrainagesystems,healthcare,drinkingwaterfacilitiesandnoregardstopreserving
orincreasingagriculturallands,propertownplanning,populationcontrolandsoon.Nodoubttheyareinterlinked
anditisabigjigsawpuzzle.Ifitisyour'soryourson'sexamorprojecttopic,howdoyoudealwith.Forexample,
anidealtownneedpropertrafficcontrol,footpaths,drainagesystems,waterrecycling,agoodeveningwhere
familiescanspendoutside,communityspiritandsoon.
Wearenotshortofbrainpower.Ifabovearegivento10universitystudents,theywillcomewith1000waysof
doingthese.Weneedideas,Moneyandpeoplewhocanexecute.Todothis,avisionaryleaderwithclearplanis
needed.
Canwedothiswithdemocracy.Nowayasthepartywillhaveonly5yearsandonehastomakeunpopular
decisionstoraisemoneyandachieveabove.
Canadictatordoit.Yes,providedheorsheisavisionaryandhasclearplanwithENDINMIND.He/sheneedto
havegoodpeopletosupport/execute.Buthe/sheshouldbenononsensepersonandneedtowork24hoursa
dayfor365daysfornext10years.HowcancountrywithcurrentstateofaffairscancompetewithChinaorUSA
OrEuropeancountriesin10years.Itisatallorder.Oneneed25yearstoshow60%progressasourcountryis
vastanddiversified.
Ratethis:+35

AmitRaisaid:(Sat,Sep1,201210:26:49AM)

Iamtotallyagainstthisstatement.WhatIndianeedsisamotivatedcitizenry.Indemocracytheultimatepower
lieswithpeople.Peoplehavefailedtorealizeit.Allourproblemshaveoriginatedbecauseofourfailureto

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

16/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

understandthesystemandourinabilitytoprovideresistancetoillpracticesrampantinsocietyandcountryat
large.Insteadofcomplainingaboutthepoliticiansallthetimeweshouldfocusonownownwayofliving.
Democracyatleastmakespoliticiansresponsibletothecountry.Godknowswhatwillhappenifaccountabilityis
takenoutofequation?chaosperhaps.
Ratethis:+19

17

Sakshisaid:(Wed,Aug29,201211:20:38PM)

Ithinkchangeisthelawofnature.
Seeingpresentconditionofourcountry,wecan'tfeelsecureforourfuture.
Andifweseeonotherside,wearenotgettinganyfavourableresultfromourpresentgovernment.
Sowithan"UMMED"wecanacceptasystemofdictatorship.NotonlyadictatorbutaBENEVOLENTDICTATOR.
Forthedevelopmentofourcountry,Ithinkthischangeismust.
Ratethis:+10

Subhashsaid:(Sat,Aug18,201208:55:00AM)

DictatorshipwouldsolveallofIndia'sproblems.Howevergooddictatoristhekeyproblemhere.Ifwehadagood
dictator,onewhoisselfless,andcaresonlyforthewelfareofthepeople,likeaKing/Emperor,ourcountrywould
flourish.AgooddictatorwouldsolveallofIndia'sproblems,fromthebottomtothetopi.e.fromaddressingbasic
problemssuchasthepatheticdrainagesystemofIndiatorootingoutcorruptionandmodernisingthearmed
forces.OneoftheproblemswithIndiaistheeconomy.Welackarobusteconomicplan,alsoalthougheconomically
Indiaismakingsomeprogress,itistooslow.Australiahasapopulationof20milionpeoplewhilstIndiahasa
populaationof1.2billion,500timesover,andyetwehavesimilarfigureofGDP.Thegooddictatorwouldlookinto
suchproblems,andincreasetheGDPofIndia,tofundrevenuetoaddressinternalproblemssuchasthelackof
waterrelatedinfrasturctureasdescribedabove.
However,afterIndiahademergedasa"developed"nationandakeyinternationalplayer,thedictator,ifheis
trulyselfless,wouldgiveuphispositionofpower,andtransitionthenationtoonceagainbecomethelargest
democracyinthwworld.
Inconclusion,a"good"dictatorshipisneededinIndiatosolveitspettytolargeproblemsandcreateasuitable
"living"environmentforitscitizens.Thenafterallthisisachieved,thenIndiashouldbecomeademocracyagain,to
honourthosefreedomfighterswhohavefoughtforademocraticIndia,duringthepreindependaceera.Iknow
thatthissoundslikewishfullthinking,butisalegitimatereasonforadictatorship.
Justsoyouknow,iama16yearoldIndianNRIlivinginAustralia,andifatmyageandplace,Iamtakingkeen
interestinsuchissuesisbecausetheproblemsandcorruptionwhichplagueIndiaisunforgivable.
JaiHind,JaiBharat.
Ratethis:+67

VaibhavKumarsaid:(Fri,Aug17,201208:16:25PM)

Ithinkdictatorshipcan'tbegoodaseverypersonhavethereownpointofviews.Ifwehadadictatorshipwecan't
beabledowhatwethink.Ithinkweshouldtakepowerinourhandsandweshouldnotletthegovernmentdo
whattheywant.Wehavethepeoplespowerbuttheonlyneedisthatweshouldthinkaboutourownpowerand
usethatwell.
Nowaythatadictatorshipcanbegoodwewillloseallourrightsandpowers.
Ratethis:+8

Adityasaid:(Wed,Aug1,201210:45:08PM)

Dictatorshipisgoodaswellasbadjustastwosidesofacoin.Indictatorshippeoplearebarredofliberty,but
becauseofthisthegovernmentcanimplythelawswithoutanyopposition.Italsohelpsinbringingasenseof
discipline.Ifthedictatorisagoodmananycountrycanachievegloryjustasliketurkeywhichhadgoodfortuneof
rulingbyKemalPasha.EvenHitler'sdictatorshipshouldbetakenintoaccountthatdespitehiscrueltyagainstthe
Jews,herecoveredGermanyfromaterribleposition.However,forexcellenceofdictatorshipthedictatormustbe
keptunderthescannerbyacommitteeofhonestministers.AcorruptdemocracysuchasIndia,reallyneeds
disciplinewhichcanonlybeattainedbyapowerful,honestandvirtuousdictator.
Ratethis:+30

Mitalisaid:(Sat,Jun30,201206:34:57PM)

Democracyisbetterasyouareallowedtodowhateveryouwanttodoforthewelfarebutdictatorshipisaforce
accordingtowhichacitizenhashavetoact.SoIpersonallybelievethatdemocracyisfarbetterthandictatorship.
Ratethis:+5

19

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

17/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

ShilpaYadavsaid:(Sun,May20,201204:05:12PM)

Everysituationhasitsprosandcons.ButIstronglyfeelthatgivingallthepowerstoasinglepersonwillonly
worsenthesituationbecauseeverypersonhashis/herdifferentviews.Accordingtomeweallshouldtrytoelect
thebestpersonwhilevoting.No,oneisgoodenoughbutbadismuchbetterthantheworst.Andonly
governmentisnotresponsiblewetooareresponsibleforthissituation.Publicpoweristhepowerwhichis
capabletodoeverything.Wemustrealizeourpowerandshoulddefinitelyvotetosaveourcountryandtomake
ourcountryadevelopedcountry.DREAMWHICHWILLDEFINITELYCOMETRUE.
Ratethis:+26

Atgsaid:(Sat,Apr28,201206:18:41PM)

Governmentalwaystrytoprotectcorruptpeoplelikekalmadi,Araja,kanimoiandmanyothers.Theyareallfrom
congress.Socongressdidnottookanyaction.Theyalwaystrytoincreasetheirbankbalances.Theydonothave
careofpublic.Whotrytoraisehisvoiceagainstthiscorruptsystemgovenmentcrushthem.Thisisenough.We
havetotakeaction.SUPPORTME.
Ratethis:+33

19

Atgsaid:(Wed,Apr25,201211:33:37AM)

Duetocorruptdemocracytherewasnocareofourtalentedpeopleandtheywillgotnojob.Butamericagave
themjobopportunitiesduetotheirtalent.Soamerica'sdevelopmentisfastandIndia'sslow.
Ratethis:+11

19

ZeeshanDanishsaid:(Tue,Apr24,201211:20:33AM)

TakingpresentpoliticsofIndiaintoconsideration,itseemsdemocracyistheworstformofgovernment.In
democracy,poweriscenteredinthehandsofvariousministerselectedbypeople.Amongtheseministers,only
fewofthemaregoodandmajorityisbad.Thesebadpoliticiansnotonlyspoilthecareerofgoodonesbutalsothe
careeroftalentedyouthofcountry.Theyonlyfetchbenefitsanddoesnottakecaretowardsthedevelopmentand
welfareoftheircountry.Soweshouldelectasinglepersontoruleourcountry.Butthissingleperson(dictator)
shouldpossesseachandeveryqualitythatatruepoliticiansshouldhave.Allpowersshouldbegiventohim.He
willutilizethesepowersinaproperwayandwilltakegoodstepsforthebettermentofpeople.
Ratethis:+28

Atgsaid:(Fri,Apr20,201207:46:44AM)

NowadaysIndiadefinitelyneedsdictatorship.Iagreethatdictatorshipisnotgoodasdemocracy.Butsome
politiciansspoilthemeaningofdemocracy.Theyaremakingsituationofourcountryworst.Nowadaysifyousee
politicsyoufoundthatmanypoliticianshavecriminalrecordslikemurders,corruptionsandmuchmore.Canyou
imagineiftheyrulewhatissituationofourcountryinfuture.Theywillsellourcountrytoforeignersformoney.
Somepoliticiansaregoodbutbadmany.Sotomakeourcountrynotjustpowerfulbutalsocrimefreeand
corruptionfreeweneedsdictatorshipassoonaspossible.
Ratethis:+11

Atgsaid:(Wed,Apr18,201209:42:56PM)

Indiaisarichandpowerfulcountry.Butitswealthiscollectedinformofblackmoney.Somepeopleandcorrupt
politiciansspoiledourcountry.Indiahaslotsofpreciousmineralsbuttheysoldthemcheaply.SoIndiahaveto
faceeconomicproblems.IfIndiagetsitsblackmoneybackitbecamepowerfulfivetimesamerica.Iwantto
becamedictatorofIndiaanddoitso.IwanttomakeIndia'THESUPREMEPOWER'.Supportme.
Ratethis:+26

Yashsaid:(Thu,Apr12,201210:48:32PM)

Yes!!!!!!Ournation'sforeignpolicyisveryweak.Thecommonoutputofforeigncountriesis"India,fullupof
corruption,crime,misusesofhumanrights".Thismainthingsareobstaclebetweennation'sforwardpolicy.Our
greatenemiespakistanandchinashouldnotbegreaterthanusinmanyfields.Democracyisimaginarypolitical
systemwhichapplyonlyin'truthworld',whichisfreefromcorruption,untruthandsinlesssituations.Soallpeople
arenotgreatthinker.andalsocallthat,"humanneverfindlastandfirsttruth.
Ratethis:+16

Vigneshwarsaid:(Tue,Apr10,201207:23:39PM)

Inpointofview,dictatorshipisbestbecauseoncepeoplewillcomeunderthepowerofthepoliticianwhoputthe
rulesintherulesinaverystrictway,peoplewillnotcrossthewaywithoutorders,anditwillleadthecountryto
develop.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

18/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

Butthereisalsoanegativeinthatrulewhatismeantthatthepoliticianwillnotconsiderwhatthepeopleare
expectingbecausehemadetheseparateforthedevelopmentofcountry.
Ratethis:+8

AnuradhaOinamsaid:(Tue,Mar13,201211:53:09PM)

EveryoneknowsIndiabeingadevelopingcountryneedsalotofreformsinthefieldlikeremovalofcorruption,able
toreachthenecessaryrequirementtotheneedy,musthaveaneyeongrassrootspeople,profarmerasIndian
economyisbasedonagriculture...etc,sobyseeingallthesethingswhatiwanttosayisthatanytypeof
govt.eitherunderdictatorshipordemocraticgovt...,itwillbealrightifeverythingisdonehonestlyforthewelfareof
peopleandforthewelfareofthecountry..becauseanyofthistwoformisnothingbuttheyarehereforthe
people..andalso,theonlywishofthepeopleistohaveapeaceful,selflesscountrywhatwecalled'ramrajya'
earlier..
Ratethis:+9

SarveshKasatsaid:(Fri,Mar2,201207:08:56PM)

Ihaveafacttospeakthattheperiodfromwhichamericafaceddevelopmentwasfrom1775to1900....thusittook
almost125yearsbuthitlermadeitpossibleinmerely20yrsaftertheworldwar1wherethesituationwas
terrible...apainterwhowasdamnpassionateabouthiscountryroseagainstallandthusmadethedevelopment
possible...weshouldconsideratleastthispositivepointwhichindianeedsatpresentstage...sotoprecisethings,
indianeedsapowerfulandpassionateleader(dictator).....!!!!
Ratethis:+16

ShaliniRawatsaid:(Sat,Feb25,201212:36:14PM)

Well,Idon'tthinkthatdemocraticsystemhastobeblamedforthecurrentsituationinourcountry.Itisthesheer
faultofourcorruptpoliticianswhohavecreatedamessinthecountry,bymisusingpublicfundsandthereby
tarnishingtheimageofourcountryworldwide.Sayingthatonlyagooddictatorwillbethesolutiontoour
problemsisabigmistakeaswehavealreadyseeninthemiddleeastwherepeoplecameontothestreetsand
askedtheirdictatortostepdownandexpressedtheirdesiretohavedemocracyintheirrespectivecountries.
Givingtoomuchpowertoasinglepersonwillonlyaggravateourissues.Weshoulddefinitelynotforgetthat
"democracyisforthepeople,ofthepeopleandbythepeople"andthereforeifpeopledonothavesayinthe
politicalsystemofacountry,theyareboundtoretaliate,ifnotnowbutdefinitelyinfuture.
Ratethis:+27

Himanisaid:(Sun,Feb19,201209:48:58AM)

WeallweretaughtthatDictatorshipisbadanddemocracyisgood,selfgovernmentisgood.But,wecannotsay
thatselfgovernmentisasubstituteforagoodgovernment.
IndiaisanationwheretherearestarvationdeathshappeninginroutineintheGanjamDistrictofOrissa.Andon
theotherhand,everyyeartherearegrainsworthcroresbeingrottenoreatenbyrats.
whycan'tthesegrainsbegiventothosepoorpeoplewhodieeverydaybecauseofstarvation?
whomshouldweblamethisfor?
Thepersonwhostandsbetweennotmakingthingshappeningisapolitician.
Corruptionstartsfromapoliticiananditstartsfromtheheadofhispowertothetail.
Hence,inawayINDIADEMANDSABENEVOLENTLEADER,NOTADICTATOR!
Aleaderwhobelievesinmakingthingsright&fair.
Development,foreignpolicies,traderelations,education,corruptionfreenationshouldbethecommitmenthe
shouldworktowards.
Educatedelectoratesrulingthecountrywithcasespendingagainstthemthisissimplyanunfairelectorateat
power.
Wehaveseenthecolorsofdemocracy&thewhimsandfanciesofthepoliticalleaderswhocomeatpower.Now,
weallneedtoseethechange&letsnottakeexamplesfromthepastinstatingthatdictatorsarebad.
Dictatorshipisnotallaboutaslaveandruleragreement,withchangingtime,weallhaveseentheyouthofthe
countrystandingfortherights.Hencechoosingaleadernotadictatorwouldbeagoodsolution.
Hence,Igoforabenevolentleader!!!
Ratethis:+21

NileshPatilsaid:(Mon,Feb13,201201:28:13AM)

Hi,Iveryworriedaboutourconuntry,becuaseofpoliticianourMiddleclasspeoplesgetburdnedandextreme
pressurizedduetothismarketHighandotherproductsvalues..Ineedtodosomethingforourcountrytobetter
growthofIndia,butnotabletofindoutthewaytoproceedfurther!!!
Ratethis:+4

SathishKumarsaid:(Wed,Feb1,201210:17:23AM)

Ithinkweneedpride.noneedofanything.Ifwecreateprideandremovethecaste,alltheproblemswill

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

19/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

automaticallygobyitself.
Britishpeoplecameinsideandtheyintroducedsomethingcalleddivideandrule.
Sonowweneedapridefromallindiancitizen.Thenyouwillseeprogressingindia.
Ratethis:+6

Rakeshsaid:(Fri,Jan20,201201:47:32AM)

WeknowthatnowdaysIndianpoliticsisnotgoodmostofpoliticiansarecurruptedbutweshouldknowthat
democracyis"forthepeople,bythepeople,ofthepeople".Thisisaneedthateveryonebehavelikeadictator
andabondedourguilty.
Ratethis:+4

Mukeshsaid:(Thu,Jan19,201208:54:42PM)

IwillnotsaymuchbutIwanttodragyourattentiontowardschina.Chinaisalsoabigcountryandmore
populationthanIndiabuttheydoingwellinallfeildsandalsochallengingthemostpwerfulcountryinworld(usa).
Theresonistheirgovernmentwhichfollowingdictatorshipbeautifully.Andchinaisgrowingdaybydayasweall
knowthetruth.
Ratethis:+5

Sudeepsaid:(Sat,Dec3,201104:02:30PM)

WhatIndianeedisagoodandhonestleader,weatheradictatororademocraticallyelectedone.TheLeader,
whocanleadIndiansandguidethemtosuccess,.Todaywehavelostfaitheveninourelectedleadersanddoubt
andquestiontheirdecisions.Arealleadercanunderstandtheneedofthemassesandthecountry.Hecan
mobilizesupportfromeverypersoneventhoughthedecisionispainfulforsomeofthembutgoodforthecountry
asawhole.BesidesthisthepeopleofIndiamustunderstandthebenefitsofdisciplineandeducation.Onecan
seethedifferencebetweenthestudentsofadisciplinedschoolandrougeschool.
Ratethis:+11

Dhineshsaid:(Wed,Nov30,201101:19:33PM)

IthinkweneedaresponsibleandapowerfulDictator.Becuaseonthedemocraticeventheleaderisgood(Nehru,
KamarajEtc)butthecorruptionisnotcleared.Butifweareunderagoodresponsibleandapowerfulleaderthen
thecorruptionwillbegone.Becauseonthedictatorsideifanyofpersonsaredoneanyilleagalworkthenthe
actionwillbetakenbyimmedietly,butindemoratictheywon'ttakeanyofactions(egPoliticians).Soweneeda
powerfulandresponsibleDICTATOR.
Ratethis:+18

ManojManralsaid:(Fri,Nov18,201103:31:34PM)

Ithinkweneedasoundbodyofgovernmentwhichprimarilyconcernindia,secondarythepublicandthenother
factors..Tochangeonlygovernmentformcan'tbeagoodsolution.Weneedtohavesomechangesinour
traditionalwaytoworkthenwedefinatelygotsuccessbecauseindiahavelotofcreativepeoplewhoshowstheir
talentoutsideindia.
Ratethis:+5

SimranJoshisaid:(Mon,Nov14,201104:12:06PM)

Accordingtomesurelyweneedtocontinuewithdemocracy.Theonlythingisweneedtoeradicatecorruption
fromourcountry.Dictatorshipcanworsentheconditionofourcountryasthenwewouldhavenorighttoexpress
ouropinions.

Ratethis:+13

PabitraMangarajsaid:(Thu,Oct20,201103:21:56PM)

ItotalyagreewithabhisekwewanttoseeagoldencitytoourIndianIndiahaslotsofcapabilitytochangethe
citybuttheproblemisourpolticianwhototalyendtothiscountrynotdirectlybutindirectly,weallknewinour
countrymanymanycroresofmoneyispresentbyblackmoneybutnobodywantstoseewhycauseofour
selfishnessweonlythinkaboutussohowIndiawillchangewithoutyourhelp.Soinmyopeniondictorshipmust
beneededtochangeourcountry.
Ratethis:+15

Bharatsaid:(Thu,Sep29,201107:39:44PM)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

20/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

Well,democracyisthebetterwayofrunningcountrywithchangesandnotfolloweddepressofanythingbecause
thereisamanymoreoptiontosolveproblem.Dictatorshipmeansonethathaspowertomakepossiblething,
thereisnobodytosayingitiswrongwithambitious.Indiapopulationissobigsoweneedtofacilaiteofindividual.
Whywearegoingfordictarship,onlyformakingthingpossiblelikecorruptiongrowththatcomesfromchangingof
timesoweneedtomodifyourconstitution,rules,policies,betterlivingpolices.Weshouldallegeofwhatismatter
accordingtothistakingdecision.Whywearegoingforunusualthing.
Ratethis:+5

Youtubhasaid:(Sat,Sep17,201104:06:27PM)

Idon'tthinkthatdictatorshipwouldhelp.Inmyopinionitcanmakesituationofourcountryevenworse.Alsowe
mustnotforgetthedreamofMahatmaGandhijiwhowantedIndiatobeademocraticcountrynotacountry
havingdictatorship.
Thusinmyopiniondemocracyisthebestformofgovernmentwhichwillhelpinmakingourcountryadeveloped
country.
Ratethis:+14

14

SpeakYourMind:

...

Pleasedonotusechatterms.Example:avoidusing"grt"insteadof"great".

Submit

Relatedtopics:
Marriageisasocialtrap
Examinationshasitkillededucation
CanOneContributetotheSocialSectorwhileBeingEmployedintheCorporateWorld?
GovernmentPumpingMoneyintotheEconomyisnottheSolutionforourEconomicProblems
AreCricketerstobeblamedforMatchFixing?

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

21/22

1/21/2015

WhatIndianeedsisaDictatorship?GroupDiscussion

20082014byIndiaBIX T echnologies.AllRightsReserved|Copyright|T ermsofUse&PrivacyPolicy

Contactus:info@indiabix.com
Bookmarkto:

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/whatindianeedsisadictatorship/

Followusontwitte r!

22/22