Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The following report is an analysis and action plan conducted on the position called the
Highland Street AmeriCorps Ambassador of Mentoring at Big Brothers Big Sisters of Central
Mass/Metrowest. The purpose of this assignment is to provide a demonstration of competence in
the staffing, assessment, and law of human resources. This report will provide the viewer with a
sourcing plan for the position. Throughout this report, you will see evidence of competence in
these subject matters.
Big Brothers Big Sisters of Central Mass/Metrowest, also known as BBBSCM, has been
an active affiliate of Big Brothers Big Sisters Foundation since 1963 (Our Mission and History).
Their mission is to provide children facing adversity with strong and enduring, professionally
supported one-to-one relationships that change their lives for the better, forever (Our Mission
and History). The agency is comprised of approximately 25 full-time and part-time employees
with hundreds of volunteers. These volunteers act as mentors for youth that are facing adversity
in some manner. This type of volunteerism builds a strong connection and is responsible for
changing lives.
BBBSCM is a 501(c) 3 non-profit foundation located in Worcester and Framingham,
Massachusetts. The agency has minimal competition since it is a nonprofit working to help
youth. There are, however, several organizations in the area working for the same goal.
BBBSCM is still a business and competes to have the highest number of successful matches,
mentor pairs, in their service area. The local competition includes, but is not limited to: Girls,
Inc., LUK Mentoring Program, and the Mazie Mentoring Program.
Since BBBSCM is a non-profit agency, it relies on donations and grants for funding.
During FY 15 the agency had approximately $895,000 in assets, $267,000 in property and
equipment, and a total liabilities and net assets of approximately $1,100,000 (2015 Financial
Statement). The agency received approximately $1,350,000 in public support and $185,000 in
revenue (2015 Financial Statement). 69% of funding went directly towards programming for
mentors and mentees, 17% went towards the administration which includes payroll, and 14%
was allocated to fund raising efforts (2015 Financial Statement).
The specific position that was analyzed is called the Highland Street AmeriCorps
Ambassador of Mentoring. This position is a run in partnership with the Highland Street
AmeriCorps agency. An employee holding this position agrees to work with the agency for one
year as a stipend/volunteer employee. Turnover is very unlikely before the end of the contractual
term of one fiscal year. According to the Director of Operations, turnover is less than one percent
in this specific position.
The current Highland Street AmeriCorps Ambassador of Mentoring is Stephanie Cartiero.
Stephanie has been working with the agency since mid-February. Her supervisor is the Director
of Operations, Hawley Harrigan. The Ambassador of Mentoring, also known as the AOM,
position is key to the agencies success in completing their mission. The AOM is tasked with
creating clear communication strategies, performing match support, and attending training
seminars to create new programs and implement them within the agency to assist them in
achieving their mission.
The job analysis interview was completed on Tuesday, February 23rd, 2016 at BBBSCMs
Worcester office. Three analysts were met by Stephanie Cartiero, current AOM, and were guided
to a small conference with a round table. The interview was casual and lasted for approximately
thirty minutes. During the interview, Stephanie was asked about her job duties and tasks. Given
that Stephanie is a fairly new employee, the team struggled to receive concise information from
her regarding her duties and tasks. After her interview, the team interviewed her supervisor,
Hawley Harrigan. Hawley was able to provide the analysts with more accurate information that
pertained to the AOMs job duties.
Overall, the interview was a success after the Director of Operations provided the team
with a more precise picture. For example, Stephanie had informed us that she was responsible for
creating a social media plan. Hawley informed us that was not as accurate as it could be and gave
us a more defined description of that specific task. Stephanie also forgot to mention that she is
expected to attend Highland Street Ambassador trainings and meetings on a monthly basis. After
meeting with Hawley, the team was presented with enough information to complete an accurate
report.
A job rewards matrix is a visualization of benefits an employee in a specific position
receives. These can be intrinsic rewards like improved self-esteem or personal growth and
extrinsic rewards like benefits and salary increases. In this company, the job rewards matrix
focuses more on intrinsic rewards since BBBSCM is a non-profit and does not necessarily have
the funds to provide extrinsic rewards. BBBSCM looks to hire altruistic people who are looking
to be engaged in a philanthropic effort and are not looking for monetary rewards for their hard
work.
Below you will find the job analysis report, task statements, KSAOs and how they link to
the job duties, job duty and task groupings, critical incident statements, weighed job duties, job
requirements matrix and a job rewards matrix.
Director of Operations_____
Provide an example of a decision related to this duty that would be referred to your
supervisor.
Mentors becoming too attached to their mentee; matches that are not good for each
other.
Maximum weight you must lift, push, or pull: 10 pounds Frequency: Twice per month
None
Other experience you had at the time you started to work in this position including experience
gained in other organizations:
Experience in the same or very similar job: 3 Years
Job related experience: 2 Years
Supervisory Experience: 2 Years
Managerial Experience: 2 Years
Licenses/Certifications: None
Current Position:
How many employees report to you directly? Zero.
____2/22/16___
Date
Supervisor Interview
Review of Job Holder Interview:
Job Duty 1: Program Support
Comments:
Critical Incident example of good work performance: (Not necessarily the current job
holder/may be hypothetical if there has been only one position holder and no incident that would
be exemplary of the specified performance level)
Situation: Match Support
What the employee did: Found a training to use towards improving matching
Results of the behavior: More successful matches in the agency
Critical incident example of poor performance: (Not necessarily the current job
holder/may be hypothetical if there has been only one position holder and no incident that would
be exemplary of the specified performance level)
Situation: Matching
What the employee did: The employee failed to provide proper match support by
failing to pay attention to the pairs needs
Results of the behavior: The pair was unmatched and the child had psychological
issues.
Job Duty 2: Social Media
Comments:
Creating newsletters
Updating blog and social media
Creating a social media plan
Critical Incident example of good work performance: (Not necessarily the current job
holder/may be hypothetical if there has been only one position holder and no incident that would
be exemplary of the specified performance level)
Situation: New and Improved Blog
What the employee did: Moved the blog to a better, more user friendly platform and
started posting on a regular basis
Results of the behavior: Site traffic and user interactivity improved, along with online
donations
Critical incident example of poor performance: (Not necessarily the current job
holder/may be hypothetical if there has been only one position holder and no incident that would
be exemplary of the specified performance level)
Situation: Bad Blogging
What the employee did: The employee was not confident in their ability to post and
stopped creating content
Results of the behavior: Site traffic declined, along with major donors pulling their
funding
Job Duty 3: AmeriCorps
Comments:
Continuous training
Service learning
Planning and executing meetings
Community service work with other AmeriCorps volunteers on a weekend by weekend
basis
None provided
*Note: This form was originally completed by hand and was transferred to a word processor for
ease of review.
Task Statements:
What?
To Whom/What?
How?
Why?
Assist
Matches and
support specialists
Develop
To enhance the
publics knowledge of
the agency.
Enhance
To portray an
accurate up-to-date
message of the
agency.
Attend
AmeriCorps
Training
Monthly in Boston
To enhance
knowledge of service,
learning, planning,
and executing in a
non-profit.
KSAOs:
Knowledge:
Bachelors degree in social work
Previous leadership experience preferred
Experience with blogging platforms
Skills:
Interpersonal
Communication/Technology
Public Speaking
Organizational development
Ability:
Other:
Passion for working with and helping others in the non-profit sector
Some travel may be required
Multi-lingual a plus
Job Duty
Importance (1-5)
4- Very high
Relative Time
Spent (8 hr day)
5 hours
high
2 hours
low
1 hour
Results: An important donor withdrew their funding because the required information
was not posted by the deadline
2.
What the employee did: The employee was consistent with her blog posting and created a
monthly update posted under the News section.
Results: Higher web traffic was received and donations were more consistent
3.
What the employee did: The employee failed to properly supervise his/her match. The
mentor stopped meeting with his/her mentee.
Results: The match had to be separated which caused the child sadness and isolation. The
volunteer was removed from the program and the child is on the waiting list for a new mentor.
4.
What the employee did: The employee consistently met with his/her mentor and mentee
pair and resolved any issues.
Results: The pair has been successful for ten years and continues to be the strongest
match in the agency to date.
5.
What the employee did: The employee attended an AmeriCorps training on building
connections between mentors and their mentees and brought the program back to the agency in
Worcester.
Results: Our match support team has had higher numbers of successful matches in the
last several months because of this training.
Job Duty
Program and
Match
Support
Tasks
Social Media
Planning
Agency
Development
Importance
Time
Spent
Provide
program
support
Assist in
interviews
Perform
backgroun
d checks
Oversee
matches
50%
60%
Create
social
media
action
plan
Increase
public
awareness
35%
Attend
training
sessions
Enhance
agency
teams
skills and
abilities
Engage
15%
KSAO
35%
5%
Importan
ce of
KSAO
(1= Low
10= High)
(E=
Essential)
Interpersonal
Skills
Supervisory
Experience
Ability to
travel
9E
Knowledge of
social media
platforms
Writing skills
Microsoft
Office
Leadership
Training
experience
10E
staff
members
Reward
Amount
Differential
Stability
Who does it
appeal to?
Salary
$12,000/year
average
Changes based
on performance
and
achievements
People looking
to give back,
and not just
seeking a
paycheck
Gratitude
Unlimited
N/A
Depending on
performance
An altruistic
employee
Benefits
Medical, dental,
cell phone
stipend, parking
reimbursements
NONE
Highly stable;
rarely changes
Most employees
Selfguidance/minima
l supervision
Above average
Depending on
reliability
As long as the
employee
continues to
exceed
standards
I believe that I was able to obtain enough information during my interviews and job
analysis to prepare a job description that adequately represents the position available. If I were to
change anything about the process, I would ensure that the employee was not a subcontractor
type. I would also ensure that the employee had spent at least one year with the company. This
would have provided more concrete information to build the report and job description on.
The agency is seeking a person that is more of an altruist and is motivated by their
passion for helping others. The Ambassador of Mentoring works in partnership with AmeriCorps
and will work with Big Brothers Big Sisters for a service period of one year. The person in this
position will work with the Director of Operations to improve the current processes that exist
within the agency to make them more effective and efficient. The AOM will also work as a
Match Support Specialist to help create new successful mentor pairs. The AOM will attend
monthly AmeriCorps trainings and share the information learned to create programs that assist in
the growth of BBBSCM employees within the agency. (See next page.)
Approvals/Authorizations:
___________________________
_______________________________
Tyler Hussey, Preparer
Hawley Harrigan, Supervisor
__________________________
Jeffrey Chin, Department Head
Sourcing Plan:
Big Brothers Big Sisters of Central Massachusetts/Metrowest seeks an altruistic
individual that has a passion for helping others grow. The individual in this position will work
with both BBBSCM and AmeriCorps to complete this task. The most desirable employee will be
able to work in a diverse office with the ability to achieve creative solutions to problems. The
candidate will be able to work in an office environment and travel in the Worcester, MA area
with or without reasonable accommodations. The ideal candidate would be multilingual, have a
Bachelors degree in social work, have previous leadership experience, and have experience with
blogging platforms.
To source for this job, I would utilize several networks to reach the largest number of
qualified applicants. I would post this position on: Indeed.com, MassNonProfitNet.org,
Idealist.org, and the company website. The two organization websites are specifically targeted to
non-profit agencies and people that are interested in working with them. I would promote the
advertisement using our social media platforms which include: Twitter, Instagram, LinkedIn, and
Facebook. Along with web postings, I would post this position in the Worcester Telegram and
utilize employee referrals. The Telegram reaches a broad audience of people and would appeal to
candidates from diverse backgrounds. The current talent at the agency would also provide this
advantage for a similar reason. I would also advertise this position with local colleges, like Clark
University. This is the perfect position for a new college graduate that is looking to enter the non-
profit sector. The agency has had several Clark University graduates that have completed the
year of service successfully and have moved up in the company. The position is also managed by
the AmeriCorps, so they are partially responsible for pooling candidates. I would be in contact
with their job placement specialist to see which of their qualified talent would be interested in the
position.
In order to comply with EEO and per the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the posting will not
include language that deters people of any protected class from applying for the position. The
advertisement will also avoid terminology that could lead to deterring qualified candidates that
are protected by the Age Discrimination Employment Act of 1967. The agency personally
supports employees of all ages and currently has employees from ages eighteen to seventy. The
building the organization is located in is wheelchair accessible and the specific office is on one
floor with no stairs. Any reasonable accommodations would be made to comply with the
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. All employee wages are calculated based upon their
previous work history and experience in the industry. Gender plays absolutely no role in the
hiring or wage decision.
Assessment Plan:
This position is unique to staff. In order to evaluate external candidates I will utilize
standard structured/semi-structured interviews with multiple current employees, behavioral
interviewing/group interviews, and work samples. The structured interviewing will ensure that
each interviewer is following the same set of standards, but allows some freedom for
customization. The questions in the structured interview will be behavioral based and allow for
candidates to provide answers with examples of previous work and experience. A group
interviewing day would be set up so the candidate is being analyzed by several employees at
once. This allows for each interviewer to examine and interpret what they see and compare with
the others. The candidate would be given a task to work with current employees to solve a
problem creatively. This would allow the interviewers to assess the candidates fit within the
culture and their skills to analyze and provide solutions.
These assessment methods will allow the agency to assess each candidate in the same
way and to select the proper candidate based on their qualifications. Ensuring that each candidate
is asked the same questions will allow equal assessment. The behavioral/group process will
allow the interviewers to analyze how the candidate interacts with the team that they would be
working with. This will help the team decide if the person is a good cultural fit and if they have
the skills that will be hired versus trained into a candidate. The work sample will allow the
interviewers to determine how well the candidate can create social media, which is a very
important task for this position.
The initial interview will be a phone screening. This complies with the EEO because the
candidate is not seen. The interviewer is not able to make any decisions based upon protected
classes which are stated in the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The agency is also very supportive of
people from diverse backgrounds since they serve a wide variety of clients. Creating a structured
interview will allow each candidate to be given the same opportunity to present information.
Questions will be based upon job qualifications and answers will be carefully recorded. The
interviewers will not ask any questions that are related to any sort of disability, race, national
origin, age, religion, military status, gender, marital status, family status, physical attributes, or
sexual orientation. With the stated methods in place, BBBSCM will comply with all EEO laws
and regulations.
Application form
Interview questions
Form for recording responses to questions
Form for recording results of all assessment measure for a candidate (scoring key)
APPLICANT INFORMATION
Last
Name
Street
Address
Dat
e
Apartment/U
nit #
First
Stat
e
E-mail
Address
City
Phon
e
Date
Available
Position
Applied for
Are you a citizen of the United
States?
Have you ever worked for this
company?
Have you ever been convicted
of a felony?
M.I.
ZIP
Social
Security No.
YES
NO
YES
NO
YES
NO
Desired
Salary
YES
NO
EDUCATION
High
School
From
Addre
ss
To
Did you
graduate?
Colle
ge
From
NO
Degree
NO
Degree
NO
Degree
Addre
ss
To
Did you
graduate?
YES
Addre
ss
Other
From
YES
To
Did you
graduate?
YES
PREVIOUS EMPLOYMENT
Compan
y
Phone
Address
Supervis
or
Starting
Salary
Job Title
Ending
Salary
Ending
Salary
Responsibiliti
es
Reason for
Leaving
May we contact your previous supervisor for a
reference?
Compan
y
From
To
YES
Phone
Supervis
or
Address
Job Title
Responsibiliti
es
NO
Starting
Salary
Reason for
Leaving
May we contact your previous supervisor for a
reference?
Compan
y
From
To
YES
NO
Phone
Supervis
or
Address
Starting
Salary
Job Title
Ending
Salary
Responsibiliti
es
Reason for
Leaving
May we contact your previous supervisor for a
reference?
From
To
YES
NO
Interview Questions:
Date
1. Could you tell me a little bit about your previous work experience and
background in the nonprofit industry?
2. What do you consider to be your greatest strength?
3. What personal weakness has caused you the most difficulty in your previous work
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
experience?
If you could improve one thing about your current job, what would it be?
Tell me about an obstacle you have had to overcome.
What is your greatest weakness?
How would you describe your leadership skills?
What personal quality do you believe will most contribute to your career success?
Thinking about your previous work experience, what job responsibility have you
Recording Responses
Candidate
_______________
Name:
___________________________
Date
of
Interview:
8. What personal quality do you believe will most contribute to your career success?
__________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
9. Thinking about your previous work experience, what job responsibility have you
found must unpleasant and why?
__________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
Additional Comments:
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
Scoring Keys:
1 = Low Competent
Key Competency:
Interpersonal
Communication
Working with others
Technology
Work Samples
4 = Highly Competent
1
basic
Personable
Management experience
Additional Comments:
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
Would you recommend moving this candidate forward? (1, 3, 5) ______________
1: Do Not Recommend
5: Highly Recommend
Date:
Socialization Plan:
Big Brother Big Sister is a small, close-knit, agency where all employees know one
another. It is important to properly socialize the newly selected employee to welcome them to the
culture. Big Brother Big Sister is considered not just a workplace, but a family. All fifty
employees know each other and every accomplishment, birthday, and job well-done is celebrated
by the entire team.
When the employee enters the Worcester office for the first day, they will be greeted by a
welcome party with the entire team. The CEO, VP of Programs, Director of Operations, and VP
of Development are the executives that will be present. After the celebration and a welcome
breakfast, the new employee will watch a brief, ten minute video on the history of the agency to
develop a better understanding of the BBBSCM culture and purpose. In the video, the new hire
will notice the family-like bond that the employees have. After completing the video, the new
hire will be brought into the CEOs office and join the rest of the executive leadership team.
The employee will be further introduced to the company and each executive member will
introduce themselves by their first name, and give a brief description of their position. The
Director of Operations will then hand the employee their welcome kit. The welcome kit is a box,
wrapped like a gift. Inside the new employee will find company apparel, a BBBSCM coffee cup
and pen, a binder with policies/procedures and FAQ, a parking pass, and a $25.00 Amazon gift
card. The employee will then move the office of the Director of Operations. The Director of
Operations is the direct supervisor for the AOM and will be able to provide any necessary help
during the process. The new employee will begin to read the policies and procedures and break
for lunch. Lunch at BBBSCM is like a family gathering. All of the employees will stop at the
same time, move to the kitchen/break area and eat lunch together. During the lunch session, the
new employee will participate in ice breakers and learn more about their new coworkers.
For the next several days, the employee will continue to read the handbook and converse
with the office employees. This will allow them to understand the agency and gauge the culture.
Once the employee has finished reading the policies, they will move to shadowing a Match
Support Specialist. The MSS will work with the AOM to introduce them to the position of match
creation. After two weeks of interactive observation, the AOM will be assigned their first case
and will be ready to work on their own. The Director of Operations will give a three month and
six month formal review, but is always available for feedback.
This individual socialization plan focuses specifically on the newly hired individual and
can easily be adjusted to the individuals specific needs. The welcome party and history video
introduce the employee to the culture at the company. Having the executives and office
employees there on the first day makes them feel included and welcomed. Inviting them to the
family lunch and having them shadow gives them a chance to ask questions and become
accustomed to the inner workings of the agency.
Socialization Schedule:
Time:
8:30
10:00
10:00
11:00
11:00
12:00
Monday
Welcome
Tuesday
Staff Meeting
Wednesday
Staff Meeting
Thursday
Staff Meeting
Friday
DAY OFF
Meeting with
Meeting with
MSS
MSS
DAY OFF
executive
different
Observations
Observations
team
Policy review
MSSs
Skype Call
MSS
MSS
with Director
with
Observations
Observations
Party
DAY OFF
of Operations
Framingham
12:00
Lunch Break
Office
Lunch Break
Lunch Break
Lunch Break
DAY OFF
2:00
2:00 3:00
Company
Policy review
MSS
Assigned First
DAY OFF
Info Video
with Director
Observations
Case
and FAQ
Meeting with
of Operations
Policy
MSS
First Case
CEO to
Examination
Observations
Review with
discuss first
and BBBS
day
Certificate
3:00 4:30
MSS Mentor
Works Cited
2015 Financial Statement. n.d. <http://bbbscm.org/financial-information>.
Our Mission and History. n.d. <http://bbbscm.org/mission>.
DAY OFF