Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 2
Introduction
There are significant and influential musical performance ractices
occurring throughout Australia on the periphery. I use the term
periphery to describe practices that are outside of mainstream
Australian popular music culture. I use the term significant to
indicate that these practices are important in discussions surrounding
contemporary music within, white Australian culture. This paper will
attempt to discuss ways in which an Influential performer musician can
exert influence on the practices of the wider subculture that surrounds
them and beyond that, the broader culture with which they identify
with.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 3
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 4
iv
Gregs musical practice and the musical community that surrounds him
represent one of many musical subcultures that co-exist in Australia.
The question that I address within this paper is whether Gregs practice
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 5
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 6
Greg sees himself as a self-taught drummer and has learnt mainly from
playing along to his favourite records. Jazz drummers such as Elvin
Jones Tony Williams Billy Cobham and Harvey Mason were among his
major influences. Gregs other main musical influences are Folk
Drumming Traditions especially the musics of Ireland, India, Polynesia
and Africa.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 7
on the dining table with his cutlery. As a drummer in the school band,
he had a rudimentary music education. During the 1960s,
contemporary musical styles were not part of the musical curriculum in
Australia and Greg was not so interested in classical music. As a
teenager, he decided to study art and design at college, believing that
graphic design was going to be his vocation.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 8
time is it and what day of the week is it and what age you are.....
Numbers really run right through everything. x
Gregs numbers-based approach is a system of composition,
improvisation and communication amongst players. As a system of
composition, it produces original and interesting rhythmic motifs.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 9
2
7
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 10
2
7
7
7
2
Using the
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 11
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 12
This Greg Sheehan rhythm circle describes the multiple meters of three
against four against five.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 13
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 14
FATS is a quartet that features tenor saxophonist Dave Addes and Aria
award winning trumpeter Scott Tinkler. This group performs intense
improvised music based on compositions by all members of the group.
Greg enjoys playing with this group as the music is varied and played
in a spirit of good humour and enjoyment.
Coolangubra.
This trio of acoustic musicians was formed in 1989 when Greg became
involved in the Save the South East Forests anti- logging campaigns in
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 15
NSW. Greg and violinist Cleis Pearce had first met award winning
bluegrass Guitarist Steve Berry at the Tamworth Country Music
Festival. Steve was involved in a non-violent action group as part of
the anti- logging campaigns. Coolangubra played acoustic
instrumental music influenced by many different styles; including Jazz,
Irish and Indian music, and Bluegrass. Steves virtuoso acoustic guitar
playing gives Coolangubra a very original sound.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 16
Circle of Rhythm.
This is Gregs current percussion project. This project involves two
Sydney based musicians; Tabla player Bobby Singh and multi
Instrumentalist Ben Walsh. This project performs percussion-based
music from all over the world and features Greg playing electric
bass and a new instrument from Switzerland called a Hang
(pronounced hung-a metal bowl similar to a small inverted
Caribbean steel drum). This group tours all over Australia and has
just returned from their first International tour.
All of the projects listed above incorporate many disparate musics from
all over the world.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 17
Greg has been teaching music using his own self-devised method for
over twenty years. He has had no formal teacher training, only the
basic ideas he took from a book he read by Gary Schaefferxv. The
maxims that he goes by when teaching are:
His music festival workshops are well known and Greg is skilled in
leading lead large numbers of people in an enjoyable and uplifting
session of body percussionxvii. His numbers system enables a
workshop group to compose and perform highly complex drum
rhythms in a very short time. Gregs use of body percussion patterns is
based around childrens clapping games from different parts of the
world. Greg finds that body percussion is a great way to introduce the
concepts of rhythm to those who have never studied it:
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 18
I was looking for a way to teach western people who had no tradition
of music a way to play highly syncopated rhythms. Western people all
know maths and know how to analyse concepts. Numbers and body
percussion is a way for people to learn how to feel rhythms that people
from other cultures have grown up with.xviii
Greg finds that body percussion enables people to be free from the
preconceptions of drumming that exist when someone holds a drum.
By removing the icons of exotic cultures such as congas djembes or
darabukas, it is easier to introduce the concept of playing rhythms to
people who have never touched a drum before. Body percussion
involves the whole body, and allows people the space to move
together, developing the basic musical concepts of body
independence, ensemble playing, listening and syncopation without
the need for textbooks or musical notation.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 19
During the eighties and nineties, while living in Sydney, Greg self
funded and self promoted a series of events called Drum Ups, that
were held at the premier Sydney live venue, The Harborside Brassiere.
At these events, Greg created a diverse program of music that one
would not usually see sharing the same stage. One such event
included(on the same bill) a Scottish Marching band, an electric bass
trio, a dance group of elderly people and a percussion troupe playing
garbage bins! In his time at Byron Bay in Northern NSW, Greg has
organised a similar series of events (the Knot Gigs) in Byron Bay.
Aside from the unique and often bizarre musical content, these type of
performances functioned as excellent networking events for local
musicians, who could exchange musical ideas with other musicians
that they would not normally have encountered. These events
highlight Gregs ability to be a conduit for musical translations between
different musical forms.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 20
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 21
Greg acknowledges that the source for his numerical rhythmic ideas
does come from other cultures such as North Indian Hindustani music.
This musical culture utilises groups of rhythmic syllables that are learnt
by speaking each phrase, then transferring them on to specific sounds
on percussion instruments.xxi Greg uses the processes of learning and
performance that are imbedded in these traditions to create his own
interpretation of a musical style rather than learn the forms inherent in
the musics. In concert, Greg introduces his own musical compositions
as not a version of Indian music or Polynesian Music but his own
reinterpretation of that particular style. It is this process of
reinterpretation that is integral to the creation of a distinct musical
style that combines produces hybrid or syncretised forms.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 22
Superculture
Intercultural space
Drumming
Sub-culture
Greg
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 23
For this framework, I use the term subculture and levels of Culture
with specific reference to the terminology of Slobin (1993) in
Subcultural Sounds-Micromusics of the Westxxii. Slobins delineation
of a cultural space into distinct and concentric layers of culture allows
an alternate focus on the interaction between and within layers of
culture. Amongst the participants of a musical subculture, (made up of
musicians, audience members, other interested parties such as family
friends business associates etc) individual participants are able to
influence the musical decisions of others through innovative or highly
appreciated musical practice or performance. Outside the subcultural
layer, are external influences such as global commercially-driven
musical cultures (such as pop music marketed by major record
companies) and foreign musical subcultures that affect an individual
subculture through interaction at what Slobin Terms an Intercultural
level.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 24
Global Super-Culture
Inter-cultural Space
Drumming
Subculture
Greg
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 25
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 26
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 27
Fig3ArepresentationofaperformerasaCulturalNomad.
Ahypotheticalmapoftherelationshipsbetweenindividualmusicians/(sitesofmusic
practice)amicromusicalsubcultureshowinglinesofinfluencesandconnectionwith
theinterculturalspaceoverculturaldistanceandtime.
C
InfluentialmusiciansuchasGreg
Secondarymusician(siteof
performance)
(DirectionofInfluentialmusicianspracticeovertime)
NoninfluentialPerformer
Linesofinfluence.
Frontierof
subculture
Intercultural
space
Intercultural
space
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 28
Figure4MusicianasasiteofCulturalTranslation.
CreativeInputs
SiteofTranslation
An original
musical style
Aesthetic
Influences
Ideas from other
cultures
Interpreted
Cultural forms
Inspiration to playbeautiful natural
environment
Creativeoutput
Musician
Without
Clear cultural
Identity
Distortion of
many
disparate
forms
Syncretion of
many forms
New musical
translation
Concluding Remarks
What I have attempted to combine in this discussion, is an empirical
study of the practice of one individual musicians contribution to the a
musical subculture that surrounds them. Slobins analysis of cultural
flows through concentric layers of influence is a convenient conceptual
structure into which an Influential musical practice can be placed in a
theoretical context.
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 29
Hill B(2016) The musical ideas of Australian Drummer Greg Sheehan. Monash University Honours
(Ethnomusicology) thesis. (originally presented at the 2004 SIMS Conference at the Victorian College of
the Arts/ University of Melbourne)
Page 30
Footnotes
LloydSwantonandChrisAbrahamsarewellknownfortheirinstrumentaltrioTheNecks,Lindsay
PollockisawellknowninstrumentbuilderandworldauthorityonMacedonianMusic.Colinofford
hasachievedworldwidefamcwithishandbuiltoriginalinstrument,theGreatIslandMouthBow.
ii
FromonlineReviewofCoolungubraperformancebySteveBaker
www.abc.net.au/farnorth/stories/s1372322.htmaccessed27thAugust2005
iii
WomadFestivalonlinepreviewwww.va.com.au/womadelaide/artists/Utungun_Percussion.html
accessed27thAugust2005
iv
www.abc.net.au/arts/adlib/stories/s880964.htmaccessed27thAugust
v
ThemusicalideasofArnoldSchoenbergandhistwostudentsAntonWebernandAlbanBergbecame
knownastheSecondViennieseSchool.Schoenbergdescribedatheoryofharmonythatincluded
atonalandsymmetricalscalesthatdidnotexistin19thCenturyEuropeanmusictheory.Hecomposed
musicthatincludedcompositionsbasedonmathematicalformulationasratherthanFunctionalharmony
basedonCadentialmovementsfromadominantchordtoatonicchord.WebernandBergbecame
knownasserialistsduetotheiruseofpatternsandnumberssequencesandseriestoconstructmusic.
vi
TextofrecordedinterviewwithGregOctober2003.
vii
Stokes(2003)ReaffirmsSlobinstheoreticalapproachwhendiscussingTurkishrappersinEurope.
McCuthcheon(2005)usesSlobinsubcultural/superculturalframeworkanforanalysisofcorporate
controlovertheTorontoDancescene.
viii
ForamoredetaileddiscussionoftheperilsofparticipantobservationseeBecker,HowardS.
(1993).:Problemofinferenceandproofinparticipantobservation,Reprintedition.IrvingtonPub.
ix
ExcerptfromrecordedpersonalinterviewAugust2003
x
ibid
xi
Jarne(2004)hassomeinterestingcommentsonthewayrhythmsfromtheAmericasarecombinations
ofNumbersmainlyrhythmicgroupingsoftwosandthrees.
xii
InWestAfricandrummingmusics,adrumensemblewillbeledbyonedrummer,whoplays
rhythmicmotifsandcallsthatalldrummersintheensemblerecognise.NorthIndianHindustani
musicincorporatesasystemofcountingthatisusedasanimprovisingstructure.
xiii
InterviewtextOctober2003.
xiv
Takenfromwebsitehttp://www.aidc.com.au/social_program.htmlaccessed14thSeptember2003
xv
ThisinformationisfromaninterviewwithGregSheehanconductedinDarwinbyTimStewartin
1993andpublishedaspercussiononthevergeofperilinGreenLeftReviewonlineweekly
www.greenleft.org.au/back/1994/165/165p29.htm.Ihavenotbeenabletofindthebibliographic
detailsforthebookMusicforChildrenbyGarySchaefferthatGregreferstointhisarticle.I
suspectthatthetitleandAuthormaywellbeinaccurate.
xvi
GregSheehaninterviewAugust2003
i
xvii
ibid
Thepercussionistswhostatedthiswishestoremainanonymous.
xx
Asabove.ThisisonedifficultyIencounteredwiththeresearchasmusiciansdidnotwanttheir
nametobeassociatedwithcriticismsofthemusicianshipoftheircollegues.
xxi
JaiyrazbhoyNA(1971)TheRagsofNorthIndianMusicFaberLondon
xxii
SlobindefinesthreemainlevelsofcultureasupercultureaintercultureandsubcultureThese
threelevelsofcultureinteracttocreateaglobalnetworkofsubculturessurroundedbyaninterculktural
spacethatfunctionsasthesiteofCulturaltransformation.
xxiii
Grehan(2001)usesthetermculturalnomadsandnomadicperformance.inrelationtoindigenous
danceperformancesinwesternAustralia.Andhowsitesofperformancecanbecomesitesof
xviii
xix
interactionandinfluence.
xxiv
Fromwww.encyclopedia.laborlawtalk.com/TransculturationaccessedMonday29thAugust2005
TransculturationisatermcoinedbyFernandoOrtizin1947todescribethephenomenonofmerging
andconvergingcultures.
Bibliography.
Becker, Howard S. (1993). : Problem of inference and proof in participant
observation. Reprint edition. Irvington Pub.
Cameron N 1995 Maleny Folk Festival and the Art of Celebration.Mimburi
press Maleny.
Eagleton T 2000 The Idea of Culture Blackwell Publishers Oxford.
Edgar A and Sedgewick P(eds)2002 Cultural Theory- The Key Thinkers Cambridge
University Press
Finnegan, R. 1989.The Hidden Musicians: Music Making in an English Town.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Friedman J 1994 Cultural Identity and Global Process Sage London.
Gibson C and Connell J 2003 Bongo Fury:Tourism, Music and Cultural Economy at
Byron Bay Australia in Tijdshrift voor Economische en Social
Geographie Vol 94 No 2 P164-187
Grehan H 2001Mapping Cultural Identity in Contemporary Australia Performance
in Dramaturgies No 2 University of Brussels
1990
Selected Discography
Greg Sheehan Back in the Dim Dim World Self Released Cassette recording
1987.
Skin Self Titled Kin001Copyright Skin Music 2002
Coolangubra Storm Coming copyright Coolangubra 1990
Utungun Percussion Zing Copyright Utungun Percussion 1995
Wanderlust Dakar Copyright ABC Records 1994
Free Boppers Fire Copyright Birdland Music