9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.

<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP

ChanRobles VirtualLawLibrary

Like

|chanrobles.com
Search

Tweet

Philippine Supreme Court Jurisprudence > Year 1907 > July 1907 Decisions > G.R. No. L3474 September 20,
1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.
008Phil565:

Search

ChanRoblesOnLineBarReview

FIRSTDIVISION
[G.R.No.L3474.September20,1907.]
RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.,PlaintiffsAppellees,v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.,
DefendantsAppellants.
W.A.Kincaid,forAppellants.
Hartigan,Rohde&Gutierrez,forAppellees.
SYLLABUS
1. APPEAL ASSIGNMENT OF ERRORS. Where upon an appeal by both the plaintiff and the
defendantitappearsthattheplaintiffmadenoassignmentoferrorsagainsttherulingsoragainstthe
decision of the lower court. so much of the judgment as may be adverse to the plaintiff can not be
consideredbythiscourt.
2. MARRIAGE SUFFICIENCY OF PROOF. When a marriage ceremony is duly celebrated between
twopersonsuponacertaindate,inordertoshowthatthesamepersonsarelawfullymarriedbefore
that time it is necessary to prove that a marriage ceremony had theretofore been celebrated
between them. The fact of having had children prior to the celebration of the latter ceremony does
notproveaformermarriage.

DebtKollectCompany,Inc.

3. COMMONLAW MARRIAGE. What are known as commonlaw marriages in England and the
UnitedStateswereneverrecognizedbytheSpanishlawinforceintheseIslands.Novalidmarriage
could exist under the Spanish law unless some ecclesiastical or civil functionary intervened in its
celebration.
DECISION
WILLARD,J.:

ChanRoblesIntellectualProperty
Division

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

TheplaintiffsbroughtthisactionintheCourtofFirstInstanceofManilaonthe2ddayofJune,1902,
askingthatadeedmadebyAntonioEnriquezonthe27thofMarch,1883,conveyingtothedefendant
Carmen de la Cavada certain real estate in the city of Manila, be annulled and set aside. Judgment
wasrenderedinthecourtbelowtotheeffectthattheplaintiffsweretheownersofanundividedhalf
of the said real estate, and that the defendant Carmen de la Cavada should pay to the plaintiffs
upwardof1,300pesos,asrentsandprofitsthereof.Bothpartiesmovedforanewtrialontheground
oftheinsufficiencyoftheevidence,bytheplaintiffsinthiscourthaveneitherassignedaserrorsthe
rulingsmadeagainstthem,bythelowercourtnorhavetheydiscussedanysuchrulingsintheirbrief.
So much of the decision, therefore, as is adverse to the plaintiffs we can not consider, and the
questionstoberesolvedarethosepresentedbytheappealofthedefendants.
Thedecisionofthecourtbelowwasbaseduponthefollowingfacts,deemedtobeestablishedbythe
evidence, namely, that Antonio Enriquez and Doa Ciriaca Villanueva were legally married prior to
the year 1860 that in 1861 the property in question was acquired by Antonio Enriquez that it
thereby became a part of the property belonging to the conjugal partnership that Doa Ciriaca
Villanueva died in 1882 that upon her death an undivided half of the property passed to her heirs,
the plaintiffs that when, in 1883, Antonio Enriquez undertook to convey the entire property to the
defendantDoaCarmendelaCavadahe,asmatteroflaw,conveyedonehalfthereof,andthatthe
otherhalfremainedandnowisthepropertyoftheplaintiffs.

1/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
ThecorrectnessofthisdecisiondependsuponthequestionastowhetherAntonioEnriquezandDoa
Ciriaca Villanueva were legally married in 1861. The court below found and, the evidence sustains
thatfinding,thatamarriageceremonywasdulyperformedbetweenthesepersonsin1865,butheld
thatthefactthatpriorto1861theyhadlivedtogetherashusbandandwife,hadbeenrecognizedas
such, and had children who were baptized as the legitimate children of their lawful marriage was
sufficientevidencetoraisethepresumptionthattheywereatthetimelegallymarried.
Amarriageceremonyhavingbeendulycelebratedbetweenthesepersonsin1865,itisnecessary,in
order to show that they were legally married before that time, to prove that the same kind of a
marriageceremonyhadtheretoforebeencelebrated.Although,asheldbytheSupremeCourtofthe
United States, by the common law of England, a valid marriage might be contacted without the
interventionofanyecclesiasticalorcivilfunctionary(Traversev.Rheinhardt,27Sup.Ct.Rep.,563,
decidedApril15,1907),yetsuchwasneverthelawintheseIslandsduringtheSpanishdomination
here. During the entire period of that domination no valid marriage could exist unless some
ecclesiastical or civil functionary intervened in its celebration, and the intervention of civil
functionaries was limited to the short time elapsing between the 8th day of December, 1889, when
theCivilCodetookeffecthere,andthe29thdayofthesamemonth,whentheprovisionsofTitleIV,
BookI,ofthatcodeweresuspended.DuringthetimecoveredbythelivesofAntonioEnriquezand
Doa Ciriaca Villanueva no valid marriage between them could be contracted by their mere
agreementtolivetogetherashusbandandwife.

Thereisnoproofinthiscasethatamarriage,validinaccordancewiththelawstheninforceinthese

Islands,wascelebratedbetweenthesepersonsin1865.Inordertoshowthattheywerebeforethat
time husband and wife, it was necessary to prove that a marriage ceremony in which an
ecclesiasticalfunctionaryintervenedwasdulycelebrated.Noproofofanysuchmarriagewasoffered.
As has been said, the fact that prior to 1865 they lived together as husband and wife and had
childrenisnotevidenceinthiscasetoshowthattheyweremarriedpriortothattime.Noristhefact
thatinthecertificatesofbaptismofthesechildrenitisstatedthattheywerethelegitimatechildrenof
thelawfulmarriageoftheirparents.
Thecourtbelowsaid:

jg c : c h a n r o b le s .c o m.p h

"Loss of the record of the first marriage, or some like reason, might have made the second
ceremonyseemnecessaryandforthatreasonitwascelebrated."
c r a la wv ir t u a 1 a wlib r a r y

July1907Jurisprudence
[G. R. No. L3273. July 13, 1907.] THE UNITED
STATES, PlaintiffAppellee, vs. QUIRINO PERALTA and
VICENTEPERALTA,DefendantsAppellants.
[G. R. No. L3556. July 13, 1907.] H. J. BLACK,
Plaintiff, vs. CARL T. NYGREN, acting provincial
treasureroftheProvinceofPampanga,Defendant.
[G. R. No. L3332. July 18, 1907.] THE UNITED
STATES, PlaintiffAppellee, vs. HARRY B. MULFORD,
DefendantAppellant.

This consideration is to our minds entirely insufficient to explain the celebration of the second
marriage.Iftheformermarriagehadtakenplace,itmusthavebeencelebratedbeforesomepriest
or other officer of the Roman Catholic Church. The law required that a record of such marriages
should be kept in the parish registry, and if such marriage in fact had been performed, it probably
wouldhavebeeneasytohaveobtainedacertifiedcopyofsuchrecord.Noevidencewasofferedin
thiscaseofanyattempttoobtainsuchrecordorthattherecordsofthechurchweretheceremony
hadbeenperformedhadbeendestroyed.Infact,noproofwhateverwasofferedinthecasetoshow
the celebration of such prior marriage, except the facts hereinbefore stated, that the parties lived
together as husband and wife and had children who were baptized as aforesaid. We hold that this
evidence is insufficient to prove in this case a prior marriage, where it appears that a marriage
ceremony was duly performed between the parties at a later date and we therefore hold that
Antonio Enriquez and Doa Ciriaca Villanueva were not legally married prior to 1865, and that,
therefore, when this property was acquired by Antonio in 1861 it did not become a part of the
propertybelongingtotheconjugalpartnership,butonthecontrarywasapartofthecapitalwhichhe
brought to the marriage. Being a part of the capital brought to the marriage by the husband, upon
the death of the wife the husband surviving her no interest whatever therein passed to her
heirs.
Thejudgmentofthecourtbelow,whichrestssolelyuponthepropositionthatatthetimeofthedeath
of Doa Ciriaca Villanueva onehalf of this property passed to her heirs, can not, therefore, be
sustained. That judgment is reversed, without costs to either in this court, judgment is entered
acquittingthedefendantsofthecomplaint,withthecostsofthefirstinstanceagainsttheplaintiffs.So
ordered.
Arellano,C.J.,Torres,Johnson,andTracey,JJ.,concur.

Adsby Google
Adsby Google
Adsby Google

CourtCases
GRCase
GRL

[G. R. No. 3621. July 26, 1907.] THE UNITED

STATES, PlaintiffAppellee, vs. MACARIO SAKAY,
JULIAN MONTALBAN, LEON VILLAFUERTE, and LUCIO
DEVEGA,DefendantsAppellants.
[G. R. No. L2997. July 27, 1907.] ANDRES
BARTOLOME, PlaintiffAppellee, vs. SIMEON MANDAC,
ETAL.,DefendantsAppellants.
[G. R. No. L3397. July 27, 1907.] THE UNITED
STATES, PlaintiffAppellee, vs. BERNARDO ALAMEDA,
DefendantAppellant.
[G. R. No. L3431. July 27, 1907.] THE UNITED
STATES, PlaintiffAppellee, vs. CHU CHIO, Defendant
Appellant.

GRCase
CourtGR
CompanyLaw

QUICKSEARCH

[G. R. No. L3476. July 25, 1907.] DOROTEA

MENDOZA,
PlaintiffAppellant,
vs.
CASIMIRO
FULGENCIOandJOSEDEASIS,DefendantsAppellees.

[G. R. No. L3563. July 26, 1907.] THE UNITED

STATES, PlaintiffAppellee, vs. MAXIMO AUSTRIA, ET
AL.,DefendantsAppellants.

GRGR
VSGR
GRIn

BacktoHome|BacktoMain

[G. R. No. L2646. July 25, 1907.] MARIA ROURA

AND JUAN ROURA, PetitionersAppellants, vs. THE
INSULARGOVERNMENT,RespondentAppellee.

[G. R. No. L3348. July 26, 1907.] JULIAN NAVAL,

PlaintiffAppellant, vs. HERMOGENES BENAVIDES,
DefendantAppellee.

LawGR
GRNo
GRV

1901

1902

1903

1904

1905

1906

1907

1908

1909

1910

1911

1912

1913

1914

1915

1916

1917

1918

1919

1920

1921

1922

1923

1924

1925

1926

1927

1928

1929

1930

1931

1932

1933

1934

1935

1936

1937

1938

1939

1940

1941

1942

1943

1944

1945

1946

1947

1948

1949

1950

1951

1952

1953

1954

1955

1956

1957

1958

1959

1960

1961

1962

1963

1964

1965

1966

1967

1968

1969

1970

1971

1972

1973

1974

1975

1976

1977

1978

1979

1980

1981

1982

1983

1984

1985

1986

1987

1988

1989

1990

1991

1992

1993

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2013

2014

2015

2016

2012

[G. R. No. L3479. July 29, 1907.] THE UNITED

STATES, PlaintiffAppellee, vs. WILLIAM BOSTON,

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

2/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
DefendantAppellant.

MainIndicesoftheLibrary>

Go!

[G. R. No. L3496. July 31, 1907.] THE UNITED

STATES, PlaintiffAppellee, vs. URBANA NACION,
DefendantAppellant.
G.R. No. L3273 July 13, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
QUIRINOPERALTA,ETAL.
008Phil200
G.R.No.L3556July13,1907H.J.BLACKv.CARL
T.NYGREN
008Phil205
G.R. No. L3332 July 18, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
HARRYB.MULFORD
008Phil208
G.R. No. L3541 July 20, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
ESTEBANSEVILLA
009Phil700
G.R.No.L2646July 25, 1907 MARIA ROURA, ET
AL.v.INSULARGOVERNMENT
008Phil214
G.R.No.L3476July25,1907DOROTEAMENDOZA
v.CASIMIROFULGENCIO,ETAL.
008Phil243
G.R. No. L3348 July 26, 1907 JULIAN NAVAL v.
HERMOGENESBENAVIDES
008Phil250
G.R. No. L3563 July 26, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
MAXIMOAUSTRIA
008Phil254
G.R. No. 3621 July 26, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
MACARIOSAKAY,ETAL.
008Phil255
G.R. No. L2997 July 27, 1907 ANDRES
BARTOLOMEv.SIMEONMANDAC,ETAL.
008Phil263
G.R. No. L3397 July 27, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
BERNARDOALAMEDA
008Phil266
G.R. No. L3431 July 27, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
CHUCHIO
008Phil269
G.R. No. L3479 July 29, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
WILLIAMBOSTON
008Phil271
G.R. No. L3496 July 31, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
URBANANACION
008Phil274
G.R. No. L3640 August 1, 1907 CHARLES S.
ROBINSONv.CHARLESF.GARRY
008Phil275
G.R.No.L4011August1,1907MAMERTABANAL
v.JOSESAFONT,ETAL.
008Phil276
G.R.No.L3574August2,1907UNITEDSTATESv.
NICOMEDESDEDIOS
008Phil279
G.R. No. L3965 August 2, 1907 ENRIQUE F.
SOMES,ETAL.v.A.S.CROSSFIELD,ETAL.
008Phil283
G.R.No.L3422August3,1907UNITEDSTATESv.
MANUELSAMONTE
008Phil286
G.R. No. L3576 August 3, 1907 FLORENCIO
TERNATEv.MARIAANIVERSARIO
008Phil292
G.R.No.L3841August3,1907CHUNGKIATv.LIM
KIO,ETAL.
008Phil297

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

3/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R.No.L2730August7,1907UNITEDSTATESv.
BASILIOMORALES,ETAL.
008Phil300
G.R.No.L2837August 7, 1907 CALDER & CO. v.
UNITEDSTATES
008Phil303
G.R.No.L2838August7,1907MACONDRAY&CO.
v.UNITEDSTATES
008Phil305
G.R.No.L3419August7,1907UNITEDSTATESv.
DOMINGOPOLINTAN
008Phil309
G.R.No.L3517August7,1907UNITEDSTATESv.
JOSEMAGNO,ETAL.
008Phil314
G.R.No.L3586August7,1907UNITEDSTATESv.
HIGINOVELASQUEZ
008Phil321
G.R.No.L3608August7,1907UNITEDSTATESv.
ESTANISLAOFLOIRENDO
008Phil325
G.R.No.L3842August7,1907VICTORINORON,
ETAL.v.FELIXMOJICA
008Phil328
G.R.No.L4008August7,1907AGUSTINGARCIA
GAVIERESv.WILLIAMROBINSON,ETAL.
008Phil332
G.R.No.L2836August 8, 1907 CALDER & CO. v.
UNITEDSTATES
008Phil334
G.R. No. L2840 August 8, 1907 KUENZLE &
STREIFFv.UNITEDSTATES
008Phil339
G.R. No. L4002 August 8, 1907 LO PO v. H.B.
McCOY
008Phil343
G.R.No.L3507August9,1907ISABELOAGUIRRE
v.OCCIDENTALNEGROS,ETAL.
008Phil350
G.R. No. L2841 August 10, 1907 RUBERT &
GUAMISv.UNITEDSTATES
008Phil352
G.R.No.L3488August10,1907C.S.ROBINSON,
ETAL.v.THESHIP"ALTA",ETAL.
008Phil355
G.R. No. L3456 August 14, 1907 JOSEPH N.
WOLFSONv.ELIASREYES,ETAL.
008Phil364
G.R. No. L3529 August 14, 1907 ESTEBAN
GUILLERMOv.RAMONMATIENZO,ETAL.
008Phil368
G.R.No.L2839August15,1907CALDER&CO.v.
UNITEDSTATES
008Phil373
G.R. No. L3562 August 15, 1907 GUTIERREZ
HERMANOSv.ANTONIOVALLEJO
008Phil377
G.R.No.L3363August17,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.JOAQUINCELIS
008Phil378
G.R. No. L3554 August 17, 1907 JULIANA
BENEMERITOv.FERNANDOVELASCO
008Phil381
G.R.No.L3572August17,1907S.G.LARSONv.H.
BRODEK
008Phil383

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

4/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R.No.L3627August17,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.JOAQUINCELIS
008Phil385
G.R.No.L3664August17,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.LEONACINCO,ETAL.
008Phil388
G.R.No.L3200August19,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.TOMASCOLOMBRO
008Phil391
G.R.No.L3625August19,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.JOAQUINCELIS
008Phil394
G.R.No.L3432August20,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.ESTANISLAOGASINGAN
008Phil397
G.R. No. L3567 August 20, 1907 KAY B. CHANG,
ETAL.v.ROYALEXCHANGEASSURANCECORPORATION
OFLONDON
008Phil399
G.R.No.L3626August21,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.JOAQUINCELIS
008Phil408
G.R.No.L3460August22,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.LEONNARVASA,ETAL.
008Phil410
G.R. No. L3557 August 22, 1907 VICTORIANO
GARCIA,ETAL.v.REMIGIODIAMSON
008Phil414
G.R.No.L3173August23,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.MODESTOGARCIA
008Phil416
G.R.No.L3568August23,1907ROMANESPAA
v.LEONARDOLUCIDO
008Phil419
G.R. No. L3510 August 24, 1907 HENRY
OCONNELLv.NARCISOMAYUGA
008Phil422
G.R.No.L3573August24,1907HENRYBRODEK
v.S.G.LARSON
008Phil425
G.R.No.L3604August24,1907INTERNATIONAL
BANKINGCORP.v.FRANCISCOMARTINEZ
008Phil427
G.R.No.L3622August26,1907H.W.PEABODY&
CO.,ETAL.v.PACIFICEXPORT&LUMBERCO.
008Phil429
G.R. No. L3734 August 26, 1907 JAMES J.
PETERSONv.RAFAELAZADA
008Phil432
G.R. No. L2871 August 29, 1907 LA COMPAIA
GENERALDETABACOSDEFILIPINASv.UNITEDSTATES
008Phil438
G.R.No.L3192August29,1907LUISAALVAREZ
v.SHERIFFOFILOILO,ETAL.
008Phil441
G.R.No.L3458August29,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.FIDELGONZALEZ
008Phil442
G.R.No.L3526August29,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.SEVERINOMACAVINTA
008Phil447
G.R. No. L3636 August 29, 1907 FREDERICK
GARFIELDWAITEv.JAMESJ.PETERSON,ETAL.
008Phil449
G.R.No.L3547August30,1907LORENZAPAEZv.
JOSEBERENGUER
008Phil454

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

5/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R.No.L3628August30,1907MANUELCOUTO
SORIANOv.BLASCORTES
008Phil459
G.R.No.L3416August31, 1907 UNITED STATES
v.PILARJAVIER,ETAL.
008Phil462
G.R.No.L3561August31,1907RITAGARCIA,ET
AL.v.SIMEONBALANAO,ETAL.
008Phil465
G.R. No. L3630 August 31, 1907 JOS. N.
WOLFSONv.CAYETANOCHINCHILLA
008Phil467
G.R.No.L3637August31,1907PEDROP.ROXAS,
ETAL.v.ANASTASIOCUEVAS,ETAL.
008Phil469
G.R. No. L3220 September 2, 1907 MURPHY
MORRIS&CO.v.UNITEDSTATES
008Phil479
G.R.No.L3396September2,1907STRUCKMANN
&CO.v.UNITEDSTATES
008Phil483
G.R. No. L2538 September 4, 1907 MARIANO
PAMINTUAN,ETAL.v.INSULARGOVERNMENT
008Phil485
G.R.No.L3648September5,1907LUTZ&CO.v.
COLLECTOROFCUSTOMS
008Phil492
G.R. No. L3667 September 5, 1907 NATALIA
FABIAN,ETAL.v.SMITH,BELL&CO.
008Phil496
G.R. No. L3326 September 7, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.LAURENTEREY
008Phil500
G.R. No. L3482 September 7, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.BARTOLOMEGRAY
008Phil506
G.R. No. L3489 September 7, 1907 VICENTE
NAVALESv.EULOGIARIAS,ETAL.
008Phil508
G.R. No. L2526 September 10, 1907 PEDRO
PAMINTUAN,ETAL.v.INSULARGOVERNMENT,ETAL.
008Phil512
G.R. No. L3301 September 10, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.EMIGDIONOBLEZA
008Phil515
G.R. No. L3616 September 10, 1907 CIRILO
PURUGANANv.TEODOROMARTIN,ETAL.
008Phil519
G.R. No. L3221 September 11, 1907 ATLANTIC,
GULF&CO.v.UNITEDSTATES
008Phil524
G.R. No. L3708 September 12, 1907 ELVIRA
FRESSELLv.MARCIANAAGUSTIN
008Phil529
G.R.No.L3383September13,1907TANLEONCO
v.GOINQUI
008Phil531
G.R. No. L3546 September 13, 1907 PIA DEL
ROSARIOv.JUANLUCENA,ETAL.
008Phil535
G.R. No. L3132 September 14, 1907 MANUEL
SOLER,ETAL.v.EMILIAALZOUA,ETAL.
008Phil539
G.R.No.L3146September14,1907NICOLASCO
PITCOv.PEDROYULO
008Phil544

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

6/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R.No.L3534September14,1907TOGUIOCCO
v.LORENZODELROSARIO
008Phil546
G.R. No. L3395 September 16, 1907 PEDRO
ARENAL,ETAL.v.CHARLESF.BARNES,ETAL.
008Phil551
G.R. No. L3067 September 17, 1907 RUBERT &
GUAMISv.LUENGO&MARTINEZ,ETAL.
008Phil554
G.R.No.L3434September18,1907SAGASAGv.
VICTORIATORRIJOS
008Phil561
G.R. No. L3474 September 20, 1907 RAFAEL
ENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.
008Phil565
G.R. No. L4244 September 20, 1907 RAFAEL
MOLINAv.ANTONIODELARIVA,ETAL.
008Phil569
G.R. No. L3575 September 23, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.TRANQUILINOALMADEN,ETAL.
008Phil573
G.R. No. L3672 September 23, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.ESTANISLAOEUSEBIO
008Phil574
G.R. No. L3675 September 23, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.GREGORIOAMANTE,ETAL.
008Phil577
G.R.No.3527September23,1907TANTIOCOv.
MARCELINALOPEZ
011Phil591
G.R. No. L3726 September 23, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.FERNANDOMONZONES,ETAL.
008Phil579
G.R. No. L3369 September 24, 1907 JONAS
BROOKBROS.v.FROELICH&KUTTNER
008Phil580
G.R. No. L3597 September 24, 1907 MANUEL
MESIAv.PLACIDOMAZO,ETAL.
008Phil587
G.R. No. L3615 September 24, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.BRIGIDOCASIN
008Phil589
G.R. No. L3669 September 24, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.DOMINGOBALTAZAR
008Phil592
G.R.No.L4138September24,1907SYHONGENG
v.SYLIOCSUY
008Phil594
G.R. No. L3728 September 25, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.ANASTASIOMAISA
008Phil597
G.R. No. L3207 September 26, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.CATALINOGARCIA
008Phil598
G.R. No. L3373 September 26, 1907 VICENTA
JALBUENAv.GABRIELLEDESMA,ETAL.
008Phil601
G.R. No. L3535 September 26, 1907 RAFAEL
ENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.
008Phil607
G.R. No. L3645 September 26, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.EMETERIODACANAY
008Phil617
G.R. No. L3439 September 27, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.JUANMONTANER
008Phil620

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

7/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R. No. L1516 September 28, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.DOMINADORGOMEZ
008Phil630
G.R. No. L2264 September 28, 1907 P. JOSE
EVANGELISTAv.P.ROMANVER
008Phil653
G.R. No. L3629 September 28, 1907 MATEA E.
RODRIGUEZv.SUSANADELACRUZ,ETAL.
008Phil665
G.R. No. L3684 September 28, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.EMILIONERI
008Phil669
G.R. No. L3767 September 28, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.FLORENTINOLEYBA,ETAL.
008Phil671
G.R. No. L3497 September 30, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.L.V.SMITH,ETAL.
008Phil674
G.R. No. L3584 September 30, 1907 ARTADI &
CO.v.CHUBACO
008Phil677
G.R. No. L3727 September 30, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.FLORENDOGADILA,ETAL.
008Phil679
G.R. No. L3543 October 1, 1907 LA CAPELLANIA
DEL CONVENTO DE TAMBOBONG v. GUILLERMO
ANTONIO,ETAL.
008Phil683
G.R. No. L3587 October 2, 1907 FRANCISCO
ALDAMISv.FAUSTINOLEUTERIO
008Phil688
G.R.No.L2827October 3, 1907 MARIA LOPEZ Y
VILLANUEVAv.TANTIOCO
008Phil693

G.R.No.L3409October 3, 1907 UNITED STATES

v.REMIGIOBUSTAMANTE,ETAL.
008Phil698
G.R.No.L3515October 3, 1907 UNITED STATES
v.ANDERSONMACK
008Phil701
G.R.No.L3520October3,1907HIJOSDEI.DELA
RAMAv.JOSEROBLES,ETAL.
008Phil712
G.R. No. L3571 October 3, 1907 VALENTIN
LACUESTA,ETAL.v.PATERNOGUERRERO,ETAL.
008Phil719
G.R.No.L3957October3,1907DOMINGOREYES,
ETAL.v.SOREFIGENIAALVAREZ
008Phil723
G.R.No.L3716October 4, 1907 UNITED STATES
v.BIBIANOBORJA
008Phil726
G.R.No.L3729October 4, 1907 UNITED STATES
v.ZACARIASVALENCIA
008Phil729
G.R.No.L3744October 5, 1907 UNITED STATES
v.CARLOSCASTAARES
008Phil730
G.R.No.3067October7,1907RUBERT&GUAMIS
v.LUENGO&MARTINEZ,ETAL.
008Phil732
G.R.No.L3642October 7, 1907 UNITED STATES
v.ANTONIOXAVIER
008Phil733
G.R.No.L2558October 8, 1907 UNITED STATES
v.JULIANMACALALAD
009Phil1

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

8/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R. No. L4052 October 8, 1907 ENRIQUE F.
SOMESv.HON.A.S.CROSSFIELD,ETAL.
008Phil284
G.R.No.L3715October 8, 1907 UNITED STATES
v.BIBIANOBORJA
009Phil8
G.R.No.L3749October8,1907ARTADY&CO.v.
CLAROSANCHEZ
009Phil10
G.R.No.L3807October 8, 1907 UNITED STATES
v.SANTIAGOCABIGAO
009Phil12
G.R. No. L4052 October 8, 1907 ENRIQUE F.
SOMESv.HON.A.S.CROSSFIELD
009Phil13
G.R.No.L3752October 9, 1907 UNITED STATES
v.FAUSTOBASILIO
009Phil16
G.R. No. L4057 October 9, 1907 MARIANO
MACATANGAYv.MUN.OFSANJUANDEBOCBOC
009Phil19
G.R.No.L3181October10,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.GUMERSINDODELASANTA
009Phil22
G.R.No.L3438October12,1907MANUELLOPEZ
YVILLANUEVAv.EVARISTOALVAREZYPEREZ
009Phil28
G.R.No.L3594October12,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.ALLENA.GARNER
009Phil38
G.R.No.L3609October12,1907EULALIAESPINO
v.DANIELESPINO
009Phil41
G.R. No. L3660 October 12, 1907 JOSE TAN
SUNCOv.ALEJANDROSANTOS
009Phil44
G.R.No.L3887October12,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.PEDROFLORES
009Phil47
G.R.No.L3961October12,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.ISIDOROBASE
009Phil48
G.R.No.L3224October17,1907MUOZ&CO.v.
STRUCKMANN&CO.,ETAL.
009Phil52
G.R.No.L3796October17,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.MACARIARAMIREZ
009Phil67
G.R.No.L3905October17,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.REMIGIODONATO
009Phil701
G.R.No.3810October18,1907UNITEDSTATESv.
DAMIANORERA
011Phil596
G.R.No.L2870October18,1907CITYOFMANILA
v.INSULARGOVERNMENT
009Phil71
G.R.No.L3766October18,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.PONCIANOLIMCANGCO
009Phil77
G.R.No.L3808October18,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.JACINTOVICTORIA
009Phil81
G.R.No.L3873October18,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.JUSTODACUYCUY
009Phil84

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

9/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R.No.L3760October19,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.WALTERB.BROWN
009Phil89
G.R.No.L3819October19,1907JESUSSANCHEZ
MELLADOv.MUNICIPALITYOFTACLOBAN
009Phil92
G.R.No.L3853October19,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.JUANVILLANUEVA
009Phil94
G.R.No.L3949October19,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.GABINOSORIANO
009Phil98
G.R.No.L3532October21,1907TYLACOCIOCO
v.ARISTONMURO
009Phil100
G.R. No. L3644 October 21, 1907 VICENTE
QUESADAv.ISABELOARTACHO
009Phil104
G.R. No. L3694 October 21, 1907 JULIANA
BONCANv.SMITH
009Phil109
G.R.No.L3649October24,1907JOSEGUZMANv.
WILLIAMX
009Phil112
G.R. No. L3761 October 24, 1907 SALUSTIANO
LERMAYMARTINEZv.FELISAMAMARIL
009Phil118
G.R. No. L3560 October 26, 1907 MAGDALENA
LEDESMAv.ILDEFONSODORONILA
009Phil119
G.R.No.L3619October26,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.APOLONIOCANAMAN
009Phil121
G.R. No. L3676 October 26, 1907 PONS Y
COMPANIAv.LACOMPANIAMARITIMA
009Phil125
G.R. No. L3695 October 16, 1907 ALEJANDRA
PALANCAv.SMITH
009Phil131
G.R.No.L3745October26,1907JUANAGUSTIN
v.BARTOLOMEINOCENCIO
009Phil134
G.R.No.L3756October28,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.ILDEFONSORODRIGUEZ
009Phil136
G.R.No.L3633October30,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.TEODORABORJAL
009Phil140
G.R. No. L3908 November 1, 1907 ENRIQUE
SERRANOv.LEANDROSERRANO
009Phil142
G.R. No. L3732 November 2, 1907 CLEMENCIA
FELIXv.MATEOAFELIX
009Phil144
G.R. No. L3427 November 6, 1907 CAPELLANIA
DELCONVENTODETAMBOBONGv.HIPOLITOCRUZ
009Phil145
G.R. No. L3623 November 6, 1907 RUPERTO
RELOVAv.ELENALAVAREZ
009Phil149
G.R.No.L3661November6,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.LAUREANORODRIGUEZ
009Phil153
G.R.No.L3985November6,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.ANANIASCERVO,ETAL.
009Phil158

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

10/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R.No.L3986November6,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.AMBROSIOGESMUNDO
009Phil160
G.R.No.L3996November6,1907UNITEDSTATES
v.JUANBAILON
009Phil161
G.R. No. L3852 November 11, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.EDUARDOMONTIEL
009Phil162
G.R. No. L3779 November 13, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.OTISG.FREEMAN
009Phil168
G.R. No. L3787 November 14, 1907 TEODORICA
ENDENCIAv.EDUARDOLOALHATI
009Phil177
G.R. No. L3754 November 15, 1907 ANGELA
OJINAGAv.ESTATEOFTOMASR.PEREZ
009Phil185
G.R. No. L3516 November 16, 1907 FELISA
NEPOMUCENOv.CIRILOA.CARLOS
009Phil194
G.R. No. L3838 November 16, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.AGUSTINFERNANDEZ
009Phil199
G.R. No. L3840 November 16, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.IGNACIOBORSED
009Phil203
G.R. No. L3878 November 16, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.ATANACIOMACASPAC
009Phil207
G.R. No. L4123 November 16, 1907 LA YEBANA
COMPANYv.TIMOTEOSEVILLA
009Phil210
G.R. No. L4018 November 18, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.DEMETRIOSALUDO
009Phil213
G.R. No. L3144 November 19, 1907 CARMEN
AYALADEROXAS,ETAL.v.CITYOFMANILA,ETAL.
009Phil215
G.R. No. L3638 November 19, 1907 FAUSTINO
GUERRAv.BLANCOSENDAGORTA,ETAL.
009Phil222
G.R. No. L3662 November 19, 1907 VICENTA
ACUAv.THECITYOFMANILA
009Phil225
G.R.No.L3610November 20, 1907 JOSE CAMPS
v.PEDROA.PATERNO
009Phil229
G.R. No. L3774 November 20, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.VICENTESOTTO
009Phil231
G.R. No. L4069 November 20, 1907 JUAN
JAUCIANv.ROBERTOFLORANZA
009Phil236
G.R. No. L2786 November 21, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.VICTORIANOASEBUQUE
009Phil241
G.R. No. L3900 November 21, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.CANUTOBUTARDO
009Phil246
G.R. No. L4357 November 21, 1907 MIGUEL
PAVONv.PHIL.ISLANDSTELEPHONE,ETAL.
009Phil247
G.R.No.3747November22,1907YUCHENGCOv.
ALFONSOTIAOQUI,ETAL.
011Phil598

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

11/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R.No.L3755November 23, 1907 C. C. PYLE v.
ROYW.JOHNSON
009Phil249
G.R. No. L3823 November 23, 1907 PEDRO P.
ROXASv.MARIADELAPAZMIJARES
009Phil252
G.R. No. L3750 November 26, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.JUSTOGAMIS
009Phil259
G.R. No. L3964 November 26, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.ESTEBANMALABANAN
009Phil262
G.R. No. L3973 November 26, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.MARTINSOL
009Phil265
G.R. No. L3741 November 27, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.AFRONIANOFERNANDEZ
009Phil269
G.R. No. L3702 November 29, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.ESCOLASTICODELACRUZ
009Phil276
G.R. No. L4338 December 2, 1907 ALFRED B.
JONESv.J.E.HARDING
009Phil279
G.R.No.L3738December3,1907JOSEACOSTA
v.ANDRESDOMINGO
009Phil290
G.R. No. L3190 December 4, 1907 ASUNCION
ALBERT Y MAYORALGO, ET AL v. MARTINIANO
PUNSALAN
009Phil294
G.R.No.L3935December 4, 1907 UY PIAOCO v.
SERGIOOSMENA
009Phil299
G.R.No.L3378December5,1907JOSECASTAO
v.CHARLESS.LOBINGIER
009Phil310
G.R. No. L3713 December 5, 1907 UNION
FARMACEUTICAFILIPINAv.FRANCISCOICASIANO
009Phil319
G.R.No.L3826December7,1907CARMENAYALA
DEROXASv.JUANAVALENCIA
009Phil322
G.R. No. L3847 December 7, 1907 LEOPOLDO
FERRERv.RAMONNERIABEJUELA
009Phil324
G.R.No.L3704December12,1907LACOMPAIA
MARITIMAv.FRANCISCOMUOZ
009Phil326
G.R.No.L3895December14,1907Inthematter
ofA.K.JONES
009Phil347
G.R. No. L3899 December 16, 1907 ALFREDO
CHANCOv.ANACLETAMADRILEJOS
009Phil356
G.R. No. L3933 December 16, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.PAULINOSANANDRES
009Phil362
G.R. No. L3959 December 16, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.FLORENCIOPARAS
009Phil367
G.R. No. L3972 December 16, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.MATEOGUANZON
009Phil371
G.R.No.L3596December 17, 1907 LUCHSINGER
&CO.v.CORNELIOMELLIZA
009Phil376

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

12/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R.No.L3128December19,1907UNPAKLEUNG
v.JUANNIGORRA
009Phil381
G.R.No.L3128December19,1907UNPAKLEUNG
v.JUANNIGORRA
009Phil381
G.R. No. L3688 December 19, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.JOHNHAZLEY
009Phil384
G.R. No. L3891 December 19, 1907 ELENA
MORENTEv.GUMERSINDODELASANTA
009Phil387
G.R. No. L3505 December 20, 1907 ARCADIO
MAXILOMv.GAUDENCIOTABOTABO
009Phil390
G.R. No. L3980 December 20, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.RUPERTOGOROSPE,ETAL.
009Phil394
G.R. No. L4061 December 20, 1907 MANUEL
TAGUINOTv.MUNICIPALITYOFTANAY
009Phil396
G.R. No. L3483 December 21, 1907 BENITO
MOJICAv.JUANAFERNANDEZ
009Phil403
G.R. No. L3788 December 21, 1907 PEDRO P.
ROXASv.JULIATUASON
009Phil408
G.R. No. L3936 December 21, 1907 JOSE
VILLEGASv.NICOLASCAPISTRANO
009Phil416
G.R. No. L3991 December 21, 1907 SIMEON
ROQUEv.RUFINONAVARRO
009Phil420
G.R. No. L3992 December 21, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.MAGDALENOMENDEZ
009Phil422
G.R. No. L4086 December 21, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.MAXIMOBRELLO
009Phil424
G.R. No. L4201 December 21, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.ESPIRIDIONROTA
009Phil426
G.R. No. L3570 December 23, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.ELIGIOC.GARCIA
009Phil434
G.R. No. L3948 December 27, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.GABINOSORIANO
009Phil441
G.R. No. L3969 December 27, 1907 UNITED
STATESv.GABINOSORIANOSANTILLAN
009Phil445
G.R. No. L3212 December 28, 1907 ROMAN
CATHOLIC APOSTOLIC CHURCH v. MUNICIPALITIES OF
TARLAC,ETAL.
009Phil450
G.R. No. L3273 July 13, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
QUIRINOPERALTA,ETAL.
008Phil200
G.R.No.L3556July13,1907H.J.BLACKv.CARL
T.NYGREN
008Phil205
G.R. No. L3332 July 18, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
HARRYB.MULFORD
008Phil208
G.R. No. L3541 July 20, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
ESTEBANSEVILLA
009Phil700

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

13/14

9/9/2016 G.R.No.L3474September20,1907RAFAELENRIQUEZ,ETAL.v.FRANCISCOENRIQUEZ,ETAL.<br/><br/>008Phil565:JULY1907PHILIP
G.R.No.L2646July 25, 1907 MARIA ROURA, ET
AL.v.INSULARGOVERNMENT
008Phil214
G.R.No.L3476July25,1907DOROTEAMENDOZA
v.CASIMIROFULGENCIO,ETAL.
008Phil243
G.R. No. L3348 July 26, 1907 JULIAN NAVAL v.
HERMOGENESBENAVIDES
008Phil250
G.R. No. L3563 July 26, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
MAXIMOAUSTRIA
008Phil254
G.R. No. 3621 July 26, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
MACARIOSAKAY,ETAL.
008Phil255
G.R. No. L2997 July 27, 1907 ANDRES
BARTOLOMEv.SIMEONMANDAC,ETAL.
008Phil263
G.R. No. L3397 July 27, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
BERNARDOALAMEDA
008Phil266
G.R. No. L3431 July 27, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
CHUCHIO
008Phil269
G.R. No. L3479 July 29, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
WILLIAMBOSTON
008Phil271
G.R. No. L3496 July 31, 1907 UNITED STATES v.
URBANANACION
008Phil274

|Disclaimer|EmailRestrictions

Copyright19982016ChanRoblesPublishingCompany

http://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/1907julydecisions.php?id=295

ChanRobles VirtualLawLibrary |chanrobles.com

RED

14/14