Sie sind auf Seite 1von 48

Author's Accepted Manuscript

Efficiency and productivity of the cement


industry: Pakistani experience of deregulation
and privatisation
Yaseen Ghulam, Shabbar Jaffry

www.elsevier.com/locate/omega

PII:
DOI:
Reference:

S0305-0483(15)00015-8
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.omega.2015.01.013
OME1483

To appear in:

Omega

Received date: 25 April 2013


Accepted date: 26 January 2015
Cite this article as: Yaseen Ghulam, Shabbar Jaffry, Efficiency and productivity
of the cement industry: Pakistani experience of deregulation and privatisation, Omega, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.omega.2015.01.013
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for
publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of
the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and
review of the resulting galley proof before it is published in its final citable form.
Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which
could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal
pertain.

 

 
   
      
    


   

  
      
!    "  #  
$    

  %&'(!)
! 
*+#,+ + -



 
.   
              -
  +.      
    
 
/ /
 
    

 012 
 3
 - 
3
       43
 - (+ +   3
 + 3+ 5667 81  
  
 2 
       
 /  
   " 
 $
 -     
  !    569155:;+ 2 
 /  
      

  <
2    /     + .

 /  
              
/    
 
 + 3 
          
  
 
-   
 
 
              
 +

!=
 
&>5&='5
)/ 
!  ?<
2  ?-   ?$ ??@
 
012 
 ?. 
 


 
 
./&976    
 
 
          1      /+    
       //

 +%/
    /    
    
 
 
/         + . /  

    
 
    
    
 +.
   +.
? 
    

  
 A      
 -   
      
  
+

.   
      
          
 -   +.    
  
- 4 ;/  1

    / 
 
    

     




   &+. 1 
    

 
   / B    4&97C  56&&;+    

  
 
  /
           /             D 
   
+.
 
   

        
   
/

 
   B+


-        
/  + "? 
     
?          
    E    +        
* <  
F::G H


 F77G @ F>>G  -    F&CG  -   F>9G 3   F79G
1

3




   
 5666 

        B /   +

 -   F&IG (D  A   F'5G  -    F&7G    F5>G <   
  #F:5G"JF>&G8  F:IG-   F57G@  
F>CG @    3 F>IG   K   F9IG5+ .  
   
   

   
  
   
  +.
   1        2     
  
    
  
+

.        
  
  
'+!  
        
     B     
    
 /   
  -
        - -
+           
   E       1 1  

* 
 -FC7G$FCIG 

 -FC9I6G;/F5:G! F'7G


   <  F:6G $    "  FC>G 

    F'6G =   L  F:&G


/F5CG.A @F7:G

F'&G/F5&G%- FC&G
  $F:G 

FI&G
1% F>G FIG+( 
                     /  
 
 
 
   
 / D       
    

 
>+

./        1M1     
  
       " 
 4 ";     


5

   
   
  
*  
E 

    N


      +.       
   
     /

     /           
 /  -

   
+
'    



 

  
/ 2 

B      .


4

3
 - 3
47779;   1   +

    1        ( !
  
 4(!;+
(   
     "   
 /  / 
 /


  
    
 4
  
B

   
  :;+ O (!       

  

        B          
        
    
 /    

   
               
    
 


      + O    


        
  
 
  /     
   
+
@  
 /
2       
         /     
    -      
 +

(        (!             
  %<!D
>&/        (!
  + 2 
 %<! 
   !   
  %

$         
 

        (! 
    + . 
 @   + F>:G     
 </ F:'G 
-@/F>7G  
 $FCCG
 / 

 
      .   .   F7>G    
   
  
   F5IG 
 $    FC'G  
    (     F'IG 
 

        FI5G  #  
     .P
   F7IG  # 

-+


  < 

 < < F:CG? 3


 - 3
F96G 
 


-
 1 - 
+O      

   
    
   /

 
 1  +

     &996        


    B   
  (!  ?        3
 FIC17'G (     F':G
(      F'>G   3
 -   3
 F7996G+ 3
 -   3
 F79 96G

       
012 

      
 +. 
    
012 

   
         
     

    / / +
    F55G  
       
      +
3           
 
    
  
   +3
 
   
   1       (! " (
@

 4"(@;
   1  
  
    ?   
       
 
         C+

3      
  
-    4 ;+ <             &99C 566I
 + !       

 / 566I  56&&         
   

          + H     
   / /   


/ 
    
 &996+ .     2 

 + %

  
B      
   1    + . 
/

   
 
 
 + "       /      B   
    
     
+

.           B     /  -
     /

   /       


  
 &996+   
   /     

               
 +         
  /-      2  
6

 ' 


    
 /     +

      + (     


 
   
 
  B  
+

!    


 
     /

1
  -   :+:N

  
    &+>N  (     '6 

 -
$   

   8


 !B 2 +         &95& /
-D
/ /  >>:664;+. 
/  
 
      &9>I+     /   /  
   

4

 ;//
  >76666+( 
&9:6D  &9C6DB  
 /           /  
 
      - O 
 (
   4O(;+ .  
   /   9+IN      &9C6+       &9I& 
        '+>: 

/:7N 
  
  >5N       
+   
1
   
  
       &9I5   

    
 / 
        
O 
 <  4%O<;    2 
        
-4 ;+

.
  

A
   / 
<
% &9I7
         
 /I+.1 E -  8/A 


BB     
     
- 
&99&195+            

  
     

         
 
A    
 -  

I      

    
   /         
1
/ /    

&9II+


   
     / 
 
    /     
&'+5N2 --.
   = 4.=;+

. 
             
   
    &99&195+  
   /      / '6


$ &97>O -4O;+.




  
    
+O&995 
  7     C  
   
     5   Q! 

 R+ .         /  
   &995    
 // 
        +./
/  
 &99C  
 
 
/  1/          &999   566'+   566' 

 
         /+%
      
    
  -     /-+ .
  /- /      561'6N  /-       + .
 /   /   
?   +
   / /  /   +
     /+. /  
   &99&            / /  2 

 +

. -       
 

            
 + .   
      +  
 

         


  
/    
 
 /   +
     &996   
    /      


   -                 7+ .
    / 
     

 
 &99:1C566>1:+@/ 566I@ 
O B 1
 

4" &;+.     
B
  
  

 /
 B    

+
F" & G

" #      

     

$ % 
  
./&976 

      


    /   
 
 +.
 
2 /       
+
" 
  
  &976 &996 /  +.

 /   4 
   B ;+.
     D  1 1 +

O    
 - /   
    +     
    F&'G     H F&:G    -   F56G    
    /

  +  F5G 
  H F&:G -   @
 F7G   82   ) 
 F:7G 
  
  /    
    
 
 /  
 
 +!
     

7. / 
&:6666/-

  
  
+"    B

     O  /

<
!    
 +

 
 )F&>G<F::G 
F&9G

F>5G9

FI>G 
FC5G+

O  B   -            
 -
 /  &6+ 8
             ) F&G /
    1   1            /
 
  
           + .       
    
     
+O

/ 
 

    + 82   ) 
 F:9G 
  Q
2        

  
              
   
/     D
 
 
/   /- 
   
      /
R+ @/ 
 /      
   /

   
 /   +

    45666; 
  
 1  4  .
&+;+
 /  
     
    /   /  

       
   
      
 B   /    + 

 -FC7C9G 
        )+
= 

 -FI6I&G/ 


/   
        
  
+ $ FCIG / 
        $    "  FC>G        



F>5G 
-    1
  

  /
+
10

.
 

 
 - 
    
/

  
   
&:+

        + =   L  F:&G 


     
     
  
  +
F.
& G


 /     

+!  F'7G       +
. / 
   4."; /   
         
        + 

    F'6G 


   
          )+ O
         
   +.A @F7:G     
/ 
        +

F'&G
#          
       
/

     +

   
     

       + / F5:G 
      
    
<
/   1/     /       &9I619I+

   . A FI'G  . -            
/     
  + < F:6G   
  /+ /       
 1/   + / F5CG       
      
 /    +/F5&G      

     4$ @ 


  -;        $ + %-    FC&G 
     


   //. -      &97'199+


.  
 /  
 
  + 
 $F:G 
 
      
              '156N+    FIG

10


   /  /            
 $      +     
 
 +

O 
 
 B 
  
 1  
   
 D   
+.
   
  

/*

&+ 
-  
 &   
    
         1
         
  D    
   
      / F5:G+ . /  
/         
 
        
   

 +3  



  
   /
 

 +

5+   
-                

      

 
 . AFI'GFB
G/F5CGF/G
 @F&&GFG %- 
FC&GFG+%   /     
-   / 
      
 B4-//
D
  B;
   '6

$ 8
!B 2 +

'+ <         
 &
-     D    
    ++/F5:GF  G 
 . AFI'G
F  G/F5CGF  G
 @F&&GF G/
F5&G F G %-    FC&G F G     $ F:G

11

F G+  


    /

        


< F:6G   
      # 
        
 +3  
   / 
     1    
 D     /

 +

>+           E 
    D   
 5666   
&
   
    
)$O            
 
4   )  . -   O ;+ 

      





 
 
   
          
 + -
    
     B 

/      
 


4     
 ; 
 


   
/      
         /    D
    +

O  

/   /          / / /    
     +
& '
 
O   
     /

/3
 - 
3
F7996G  
1      
    
 +3
    
 

 &&+3/ 
 / 
  "(@ (!  
B            1 012 
  
  
   10 2 
  + O   2  
 /    

&&

" 
    
   
 
  1  

 3
 - 3
F7996G+

12

  
           <
2     B   
 +

=          2  4;       2  42;     
 
  
/        
  

      /               2  


    2  2    +.


  


       


 +   /- 


          4  -;  + "   
                    -+ .  

             



 
   4      4  E  ;  B    
4  ;;+.          FI:G  *
 
    
      
 
   !   
 

"

  #

.        4&;          , !      


                  45;      +   
     
 4$ ;            
    
   

    


 $  
 +@/
  
4H$ ; 


   4   ; 


  2    
  A &5+"SF'9G   
      

  B    *
% 
  %  
%   %   & 

.  -/                    '( $

)  * ,*+   


 E     
 += 
&5=A 
-
 

    

A        

+

13

 -/  


  /   
    +(F'CG  


4"(@;

-,
*


. -,

$

8
45 65 -78

0 1  

23


1 9 1)  0 : ) ; 

 
  
4H$ ;(!  
  < /
. =<>< *
B

 


?<@AB -,


$ C0 1 

23
 D 1

)+

)+

)+

9 E N) 1)  0 : E N) 0 )  E N) $  N) :  G) $  H  I

(!   "(@                  

    
  + /(! "(@  /
#       (!           B+ .
   4&5';     
   
  

?@AB        


          + . B  J
 K,*+ N) $  4:;   J    
 

  
+

  
  
  (! 
"(@  + @/          
     
 
    
   /  -           
 
 

+ O   
      
    
 
(!   "(@       B 
 
/+ " B 
  (! H$ 
     

LM

   "(@

M

 /      

  - 4(<;+O /  


    
   /
 2             
   
 
    (! "(@  

 

 

   +@ 
     

14

(!   "(@    //   / &'+ 3


 -   3
 F95G    
  /       /             
-
 
  


 
+@  

(! "(@ 



  

 
      

/  
       +.      
    10    1   + .
   
       

     +

$ 
                  
 

/   
    
 Q 1 R Q 12 
 R&>+



 

A
F5'G 
  1   2  B 
1           +O 
      
    

            


+ 


/3
 - 3
F9&G//        

13

. B  


         

    /   F'G <   -


F:>G+. 
   B  

  
 

         
     

      4B 
     

  <
F59G-F9G3
 - 3
F96G 3
 
F9:G+ 3
 -   3
 F95G     B  
   
        
 +
14

" 
   A
F5'G Q 1 R  ( F''G FCG  

(    F'>G  


Q 1R    

 Q 1R2 
 3
 - 
3
F9'G
  102 
 +
15

<   


 
 - A
F5'G+

15

   /     #  + .      
 
45; 
/*

N 
OP    QRS  
 M  OP   T 

(     /    B  



U  OP U  

  +"  B   B   



       
V

 
/S4  $ S    MS  
   P
 MWXN 
OP   Y


. 1 B   *
  Z [ 
P  C  D      9 P


3
 - 3
F9&G  
   
 P  
P    

 1 +     2     


 / 
  B        
          
2  2 + 
<
 2  
 A

F5'G 
    B 
        
 D    
         -+  
    1    
 1   

U   *

P U  TX\]0  H ^  P


 9 U Y _ 

3    


    
  

      +(  

 
      /  U:      
     1    E  
   +


 

  

    
    2 
       3
 -   3
 F95G
  
  
/  *
+

        


+

16


+  
  -,
$ C)  ) Z)+   
    



  
    4 ;    
 /  
 
  S    /  +   
 ` 
 %  % a  %  ^

+ O           f t    
   
2 


 A   +


"

/ 3
 -   3
 F9'G +':I      S      
 



  *


b U  U $ cd 9 U   : U e Qfg  h

.   


 / S   /-


 (<U  U .     


 

     
   B    +$
                  
   

 
- /        4 
   3
 -   3

F9'G+':I;+


8/ b , 


      /*

%   
 $ ijk%  
b%   %    

.
 12 
       *
%l   $ ijk%  
b  %   %   " m 4&&;
.
 12 
  *





l $ %l    %l   
    # 

<
" n<o p q    <r
o =><   



 2 49;  *

17

`
`
t , U  U
-F`
s
$ R E u* 9 U  * : U
*  *  -F`
&
*+

/V4W;    +8/ n<o p q  


 X4WW;
t w , D=yxy z 

/*
/v


`
t ,  %   %
-F`
  $ ijkC%  Ds
%{l,
  " m Z ;

3
 - 3
F95G    |{`}F` 0 1     

   E    


012 
       
/ 

+0U  1U   



%~ % /
 -

`
`
t F |
t 

ws
U  | 1U D-F` z  "  wsF | U  | 1U D-F` z  " 


  %{l, U  U       + 3
 -   3
 F9'G   

       


   4&;     
   
  

  

        


 
    1 + .
   0            
  2 
    
   + 3 B   /  
       / 


0U6+9   
 +3 3
F9>G"!$
 
 
1             +

 
    
 
3
 - 3
F9'G   /   

 
 %l *L  *L M%l *  * ^  
 
   /
  
     


  
    4&;     45;
01
2 
    &   5+   

           
        +"2 
      
  //  & 5 

 *


18

l   L $

* ,  



,  
%l *L  *L
I 


%l *  *

3l   L     /  & 5

  
 
  012 
    &   5+ 3 4& 5;       

B     ,   L   +




<
2   B       B "S
F>6G//  & 5 

       

               (! "(@ %$(!$<  
  

 012 
+<
2   B  &C*
Yl   L $ * ,

 

458 658
. 
8

458 658
. 

458 658
. 
8

458 658
. 

L , 8 8

T 

. B   4  ;     &5
   4  2 4&C;; 
 

4       2  4&C;;+  
   3
 -   3
 F9'G 
    
           / /  "S   F>6G+ "
     -  / B      012 
     

                     
   
  + Yl   L  Z& /
           Yl   L  [&
   
+

(   
3 

  &97C56&&+.   
   
   /
               #   

16

" 
3
 - 3
F9'G'C&+

19

         1    


E  + %    
 
   
 
    
    +3B  D  

 
  
/-   
 

    B&I+.     
  
 &7 B  
&9  
    B  56     
  
B  /  - 
5&+$

B  
 
B /

 

  
  ( 
 
  B /

  B+

     /-/

  
      &97C  &99C+ "    /       
 
 /  

 -   <      3


 - F9CG  
 -" !B 

4  
 ; 
   - F>'G+ "        
    /  


 /
    /    
  /+ "    &9951C   

 / // 
 

  /- +


.

/   /-/ 


 -
     + 
 F&5G          
 

/   B 
5:N/-/ 

17

%   

2   
  F&6G . -   - 

F7CG+
18

    


 1   /-+3   +"  


/   - -+
  B/
 
 +%   
 
$  FC:G+
19

20

8B  
      
+%    
  F&6G+
" 
       :6N  +3

/ 


 . AFI'G  


    +
21

.   


 
 . AFI'G    &7N  +

20


  -    /       
+ (
  / / 
/      
+@  &9951C 
 /-       

    
    /-     
      /- /     
  - \ 5:N 
  /-+ "    /    * &97C &99&   &99C+ .


      * &97C    N  
    &97C19&
 &99&1C
+(



 
 &99I/ /
  + .  / 

     


      /
  + .         /- 

    /    
  /- +

.
5/         +
-

/  
 +.
 
 /
  
    B
   

     
  >6I /  
    
   B    + O     
   
  / 
-
      
           
  4 ;      + 3           
 012 


    /        
 / 
/   
+
F.
5 G

)   

" /       
          
 "(@  
(!   4.
 ';?   
 

  
   Q"!$R / 
3
F9>G55+3       


  
 D   + 3               
55

3
3

 2   
 2  

"!$
 +

21

      /


        

  
  5'. /"(@       
   
   
       B     1     
          
 A /        + H
    
 
       

 

       4  
;+.(! /B 
'N  
  1 
4&97C19&;   CN       4&995156&&;     E  
/    'NCN  +
      
     
             4&995197;+ .    
4566I1&&; /                 &995197   
   1  +.(!
  
 

 /        

    (!  E  


   4  B  
 5N      1     
 ;+.   / (!  
  
 B     +
F.
' G

8B/      
4 1 ;    
5>+O  
      
    B    +3    

     
B    +=-.
' 


5'

3      



     
1 

  +


24

3     1      U:+3
B  / U>

        B + (       ?   
  
     +

22

Q%$(!$<R   
              + "    
  1     
Q%$(!$<R 
  
   B   B      +
 
   
B   B +.  
  1    /   
   +.

56N

  &6N 566I156&&+. 


      (! +

. (!   "(@   
  2 
     

  
 A   
/
 +OB 
  /1  
 /     B   /  (! /      
 1
2 
           
+ .       

      
&6N   
   
 + . 
  B 
 'N    &99517+ .        

              + .   5+:N>N  &&+CN
&99556&&&99956&& 566I56&& 
5:+%  
 
 
 +3 1  
   # :IN 2    &+7   4&E6+:C7:; 
4  
;
    0U6+9 2 
  
  
  + O  
     I&N    &E6+I&U&+>    
 
  0U6+92 


 +@   
/ 
   
   5C+
5:

.   


          +O

     / /                    
 2 
 #   /  +@ /



    +
26

%    0


2 
6+9+ 3
B  / 0
6+76+7:  6+7I+

.        B + !       

  

 
   
  ?   
   
 +

23

"  5 


         
 
  012 
     

    + 3               
 +
-    / &97C19:  /
    &99C /  
 566I         B +
!      

 566I56&&     




    +] 



   
         + H           
 
     
   /-
      + H      / 

  
  
     


/
   &99I/ +
F" 5 G

.    
  

   


 
  /  
 / 4 
 
   ;+ 8B /        /    

  
                + . 
   B  
  " '+.    &99&15 


 
^ D+ 3 

/        41    ;+ . B
      / /       1    
    4


 ^D;+.  4


 ^ 
 D;
 //  
   4 / ; 
/
 &99&195 2 
/ +

" '
 / &995  /   
 1     B   &97C+ 3             

   
      &99'  566I     566I    /  

    +8
 / 

 719N

24

   
    / &995   56&&+        B   
      
 +(  &99C5665
    /

          

 +%

 B  >N     


 +  
      /             +  
 &99: D    
 B     +
F" ' G

.
 >        <
2      
  
 5I+3 

  /+<




  &              &       
 + =-       B      
 45N;   1
  /B &977+(    B  

 
>56 /

5+&N /
 /     4&995156&&;+.566I
     B 
  /   
   &>+CN    
 

  
 /-+O/B
566I   
 4 
5+9N &995156&& >+>N/ 
&99956&&;+

8B/B      E 
    

4  012 
;+"
-1  /
    
      1     / 

   

27

3           


 2 
 

      


   / 0 U 6+9+ (        0        /D
 /
B  /0U6+7+.    B+B   /
  D 
      
   
   4E;   +

25

          


 
 57 4    
 5N 
 6+CN /
       &+>N  
;+3
 

 
 /+" / &99&15 '+:N
 /
      +. 
  


   
 

          + $


   
 

       # 
/ 

 / /    
 4      ;+ "  
   
   B   
  &6N 
            
2 

 4    1'+:N    


 1C+&N;+ .    >   
  /

/  

A      


 
 + 
    
   2 


&996 
5666   B    
&97C19&+


F.
> G


"       /     B       
     
4 
5+&N &+CN/
      
   6+:N    59;+ "      &+CN
    '6 /     
        46+CN;  
57 % 
1

 
 /  $F:G/  &N

  

  +
59

O   


 
 
FI&G;/    
 

     


   
 
   + H
/          
   
$FCIG$  " FC>G  
 . AFI'G  
     
     A
     . -+ O


  / 
      +
'6

  
! F'7G+O   

    


  
  

    F59G      )   


 +
O               
   - FI6G /    

 !
  3
/ / 2 
 #  ." 

26

 
45+5N;'&+.
 
 
   
        / 

 /   1         
B /&995 56&&+" 
  B  
&+>N
              2 

 4    6+IN  


 
 6+IN;+ .                /
     &996 
5666/

   2 


 

   /


     +  
       /  
 2 

&996 
5666     I+:N
/         
   
 
    4:+&N;  
       5+:N+ .      
      

/  /
  +

. 
  / 1    
/ 1 *&99517 
      &999
56&&+ %

      /


             
B   /
 4.

>;+ "     &99& / B      
  >N   
&99517  
  /    +.

          
  /   F5&G     $ 
    +

8B/  D 
  / / 
                
    4   

 +. 
  
  
   

   /
2  +    


     
       
          + @  
          
+         
/  $F:G;/'156N +
'&% /


 
 
FI&G+

27

             
      
  ;  B
   E   +.

  B      .
 :+     /
     

 /   4 
;   
 
+ .   
 
   B 
    E   
 /
      
4/; +
F.
: G

/     
/ 
  
/ 4
;B4
B;    
4   /@ 
O B;+@ 
     
B  /

    4
 
  _;    '5+ .  
  4
(4 ;;     /4   ;;  ''+
.         4      B  
   4 ;  
 
  4 ;        
  #  4 B;;+  
   
 4;                 
  +


'5
@@O/
 

 - 


 /  


   B      


+ @    
  @@O /

      
 + 8 -

FC6G    


     /

 
     + FIG
  

             B     /   
     /-
   +@  
 
 //
        +% 

  B
 
 
 . AFI'G+/F5:G
 
 @@O


 /  +
''

% 
       / 
 
 . AFI'G+

28

.B
    B  4B ;   
4 ; 
     + (    - $  4-+ $+;
  B  /
        +
         
 4  
 2 
     
&995 / ;            &995      1
  + 
 
 
 4
 ;             
 /  /  
  
/      
 
 

  +

*   
.    / B  

      
 &976     &996+ .     

B
   
         
 

  +@/   

  -  /
 +.(! 1   

      +"2  
  
 
B
   

/
 Q 
-
R+.
B
 

/+$ 
 
 
/   B    (!      

  
   - 
 
 + .        
 /      
   
 A  1  (!+

8/   
  1    
12 

        B 
        
      
4      ;   
  
 + .     
 
   
1     
12 
 3
 - 3
F7996G 


    
          -    + .  

 1  
    +. 

29

       


 
 
 +%
     
   
      

/+ @           
   
     
     
     

E    +

3 
-    B     
   

/ +@// 


 
        + .       /     
 
 
/+.    &999566I/    
            / 
    
   
#  /
 B 
 +3
  
    

  / 
    
 +


30

+ 
F&G  + ) $+    B   -*  
  
/+O
  -* 
(
 
 O 4 (O;?&99:+
F5G + . 
      /  +   <+*


?&97C+
F'G  (+ =

 )+    + "


         
     
+ 
!   &9II?C4&;*5&1'I+
F>G 
1%  <+ !      A   
  + 
 
!   5665?'>4&;*&&&1&&I+
F:G   )+ $ <+ .      A+ O
 $/ 
" 

566I?&C4>;*':>`'CC+
FCG  + (  + . 1 + 8     *   

2 
1  +!   .566:?5&45;*':7`'79+
FIG+) - +< (+%/    
+ 
 !   5667?'C4';*>971:69+
F7G- !+@
$+       
     
+ +
  /+O
!   $/&97>?5:4';*C>I1CC5+
F9G-+
 

$+=/
+]   !
       +$/
!      &99I?I94>;*:5I1:'9+
F&6G   +O  B 

  (! /-* 
 
      O     +  
   %
 $ 
 56&&?C549;*&C5&1&C'I+
F&&G 
 + @ !+ %/    * 
     
 
 1   +$/!      566:?7I4&;*&':1&>I+
F&5G
)+  
  -+O
= %A
4O=%; /A
 ?&997+
F&'G  .+  <@+  
  +    

       *


 

  + 
  &9I9?'>4&;*::1C>+

31

F&>G<$+)+ )  *
 B +3

(
 &979?&I4:;*C>'1C:I+
F&:G   !+ H $+ %/          * 
         B     
  +  
  =/  
!   &979?'54&;*&1''+
F&CG -8++(A B  
  a
       + 
 !  5665?&&4 +&;*&&&`
&>6+
F&IG  - 8+ +     %+ A         
 * 1

  +  1"  
566>?&54&;*C:196+
F&7G -8++   %+A  *

/       +  
 " 
 !   566:? IC45;*'C91
'99+
F&9G    < + - (+ .       
      )
A +
 !   &99I?594';*59I1'&6+
F56G  - <+ 
 + H $3+    + 3- + @ 
?&99'+
F5&G / (+ !
  + .
  + .      A*
 

    @  $  $    -+  
  
 
 !   566C?
&&>4&;*C&199+
F55G   + ( $ - + ( + .     
    
 +  
   (
56&'?:I4&;*'>91'C'+
F5'G A
 + "
 +   =+ 8     *     +
 
!   5665?&6C4&;*&`5:+
F5>G+"<+$ %+@D 
      

  %!a! <-$/566C?I751&69+
F5:G/!3+A   
  *        
<
/+ (
 $/566&?&'45;*5IC1'6I+

32

F5CG / !3+ O         A  <
/ 

 
   +. 
O 
!   566>?:545;*5II1579+
F5IG 

 .+ <


 + $  + !  
1       
  
+% 56&>?>5&&:I1&C:+
F57G - +    + .         
  +
 
(
   5667?>>49;*&'>5`&':'+
F59G  $+ < = )$+        2    
 



  +.$/!      &99C?I745;*':91C>+
F'6G

)+ (3+    


   )
 
+
 !   566'?':4';*5:&15CI+
F'&G

)++3.+.
/A (! 
       +  
!       566:? :I4:;*>''1
>C5+
F'5G (D  A + < 3+ $ 8+ !    
    1  
  1A  *!    
   + 

" 566:?&&4:;*I>I`ICC+
F''G (  + 8   
            
       
2 
++(+(+  $  
 !   <b 2   ]  b     
 .
  O 
=  2 
bb
 .
 OOO?566'+
F'>G (  +   =+ 8      
* 
  
 2 

 + 
!   566I?&>645;*'I:`>66+
F':G(+  =+O  

    
*

  + 
 
566:?5>4&;*9'`&5&+
F'CG ( (+   =+ .
- @+ < 
       +  
     
  *         +<+ <   +  
 @+.
-   *81@

 ?&97>*5>'`5CI+

33

F'IG( <+ +


 
 
   
  A  -
 
 +% 56&>?>CI>17:+
F'7G! +<
 +=  .+3 A   a!  
 D A
D
/+3
(
 5665?'64&&;*&77:1&79I+
F'9G"S$+- +=

)+.      +*


)
/18# 
?&97:+
F>6G "S $+ - + =  +   $ +   
   / 

*  <
2      R  ( !
 
*   

  
   + + 3+ 3+ ++ =/  =+ <+   (  *
)
/    &99>+
F>&G "J  !+  c + OdeA <+ %    - -     1
/   A*   B + O
 $/  " 


566I?&C4>;*'CI1'79+
F>5G 

   =+ .  + H
 O+ 3
 2    

  
 
+3(++*.3
-?&99>+
F>'G    - 8
 (
  "   48(";+  
 +) -?&99&+
F>>G@+ `  A  A $ 
 + 

" 
$ 566&?5>4&;*&&9`'&+
F>:G @   3+ @ "8+   @+ <      
     
          /1(!  
./+
% 56&>?>7>91:9+
F>CG@ =3++O  A 
 *   + 

!       56&6?745;*&''`&:C+
F>IG@ K+3)+
 A     *   
+!   $/56&&?554&;*&5&1&'5+

34

F>7G @/ 8+  +  + = @ +  (+ 
    

/
   
 *"     

 +% 56&'?>&'::'1::7+
F>9G  - + = + )  +  =-f 
  *  1 1 A
 + 
O
(
 566'?&:4C;*I5I1I>:+
F:6G  (+ <  8+ %/       *      !+
$/(
 !   5665?C45;*57>`'6&+
F:&G = 3+ L  =+ .     A       
   
   /
+ 
=/ !   566>?>I45;*'9:1>'6+
F:5G <  O+   # 3+ .    A       /

A    -+! <-$/566I?745;*&'>`&>C+
F:'G </ )+ $-     
      -*  /-
(! /-+% 56&'?>&556I15&:+
F:>G< 3 -+!    1( 
   /
  +O
!   $/&9II?&745;*>':1>>>+
F::G<3=+8$$  H<+. 
 
  
/
  *
  

+. 
" &99>?L=OL
45;*>6'1>:5+
F:CG < 

 @+< <  (+ $


  
     AA
  -+  
 
- " &99'?&I451';*'79`>6:+
F:IG8   +A  +% <+.  /
A  
  
<!8  * . 
  /       

A 
 +
O
$/" 

566I?&C4>;*''51':'+
F:7G828@) 
$+. 
 -+.-
(
 $/&99&?'645;*&6:1&>>+
F:9G828@) 
$+    
 -+OQ@/ 
/-a! H+H+$   R+= *
$ 
 ?&99I+

35

FC6G8 -

 +     + 



 
  &99C?
&6>4>;*I5>1I>C+
FC&G%-+)+. A  */ A/-a
3
(
 566C?'>49;*&:'I1&::C+
FC5G
+A  
   /
 2  * 
fO!
   4O!;+3
(
 &999?5I45;*'>'1'C6+
FC'G$ +++   O 
 * 

+% 56&>?>>:71C9+
FC>G $  <+ "  =+ A       A
 
   * 
  
 +
 !   =5665?94&5;*75'175C+
FC:G $   $+ % + .

 $+ !   


  /
     
   
  *
  
 
   
  
  +!
 56&5?>>*&>6`&:5+
FCCG $ 8+ (  + <    B
        
 
 
/ 

    +% 56&'?>&>C:'1CC>+


FCIG $ <+ .  
        *  1   
  +!!   566&?5'4';*59:1'6>+
FC7G 
( +-(+.   
/ /
   !
    3
*  
      + <
   ( 
!   5666?5&4C;*5:'15C7+
FC9G 
( +-(+ g    3g /
   !
  g 3
+ $    E   
 $ 
O 5666?59*'7+
FI6G 
( +-(+     A / /
 !
  3
+ 
$
!   566&?564&;*C&196+
FI&G 
 ( +- (+3 1 .+ (        
 
     
  /A !
 3

/ / *&97:`5666+ 
 
566I?574&;*&5I1&'9+

36

FI5G  +  +%     #  


 `(
(!
 
  a% 56&>?>I&1&C+
FI'G 
 +. A!+A/   
   . -
  +
 
  !   566&?I54>;*:7&1C6:+
FI>G

 3+ $          8/ K


  
  
  
  +
 
 
&999?&&45;*&''1&>I+
FI:G   $3+ .         +  *   
?&9I6+
FICG   =+ 3
 3+  
      * /   
    
+<   &997?>>4&&;*>9`C&+
FIIG  =+3
3+  
 /"E@  + 

!  
&999?&&4&;*CI`76+
FI7G  =+3
3+%  / (! h   a
=  /
-+ 
!  
&999?&&4&;*9'`9I+
FI9G  =+3
3+
  
    
 
+ 

   5666?5I4C;*II9`765+
F76G  =+3
3+  
     
*
+ 
!  
5666?&'4&;*>9`I7+
F7&G   =+ 3
 3+ .           
+
    566&?'64&;*&:9`&7>+
F75G   =+ 3
 3+ 
  i 
 ^D  !   (+!++R  =
<  i 
 !   
         + i
A <  * i   566&+
.
Q  (!!  O 
R
( 8+6665O   2 i
2  = = 1
18 
 +566&+
F7'G   =+ 3
 3+ 81         
+ !   
 
%
$ 5665?&'94&;&&:1&'5+

37

F7>G . )+ .   <+ (   (! / /-   *  
 -1   
 +% 56&>?>5&&5>1&'&+
F7:G .A + @ 3+  A       *     

     4 
;.$ *
    
566:?'94:;*>6:1>5>+
F7CG.- )+ - (+    B*B 

-   +
 !   566:?'I4';*5I9159&+
F7IG .P
 @+ -  $$+  
 + ./   
   /
/ 
# 
-`
      
 

+% 56&:?:&&&15'+
F77G H


 + A     *  /     
 

A
     + 
!   g%A5666?>54&;*
>'1I>+
F79G 3 K+ H
 %+ (D  A + @ <)+ .  
       
D/
  +" 
< 566'?'545;*&6I1&5C+
F96G3
 -(+3
3+8/    
   B + +
  
-+ 
<!   566&?>I4';*C:'1CI>+
F9&G 3
 - (+   3
 3+ $  1          
  
 + +   
-+3-+" 
$- += +
566'8 +
F95G 3
 - (+ 3
 3+ 81     
 2 
   
  
/
 " 
$  - + 

!   5667?>:4&15;569155:+
F9'G 3
 - (+ 3
 3+ $     2 
        
    + +   
 - &97:`566>+  
    g !   
 5669?5I4';*':>1'C7+
F9>G 3
 3+ "!$*  /  -      
+  1!   

  5667?>54>;*5>I15:>+

38

F9:G3
3+)+8  
  
   B 
+ +
+ 

 !   566>?&94>;*:6:`:5>+
F9CG 3
 -+    
    A #      + O
  
-* 
$?&97C+
F9IGKL+K .+ @+O      1     
A  +.!  56&5?>:4:;*:619&+




39

# ,    ,


   -%  
.     
!///



  

 




 



  

   



 


     

% 

  

&''    

, 

. ) ) ''   

 
-FI6G

 

  !"

# !

() *"

!+ !

  


 
   $ 
,'  

   
/ 0!#"
& )
#"
6
,  +"

7) 2"
( 
#+"
8 9"

+ 

,'  

/1 

-
  
  

2 

/   


,'  

-
  
  

5    

# !

% 3
40 
&  

 

 
40 
  
/ 

    

 
: 
  

-
  
  

-   ''   

() * "

!+ !

,'  

, 

  

4 
. "
/0
."
( 
#"
4
*"

 

,'  

5 

  

/ 
   
/ 
   
,'  

: 

  

: 

<1 
%  "

# 

,'  

 ;
. ;

1 ;
 
/1 

-
  
  

%
$ "
!"

 #

,'  

  

,'  

%'  
!"

!  
+
*++

*++2
* 
2
*++*


*+++

*++#

  

-) ''   

&''      

  0    


 ''   
5  '   
. ) ) ''      0;
     
$  ' )
)       
       
 ''   
      
 ''   
 '' '  0 
  

  

5$  



  

5  

& )
:)
 

  

-     

  

=  ' $  )


$   

40



  !"  #
$ 
 !

%


 &


    '  

<  

,  >

2+!

*>2

#*+>#

 >

*2+#> #

( 

,  >

2+!

*#>

*+2>2

2>#

2+>2

8$

-$

2+!

! >

2*>+

+

*+

,  

,  >

2+!

*#>*2

 !> 

*>2

2*>*

7

,  >

2+!

!#

*>*

>2 

>



( )  

  
! !*"" !
!* 

?

7=. 

7=.

=&% 

=&%

=&%)

<=&,  <=&,

+> ! 

>+ !

+>! *

@
@
A
%-/  A
%-/

@ 
A
%-/)

>2**

+>!+ 

+>

+> 

 ' 


 

>+++! +> >+##

 ' 


* 

>++ # +>*! >+ * 

+>#

>+#*

+>! 

>**+

+>!2!

>+*2

+>!+

* 

>++# +># >+

+>#

>+2

+>!!2 

>* 

+>!*!

+>

+> #!

 

>++  +> ! >+2

+>2# 

>+* 2

+>! 

>*#

+>##2

>+2#

+>!*

 + 

>++  +>2 >+22

+># 

>+*

+>! 

>+#+

+>*#

>++

+>!!

*++! 

>+++ +>  >+#

+>++

>+**

+>!2

>#**

+>+2

> +

+>!+

41

>+!*
+>
>+*
>+2 
>++*
+>!
>+!
+>!
>+
+>
>++
+>
+>#
+>*
+>!+
+>
+>2+
+>! 
>+##
+> 
>2 
+>!+
+>22
+>#
+>+
>+*+
+>!
+>!
+>
+> 


  


8*+B
566I+

!


+

*
#
2

 
!


*+++
*++
*++*
*++#
*++2
*++
*++ 
*++!
*++
*++
*++
*+
 
* *+

* *+ 
* 

 *+ 




>+2
+>
>+*
>+#
+> 
>+ 
>+#
>+*
+>!*
+>2
>+
>++*
>+++
>+2
+>2
>+2!
+>2!
>+#2
+>!2
+>2
>+ 2
>++
+>#!
+>#
>+#+
>++ 
+>
+>*
>++
+> 

>+*#
+>!
>++2
>+
>+#
+> #
+>*
+>2
>+2
>+*
+>
+>
+>#
+>2+
+> 
+>2
+>#
+>22
>+ 
>+22
>+!!
+> 
>++!
>+2!
+>!
>+2
+>2
+>!
+>!
+> 

 
     


>
+>#
>+2#
>++!
>+2
>+!+
>+#!
>+#*
>+*+
>+#
>+2#
>+22
+>**
+>
+>#+
>++ 
>+*
>+#
>+*+
+> 
>++ 
+>2
+>#2
+>2!
+>#
>+##
+>2
+>#
>+2+
+>

>*!
+>2*
>++
+>
+>
>*!
>+ 
>+#
+>!
+>
+>#
>+*
>+
+>
+>2
>+!#
>+#
>+! 
+>!
+>*
+>! 
>+ 
+>*
+>!+
>+!
>+#
>++ 
>++!
>+#
+>+

+>* 
+>*
>+##
>+*+
>+*#
+>+
+>!+
+>
>+
>+#2
>+
+> 
+>#
+>
>+2
+>#
+>!
+> *
>+ 
>+#
>+#
+>##
>++ 
>+!
+>
+>
+>!
+>! 
>++*
+> 

  
8668

        



>+
+>+
>+
>* *
>+ 2
+>!
>+
+>!+
+>
>+*
>+*
>+
+> 
>+*
>+#*
+> 
+>2!
+>#!
>+#
>++ 
>+!+
+>2+
+>2#
>+##
+>*
>+
+> 
+>
>++*
+>!+


  

+>
>++2
>+*2
>* 
+>*!
+>**
>**
>+ 
+> 
+>+
>+#
>++
+>!2
>++
>+
>++!
+>*#
>++
+> *
>++*
+>2#
+>#2
+> 
>++
>+!*
>+#
+>#
+> 
+>+
+>

 

  

>
+> 
+>
+>!
>2
+>!*
+>
+>2
+>
>* 
+>
>+2
+>
+>#
+>!
+>
>+* 
+>*
>+! 
>++2
>#
+>
+>!#
>+*#
+> *
>+ 
+>#
+> 
>+
+>!

>+2
+>2 
>+#*
+>2
+> 
+>*
+>
+>2
>#!
+>*
+>
+>*#
>++
+>#!
+>!!2
>+2









>++*
+>*

+>##


   
  


>+ 
+>2 
>+*
+>!
+>+
+>2!
+>2
+>
+> 
+>2
+>
+>2 
>+ 
+>*#
+>+
>*++









+>!
+>!

+> +


+>2
>+++
>++ 
>+*+
>++ 
+>!#
+> 
+>
>+
+>+ 
+>*!
+>!
+>2
+>+!
+> +
+>!









>++
+>2

+>!*


 !
     




+,!  !  * 
   
#-
 ./
 !01 

 2034567

42

+>+*!

+>+2+

+>+#

+>+*

+>+ 

+>++

+>+2

+>+ 

+>+*

'

''

$ 

B



B)

 

 *

 

+>

+>*2 

+>#+

+>#2

+># #

+>##*

+>##

+>#2

+>##

+>###

+>+

+>+

>+++



+>+

+>22

+>#+

+>2#

+>2+ 

+> 

+>* 

+>+

+>2 

+>*

+>2

>+++

B 

+>+ 

+>+# 

+>+!

+>2!*

+>22

+>!#

+>!

+>!*

+> 2!

+>!# 

>+++

)) C

+>2

+>2#+

+>2!

+>*

+>

+>

+>!2

+> 

+>**

>+++



+>2*

+>+

+>+

+>#

+>#+

+>

+>2!

+>*

>+++

'

+>2+#

+>22

+>*

+> 

+>+ 

+> 

+>#

>+++

''

+>#*

+>2 !

+>*2

+>!

+>

+>+

>+++

$ 

+>#*

+>##

+>2#

+>#

+>

>+++

B

+>+

+> 

+>!! 

+>!

>+++



- D $B 


,E     B
7 F  G
B &B F   1F>GG
)) C.' )5BFB ' $')' G
D'  F>$  G
','    BF$H++G
''I' B ' F1>>,  G
$ $    F1>>,  G
BI  B F1>>,  G
 F,  G
B)&B) F1>>JKG
 7  F  
KG
 *=  $H'    J  F*G;+ ) 
   $   $ $'   >,  $  

+>++*

+>+!*

B 



+>+# 



)) C

>+++

+>+2#





# (       

+>2! 

+> #!

+>!

>+++

B)

+>2+

+>*2

>+++

 

+>#

>+++

 *

>+++

 

43

. ,   


 
+> +
+>2+
+>*+
+>++
+>++
+>+ +
+>+2+
+>+*+

)) C

)) C 

*+

*++

*++

*++

*++!

*++

*++

*++2

*++#

*++*

*++

*+++





!





2

#

*



+





!

+>+++

)) C

8*
_*.

@ 
O B
_*.
@ 
O B
_ *  
   @ 
O B


. !0 
  1  2$3   
4  

>+++

+>++

+>++

+>++

+>++

+>+!+
+>+ +

+> ++
+>++
+>++
+>+2+
+>2++

D 

&''  

+>!++

+>+#+

+>#++

+>+*+

+>++

+>++

+>+++

+>+++

!


+

*
#
2


!


*+++
*++
*++*
*++#
*++2
*++
*++
*++!
*++
*++
*++
*+

+>*++

?

I&<,%/5(














,&=5%-

%5/.,&/5(

D%5%-(&

44

. "0 
  1  2$3  -% 

+>++
+>++
+>!++
&''  

+> ++
+>++
+>2++
+>#++
+>*++
+>++

!


+

*
#
2


!


*+++
*++
*++*
*++#
*++2
*++
*++
*++!
*++
*++
*++
*+

+>+++

  0

?
  

$ 

45


 '
   "
! !*"" !
!* 


 
 
!


+

*
#
2

 
!


*+++
*++
*++*
*++#
*++2
*++
*++ 
*++!
*++
*++
*++
*+
 
* 
* 
 
 + 
*++! 

@ A
%-/)

@ A
%-/)

@ A
%-/)

<=&, 

<=&,

@H+>+
+>2#
+>
+>+ 
+>*+
+>#
+>*
+>22
+>2!!
+>
+>2
+> 
+>2
+>!#
+>
+> * 
+> 
+> *
+>2
+> #
+>!
+> +
+>*
+>2*
+>!
+>2!2
+> +
+>2 
+>
+>*
+>!2
+> +*
+>#*

@H+>
+>*
+>
+>+ 
+>*+
+>#
+>*
+>+#
+>*
+>2
+>2
+> 2
+> #*
+> *2
+> #
+> !#
+>

+>!+
+> 
+> #
+>  
+> *+
+> *
+>!
+>*
+>#2
+> +
+> 
+> +
+> 
+> #2
+> 2
+>

@H+>!
+>*
+> 
+> 
+>!
+>#
+>!
+> #
+>*
+>!
+> 
+> 2
+> #*
+> *2
+> #
+> !#
+>

+>!+
+> 
+> #
+>  
+> *+
+> *
+>!
+>*
+>#2
+>!!
+> 
+> *!
+> +
+> 2*
+> 2
+> +

H2
+> *
+>!*+
+>!+
+>! 
+>!#!
+>!2
+>!*+
+>!#+
+>!#
+>!*+
+>!!
+>!
+>!2
+>!#
+>!#
+>!*
+>!2
+>!*
+>! 
+>!2
+>!#*
+>!*
+> !
+> !!
+> 
+>!2#
+>!*
+>!*
+>!#!
+>!*#
+>!#
+> 

H2
> *
>!!
>#*
>2+
>+#
*>+
*>2
>!2
>#2
>2*
>*#
>2*
>*+2
>*+ 
>22
>*2
>+ 
>*
> 
># 
>!*
>2!
>*!
>2* 
>2*
>* 
>2+
>#2
>!+
>*22
>2
>2*



46

8*+B
566I


  
!
>2

+> +

>+*
+
>+*

>++ 
*
+>+
#
>+*!
2
>++

+>
 
+> 
!
+>!*

>+++

+>#
*+++
+>!
*++
+>#
*++*
+>! 
*++#
+>*
*++2
+> #
*++
+>!
*++ 
+>!
*++!
>+!2
*++
+> !
*++
+>*
*++
+>#
*+
+>
 
>+#2
* *+
+>!#

* *+ 
+> 
* 
+>

 *+ 
+>




 
     
>
+>
+>! 
+>2
>+*
+>#
+>!
>+ 
+>!
>++
>+*
+> +
>+
+>!!
>+!
+>2
+>#+
>+!2
+> 
>+#*
+>
+>!
+> 
>+# 
>+**
+>##
>+ 2
+>*+
+>
+>#
+>+
+> 
+>* 
>++2
>+*
+>*
+>2
>+# 
+> 
>+
+>
> 
>+2
+>2
+>*!
>+
+>**
>+!
>+*
+>!#
>+* 
>++
+>2
+>
+>!
+>+
+>!
>+++
+>
+> 

  
8668

        
>**
>#+
+>2*
+>#!
+> 
+> !
>+2
>+2
>++2
>++2
+># 
>+!2
+> 
+>#
+>*
>+ 
>+ 
+> 2
>+#
>+!
+> 
>+ 
>#
+> 
+> 
+>!
>*
>+#
>+ *
+>
+> 2
+>!
+>#
+>
+>!
>+*
+>
>+ 2
+>!
+> 
+>2
+>!
>++
+>
>+*
+>#
+>2
>+
+>!
+>*
+>!
>+ !
>*
+>*
+> 
+> !
>
+>*
+>!
+>
+>2!
+>##
>#
+>
+>#
+>
>+ 
+>!+
>**
+>*
+>*+
>++
+> 
>+ 
+>
>+# 
>+2
+>
+>#
+>!
+>!
+>
+> 
+>+
>+*
>+*
>++#
+> 
+>!
+>*

  
>2# 
>+*
>+
>*+
>+!
+>+ 
>+!
>+
+>*
>+!+
+>*
>+ 
>+*
>+#
+> 
+>#
+># 
+>
+>2
+> 2
>++
+>2 
+> !
+>
+>
>2
+>!
+>!!
>++ 
+> 

 

  
>*# 
>++!
>+2#
>*#
>+ !
+>+
>*
>+*
+> 
+>!
+>*
>+*#
>+#2
>##
+>2#
>+! 
+>+!
+>2+
+>!
+>#!
+>2
>++ 
+> 
>+++
>+
>+*
+> 
+>2
+>
+>!
   
  
> *
>+2
>+2
+>22
+>!!
>+**
>2
>++2
>+*
+>*
+>2
+>*
+>!
+> 2
+>+
+>#
+>#*
>2*
>**
+>#*
>+#*
+> +
>+##
+>2
+>*
>+
+> 
+>+*
>+2 
+>!!+
+>*#
>++
>+#*

+>!

+>!

>+*

>

+>2

>++ 

+>

+> 

>+!
>++
+>#
+>#*
+>2

>+!
+>2
+> 2




 '9
   ",!  !  * 
   
#-
 .0345:7
 !
     
># 
+> #
+> !
+>!
>+*2
+>
+>#
>+2
+>!
>++2
+>2
+>!
+>!#
+>+
>+!!
+>*
+>2#
>**
+>!!
+>2
>+#2
+>*
+>2*
>+ *
>+
+>*
+>* 
+>!2
+>2
+>!*
+>! +
>#!


















>++
+>
+>2 
+>


+>#
+>!



47

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen