Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Flying Efficiently
In a world of $7 avgas, its more important than ever to get the best bang for the buck.
by Mike Busch
Throttle
Lets start with something simple throttle position.
Our piston aircraft engines are always most efficient at
wide-open throttle (WOT). Retarding the throttle from its
wide-open position closes the throttle butterfly valve in
the carburetor or throttle body, and literally chokes off the
engines air supply, intentionally reducing its volumetric
efficiency. It doesnt take rocket science to figure out that
this is not something you want to do when striving for
maximum engine efficiency. Could you operate at maximum
efficiency if someone was trying to strangle you? Neither
can your engine.
As a general rule, for best efficiency, we always want to
be operating at WOT, or as close to WOT as we can without
exceeding the engines operating limitations. Normally
aspirated, turbonormalized and mildly boosted turbocharged
engines can, and should be, operated continuously at WOT.
Figure 1: This test flight of a Beech F33A has the first eight
minutes flown oversquare, and the next 10 minutes flown
undersquare at precisely the same fuel flow. Note how
much higher the EGTs and CHTs are during the undersquare
segment, reflecting significantly lower efficiency.
RPM
Volume 8, Number 3
CIRRUS PILOT
17
Qubec
b
We dont ADVERTISE
Montral
o
Personal MAINE
Service,
MAIN
We LIVE it!
VERM
ONT
NEW
W
HAMPSHIRE
HAMP
MPSHIRE
Fredericton
Freder
ric
ict
ccton
Montpelier
Montp
Montpel
pelie
e err
el
yracuse
yrac
cuse
ccus
use
RK
K
Augusta
us
Portland
and
nd
Concord
Co
C
Albany
Al
A
lba
Springf
Springfield
Springfie
n
Hartford
Hartford
Hartfo
Providence
vidence
vid
ide
en e
ence
CONN.
C N
CON
R.I.
Ne
New
warkk
w
Newark
New
ew
w Yo
York
Y
n N.J. N
Do
Dover
D
overr
o
apolis
apol
ap
polis
480.363.0058
Cirrus Aircraft Factory Authorized Service Center
info@massaviation.com 508.363.0691
HINGTON,DC
HIN
NGTON,D
N
,DC
CWorcester Regional Airport (ORH)
D
DEL.
Ask us how our customers get totally free oil changes
mpton
o
rfolkk
18 CIRRUS PILOT
Brian Mackin
Aircraft Sales Director
brian@pacaircenter.com
Specializing in Pre-owned Cirrus
and new Cessna Aircraft
SEE OUR QUALITY PRE-OWNED INVENTORY AT
PACAIRCENTER.COM
May/June 2013
Mixture
Staying with the simple stuff: If we want to optimize
efficiency, we need to lean aggressively. Duh!
So-called best economy mixture which is the mixture
that achieves minimum brake specific fuel consumption
(BSFC) and maximum nautical miles per gallon of fuel
invariably occurs well on the lean side of peak EGT,
typically somewhere between 30F and 70F LOP. To
make things even simpler, if you lean the engine until the
onset of perceptible roughness, then richen just enough to
make the roughness go away (and not any richer), youll be
close to best economy mixture. Pilots have been using this
technique for about 100 years, and it works pretty well.
There are all sorts of other side benefits that come with
operating the engine aggressively LOP. This method of
operating is both cleaner and cooler. It reduces stress on
critical engine components, and it minimizes the buildup of
harmful exhaust deposits. Its the kindest thing you can do
for your engine, and will provide you maximum longevity.
My own geriatric engines are a perfect case study of this.
Maximum longevity plus maximum efficiency whats
not to like?
Volume 8, Number 3
CIRRUS PILOT
19
Airspeed
If you ask what airspeed is most efficient, things start
to get a bit more complicated. Thats because there are a
bunch of different airspeeds that compete for the title of
most efficient.
One such contender is the airspeed that achieves
minimum drag. It is variously referred to as maximum
L/D speed or minimum thrust-required speed. You can
generally find it in the emergency procedures section of
your POH as best range glide speed. For my Cessna
310, its 111 knots indicated. For a Cirrus SR22 G3, its 88
knots indicated. Those speeds are at max gross weight; at
lighter weights, the speed is a trifle lower. It varies with the
square root of weight.
When used as a cruise speed, this maximum L/D speed is
the speed that provides best range. This is the speed youd
want to fly if you want to be able to fly as far as possible
on a given amount of fuel, or alternatively, if you want
to get to your destination with the maximum amount of
fuel reserve. This speed is sometimes useful when flying
maximum-range missions, but its slower than most of us
are willing to fly.
Two other contenders for the title of most efficient
speed can be derived from this max L/D speed, a.k.a.
best range speed. One is slower, the other is faster. If we
divide max L/D speed by 1.316, we get best endurance
speed or minimum power required speed. This is the
speed youd want to fly if your goal was to remain aloft
for the maximum time or alternatively if you want to use
the minimum amount of fuel per hour. This speed is useful
for loiter-mode operations like aerial surveillance, fish
spotting, pipeline patrol, etc. This is a very slow airspeed,
and definitely will not satisfy your need for speed. It also
puts maximum stress on your bladder.
A faster and more satisfying most efficient speed is
obtained by multiplying max L/D speed by 1.316. This gives
us what is commonly referred to as the Carson speed
after renowned Naval Academy professor Bernard H. Bud
Altitude
So far, weve determined that to achieve optimum
efficiency, we want to cruise at wide-open throttle, minimum
allowable RPM, and at an IAS of approximately Carson
speed (which is relatively low as indicated airspeeds go).
Lets see if youve been paying attention. Heres a pop quiz
Question: How can we do all of this at the same time?
Answer: By flying at a relatively high altitude that allows
us to fly WOT without exceeding Carson speed.
In a high-performance normally-aspirated airplane, this
generally means cruising up around 12,000 feet, give or
take. In a turbocharged airplane, it usually requires climbing
up to the low flight levels. These are the altitudes at which
these airplanes are happiest and most efficient.
About the Author: Mike Busch has been a pilot, aircraft owner
and CFI for more than four decades and 7,500 hours. He
became increasingly interested in the maintenance aspects of
aircraft ownership about 20 years ago, ultimately earned his
A&P/IA, and in 2008 was honored by the FAA as National
Aviation Maintenance Technician of the Year. Mike is founder
and CEO of Savvy Aircraft Maintenance Management, the
worlds largest firm providing professional maintenance
management for owner-flown aircraft, which presently manages
more than seven percent of all Cirrus airplanes in North
America and growing five percent per month. In his spare time,
Mike is also a prolific aviation writer, teacher, consultant and
expert witness. He writes the maintenance column in Cirrus
Pilot magazine, and has written many hundreds of technical
articles published in American Bonanza Society Magazine,
Aviation Safety, AVweb, Cessna Pilots Association Magazine,
EAA Sport Aviation, IFR, Light Plane Maintenance, and The
Aviation Consumer. In addition, he conducts free maintenance
webinars on the first Wednesday of each month. Mike cofounded AVweb in 1995 and served as its editor-in-chief for
more than seven years. Questions for Mike Busch may be
emailed to mike.busch@savvyaviator.com.
Volume 8, Number 3
CIRRUS PILOT
21