Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
World Conference
on Women
LEGAL COMMITTEE
LEGAL COMMITTEE
Dear Delegates,
It is with great pleasure that I welcome you to the United Nations
World Conference on Women of the Harvard World Model United Nations 2016! My name is Eesha Khare, and I am honored to be serving as
your Chair for these important and crucial topics.
Originally from Saratoga, California, I am currently a junior at Harvard College studying Biomedical Engineering with a focus on chemistry
and materials on the bachelors of science track. Apart from my involvement in Model UN at Harvard, I am passionate about developing technology for a sustainable world and have worked on researching energy
storage devices, for which I was named to the Forbes 30 under 30 in
Energy list in 2014. I currently work as a biomaterials researcher at the
Wyss Institute for Biologically Inspired Engineering and enjoy connecting
world events with my research. I also love traveling, walking outside, and
most of all, dancing.
For the past two years, I have attended the Women in the World
Conference held in New York City. Each year, the conference serves as a
platform to address the larger issues regarding womens empowerment,
gender equality and violence against women. Yet to this day, gender
equality has not been achieved, and while conferences such as this shed
light on the many issues that surround gender dynamics, it is up to us to
carry through effective action on a day-to-day basis. My position as the
chair of the Womens Initiative in Leadership at Harvard Kennedy School
of Governments Institute of Politics, further served to confirm this belief
and I truly believe that the world can be made a much better place if we
worked to give underrepresented women the opportunity to participate
in society. This is an age-old problem, but I am confident that we as a
generation can work towards solving it.
Introduction
Topic A: Women in
Corporate and
Electoral Governance
History and Discussion of the Problem
As of January 2015, 21 percent of parliamentarians are women, up from just 11 percent during
the Beijing Fourth World Conference on Women in
1995. While the number of female politicians has
doubled within the past twenty years, women still
remain a far minority in governance. In a history
where women are already disadvantaged due to
discriminatory laws and practices, having women in
leadership roles both in electoral and corporate governance can make a difference that benefits society as
a whole and helps advance the status of women.
The history of the world has been filled with
influential women in positions of power, ranging
10
violence against women, resources for women, womens rights and the promotion of womens economic
equality can all be categorized as women-friendly
policies. Within developing countries, a longitudinal
study demonstrated that an increase in womens legislative representation also contributed to improvements in child health. However, even within this
general consensus that an increase in womens representation results in an increase in female-friendly
policies, there are many nuances that affect how
women vote. One study found that party dominance
and attitudes towards women in legislature significantly affect the passage of women-friendly policy.
Other studies have found that party affiliation com-
11
12
ease in the boardroom if surrounded by other women. A subsequent study in 1988 demonstrated an
increased number of women in Swedish legislature
resulted in a decrease in resistance to womens participation in political positions. Moving to corporate
boardrooms, a widely publicized study in 2006 reported that having three or more women on a board
can create a critical mass where women no longer
are seen as outsiders. In other words, one woman
no longer represents the womans point of view and
because the women express different views and often disagree with each other [they are] treated as
Current Situation
Through the course of the past fifty years,
many electoral policies have developed in order
to increase the number of women participating in
legislature and corporate governance. Among these
include gendered quota systems and the local and
regional level. However, such measures raise much
concern on the overall status of women as political representations. Added factors such as negative
stereotyping of women in office in the media coupled
with studies that show that women in reserved positions merely serve as figureheads with no real power,
rather than actors, increase the complexity of how
increased womens legislative representation should
be achieved. This section discusses some of these
issues in greater depth in order to develop a foundation upon which delegates can create a resolution for
women in power and decision-making.
Gendered Quota Systems
Gendered quota systems have been among
the widest-reaching electoral reforms aimed at
WORLD CONFERENCE ON WOMEN
13
14
different ways depending on the system of governance. As a result, not all quotas will create the same
rise in numbers of women elected to parliament or
increase womens substantive representation. For
example, Rwanda implemented a constitutional
mandate where women must account for 30 percent
of parliamentary seats, but remarkably now women account for close to half the seats in the lower
house of parliament. Other implementations have
resulted in smaller increases of women; France has
a parity law that stipulates 50 percent of all electoral
candidates to be female, but after the 2002 election,
there was only a 1.4 percent increase in the number
of women elected because of underlying attitudes of
political parties towards women. And yet others have
experienced setbacks in such as in Uganda, where
women are regarded as tokens in the government
and not true members.
Examples of such quotas are wide and varied.
India has a quota process for local governance that
resulted in small-scale local changes. The Panchayat
Raj Act in India reserves 50 percent of village, block
and district council positions for women. A study on
this movement determined that female council chief
members served as positive role models for girls in
the community, encouraging them to have greater
educational and career aspirations. Another study
found that leaders invest more in infrastructure that
directly relates to needs of their own genders, such
as drinking water and roads for women. The reservation has also erased the bias against female leaders
and has made it easier to elect female leaders in even
higher positions of power. For example, Sonia Gandhi is the President of the Indian National Congress
and Indira Gandhi was the former Prime Minister
of India. However, even with women in councils for
local decision-making, progress on womens issues
remains stagnant in India. India serves as a great example where attitudes about women in office do not
extend to attitudes on women in the household. This
15
16
17
Female heads of government as per data provided by an EIU study of government from 1900 to present. The study considers female heads of
government, but not heads of state.
Source: Clinton Global Initiative. No Ceilings Report. 2015. Web. 20 May 2015
18
Percent of men who disagree or strongly disagree that men make better political leaders than women do, as per the World Values Survey conducted in 2010.
Source: Clinton Global Initiative. No Ceilings Report. 2015. Web. 20 May 2015
WORLD CONFERENCE ON WOMEN
Rousseff, and South Korean President Park Geunhye. Women are also more likely to vote than men
and a study of American women showed that 63.7
percent of female citizens voted in the 2012 presidential election compared to 59.7 percent of their male
counterparts. However, still women do not have the
right to vote in places such as Lebanon and Vatican
City, and Saudi Arabia only recently granted womens
suffrage in 2015.
Challenges
Despite increased efforts by governments, regional bodies and non-governmental organizations,
still many women face difficulty both in political participation as well as being elected to parliamentary or
corporate office. One major challenge is the lack of
a comprehensive solution that adequately addresses
social factors, issues with quotas themselves and cultural nuances. Because the very root of the problem
is still inconclusive, a sustainable and impactful way
to elect women to office may currently require concerted and carefully planned measures. For example,
it may be possible that increased access to child-care
and family support may enable more women to leave
the home and join the workforce. Another aspect
of the solution may be possible in addressing how
women are portrayed in the media. Because many
media outlets have biased coverage of womens campaigns that affect how women are perceived in general public, measures that specifically target equitable
media coverage may reduce public discoloring of
women in power. Further, issues surrounding quotas
and token women may be approached from a company perspective where companies regulate themselves towards their own public targets.
Social factors and specific cultural nuances
of various countries also pose challenges to bridging
the gap of women in office. Different societies may
require an incremental increase in the number of
women in decision-making, while others may wish
19
Constitutional Monarchies
Countries in this bloc have a constitutional monarchy where the monarch serves either an
executive or ceremonial power in concert with
other bodies or parliaments within the government. Such countries face similar challenges as the
republic countries in terms of increasing the number of women representatives in their government.
However, the nature of the constitutional monarchy
allows a number of appointments to be made within
the government. Possibly appointing more female
positions within the government may be part of the
solution towards increasing the number of women
representatives. For example, a knighthood or honor
system in the United Kingdom may be used to bring
both men and women to prominence. Such countries
need to balance appointment versus encouragement
carefully in order to improve the situation for women
entering government.
Republics
Countries in this bloc have a republic system of governance have an executive leader with an
accompanying legislative body, where the citizens
either directly or indirectly elect their representatives. Such countries both present the opportunity
for women to serve in government, but also present
a number of challenges. Institutional barriers may
prevent women from accessing positions within
the government and countries in this bloc need to
make an active, conscious effort to increase womens
participation by addressing issues such as media
coverage, stigma, and legislation-to-societal change
translation. These countries will also have difficulty
because simple appointment of female in governance
positions is not as easy due to the nature of the democracy. Countries in this bloc will need to balance
how to increase female representation while still
maintaining the nature of their republics.
Absolute Powers
Countries in this bloc have absolute monarchies or communist bodies in which all the power
is vested in a single governing body. Such countries
have the power to make key decisions for their society with little resistance from opposing parties. In
this manner, countries with such a system of governance might be able to more quickly legislate certain measures to help improve the status of women.
However, this system of governance with a single
ruler often means that a male leader rather than a female one runs the country. A key challenge for these
countries will be in determining how to increase the
voice of women without sacrificing the nature of the
monarchic system. Proposals towards improving
gender equality may require direct government run
programs to reach out and ask for womens feedback and subsequently make laws that address these
issues.
Bloc Positions
21
22
23
Total legal protection around the world against the four forms of violence against women. Numbers correspond to strength of law. 0 indicates no
protections and 12 indicates full protection.
Source: Violence Against Women and the Law. Washington Post. 2015. Web. 20 May 2015
25
26
own objectification. This tension is also evident in research that suggests that womans clothing is a factor
in sexual assault while others that suggest it does not
determine who is victimized. A law review study on
the role of dress in sexual assault cases in the United States found that there was a lack of cases where
dress was used as evidence either because of US law
or because the target was not generally provocatively
dressed. Therefore, the study determined that dress
was used not in legal proceedings, but more in who
the assailant chose to target as victims. The study
further looked into how a womans dress plays into
her targeting as a rape victim. The conclusion is that
womans dress has little impact in whether she will
be sexually harassed, but rather the idea that provocative clothing causes rape is more a societal justification for why rape happens to someone else and
not them. Ultimately, issues of dress in rape cases in
the United States are not common and are more a
societal justification for explaining why rape happens
to certain woman than a major factor contributing to
who is targeted.
The SlutWalk movement in 2011 saw women in the United Kingdom protesting the popular
rhetoric that women are responsible for their own
rape due to the clothes they wear. In the movement,
men and women were invited to dress in sexually
provocative clothing to protest this idea that womens dress influences their rape. A study on Muslim womens dress in Europe during this period of
SlutWalk revealed that the use of slut in SlutWalk
may prevent the issue from being appropriately addressed. Further, because Muslim women often have
to balance the liberal European culture, with the
traditional Muslim one, such strong language may
prevent their full realization of sexual freedoms.
27
28
conversation on intersection of terrorism and violence against women. Yousafzais incident is not
alone. Rape and violence has been used as a weapon
of war in multiple regions. Rape was used as a form
of religious terrorism in the war between East and
West Pakistan where men were engaged in a cosmic
war with women, who are considered evildoers.
Similarly, rape was used as a weapon of terror in
Bosnia, where mass rapes were an element of ethnic
cleaning of non-Serb Bosnians. Rape is common in
conflict zones and the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Refugees has organized security patrols
to relocate vulnerable women to safer areas.
Role of media in covering rape
An article titled A Rape on Campus was
published in the December 2014 issue of the Rolling
Stone and has since been retracted by the publisher
due to inaccuracies and significant discrepancies.
The article described how several members of a
fraternity raped an unidentified woman as a part of
an initiation ritual of a fraternity at the University of
Virginia. The story sparked a strong reaction from
the university and local community and resulted in
the vandalism of the fraternity and the defamation of
members of it. However, after a series of subsequent
interviews, the story was revealed to be false and
reporters began observing a number of discrepancies in the way in which the story was investigated.
It turned out many of the claims the girl had made
were false and the incident may not have actually
happened at all. The poor journalism and ethics of
the article raised a robust media reaction, which
the piece receiving Columbia Journalism Reviews
Worst Journalism of 2014.
This case is important to understand because it has a number of consequences both on
how rape is reported and whether it is perceived
as real. Some journalists are concerned with how
such fragile cases are reported and how misreport-
Tech Community
This idea of censorship also pervades to social media and other technology currently available
today. Because of the free speech act in countries
such as the United States, social media companies
allow the posting of rape and violent videos, which
has had consequences on attitudes towards women. In December 2012, an Icelandic woman named
Thorlaug Agustsdottir posted a piece condemning a
Facebook group called Men are better than women,
which subsequently posted distorted altered photos
of her face with violent messages. When asked by
Agustsdottir to remove the groups post, Facebook
replied that it did not violate Facebooks Community Standards on hate speech and instead labeled the
post at Controversial Humor. Only after significant
attention did Facebook apologize for its mistake and
take down the harmful post. This case highlights the
complexities of free speech: on one hand, it promotes
the open spread of different ideas. On the other
hand, it often amplifies dangerous ideas, further val-
29
31
32
Matriarchal Nations
Countries in this bloc include those whose
governance mostly consists of a significant number
of females and whose societies are deeply embedded
in matriarchal roots. While some may believe that
matriarchal societies often do not face as many problems regarding violence against women, this in fact
is not true and these nations need to work towards
building a proper system of law enforcement that
targets the issue.
Gender-equal nations
Countries in this bloc include those whose
governance has a roughly even division of males
and females. While no nation has achieved complete
gender equality, nations close to achieving gender
equality in governance often have laws that are more
equitable towards men and women. Such nations
have to work on further developing measures, which
improve the status of women in their society. These
nations also have to search for lesser known places
where gender discrimination happens in order to
further eliminate violence against women.
Suggestions for Further Research
In addition to this study guide, committee
members should utilize the official United Nations
website (www.un.org) and the website for UN Women (www.unwomen.org) in order to learn more about
initiatives that the UN is current conducting towards
improving gender equality. These websites will not
only provide a better understanding on the structure
and function of the World Conference on Women,
but will also serve as a more detailed guideline for
past and current actions of the committee. In particular, reading the seminal Beijing Platform for Action
1995 and its subsequent 20 year follow up (http://
beijing20.unwomen.org) will allow a much more
thorough understanding of where the issue currently
stands.
Position Papers
Closing Remarks
Gender equality is an issue that has and
continues to stay on the forefront of societal issues
today. It is simply outrageous that in many aspects of
the world, women still are not treated as their male
counterparts are. By effectively addressing issues
surrounding women in electoral and corporate governance and violence against women, the entrenched
discrimination against women can be reversed and
women will be able to have a strong voice in world
affairs in the next many years.
This study guide provides only a brief summary of issues and perspectives regarding the two
topics of the conference, but there are still many
avenues and ideas yet to be explored. In addition to
reading the study guide and learning more about
your countrys position and policies, it is important
WORLD CONFERENCE ON WOMEN
33
Timeline of Important
Events
1910 The Socialist International meeting in Copenhagen establishes a Womens Day to honor the
movement of womens rights. It was adopted by 17
countries and over 100 women.
1975 First World Conference on Women in Mexico
City and International Womens Year
1977 UN General Assembly adopts a resolution
proclaiming a United Nations Day for Womens
Rights and International Peace
1980 Second World Conference on Women in
Copenhagen
1985 Third World Conference on Women in Nairobi
Endnotes
World Conferences on Women. UN Women, n.d.
Web. 24 May 2015.
UN ECOSOC.
UN Women. Facts and Figures: Leadership and
Political Participation. February 2015.
UN Women. The United Nations Fourth World
Conference on Women.
UN Women. The United Nations Fourth World
Conference on Women.
UN Women. The United Nations Fourth World
Conference on Women.
Liam Swiss, Kathleen M Fallon, and Giovani Burgos.
Does Critical Mass Matter? Womens Political Representation and Child Health in Developing Countries.
35
36
Beiner, 2007.
Beiner, 2007.
Jason Lim and Alexandra Fanghanel. Hijabs, Hoodies and Hotpants; negotiating the Slut in SlutWalk.
2013.
B Cioppa. Daily Mail. June 2015.
Brinkley. Wall Street Journal. 2013.
LeeAnn Kahlor and Dan Morrison. Television
Viewing and Rape Myth Acceptance among College
Women. 2007.
Kahlor and Morrison 2007.
Lonsway and Fitzgerald 1994.
Markova and Power 1992
Kahlor and Morrison 2007.
Jessica Rehman. Rape as religious terrorism and
genocide the 1971 war between East and West Pakistan. 2012.
Cheryl Benard. Rape as terror: The case of Bosnia.
1994.
USA Today. Rolling Stone report leaves trail of damage: Our view. 2015.
Catherine Buni and Soraya Chemaly. The Unsafety
Net: How Social Media Turned Against Women.
2014.
Buni and Chemaly 2014.
UN HeForShe.
UN HeForShe.
Cathy Young. Time. 2014.