Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The demoralising political effect of this abrupt departure on Petrograd workers is wellcaptured in the latest work. However, this is perhaps not the main point of interest during a
period in which counter-revolutionary armies were being consolidated in other areas of the
country: in Siberia and on the Don.
Somewhat less than in his two previous studies is Rabinowitch capable of illustrating
the intervention of mass organisations and spontaneous waves of protest in the political
process in his most recent work. We do see examples of this in the opening sequences of the
book, which describe the direct resistance of some railway workers and civil servants to the
idea of an exclusively Bolshevik government, resistance which is countered with patiently
garnered resolutions from mass meetings held in factories, barracks and dockyards. However,
the pre-eminent fact that a stable and largely uncontested Bolshevik-Left Essar coalition
government emerged from these negotiations gives this latest volume a somewhat more elitecentred focus than its predecessors. Protest movements against it prove feeble and ineffective.
The picture of a radically disunited Bolshevik Party remains nonetheless, though even here
we see a growing emphasis on the need for discipline, especially during the Brest-Litovsk
negotiations, in which the party proved itself split three ways on that most crucial of issues,
war and peace. Rabinowitch also portrays it as a party of government containing opponents
by means of a considerable reserve of political skill, occasional violence and electoral fraud.
The last of these is not demonstrated in a particularly clear manner and one suspects that the
author has not sufficiently taken into account the crude tactical choices of the Left Essars as a
factor undermining their level of support at elections. This said, the evaluation of the brutality
meted out by Red Guards to pro-Constituent Assembly demonstrators is convincing, and it
illustrates how little control the new government had over its own security apparatus.
With works on a similar theme already in circulation that of Serge springs to mind
the specialist reader may pose the question of whether there is much that is not already
known in Rabinowitchs latest work. Having said that, this new volume will doubtless prove
a revelation to broader academic and general audiences which, if it could never reach the
stratospheric standards of the authors earlier books, will significantly raise their level of
understanding of the Russian revolution.