Apple boss 'wrong' in US testimony, says tax

chief
Cormac McQuinn Twitter
Published 14/10/2016 | 02:30

222
Apples Tim Cook. Photo: Niall Carson/PA Wire
Apple boss Tim Cook was "wrong" to say that the tech firm got a "tax incentive arrangement" in Ireland, the
chairman of Revenue has said.
Niall Cody has told TDs at the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) that the remarks by Mr Cook at a US Senate
hearing in 2013 are "not correct".

222 222
Revenue chief Niall Cody. Photo: Tom Burke
In August, the European Commission ruled that Apple was the beneficiary of illegal State aid in Ireland and
demanded that up to 13bn in back taxes be recovered from the company.
Both the Government and Apple have rejected this decision and denied any wrongdoing. While the
Government is appealing the ruling, Revenue has been tasked with recovering the back taxes which are to be
held in escrow until the end of legal proceedings. Mr Cody told TDs that Revenue had begun the process of
calculating the sum to be sought from Apple.
He was asked about Mr Cook's comments in the US Senate, as well of those by another Apple executive who
said the company negotiated a tax rate here of less than 2pc.
Serious
Mr Cody said he was constrained in what he could say about an individual taxpayer.
But he said: "What Tim Cook said in the Senate hearings is absolutely, in Revenue's opinion, not correct."
Sinn Fin's David Cullinane said it was "very serious" to accuse the head of a multinational organisation of false
testimony. Mr Cody replied he could only talk about what happened in relation to Revenue and Apple in 1991
and 2007.
Mr Cody said he could not answer whether what was said in the Senate hearings was right or wrong. "I can only
say what happened in Ireland... The impact of that was he [Mr Cook] was wrong."
Mr Cody insisted there was no special arrangement with Apple.

Fianna Fil's Shane Cassells asked if the Apple controversy had been damaging for Ireland and Revenue. Mr
Cody said he'd rather talk in general terms about international tax and Ireland's role in efforts at reform.
"We are punching above our weight in solving it but it has to be solved on an international basis," he said.
Separately, Mr Cody told TDs it would cost 3m to upgrade the Customs Service IT system to cope with a
doubling of non-EU trade due to Brexit.
He said Revenue had been allocated an extra 5m in the Budget which would be used in part to hire 40 staff
members to help plan for Britain leaving the EU.
Mr Cody said there could be "significant problems" relating to trade across the Border, including for the agrisector and supply chains of "big multiples".
He added: "Legitimate trade will be facilitated as much as possible." Mr Cody said Revenue was looking at the
EU borders with Norway and Turkey as possible models that could be implemented here.
Earlier, Comptroller and Auditor General Seamus McCarthy told TDs Revenue carried out 400 random audits of
individuals and businesses a year and found that about 40pc under-declared their tax liability between 2013
and 2015.
Irish Independent
Follow @Independent_ie

Promoted Articles

Rogue Indonesian tax collecter

unwittingly threatens supply
chain

No Irish Need Apply professor First Lady Michelle Obamas

says 14-year-old girls findings Irish slave owner roots
IrishCentral

IrishCentral

The Crocodile Dundee Stars

Look Unrecognizable Now

6 Incredible Things That Only

Happen in Scandinavia

Abandoned Automobile
Dealerships [PHOTOS]

Time To Break

Goodnet

Gleems

Nikkei Asian Review

These Incredible Photographs

Prove Murphy's Law Is Real
Gleems

Robin Wright Won the Bidding

War for a West Village
Penthouse

Angelina Jolies Dad Jon Voight

Spills Details On Brad Pitt
Divorce:

Mansion Global

Radar Online
Recommended by

Related Content
Offshore tax cheats to be targeted under State's new plan
EU regulators haven't extended scrutiny to Google tax deals
Income tax take is down, corporate tax is up, but 'don't panic, it will all balance out in the end'
Apple tax ruling 'dented consumer confidence'

Read More
Gavin Slark

Kenmare Resources and Grafton Group add non-executive directors to boards

Michael Cogley Irish mining company Kenmare Resources and building materials firm Grafton Group have both
added to their boards this morning with non-executive appointments.

What it says in the papers: business pages

Michael Cogley Here are the main business stories from this morning's papers:

Virgin Media boss doesn't rule out cuts at 'struggling' UTV Ireland
John Mulgrew Virgin Media hopes to complete its takeover of UTV Ireland by the end of the year, its boss has
said.

Recommended Videos
from

VIDEO - Caught on camera:

Is this the world's worst
driver ?

VIDEO: Michael Noonan

answers key questions
about Budget 2017

VIDEO: Gone in 60 seconds Kevin Doyle explains Budget

2017

VIDEO - Caught on camera:

Is this the world's worst
driver ?

VIDEO: Michael Noonan

answers key questions
about Budget 2017

VIDEO: Gone in 60 seconds Kevin Doyle explains Budget

2017

Independent.ie
News
Irish News
News
Politics
Education
Health
Courts
World News
Europe
Britain
North America
US Election 2016

Latin America
Middle East
Asia-Pacific
Australasia
Africa
War On Terror
Opinion
Letters
Columnists
Editorial
Comment
Local Papers
Weather
Forecast
Upload your Weather photos
1916
Business
Budget 2017
Brexit
Irish
Commercial Property
Banking Inquiry
Rich List 2016
World
Technology
Tech & Gaming
Digital Edition
Infosec 2016
Personal Finance
Latest News
Property & Mortgages
Pensions
How Much is Your House Worth?
Small Business
Latest News
Advice Centre
Your Stories
Farming
Ploughing Championships
Jobs
Media & Marketing
Sport
Soccer
Premier League
Champions League
Other Soccer
International Soccer
League of Ireland
Euro 2016
GAA
Gaelic Football
Hurling
Ladies Football
Camogie

Rugby
Champions Cup
Guinness Pro12
Six Nations
Other Rugby
International Rugby
Leinster Rugby
Munster Rugby
Connacht Rugby
Ulster Rugby
Schools Rugby
Rugby World Cup
Golf
Horse Racing
Other Sports
MMA
LeftField
Greyhounds
Life
Health & Wellbeing
Health Features
Healthy Eating
Fitness
Mental Health
Living With Cancer
Mind Yourself
Home & Garden
Homes
Interiors
Gardens
Home Property Videos
Family
Family Features
Mothers & Babies
Parenting
Learning
Fertility and You
Food & Drink
Food News
Recipes
Food Reviews
Wine
Table Talk
Motoring
News
Reviews
International
Talk
City Cycling
Archives
Lucindas Ireland
Style
Celebrity
Celebrity News

Celebrity Features
Fashion
Fashion News
Fashion Fix
Style Talk
Beauty
Body
Makeup
Hair
Sex & Relationships
Weddings
Voices
Galleries
Society
Competitions
Entertainment
Movies
Movie News
Movie Reviews
Television
TV News
TV Reviews
Music
Music News
Music Reviews
Windmill Lane
Radio
Books
Book News
Book Reviews
Theatre & Arts
Games
Festivals
SummerFest
Upload your festival photos
Banter
Cute
Gizmo
Videos
Trending
Coffee Break
Competitions
Horoscopes
Lotto
Crosswords
Windmill Lane
Travel
Travel News
Top 10s
Ireland
Europe
World/USA
Family
Sun

Cruise
Ski
Travel TV
Hotels
Holiday Deals
Video
Podcasts
Sponsored
Serious Support
Business Hub
StoryPlus
Sponsored Features
Search

Go