Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
www.technicalanalyst.co.uk
Exploiting Market
Mispricing with
Castlestone
Management
Awards
Technical Trading
Welcome
In this edition we speak to London based hedge fund
Castlestone Management about how they look to exploit
market mispricings as part of their trading and investment
strategy. This provides a fresh perspective on how to view
deviations of prices from fair value using a combination of
technical and fundamental analysis. Given the recent calls that
US and UK stocks may be peaking, we also look at the Rex
Oscillator, a less well know indicator that has a good record
at anticipating major market turns in the stock market.
Matthew Clements
Editor
SUBSCRIPTIONS
2010 Global Markets Media Limited. All rights reserved. Neither this publication nor any part of it may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted
in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of Global Markets Media Limited. While the
publisher believes that all information contained in this publication was correct at the time of going to press, they cannot accept liability for any errors or omissions
that may appear or loss suffered directly or indirectly by any reader as a result of any advertisement, editorial, photographs or other material published in The
Technical Analyst. No statement in this publication is to be considered as a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell securities or to provide investment, tax or
legal advice. Readers should be aware that this publication is not intended to replace the need to obtain professional advice in relation to any topic discussed.
Apr-Jun 2010
OUT IN MAY!
The Technical Analyst is proud to announce the forthcoming publication of the second book in its
Discussion Series. Technical Analysis in the FX Markets features interviews with 15 professional
market analysts in their use and application of TA to make trading calls and investment decisions in the
currency markets. The book describes technical strategies that are uniquely effective in the foreign
exchange market with a focus on indicators, pattern set-ups and short-term techniques.
Contents
Apr-Jun 2010
www.technicalanalyst.co.uk
Exploiting Market
Mispricing with
Castlestone
Management
Awards
Technical Trading
COVER STORY
Interview:
35
06
10
19
AWARDS
INTERVIEW
15
25
10
15
Behavioural Investing
22
25
35
RESEARCH UPDATE
41
TRAINING DIARY
44
Apr-Jun 2010
04
Behavioural Investing
06
MARKET NEWS
AND VIEWS
BOB PRECHTER IN
LONDON
Bob Prechter of Elliott Wave
International has joined the growing ranks of analysts forecasting
an imminent market top in
stocks. Speaking in London in
February he described stocks as
being in a serious bear market.
Explaining the current situation
PRESIDENTIAL CYCLE
SEES 2010 STOCK
CORRECTION
Technical Trading
Apr-Jun 2010
Technical Trading
THE REX
OSCILLATOR
INDICATOR FOCUS
Apr-Jun 2010
presents
European Conference
2010
18 May 2010
The Westbury Hotel
Mayfair London W1
Topics include:
+ Fund managers
+ Hedge funds
+ Traders
+ Risk managers
+ Analysts
+ Brokers
+ Market cycles
+ Bollinger: Trading Volatility
+ Intra-day FX effects
+ Measuring momentum
+ Testing trends
+ Opportunities in EM
+ Chart pattern strategies
Speakers include:
John Bollinger
Bollinger Capital
Management
Avi Hooper
Invesco
Louis Yang
Citibank
Charles Morris
HSBC Asset
Management
Maxime Vietmont
BNP Paribas
Nawaz Imam
Citibank
Robin Griffiths
Cazenove Capital
Management
Bruce Kamich
Morgan Stanley
Smith Barney
John Forman
Thomson Reuters
Technical Trading
Figure 1.
positive. The average weekly loss was 2.5% and the average
weekly gain was 1.9%.
Figure 1 shows how the RO gave a very strong sell signal
in April 2009 for the USD Index. This was followed by a buy
signal in November of the same year. The RO usually generates strong signals only intermittently. This year saw a major
signal in January for US stocks. Stockton noted that the RO
Figure 2.
Apr-Jun 2010
Trading The
Gold Market:
USD vs EUR
Technical Trading
By Lynnden Branigan,
Chief Technical Analyst, Informa Global Markets
A twelve-week corrective dip in gold, as commonly benchmarked against the US dollar, has prompted a test of a 16month bull channel. However, looking away from the precious metals status as a hedging tool against USD fluctuations and inflation, we take note that there have been new all
time highs recently seen against the core European currencies.
Since the initial sell-off from the 2 December 2009 peak
stalled on 22 December, the value of gold, when priced in US
dollars, made a lower high on 11 January before resuming a
downward path to a new closing low at 1063.30. Meanwhile,
over the same period, gold in terms of the Euro extended
10
Apr-Jun 2010
Technical Trading
Apr-Jun 2010
11
Technical Trading
Apr-Jun 2010
Technical Trading
the longer-term trend for higher highs and higher lows. This
would then target channel support at 732.30, the equivalent
of which is at 1101.25 on the USD/Gold chart.
RESISTANCE
925.50
900.00
Psychological & equality projection of 534.30/785.30 measured off the 649.00 low
919.00
858.00
SUPPORT
797.10
759.40
773.80
732.30
Informa Global Markets obtains information for its analysis from sources it considers reliable, but does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of its analysis or any information contained therein. Informa
Global Markets and its affiliates make no representation or warranty, either express or implied, with respect to the information or analysis supplied herein, including without limitation the implied warranties of fitness
for a particular purpose and merchantability, and each specifically disclaims any such warranty. In no event shall Informa Global Markets or its affiliates be liable to clients for any decision made or action taken by the
client in reliance upon the information or analyses contained herein, for delays or interruptions in delivery for any reason, or loss of business revenues, lost profits or any indirect, consequential, special or incidental
damages, whether in contract, tort or otherwise, even if advised of the possibility of such damages. This material is intended solely for the private use of Informa Global Markets clients, and any unauthorised use,
duplication or disclosure is prohibited. This material is not a comprehensive evaluation of the industry, the companies or the securities mentioned, and does not constitute an offer or a solicitation of an offer or a recommendation to buy or sell securities. All expressions of opinion are subject to change without notice.
Apr-Jun 2010
13
Technical Trading
BEHAVIOURAL INVESTING
Alida Carcano of AD Advanced Finance in Switzerland discusses how behavioural finance can, and cannot, be used to help in making investment decisions, and how the credit crunch has taught us more about the behavioural
biases of investors.
Do you believe that markets are always inefficient?
I do believe that markets are quite efficient but inefficiencies exist in the short to medium-term and/or in specific market niches; they then tend to disappear in the
medium to long-term. BF can exploit these inefficiencies
opportunistically. I think it is important to notice that, not
only in finance but generally speaking in our everyday
life, emotion and instinct are increasingly being recognised as natural principle, while the long-standing
supremacy of rationality is coming under fire.
Does BF completely disprove the Efficient Market
Hypothesis?
I think that BF actually proves that markets are efficient
because in the medium/long-term market prices are
Apr-Jun 2010
15
Technical Trading
Apr-Jun 2010
Technical Trading
17
OUT NOW!
Global Markets Media is proud to announce the launch of a new range of books dedicated to the discussion of technical analysis and behavioural finance. The first book to be
published, Technical Analysis in Fund Management, features interviews with leading
investment managers and analysts on their approach to using technical analysis in their
investment decisions.
TNCP
Technical Trading
THE
Triangulation
Indicator: Part 2
By Trevor Neil and Catalin Nicolae Plapcianu
TNCP Adaptor
This turns the TNCP Triangulation signals covered in the last
issue of The Technical Analyst magazine into a system.
Following trade entry with TNCP Triangulation, you can use
the TNCP Adaptor to stay with the trade as long as it has
power and exit at exhaustion. The TNCP Adaptor deterApr-Jun 2010
mines the market condition and the exit set with relation to
the market price and its trading condition. With an entry and
exit technique, we can set rules for trading and create a technique or system.
19
Technical Trading
This weighted moving average calculation makes the stop follow the price more aggressively. We hold the long position as
long as the close of the bar exceeds the rolling value of Z. We
exit on a closing break of Z.
Figure 2.
Trending markets
We define trending conditions by using the same Variation
measure. First we calculate the variation as before:
Variation=TL12+TW12=V12
Figure 1.
Apr-Jun 2010
Technical Trading
Figure 3.
b) If the previous move (last 12 bars) was upward and a buying pivot occurred and the 4th bar has W (pips won) greater
than the last 12 bars, then continue the trade. This calculation
is made until the move is exhausted (Figure 4).
Figure 5.
Figure 6.
Figure 4.
21
Market Cycles
and Business
Cycles
Technical Trading
Apr-Jun 2010
its and interest rates are usually related to stock prices. If the
economy acts in a cyclical manner, then stock prices will also
be cyclical. Assuming market prices, on average, properly
reflect expectations of the economic fundamentals, then
stock market cycles should precede economic cycles (see
Figure 1).
Of course, stock prices can deviate from what a simple dividend discount model would suggest is a fair price for extended periods, a phenomenon that has been called irrational
exuberance or irrational pessimism by various authors. To
label these price deviations as irrational is merely to highlight
how actual prices are out of proportion (rational means in
a ratio to) to the model that the researcher is positing is fair.
If the market price differs from the model price, perhaps it is
the model that is wrong, not the market. Holding on to
Technical Trading
Market
Cycle
Business
Cycle
23
Economic Activity
Technical Trading
Asset Classes
Recovery
Decline
Stocks
Stocks
Stocks
Stocks
Stocks
Stocks
Bonds
Bonds
Bonds
Stocks
Small
Large
Mid
Large
Small
Large
Mid
Mid
Mid
Large
Value
Value
Value
Value
Value
Value
Growth
Growth
Growth
Value
Active
Active
Passive
Active
Active
Active
Active
Active
Active
Active
Telecomm.
Info. Tech.
Financials
Info. Tech.
Telecomm.
Energy
Energy
Health Care
Energy
Energy
Utilities
Health Care
Telecomm.
Health Care
Utilities
Materials
Industrials
Consumer
Stap.
Industrials
Materials
Second Worst
Sector
Consumer
Discr.
Energy
Health Care
Energy
Consumer
Discr.
Health Care
Telecomm.
Telecomm.
Telecomm.
Health Care
Worst Sector
Health Care
Materials
Industrials
Materials
Health Care
Telecomm.
Financials
Utilities
Financials
Telecomm.
Management Style
Active vs. Passive
Sectors
Best Sector
Second Best Sector
Figure 2. Historical Relationship between the Business Cycle and Asset Class Performance
Apr-Jun 2010
Conclusion
The markets and the economy are tied together: business
profitability varies across the business cycle and investors typically anticipate these changes in profitability. Because of
behavioural biases, market prices can systematically over- and
undershoot what the fundamentals would dictate. In this article we have examined these historical tendencies to show
what, historically, outperforms in various parts of the business cycle. This analysis can hopefully help in making portfolio allocation decisions as investors search for investment
opportunities in all parts of the business cycle.
Brian J. Jacobsen (Ph.D., CFA, CFP) is Chief Portfolio
Strategist and Wayne Badorf (CFP) is National Sales
Manager at Wells Fargo Funds Management, LLC.
The views expressed are of March 31, 2010, and are those of Dr. Brian Jacobsen and Wayne
Badorf, and not those of Wells Fargo Funds Management, LLC. The views are subject to
change at any time in response to changing circumstances in the market and are not intended to predict or guarantee the future performance of any individual security, market sector
or the markets generally, or any Wells Fargo Advantage Fund.
Awards
Apr-Jun 2010
25
Awards
The Technical Analyst was proud to present its 2010 awards at our annual awards ceremony held at the
Sheraton Park Lane Hotel on 25 March 2010. We would like to congratulate the winners and finalists and
thank all those who took part in this years event, including over 100 nominees, and most especially our panel
of judges who found time amongst their regular work schedules to appraise the nominations.
We would also like to thank our guest speaker, Robin Griffiths, for giving the audience a fascinating and
highly entertaining after dinner speech. With his huge experience in the markets, Robin is without doubt the
leading figure in the technical analysis community and his help and support to the magazine over the years
has been invaluable.
Shortlised Finalists:
DayByDay
Dorsey, Wright and Associates
Friedman Billings & Ramsey Int.
Lowry Research Corporation
Redburn Partners
Winner:
Lowry Research Corporation
Like last year, the judges were impressed with the outstanding breadth and innovation of Lowry Research
Corporations output. Valerie Gastaldy's work at DayByDay was also highly praised.
Best FX
Judges:
Jessica James (Citigroup)
Chris Charlton
(Centa Asset Management)
Shortlisted Finalists:
Informa Global Markets
PIA
RBC Capital Markets
Royal Bank of Scotland
TRADING Central
UBS Investment Bank
Winner:
RBC Capital Markets
In this category the judges decided to assess the finalists by looking at several key areas: pure technicals;
strategy; personal committment & integrity (i.e. follow-up of previous strategy recommendations and profit &
loss acknowledgement); brevity and presentation.
They were particularly impressed with PIA who they thought, Offered the best technical trading service for
short-term traders with very good personal integrity - an excellent service. Informa Global Markets was also
praised as a good service for general strategy and for keeping abreast of the markets. The winner, however,
was RBC Capital Markets for its, Solid all round offering with innovative strategies, particularly in hedging,
providing an excellent service for a wide audience.
26
Apr-Jun 2010
Awards
Charles Morris (left) of HSBC Global Asset Management collects the award for Best Equity Research &
Strategy on behalf of Lowry Research Corporation from compere Gerald Ashley.
George Davis (right), Director and Chief Technical Analyst, Fixed Income and Currency Strategy at RBC Capital
Markets, collects the award for Best FX Research & Strategy from Chris Charlton of Centa Asset Management.
Apr-Jun 2010
27
Awards
Clive Lambert (left), Director of FuturesTechs, collects the award for Best Fixed Income Research & Strategy
from Avi Hooper of Invesco.
Paul Day (left), Chief Market Analyst at MIG Investments, collects the award for Best Specialist Research from
Alex Spiroglou of ODIN Capital Management.
28
Apr-Jun 2010
Awards
Shortlisted Finalists:
FuturesTechs
Informa Global Markets
PIA
Royal Bank of Scotland
UBS Investment Bank
Winner:
FuturesTechs
The category for Fixed Income Research & Strategy was particularly close, with each of the finalists having
something valuable to offer. In the final analysis, the award was given to FuturesTechs for the high quality of
their overall research process and clear presentation style.
Shortlisted Finalists:
Dorsey, Wright and Associates
eYield
Financial Trend Analysis
JPMorgan Equity Quant Research
MIG Investments
Winner:
MIG Investments
This category by its nature covers a variety of companies offering many different services or research specialities; from eYields Elliott Wave based market commentary to last years winner, JPMorgans Equity
Quant Research team, who produce excellent research that is highly relevant to technical analysis and
momentum trading in particular. However, for their, "Well explained, usable, practical, specialist technical
research based on DeMark's indicators", the judges declared Paul Day of MIG Investments the winner.
Apr-Jun 2010
29
Awards
Product Awards
Best Specialist Product
Judges:
Trevor Neil (Betagroup)
Alex Spiroglou
(ODIN Capital Management)
Shortlisted Finalists:
Fidessa (FFI and Fragulator)
ITTrading
(Candlestick Pattern Tracker)
Market Studies
(DeMark Indicators, Cursor
Commentary and TD Research)
Recognia
TraderDNA
Winner:
Recognia
The finalists for the Best Specialist Product category were once again an interesting mix of products and
companies, including Fidessas Fragmentation Index and Fragulator which provides a measure of how different stocks are fragmenting across primary markets and alternative venues. In the final analysis, and
based on the strength of the nomination, Recognia was declared the winner for their, "Clever powerful pattern recognition software."
Shortlisted Finalists:
Bloomberg
CQG
Interactive Data
QuantHouse
TraderMade
Winner:
Bloomberg
Whilst TraderMade provides excellent data for the FX markets and QuantHouses QuantFeed provides a
first class ultra-low latency solution for automated and algorithmic trading, the judges gave the award to
Bloomberg for, Their outstanding and comprehensive market data offering across all asset classes.
Shortlisted Finalists:
Alphacet
FlexTrade Systems
Patsystems
Progress Apama
QuantHouse
TickCOM
Winner:
Progress Apama
The judges took a highly systematic approach to this category, scoring finalists based on 15 key criteria. In
the end, three nominees - Alphacet, Progress Apama and QuantHouse - scored incredibly closely and all of
them would have been worthy winners.
Progress Apama were awarded the category for the second year running with their excellent all-round
easy-to-use product scoring solidly across the board, and particularly well in the area of execution integration.
QuantHouse ran Progress an incredibly close second. The judges thought it especially good with regard to
historical data coverage and programming ease of use. Flextrade also did well in the more specific area of
algorithmic execution, scoring top marks for Execution Algorithmic Development.
30
Apr-Jun 2010
Awards
Eugene Sorenson (right), TA Specialist at Bloomberg, collects the award for Best Data Provider from Trevor
Neil of Betagroup.
31
Awards
Jeremy du Plessis (left) and David Linton (right) of Updata collect the award for Best Technical Analysis
Platform from Rashpal Sohan of Rathbones.
George Davis (right) of RBC Capital Markets collects the award for Technical Analyst of the Year from
Trevor Neil of Betagroup.
32
Apr-Jun 2010
Awards
Shortlisted Finalists:
Bloomberg
CQG
TraderMade
tradesignal
Updata
Winner:
Updata
The judges tried to be as objective as possible, comparing the platforms across some 164 different factors.
They recognised that some aspects cannot be easily quantified such as look and feel, adaptability of the
system, level of support etc, but they tried as much as possible to incorporate all of these factors into their
final decision.
Updata has succeeded in incorporating a vast number of analyses into their platform. The number of
methodologies is rapidly increasing and is in our view constantly adapting to clients wishes; this is one of
Updatas key strengths. The look and feel of the platform is second to none and the ability to link to several
external data providers is a plus. Key strengths are the charting engine (especially point&figure), multiportfolio backtesting abilities, programming in easy to use language, reporting capabilities and catering for
users from all walks of life. Updata releases new updates fairly regularly responding to new demand from
clients, and new insights or improvements to the system.
The judges were also impressed with CQG and Bloomberg: CQG has been a leading product for more
than 30 years, making them the industry standard. We liked the availability of clean data and the vast number of proprietary third party analyses (such as DeMark methodologies) on the platform. Easy to use and
powerful analysis capabilities are CQGs key strengths.
The technical analysis capabilities of the Bloomberg system, on the other hand, have improved fantastically in the last few years. Incorporating programming capabilities is a factor to work on however. No doubt,
Bloomberg is one of the most comprehensive and easy to use platforms while maintaining high quality and
standards in both look and feel and methodologies. The link to other non-technical information such as
security pricing and news is invaluable.
Shortlisted Finalists
Dave Floyd
(Aspen Trading Group)
Jean-Charles Gand (Socit
Gnrale Gestion (Amundi Group)
Valrie Gastaldy (DayByDay)
Thomas Schroeder
(Chart Partners Group)
Plus the winner from each
Research & Strategy category
Winner:
George Davis,
RBC Capital Markets
For his well presented, innovative research and strategy in the FX markets, George Davis also won
Technical Analyst of the Year. Honourable mention however must also go to Valrie Gastaldy at DayByDay
and Jean-Charles Gand at Socit Gnrale Gestion (Amundi Group).
Apr-Jun 2010
33
Interview
INTERVIEW
Apr-Jun 2010
35
Interview
36
Apr-Jun 2010
Interview
TA: What are the main markets you trade? Can you give
a brief description of your main funds, AUM and investment approaches?
LD: Our trading approach is 100% discretionary, using fundamental analysis to develop trading themes and overlaying
technical analysis for trade implementation. We take directional and relative value positions using futures and forwards
in the G10 markets within four major asset classes: equities,
fixed Income, commodities and FX. The main fund is the
Porcupine Global Macro Fund and our objective is to generate positive absolute returns while managing downside
volatility. Assets under management total $33m as of 31st of
March 2010.
LD: We track market correlations and review them constantly. Relationships tend to be highly correlated for periods then
often become crowded, or are affected by fundamental news
flows, and then the relationship becomes non-correlated. For
example, in 2007 we were long corn, short wheat and dollar
neutral. Part of the trade thesis was a play on crop rotation
and price equilibrium. The other part of the trade was a play
on ethanol. The correlation between long corn/short wheat
at the time was 0.86.
LD: Identifying price inefficiencies are derived from our rigorous research process. We believe that the market becomes
mispriced for a number of reasons: this includes, behavioural finance and how the markets react to the release of estimated data, and the concept of reflexivity (as discussed by
George Soros) which states that at some point in time
markets will return to their fair value or the
unexplainable price action will disappear which creates a trading opportunity.
Apr-Jun 2010
TA: To what extent are the commodities markets speculative in nature and to what extent are they driven by
fundamental factors?
LD: The best way to describe fundamental factors vs speculation is to take a view on your investment horizon. The longterm is the great fundamental play in the commodity market.
Shorter-term price action is driven by speculation. An example is gold. Gold has rallied from approximately USD$340 to
USD$1150 over six years. This longer-term move has been
due to several fundamental factors such as the USD depreciation against emerging market currencies, inflation hedging,
geopolitical hedging, real asset plays and a credit crisis
hedge. However, as we have seen over the last 12 months, as
more participants are able to trade gold (in the form of
Exchange Traded Commodities and Funds), gold price
moves can be seen as speculative in the short-term with the
longer-term trend still rising.
TA: Are there any trading/investment strategies unique
to the commodities markets that you tend to employ?
37
Interview
IF SHORT-TERM TRADING
OPPORTUNITIES ARE SEEN, WE WILL LOOK FOR
EXHAUSTION OR BREAKOUT MOMENTUM PLAYS.
tract can become crowded. Structuring calendar spread trades
can be advantageous during these times.
TA: What are the main advantages to trading the agriculturals? Are there any seasonal factors that are relatively easy to exploit?
38
Apr-Jun 2010
LD: We typically look at exhaustion price action in the markets. This can be identified in a number of ways: trading volume levels tend to stabilise or start declining, fatigue in the
price action by rate of change and open close tick data, additionally the market begins to tire of fundamental reasons for
buying or selling and the media becomes overly obsessed
Interview
Apr-Jun 2010
39
Interview
40
Apr-Jun 2010
DISCLAIMER
This document is intended only for professional investors and financial advisers.
The material on these pages is provided for information purposes only; it is not
an invitation to invest. Income from investments may fluctuate and investors
may not recoup the amount originally invested. Please refer to the relevant funds
Confidential Explanatory Memorandum for detailed information and/or seek
relevant professional advice before making any investment decision. This document contains forward-looking statements concerning the financial condition,
results of operations and businesses of Castlestone Management. Such statements, expressed or implied, are based on management's current expectations
and assumptions, which may change without notice, and are no guaranteemof
future results, performance or events. This document does not constitute an
offer or solicitation to sell shares in any of the funds mentioned, by anyone in
any jurisdiction in which such offer or solicitation is not authorized or to any person to whom it is unlawful to make such offer or solicitation. Persons interested
in acquiring funds should inform themselves as to (i) the legal requirements in
the countries of their nationality, residence, ordinary residence or domicile; (ii)
any foreign exchange controls; and (iii) any relevant tax consequences. Selected
retail fund share classes may include an administration fee, which is not paid to
the Investment Manager.
Castlestone Management Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial
Services Authority in the UK. Securities and Exchange Commission. Castlestone
Management Limited is authorised by the Financial Services Board in South
Africa. Castlestone Management Inc. is regulated by the British Virgin Islands
Financial Services Commission.
*The data denotes the actual performance net of management fees, performance fees and expenses of the Porcupine Global Macro Plus share class C. Past performance is not a guide to future
returns.
Research Update
ASSYMETRIC
BIASES
INDIVIDUALISM AND
MOMENTUM PROFITS
A team of international researchers has examined how cultural differences influence the returns of momentum strategies.
They measure cross-country cultural differences using an individualism index developed by Hofstede (2001), which is related to overconfidence and self-attribution bias. The authors
find that individualism is positively associated with trading volume and volatility, as well as to the magnitude of momentum
profits.
Individualism and Momentum around the World, Andy C. W. Chui,
Sheridan Titman, K. C. John Wei, Journal of Finance, Volume 65,
Issue 1, Feb 2010.
Apr-Jun 2010
OPTIONS VS
FREQUENT TRADING
41
Research Update
DISPOSITION EFFECT
AND FUND FLOWS
Are the behavioral biases of fund
managers affected by capital flows?
Two researchers at the National Cheng
Kung University have examined the
relationship between fund flows and
the disposition behavior of fund managers. They find that the disposition
biases of fund managers are significantly negatively correlated with unexpected fund flows, but insignificantly
OWNERSHIP CONCENTRATION
AND EARNINGS ANNOUNCEMENTS
A team from INSEAD have studied the behaviour of stocks with concentrated institutional ownership. They show that following earnings announcements concentrated
stocks exhibit superior abnormal returns. This effect is equally strong for positive and
negative surprises. A trading strategy long in announcing stocks from the highest concentration quartile and short in announcing stocks from the lowest concentration quartile delivers an average monthly return of 1.32%. This return fades rapidly if the portfolio is held beyond the month of the announcement. The profits from the trading
strategy are largely unaffected by direct or indirect transaction costs for reasonably large
portfolio sizes.
The authors suggest that closely held stocks might benefit from strategic trading by
holding institutions which have incentives to keep stock prices and portfolio values
high. In line with this theory, they find that institutions significantly reduce their selling
pressure in concentrated stocks around earnings announcement thereby withholding
liquidity and forcing price inflation. The concentration effect is stronger if the stock is
held by funds representing few families, underperforming funds, and funds for which
the stock is a major investment.
THE PREDICTIVE
VALUE OF
INSTITUTIONAL
OWNERSHIP
Chuprinin, Oleg, Massa, Massimo and Loutfi, Zeina, Too Few Investors Make the Party: Analysis of
Return Patterns in Stocks with Concentrated Ownership (March 15, 2010).
Research Update
Can a technical momentum strategy be improved upon through the inclusion of fundamental information? This is the question posed by a research team from Rutgers
University who examine how fundamental accounting information along with the
technical information such as past returns and past trading volume data can be used
by investors to separate momentum winners from losers. Previous research has shown
that the technical momentum strategy based on the past winners and losers in terms
of cumulative returns, generates significantly positive returns in the subsequent periods. This new paper proposes a unified framework of incorporating the fundamental
indicators FSCORE (Piotroski (2000)) and GSCORE (Mohanram (2005)) into the
technical momentum strategy. The authors have developed three hypotheses to test
whether a combined momentum strategy outperform the technical momentum strategy or not. From the empirical results of these three hypotheses, the authors conclude
that the combined momentum strategy outperforms a technical momentum strategy
by generating significantly larger returns for both growth and value stocks.
Lee, Cheng-Few and Shih, Wei-Kang, Technical, Fundamental, and Combined Information for
Separating Winners from Losers (April 15, 2010).
The index effect, or the excess returns of a stock added to a leading index, is one of the most researched pricing anomalies in
finance, but is the index effect shrinking? To answer this question, Standard & Poor's Index and Portfolio Services studied the index
effect for headline indices of five of the biggest equity markets in the world: U.S. (S&P 500), Canada (S&P/TSX 60), Japan (Nikkei
225), U.K. (FTSE 100) and the Germany (DAX 30). They found that excess returns for index additions have diminished over the
past five years. The median excess return of S&P 500 additions was 3.8% for the past five years, compared to 6.0% for the five years
prior. The declining pattern is also observed in Nikkei 225, S&P/TSX 60 and DAX 30, but not the FTSE 100.
The authors attribute the diminishing index effects to several possible factors: 1) The index effect has fallen victim to its own popularity. As more arbitrageurs have come in to the market, arbitrage profits have reduced and 2) Changes in market structure and trading patterns of index funds have dented the index effect. They conclude that the index effect may never vanish completely, but its
days as a profitable trading strategy may be numbered. Alternative index related profit opportunities may involve trading index
changes in the options market or trading index share changes.
Standard & Poor's, Index and Portfolio Services, , The Shrinking Index Effect: A Global Perspective (November 1, 2008).
Apr-Jun 2010
43
Training Courses
London
London
London
London
Principal Trainer
29/30 June 10
London
Trevor Neil
Trevor Neil became a
commodities trader at Merrill
Lynch in the mid 1970s
before going on to work
at LIFFE giving technical
analysis support to floor traders.
In 2000 he became head of technical
analysis at Bloomberg where he was
responsible for training and technical
analysis software development.
London
DEMARK INDICATORS
An in-depth look at these unique market timing tools.
16 September 10
London
OTHER COURSES
Backtesting and Optimization Workshop
22/23 June 10
London
23/24 November 10
London
Pairs Trading
18/19 May 10
25/26 November 10
London
London
Research
Meetings
Representation The STA lobbies on behalf of analysts with data vendors, exchanges and regulators.
The STA represents the UK at the International Federation of Technical Analysts (IFTA)
Accreditation
s
s
s
s
s
Bloomberg
CQG
eSignal
FutureSource
Reuters
more - www.updata.co.uk/private
www.updata.co.uk
Advanced Trading Tools