Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Saigo
Research Manager,
Mechanical Engineering Laboratory,
Agency of Industrial Science and Technology,
1-2 Namiki, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8564, Japan
e-mail: saigo@mel.go.jp
K. Tani
Professor,
Gifu University,
1-1 Yanagito, Gifu 501-1193, Japan
e-mail: tani@info.gifu-u.ac.jp
H. Usui
Nippon Steel Corporation,
2-6-3 Otemati, Chiyodaku, Tokyo 100-8071,
Japan
e-mail: usui@tekkai.nsc.co.jp
Introduction
Recently, traveling-wave control has been studied as an alternative to mode-based vibration control by several researchers.
Wave control has several advantages over mode-based vibration
control; it has no control and observation spillovers that may occur in the vibration control when there are some imperfections in
system modeling or inaccuracy in sensor locations; it has a better
control performance than vibration control at low frequencies; and
it is basically a local control method to which we have paid attention in our studies. The last feature means that we can suppress the
vibration of a system using no more than the information about
the dynamic states of the element nearest the actuator. This is
quite advantageous to the system whose parameters are changeable during control operations.
The studies of traveling-wave control include Vaughan 1, Von
Flotow 2,3, Millar 4, Mace 5, Fujii 6, Tanaka 7 and Utsumi 8. These studies of traveling-wave control of elastic beams
or strings have used the theoretical solution expressed in the form
of traveling wave and derived the nonreflecting condition of
waves at the control point. On the other hand, OConnor 9
treated a mass-and-spring system and presented a method of the
wave-absorption in a discrete vibration system. In these studies,
few attempts have been made to apply the wave control strategy
to practical vibrating systems to show the above-mentioned advantages of traveling-wave control.
In the previous paper 10, we presented a new practical wave
control strategy that is easy to build in a control computer with
on-line calculation of the imaginary wave-propagating system. We
applied the presented method to the vibration suppression of a
multiple-pendulum system and showed the effectiveness of the
method experimentally. There, vibration control by controlling the
support movement was addressed and no support movement for
traveling toward a given target position was considered.
In the present paper, the wave control method presented in the
previous paper is expanded to consider the combination of traveling control and vibration control. In this case, the control system
has to achieve a system displacement to a desired target position
Contributed by the Technical Committee on Vibration and Sound for publication
in the JOURNAL OF VIBRATION AND ACOUSTICS. Manuscript received May 2000;
Revised Jan. 2002. Associate Editor: R. L. Clark.
Equation of Motion
2.1 Multiple-Pendulum System. Figure 1 shows a traveling multiple rigid-pendulum system and a traveling wire-and-load
system. The equations of motion of a traveling multiple-pendulum
system of n degrees of freedom DOF are obtained using the
Lagranges equation of motion. The kinetic energy T k and the
potential energy U k of the k-th pendulum are expressed as
T k m k y 0
jk1
l j j
/2I k 2k /2m k y 0
jk1
U k m k g h k 1 2k /2
jk1
l j 1 2j /2
l j j k h k
k1
I k l 2k
i1
h k m k
k1
m i k l k
ik1
j1
j1
lj
i1
k1
m i h j m j j l k
i1
mi
k1
l i i g l k
i1
m i h k m k k 0
(1)
Downloaded 07 Jun 2008 to 203.199.213.130. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
q 1 p 1 J 1 / r 1 m 1 1 q 2 p 1 2 g m 1 r 2 m 2 p 1 1 2
0
q k1 p k1 k1 q k p k J k l k 1r k1 m k1 p k1 k
k2
q k1 p k k1 g
k1
j1
j1
m j r k1 m k1 p k1 k1
r k1 m k1 p k k1 0
m j r k m k p k p k1 k
j1
mj
k1,n
(2)
q n1 p n1 n1 J n l n 1r n1 m n1 p n1 n
n2
gp n1
j1
Control Strategy
n1
m j r n1 m n1 n1
j1
mj
r n m n n y 0
r k h k /l k ,
J k I k /l k ,
p k 1/ 1r k m k r k1 m k1 ,
q k J k h k m k
From the above equation, we see the term of the support movement appears explicitly only in the equation of the uppermost
pendulum.
2.2 Wire-and-Load System. The wire-and-load system
shown in Fig. 1 has a small rigid pendulum between the support
and the wire, and there is a load at the bottom of the wire. The
wire length is fixed. Assuming the equation of the wire is expressed by that of a dangling string and applying the finite difference method to the equation of motion, we obtain a system of
equations similar to that of a multiple simple-pendulum system
see Appendix. In the following numerical simulation, we will
treat the wire-and-load system as a non-homogenous multiplependulum system consisting of the uppermost rigid pendulum and
a large-DOF series of simple pendulums, among them the lowest
having a mass equal to that of the load.
344 Vol. 125, JULY 2003
Fig. 2 N-DOF imaginary system for traveling pendulum system y c : traveling command, x 0 : vibration control a Nontraveling Imaginary System NTIS, b Traveling Imaginary
System TIS
Downloaded 07 Jun 2008 to 203.199.213.130. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
geous first to move the system near the destination with less vibration and then to control the final position accurately. It is an
easy job for the control computer, given the present and target
positions, to cancel the error of the final position.
When the real pendulum system is connected to the imaginary
system, the acceleration of the lowest end of the imaginary system
is represented as
x 0
i 2 /lh g 0 h/l g 1 0
1h/l
(3)
Experiment
Downloaded 07 Jun 2008 to 203.199.213.130. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
pendulum are 60 mm, 40 mm and 15 mm, respectively. The diameter of the wire is 1 mm. The length of the wire and the weight
of the load can be changed.
The computation of the control is conducted by a DSP
TMS320C30 for the rigid-pendulum system and a personal computer with 200 MHz CPU for the wire-and-load system. The sampling period of A/D conversion is 0.1 ms for the rigid-pendulum
system and 2 ms for the wire-and-load system. A 10-DOF system
of simple pendulums has been used as the imaginary system.
4.1.2 Experimental Results. The following system movement pattern is used as the traveling command in the experiments;
the acceleration y c is 4.26 m/s2 for the time period between 0 s
and 0.0352 s and 0.01883 m/s2 between 0.0352 s and 8 s. Using
this acceleration pattern the pendulum system should travel the
distance of 0.60 m in 8 seconds.
a The case of the multiple-pendulum system
Figures 5 show the effects of the different initializing methods,
the PI and VI methods, for the 3-DOF traveling rigid-pendulum
system with 3. In these figures, the curve rising to the righthand side is the position of the support and the vibration waveform is the angle of the uppermost pendulum. From these figures,
we can confirm that our method is effective for a traveling pendulum system as well as for a nontraveling system. Figures 6
show the control performance of the PI method and the VI
method on the 1-DOF pendulum system three pendulums are
connected rigidly. Both initializing methods have excellent vibration suppressing effects. Similarly, the control performance on the
non-homogeneous 2-DOF pendulum system the lowest and the
middle pendulums are connected rigidly is well confirmed figures are not shown. The control program for the 2-DOF system is
the same as that for the 3-DOF system, for the uppermost pendulum and the total mass of the system are the same.
b The case of the wire-and-load system
Figures 7 show the effects of the different initializing methods,
the PI and VI methods, for the traveling wire-and-load system
with the wire length l0.5 m, the load weight w12.3 N and
3. In these figures, the curve rising to the right-hand side is the
position of the support and the vibration waveform is the angle of
the uppermost pendulum. From these figures we can see that the
VI method has quite an excellent damping performance Fig.
7c. The PI method is accurate in positioning the pendulum system at the traveling destination, but the vibration control performance is not so good. The performance of the VI method is not so
good figure is not shown. The vibration waveform shown in Fig.
7c resembles well that of the 1-DOF rigid pendulum shown in
Fig. 6b. This means the dynamic characteristics of the experimental wire-and-load system is similar to that of the 1-DOF rigid346 Vol. 125, JULY 2003
pendulum system and the vibration of the wire is practically negligible. Figures 8 show the effect of the wire length l and the load
weight w on the control performance of the VI method when
1. We can see the control performance is independent of the
change of the wire length and the load weight. Besides, the control performances in Fig. 8 for 1 are better than that in Fig.
7c for 3, which confirms that the quick wave propagation in
the imaginary system brings about a better performance in vibration suppression while the system is stable.
Downloaded 07 Jun 2008 to 203.199.213.130. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
Figures 9 show the results of the operation in which final positioning accuracy is concerned when the VI method is used for
vibration control. As stated earlier, this method can produce a
positioning error, and some measures should be taken when accurate positioning at the target is needed. Figure 9a is an overrun
case where the vibration control is switched to the VI method and
the traveling command is suppressed the instant the support
reaches the exact target position. Figure 9b is a case where the
positioning correction to the exact target position is carried out
using the VI method after the traveling command is over. Either
Fig. 8 Experimental results of wire-and-load system for different wire length and load weight with VI method 1,10. a
l 0.3 m, w 12.3 N b l 0.9 m, w 31.9 N
Fig. 10 Experimental result of nontraveling wire-and-load system for large amplitude with PI and VI methods l 0.3 m, w
12.3 N, 10, 10.
Downloaded 07 Jun 2008 to 203.199.213.130. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
4.2.1 Experimental Apparatus. Figure 12 shows the experimental model of a crane, which has a load suspended by a wire
and a pulley. One end of the wire is fixed to the motor shaft for
winding and the other end is fixed to a small rigid pendulum that
is attached to the nut of the ball-screw with free rotation. The
distance between the axis of the rigid pendulum and the wire
return on the returning pulley is equal to the diameter of the pulley. Then, the angle of the rigid pendulum is practically equal to
the swing angle of the load independent of its height when the
small vibrations of the wire can be ignored. This means the sta-
tionary direction of the pendulum is always vertical and the vibration suppression strategy for the wire-and-load system is applied
directly by monitoring one half of the load suspension system.
Our experiment has shown that it is possible to neglect the small
wire vibration in the wire-and-load system as well as in most
practical crane systems. The velocity pattern used of winding-up
and rewinding-down is 0.1 m/s and 0.1 m/s, respectively. The
load moves between the vertical positions of 0.9 m and 0.3 m
during the time period between 0 s and 6 s.
4.2.1 Experimental Results. Figures 13 show the experimental results for the case of winding up the load; a in Fig. 13 is the
case where no vibration control is used, b is the case with wave
control in the PI method, and c is the case with wave control in
the VI method. Figures 14 show the cases of rewinding down the
load with controls similar to those in Fig. 13. The system movement pattern is the same as in the case for the wire-and-load
system. In Fig. 13 we can see the amplitude of the vibration in
winding-up without control becomes larger as the wire length becomes shorter, due to the instability in winding-up of a suspended
load. The contrast in these figures demonstrates the effectiveness
of the stabilization using the wave-absorbing control. In addition,
the wave control method presented has shown an excellent control
performance regardless of the wire length. Figures 13b and
14b with the PI method for a large value of show relatively
good results in the final state of the load, that is, accurate final
position and small vibration. Thus, we can use the PI method to
position the system accurately at the target position if its vibration
suppression performance is acceptable. Even if the VI method is
Transactions of the ASME
Downloaded 07 Jun 2008 to 203.199.213.130. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
ratio of the mass of an imaginary system pendulum to that of the uppermost rigid pendulum
ratio of the length of an imaginary system pendulum to that of the uppermost rigid pendulum
angle of the uppermost rigid pendulum
angle of the lowest imaginary system pendulum
k angle of the k-th rigid pendulum numbered from
the free end
h k distance between the center of gravity of k-th
rigid pendulum and the axis of k-th connecting
pin
I k moment of inertia of k-th rigid pendulum about
the axis of k-th connecting pin
m k mass of k-th rigid pendulum
l k distance between the axes of the k-th and
(k1)-th connecting pins of the rigid pendulum
k angle of the k-th imaginary system pendulum
numbered from the lowest end
n
x 0 k1
l k k n: degrees of freedom of imaginary
system
y 0 horizontal displacement of the support imaginary
or real
y c traveling command
deflection of the wire
i deflection of the i-th finite element of the wire
z coordinates of the wire measured from the lower
free end
Appendix
We assume the equation of motion of the wire is expressed by
that of a dangling string. By balancing the horizontal component
of forces on an infinitely small element z(zdz), the following
equation is obtained as
Fig. 14 Experimental results of crane system for lowering load
total weight17.6 N. a No control, b Control with PI method
10, 10, c Control with VI method 1, 10
used, the final position errors are not very significant. Figures 13
and 14 have shown our wave absorbing method is useful for the
actual crane system.
Concluding Remarks
In this paper we propose a wave control method using a nontraveling imaginary multiple-pendulum system applied to vibration control of the traveling suspended system. We have shown
that the method presented, using little information about the suspended system states, is quite effective for a traveling suspended
system whose dynamics are changeable during operation. The initializing methods with and without shifting the support of the
imaginary system have their respective merits for the application.
The former realizes accurate final positioning while the latter realizes excellent vibration suppression. Combination of methods
can produce excellent overall performances. This control method
can readily be applied to real crane systems that have a moving
pulley and parallel wiring.
Nomenclature
g Gravitational acceleration
( ), ( ) first and second order differentiation with respect
* *
to time
i 2 square of radius of gyration on the supporting
point of the uppermost rigid pendulum
l length of the uppermost rigid pendulum
h distance between the supporting point and the
center of gravity of the uppermost rigid pendulum
0 ratio of the mass of the total real system to that of
the uppermost rigid pendulum
Journal of Vibration and Acoustics
M
2 1 2
z
0
z g t2
z2
(A1)
where is the lateral deflection of wire, z is the coordinate measured from the lowest end, is the mass of string per unit length
and M is the mass of load.
Appling the finite difference method to the above equation using the following approximations,
2
z
i1 2 i i1
z
i i1
,
z
z
ziz
we obtain
M
2 i i1 i1 i1 2i1 i i i1
z i1
g i
(A2)
Downloaded 07 Jun 2008 to 203.199.213.130. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm
References
1 Vaughan, D. R., 1968, Application of Distributed Parameter Concepts to
Dynamic Analysis and Control of Bending Vibrations, ASME J. Basic Eng.,
90, pp. 157166.
2 Von Flotow, A. H., 1986, Traveling Wave Control for Large Spacecraft Structures, AIAA J., 9, pp. 462 468.
3 Von Flotow, A. H., 1986, Disturbance Propagation in Structural Networks,
J. Sound Vib., 106, pp. 433 450.
4 Miller, D. W., and von Flotow, A. H., 1989, A Travelling Wave Approach to
Power Flow in Structural Networks, J. Sound Vib., 128, pp. 145162.
5 Mace, B. R., 1984, Wave Reflection and Transmission in Beams, J. Sound
Vib., 97, pp. 237246.
6 Fujii, H., and Ohtsuka, T., 1992, Experiment of a Noncollocated Controller
for Wave Cancellation, AIAA J., 153, pp. 9397.
7 Tanaka, N., and Kikushima, Y., 1992, Active Wave Control of a Flexible
Beam, JSME Int. J., Ser. III, 351, pp. 236 244.
8 Utsumi, M., 1999, Analytical Implementation of Wave-Absorbing Control
for Flexible Beams Using Synchronization Condition, ASME J. Vibr. Acoust.,
121, pp. 468 475.
9 OConnor, W., and Lang, D., 1998, Position Control of Flexible Robot Arms
Using Mechanical Waves, ASME J. Dyn. Syst., Meas., Control, 120, pp.
334 339.
10 Saigo, M., Tanaka, N., and Tani, K., 1998, An Approach to Vibration Control
of Multiple-Pendulum System by Wave Absorption, ASME J. Vibr. Acoust.,
121, pp. 524 533.
Downloaded 07 Jun 2008 to 203.199.213.130. Redistribution subject to ASME license or copyright; see http://www.asme.org/terms/Terms_Use.cfm