Sie sind auf Seite 1von 31






 
 !
"#
$

&%')(*+ -,*./0(
123547698:;=<)>@?BA9CEDFHGI"<45JLKNM5OPARQS?B452)TOP2LCVUI
WYXZ[S\$]_^a`cb/d\$efbgah ij\!gk]mlfnpoVqsr$o
WutkZv\!ewbV\$`hxgk`'y9^Eza\|{5lm\!emgkd\$e_^
W@}fZ'[S\$]=b~^a`cb/d\$efbgah^ b/lm\!d^b/qr$^a^ emvgad]m=b/\$`-pr$q\!emr$\!o
vgagk`V^amg=r~lmgpgkgah qeB\$o$
ijgksm\$ev+aafBXkBS=
 5
wExw

XkX =gad\j-gab~^ bVqgke jj


Rpp_NEB== " ! w !@p

t=X B^ad]m\ ocb/qsd^ bVqemb/lm\jm\!`Vqsz ^ bVqsza\gah ^"oVdgpgab/lhxmeBr!b/qsgke


&f p@m_p= P" f*-$wpk

}BX '^na\$oVq^aeewza\$`oVqgaeqe{5`/^ r!b/qsr$\ j


}Bt '^na\$oz=o-_`V\!wm\$efb/qsob jX
Bwp*kRp*xLmm
p
mX '^na\$oN-qsoVjjXEt
mt yl_^bqo'b/lB\|gkobvgkemo\$`cza^b/qsza\|{5`qgk`/X$
_9@j=! p$xp
p
=X '^na\$oN-qsoVjjXE
=t lm\^ b{5`Vqsgk`qoe=hxgk`Vd^ b/qzk\ jX
@9@x@9px *m*_kpa7*7| !R@9p
x *mP
p
_9@SwEPk_')=@@R_@
p
X

_9@| @ @k=&f &m *


pupp*k=

     
p gkszpqeB&^aeRqsewza\$`oV\]m`g
m\!dd\$^aemo'd^awqemqeBhx\!`V\!emr$\!o^ gaBb']mlfnpoVqsr^aonpobV\$do
hx`gkd`\^am^ b~^Blm\!oV\qeBhx\!`V\$eBr$\$oN^a`\ _^aoV\!gked^ b/lm\!d^b/qr$^a)`\$]m`\$o\$efb~^ bVqgkeBo
g hbVlm\ onpobV\$d o \ r^asb/lm\!oV\ `V\!]m`V\!oV\!ewb/^ b/qsgkemodgpm\!o$ Bemr!bVqgke_^ ogahb/lB\
dgpm\$so'`V\!]m`V\!oV\$efb-
g mo\$`cza^ m\]m`gk] \$`bVq\!ogahb/lm\jonpocb/\$d mhxgk`'\B^ad]B\a=b/lm\d^aoVo
B\$emoqsbn^ao-^hxmemr!bVqgkegahoV]_^ r$\qeb/lm\^a`bVl_b/lm\jm\!]Bb/lgah*b/lm\r$gkefbVqem\!ewbVo$_b/lB\
`V^amqsmogah*b/lm\jr$ga`V\ d^ ewbV\ gkmemm^a`na
e hxgk`d&mH^b/qeBqsewza\$`oV\"]m`V g m\!do^aem qefb/\!`V]m`\!bVqemqsefzk\$`oVqsgke \$obVqd^ b/\!o \
eB\$\$b/g^amB`V\$oo-bVlm\hxgksg qem&wm\!obVqgkemo!
~ Ng ^ar$r!m`/^b/\$n^ `V\bVlm\m^ b~^wemg el_^ bqso$ l_^ bmgp\$oqsbd\$^ae9bVg
 bb/lB\m^ b~ ^ f
~ Ng ^ar$r!m`/^b/\$n qojb/lm\]mlfnpoVqr$^aocnpob/\!d dgpm\$s\$+[Sgp\$ojb/lB\dg=m\!qe 
r$Bm\^a b/lm\j]mlfnpoVqsr^a\ )\!r!b/ob/lm^ b-r$gkefb/`q m=b/\joVqskemq  r^aefb/nbVgb/lm\j_^ b/^f
V~yl_^ b qsowemg e" ^ gkBbb/lm\dgpm\$p]_^a`V^ad\!b/\!`Voqemm\!]\!emm\!ewbVsngahmbVlm\'_^ b/^f
e gabVlm\$` ga`Vmo! lm^ bBg=\!oqsbd\^ae hxgk`^dg=B\$'b/g \`V\$^aoVgae_ ^ ms\gk`
mem`V\$^aoVgae_ ^ ms\E
lm\emg b/\5qo)gk`Vf^ emq !!\$^aohxgksg o$e|=\$rb/qsgke"t \oV\bb/lm\5a\$em\!`/^akhx`V^ad\ ga`V
hxga`bVlm\qsefzk\$`oV\S]B`V
g ms\$do5b/l_^ #b qs$ \r$gaemoVqsm\$`\$5e=\$rb/qgae%} \]B`V\$o\$efb'&b g
B'q \$`V\!efb^a]m]m`gf^ar~lm\!o w(n lmqr~lR]B`Vqga`qe=hxgk`Vd^ b/qsgker^a)e \qemr!mB\$qseRk\$gk]Blwnp*o 
qsr^aqefzk\!`VoV\r^ r$BH^ bVqgkemo!'^na\$oVq^ae^aem hx`V\$wm\!efb/qocb lm\!oV\&b g^a]m]m`gf^ar~lm\!o
B'q \$`&hxmemm^ad\!efb~^assnqe b/lm\d\^aeB+o w,n lmqr~l]m`V g _ ^ mqsqsbnqoqsefb/`Vgpmmr!\$qefb/g
bVlm\Rr^ r$BH^ bVqgkelm\!n ^ oVgb~^a \hxmem_^ad\$efb/^anB'q \$`V\!efb^a]m]m`gf^ar~lm\!o&b/gb/lB\
bV`V\$^ b/d\$efbgahbVlm\
g mo\$`za\$ _^ b/^R^aem ]m`qgk`NqeBhxgk`d^b/qgaeS'^na\$oVq^aemojqefbV`Vgpmmr$\
]B`V
g _^ mqsqsb/qs\$o gkeRb/lm\o]_^ar!\g hdg=B\$oW@]m`qgk`qeBhxgk`d^b/qgaeqo'bVlwmo]m`V
g m ^ mqsqocb/qrZ
^ em"r$gkemBqsb/qsgkegke&bVlm\
g moV\!`za\$m^ b~^B_`V\$wm\!efb/qocb/o!pgae"bVlm\gab/lB\$`5l_^aeBw^aoVomd\
^RmqsobV`Vq BBb/qsgke ]m`Vqsgk`bVg g moV\!`zpqemb/lB\m^ b~^B- lBqr~l mg=\!ojemgabr~l_^aema\gaemr$\b/lB\
m^ b~^"l_^zk\ \!\$e g moV\!`zk\!^ emmo\B\!b/\!`VdqemqsobVqr]m`qgk`qseBhxgk`Vd^ bVqgk-e =]m`V g _ ^ mqs. 
qbn\$efb/\!`VobVlm\|r$^ar!mH^b/qgaemoz=q^bVlm\|_^b~^\!`V`gk`Vo!/ lmqsr~l ^a`V\|^aoVomd\$bVgl_^zk\&^
`V^aemmgad r$gkd]gaem\$efb-lm\r~lmgkqr!\|gah ]m`Vqsgk`]m`V
g m ^ mqsqsbndgpm\$hxgk`b/lB\&'^nk\!oVq^ae
qseBhx\$`\$emr!\Sqoemgab'^a' ^n=or$\$^a`\zk\!0e lB\$eb/lB\S]m`Vqsgk` qeBhxgk`d^b/qgaeqs1o \$ m\  em\$2
bVlmqoqso-BqoVr!moVo\$ qsep\$r!bVqgke^ em\B\!d]Bq  \$0 qsb/l^bVgEn]m`V
g B\$dqe=\$rb/qgae
p-lB\&\B^ad]m\qsmocb/`V^ b/\!o-lB3g  `\$]m`\$o\$efb/qsemRm\!bV\$`dqsemqocb/qrjr!gkemobV`/^aqsefb/o]B`V
g 
^ mqsqobVqr$^and^n q5e 4\!r!bqeBhxga`Vd^ b/qsgke qefb/gb/lm\r^asr$m^ b/qsgke b/l_^b|qsoemg b|ocb/`Vqsr!bVsn
}

`\$wmqs`V\$6 fnb/lm\-r$gaemobV`/^aqsewb$ lmqso ]B`Vg


ms\$d7 \$r!gkd\$o8ga`VoV\-qe"lmqsklmqd\$emoqgkem^a
o]_^ar!\$o$ e =\!r!b/qsgkem6o 9 ^aem: \]B`VgEzpqm\b&g\B^ad]B\$og hNqsefzk\$`oV\]m`g
m\!do
m^aoV\!gke`V\$^a_^ b/^&b/g"qsmocb/`/^b/\NbVlm\j]gaqefb/o`/^ qoV\!qeRb/lm\jemg b/\a

;#<; =>1?A@CBD>8E$FGE$H>1I

-\$`\qso^olmgk`cboVmdd^ `ng hb/lB\eBgab~^ bVqgkebVl_^ bJqs2 \jmoV\!lm\!emr$\hxgk`bVl


Kmqd5\$emlmoq\jgkemoV]_^au^ar!\g mh MLO^aN`cb/WQPSlR dZ gpm\!o$5Lsqem\$^a`za\$r!bVgk`oV]_^ r$\amo_^assnqse  emqb/\
T np]mqsrlm^a\ssn)oV]_P^ar!=U \|Vgah lmd\!`V\$\%^aW oVmq`o'\$db/lB\$\efewb/o!mdX e\!]m`-`Vg ^ahr!bVg
qB r$oV\\$^a`cz .' ^ b/^qsnpgko emo$ emqsbV\mqsd\!emoVqsgke_^aP
[^b~^`/^aeBmgkd z ^a`qH^ B \a=moVm^anzk\!r!bVgk`-z ^asm\$)
#Y ^am\!o-b/^aa\!egkeZf n _b/lB\_^b~^B \[ T ylm\!`V\b/lm\!`V\|qsoemg_^ emk\$`
gahr!gkeBhxmoqgke) \% qsmoV\ ^aeB qsewbV\$`r~l_^aemk\$^ m nk
5Ldgpm\!gk`]_^a`V^ad\!b/\!`$ [ K
] WfZV^_aB` WfZ5=] \$r!b/^ b/qsgke^aemza^ `VqH^ emr$\gk] \$`V^ b/ga`Vo$
g=m\!o^a`V\"mo_^assn ]_^a`V^ad\!b/\!`Vq'$! \$ oVgb/l_^b\!obVqd^ b/qsem^dg=B\$qoj\$wmqz ^a\!ewb
bVg\!ob/qsd^b/qeBRqsb/or$ga`V`V\!oV] gkemmqsem]m^a`/^ad\!bV\$`o$Bb$r!\$^a`Vnkb/lm\r~lmgkqsr$\g h'g

o\$`cza^m \!o|^aeB]_^ `/^ad\!bV\$`Vq'! ^ bVqgkeqojemgabmemqswm\a_gk`qemocb~^aeBr$\a*qe ]m`g
m s\$dogah
\!H^aocb/qsr$qsbnX \Nr^aemoV\-b/lm\N\$H^ ob/qsrob/q.) eB\$oVo b/\!emoVgk` gahbVlm\-\$H^ ob/qsrr$gkd]mq^aemr!\bV\$e
ogk`$y\|r^ emoV\' ^zk\b o]\!\$gk`' ^za\&oVsg3 eB\$oVo!Se\$obVqd^ b/ga`-g h ^dg=m\!
Wxgk`N^hxmemrb/qgae_^ab/lm\!`V\!gah~Z-qoN^hxmemrb/qgae:c Ted K -lm\&\$ocb/qsd^ bVgk`-d^nX4 mocb
\!obVqd^ b/\bVlm\]_^a`V^ad\!b/\!`Vo bVl_^ br~l_^a`V^ar!bV\$`q$! \'bVlm\dgpm\!ulm\\$ocb/qd^ bV\'kqsza\$eb/lB\
m^ b~^ qoB\$emgabV\$^aoBc W Z
f g h 8iXjlk Gi m 6Ln po q  S  rs5 6tZu
$j m
NoNbVlm\|`\$oVBsbSg hoVgkd\d\^ oVm`\$d\$efbgk`No\!bg h5d\$^aoVB`V\$d\$efbVo$^epBdv \!`W gah
m^ b~^"^a`\r!gks\$rb/\$) lB\^ dgkBewb-gah_^ b/^qo^a.' ^npo  emqsbV\ \!r^amo\qsemobV`Vmd\$efbVo
lm^Eza\  emqsbV\J_ ^aem qBbVly\moV_^ snb~^ a\'b/lB\-m^ b~^So]_^ar$\ T b/gw \PBU lm\_^ b/^

^ `V\`\$H^b/\$bVgb/lm\]mlfn=oqr$^a'dg=m\!ob/lm`gkmklbVlm\hxgk`x^a` dgpm\$sqemgk] \$`V^ b/gk`


W@^aogwemge ^ o-bVlm\m^ b~^"d^ ]m]mqeBwZlm\hxgk`'^ `Vga]\!`/^ bVgk`qo-^hxmeBr!b/qsgkeb/l_^ b
d^a]mo'za\$rb/gk`o-hx`gkd0dg=m\!oV]m^ar$\jqefbVgm^ b~^oV]m^ar$\
y K dzT0{
e"]m`V^ar!bVqr!\bVlm\'hxgk` '^a`ga]\!`/^ bVgk` qso5^a. '^npo ^ae^a]m]m`gE=qsd^ bVqgke)e"k\!gk]mlfnpoVqr!o
bVlmqoqso-]B`Vqd^a`qs6n \$r$^amoV\gkem\jr^ emy emgab^ gk`Vb/g`V\!]m`V\!oV\$efbNb/lm\jb/`m\jr$gkd]m\=qsbn
g h b/lm\|^a`bVlgker$gkd]mBbV\$`$- zk\!e qshb/lmqso \$`\&]gaoVoV'q m\jqbdqklfb-emga|b %\ gk`bVl
bVlm\}\ gk`cbkqsza\$eRb/lB\qemocb/`VBd\!ew b ~ o`\$ogkBbVqgke^ emRemgkqsoV\\zk\!qebVlm\_^ b/^B5lmqo
qs \mqsoVr$BoVoV\!qsem\!b/^aqmqseb/lm\emgabV\a mBb5hxga`5emg qsboV r$\!o bV%g \-^ '^a`\b/l_^ b
bVlm\$`\qso^ e|\$``Vgk`^aooVgpr$qH^b/\$% qsbVl|moqem y =qsemr$\b/lBqo qa \^ae|\!`V`Vga`^aooVgpr$q^ b/\!
qb/l9bVlm\^ mqsqsbn b/g]m`V\!mqrb|b/lB\d\^aom`V\!d\!ewb$5qsbqo|^ae Wmqd\$eBoVqgae_^a5zk\!r!b/ga`
qe_^ snab/lB\$`V)\ qs" \^a\e Wmqd\$emoqgkem^aza\$r!bVgk`"gahN`/^aemBgkd d\^aom`V\!d\!efb
\!`V`gk`Vo! =gbVlm\jr$gkemeB\$r!bVqgke \!&b \$\$edgpm\!o^aem_^ b/^r^ae S\ `qsbb/\$e^ao!
y W -Z {
iqsza\$ed\^ oVm`\$d\$efb/o =bVlm\Skgk^aqsobVg&\$ocb/qd^ bV\-bVlm\Sdg=m\! W@gk`^hxmemrb/qsgke_^a
W ZVZ hxmemrb/qsgkeg hbVlm\m^ b~^Rb/l_^bjqojmoV\!bVg\!ob/qsd^b/\b/lm\"dg=B\$ W@qP \ s
bVlm\jqefzk\!`Voqgke^aagk`Vqb/lmdZqsor^as\!^ae\!obVqd^ b/gk`gah
-gab/\SbVl_^ b'oqemr!\ d^a]Bo^aeRqe  emqsbV\mqsd\!emoVqsgke_^a oV]m^ar$\qsewbVg^  emqb/\SBqd\$e 
oqgkem^aNo]_^ar!\ab/lm\my^ b~^9d^a]m]Bqeml_^aoR^9eBgke bV`Vqz=q^aa\!`Vem\!u =gm\zk\!e qseb/lB\
^ moV\!emr$\"gahd\^aom`V\!d\!efb^aem dg=m\!qsem\!`V`Vga`VobVlm\_^ b/^d^ ]m]mqeB qsemg b \
qsefzk\$`cb/'q m\^aem b/lm\oV\b|g hdgpm\!oSb/lm^ b|]B`V\$Bqr!bjbVlm\_^b~^\$w_^ass:n \$s d^n \
wmqb/\'^a`Va\a*lmqo qseqsbVoV\$h_qe|emgab^S]m`
g ms\$d b/lB\]m`V
g B\$d qsGo lm\$ebVlm\$o\\$w_^assn
]B`V\$Bqr!bVqemdgpm\!onpq\$s qsmn m'q \$`\$efb|z ^asm\$ohxgk`jb/lm\dgpm\$hxmemrb/qsgke_^a8 \
^ `V\'qsewbV\$`\$obV\$qen&qsemr$smmqsemS]m`qgk`qeBhxgk`d^b/qga%e \-^ bVbV\$d]Bb b/gr!gkemocb/`/^ qe&b/lB\
`V^aemk\gah'hx\$^aoV'q m\"dg=B\$o^aeBb/lwmor$gkefbV`Vgkb/lm\}\ \$rb&gahb/lmgko\ewms\$\!d\!efb/o$
lBqoqo"qsmocb/`/^b/\$ qb/l^ae \B^ad]B\qe =\$rb/qsgketpsXk zk\$e lm\$e bVlm\$`\qso^
Bemqwm\"oVgaBbVqgkeqbjd^n \"memocb~ ^ ms\b/goVd^a]\!`b/B` _^ bVqgkeBoqse b/lm\"_^ b/^B"e
bVlmqor$^aoVw\ \d^n^asoVgmo\ogkd\]B`Vqga`qeBhxgk`d^b/qgaeb/g"ocb~ ^ mqs'q !$\bVlm\joVgksBb/qsgke

O<; 0F?A*@1ZE$Hx?FGE$HxISEMS@@H&8FGE$H*1@>1F$?>>E$
IS2E$H>1I
*g|dgabVqsz ^ b/\'bVlm\BqoVr!moVoqgke\bBor$gaemoVqsm\$`^oqd]m\\B^ad]ms\ lBqr~lolmg ob/lB\
eB\$r$\!oVoqsbngah_qsemr$smmqeB]m`Vqsgk`qeBhxgk`d^b/qgae ^ b/\!`$qe|=\$rb/qsgke|m3 \# qsfqefbV`Vgpmmr$\

bVg=gaohx`Vgkdob~^b/qocb/qsr^am\!r$qsoVqgaeb/lB\$gk`cnbVl_^ bN^asg7mob/gw_^aefb/qhnRb/lm\qeV_B\$emr!\
g hm.q )\!`V\!ewbbnp] \$o-gah]B`Vqga`'qeBhxga`Vd^ b/qsgke
=B]m]gaoV"\ \'l_^zk\emgkqocnj
g mo\$`z ^ bVqgkeBogah^NoVdg=gabVlhxBemr!bVqgke ^ b*b/lm\\$wmqBqo 
b/^aefb-]gkqsefb/o _-" {{{ U
3 W M@Z x
X {.{'{ W
WcXZ
lB\$`V\"b/lB\\!`V`Vga`V%o x^a`V\^aooVmd\$ b/g 0\ QW@V -NZ y+\ '^ ewbb/gmo\"bVlm\$o\
g moV\!`z ^ b/qsgkemob/g"\!ob/qsd^b/\bVlm\jm\$`qsz ^ b/qzk\ y9\jm\  em\jb/lm\j\$ocb/qsd^ bVgk`
W MGuZ 3/G 
WutkZ
lB\$`V\ qobVlm\Bqob/^aemr!\ \!&b \$\$eRr!gkemo\$r$=b/qsza\]gaqefb/o!B^aeB( M W M/M:MxxZ kt=
*gd\$^aoVB`V\&b/lB\]\!`hxgk`d^aeBr$\&gahbVlm\\$ocb/qd^ bVgk`WPtk|Z \BoV\b/lm\d\^ e oVw_^a`\$
\!`V`gk`Wu=Zlm\za^ `VqH^ emr$\j^aeBZ mq^aogah'WutkZ'^ `V\
Y ^ ` W MGP*Z t N N
qH^ao WMuZ* ] W WMGuZG\ WMZZ
W M/VZG \ WM@Z \ WMZ WxZG WMPZ
hxga`NogkdX\ [ MM/*P-y\&em\!\$ dgk`V\qeBhxga`Vd^ b/qsgkeRb/g^ oVoV\!oVoSbVlm\&oVq'!$\gah b/lB\
BqH^ao! \b-mo-^aoVomd\bVl_^ bb/lB\o\$r!gkemB\$`Vqz ^ b/qzk\qJo gkmeBm\$gke _M
W Z  [ _M {
bbVlm\$ehxgksg ob/l_^b
qH^ o W MGP&Z x QW $xZ!W $xZ 
hxga` ogkd\ $ \!&b \$\!)e )^aem M No d b/lB\-z ^a`qH^aemr!\kg=\!o5b/gqe  eBqsbvn lmqs\
bVlmw\ mqH^ okg=\!ob/g !$\!`Vgmlm\BqsJo gamemm\!Z fn
t N B| W M&Z Y ^a` W MP*Z qH^ o W MGP*Z N t N N N { WP}fZ
N
N

 5b 553*p ax  xbGQ38b5}0b3xxx3}J3x88Ob

b"qso&r$s\^a`&bVl_^ b"r~lmgpgkoqembVlm\oVd^as\$ob ] gkoVoq ms\mgp\$o"emgab"s\^abVg b/lm\) \$ocb


\!obVqd^ b/\ bVlm\emgkqsoV\l_^ oSb/0g \&3b/ ^aa\!eqsefb/g^ar$r!gkmefbe h@^arbbVlm\"g\!objm]B]\!`
gkmeBqo-
g Bb/^aqem\!hxgk` t -lm\&H^ `Vk\!`-bVlm\z ^a`qH^aemr!\g h5b/lm\emgkqo\a
bVlmS\ qB\$`'b/lB\o]_^ar!qem \!&b \$\$eb/lm\] gkqsewbVo$=b_m+g \`\^assnem\!\$bVg"^aoVomd\
^ ewndgk`V\]m`Vqsgk`qseBhxgk`Vd^ bVqgkeEqse^amBqsb/qsgkebVgSdg=m\!WYXZ b/Sg gkmem&bVlm\='y\
Bgm^a \'^aefnoVdg=g b/ljhxmemr!bVqgke y lmqsr~lz ^aemqsoVlm\!o ^ bbVlm\] gkqefbVo - {'{.{ x U lm\$e
bVlm\hxmemrb/qga
e y o/^ bVqo  \$ojb/lm\"o/^ d\"dg=m\!^ao nk\bbVlm\$qs`B\$`Vqz ^ b/qzk\$o
r!gkms \zk\!`nm.q )\!`V\$efb$_gk`\B^ad]m\ _r~lmg=gaoV\^aeqefb/\!k\$` ^aemm\  em\
y W Z oVqe 5t - W -VZ {
lB\$e W MxZ y W MxZ W MZ^ em
W Z W Z 5t - r!gko 5t W ( -VZ {
n r~lmgpgkoVqsem) ^a`Vk\|\$emgkBkl \"r$^ae d^a \b/lm\m.q )\!`V\!emr$\ W MZ W MuZ
^ o^a`Vk\ ^ o \ ^aefb qsb/lBgkBb]m`Vqsgk`qeBhxga`Vd^ b/qsgk
e \9r^ e emg b\!ob/qsd^b/\b/lB\
B\$`Vqz ^ b/qzkS\ qsbVl  emqsbV\jmemr$\!`b/^aqefbnk

i   i&
 
nk5

i&  5
 5 po  n qZu

lB\$`V\^a`V\b&g|hxmem_^ d\!ewb/^an&mq.)\!`V\!ewbd\$^aemqsemkogah)bVlm\NbV\$`d  ]m`Vg _^ mqsqsbnjqe


r!gkddgkemo/^aa\"Wu=r$^a\!o +pemq\!m\$`!)XEk
9kZ5h \Sb/gkoo^|r$gkqs0e b/qsd\!o$lm\$`\
qso^a`Va\a=^aemo\$\S`gkmklm6n ktlm\^aBo$=bVlm\$e \SoV^Enb/lB\]m`
g _ ^ mqsqbngahk\bVbVqem|^
lB\^aqe^-aqszk\!ebVgkoVo*qo* ^ gkBb  lmqso*qsefb/\$`]m`V\b~^ bVqgkejgahB]m`V g _ ^ mqsqsbna _^ao\$|gae
bVlm\hx`\$wm\$eBr!nRgahgaBb/r!gkd\!o'gah`V^aemmgkdb/`V^aqso$wqo b/lm\!`V\hxgk`V\r$^as\$  hx`V\$wm\!efb/qocb m
Seb/lB\-g b/lm\!` lm^aem"qsbqso r$gkddgke&b/gjlm\$^a`ob~^b/\$d\$efbVo omr~l^ o$  b/lm\]m`
g _ ^ mqsqbn
g h`/^aqse|b/gkdgk``Vg qo5  vm5=qsemr$\b/lmqso ob/^ b/\!d\!ewb mg=\!o5emgab5`\!hx\!`b/gSbVlm\'`V\!]\$^ b/\!
gaBb/r!gkd\-gah^`/^aeBmgkd b/`qH^aPfqsb qo emgab'^hx`V\!wm\$efb/qsobmoV\Sg hb/lm\-b/\!`Vd]m`V g _ ^ mqsqsbna
-^ bVlm\$`!qbr!gkefzk\!npoj^ocb~^ bV\$d\$efbSg h5qeBhxga`Vd^ b/qsgke W@gk`NH^ar~bVlm\$`\$gah/Z-lmqsoqob/lB\
^Ena\$oqH^aeRmo\gah  ]m`V
g m ^ mqsqsbn mgabVlqm\$^ao oV\$\!de_^b/m`V^a_b/g&ogkd\-m\!k`V\!\amog&qsb
qso]\!`Vl_^ ]momeBhxgk`cb/me_^b/\b/l_^b-bVlm\jo/^ad\Sb/\!`Vd0qsomoV\!bVgB\$oVr!`V'q \b/lB\$d
'^na\$oVq^ae&qsewza\$`oVqgae|l_^ao*f^aqsem\$r$gkeBoVqB\$`/^ m\] gk]mm^a`VqbnqeqsbVo^a]B]mqsr^ bVqgkeSbVg
a\$gk]mlfnpoVqsr^a qefza\$`Vo\S]m`
g m\!do!lm\N]mlmqsgkogk]mlfn"gahbVlmqo ]m`Vgpr$\!mm`\qo^aohxgksg o$

p m]m] gkoV\gaem\wemgooVgkd\!bVlmqeB^ gkBb&^dgpm\!# \!hxga`V\moqemb/lm\_^ b~^=lmqo


wemgs\$mk\qsoSr^ objqe ^]B`Vg
_^ mqsqobVqrjhxgk`Vd^aem qsoSr^ \!b/lm\|]m`Vqsgk`S]m`g
_^ mqsqbn
dgpm\$P{5`qgk`d\^aeBo \!hxga`V\b/lm\_^ b/^-lm^Eza\" \$\!e|`V\!r$gk`m\$2 kqu \a qseBhxgk`d^ bVqgkeNb/l_^ b
qso|qsemm\$] \$eBm\$efbgahb/lm\m^ b~^bVg \`V\!r$gk`m\$)hgkem\l_^ao^oV\!b&gah_^ b/Z^ lmgko\
ocb~^ bVqocb/qr$^aSr~l_^ `/^arb/\$`qocb/qr!o^a`V\ wemg e W@\ BsbVlm\ _^ b~^ r$gEz ^a`qH^aemr!\ d^ bV`Vq hxgk`
ij^amooVq^ae\$``Vgk`o~Zb/lB\$e'^nk\!oVqH^ eqsefzk\$`oVqsgkej]m`VgEzpqm\!o*^hx`/^ad}\ gk`V-hxgk`r$gavd mqeBqem
bVlm\]m`V
g m ^ mqsqocb/qr]B`Vqga`dgpm\$qseBhxgk`Vd^ bVqgke qb/lb/lm\qeBhxgk`d^b/qgaer$gkefb/^aqem\!qe
bVlm\
g BoV\$`czk\!m^ b~^9qsegk`m\$`b/g`\  em\bVlm\]m`qgk`mqsob/`q m=b/qgae lB\m] _^ b/\!
BqobV`V'q mBb/qsgke qob/lB\] gkobV\$`Vqsgk`"dgpm\!mqocb/`V'q mBbVqgke kqzk\$eb/lm\_^ b/V^ qsbq+o l_^b
\|wemg  ^hb/\$` \l_^za\&^aooVqdq^ b/\!Rb/lm\_^ b/^^aeBb/lB\]m`qgk`qseBhxgk`d^ bVqgke) lB\
] gkqsewbgahSmoVqsembVlm\_^b~^ qo"b/l_^ bb/lB\] gkobV\$`Vqsgk`"dgpm\!-qseBhxgk`d^ bVqgke lBgk]\hxmn
r!gkemocb/`/^ qemob/lB\dgpm\$dgk`\b/qsklfb/snb/l_^ ebVlm\j]m`Vqsgk`dg=m\!mqsob/`q m=b/qgae
-3g \!za\$`!pbVlm\emgabVqgkegah ]m`qgk`dgpm\$pob/^ b/qsobVqr$o5r$^aeqe]B`/^arb/qr!J\ \ogkd}\ l_^ b
ol_^afnko^ae\m^ d]ms\akr!gkemoqm\!`5^SoV\!qoVdqroVm`czk\nkeoVmr~l^Soqsb/m^ b/qsgke&gkem\d^n
lm^Eza\^h@^ q`Vn^ar$r!m`/^b/\jqm\$^&gahb/lm\`V^aemk\!ogah*oV\$qsoVdqrza\$sg=r!qsbn^aemm\$eBoVqsbnb/l_^ b
^ `V\`\^asqobVqr ^aem ] \$`l_^a]mo\zk\!e bVlm\zk\!`bVqr^ r$ga`V`V\!H^ bVqgke\!emab/lW@qsh gk`\ lBgk\
d\^ oVm`\$d\$efb/o^a`\^z ^aq ^ m\Z Ng \!zk\!`$_b/lB\Slmgk`q !$gaewb/^a \$eBab/lRor^as\gahb/lB\zkb\ 
sg=r!qsbn^aem m\$eBoVqsbn z ^a`qH^ bVqgkeqoSb/g^RH^a`k\\pbV\$efb|Bemwemg eRiqsza\$e b/lmqso$lmg 
r$^ae'^nk\$oqH^ae qefza\$`Voqgke \"oVg]gk]BmH^a|` lm\$e gkm`j]m`qgk`Swemg s\$mk\"qsogahb/\!eog
] gpgk`~7lm\`V\^ oVgke hxgk`b/lmqsoqsob/l_^ bqe ]m`V^ar!bVqr!\bVlm\hxga`Vd^aqsoVdgah']m`qgk`dgpm\$
ocb~^ bVqocb/qr!o'qoBoV\$RbVg`\$kBH^a`q !$\-b/lm\j] gkobV\$`qgk`'ogk=b/qgae =bgkkqsr^assnawbVlm\]m`qgk`
BqobV`V'q mBb/qsgked&mo"b \peB3g e^]m`Vqsgk`VqPpqs(e lmqsr~lRr^ao\Sqsbr^ ememgabd^ bb/\!#` lm\b/lm\!`
qb`\$kBH^a`q !$\!oNbVlm\|]m`
g ms\$d WuigkBza\$qH^  pr^as\$o$XEka 9aZ-e ]m`/^arb/qsr$\a zpqH^^oVmbr 
r!\$ooVqgae gahm'q \$`\$efbr$^ar!mH^b/qgaemo$b/lm\r~l_^a`V^ar!bV\$`qobVqr!ogahNb/lm\]m`qgk`"dg=m\!^a`V\
g hb/\$e b/Bem\$ qe oVBr~l^ '^n bVl_^ bb/lB\`\!b/`q\zk\$ dg=m\! l_^aojo$ 4\$rb/qzk\$n ^ak`\$\ 
^ m\|hx\$^ b/B`V\$o!&-gab/\&bVl_^ bjqeoVmr~l^ae ^a]m]m`gf^ar~l b/lB\]m`Vqsgk`Sdg=m\!ocb~^ bVqobVqr!o^a`V\
BoV\$^]gkocb/\!`Vqga`Vq)bVg"bVmem\b/lB\`\!bV`Vq\zk\!dg=m\! 
'^na\$oVq^ae ob/^ b/qsobVqr$o`V\!q\!or!gkd]m\b/\$n gke9bVlm\oV] \$r!q  r$^ b/qsgkegah']m`Vqsgk`dgpm\$
ocb~^ bVqocb/qr!o$qu \agaeb/lm\|peB3g s\$ma\&b/l_^ bgkem\l_^aoSgah5bVlm\&dg=B\$ \hxgk`V\moVqsemb/lB\
`\$r!gk`Vm\!m^ b~^B9lm)\ _\=q Bqqbn b~^a \$e qse moVqsem b/lm\R]B`Vqga`&dgpm\!'ob/^ b/qsob/qsr$o"^ao
^Rwem
g b/gRbVmem\]m`gk]\!`bVq\$og hbVlm\"`V\!bV`Vqs\!zk\!dgpm\$*b/lm\!`V\!hxga`V\"qor!gkd]B\!bV\$n^ b
gpmmo qsb/lb/lm\R]mlBqgaoVgk]mlfn gah-'^na\$oVq^ae qefzk\!`Voqgke lBqo&mgp\$o|emgabd\^aeb/l_^ b
bVlm\$`\qo^aefnwb/lmqsem `VgkeBw qb/l'^nk\!oVq^aeqsewza\$`oVqgaea mBb qsb mg=\!ooVmka\$obbVl_^ b5b/lB\
`\^aogkehxgk`-b/lm\&] gk]mBH^a`qsbngah '^nk\!oVq^ae qefzk\!`Voqgk:e qb/lmqseb/lm\& ^ `b/l or$qs\$emr!\$oqo
qsemr$gaemoVqsob/\!efXb qsbVlbVlm\meBm\$`snpqem]mlmqsgkogk]mlfnkR r$gkddgae9^ bb/qb/mm\oV\!\$dobVg
\a  hlm^am-e ~ b \!q\zk\!qbm# gamm2e ~ bl_^za\o\$\$eqsb$ 

J<;

\F"@VHFIIO"@M$H*>1I

HxIMF82EMH*@
e ]m`V^ar!bVqr!\Rqsbqso&mq'r!msb&bVg lmgkem\!ob/nmo\'^nk\$o}~lm\$gk`\$d bVg oVgkzk\`V\$^aqsobVqr
qsefzk\$`oV\ ]m`g
ms\$do$LSe bVlm\gkeB\l_^aeBb/lm\qseBhxgk`d^ bVqgke^ bgkm`mqo]gkoV^ab/l_^ b
r!gkms \`V\!f^a`m\$R^ o" \$qeBwemg e^|]m`qgk`q_qo lmqalmsn&z ^a`q\!^aemgahb/\!emq'r!msb
bVgw_^aefb/qhn|g
4\$r!bVqsza\$snaSe&b/lm\g b/lm\!` l_^aem^Sr!gkd]B\!bV\''^na\$oVq^ae^ae_^anpoVqod^n
\jr$gkd]mBb/^ b/qsgke_^assn"qsewbV`/^arb~^ B \a
lm\!`V\9^a`V\ b& gqd]ga`b~^ ewbwm\!obVqgkemob/lm^ blm^Eza\bVg \9^ mm`V\!oVo\$7qse ^aefn

^Ena\$oqH^aeqefzk\!`Voqgke
Ng +Bg \`\$]m`\$oV\!efbbVlm\]m`qgk`NqeBhxgk`d^b/qgae lBqo^a]B]mqs\$oS gab/lb/gb/lB\
]m`Vqsgk`'dg=m\!qe=hxgk`Vd^ b/qsgkeR^aeBbVgbVlm\jm\$or$`q]BbVqgkegah*b/lm\j_^b~^ob/^ b/qsob/qsr$o!
Ng 7m+g \omdd^a`q !!\b/lm\j] gkobV\$`qgk`qseBhxgk`Vd^ bVqgke
lB\|oV\!r$gkeBwm\$ocb/qgaeqob/lm\\^ oVq\!obNb/g^aemxo \$`!^ bN\$^aobNqe]m`qemr!q]ms\a'bNqGo 4mocb
^d^ bb/\!`Ngah5^a]m]mn=qsem^Ena\$}o ~)b/lm\!gk`V\!d b/gr!gkd]BBb/\b/lm\]gkocb/\!`Vqga`mqsob/`q m=b/qgae
y\"b/lm\!e9mo\bVlmqojmqsob/`q m=b/qgaeb/gocb/m=n b/lm\ob/^ b/qsob/qsr$ojgahm'q \$`\$efb]_^a`/^ d\b/\$`
\!obVqd^ b/\!o$"_gk`S\m^ d]ms\a \r$^ae  em r$`V\!mq B\`V\!kqgaemoShxgk`Sb/lB\dgpm\$]_^a`/^ d 
\b/\!`VoSkqzk\!eb/lm\_^ b/^Bga`Noqd]msnmo\&] gkobV\$`Vqsgk`-d\$^aemoN^ao\!ob/qsd^b/\$o^aem] gkocb/\ 
`qgk`jocb~^aemm^a`VB\!zpqH^ bVqgkeBo^ o  \!`V`Vga` _^ `Vo BZ -g \zk\$`! zk\!`noV\$smgk
d qsp \ \
^ m\bVgr!gkd]BBb/\^asb/lm\] gkobV\$`qgk`"\$ocb/qsd^ bV\$o"^aem^asnwb/qsr^assn 1\gahb/\!el_^za\bVg
BoV\r$gkd]mBbV\$*` qefbV\$emoqszk\-^a]B]m`Vg=qd^ b/qsgkemo _^aoV\!gae^a`V gzvlm^aqegkefbV\v'^ `Vg
d\!bVlmgpmoW@o\$\jhxgk`\B^ad]m\ m^aemem\!`&WYXEkk}fZZ
lm\  `VocbSwm\!ob/qsgkeqso^"gab-dgk`V\m.q r!msbbVg^aemo \!`$-e]m`V^ar!bVqr$\jb/lB\$`V\|^a`V\
\!oVo\$efb/q^anbVlm`V\!\ocb/`V^ b/\!kq\!o$|lB\  `Vobjocb/`V^ b/\!anqsoj^oV$ 4\!r!bVqszk\'^nk\!oVq^ae gkem\a
]B`Vqga`]m`V
g m ^ mqsqsbVq\$o^a`\ B\$oVqskem\!bVgN`\$]m`\$oV\!efb ob/^ b/\!ogahBdqeB]m`V&\ 4mmqr!\$ogk`]m`qgk`
\=]\!`Vq\!emr$\ Bb$ m\$] \$eBmqemgke9b/lB\R^adgkmefb^aeB9bnp]\g h]m`Vqsgk`qseBhxgk`d^ bVqgke)
bVlm\|r~lBgkqr!\|gah5]B`Vqga`-d^ngk`-d^nemgab \r$s\^a`!-ga`-\B^ad]B\a qsh ^]_^ `/^ad\!bV\$"` !
d|mobq\ \!&b \$\$e _"^aem0 E=qo qsb 4Bob/q  \$b/g^aooVmd\NbVl_^ #b !l_^ao^memqhxgk`Vd]m`qgk`
BqobV`V'q mBb/qsgkegkejb/lm\ qefbV\$`z ^a _My\ qsf^ mm`V\!oVob/lmqsopB\$obVqgkeqe^ae\B^ad]m\
\$sg jV mBbhxgk`emg oVqsd]Bsn
g mo\$`za\Sb/l_^b'b/lm\!`V\^ `V\Sqse  emqb/\$n"d^ ewn]m`
g _ ^ mqsqbn
BqobV`V'q mBb/qsgkemojr$gaemoVqsob/\!efvb qsbVl9b/lmqsoocb~^ bV\$d\$efbg]mqr~ gkem\d^n \^ae9gza\$*` 
o]\!r$q  r^ bVqgke gah b/lB\^z ^aqsH ^ ms\|qseBhxgk`Vd^ bVqgke zk\!e^ae ^a]m]m^a`V\!ewbVsn r!gkemo\$`z ^ bVqsza\
^ ]m]m`Vgk^ar~lomr~l ^aob~^awqsemb/lm\ ]B`V
g _^ mqsqsbn mqsob/`q m=b/qgae b/l_^bRd^Bqsd'q !$\!ob/lB\
\!efb/`Vga]wnoVV 4\$rbRb/gbVlm\r!gkemocb/`/^ qefbbVl_^ $b !7qs\$oqebVlm\qsefb/\$`cz ^aud^n\$^abVg
]m^ b/lmgagkkqs\$oqse lBqkl mqd\$eBoVqgae_^a]B`V
g ms\$do$lmqooVlB3g olmg  m.q r!msbqbjd^n
\bVgme_^ vd mqamgkmosn]m`\$oVr!`V'q \b/lm\&ocb~^ bVqocb/qr$^a]m`Vga]\!`b/qs\$o-gah5b/lB\|]m`qgk`-dgpm\!u

S em\v^n gkBbjg h bVlmqoBq\!dd^"qoSb/gRqskemgk`\&qsb^aem ]m`V\!oVmd\&b/lm^ b  ]m`g


_^ mqsqbn
sq\!o5qeb/lm\\nk\-gahbVlm\ \!lmgksm\$`xm mBbb/lmqso5d\$^aemo5b/lm^ bgkm`] gkobV\$`Vqsgk`5]m`g
_^ mqsqbn
qs/ \jmq.)\!`V\$efbhx`Vgad nkgam`Vo!
oV\!r$gkeB^a]m]B`Vgf^ar~l^ bVbV\$d]Bb/o5bVgd^a \N^jdgk`V\
g 4\$r!bVqsza\Nr~lmgaqr$\gah)]m`Vqsgk`V8o fn
`\$n=qsemgkeRb/lB\$gk`\!b/qsr^a)r$gkemoqm\!`/^ bVqgkeBooVmr~l^aod^Bqsd&md\$efb/`gk]fnkmbV`/^aemochxgk`Vd5^ 
bVqgkeqsefza^ `VqH^ emr$\j&W %k^n=eB\$o qefz ^a`Vq^aefb5]m`Vqsgk`~bZ fgk8` fnoVgad\!lmg  moqem^H^ `Vk\'ewmXd \!`
g h
g moV\!`z ^ bVqgkemob/g&\!ob/qsd^b/\S^]m`Vqsgk`$ lBqo'^ bVbV\$`^a]m]m`gf^ar~lRqooVgkd\!bVqd\$or^as\$
')(* ,+b-/.10324.15 '76 _gk`\B^ad]m\ oVB]m]gaoV\gkeB\qsomgaqem^k`V^Ezpqbn qefzk\!`VoVqsgke9bVg
\!obVqd^ b/\d^aooB\$emoqsbnqseogkd\ `V\$o\$`czkgkqs`$=m]B]gko\ hxB`b/lB\$`b/lm^ bb/lm\!`V\ ^a`V\
^z ^aqsH ^ ms\"^^a`Vk\"ewmvd \$`gahqsemm\$] \$eBm\$efbqm\!ewbVqr$^anmqsob/`q m=b/\$H ^ gk`V^ b/gk`cn
d\^ oVm`\$d\$efb/o'g hm\$eBoVqsbnhxgk``Vgpr~pob~^a \$ehx`Vgad b/lmqso`V\!oV\!`zkgaq`jW@^ mqs|qs8h Z lm\!e
gaem\Rr$gkB mo\bVlm\Rd\^aom`V\!d\!ewbVob/g \$ocb/qsd^ bV\R^ ]m`V g _ ^ mqsqsbn BqobV`V'q mBb/qsgke9hxgk`
d^aoo|m\!emoVqbnbVl_^ br$gkms \mo\$ ^ao|^]m`Vqsgk`hxgk`bVlm\a`/^zpqsbn qefzk\!`Voqgkelmqo
qsob/lB\^a]m]m`gf^ar~lb/^aa\!eqse WuigkBza\$qH9^ +=r$^a\!o$XkkfZ lm\!`V\jqe oVqb/QW gk`Vb\ lmgks\EZ
d\^ oVm`\$d\$efb/o^a`\BoV\$9^ao^ae \$d]mq`qr^ ]m`qgk`Shxga`oVm`ch@^ar$\oV\!qoVdqr|_^ b~^=lB\
\!d]Bq`Vqsr^aa'^nk\!o ^ae_^ snpoVqsor^a%e \o\$\$e|^ao*^ae^a]m]m`gE=qsd^ bVqgkeSbVg-^hxms; : ' +<.1+=-7:-/.10
2".15 '76 ^ae_^ snpoVqs
o _^ao\$ gkebVlm|\ 4gkqefb]m`V
g m ^ mqsqsbnmqsob/`q m=b/qgaegah^as]_^ `/^ad\!bV\$`Vo
^ em^z ^aq ^ ms\_^ b~^=5_gk` ^aeqsewbV`Vgpmmrb/qgaebVg|\$d]mqs`Vqr$^a_^aeBlmqs\$`/^ `Vr~lmqsr^adg=m\!o
o\$\ hxgk`-\B^ad]m\ i\$sd^ e\b^aPWcXEaa 9kZ^aem`\!hx\!`V\$eBr$\$oSbVlm\$`\$qse-ga`^`V\!zpqs}\ 
gaebVlm\jm\!za\$sgk]md\$efbg h
g 4\$r!bVqsza\]B`Vqga`VooV\!9\ >j^ao"o  y^ oVoV\!`Vd^aeWcXEakfZ
J<

\F"@@?SM@BA|S@I"E$HE

b/lmqs`Vocb/`/^b/\$ nqsoNb/g^ _^aemBgke '^nk\!oj^asbVgkk\!bVlm\$`^aem mo\&gkemnm\!bV\$`VdqeBqobVqr


]B`Vqga`qe=hxgk`Vd^ b/qsgke^ gk=bdgpm\!o$^Eza\oV] \$\$qoS] gkoqsb/qzk\W@^d^bVb/\!`Sgah m\  emq.
bVqgke_Z zk\$sg=r!qsbnqoj\!oVob/l_^ e bVlm\o]\!\$gah'sqklfbW@^bVlm\$gk`\!bVqr^ ]m`V\!mqrb/qsgkeZ b/lB\
^a`cb/-l ~ o5d^aoVo5m\!emoVqbn&qso \!oVo b/lm^aetkC  r!(d R-W@^Sr$gkvd Bqe_^ bVqgke|gah
g moV\!`z ^ bVqgke"^aeB
bVlm\$ga`n|bVl_^ bqo5^asdgaobr$\$`cb~^aqsemsnjbV`Vm\Z lm\qseBhx\$`\$emr!\']m`
g m\!d qsoocb/qs=ocb~^ bVqocb/qr$^a
oqemr!\S`/^ emmgkd_^ b/^&memr$\!`b/^aqefb/qs\$o^ `V\b/^aa\!eqsefb/g"^ar!r$gkmefb$ooV\!ewbVqH^assnb/lm\qm\$^
qsob/ggpgk^bbVlm\oV\!bgah^adgpm\$soSb/l_^b  bbVlm\"_^ b~^=lm\!e] \$`hxga`Vd om`Vk\!`n
gaebVlmqo oV\bpr$Bbb/qeB|^ ^En"bVlmgkoV\-dg=m\!o bVl_^ bzpqgk^ b/\'bVlm\NB\!b/\!`VdqemqsobVqrr$`qsbV\$`Vq^B
\ Bs l_^zk\em\$f^b/qsza\B\$emoqsbnklB\|`V\!oVm|b qs- \^W@]B`V\$omd ^ msnod^ \!`~Zo\!bNgah
dgpm\$sobVl_^ b b-b/lm\_^ b~^^aemo/^ bVqohnbVlm\]B`Vqga`-r!gkemoqm\!`/^ bVqgkemo!eb/lBqohx`/^ad\ 
gk`emg"]_^a`cb/ qsr$m^a`dgpm\$qeb/lB\r$gkemocb/`V^aqem\!oV\!blm^aooV] \$r!qH^aoVqaemq  r$^aemr!\a y\
lm^Eza\emvg ^Engaho/^npqeB&b/l_^ b'dgpm\$ qso'dgk`V\Nq \$nb/l_^aeRdgpm\$ =oVqeBr$\qe
bVlmqoShx`\$wm\!ewbVqocb&^a]B]m`Vgf^ r~l \"l_^zk\emgabjm\  em\$9^]B`V
g _^ mqsqsbnmqocb/`q mN BbVqgke gae
bVlm\dgpm\$so bVlm\$doV\!szk\!o$sM \SBg&qo r~lmgpgkoV\^ ewndg=B\$b/l_^ b  bVob/lm\N_^ b/^b/g&^
X

B \$oVqs`V\!s\!za\$^aem"oV^ b/qso  \!o b/lm\]m`qgk` dgpm\$=r$gkemocb/`V^aqefb/o! qwlmgaemgEz/~ o`V\!kmH^ `Vq!$^5


bVqgkeRqso'gkem\^nRgah*g
Bb/^aqemqsem^aeqsewza\$`oVqgae^ kgk`qsbVlmd wn`V\$ocb/`qr!bVqem&bVlm\Sh@^adqn
g hdgpm\!ob/l_^b  bb/lB\_^ b/^V -\a ms'^adgaem9^ 'b/lB\dg=m\!ob/lm^ b  bbVlm\_^b~^B
nagkr~lBg=gko\gkeB\-bVl_^ bl_^ao ]_^a`bVqr!mH^a` hx\$^ b/B`V\$o!pbVlm\odgpgabVlm\$ocbfb/lm\-oVlBgk`bV\$ob$B\b/ra
W@_gk`qemocb~^aeBr$\a_o\$\=r$^a\!o-\bN^auWcXEkafZ^aemigkBza\$qHD^  pr^as\$oWcXEaa 9kZVZ
eb/lm\'^nk\!oVq^ae]m^a`/^aBqkdB]m`
g _ ^ BqqbnBqobV`V'q mBb/qsgkemo^a`\Sb/lm\jhxmemm^ad\!efb~^a
bVg=gao$^Ena\$oqH^aemo`V\$k^a`Vqsb^aod\^ emqem hxm'b/goV] \^agahSbVlm\]m`
g _ ^ Bqqbngah^
lfnp] gab/lm\!oVqso-aqszk\!eogkd\\!zpqm\!emr$\ ^aem^a`V\ ^ B\bVgr!gkemmBr!bN]m`Vb\ _^ b/^"^aem]gaoxb 
m^ b~^9qseBhx\$`\$emr!\$o! _`\$wm\$efbVqobVoR^a`\dga`V\r!gkemr!\$`VeB\$
qsbVl]m`Vb\ _^b~^9qseBhx\$`\$emr!\
^ em `me qsefb/gm'q r$Bsb/qs\$o lm\!e b/`cnpqem b/gkqzk\ ]gkocxb _^ b~^ qsewbV\$`]m`V\b~^ bVqgkemoRbVg
bVlm\$qs`]m`Vb\ _^b~^hxgk`Vd|mH^ bVqgke)9egab/lm\!+` gk`mo$memr!\$`b/^aqefbn \!ob/qsd^b/\$oomr~l^ao
r!gke  B\$emr!\o\!b/o^a`+\ _^ao\$ gkeb/lm\"\!`V`Vga`Smqocb/`q mBbVqgke)2 lmqr~l qso^aoVomd\$ b/0g \
wemg e"^-]m`Vqsgk`VqPa^aeB|gke&lfnp] gab/lm\b/qsr^ap`V\!]\b/qsbVqgkeBo*g h_b/lm\_^ b~^-f^ bVlm\$`qem-]m`Vgpr$\!oVo!
-g \zk\$`!woV\$\ijgk=b/qEo v'^ao\$^|WYXEkfaZhxgk`^`\!zpq\  gah_d\!b/lBg=mgagkkqs\$ob/lm^ blm^Eza\
\$\!eB\!zk\!gk] \$b/g"mghx`V\!wm\$efb/qsobN]gaoxb _^ b/^"qseBhx\$`\$emr!\a
y\l_^zk\oV\$\!eb/l_^bb/lB\r~lmgkqsr$\g h]m`Vqsgk`mqocb/`V'q mBbVqgkemoqoemgab^a' ^npo \!
B\  em\!"e bVlmqor$^aoV\"qb gkB oV\!\$d dgk`V\`\^aogke_ ^ ms\&b/gRhxgksg  ^Rhx`\$wm\!ewbVqocb
^ ]m]m`Vgk^ar~lBbqsbd^n^asoVg|lm^a]m] \$ebVl_^ b']m^a`/^ad\!bV\$`o'^a`\emga#b \$ m\  em\$)_gk`
qsemob/^aemr!\aqob/lB\  bV`Vm\jd^aoVo-gahb/lm\j\^ `b/Vl ^"d\$^aemqeBahxm\B]B`V\$ooVqsgke{*\$`l_^a]mo!
BBb mg=\!o bVlm\-m\  eBqsb/qsgke"qemr!mB\bVlm\-^ b/dgko]mlm\$`\Eh)oVglmg d&mr~lgah)bVlm\N^ b/dg 
o]mlm\!`V\EheBgabfmgp\$o5qbb/^aa\qefbVg^ar$r!gkmefbb/l_^b b/lm\d^aoo qo r!gkemocb~^aefb/n&r~l_^ emkqeB
WxoVsqklfb/nBZ-hx`Vgkd\a mdqr!`Vgkd\!bV\$gk`qsb/\!o~ za\$e9qhnagk9d^a \"bVlm\  b/`m\"d^aoojgah
bVlm\^a`bV$l S\$ m\  em\!Wxqsb qpobVqs \^a` Bqsb/`V^a`njbVgogkd\'\pb/\!efbZwqb r^ eeB\!zk\!`
]B`V\$r!qo\$snpeB3g e^aefnRdgk`V\SbVl_^aeRb/lm\bV\$d]\!`/^ bVm`V\jgah^aeqoVgaH^ bV\$Rf^aor$^ae \
=gB# lmqsr~l^a]m]m`gf^ar~l q+o \!bb/\$`/'^na\$oVq^aemo^a`\Rl_^a]m]fnbVg ]gkqsefbgkBb"ogkd\
\$swemg e qeBr$gkemoqocb/\$eBr$q\!oSqeb/lm\hx`V\$wm\!efb/qocbjd\b/lmgpmgksgkanaS=gad\'^nk\!oVqH^ emo
\zk\!eag^aoh@^a`^aor!H^aqsdqsemb/l_^b^aefnkgkeB\SqelB\$7` lmqo`Vqalwbhx`/^ad\g hdqsemolmgkms
\"^'^nk\!oVqH^ e"_`V\$wm\!efb/qocb/o!gke bVlm\"gab/lm\!`l_^aem)*r!gkd]mH^aqse ^ gkBbbVlm\oVgkd\ 
bVqd\$ooV$ 4\!r!bVqszk\ r~lmgaqr$\gah]m`Vqsgk`^aeBb/lm\r!gkd]mBb~^b/qgae_^a-r$gkd]m\=qsbngahb/lB\
^Ena\$oqH^ae^a]m]B`Vgf^ar~l)9e `V\$^a'mg e ub/g \^a`cb/l _^ b/^ ^ae_^anpoVqo \]m`\!hx\$`&bVg a\!\$]
^ e ga]\!e dqeB[S'q \$`V\!efbjd\b/lmgpmoSd^:n +\ \bVb/\!`Sb/l_^ e g b/lm\!`Vom\!]\!emmqeBgae
bVlm\j]m`V g m\!d5gab/loVr~lBg=gksogahqseBhx\$`\$emr!\jl_^zk\joVgkd\!bVlmqeB"bVg" g )\!`$_gk`r!gkgk`chxm
BqoVr!moVoqgkeBo|gke b/lm\r$gkd]_^a`qogkeg hb/lB\&b g^a]m]B`Vgf^ar~lB\$o&o\$\ hx`gkeWYXEkkfZ^aeB
qsemm\nWYXEa 9kkZ5=\!\^ oVg$ mqeWYXEkawZhxga` ^npoq+e lmqsr~lhx`\$wm\$efbVqobd\!b/lBg=mo
r$^ae \jmo\$b/gr$gkd]m\!d\!efb'^nk\!oVqH^ eqe=hx\$`V\!emr$\!o$
XaX

o:iH 8I SS- HR 8o rs  6J iLKLM


e^'^na\$oVq^aer$^ar!mH^ bVqgke)$ l_^ b/\zk\!`\|^a`V\\$ocb/qsd^ bVqem"m\!]\!emmoSgaeb/lB\|]m`qgk`
^ em r$gkemBqsb/qsgke_^amqocb/`qm BbVqgkeBo&kqsza\$e b/lB\m^ b~^B9oh@^a`"^aov \peBg3j b/lm\!`V\qo
eBg \!ob/^ mqsoVlm\! ]m`Vgpr$\!mm`V\RbVg r~lB\$r~ lmg
 d|mr~lqseBhxgk`d^ bVqgke b/lm\]m`qgk`|qe54 \!r!b/o
qsefb/gbVlm\] gkobV\$`qgk`\$obVqd^ b/\!o$eb/lmqso|\B^ad]ms\6 \ qs r!gkd]_^a`V\b/lm\N+b gah
bVlm\\$ocb/qsd^ bVgk`Vo!&*gd\^ oVm`\&b/lm\"] \$`hxga`Vd^aemr$\|gah'^ e \!obVqd^ b/gk`SBc W Zgah 67 OP6  \
B\  em\b/lB\sgkoVohxmemrb/qsgke W =c W ZVZ oVlmgkB^a' ^n=o6 \emgae em\!f^ bVqszk\^aeB
olmgkmsZ \%$! \$`ghxgk`bVlm\bV`Vm\dg=m\!ul_^ b-qo!hxga`N^ ewn [ K W ZQ ^aeB
bVgZW \( Bc W ZpL Z Blm\!e9lmqs\SbgaqsooVo^ r!qsob/m^^adn \$^aoVm`\_gagkh)`jb/\lmB\S^ar!dgk]mob\ gah^\$ocr$b/gaqsdd^dbVqgkeme jb/gklBo\Nob/hxm`mem\r!bVdqgkgpe m\$qo

bVlm\oVw_^a`\$\!`V`Vga`$ W =c W ZVZ W =c W ZVZ$N RBbjb/lB\$`V\^a`V\"gabVlm\$`r~lmgkqsr$\!o


sq \R/S emgk`d0\$``Vgk`!
lm\sgkoVo W =c W ZVZqo'^&`V^aemmgadz ^a`qH^ m s\Noqemr!\Sqsbm\$] \$eBmogkeb/lB\S_^ b/^
y\S^za\$`/^ k\SgEzk\!`b/lB\S_^ b/^b/gg
B b/^aqe^ae^zk\!`/^aa\Sgkoo$ lBqoqsor$^as\$b/lm\T+ 67O gah
c kqsza\$eb/lm\jdg=m\!
W@wZ
P$ "P W ac Z "] U W Bc W ZZ*
lB\$`V\LVqso-bVlm\|]B`Vg
_ ^m qsqsbnRmqsobV`VqB Bb/qsgkeg h b/lm\\$``Vgk`o$Nga`Nopm^a`V\! \$`V`gk`sgkoVo
F

bVlm\j`VqsoVqsob/lm\jmo_^ad\^aeoVw_^ `V\$\$``Vgk`!
W

<; \ F"@YXH*[Z

lB\\=]\!r!bV\$sgkoVom\$] \$emBo-gaeb/lm\r~lmgaoV\$edg=m\!upgkd\\$obVqd^ b/ga`Vod^nlm^Eza\


od^ `qoVwojhxgk`joVgkd\dgpm\$so mBbemgabhxgk`jgab/lB\$`Vo!*gr$gad]_^ `V\"\$ocb/qd^ bVgk`Vo \
eB\$\$^k g _^a)d\^ oVm`\jbVl_^ bb/^aa\!oN^ bVlm\jdgpm\!o'qsewbVg^ar$r!gkmefblm\'^nk\!oVq^ae
`qoqsoB\  em\!^aobVlm\'\=] \$rb/\$&z ^asm\g hmb/lm\`Vqojgza\$`bVlm\dgpm\$pmqocb/`q mBbVqgk2e aqe
g b/lm\!1` gk`Vmo!Bqbqso^ \$qsklfb/\!^Eza\$`V^ak\g hb/lm\N`Vqo"moVqsembVlm\dg=B\$ mqocb/`V'q mBbVqgke
^ o \$qsklfbhxmemr!bVqgke)
&f p wm @$ `8\ ] \7] U W c=W ZV&Z
lB\$`V_\ ^ qsoRb/lm\ ]m`qgk`RmqsobV`Vq BBb/qsgkegkeb/lm\ dg=m\!o!Ne \!obVqd^ b/gk` qb/lb/lB\
od^ \!ob'^nk\!oVq^aeR`VqsoV"qor^as\$`^ 24.15 . +5NgabV\b/lm^ 1b \Sl_^za\moV\!^
hx`\$wm\!ewbVqocb^ ]m]m`Vgk^ar~lbVg"m\  eB\jbVlm\'^'7nk6a\!oN'76)`bqoV( mobdqc emr!\ \jl_^zk\emgabr!gkemmqb/qsgkem\$
gaeb/lB\
g BoV\$`czk\! _^ b~^ bVlmqo-kgp\$oN^af^aqsemobb/lB\]m`qemr!q]ms\$ogah5ogkd\|'^na\$oVq^aemo!-b
Bg=\!od^aa\o\$emo\aklmg \!za\$`$kbVg\=]\!r!bkg=gphx`V\!pB\$efb/qsob \!l_^z=qsgk`qshpb/lm\'^nk\!oVq^ae
^ ]m]m`Vgk^ar~lqso'b/g \BoV\$`V\!]\$^ b/\!msn qb/lm.q )\!`V\$efb-_^ b/^oV\!bVo$
XEt

S[ \!emgab/\w fnZb/lm\O4gkqsewbBqobV`Vq' mBb/qsgkegkedg=m\!o^aeB_^b~^Blm\jd^a`Vkqse_^agah


qb/l`V\!oV] \$r!b-b/gbVlm\j_^ b~^"qog Bb~^aqsem\$0 fnRqsewbV\$k`V^ b/qsem6gEzk\$`b/lB\dgpm\$so$
W Z fe8g W iZ h
_`gkd0'^na\$ o ~_bVlm\$gk`\$dmb/lm\jr!gkemmqb/qgae_^a)]B`V
g _^ mqsqsbngke aqszk\!e qo
W iZ ^ W Z
j W Z
W Z
lB\$`V$\ ^ W Z*bVlm\^]m`qgk`q5mqocb/`V'q mBbVqgkeqsojbVlm\d^a`kqe_^ gah qsbVl9`\$oV] \$rb|bVg
lm\r$gkemBqsb/qsgke_^a]m`
g _ ^ Bqqbn j W ZjqsobVlm\og r$^as\$^Ena\$oqH^ae ] gkobV\$`qgk`
]B`V
g _^ mqsqsbnk\=]m`\$oVoqemb/lm\"qsm\^b/lm^ b j W Z^aoVoqdq^ b/\!ob/lm\m^ b~^^aem ]m`qgk`
qseBhxgk`d^ bVqgke)
Sem\r^aem\  eB\^ewmXd \!`gah`V\$^aoVgkem ^ m\\$ocb/qsd^ bVgk`Vo"gah hx`gkd j W Z
_gk`\B^ad]m\ =bVlm\ b/lm^ bd^=qdq !$\!o j W ZNW@gkk` V(mlcBW -Z lnpobhxgk`'ogkd\
o`q fZ`gaem\"r$gkmsr!gkd]mBb/\&bVlm\\$obVqd^ b/ga`b/l_^bjkqsza\$ojb/lm\"oVd^as\$ocbj'^nk\!o
`qohxgk`^"kqsza\$e]m`qgkk` ^^aemgkoohxmemr!bVqgke 5y9\jl_^za\bVlm\hxgks3g qsembVlm\$ga`V\$d
*wp _gk`|oVw_^a`\$\$`V`gk`gaoVo|hxmeBr!b/qsgke b/lm\^Ena\$o\$ocb/qd^ bVgk`|qso&b/lm\R] gko
bV\$`qgk`'d\^ e# \!lmd^aeme WYXEkk}fZB]_^ k\ta}kB
-\$`\qo ^oVqd]ms\\B^ad]m\gahBoVqeB|^emgk`Vd^a_]m`qgk`5bVg\!ob/qsd^b/\N^emga`Vd^a_d\$^ae
NoVomd\ b/l_^bbVlm\$`\'^a`1\ W
g moV\!`z ^ bVqgkemo rW h$7h N {.{'{ h U -Z lmqsr~l^a`V\ qqsX 9W _M N Z
^ emRb/l_^ "b \ ^aefbb/g\$ocb/qsd^ bV\b/lB\d\$^a0e _kqzk\!ebVl_^ b'bVlm\]m`qgks` ^qOo rW !G N Z
-]bVg ^ r!gkemob/^aefbh@^ r!b/ga`$b/lmX\ 4gkqsewb"BqobV`V'q mBb/qsgke9hxgk6` _^ em qsoWVQW \!lmd^aeme
Xkk}fZm]_^ak\tf}fZ
W _pZ \Bu] t tX vxw/U &W h
\_pZ Nzy \=_] t t5X QW _X{!Z Niy
lB\] gkocb/\$`qgk`d\^ eqsokqsza\$e fn
] QW _ Z WsW- | 5 -N N}X3!5 N N
lB\$`V~\ | qo'bVlm\jd\$^aegah*b/lm\j_^ b/^B5lm\]gaob/\!`Vqsgk`z ^a`Vq^aemr!\qo
^_a`BW _- Z W5 N X X3 N {
X}

- gab/qsr$\b/l_^ bb/lm\]gkocb/\!`Vqga`z ^a`Vq^aemr!\qo _&f `\$mmr!\$\ fn9bVlm\]m`\$o\$emr!\g h-^


eBgke$!$\!`Vg lm\R] gkobV\$`Vqsgk`|d\^ eGlmqsr~lqsobVlm\'^nk\!o\$obVqd^ b/ga`hxgk`oVw_^a`\$
\!`V`gk`gkoo$_r$^aeZ \S`VqbVbV\$e^ao
c=W Z t W- WN  NX N y | t W N3X  N X3 N y ! {
ebVlmqor^ao\Sb/lm\^Ena\$o\!ob/qsd^b/gk` qo^ \!qklfbV\$^zk\$`V^ak\Sg hb/lm\Sd\^ egahb/lB\
m^ b~^&^ emb/lB\d\^aeg hb/lm\S'^nk\$oqH^aeR]B`Vqga`mqsobV`Vq BBb/qsgk-e fb/lm\NH^ bb/\!`qsob/lB\S'^nk\!o
\!obVqd^ b/gk` \!hxgk`\^ ewn_^b~^jl_^zkS\ \$\!e`V\!r$gk`m\$5lB\S'^nk\!o'`VqsoVqso bVlm\Nqsefb/\$a`/^a
gEza\$`5b/lm\_^b~^gahb/lm\] gkobV\$`qgk`z ^a`qH^aeBr$\ga2h __5=qsemr$\b/lB\]gkocb/\!`Vqga` za^ `VqH^ emr$\'Bg=\!o
eBgabB\$] \$emRgah wb/lm\'^nk\!o`Vqoq-o 4mobb/lm\N]gaob/\!`Vqsgk` z ^a`qH^aeBr$\a NgabV\^asoVgb/l_^ b
^ o d Bqsemr$`\^aoqemkn obV`VgkeB]m`qgk`jqe=hxgk`Vd^ b/qsgkebVlm\\!obVqd^ b/\r$gkefza\$`Va\$o|bVg
bVlm\|]B`Vqga`-d\^ e|o d qeBr$`V\$^aoVqsemk)n \$^a]m`Vqsgk`NqseBhxgk`d^ bVqgke)=b/lB\&'^nk\!o
\!obVqd^ b/\&r!gkefzk\!`Vk\!ojbVgRb/lm\&d\^ e g h bVlm\_^ b/^BogemgabV\&b/l_^b^aSo d b/lB\
]B`Vqga`'qoqsd]m`gk] \$`jWxemgab-emgk`d^asq !$ ^ m\Z

SFGEH*EMS@ >1E,>"IS@$8FGEMH&1@H>#
bgahbV\$e l_^a]m] \$emob/l_^bbVlm\$`\qsojemgab\$emgkBklqseBhxgk`d^ bVqgkebVgr!gkemocb/`VBr!b^]m`qgk`
B\$emoqsbn hxgk`b/lm\memwemg e9z ^a`qH^ B\$o!gk`bVl_^ bjb/lB\qseBhxgk`Vd^ bVqgke ^z ^aq^ ms\&qojemgab
\$^aoVqssnjb/`V^aemoH^ bV\$&qsewbVg^]m`g
_ ^ B qqsobVqrob/^ b/\!d\!ewb k nk\b8 \'eB\$\$^]B`Vqga`*bVg \^ m \
bVgR^a]m]Bsn'^nk\$o}~ b/lm\!gk`V\!debVlmqor^ao\v \&bV`nb/g  eB^]m`Vqsgk`NbVl_^ bS qs*^asg
Bo-bVgr!gkemmBr!b-b/lm\'^nk\!oVqH^ eqe=hx\$`V\!emr$\ lmqs\jqe34 \$r!bVqem"^"dqemqsd&mdgah5^a`cb/q  r$q^a
qseBhxgk`d^ bVqgke2a b/l_^bqso$wqe=hxgk`Vd^ b/qsgkev lmqsr~lqoemg b4 mocb/q  \$(w nbVlm\-]m`Vgpr$\!oVo$5ylm\!e
eBg]B`Vqga`qeBhxgk`d^b/qgaeqo^z ^aqsH^ m s\| \r$^a)r$gkemo\$`cza^b/qsza\j]m`Vqsgk`VoemgaemqeBhxga`Vd^ b/qzk\a
y\lm^Eza\|m\  em\!b/lm\'^na\$oS`qoV` \hxgk`-^'^nk\!o\$ocb/qsd^ bVgk`)c \Skqsza\$e^"]m`qgk`
^_ b"ocb~^aemBo&b/g`\^aogke b/l_^ b|b/lm\Rdgk`V\qeBhxga`Vd^ b/qzk\"b/lm\R]m`qgk`b/lm\oVd^as\$`qsb/o
^ oVoVgpr$q^ b/\!`Vqo $ \b/lB\$`V\hxgk`V\joV^Enb/l_^ bbVlm\j]m`Vqsgk`s^qo0 ' . 6)b .1 c +<.0 ' qh` \Q` \z
hxga`^aefngabVlm\$`]B`Vqga`s^
H 5Ls\^aocb'h@^zkgk`V^ m \]B`Vqga`qo'^aoVog=r!qH^ bV\$) qsbVlb/lm\k`\^ bV\$ocb
Be_^zkgkqs_^ m s\gkoo$
e bVlm\hx`V\$wm\!efb/qocb^a]m]B`Vgf^ar~lb/lm\k`V\$^ b/\!obme_^zkgaq_^ B \gkooqso^aooVgpr$q^ b/\!
qb/lb/lm\d^=qsd&md `VqsoV WxwZ-gEzk\!`S^asb/lm\]gkooVq'm \dgpm\!o$Ne\$ocb/qd^ bVgk`b/l_^ b
dqeBqdq$! \!ob/lm\'d^=qd|md `Vqoqsor$^as\$^ ( , M ( . '76)b ( . bdc +88 \!lmd^aemeWcXkk}fZ
olmg obVl_^ bmemB\$`r$\$`cb~^aqse r$gkemBqsb/qsgkemoSbVlm\\!obVqd^ b/gk`r$gk``V\$o]gaemmqeBbVg^R\$^aob
h@^zagk`/^ B \]m`qgk`5^ r!b/m^an|dqemqsdq'$! \!o*bVlm\d^=qsd&md `Vqo lmqo5qso b/`m\afhxgk` \B^ad
]B\a
 lB\$ebVlm\-'^nk\!o\!ob/qsd^b/gk` lm^ao ^r!gkemob/^aefb `Vqo ebVlmqo5o\$emo\ \-r^ae"b/lmqsem
W

<

X$

g h^s\^aocb'h@^zkgk`V^ m\]B`Vqga`'^ao \$qeB"^&`VgkBbV\Sb/gb/lB\dgkocbr$gaemoV\!`z ^ b/qzk\'^nk\!oVq^ae


\!obVqd^ b/gk`!
-3g Bg=\!ogkem\  emR^r$gkeBoV\$`cz ^ b/qzk\WxemgkemqseBhxgk`d^ bVqsza\EZ ]m`Vqsgk`~Rk^aqefbVlm\$`\qo
eBg\$^aon ^ emxo \$`!\zk\$e b/lm\&bV\$`do r$gkemo\$`cza^b/qsza \ ~^aeB} emgkemqseBhxgk`d^ bVqsza \ ~^ `V\emgab
\$sm\  eB\$ Bbgkem\Nr^ae)phxgk` \B^ad]ms\awm\  em\^jd\$^aoVm`\gahqeBhxgk`d^b/qgaeW@\a m
\!efb/`Vga]wnBZR^aemm\b/\$`dqsem\ ^]m`qgk` lmqsr~ldqsemqdq !!\$7o d^=qsd'q !$\$obVlmqod\^ oVm`\
Wx\a md^Bqsd&md0\!efb/`Vga]wnBbZ gk`-gkem\r$gkmsm\  em\&]B`Vgk] \$`cb/q\!o-bVl_^ bemgkemqseBhxgkd^ b/qzk\
]B`Vqga`Vo5^a`\'\=] \$rb/\$"b/glm^Eza\W@\a mfqefz ^a`Vq^aemr!\EZ =\$\ >j^aoo y9^aooV\$`d^ eWYXEkkkZ

ivm j$` g  q   rs56tj$m


e=\$rb/qsgke9)\oVlm^a5mqsoVr!moVo^r!gkoVdgksgkkqr$^a]B`Vg
ms\$dlm\!`V\\\=]msgk`V\b/lB\
o\$emoqsbVqszpqsbngah oVgkd\|meBpeBg3 e ]m^a`/^ad\!bV\$`o-bVgmq.) \!`V\$efbS^adgamefb/o-gah5]m`qgk`qe=hxgk`
d^ bVqgke6- \$`V\ \r$gaemoVqsm\$`^oqd]m\|\B^ad]m\"gah\$obVqd^ b/qsemRb/lm\"d\^ae _ gah'^
Bemqsb5z ^a`qH^aemr!\emgk`d^a=mqocb/`qm BbVqgke9 W_M XZG qb/l^ae"g
m o\$`z ^ bVqgke`hjhx`Vgkd 9 W_M XZ
aqszk\!ebVl_^ bw_- qowemg ebVg \ gkBemm\$(f n6 lm\$o\Nb& g|]m`g
m \!do ^a`\-^ar!bV_^an
`\$^ b/\! _gksg3 qsempb~^a`WYXEkak9 ZG \ q mo\b/lmqso&^ao"^dgpm\$gah-^ae qefza\$`Vo\
]B`Vg
m s\$d  qsb/l ^R]m`qgk`Sr!gkemocb/`/^ qefb|yqb/lmgaBbb/lm\"]m`qgk` gkBemEhqsoj^ae \$ocb/qd^5
bVgk`gah_m Bb \lmgk] \b/gmg: \!bb/\$`W@g
= b~^aqse9^oVd^as\$`j`VqsoV=Zwf nqemr!mBqemRb/lB\
gkmeB qeBhxgk`d^b/qgaeN g r^ae: \"qemr!mB\|b/lmqsoqseBhxgk`Vd^ bVqgkeqebVlm\\$ocb/qd^ bVqgke
]B`Vgpr$\$Bm`V\ eB\] gkooVqB qqbnqo'b/g"mo\^^Ena\$oqH^ae^a]m]m`gf^ar~l^aem^aoVoqke^]m`qgk`
BqobV`Vq'm Bb/qsgke"b/gv_+ lmqsr~lqo memqhxgk`Vdgke:|u 5y\ qs_oVlmg
 b/l_^bb/lBqo memqshxga`Vd
BqobV`Vq'm Bb/qsgkeRqe34 \$r!bVoobV`Vgkema\$`qeBhxga`Vd^ b/qsgkeb/lm^aedqsklfbJ \j\z=qsm\$efb$
O<; \F "@Y
XH*[ Z
wb~^a`cbO qsbVlR^aeRg
m o\$`cza^b/qgae
h"hx`gkdA WQ_$ XZ^aemRom]m] gkoV\ \Swemg7
 ^&]B`Vqga`Vqb/l_^ b
_- qo+ gkmemm\!f n\E y\qemr!gk`V] gk`/^b/\bVlm\0 gkBemf n ^ oVoVqskemqsemb/g_ ^ ]m`qgk`
Bemqshxgk`dnmqocb/`Vq'm BbV\$gke,|u lm\"4 gkqefbmqsobV`VqB Bb/qsgkehxgk`_ ^ emhqo
W&hMp_ Z tX ] X t5 \=]u tX Wrh p_ Z /N
lB\$`V\ ] qo'bVlm\jqemBqr^b/gk`hxBemr!bVqgkeRhxgk`'bVlm\jqefb/\!`z ^a qu \a
^ WQ=_ Z tX 3 ] Wp_ Z {

XE

p b/^a`VWcXEaa9kZolmgobVlm\`V\!oVmb/ogah^"gaewbV\v'^a`Vsgr^asr$m^ b/qsgkeg h*bVlm\j'^nk\!o


`qo hxgk`Rb/lmqso]m`Vg
B\$dy9\qsS`V\!]m`Vgpmmr!\bVlmqor^ r$BH^ bVqgkeN^ab/lmgkBklqsbqo
] gkooVq B\|bVgr!gkd]mBb/\&bVlm\"'^nk\!o\!obVqd^ b/\^ em`qozpqH^Rewmd\$`qr^ qefbV\$k`V^ b/qsgke
qkm`\jXSoVlmg obVlm\`\$omsbVogahbVlmqogkefbV\jv'^a`Vsgr$^ar!mH^b/qgaeg h'^nk\!o`Vqov qsbVl
^Bemqshxgk`d]B`Vqga`Sgke r$gad]_^ `V\$ qb/lb/lB\dqsemqd^`VqsoVb/)g \m\$or$`V'q \!
eB\pbob/lm\Sr!gkemocb/`/^ qef"b \^a \$emoQW -qsemr$`\^ao\$o~Zb/lm\^Ena\$o`qoVk\b/or!gko\$`bVgXk
Wxlm\m^aoVlm\!^aeB9mgabb/\!9r$B`zk\!o&qe b/lBqo  km`6\ qs8 \"\=]mH^ qem\!9qe b/lB\em\pb
o\$rb/qgae Z
O<

S@?0*FGEYH*>1H*YISb>1?FGE$H*1@

y\l_^zk\|BoV\$b/lm\memqhxgk`Vdmqocb/`Vq' mBbVqgkeRb/g  ogahb/\!e$Wxqu \ar$gkefzk\!`bNb/g^]m`g


_^5
BqqsobVqrob~^b/\$d\$efb~ZNb/lm\r!gkemobV`/^aqsef%b _ [ P"NgC\+^aefbbVgRd\$^aoVB`V\&b/lB\
\ )\!r!bg hb/lmqsoogahb/\!emqeB&gahbVlm\r!gkemobV`/^aqsefb ^za\\Nqemr!mB\$dgk`V\-qe=hxgk`Vd^ b/qsgke
bVl_^a0e \j`\^assnl_^a
iqsza\$ebVlm\|
g BoV\$`cz ^ b/qsgke hhx`Vgad 9W _MXZ-^aempeB3g qsembVl_^ b _-MDE/ l_^bSqo
bVlm(\ gk`ob&`qoW@d\^aeoVw_^a`\$ \$``Vgk`/Z \d^n lmgk] \bVg^ar~lmqs\!za(\ qsbVlbVlm\ '76)b
\!obVqd^ b/gk` qsb/lBgkBb"qd] gkoVqsem ^ ]m`Vqsgk`&mqsob/`q m=b/qgae gk
e _pegabVlm\$+` gk`Vmo \
^aefbb/gr$gkd]mBbV\Sb/lm\jdqemqsd^`qo) P"W Zkqzk\$eb/lB%\ gkmeB
P"W Z dqe _d^ 7 ] ]U QW _\c=&W hpZVZ N {
P"QW !Z"qo^sg \!` gkmemhxgk`bVlm\d^=qsd&md`qoV ^ em^aem]m] \$(` gkBemhxgk`
bVlm\j`VqsoVg h5^aefnRgabVlm\$`\!ob/qsd^b/gk`! b/lmgkBklqsbqsom'q r$Bsbb/g"r!gkd]BBb/\jqsbVo\B^arb
z ^asm\aqbqo\$^aon bVgoV\$\bVl_^ %b P"W XZ dqse 5 N 1X w&[Sgkemgklmg\b|^ uRWYXEkkkZoVlmg 
bVl_^ b
N P"QW Z {
N X
qkm`\NXoVlmg o5m]m] \$` ^aem&s3g \$G` gkBemmohxgk`*hxgk`b/lm\'dqeBqd^`qoV^ao^Nhxmemrb/qgae
g h E5NgabV\-bVl_^ b hxgk1` }bVlm\^Ena\$o'`qoqo gkBb/oqm\b/lB\Ndqemqsd^+ gkmemmo!5lmqo
qso-^ae^ `b/qh@^ar!b'gahbVlm%\ ^)n \l_^zk\  oVg hb/\$eB\$$ "b/lm%\ gkmem eg b/lm\!` gk`mo$_b/lB\
Bemqshxgk`d ]B`Vqga`'mqocb/`q mBbVqgkeRqs5e 4\$rb/odgk`V\qeBhxgk`d^b/qgaeb/lm^aebVlm\l_^a`0 gkBemgae
___^ po 4Bmk\$0 fnRr!gkd]m^a`Vqsem|b/lB\dgkocb]\!oVoqdqobVqrhx`\$wm\!ewbVqocbN`qo( qsbVlb/l_^bgah
bVlm\'^na\$oVq^aeR\$ocb/qsd^ bVgk`$_gkO` q&b/lm\Nr$gkd]_^a`qogkeqo emgab'\^aocn m=bqsbr^ae^ oVg
\-oVlmg ebVl_^ 1b P"W Z d X^a#o d =gm=^aob/lm\ gamem \$^aa\!emob/lB\'^na\$o^aeB
dqeBqd^`Vqo gab/l^a]m]B`Vgf^ar~l Xk
X

1.0

0.8

risk

0.6

0.4
Bayes MC simulation
Minimax lower bound
Minimax upper bound

0.2

0.0

6
8

interval halfwidth

10

12

 qkm`\Xa"ga`opm^a`V\!\!`V`Vga`|gaoVo$b/lm\'^nk\$o`qo^ oVoVgpr$q^ b/\! qb/l ^memqshxga`Vd


]B`Vqga`qooVlmge^agaemqsbVl&b/lm\m]m] \$`^aemsg\!`8 gkBemmo gke&bVlm\dqemqsd^`Vqo&^ao
^hxmemr!bVqgkegahb/lm\oVq!!\SgahbVlm\S gkmemmqsem&qsewbV\$`cza^ pP5ylm\$eqor!gkd]_^a`/^ m\
bVgSgk`\$oobVl_^ae|bVlm\z ^a`Vq^aemr!\WcXqe|bVlmqor^ao\EZab/lm\`Vqo^aoVog=r!qH^ bV\$X qb/l^-memqshxga`Vd
]B`Vqga`'qogk]=b/qdqocb/qsr
X9

rs  6  8 o H  m  :iXj k :i9-S" o


  nH  m  :iXj  
No%\lm^Eza\w4 mocb|o\$\!e dgkob]m`g
_^ mqsqbnmqsob/`q m=b/qgaemomoVm^an l_^zk\dgk`\"qe
hxga`Vd^ b/qsgkeRb/l_^aeqd]mqs\$0f n^l_^a`r!gkemobV`/^aqsefbgo/^nk hxgk`-qemocb~^aemr!\ab/l_^bS^aefn
dgpm\$# qsb/ll l Xqso|hx\^aoqm s\qor!\$`cb~^aqsemsnemgabbVlm\o/^ad\b/lmqsem ^ao"o/^npqeB
bVl_^ b^as dgpm\!oS qsbVll l
X^a`\"\$w_^assn sqa\!snaem lmqs\v \r$gkB gpgk
hxga`&b/lm\dgkob"r!gkemoV\!`z ^ bVqszk\gk`s\^aocbh@^Ezagk`/^m \oVBr~l ]m`g
_ ^ m qsqsob/qsr^aooVqskemd\$efb
^ar~wmoWcXkkfZd^ a\$o|^ae9qsefb/\$`\$ocb/qeB^a`kmd\$efb^ak^aqemocb^aefnomr~l ]m`g
_ ^ m qsqso
bVqr`\$]m^ar$\!d\!ewb-qselBqkl ga`qe  eBqsb/\b mqsd\!emoVqsgke_^a dg=m\!oV]m^ar$\!o$O- qo] gkqefbr$^ae
\qssmobV`/^ bV\$ qsb/l9^oVqsd]B\"\B^ad]m\ pm]m] gkoV\b/l_^ b&^a8 \wemg ^  gaBb&^ e
WN Bqd\$emoqgke_^ _dgpm\$mza\$rb/gk` qso5b/l_^ bqsbVo\$eBab/l6 l lqos\$oVob/lm^aeogkd\
]m^a`bVqr$BH^a`-za^ m\7pmemqbnhxgk`Nb/lm\&oV^aa\"gah m\ emqb/\$eB\$oVo!&e gab/lB\$`S gk`Vmo!oVm]B]gko\
\Swemg ^|]m`qgk`qbVl_^ b qor$gkeBob/`V^aqeB\$bVgv  \ qsbVlmqeb/lm\|WG- mqd\$emoqgkem^amemqsb
m ^a" U '^ar~wmor!gkemoVqsm\$`oz ^a`qgkmo]m`g
_ ^ m qsqsob/qsrR`V\!]mH^ar!\$d\$efb/ogahSbVlmqol_^a`
r!gkemocb/`/^ qefb bVlmqojqor^ \!  oVgahbV\$emqsem
 bVlm\r$gkemocb/`V^aqefbRy\r!gkm hxgk`j\B^ad]m\
r~lBg=gko\|^"]m`qgk`']B`Vg
_ ^m qsqsbngke  lmqsr~lqso-Bemqshxgk`dgkeN U N^ad\$snaBb/lB\]B`Vg

^m qsqsbnRb/lm^ b  qssq\|qse oVgkd\&od^as*zagkBd\+c [ oVl_^asG \\$w_^ab/g0c
Bqszpqm\!: fnbVlm\|zagkmd\|g h U vlBg=gkoqemb/lmqsomemqhxgk`Vd U ]m`qgk`-gkebVlm\v _^ u qsbNqo
eBgabmq' r!msbbVgolmg7
 b/lm^ bb/lm\j\B] \$rb~^ bVqgkegah N hxga`^aeZWN Bqd\$emoqgke_^ qo
] WQ N Z W(W t
lBqr~l|r!gkefzk\!`Vk\!o b/gX'^aoW qsemr$`\^ao\$o! Ne=hxgk`bVme_^ bV\$sna bVlm\ z ^a`qH^aeBr$\ gah$ N ag=\!o^ao
XW hxgk`'^a`Vk\W ^aemRbVlpBo \joV\!\$d0b/glm^Eza\qsefb/`Vgpmmr!\$^]mq\!r$\gahqe=hxgk`Vd^ b/qsgke
bVl_^ b(' ^aoemgabqd]mqs\$w n bVlm\gk`qkqse_^a'r!gkemobV`/^aqsefb em^ad\!sn b/lm^ bhxga`H^ `Vk\0W
bVlm\|gaemsnsqa\!snza\$rb/gk`o  qsl_^zk\\!emab/l\$w_^a*b/ggkem\alm\`V\$^aoVgkehxgk`-bVlmqo
^ ]m]_^a`\$efb/nobV`/^aeBk\w \!l_^z=qsgk`l_^ao'bVg"mg+ qsb/lRbVlm\' ^nzagkmd\$oJ \$lm^Eza\qselmqkl
Bqd\$emoqgke_^ )oV]m^ar$\!o$h \r!gkd]BBb/\b/lB\jzagkBd\gah ^ae0WG- mqd\$eBoVqgae_^aolm\$sgah
bVlmqr~wem\!oVo|p4 Bob-qemoqm\j^ ePv- mqH^ d\b/\$`Jm ^a \r^aeoV\!\b/l_^ b$

WQjP ZG} WQP\~ Z U WP U WP ~ Z U Z
WukZ
WPjZ#fXwX P U
lB\$`V\ U m\!]\!emmoSgaemsngkeb/lm\mqd\$emoqgke)N-g hxga`P X&^ em:_W XX \
lm^Eza\
EWj
P ZX{ U d {

lBqoo/^npob/lm^ b&^ oWk\!bVo^a`Va\aem\^ `Vsn ^ gahb/lm\"zkgksmd\g hb/lB\ _^as5qojr$gad


]B`V\$ooV\!qefbVg^b/lBqeRoVlB\$ 4Bob-qemoqm\SbVlm\j`/^aBqmo!
=bN\zk\!eb/lmqso
g 4\$rb/qsgker$^ae \jgEzk\!`Vr$gad\wqsbVl^"mq'\$`\$efb-r~lmgkqsr$\gah]B`Vg

^ mqsqsbn mqsobV`Vq BBb/qsgkebVgoVgahbV\$ebVlm\r!gkemobV`/^aqsefb _gk`\B^ad]m\ r~lmgpgkoV\ bV:g \
Bemqshxgk`dn mqsob/`q m=b/\$gk
e V X ^aeBr~lmgpgkoV\bVlm\ WLXoV]mlm\!`Vqsr^a ]gaH^a`^aema\$o
Bemqshxgk`dngaebVlm\$qs`-`\$o]\!r!b/qzk\mgkd^aqemo!lmqo]m`
g _ ^ mqsqbnqso-Bemqshxgk`d0gke l l
BBb"emgke memqhxgk`Vd gkebVlm)\ _^asu Ng \!za\$`"qsbqso&r$gaemoVqsob/\!ef+b qsb/lbVlm\Rr$gaemobV`/^aqsewb
^ emlm^ao5b/lm\]m`gk]\!`bn&bVl_^ bb/lB\-d\^ e^ emz ^a`qH^aeBr$\ga/h N qso5qemB\$] \$emm\!efbgah b/lB\
Bqd\$emoqgkeRgah*b/lB\o]_^ar!\a
=gBj^ao'^ar~wmol_^ ooV^aq)S \ d&mocb \ zk\$`cn r$^a`V\hxmqe`V\!]mH^ r$qeB^l_^a`
r!gkemocb/`/^ qefXb qb/l ^]B`V
g _^ mqsqsbn mqsobV`Vq BBb/qsgke*\$oV] \$r!qH^assn qse ^lmqskl mqd\$emoqgkem^a
dgpm\$_o]_^ar$\ ]m]_^ `V\$efbVsn"qeBemg=r!\$efbr~lmgkqr!\$o d^n"s\^a"b/gmem\=] \$rb/\$) \$lm^Ezpqsgk`$
_gk`dgk`\'qe=hxgk`Vd^ b/qsgke|gaeemgke qeBhxgk`d^b/qsza\]m`qgk`o oV\!\-g"^aem"q^agWcXE
9a}fZ^aeB
>j^ao"o  y9^aoVo\$`Vd^ae9WcXEakfZ

ivm j$` S 5  ivj Rk  pm   rs5j$

y\eBg3]B`V\$o\$efb^oVqd]ms\-\B^ad]B\`V\!H^ bV\$bVgSm\!ob/qsgke qseR=\!r!bVqgkeXky\mo\


^zk\$`cb/qsr^aoV\$qsoVdqr]m`Vg  \W Yj=3{ wmoV\! qse\=]msgk`/^b/qgaeoV\!qodgksgkanRbVgqd^ak\b/lB\
^a`cb/-l ~ oem\$^a`oVm`ch@^ar$\Z\=] \$`Vqsd\!efbb/gqsmocb/`V^ b/\Nlmg 7^  bb/\!`\$o]gkeBoV\jm\$] \$eBmo
gaeb/lB\^aooVmd\$ emgaqoV\\zk\!qseb/lB\_^ b/^Bqam`V\tolmg o|b/lm\k\$gad\b/`n gah^
YB{ oVgam`Vr!\gah ^ar$gamobVqr|\!em\$`anqsoS^ bNb/lm\|oVm`ch@^ar$\em\$^a`^za\$`cb/qr$^aG gk`\ lBgk\
Wx\hb&oVqsm\EZ ob/`qemgah-`V\$r!\$qzk\$`o"qo|sg \!`V\$ qsewbVg :^ gk`Vb\ lmgks\a5`\$r$ga`Vmqsemb/lB\
bV`/^aeBoVqsb-b/qsd\gah bVlm\&mg e kgkqsem^ar!gkmocb/qr]mmsoV\a-lm\!oV\&b/`V^aemoqsbbVqd\$oN^a`V\moV\!
bVgr$gkeBob/`mr!b-^  \!oxb   bVbVqem |dg=m\!)gahbVlm\Szk\!gpr$qbn Wxgk`'qeBm\gah`V\hx`/^arb/qsgkeZ^ao
^hxmemr!bVqgke g hm\$]BbVl ^&W fZlB\$`V\qsoemg]gkqsefbSqegpgkwqemhxgk`^ b/\!`/^az ^a`Vq^ b/qsgkemo
qse ^oqemr!\|b/lB\`/^npo]B`Vgk]_^ f^ b/\|em\^a`snzk\!`b/qsr^assnahbVlm\"^a`bVl qoSemg bH^ bV\$`V^an
qsefza^ `VqH^ ewb$kb/lmqso^ oVoVBd]BbVqgkeqefb/`g=Bmr$\!o^onpobV\$d^ b/qsrN\!`V`Vga`qsewbVgbVlm\Nr$^ar!mH^b/qgae
_gk`\$^ar~l
g BoV\$`cz ^ b/qsgkeWP^aemlm\!emr$\\^ r~l`/^nBZb/lm\hxgk` '^ `V]m`V g m\!d0qo
X
em ^&W fZ hR {
hbVlm\za\$gpr$qbndgpm\$ ^&W fZ^aembVlm\S`/^n]_^ bVlmo^a`\Swemg eBbVlm\$ebVlm\b/`V^zk\$ b/qsd\
r$^ae \jr$gad]m=b/\$0 fnqefbV\$k`V^ b/qsem&b/lm\za\$gpr$qbnR^asgkem&bVlm\j`/^nR]_^ bVl
lm\kgf^ 'qo&bVg ogkd\$lmg 0\!obVqd^ b/)\ ^&W kZRW@gk`ogkd\RhxmeBr!b/qsgke_^agah ^rW fZVZgk`
bVg\$ocb/qsd^ bV\r!gke  B\$emr!\qefb/\!`z ^aohxgk` ^&W fZSNeB\$oSo ^qo-r$gkeBob~^ ewb$)b/lB\|`/^npo qs
X

` \!hx`V^ar!b^aeBb/lm\!`V\!hxga`V\b/lB\ mgkd^aqeg hqsefb/\$a`/^ bVqgkeB\$] \$emmogkebVlm\ memwemge


za\$sg=r!qsbnklBqoSd^aa\!ob/lB\&qefzk\!`Vo\]m`Vg
B\$ddqBsnRemgaemqsem\^a`!Ny\XqseB\$ks\$r!b
eBgkemqsem\^ `Vqsbnqe bVlm\"]m`V\!oV\$efb|\B^ad]m\+ fn ^aooVmdqeBbVl_^ bjb/lB\`V^n=o^a`\ob/`V^aqalwb
sqem\!o$
-3g \!^]_^a`cb/qsr$m^aG` ^&W kZ5dgpm\$  b/o5b/lB\-m^ b~^m\!]\!emmogkelmg ^ar!r$m`V^ b/\!sn
bVlm\_^ b/^^a`V\wemg e gkmklBsnoV] \^awqeBmmqshbVlm\_^ b/^^a`V\Swemg ezk\!`nR]m`\$r!qoV\!sn
\ qsl_^zk\bV,g ga`V lm^a`V bVgr$gad\m] qsbVl^9dg=m\!-bVl_^ b  b/obVlm\$d b/g^
`\^aogke_ ^ B\m\$k`\$\ hb/lB\_^ b/^^a`\wemg e gkemn `/^ bVlm\$`qd]m`\$r$qsoV\!snkb/lB\$e \
r$^ae  bb/lm\!d dgk`\N\$^aoVqssnk ga`\m^ d]ms\apqebVlm\\pb/`V\!d\r^ao\SgahgkeBsnemgkqsoV\awb/lB\
d\^ eg hbVlm\jemgkqo\jqo^  bb/gb/lB\m^ b~^B
NoS^oqd]m\jocn=efbVlm\!bVqr&\m^ d]ms%\ \|r!gkemocb/`VBr!b/\! ^]mqs\$r!}\ qo\|r!gkemob/^aefSb ^&W kZ
qb/lkH^nk\!`Vo^ em moV\! fmeBpeB3g eH^na\$`Vob/g] \$`chxgk`Vd b/lB\`V\!r$gkemocb/`mr!bVqgke
y\jr$gkd]mBbV\$Z 9aonpefb/lB\!b/qsrb/`/^za\$b/qsd\!o^aemr$gaewb/^adqe_^ bV\$bVlm\$e
d qb/lmemr!gk` 
`\$^ b/\!i^aBoVoVq^aeemgaqoV\ 5lm\\zk\!)gahb/lB\SemgkqsoV\Smgp\$o-e ~ bd^ bb/\!`hxgk`bVlm\S]m`\$o\$efb
]Bm`V] gkoV\! o jb/lm\ ] gkqsewbqobVl_^ bRkqzk\!e ^ eBemwemg e s\!zk\!SgahemgkqsoV\qseb/lm\ _^b~^B
B'q \$`V\!efb|^ oVoVBd]BbVqgkeBo^ gk=bbVlmqojemgaqoV+\ qs s\^a b/gm.q )\!`V\$efbwqemBogah`V\!r$gke 
ocb/`mr!bVqgkemo!yqb/lbVlm\r!gkemocb~^aefb za\$gpr$qbnH^nk\!`Vo$ b/lm\onpobV\$d gah_hxgkx` ^a`|]m`
g m\!do
hxga`^a- 9a`V^n=o`\$mmr!\$ob/g
WPfZ
 
lB\$`V\ qsob/lB\Sf5 mqd\$emoqgkem^a_zk\$rb/gk`g h`\$r!q]m`g=r$^a^nk\$`'za\$sg=r!qsbnW 6 0 c '7676 bVg
o\$qsoVdgkgkaqobVo~Z^ em qo ^d^ bV`Vq v lmgko|\ `&\$efb/`cn"qo5b/lB\Nmqsob/^aemr$\b/lB|\ b/l`/^n
bV`/^zk\!oqe b/lmT\ bVl^Ena\$`! Wu=\!\ga`Vmqsem ')b .10 WcXEaa 9kZhxgk`b/lm\m\b~^aqswo \!lmqeB
bVlmqoNb/gkdgkk`V^a]mlfnr$^ar!mH^b/qgae Z =gB)b/lm\m^ b~^d^a]m]mqsem y qoNb/lm\qsemem\$`]m`Vgpmmrb
g hbVlm\jd^ bV`Vq ^aemRbVlm\joVg em\!oVo-zk\$rb/gk`
\!b z \ b/lB\ x-bVl7
g mo\$`czk\$ b/`/^za\$b/qsd\ z W ZRqsoRb/lm\ Qub/lb/`/^za\$b/qsd\
r$^ar!mH^b/\$b/lm`gkmkl^Saqszk\!e&oVsg em\$oo5dgpm\$ w^aeBv $qo*b/lm\'ocb~^aeB_^a`VB\!zpqH^ bVqgke
g h*bVlm\ Qub/lR_^b/md hb/lm\SbV`Vm\og em\!oVoqo BbVlm\$ebVlm\Shxgksg qemdgpm\$ gahb/lB\
g moV\!`zk\!b/`V^zk\$bVqd\$oqso^aoVomd\!bVg"lmgk)
W 9kZ
" W Z x&
lB\$`VZ\ xNqo^ emgkqsoV\Rb/\!`Vz
d qsbVl !!\$`gd\^ae^aem z ^a`Vq^aemr!)\ N Sm`"kgk^a'qobVg
\!obVqd^ b/\ ob~^ em_^a` ^a]B]m`Vgf^ r~lbVgogksza\ b/lmqsoR]m`V
g B\$d qobVgB\!b/\!`Vdqem\
og em\!oVoza^ m\!o bVl_^ b-d^ a\j^"dqso  b'hxBemr!bVqgkeoVBr~l^ao
N W Z X vw/ W $pZ N
WPfZ
t

source

v1
v2

Depth (m)

v3
v4
v5

v40

40

 qkm`\Rt==qsd]B\dgpm\$ gah-^za\$`bVqr$^ao\$qodqsr]m`g  s\ WYB{ Z0oVgkB`Vr$\Rqso&^ b


bVlm\oVm`ch@^ar$\gahSb/lB\^a`bVl em\$^a`^ zk\!`bVqr^  gk`\lBgk\W@s\!hboVqsm\EZocb/`Vqsem gah
`\$r!\$qsza\$`o-qso'g\$`\$qefb/g&bVlm\ ga`V\lmgks\aB`\$r!gk`Vmqsem&b/lB\Sb/`/^ emoVqb'b/qsd\Sg h^&Bg3e
agkqemr!gkd]m`V\!oVoVqsgke_^a '^zk\ lm\$o\-bV`/^aemoqsb5bVqd\$o5^a`\moV\!bVgr!gkemocb/`VBr!b^  \!oxb 
 bV\jb/qsr$emgk
eBRob~d^ ewg=b$B5\$y9uX \ N\!q`Vs\ )qs^5k em`gk\!`hx\S\$`b/olm\jb/gRmb/qsoVlmr$\`\!zabV\$q !gp^r$b/qqbganeRqs\$e `V`Bgkq`oVr!qe`V\b/bV\"lmqHo^nkr^\!`Vr$o!BH^ ^ oVbVoVqBgked \! bVg

tpX

od^ \!`|b/lm^aeogkd\bVgk\!`/^aeBr$\aN\!`V\ qob/lm\ewmdv \$`"gahg


mo\$`z ^ bVqgkeBo$lB\
ocnpvd ga N qogahb/\!e|mo\$|bVgNB\$emgabV\ bVlmqo*oVBdD \!r^amo\ N W ZqoV4mob^ae|^Eza\$`V^ak\ gah
qsemm\!]\!emm\$efb N mqsobV`Vq BBb/\!Sza^ `VqH^ m\!2o lm\$eW9aZlmgksmo^aemb/lB\ eBgkqo\5qoij^amooVqH^ e
^ emBemr$gk``V\!H^ bV\$
y\Nlm^Eza\^ oVoVBd\!b/lm^ bb/lm\ewmvd \$` gah^nk\$`oqowemg e=kqse"bVlmqo\m^ d]ms\a
BBbRb/lmqsoqomoV_^ snemgabRbVlm\ r^ oV\a vlmgpgkoVqsemb/gpg d^ ewnH^na\$`Vod^n s\^abVg
^ e gEza\$`   bVbVqemgah b/lB\_^ b~^=&eg b/lm\!S` gk`mo \\$eB B]  bb/qsemRemgkqsoV\qeBmmr$\!
ocb/`mr!bVm`V\!o$ Noqem^aeqsemoV r!q\!ewbewmvd \$` gah^Ena\$`#o qs_emgab r$^a]Bb/B`V\qsd] gk`cb~^aefb
hx\$^ b/B`V\$oqseb/lB\_^ b~^=5lm\$`\j^a`V\bV`Vqsr~po^ emRd\b/lmgpmo'bVg|b/`cnb/g"^zagkqRgEzk\!` ^aeB
Bemm\$*`   bb/qsemm*eb/lB\]m`\$o\$efb \m^ d]ms8\ \mgNeBgab*l_^zk\bVg gk``noVqsemr$\ \ qsa \
BoVqeB|oVqsd&m^ b/\!_^ b/^B *g&m\b/\$`dqsem\NbVlm\og em\!oVoz ^asm\$o b/lm`gkmkl W@fpZ \Slm^Eza\
BoV\$^bV`VmeBr^ bV\$ YS[ `V\$r!gkemocb/`VBr!b/qsgkeb/lB`Vg qem^ ^n^asb/lm\\!qk\!efzk\$rb/gk`o
qsebVlm\k\!em\$`V^a'q !$\$qefzk\!`Vo\ ^a]m]m`gE=qsd^ bVqgkegah b/l_^ b^a`V\emgab`V\$wmqs`V\!b/g  b
bVlm\m^ b~^^ bbVlm\ N X\!za\$PlB\`V\!oVmb/qeBdg=B\$qoemgabmemqwm\ p mBb|qsbqo
`\$]m`\$o\$efb~^ bVqsza\gahdg=m\!o'bVl_^ bmgemgabgEzk\!`   bb/lm\j_^ b/^Wb/gb/lB\^ oVoVBd\!emgaqoV\
s\!za\$Z
y+\ q*r$gaemoVqsm\$`b/lB\]m`V
g B\$dgah  bVbVqembVlm\"_^ b/^memm\!`j&b gm'q \$`\$efb^ao 
omd]Bb/qsgkemo ^ gkBb'bVlm\jemgkqsoV\aqkm`\}oVlmg ob/lm\ g moV\!`zk\!^aeB]B`V\$Bqr!bV\$_^ b/^
hxga`-dgpm\$so'b/l_^ b  bbVlm\bV`/^zk\!*bVqd\$ogke^zk\!`/^ak\jb/g qsbVlmqeB }do-^aem Xk do$
\$d\$Xd \!`$=bVlm\^ar!bV_^a]moV\!mmg `/^aemBgkd0emgkqsoV\Sqseb/lm\m^ b~^qo  =\$b/lm`gkmklmgaBb
^ \&^a`V\r~l_^aemkqsemqsoNgkB`S^aooVmd]Bb/qsgke^ gk=bb/lB\|emgkqsoV\ / lmqsr~lqoN`V}\ m\$r!bV\$ qe
bVlm\j_^ b/^"dqo  br$`qsbV\$`Vqsgke
y\`\!hx\$`b/g-b/lm\!oV\^ao*bVlm\ gk]Bb/qsdqsobVqrzW 0 Z^aem]\!oVoqdqobVqr-W ::L Z
or$\!e_^a`Vqsgko$E gkr$^aer!\$^a`VnoV\!\-bVl_^ bb/lm\-oVcd ^asc \$`6P'b/lm\N^aoVomd\$eBgkqo\-s\!za\$qec b/6PlB' \
m^ b~^Bb/lB\dgk`\"bVlm\]m`V\!mqrb/\$_^ b/^d&Bobhxgks3g  bVlm\]m^ bVbV\$`VegahbVlm\
g moV\!`za\$
m^ b~^B bb/^aa\!oR^9r$gad]msqr$^ b/\!dg=B\$b/g]m`\$mqsr!br$gkd]mqsr^ bV\$_^ b/[^  lm\!`Vb\ 
hxga`V\ap \RoVlBgkm \=]\!r!bb/lB)\ \!ob  bb/qeBdgpm\! bVl_^ b]m`g=Bmr$\! bVlm\s3g emgaqoV\
`\$o]gkeBoV\bV,g \dgk`V\r$gkd]msqr^b/\$ bVl_^ae bVlm\dg=B\$b/l_^b]m`g=Bmr$\!b/lm\lmqkl
eBgkqo\`\$oV] gkemo\aNh b/lm\\$``Vgk|` _^a`Vo^a`V\H^ `Vk\ bVlm\$e^oVqsd]ms\jdgpm\$- qs\=]m^aqe
bVlm\j_^ b/^B
-3g s\!bmosg=ga"^ bbVlm\dgpm\$sobVl_^ b'^ar!bV_^an  b b/lm\N_^ b/^b/gb/lm\!oV\Sm.q )\!`V\!ewb
eBgkqo\&\zk\$s o bVlm\$o\^ `V\&olmg e qse qam`V\mjbqoSr!\$^a`b/lm^ bqsh5bVlm\&_^b~^memr!\$*` 
b/^aqefbnqogkemsnB }do$bVlm\$e b/lB\dgpm\!]m`\$mqsr!bVoW@gk`|`V\$wmqs`V\!o~Z|^s3g  za\$sg=r!qsbn
!!gkem\  Ng \!zk\!`$qshb/lm\&m^ b~^\!`V`gk`Vo^a`V\^ od&mr~l ^ o&X&do$bVlm\$e ^zk\$`cnodgpgab/l
`\$o]gkeBoV\qoS\!emgkmkl b/g  bbVlm\"_^ b/^Bq:e lmqsr~lr$^aoV\^Rg  zk\!gpr$qb:n !$gaem\"qoemgab
`\$wmqs`V\$)9eh@^arb5hxgk`|bVlm\Rlmqal emgkqo\r^ oV\R\$ooV\!ewbVqH^assn9^ qeB\^a%` ^&W fZ|qsemr$`\^ao\
qs  bSbVlm\&_^b~^B lmqs\hxgk`-b/lm\|g  emgkqsoV\|r$^aoV\"^`/^ bVlm\$`Sr!gkd]mqsr^ bV\$dgpm\$*qo
tat

`\$wmqs`V\$)-W@e gab/lr^ao\$o!$ \!r^aBoV\Sgah)b/lm\NoVqeBkmH^ `Vqsbn|gah =b/lB\Nz ^a`Vq^aemr!\$o gahb/lB\


\!obVqd^ b/\!]m^a`/^ad\!bV\$`Jo \!r$gkd\zk\$`cnH^a`k\Sem\$^a`b/lmw\ gabVbVgkdg hb/lB\% gk`\$lmgks\aZ
-gk]\hxmn b/lmqso\B^ad]B\qsmobV`/^ bV\$ob/lB\qd]ga`b~^ emr$\"gahBemm\$`ob/^aemmqsemb/lB\
eBgkqo\mqsobV`Vq BBb/qsgke bVg]m`gk] \$`Vn qefb/\!`V]m`\!b&qsefzk\$`oVqsgke9\!ob/qsd^b/\$o!eb/lmqso]_^ `b/qsr 
BH^a`r$^aoV\ \mqsm-e ~ boVqd]mn]mms b/lm\!oV\ob/^aem_^a`9m\zpqH^ bVqgkemogaBb|g hl_^blB\
sg  z ^am\W@B}do/Zjqs%o lm^ b|nagkl_^a]B]\!eb/gk\!b|qshnkgk ^ oVoVBd\"b/l_^b|b/lB\gkeBsn
Bemr$\!`b~^ qefb/qs\$oqse|b/lB\'_^ b/^S^a`V\emgk`d^assnBqobV`V'q mBb/\!X _mrb/_^b/qgaemo ^ gkBbb/lm\`Vme 
eBqemd\^ae gah b/lm\"b/`V^Eza\$5b/qsd\!o$6 Ng \!za\$`$a\!\$]qse dqeB bVl_^ be_^ bVm`V\"mgp\$o-e ~ b
`\^assnwemg L ^ gkBbbV`/^zk\!b/qsd\!o$ *`/^zk\!b/qd\$o'^a`V\^ ]m]m`Vg=qd^ bVqgkemob/g&b/lB\Sb/`VB\
]B`Vgk] \$`cb/q\!oW@qP \ s  emqb/\ m^aemV qsBb/lZ|g |h ^zk\!hxga`Vdo$ _m`bVlm\$`!5b/lm\Rb/`V^zk\$'bVqd\$o
bVlm\$doV\!sza\$o^a`\mo_^an^aoVoqkeB\$) fn^lpBd^aeRqsefb/\$`]m`V\b/\!`gpgkwqeB&^ bb/lm\ '^zkb\ 
hxga`Vdo$'^ oV\$ gke b/lm\!oV\"r$gaemoVqsm\$`V^ b/qsgkemo$gkeB\dqsklfb \"s\$ b/gr$gaemr$smm\b/l_^b^
dgk`\`V\^ oVgke_^ m\\!ob/qsd^b/\&gah b/lB\Bemr$\!`b~^ qefb/qs\$oShxgk``\^a m^ b~^ gkm \"r$gaoV\$`
bVgXdojbVl_^ae9B}do$e^aefn \!za\$efb*b/lm\qefb/\!`V]m`\!b/^ b/qsgkeg hb/lB\]B`V\$o\$emr!\gah'^
sg 7zk\!gpr$qsbn !!gkem\|olmgkms \zpq\ \!: qsbVloVgad\oVr$\!]Bb/qsr$qsoVd mems\$oVoNb/lm\oVd^as\$`
Bemr$\!`b~^ qefbnR\zk\!*r$^ae 1\ 4mocb/q  \$

ivm j$`0pm    |5w i   iLK 5` 


lB\r$gaoVdqrdqr$`g'^zk\| _^ar~wk`gkmemWuvZqo5b/lB\N`V^amqH^b/qgae\!hb gEzk\!`hx`gkd+b/lB\
q '^aeBm lm`VgkBklbVlm\vA \oV\!\bVlm\memqsza\$`oV\^ao"qsbv ^aogkemsn}kkB kk
na\^a`o^ hbV\$`NbVlm\qs'^ emm-pbVmBnpqemb/lm\"v7qo-q \|mgaqem^a`Vr~l_^ \$gksgkan^ bS^
r!gkoVdgksgkkqr$^a or^as\aeXEkktr$gaoVdgkgkaqobVo\$ocb~^ m sqolm\$9bVlm\\=qobV\$emr!\gahod^
Bq`V\!r!bVqgke_^ *z ^a`qH^ bVqgkemo-qeb/lm\v7bV\$d]\!`/^ bVm`V\WP=dg=gabN\!b$|^ WcXkftkZZw ^
bVlm\$o\z ^a`qH^ bVqgkemoemg bG \$\!e|hxgkmem)ar$gaoVdgkgkaqobVo- gam&lm^Eza\`\$wmq`\$&r!gkd]m\b/\$n
eB\}+
 bVlm\$ga`Vq\!ob/gR\=]m^aqe bVlm\"H^a`k\ oVr^ \|ocb/`mr!bVm`V\ \"o\$\qeb/lB\-emqsza\$`oV\"b/g
m^EnaNefbV\$`V\!obV\$ `V\$^am\$`oSd^Enr!gkemoVBsbS=qs WcXEk
k9 Zhxgk`S^k\$efb/s\|qsewbV`Vgpmmrb/qgaebVg
r!gkoVdgksgkank
_gk`bVlm\dgkd\!efb qsboVV r!\$ob/gSb/lBqemgahb/lm\-v^ o^b/\$d] \$`/^b/m`\hxmemrb/qgae
B\  em\!|gkebVlm\memqsbo]mlm\!`V\ap \bB&W ` Z2 \5b/lB\v b/\!d] \$`V^ b/B`V\5qebVlm\mq`\$r!bVqgke
` qe b/lm\"ownay\^aoVomd\bVl_^ b qsoj^opm^a`V\b qefbV\$k`V^ m \&hxBemr!bVqgke- b/lB\dgpm\$
o]_^ar!\qso K LON W&pN Zefnhxmemrb/qsgke qe K l_^ao^o]mlm\!`Vqr$^al_^a`dgaemqr
`\$]m`\$o\$efb~^ bVqgke

|W ` Z v v _ ] s ] N W a` Z
w 3w

t}

20

time (ms)

15

10

10

data
low noise response
high noise response

20
depth (m)

30

40

 qkm`\"}B| BoV\$`czk\! _^ b~^W@ogkqs r$m`czk\EZ^aem ]m`V\!mqrb/\!9_^ b/^hxga`jb&gmq.)\!`V\!ewb


^ oVoVBd\!\zk\$sog hemgkqsoV\aeb/lm\Ngk]BbVqdqobVqr'r$^aoV\&W@_^ oVlm\!r$m`czk\Z#\S^aoVomd\b/lB\
m^ b~^^a`\^ar!r$m`V^ b/\bVg"B }|do!5eb/lm\dgk`\] \$oVoqdqocb/qrNr^ao\W@mg bVb/\!Rr$m`czk\Z$\
^ oVoVBd\bVlm\_^b~^^ `V\R^ar!r$m`V^ b/\b/ggkeBsnXk do$e gab/l9r^ao\$o|bVlm\]m`\$mqsr!b/\!
bV`/^zk\!b/qd\$o^ `V\ r$gkd]mBbV\$hxgk`^ dgpm\$SbVl_^ vb 4mocb  b/oRb/lm\ _^ b/^Be gabVlm\$`
gk`mo \ ]\!`b/B` bVlm\ dgpm\!Smefb/qsSb/lm\dqo  0b \&b \!\$e bVlm\
g moV\!`za\$
^ em]B`V\$Bqr!bV\$ _^ b/^qsoj ^ gkB%b b/qsd\!ojB}Rgk`XaB- lB\$`V(\ qoSbVlm\"epBvd \!`jgah
g moV\!`z ^ b/qsgkemo! N\$`X\ 9aB
t

wave speed (m/s)

true model
high noise
low noise

3
2
1
0

10

20
depth (m)

30

40

 
B  
   "!$#&%' ()*+,-*.#  %*'-0/'#(%)1
#2.3546879):;#&%*  &%'<=. >@?AB+3&CD&<E%*  &FG:*      HJI*KML(3FN#& 3
3&"!D#2%O:G       QPKMI(3FR&O3&"!SK8TA& O&<U ()*+WVSX0Y[Z]\
 >;#2.#  %^. _%
. #2?A>3    %#2.D#&B#2%`/a  B% b#2A33.&$#&:N&  -+
#2%c  +W\d ^;#2.#'.O?  .  %eP^.#&%;#&f3  #g  &%hJ%&#& Ci kjml
Pn![K
o %':*:N3$-G%p&<U ( ;#&$#&CH-N3%  :Gq%p >C)  @/&KA  r;#2.#(\  
#&+3b#g.^<  >%*.#  %*q3sK

?= *5u*v@w x  B Oy{z=. h:*   |#28 ;#&%  &<r$'}2K o %0/e3+33%`a&<


 (~:;#&|#&%p-N  3%`  \;3p?  .  .,3*%3&<E ;#&&%  >3(  %0
I<}>eI*KU ](*3.3  %
g v@w x=`KE<m. rpTh?r*%  <. 3% v@w x
   .3%=&<GB#&C)2#&  #2  %  %d ,'T  U3`  2#&C%0U.8\%  %Br%*%)1 i 
#&(%  83(  %0.=<A}8I*K
'%"?<d+#2.^. *'   B#2  %f&<>'T ;#&%  q3(  %0.B#&a#2%
% 3B# %3  ?= %e/  B% 
 %0p:-*+Kh4    b#&*  %*a#&   
3  #2.(. q>#&3(  %0.2<. qW#& . B# %3  H\;CFE  %. *aQ1
  #2  %&<, ;#&(%  B3)[  3%`&<=. B^B#&%0+B-G%*;#&/k.:Gk #&: 0/
4#25QP" t !![K >3m'Th;#2#(#&

0!

?= *A  U#,[.&<R%3b#g.r#&*  #&%d%  A#&%  ]. ;#2#$B#&:*:  %m


:%0  %mF`<W*#&(:+2F` ,.#&  (3.3E-N#&(&.  %mK  #r  %#&E:)1
3.#2< :;#2=&<G`;#&[1  %0.!.#&-*+ `%*.rD)F0U(|#&33%0
:;#&3&KWTA3|#&=&<  %#2   3N[.E. *,3(Ck  #&+/  %03  m% >3(  %0
#2. &,&<! 3=}_ t K o %  %03  m% r`   &%  E *
3  B#g.. \&
3)[(  3%0.8&<W*$ } t X*0&SXn;g+,3)[(  3%0.!SK D  (:    @/&FR#&(
 ;#2?A8?A#&%0.d3  #2.D#  m% +$3(  %0|K4  %3_#&%0/B3)[(  3%0   #
  %*|#&
<*%3  %;#2 &<m > F. *_*  %  . 3%  #2.  '
!  &%^. *
#2#0!SK*%U  (:+W%*m 
-*  #&  :G #&%0m  3C  3  %
:#&[1
  3a =>%&U ;#|,;#2#8*%  </r:|#&(%. : 3&F)#&%H[%(?= %H?
*Fm  %*(>#&b#&[  d    &%8  %#2. H  n?A#|H.#2  #2  %F?AH ;#|&(
%*$ C3$;#2.#B%#&, >#&+#&3  _:+#&%&K o 8#3%`%*&F #&  %*\;%  ./
#&%0/(3+  #2  </  m%   ! I*F`?= 3  * !#&%B#2&_#&-  .#&  /db#2V 
2#&C3K o     +#&8:-+3#&  3  % 3  #2  %5&< ;#&&%  H3(  %0
2< HB#2%`+d-G%*;#&/'?= H 
 0#&:*>#&  %O   .  -)  &%O&<.#|/
?=   33$&O  -G%*;#&/&K
4  %  =: *  |#&* ;#&(%  E#2%>+&m%  %B#2)% *`/&F#
  (:+,+#& 1@#&3 \ .d#.*%|#2q ):;#2%  %a?  CG/  3+a  +#&  B%
3)[H1
  3%`,3  B#g.3K4)F *n?|#&%^?
3  B#g.8. *r3)[(  3%0.' ](#2?   F?
#&%H#&( #8  C
-G%%. *='T%*V 2/#&%  %  B# _(3. *)  H1
% >#&% ?A3A. ,<+C"?  m% >`   % o (m%
 b#&E
. *$  -N3  %a4)[  &
#2+ H:N&  -+3  #2.(J&<A#^`;#&:N&+H3(  %0S!SF~?= ;#2  8 H +i H&<
 >#&+C >P,zf3%*\;*%3  %02#& ;#2=3n&$. *r`;#2:GCr3)[(  3%0
2<#&%0/H()*#2  </  m% _ $3% &/H-G%wF  3%( $r#&+#&3   3*|F`%  =C33sF

t2

2# %3[. /k2< . B-32#2  %  %. a0/@%& r?AFU?= #2  >. *


-G W?A=|#2%(*>?  . d   %*<B#g  &%
?, #"&&KEE%E&*E. ;#gW33%?  . d. *
-G #"2#  b#&-*+ ;#g#( o 4 o A_T c7>' l ;#g#0! $3%*\;*%3  %02#&CW#&
#2+(>P"I  3b#&  ;#&%q. r  %  `  .(-*.#  %&+k  |#&CC/
 %0.   B% r3%3+  %, 3%  _3#2sKQP"!![K]  33<&?A=%3 :  
 %*<B#2  %K
p #"&'-G3%%;#2.#2+C/+#&c83  %  %4)[  %kP q?= ;#2:  
% *<B#2  %'|#&%?A|4)q<J#&_?A ;#|B3%  3. B'T(:N3.#2
#2$B\ )  %'&D`/p-*$&(+k    3?*8$%  3d#&$%C/#(#& Ci #2  %
2<]#&%  %)\;%  D%`d-GA&<m:b#2  -+,%  3KAA(+a   .E.  %(&<~. _'T
(:N3.#2#&^#.#&%*\;Ce% ': O?   . *'(|#&3'T
-G  m%  ^#%*   /&  %2<_%O2<  .#& Ci #2  %3Kh@%e. O3%0^(
:G:*b#&E. *  W  ()3+3B#&A#
&k &%3Ar#&*  #&%B#&%&\+) . *
g v@w x=,#&  %:G%*%0 i g1@(|#&%H>#&  #&%#&%2#&  #&-Cm?= A2#&  #&%
*:G%,%/a%^}2F  K&KU2#&| v@w xA! v l K
,n??a ;#|a#'d  2#&  #2d%B#2    -*  %5<r a;#g
#  3%. *
( F#2%#^: 0/  |#&CC/'&  2#2{d  &#2  #g.r%#&:  _% K(TA&
    -*  %#&$3%`p#2 i *KE<~.  v#&8`%"?=%F). 3%    A .#   0< 1
?A#&O.a3:**.r. 
:N .3  &D(|#&%{#2%'2#&  #&%3&<W# ;#&(%  
3)[(  3%0
 3% >;#2.#p&K KFR  %C3/^94)  . QP"0 t !![Kp#&%0/a<3*%0  .=?+%&
&-[$( {#&:*:0#2 JT #|/3G<&d+#  3FR#2<.3=#&+F#. 33  %q:&-;#&-  1
 @/*!m%*+F2<;*2F. [/r8%&-G  3&  %r. &+k  |#&&C]#&3:*
-0/(D#&:* `/    K,  :-C  =. #2D  v=#&
%`%"?=%  3/'#&
*3.3  %3a-0/H@?A%*%*n?=%q3(+a  #&:;#&#&(3.3?=   B?83%&8-0/a
`;#&:N&+>#&(:  .*$%&#& Ci #2  %R!E#&%*{J:G[.#&  %* ![K ;#g=|#&%^?
*'. 3%R,  >?= a<3*%0  .H#2%cT #|/3  #&%d #& .'  a# 3&KO_%*
#2::#& F?=   { ;#&_-G%{<C+"?O-0/O3(Ck   .3F  ,.^:[  C/pQ1
  #2.3'2#&+*_&<A#&%5{#2  <W. [/O? d.&#2+3K@%5.  8#&. *
:G .  $`;#&:N&+d%* #  %0  38#"/p-Gd.a:*      >  %d 3/'^%&
3%  3 . 8*%3#  %0@/  %a. _3  B#g.&#2+3 &<(NK o &)B\;=:  
d*/a 8%      @/&<~. D:N .3  &A   B#2A#5|#&%;#&-Cd#&m% D&<
2#&C>&<A#&%5GK H ;#|(%*H    %5 3%  q3
#&sKQP"![KTA)# 0#  %
?a ;#|&^#'*-[  &^   B2<?= ;#2d|#&%;#&-*+B(|#2%K B a#'!  %
*3\;%3{-0/'#-N*%'%p. d'T%*V 2/O#&%*p<%*'. ;#g$ 
2#&  #&-    @/a"3
>Js[gnA[ sn>"&S~ M .[$s3"M[ Qs AgS=3 [B2S"
Q3 Mg3|[s[ng,Q"nM[s E+~ Nss M

  $  %  D+#&&


3% O ;#2D%38.a-G#&3*%`{<3K . 3%{3#
:*  &]  %0=    -**  %B<=H.GKW$%*< .%#2.3C/F >   _&<].  :    %*
C%3: 0/  #&+/a(&  2#2.3K
@%p(B#2/F 
'T#2:C_ "?=$ "?:    %)<#2  %    %C3
 %d. `;#2:GC  #2  %d:-CK  \; |#2 +i d ;#2U =?A#&  %**<b1
\  3%0  %*<#2  %d
3  B#g.=`;#&:N&+,3(  %0..>. $`  3B 3
2<_#&3#&3/&K q. 3%#&3e:    %*<#2  %c-;#2%: 0/  |#&=. *  
#2%\;%;#&CC/%*+*h. ;#g^   #2a. 53  3#&3.#&[/3:N3%&%
(3?= ;#2*-[  &'   3B&<D:    %*<&#2  %K o :N  %0.3)B-G3<&F
?{&+ ;#|&a*q:G<&(h#+#& 1@#&3]4!\af#c: 3  |#&$ ;#& 1
(%  > ):;#&%  %O%*|#25#2=} t FG-*D d%* #  %0@/'&<. 3d3  B#g.
?CO ;#|-G3%O<J#&=.a:*      2K &D *#&(:C&F  *

  "?=_3  B#g.


2<U
    l w   l w ! 2 k  % (4q#&%p:N&.3  #&%=&<].  v@w x
<&   N%0.l %l #2  %A} l } l  gKE  *r*%3#  %0@/^&<m. *>4a3  B#g.!
 "?=
?  . B}  gKE   )3 %& ;#&::G%^?   a. _:G .  #&%^&<]
 -N3|#&*  
 %*.#  %*-`/B. >:  3(+   #&N(K
H|#&%k(#&%0/5(3. *){?(?A#&%0>.-*#  %5   #2_&<(H%`%"?=%
:#&.#&(33F;-*,?A
;#|>.(B#&2
>. #2$ r%3.#  %0@/q   B#2?
#28%2=#&  \;  #&F#&  %a?  . a 8`;#&:G+_]4a   B#23K 3 =%*83
#<`3%0   aB#T #|/3  #&%#&::*0#& F    B#2C?A#"/  (:N #&%0H.-N'#"?A#&
2<$ ^3#&(:*  %%c?=   3  B#g.#/ "%$M     ^&<$()3+
 #&+/c#{&a3    #&  *q ;#&%f. q  33%3(-G3@?3%. *^CH&<
2#&  * +2<<B#&  %*<33%2]sA k P|*Pn!![K

&('*)+' ,-' .0/1' 2

TA#&`FK`P"*K$#&#2%&<U:  m-G%*  %3&: 0/)  #&  %0 :*-C(K


4 6 587"Y 9 :& ;;gX <G& >F =?mF t A @ t& P&K
T  %FDrK1B]KCF>_ i .%*&%F o KF_  %3F_EK=>KCF84)|#&C3FDC*K o K F_ ]  .3sF
4GKP"&0)K o ::  #2  %r&<    (.#|3A  .&+&.#&: 0/&K 4 6587"Y9 :&
;;gX <G&F E_GZ 5;
H=I 7&&>J8Y[ZJ.I<IKL9 :&MN:9s[ZO72F>=6P~F t Q @)LIL*K
TNNF*HK=K8B]F`  #&*FHK`DKRP"&L*KR$7`Y9J<LS<E|[.<:19T<UMRZ&ZO9+Y[ZO9 :&8J*<G&V7nY9+Y[K
h +[/K

LeastSquares
1000

Qrms

800
600
400
200
0
0

10
lmax

12

14

16

18

20

14

16

18

20

Posterior Means
14

Qrms

12
10
8
6
4
0

10
lmax

12

 DO XYr!D#2_#B<%[  &%


 L W"D~|#& 1@`;#&3r#&%5T #|/3  #&%5  #2.38&<
2<.*%|#2  %k*r}  2K  B\#&%.p Z &L'r i 7>'0/B#&:
*  [% '# t +I \
r#2b#&[  *K  H.&:k:;#2%W *n?=r. (
 &-*#  %5<& ]4
3  #2.3 &<m.  l x$KE  >+"?:C&  "?=,3  #2.3-;#&3q%^. _:G  
    -*  %^&<]
^ ?  .Z
_#&%9[\ ).qPr#&%AP W`
L XaYHF)3:G3  &C/&K
ANFN7dKRrK~P"&*PK   /p#&%b&%3.#&m:  %  :C  %.#2    3Kc;;gX<G&FErZT5;
H=I 7&&a
MRZ&OZ 9+Y[OZ 9 :&a MN :9s[dZ 73J_F ef?g?mF t N @ t 0 )K
78&% Fm7dKWKFm  Fm>KmDKF]'#&|  --N&%FYKmTDKUP"&I*KH    B#A  O"3
0/:G[#&%&+3FG#&%  (:  |#2  %3KhJ*<6<>ihMRZ&Z i+Fe8j~FP| P @RP| 0L0)K
U<%F`TDK)P" K `/  %U33/&%$#8-;#|/  #&%KJ*KB[9 :<kMRZ&ZO9+Y[Zd9 :9J<;F?#P]QPn![F
P @GPPK
_CB#2%F o KF #2  %F8C*KTDKF4%FrK*4GKCF)=-  %F*7dK`TDKRP"&0)KhR$70Y9J<ml
&Zs
J*<G&V7"Y9+Y[KA ;#&:*B#&%$#&+K
t

_*  3F&DKFh #2Cb#*F2K0P"Q K  `3%`   :G 1@;#g#  %*<3%*&KWS<;ZQ[<G&ZO9sI<G&


MRZs&ZO9+Y[Zd9 :&H=nN9soEFgpgqmL0!SF;L t  @)L&  K
_*&  #*F KCF4)|#&C3F8C*K o K;P")KR,3C*  %  %H    A?A#"&3<  %03  %a"
TA#"/&=88#&KrS<6n&[.Y"*s.t+KY[Fe8qFRL t LA@)L2 0*K
_*&  #*F KF 4)|#&C3FuC*K o KP|*KfT #|/&  #&%    a?A#"&3<  %03  %a"
:#&.#&(3,   #2  %p#&%p%3.#  %0@/'#&%;#&/)  3K!;RgX<G&WFE 4 6587"Y9 :&
H=Y"&v :w5
F efP>qF t + &A@ t &*K
Y>#&FrKF

KCF #&#&%KP| K  *C3  %f&<$:  d    -*  %d-0/


E
<&#&;C3Kx;RgX<G&mFE,ZT5;1J*KB[9 :<UMRZs&Zd9+Y[ZO9 :&JDYY"N:9J&ZO9sI<;F[=e;FGP"L& t @
P|L0&I*K

~3 B#2%%FRKP"&L*Kzya5;g7^FE ;I9T<;ZY[ZO9TK(&Zd9sI<;K h +[/K


 % +[/F]7dK6dKEP|0+ )KH  H<*.*(&<A #2     3F@ o T #|/&  #&% t P|r3%0. /KZS<>{
s.N : 9T<8|gYrF E8TZ 5;k
}I <E|[. <:
I <Zl]9.w:[Zd9sI<*YhE|g*~5&ZT5;K(&ZO9 :&#MRZs&Zd9+Y[ZO9 :Y
K
 %+[/F&7dKg6KCF04)   F o K K&kK)P"0 t K*T #|/3E  #2.3<]. A  %*|#&]3sK
;;gX <G&F E_GZ 5;
H=I7&&aMRZ&ZO9+Y[ZO9 :&aMN:9s[Zd7LR=Fe;FP@RP"*K
=-  % F`7dK0>KP"2 KTA#"/&  #&%/,   \R#&-C=#&%(C32#&%0E<3`%[/(|#&C+#2  %
<& . r#&::*  3^.#2      #&%K`J*<6<G&MYdFE MRZs&ZO9+Y[Zd9 :Y[Fe8mJ 0![F~PPA P@GPPn t K
4|#&CFhC*K o KCF]4)%  *F]>KEP"0Kd pT #|/3_%*&_.pT #|/3
pgqF~P"I& Q N@GP"I& K

4 6587nY9 :Y[F

4|#&CF C*K o KCF878) 3@/&F]BKF__ i  %2%F o KrP|I*K =+#& Ci #2  %&<
%*%  %|#2  %0&:&-+3"  B#  % H. %|#&Q1@<J#&3d?A#2. *  %^b#|/&K
S<6n&[.Y"!
st+KY[FpF~PPA N@GP|L*PK
4  +RFC*K~P"0)KrJM5;gSZ`*9+Y[Z@g7^FE>ZT5;%<69Tn&[.Y"[K4)  %0  \; o 3  #&%  -#&/&K
4&|F]K KF [Z8&iWP" t K(4.3  %{. *a_T 7>p  !|#2p#&:K
JDY[ZJ6587"Y9 :&a;;gX)<G& Fgqg=gpFREP@) )K
4`#&GFBK;TDKNP" t KE  %  #I%)\;%*  %0.32#&C  %&#%[  K 4 6587"Y
9 :&# ;RgX <G&>S<;Z@[<G&Zd9sI<G& FefP>jF;L t N)@ LL*K
L&I

4`#&GFBKNTDK]P"0)K!ld"Y 4 G7q9 :3o-9ZG5'ZT5;3 &SZG5hGJ*<G9 E>Y"N=&.


ZG5;7
+0a dgK `.a: "+g???>K.#2|KTA3&3+[/K7_*2v2.#&W)K
#&%%*F]K o KP"L)KyN"gMYE|g3MRZs&Zd9+Y[ZO9 :&S<E|[<:i~[ZG5;gYE|gZT5;
3G+I
&OZ 9sI <FEs,"Y[Z@[9sgZl 9+Y[Z9OtXZd9sI<*Y'<Gh90[V95;"XW<:[ZO9sI<*Y[K4):  %3 1
6W3+# K
]%*  F0EKCF4`#&GF8B]K0TDKF`  %[?A#|3FDK
KP"&*KRT  +%3.#  %0  W#&%*
 rT  (T #2%KMRX[tKL9ZZ@&K

L)P

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen