Ralph C. Whitley Sr.

From: Ralph C. Whitley Sr. [backflow2@verizon.net]

Sent: Tuesday, June 15, 2010 1:54 PM
To: 'Brad Wehde'; 'Branko'; Innovative.Technology@dep.state.fl.us; info@deepwater.com; CGRDCDeepwaterHorizon@uscg.mil;
President Barack Obama; RDC-BAA-DHR@uscg.mil; 'Alternative Response Technology Alternative Response Technology';
Innovative.Technology@dep.state.fl.us; horizonsupport@oegllc.com; Halvorson, Erik LT; bill@billnelson.senate.gov; 'Bill McCollum';
bobby.jindal@la.gov; 'Governor Charley Crist'; 'Branko'; 'Arlene Johnson'
Cc: puk8th@ukr.net; tmichael@oceaneering.com; pop@oilstates.com; 'Rogers, Ruth'; kristin.wright@foxtv.com; Reginald Roundtree;
news@wfla.com; news@wtvt.com; backflow2@verizon.net; backflow.prevention@verizon.net; kristin.wright@foxtv.com
Subject: NOW IS THE TIME FOR ALL HUMANS TO JOIN TOGETHER BEFORE EARTH IS LOST TO GREED AND STUPIDITY !!!! FW: To
plug MC252 and more #47
Attachments: 15.6.10-Gulf-5-4-8+.xls; 061510at1208pmRE Branko No Reply To Critical Issues.pdf; 62-770.pdf

Importance: High

First: The idea and attachment showing THERMATE or THERMITE possibly setting off lead to melt over an explosive
gas is NOT something we would recommend and in that it came from a man in Russia who in good faith is hoping to
get an idea through even with Oceaneering contacts I do hope you will understand the THOUGHT is there.

I have attached the latest PDF file sent today for review as it is critical that someone look at taking OFF the flow
pressure drawing oil, gas and water from the TOP KILL or JUNK SHOT CONNECTIONS used for MUD then installing the
correct TOP HAT with sleeve sealing on the UNKNOWN measurements of the BOP FLANGE UPPER SECTION. I tried to
get Cameron Ruth Rogers to give me two things for review. First the BOP MANUAL IN PDF IF POSSIBLE, Second. The
exact measurements of the BOP. Since no one would ASK or JOIN ME IN MAKING THE REQUEST the CEO for Cameron
possibly put it in a garbage can or DELETED the request from an old man.

Second:

Someone is REALLY STUPID forgetting that Oil 1 gallon kills 250,000 gallons of water. Putting contaminated clothing
and sand/dirt from cleanup into plastic bags then putting same in a landfill as FIVE have been identified by Waste
Management is AGAINST FEDERAL AND STATE LAW FOR FLORIDA and could kill years ahead by destroying the water
sources LET ALONE STOP ALL DESAL EFFORTS IN THE ISLANDS TO MY SOUTH AND EAST OF FLORIDA ! What a
brilliant IDEA. JUST BURY IT ! Gee. Who thought of that one ! IT MUST BE BURNED AND SAND PLUS DIRT
RECOVERED BUT ALL MUST GO ON CONVEYORS AND BE BURNED..NOT BURIED ! I noticed in 1979 that PEMEX
didnt ignore one old mans idea from Tampa General Hospital to force lead into IXTOC 1.

1
My duty as a State of Florida Certified Plumbing Contractor is to share experience whether welding or plumbing,
military or civilian in any NATIONAL EMERGENCY. Our recommendations indicated clearly this mess could have been
solved in 8 hours FLAT using hydraulic Pressure sealing pipe sections and inserting even a JET SWET type annualar
which would seal against the interior of 21 inch pipe with a .812 side wall allowing 18 inches flow to the surface.
Instead of cutting the pipe the experts from BP decided to use the 6 inch STRAW technique. THEIR CALL.WRONG
BUT THEIR CALL. Next came the Hydraulic SHEARS cutting blade on the BOTTTOM OF STRESSED
PIPE.MISTAKE.THEIR MISTAKE. Finally using circular TOOTHED SAWS cutting from bottom and sides on stressed
pipe..MISTAKE.THEIR MISTAKE. Next we watched the cut just above flange bolts on right side with diamond
cutter perhaps 50 inches across cutting on stressed side and getting jammed..MISTAKETHEIR MISTAKE.

Finally we watched in UTTER DISBELIEF the insertion of a TOP HAT 4 which was never set up to capture the DIAMOND
CUT nor the RISER BENT as it was not cut flush just above the nuts and bolts of the flange NOR did the TOP HAT 4 set
down perfect seal over the TOP FLANGE as no one knows the exact measurements of what may have been made in
CHINA and hell.no two ROVs could work together taking a 5 FOOT FLEXIBLE LADIES MEASURING TAPE TO THE
BOTTOM, PULLING IT AROUND AND VIEWING THE MEASUREMENTS TO GIVE YOU A ROUGH IDEA TO SEAL AROUND
THAT PERFECTLY CUT AND CLEAN SURFACE OF MAYBE 3 INCHES ON THE TOP OF THE BOP FLANGE. Thus
MISTAKE.THEIR MISTAKE..NO ONE CALLED CAMERONNO ONE CALLED BRANKO R. BABIC VIA SKYPE OR
TELEPHONE.NOR DID ANYONE CALL RALPHWHITLEYSR ON SKYPE OR LANDLINE.SO YOU ARE STILL THERE IN
MISTAKE MODE. Remember how stupid ideas solve MILLIONS OF DOLLARS WORTH OF MISTAKES ! You have
spent BP some $750 MILLION when you could have spent $20,000.00 solved the problem temporarily saving the GULF
and SAVING FLORIDA AND ALL ISLANDS SOUTH AND EAST perhaps with that $20,000.00 BRANKO R. BABIC FLOW
THRU PIPE, SHUTOFF, WEIGHT AND FLANGE ON TOP OF THE BOP SEALING WITH A SIMPLE MACHINED SLEEVE
THICK WALL WITH BOLTS as recommended. !

Choice is YOURS BP. At least until Admiral Thad Allen gets permission to bring in the USCG, USN SEABEES and other
municipal and County utility people who knew on the first 4 days how to solve the leaks.all three but it sounded so
very STUPID to some who are trying to figure out how to tie their shoes Right to Left or Left to Right. What will it
COST in the LONG RUN ????? BILLIONS when you only had to spend some $20,000.00 but the EXPERTS never went to
a welding shop then into a POOL to check the models to see if those two OLD PEOPLE WERE CORRECT ! Silly Huh?
So was the FORCE LEAD INTO THE CASING PEMEX IDEA IN 1979 !

Now read the THERMITE EXPLOSION METHOD and understand IXTOC 1 went into a blowtorch mode which could
happen here.
2
LOOK AT THE REMOVAL OF THE BOP SETTING IT ASIDE AFTER YOU GET ANOTHER ONE ON A BARGE STANDING BYE
TO BE DIRECTED OVER THAT MALE SEAL AREA ON THE BOTTOM. USE HIGH PRESSURE WATER TO BLOW OUT THE
CASING AND FLANGE AREA TO BE SURE THEY DID NOT SECURE SAME WITH BOLTS..THEN MAYBE THE OLD BOP
COULD BE REMOVED AND REPLACED WITH ANOTHER WITH WATER PRESSURE FROM HIGH PRESSURE HOSES
BLOWING AWAY THE EDGE OF THE MALE ADAPTER SO THE FEMALE ADAPTER AND CRANE CAN LOWER THE NEW
BOP OVER AND MAKE A PERFECT FIT.THEN CONTROL TO THE BOP TOP FLANGE WITH SHUTOFF PLACED ON
BEFORE LOWERING CAN ATTACH TO THE NEW FLANGE FEMALE AND CHECK VALVES WITH HYDRAULIC OIL TO
SURFACE SHIP THEN BRING IN THE DP MODE VESSEL TO TAKE OVER PERHAPS OR STOP THE WELL WITH THE
BRANKO R. BABIC FRICTION PLUG SET DOWN IN THE CASING FROM THE BOTTOM SEALING IT FOREVER THEN PUT
IN PLENTY OF CEMENT MIXED WITH FRESH WATER AND DO TELL AMERICA HOW LONG BEFORE THE SEA EATS
THROUGH THE OUTER WALLS AND CAUSES EVERYTHING TO BLOW OUT AND DESTROY AMERICA.SO WE CAN GET
SPACE ON THE MOON !

Thank you Sir living in Russia for eventually this could happen ON YOUR SOIL or IN YOUR WATERS. Thank you as one
Human to another Human trying to save our Planet from some EXPERTS AND GREED ! I still will look into SOLAR
POWER later at 70 years old. My thoughts of running a vehicle using WATER FOR GAS techniques is getting more
appealing as is living on a super high mountain somewhere because those fumes are heavier than air with 4,000
potential problems sitting in the GULF alone !

Ruth DeLaMater Bundy, Age 80 and Ralph Charles Whitley, Sr. Age 70
Tampa, Florida USA
061510 @ 1:53 PM Eastern

From: [mailto:puk8th@ukr.net]
Sent: Tuesday, June 15, 2010 2:19 AM
To: TMichael@oceaneering.com
Cc: pop@oilstates.com
Subject: To plug MC252 and more #47

Pls see attachment.= backflow2@Verizon.net=Sorry,I can't open your attachment in email I rcvd.