Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
EUROPEAN
POLICY BRIEF
Landscape perception and computer modelling in
participatory mapping efforts in Latin America
The policy implications of COMBIOSERVE, an EU-funded project in communitybased conservation in Latin America
January 2015
INTRODUCTION
Computer modelling is a contemporary tool for landscape analysis. It has an important
application for the analysis and understanding of future scenarios. These are tools that
are increasingly in demand by indigenous and traditional peoples in Latin America,
either for negotiating the recognition of their rights or for planning to care for the
environment.
The use of geo-technology in computer modelling can contribute to data analysis and
the construction of models that enable the analysis of future scenarios helping to
evaluate the management of landscapes and territories. Models can be utilized to
analyse and predict resources use in space, as well as its dynamics and density, it can
also help us understand landscape dynamics, or the characteristics of soils and
topography, as well as to demarcate the scale of environmental conflicts.
Participatory mapping has emerged as a method for collecting and analysing
geographic information through co-research, making use of the interaction between
multiple forms of knowledge. Mapping is a tool that aids within contexts of socioenvironmental conflict and for coping for land use change and environmental
management processes within indigenous and rural territories. Co-research implies the
creation of a space in which indigenous or community members and external
researchers collectively interact, in this case for the production of mapping processes.
Such a collaborative possibility not only has relevant ethical implications, but it also has
the potential to derive into new perspectives for participatory mapping (such as social
and collaborative cartographies).
Local people and organizations, including many social movements for social and
environmental change, are embracing these tools and incorporating them into their
local knowledge. These people are not only mere receptors of these tools but may
tactically or strategically use them and rework them for local needs. The use of maps,
GIS tools, and participatory territorial monitoring, among others, may be taken as
examples.
Main Focus
This policy brief presents the key concepts and the methodology and information
needed in order to integrate community perception and computer modelling for
analysing and generating potential scenarios and concrete actions for landscape
conservation.
The main focus is on the uses of computer geo-technology for participatory or ethnomapping mapping for landscape analysis with indigenous and traditional peoples in
Latin America. It is based on the COMBIOSERVE experience regarding the use of
geo-technology and participatory mapping techniques. The policy brief also illustrates
the possible applications of this methodology to policy making and CSOs.
Computer Modelling
for Participatory Mapping
What does this mean?
A model is a simplified representation of reality. A map is therefore a model
representing a cartographic reproduction of terrain, earth or world. Computational
modelling can be used for generating models using digital databases organized
according to different information. Technological advances have hugely increased the
possibilities for modelling.
In line with this logic, computer models may be created using a database of traditional
knowledge. Geo-technology or espatialisation technology is fundamental to this
process and has significantly enhanced the possibilities for generating scenarios and
prognostics.
Computerized tools for the analysis of spatial data, Geographic Information Systems
(GIS), or Geographic Participative Information Systems (GPIS) also known as
EthnoGIS, have been used into mapping experiences associated with ethnoecological
and ethnobiological knowledge in order to analyse landscapes and specific territories.
The construction of maps also provides an opportunity to conduct reflective processes
with communities. It involves self-recognition and the valuing of territories and ways of
life. In other words, it is way for the members of an indigenous community to analyse
their context and plan their future.
Through the rich process of collective construction and of maps, the community creates
a Geographic Information System based on their knowledge of their local environment.
This system is a product that can be continuously expanded by community experiences
and used for diverse purposes, ranging from the training of young people and joint
learning to monitoring, planning, and management of their territory.
Step by step
The process of constructing computer models based on traditional knowledge is
difficult and methodologically controversial, since its concept is defined during the
process. In other words, there is no method or common format for its preparation. As
a guide, certain steps may be followed, although not necessarily in a sequential order.
ETHNOGIS
Traditional
Knowledge
Conversation circles,
Open walks,
Workshops, Ethnomaps,
Timelines, Conflict
analysis,
Participatory
methodologies,
Others....
Pre-existing maps,
Satellite images,
Cartographic databases,
Digital land models,
Other data
Integration
Generating computer
models
However, there is no single methodology, nor have any definitions been made for such
a construction, which must always be a continuous process. Data must preferably be
geo-referenced by a geo-positioning system (GPS), although other alphanumeric data,
or even videos and photos forming the database, can also be used. Previous
experiences demonstrate that the Computer Modelling multiples data and that there are
several possibilities.
TYPES OF DATA
Oral
Video
Alphanumeric
Georeferenced
Raster
Vector
Reports by elders
(Data: traditional
knowledge)
Free walks
(Data: traditional
knowledge)
Educational
activities in schools
(Data: multiple
knowledge)
Workshops
(Data: multiple
knowledge)
Interviews
(Data: traditional
knowledge)
Transects
(Data: traditional
knowledge)
Geo-referencing
(Data: cartographic
knowledge)
Pre-existing maps
(Data: cartographic
knowledge)
Digital image
processing
(Data: multiple
knowledge)
Modelling of data in
GIS
(Data: multiple
knowledge)
The communities within the Pilon Lajas Biosphere Reserve do not have
predetermined borders. However, an internal arrangement of their limitas
exists between these communities. The collected data was stored in the
GPS and in field notebooks. Once the work was completed this data was
sent to the academic researcher and the maps were constructed.
The convergence and tensions between knowledge assumes the need for an
attitude of respect. In other words, it treats seriously the different protocols and
assumptions that the various knowledge traditions may have. For this, we
recommend that participatory mapping processes that intend to use geo-technology
incorporate methodological approaches from anthropology and ethnoecology, such
as collaborative ethnography, which can be useful tools for communication.
A great challenge is to translate different types of knowledge through maps. For this
reason, we must evaluate what is and what is not important for spatialisation, since
each map has its own intentionality; in other words, it serves with an objective.
Thus, in each situation a rigorous study based in geographical criteria should define
what type of data or information can be spatialised.
Integrating new mapping technologies into the traditional ways in which these
communities live and think about their spaces should not involve a reduction of the
differences . On the contrary, it should strengthen it. In other words, in traditional
mapping, the process should always be the most important aspect. In this case, in
participative mapping experiences that utilize computer technology and modelling, it
is important to provide training that enables an understanding of the potential for this
techniques and to have meetings and workshops that enable knowledge dialogue.
In this context, a GIS that incorporates traditional knowledge may contain preexisting data or data constructed by a wide range of government bodies, academia
or others. However, due to its nature, data may originate from various sources and
include a range of types. However, despite the numerous possibilities for data
sources, an ontological limits prevail:
Technical scientific knowledge tends to enumerate, classify, define and
conceptualize information, and subsequently abstract reality to transform it into a
model. According to this logic, GISs are hugely important. However, it is not
possible to generalize the measurements, classifications and definitions of
cartographic knowledge to traditional knowledge.
PROJECT IDENTITY
Coordinator
Consortium
EU contact
Funding scheme
Duration
Budget
EC Contribution: 1,897,883.40
Website
www.combioserve.org
Further reading