Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
10 Hydrogen Embrittlement
R. A. Cottis
Corrosion and Protection Centre, School of Materials, University of Manchester, Manchester M60 1QD, UK
2.10.1
2.10.2
2.10.3
2.10.3.1
2.10.3.2
2.10.4
2.10.5
2.10.6
2.10.7
2.10.7.1
2.10.7.2
2.10.7.3
2.10.8
2.10.9
2.10.10
2.10.11
2.10.11.1
2.10.11.2
2.10.11.3
2.10.11.4
2.10.11.5
2.10.12
2.10.12.1
2.10.12.2
2.10.12.3
2.10.13
2.10.13.1
2.10.13.2
2.10.13.3
2.10.14
References
Introduction
Terminology
Entry of Hydrogen into Metals
Entry from the Gas Phase
Entry from the Aqueous Phase
Location of Hydrogen in Steel
Transport of Hydrogen in Iron and Steel
Sources of Hydrogen
Effect of Hydrogen on Mechanical Properties
Elastic Constants
Yield Stress
Plastic Behavior
Hydrogen Embrittlement of Steels
Hydrogen Embrittlement of Other Alloys
The Influence of Microstructure and Composition
Theories of Hydrogen Embrittlement
The Pressure Theory
Decohesion Theories
Surface Energy Theories
Hydride Formation
Local Plasticity Theories
Hydrogen Embrittlement Tests
Constant Stress Tests
Controlled Strain-Rate Tests
Fracture Mechanics Tests
Controlling Hydrogen Embrittlement in Service
Reduction of Hydrogen Content
Increasing Resistance of Steel
Prediction of Behavior
Modeling of Hydrogen Embrittlement
Abbreviations
AIDE Adsorption-induced dislocation emission
bcc Body centered cubic
CTOD Crack tip opening displacement
fcc Face centered cubic
hcp Hexagonal close packed
HELP Hydrogen-induced localized plasticity
HEDE Hydrogen-enhanced decohesion
HIC Hydrogen-induced cracking
HISC Hydrogen-induced stress cracking
SCC Stress corrosion cracking
SCE Saturated calomel electrode
902
903
903
903
903
904
905
906
907
911
911
911
911
912
913
913
914
914
915
915
915
915
915
916
916
917
918
919
920
921
921
921
Symbols
a Crack length
K Stress intensity factor
KIc Critical stress intensity factor for fast fracture
KISCC Critical stress intensity factor for SCC
r Distance ahead of crack tip
sth Threshold stress for SCC
Hydrogen Embrittlement
903
2.10.1 Introduction
2.10.2 Terminology
904
Hydrogen Embrittlement
905
Plate 1
Plate 2
Plate 3
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
1600 1500 1400 1300 1200 1100 1000
Potential (mV)(SCE)
900
800
700
Figure 1 Hydrogen permeation current as a function of applied potential, showing effect of change in reaction mechanism
below 1200 mV (SCE). Reproduced from Obuzor, U. W. PhD Thesis, UMIST, Manchester 1989.
(a)
Tetrahedral Site
(b)
Octahedral Site
906
Classification
Description
Saturable
Nonsaturable
Reversible
Irreversible
Hydrogen Embrittlement
907
Specimen
Luggin probe to
reference electrode
Platinum
counter
electrode
Nickel oxide
battery electrode
Hydrogen entry side
filled with test
solution
(b) Pipe diffusion may occur in the dislocation network of predeformed samples, whereas hydrogen
accelerated transport by mobile dislocations is
expected during plastic deformation in f.c.c.
structures;
(c) Both the local plasticity and the embrittlement of
these alloys are increased by hydrogen.
Using in situ observations in an environmental TEM,
Robertson14 has obtained further experimental confirmation of the influence of hydrogen on dislocation
dynamics, and confirmed that hydrogen enhanced
dislocation mobility.
908
Electroplating Electroplated metal coatings provide a convenient and effective means of protecting steel against atmospheric corrosion, with zinc
and cadmium being particularly useful because of
their ability to provide sacrificial protection to the
steel substrate at breaks in the coating. Unfortunately, all metal deposition processes require the
application of potentials at which hydrogen evolution is possible (in theory it would be possible to
deposit copper and more noble metals above the
hydrogen evolution potential, but as this would
also be a potential at which iron would dissolve
anodically, this would not produce good deposits).
Thus, the electrodeposition of coatings almost inevitably introduces hydrogen into the metal. The
majority of electrodeposited coatings on iron are
much less permeable to hydrogen than iron, the
major exceptions to this being other bcc metals,
with chromium being the only example in widespread use (although even here chromium is generally used with an undercoat of nickel or copper,
which will act as a barrier). Consequently, most of
the hydrogen uptake occurs in the early stages of
the deposition process, before a complete coverage
of the coating metal has been achieved, and the start
of the deposition process is particularly critical in
determining the amount of hydrogen absorbed.
Clearly, the highest possible ratio of metal deposition rate to hydrogen generation rate is required in
this period, and this tends to be favored by high
current densities. For this reason (among others), a
high current density flash deposit of metal is often
used as the first stage of a two-stage plating scheme.
Bath composition is also important in controlling
the entry of hydrogen into the steel.
Once high-strength steel components have been
electroplated, it is possible (and often mandatory) to
reduce the damaging effects of the hydrogen by baking
at 200 C. In part, this serves to allow hydrogen to
diffuse through the coating and out to the atmosphere,
but the redistribution of the remaining hydrogen
within the steel, reducing damaging local high concentrations, is probably also an important part of this
de-embrittlement treatment.
A very important area of use for electroplated highstrength steels is fasteners and other high stress components in aircraft. These are generally protected by
cadmium plating, although the toxicity of cadmium
and its compounds is giving rise to a search for alternatives. In this application, the avoidance of hydrogen
embrittlement is clearly essential, and as a result, a
Hydrogen Embrittlement
wide range of standard procedures and tests for cadmium plating of high-strength steels are available as
civil or military specifications and codes of practice.15
Phosphating Phosphating, which is widely used as
a pretreatment for steel prior to painting, involves
the controlled corrosion of the steel in acid solution, and inevitably leads to the uptake of hydrogen. By limiting the free acid in the phosphating
bath, and by introducing oxidizing agents to raise
the working potential, the uptake of hydrogen may
be reduced.
Painting Conventional paints are normally innocuous, but it seems possible that some modern waterbased paints, particularly those applied by cathodic
electrophoresis, may introduce significant quantities of hydrogen into the steel. Fortunately, these
paints are generally stoved after application, and
this is effective in removing the hydrogen, which
permeates very easily through the paint film.16
Additionally, these paints are applied primarily to
lower-strength steels in motor vehicle bodies and
similar applications, and as far as the author is
aware, no problems have been experienced in service. However, suitable tests would be advisable
if it is intended to use these processes with highstrength steels.
Paint strippers may give rise to hydrogen entry
into steel, and in critical applications, such as the
treatment of aircraft components, commercial paint
strippers should be tested before use.
Corrosion in Service Most of the modes of hydrogen entry discussed above involve a single brief
charging period, and as a result are treatable, in
that the hydrogen can be removed by a suitable deembrittlement treatment (provided the embrittlement is not so severe that cracks are formed before
the de-embrittlement treatment can be applied). In
contrast, the entry of hydrogen due to corrosion in
service is generally continuous. Thus, de-embrittlement is not feasible, and the control of hydrogen
embrittlement of high strength steels presents a
much more difficult problem.
In general, hydrogen will enter steel during any
corrosion process involving hydrogen ion or water
reduction as one of the cathodic reactions. It is frequently implied that the applied potential must be
below the equilibrium potential for hydrogen evolution before hydrogen entry into steel is possible. However, for two related reasons this is not true. Firstly, the
909
910
106
107
108
109
1010
1600
Detection limit
1200
800
400
400
In deaerated neutral salt solutions, anodic polarization of chromium-free steel tends to lower the rate of
hydrogen entry, as the fall in pH due to ferrous ion
hydrolysis is relatively limited, and cannot compensate
for the more positive potential. However, in aerated
solution, the ferrous ion can be oxidized to ferric in
solution by dissolved oxygen, and as ferric hydroxide is
much less soluble than ferrous hydroxide, the pH can
fall much lower. (This reaction is a serious problem
when trying to measure the solution pH in cracks and
crevices, and much of the early work which shows very
acid pH values in cracks in carbon steels is now known
to be incorrect because this reaction was allowed to
occur between extracting the crack solution and measuring its pH). In addition to lowering the surface pH,
it seems possible that the precipitated film of ferric
hydroxide/oxide also presents an ohmic resistance,
and may thereby allow the surface potential to become
lower than that measured in the bulk solution. It seems
probable that the combination of these two effects was
responsible for the increase in permeation current
observed for anodic polarization by Barth et al.18
Many steels contain small, but significant concentrations of chromium, and it should be appreciated that
chromium concentrations of 1% can markedly increase the tendency for local acidification, owing to the
much stronger tendency for chromium ion hydrolysis.
As considerations such as those discussed above
have become more widely appreciated, it has become
Hydrogen Embrittlement
911
600
700
800
900
1000
12
pH
11
10
9
8
H2 (mV)
7
40
20
0
20
40
60
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
1200 1100 1000 900 800 700 600
External potential (mV)(SCE)
500
Figure 6 Potential and pH in a simulated crevice, and effect on hydrogen permeation current. Reproduced from Taqi, E. A.;
Cottis, R. A. Corrosion Chemistry within Pits, Cracks and Crevices; Turnbull, A.; NPL: London, 1987; 483494.
clear that it is quite difficult to specify aqueous environments in which hydrogen entry into steel will occur
at a sufficiently low rate that the possibility of hydrogen embrittlement can be discounted. The main candidates for such an environment are strong alkalis and
highly oxidizing environments, such as nitric acid or
nitrates, which are free of species, such as chloride,
which predispose to pitting or crevice corrosion, and
high temperature environments, such as water at
250 C (since the deleterious effects of dissolved
hydrogen decrease at high temperatures).
Elastic Constants
Yield Stress
Plastic Behavior
912
Applied stress
120
100
80
60
Increasing
hydrogen
content
40
Threshold stress
20
0
1
10
100
Time to failure (log scale)
1000
Hydrogen Embrittlement
Table 2
913
Material
Yield stress
(MPa)
Failure timea
(h)
KIc
(MPam)
KISCC
(MPam)
Plateau velocity
(m s1)
HY130
300M
4340
4340
4130
4130
18Ni MS
18Ni MS
18Ni MS
900
1600
14001800
<1400
1300
1050
1900
1500
1200
NF
40150
400
10,000
NF
130170
40100
180
160
60140
115
20
3080
30
120
535
40100
120
5 108
108
105 102
106 104
105
a
The failure time presented is the approximate time to failure at an applied stress of 75% of the yield stress of the material.
MS = Maraging Steel.
914
Hydrogen Embrittlement
2.10.11.5
2.10.11.2 Decohesion Theories
The decohesion models proposed by Troiano, Oriani,
and others3335 suggest that the role of hydrogen is to
weaken the interatomic bonds in the steel, thereby
facilitating grain boundary separation or cleavage
crack growth. In view of the very low hydrogen concentration in the matrix, it is necessary for some
method to exist by which the hydrogen can be concentrated at the site of the fracture. For cracking along
phase or grain boundaries, this can be explained in
terms of the trapping of hydrogen at the phase boundary. It is a little more difficult to see how transgranular
cracking can be explained; processes which have been
invoked include the concentration of hydrogen at the
region of triaxial tensile stress at the crack tip and local
high concentrations of hydrogen being generated by
reaction or adsorption at the crack tip.
2.10.11.3 Surface Energy Theories
Surface energy theories were first proposed by Petch
and Stables.36 By lowering the surface energy of the
newly formed crack, the hydrogen reduces the stress
intensity required for brittle fracture. As with the
decohesion models, surface energy models only seem
reasonable for the case of hydrogen derived from
surface layers or grain boundaries, since the hydrogen
adsorption must occur at the same time as the fracture
event in order for the reduction in surface energy to be
effective in lowering the energy required for fracture.
915
There are several classes of test for hydrogen embrittlement, according to the application. Three general
types of mechanical test can be identified, together
with chemical and electrochemical tests intended to
determine the hydrogen content of steels or the rate
of entry of hydrogen from an environment.
916
2.10.12.2
Hydrogen Embrittlement
only by normal ductile fracture processes. Test durations clearly depend on the strain-rate and the ductility of the metal, but typical test durations for steels
in hydrogen embrittling environments are 1 week.
In addition to providing a rapid indication of the possibility of SCC in a particular system, the slow strainrate test can also be used to study the effect of material
and environmental factors on the susceptibility. For
example, Figure 8 shows the effect of environment
composition and tempering temperature on the reduction in area obtained for tests on a quenched and
tempered steel in various aqueous solutions. The minimum in the reduction in area which can be seen for
tempering temperatures of 350 C provides evidence
of the interaction between hydrogen embrittlement
and temper embrittlement.
While the conventional slow strain-rate test offers
many benefits, it does suffer from a tendency to overstate the susceptibility of materials to hydrogen embrittlement. Thus, structural steels of modest strength will
fail even under conditions giving relatively low rates of
hydrogen entry. This is because the enforced plastic
deformation provides a very severe test condition,
which may not be reproduced in service when
80
70
Air
Demin. water
1200 ppm chloroplatinic acid
400 ppm chloroplatinic acid
3.5% NaCl
500 ppm Na2S
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
550
917
One problem of both sustained load and slow strainrate tests is that they do not provide a means of predicting the behavior of components containing defects
(other than the inherent defect associated with the
notch in a sustained load test). Fracture mechanics
provide a basis for such tests, and measurements of
crack velocity as a function of stress intensity factor, K,
are widely used. A typical graph of crack velocity as a
function of K is shown in Figure 11. Several regions
may be seen on this curve. At low stress intensity
factors, no crack growth is observed until a threshold
stress intensity factor, KISCC is reached. Typically,
KISCC is fairly insensitive to the rate of hydrogen
entry into the steel (as the crack is not growing at a
significant rate, hydrogen will eventually accumulate
at a sufficient concentration at the crack tip, whatever
the rate of entry). As the stress intensity factor increases above KISCC the crack growth rate increases
rapidly, until a plateau crack velocity is attained. The
plateau velocity is a function of the rate of hydrogen
entry, and the plateau is usually attributed to the
availability of hydrogen at the crack tip being the
rate-limiting factor. Finally, the crack velocity increases again as the stress intensity factor approaches
the critical stress intensity factor for fast fracture, KIC.
918
Slow strain
rate test
No
SCC?
Not susceptible
Yes
Elastic slow
strain rate test
No
SCC?
Dynamic plastic
straining tests
Yes
Slow strain rate test - a max
Static tests
C-ring test - s th
Strain
Hydrogen Embrittlement
106
107
KlSCC
108
40
60
80
Stress intensity factor (MPa)
100
120
919
2.10.13.2
100
Retained tensile ductility (%)
920
80
Commercial alloys
High-purity alloys
60
40
20
0
0
10
20
30
40
Nickel (wt%)
50
60
Hydrogen Embrittlement
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
921
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
922
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
2.11.1
2.11.2
2.11.3
2.11.4
2.11.5
2.11.5.1
2.11.6
2.11.6.1
2.11.6.2
2.11.6.3
References
Introduction
Sources of Hydrogen
Hydrogen Pressure Induced Cracking (HPIC)
Hydrogen Embrittlement
Stress Oriented Hydrogen Induced Cracking (SOHIC)
SOHIC Mechanism
Testing Methods for Hydrogen Cracking
Hydrogen Pressure Induced Cracking
Hydrogen Embrittlement
Testing for SOHIC
Abbreviations
EFC European Federation of Corrosion
HIC Hydrogen induced cracking
HPIC Hydrogen pressure induced cracking
SOHIC Stress orientated hydrogen induced
cracking
SSCC Sulfide stress corrosion cracking
Symbols
HAZ Heat affected zone
HV10 Vickers hardness 10 Kg load
H2S Hydrogen sulfide
MPa Mega pascals
2.11.1 Introduction
There are several forms of environmental cracking
that are either stimulated or produced by hydrogen.
Over the past decade and in previous decades,
there have been a significant number of pipeline
failures attributed to such mechanisms. The types
of cracking and compatibility of materials will be
described in this chapter.
In an ideal world, high strength steels would be fully
utilized in, for example, pipelines and offshore structures, the weight advantage being very attractive. However, in general terms, as the strength of steel increases
923
923
924
925
925
925
926
926
926
927
927
923
924
particular compounds such as cyanides, atomic hydrogen can enter steel in vast quantities, whereas under
highly corrosive conditions such as corrosion in hydrochloric acid, where copious quantities of gaseous
hydrogen is produced, hydrogen atoms do not enter
the steel anywhere near such amounts.
Generation
Generation of hydrogen by corrosion processes
Fe2+
2H+ + 2e = H + H= H2
H
Fe 2e
H + H= H2
Figure 1 The corrosion process.
925
SOHIC Mechanism
926
Current research has identified the overall importance of a tri-axial stress, and a test method that
applies a complex stress field to the sample is in the
late stages of refinement.
It should be noted that SOHIC is not limited to
line-pipe, it has been observed in plates and fittings.
Interestingly, the materials in question had hardness
significantly below the level accepted for SSCC/
hydrogen embrittlement resistance.
Hydrogen Embrittlement
927
10
9
Load
0
0
10 000 20 000 30 000 40 000 50 000 60 000 70 000 80 000 90 000 10 0000
Time
2.11.6.3
At the time of writing, there is currently no universally accepted test for SOHIC. There are two published methods, one for pressure vessel plate (NACE
TM010310 the double beam test, not to be confused
with the double cantilever beam test; under review
for withdrawal) and one for line-pipe (HSE Publication OTI 95 63511 the full ring test).
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.