Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Cary Moskovitz
Duke University
Responses
However,
Yet
Concession
Response
Of course,
I concede that
Nevertheless,
It is true that
In spite of this
But
It is possible that
Writing 101
Cary Moskovitz
In the passage below, try to identify the following with notes in the margin:
claims,
concessions
In 1998, John Colquhoun published an argument against water fluoridation. Newborn and
Horowitz wrote a response to Colquhoun arguing for fluoridation.1 The following passage comes
from that response.
Newbrun, E. and Horowitz, H. Why we have not changed our minds about water fluoridation. Perspectives
in Biology and Medicine. 42:526-30 , 1999.
Writing 101
Cary Moskovitz
I will assign groups to argue for one of the claims listed at the bottom of this page. Using
what you know about the topic, construct the elements listed below on a separate sheet
of paper. (For this exercise its OK to play a bit loose with the facts.)
1. Your main claim (assigned)
2. 1-2 principal items of support for your claim (evidence, reasons, etc.)
3. A counter-argument: a reason/piece of evidence/argument that contradicts your claim and
that you believe is not valid?
a. A response to that counterargument: Why should we not accept the
counterargument?
4. A concession: a reason/piece of evidence/argument that contradicts your claim, but that you
believe has validity.
a. A response to that counterargument: Why should we accept your claim in spite of
your concessions?
Claims to argue:
1. Duke administrators should formally discourage frequent coffee consumption for
students.
2. Duke administrators should not discourage frequent coffee consumption for students.
3. Drinking coffee is generally healthy for obese individuals.
4. Drinking coffee is generally unhealthy for obese individuals.
5.
6. D