Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Judgment Sheet
IN THE LAHORE HIGH COURT LAHORE
JUDICIAL DEPARTMENT
Case No: W.P. 5406/2011
Syed Riaz Ali Zaidi
Versus
JUDGMENT
Dates of hearing:
Petitioner by:
Respondents by:
Amici Curiae:
Assisted by:
W.P. No.5406/2011
The facts are that the Prime Minister in the year 2011
W.P. No.5406/2011
W.P. No.5406/2011
W.P. No.5406/2011
Any such
following recommendation on 19.12.2010:The superior judiciary and its staff may be provided a
general increase in Pay and Judicial Allowance at the
uniform rate of 50% as made applicable to government
servants in the Budget.
W.P. No.5406/2011
5.
6.
7.
..
9.
The same was approved and letter dated 26.01.2011 was issued
to all the respective Registrars of the superior judiciary by the
Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs Division, Government
of Pakistan. The letter stated:
I am directed to say that the Prime Minster has been pleased
to approve 50% increase at the uniform rate of the basic pay
and Judicial Allowance to the staff of the Superior Judiciary
with effect from 1st July, 2010.
W.P. No.5406/2011
the staff of the superior judiciary, they are since being paid to
the staff of the superior judiciary, across the country, including
the august Supreme Court of Pakistan, Federal Shariat Court, as
well as, all the other High Courts of Pakistan except the Lahore
High Court. In some cases the Provincial Government simply
implemented the decision of the Prime Minister, and in other,
independent and separate decision of the respective judiciaries
was implemented.
12. The question before this Court is whether administrative
expenses of the High Court, which under the Constitution is an
expenditure charged on the Provincial Consolidated Fund under
Articles 121 and 122 of the Constitution, once approved and
claimed by the High Court, can be ignored or turned down by
the Provincial Government or the Provincial Legislature?
W.P. No.5406/2011
13.
autonomy;
(5)
administrative
autonomy.2
W.P. No.5406/2011
determining
its
administrative
expenses,
including
The
Habib-ul-Wahabb-ul-Khairi
and
others
v.
Articles 121 and 122 of the Constitution. Also see Accounting Policies
and Procedures Manual, Auditor General of Pakistan P.2.20.
4
Sharaf Faridi and 3 others v. The Federation of Islamic Republic of
Pakistan through Prime Minister of Pakistan and another (PLD 1989
Karachi 404) and also Government of Sindh through Chief Secretary to
Government of Sindh, Karachi and others v. Sharaf Faridi and others
(PLD 1994 SC 105).
5
Sh. Riaz-ul-Haq and another v. Federation of Pakistan through Ministry
of Law and others (PLD 2013 SC 501).
10
W.P. No.5406/2011
The financial
11
W.P. No.5406/2011
12
W.P. No.5406/2011
The
constitutional
significance
of
financial
autonomy,
13
W.P. No.5406/2011
Culture
of
judicial
independence
must
ensure
14
W.P. No.5406/2011
Article
208 of the Constitution provides that the High Court, with the
approval of the Governor concerned, may make rules providing
for the appointment by the Court of the officers and servants of
the Court and for their terms and conditions of employment.
The Rules that regulate the appointments and conditions of
11
15
W.P. No.5406/2011
The said Rule does not mean that the decision of the Honble
Chief Justice fixing the pay and allowances of the members of
the High Court Establishment will be subjected to the approval
of the Governor. The approval of the Governor is to the
promulgation of the Rules (which is a one-off act) and not to
the decisions of the Chief Justice issued from time to time
under the said Rules. Any interpretation subjecting the decision
of the Chief Justice to the approval of the Governor would be
constitutionally
impermissible
and
would
shake
the
W.P. No.5406/2011
16
that Rule 22 of the same Chapter of the High Court Rules and
Orders is simply for the efficient administrative governance of
the High Court. This Rule adopts the principles provided under
the Civil Service Rules (Punjab) regarding salaries, allowances,
leave and pension and in no manner converts or changes the
status of the officers and servants of the High Court into that of
civil servants or in any manner subordinates the authority of the
High Court in these matters to that of the Executive Branch.
21.
17
W.P. No.5406/2011
22.
the High Court so that the institution can draw up its own
administrative expenses (including remuneration of its officers
and servants). This expenditure falls under the head expenditure
charged upon the Provincial Consolidated Fund, which can be
discussed but is not submitted to vote by the Provincial
Assembly.
18
W.P. No.5406/2011
19
W.P. No.5406/2011
26.
Medical
Allow
50 %
Adhoc
Allow
2010
(w.e.f.
01.07.10)
Adhoc
Relief
2012
(at
initial
level)
Adhoc
Relief
2013
(at
initial
level)
Grand
Total
(Gross
Pay &
Allowances)
4800
1,337
1700
6000
3000
8910
1000
1485
446
960
720
30358
4800
1,337
1700
6000
3000
8910
1000
1485
446
960
720
30358
4800
1,337
1700
6000
3000
8250
1000
1485
446
960
720
29698
4800
1,337
1700
6000
3000
8910
1000
1485
446
960
480
30118
4800
1,337
1700
6000
3000
8910
1000
1485
446
960
480
30118
4800
1,337
1700
6000
3000
8910
1000
1485
446
960
480
30118
4800
1,337
1700
4000
3000
8910
1000
446
960
480
26633
4900
1,366
1700
6000
3000
9105
1000
1518
455
980
735
30759
4900
1,366
1700
6000
3000
9105
1000
1518
455
980
735
30759
4900
1,366
1700
6000
3000
8540
1000
1518
455
980
735
30194
4900
1,366
1700
6000
3000
9105
1000
1518
455
980
490
30514
4900
1,366
1700
6000
3000
9105
1000
1518
455
980
490
30514
4900
1,366
1700
6000
3000
9105
1000
1518
455
980
490
30514
4900
1,366
1700
4000
3000
9105
1000
455
980
490
26996
5050
1,413
1700
6000
3000
9420
1000
1570
471
1010
757.5
31392
5050
1,413
1700
6000
3000
9420
1000
1570
471
1010
757.5
31392
5050
1,413
1700
6000
3000
8975
1000
1570
471
1010
757.5
30947
Spl. Judl.
Allow
Utility Allow
Judicial
Allow
Conveyance
Allow
Basic Pay
(at initial
stage)
House Rent
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Pay Scale
Court /
Employees
of
Adhoc
Relief
2011
(at
initial
level)
20
W.P. No.5406/2011
Sr. Post
Allow
Medical
Allow
50 %
Adhoc
Allow
2010
(w.e.f.
01.07.10)
Adhoc
Relief
2012
(at
initial
level)
Adhoc
Relief
2013
(at
initial
level)
Grand
Total
(Gross
Pay &
Allowances)
5050
1,413
1700
6000
3000
9420
1000
1570
471
1010
505
31139
5050
1,413
1700
6000
3000
9420
1000
1570
471
1010
505
31139
5050
1,413
1700
6000
3000
9420
1000
1570
471
1010
505
31139
5050
1,413
1700
4000
3000
9420
1000
471
1010
505
27569
5200
1,458
1700
6000
3000
9720
1000
1620
486
1040
780
32004
5200
1,458
1700
6000
3000
9720
1000
1620
486
1040
780
32004
5200
1,458
1700
6000
3000
9410
1000
1620
486
1040
780
31694
5200
1,458
1700
6000
3000
9720
1000
1620
486
1040
520
31744
5200
1,458
1700
6000
3000
9720
1000
1620
486
1040
520
31744
5200
1,458
1700
6000
3000
9720
1000
1620
486
1040
520
31744
5200
1,458
1700
4000
3000
9720
1000
486
1040
520
28124
5400
1,503
1840
6000
3000
10020
1000
1670
501
1080
810
32824
5400
1,503
1840
6000
3000
10020
1000
1670
501
1080
810
32824
5400
1,503
1840
6000
3000
9920
1000
1670
501
1080
810
32724
5400
1,503
1840
6000
3000
10020
1000
1670
501
1080
540
32554
5400
1,503
1840
6000
3000
10020
1000
1670
501
1080
540
32554
5400
1,503
1840
6000
3000
10020
1000
1670
501
1080
540
32554
5400
1,503
1840
4000
3000
10020
1000
501
1080
540
28884
5600
1,544
1840
6000
3000
10290
1000
1715
515
1120
840
33464
5600
1,544
1840
6000
3000
10290
1000
1715
515
1120
840
33464
5600
1,544
1840
6000
3000
10430
1000
1715
515
1120
840
33604
5600
1,544
1840
6000
3000
10290
1000
1715
515
1120
560
33184
5600
1,544
1840
6000
3000
10290
1000
1715
515
1120
560
33184
5600
1,544
1840
6000
3000
10290
1000
1715
515
1120
560
33184
5600
1,544
1840
4000
3000
10290
1000
515
1120
560
29469
5800
1,589
1840
9000
4000
10590
1000
1765
530
1160
870
38144
5800
1,589
1840
9000
4000
10590
1000
1765
530
1160
870
38144
5800
1,589
1840
9000
4000
10940
1000
1765
530
1160
870
38494
Spl. Judl.
Allow
Utility Allow
Judicial
Allow
Conveyance
Allow
Basic Pay
(at initial
stage)
House Rent
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Pay Scale
Court /
Employees
of
Adhoc
Relief
2011
(at
initial
level)
21
W.P. No.5406/2011
Spl. Judl.
Allow
Sr. Post
Allow
Medical
Allow
11
Utility Allow
10
Judicial
Allow
Conveyance
Allow
Basic Pay
(at initial
stage)
House Rent
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Pay Scale
Court /
Employees
of
50 %
Adhoc
Allow
2010
(w.e.f.
01.07.10)
5800
1,589
1840
9000
4000
10590
1000
1765
5800
1,589
1840
9000
4000
10590
1000
5800
1,589
1840
9000
4000
10590
5800
1,589
1840
6000
4000
10590
6000
1,649
1840
9000
4000
6000
1,649
1840
9000
6000
1,649
1840
6000
1,649
6000
Adhoc
Relief
2011
(at
initial
level)
Adhoc
Relief
2012
(at
initial
level)
Adhoc
Relief
2013
(at
initial
level)
Grand
Total
(Gross
Pay &
Allowances)
530
1160
580
37854
1765
530
1160
580
37854
1000
1765
530
1160
580
37854
1000
530
1160
580
33089
10995
1000
1833
550
1200
900
38967
4000
10995
1000
1833
550
1200
900
38967
9000
4000
11450
1000
1833
550
1200
900
39422
1840
9000
4000
10995
1000
1833
550
1200
600
38667
1,649
1840
9000
4000
10995
1000
1833
550
1200
600
38667
6000
1,649
1840
9000
4000
10995
1000
1833
550
1200
600
38667
6000
1,649
1840
6000
4000
10995
1000
550
1200
600
33834
6200
1,719
1840
9000
4000
11460
1000
1910
573
1240
930
39872
6200
1,719
1840
9000
4000
11460
1000
1910
573
1240
930
39872
6200
1,719
1840
9000
4000
11960
1000
1910
573
1240
930
40372
6200
1,719
1840
9000
4000
11460
1000
1910
573
1240
620
39562
6200
1,719
1840
9000
4000
11460
1000
1910
573
1240
620
39562
6200
1,719
1840
9000
4000
11460
1000
1910
573
1240
620
39562
6200
1,719
1840
6000
4000
11460
1000
573
1240
620
34652
6400
1,780
1840
9000
4000
11865
1000
1978
593
1280
960
40696
6400
1,780
1840
9000
4000
11865
1000
1978
593
1280
960
40696
6400
1,780
1840
9000
4000
12540
1000
1978
593
1280
960
41371
6400
1,780
1840
9000
4000
11865
1000
1978
593
1280
640
40376
6400
1,780
1840
9000
4000
11865
1000
1978
593
1280
640
40376
6400
1,780
1840
9000
4000
11865
1000
1978
593
1280
640
40376
6400
1,780
1840
6000
4000
11865
1000
593
1280
640
35398
6600
1,854
2720
9000
4000
12345
1000
2058
617
1320
990
42504
6600
1,854
2720
9000
4000
12345
1000
2058
617
1320
990
42504
6600
1,854
2720
9000
4000
13120
1000
2058
617
1320
990
43279
22
W.P. No.5406/2011
Spl. Judl.
Allow
Sr. Post
Allow
Medical
Allow
15
Utility Allow
14
Judicial
Allow
13
Conveyance
Allow
12
Basic Pay
(at initial
stage)
House Rent
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Pay Scale
Court /
Employees
of
50 %
Adhoc
Allow
2010
(w.e.f.
01.07.10)
6600
1,854
2720
9000
4000
12345
1000
2058
6600
1,854
2720
9000
4000
12345
1000
6600
1,854
2720
9000
4000
12345
6600
1,854
2720
6000
4000
12345
7000
1,960
2720
9000
4000
7000
1,960
2720
9000
7000
1,960
2720
7000
1,960
7000
Adhoc
Relief
2011
(at
initial
level)
Adhoc
Relief
2012
(at
initial
level)
Adhoc
Relief
2013
(at
initial
level)
Grand
Total
(Gross
Pay &
Allowances)
617
1320
660
42174
2058
617
1320
660
42174
1000
2058
617
1320
660
42174
1000
617
1320
660
37116
13065
1000
2178
653
1400
1050
44026
4000
13065
1000
2178
653
1400
1050
44026
9000
4000
14000
1000
2178
653
1400
1050
44961
2720
9000
4000
13065
1000
2178
653
1400
700
43676
1,960
2720
9000
4000
13065
1000
2178
653
1400
700
43676
7000
1,960
2720
9000
4000
13065
1000
2178
653
1400
700
43676
7000
1,960
2720
6000
4000
13065
1000
653
1400
700
38498
7500
2,090
2720
9000
4000
13935
1000
2323
697
1500
1125
45890
7500
2,090
2720
9000
4000
13935
1000
2323
697
1500
1125
45890
7500
2,090
2720
9000
4000
15100
1000
2323
697
1500
1125
47055
7500
2,090
2720
9000
4000
13935
1000
2323
697
1500
750
45515
7500
2,090
2720
9000
4000
13935
1000
2323
697
1500
750
45515
7500
2,090
2720
9000
4000
13935
1000
2323
697
1500
750
45515
7500
2,090
2720
6000
4000
13935
1000
697
1500
750
40192
8000
2,214
2720
9000
4000
14760
1000
2460
738
1600
1200
47692
8000
2,214
2720
9000
4000
14760
1000
2460
738
1600
1200
47692
8000
2,214
2720
9000
4000
16270
1000
2460
738
1600
1200
49202
8000
2,214
2720
9000
4000
14760
1000
2460
738
1600
800
47292
8000
2,214
2720
9000
4000
14760
1000
2460
738
1600
800
47292
8000
2,214
2720
9000
4000
14760
1000
2460
738
1600
800
47292
8000
2,214
2720
6000
4000
14760
1000
738
1600
800
41832
8500
2,349
2720
9000
4000
15660
1000
2610
783
1700
1275
49597
8500
2,349
2720
9000
4000
15660
1000
2610
783
1700
1275
49597
8500
2,349
2720
9000
4000
17650
1000
2610
783
1700
1275
51587
23
W.P. No.5406/2011
Spl. Judl.
Allow
Sr. Post
Allow
Medical
Allow
19
Utility Allow
18
Judicial
Allow
17
Conveyance
Allow
16
Basic Pay
(at initial
stage)
House Rent
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Pay Scale
Court /
Employees
of
50 %
Adhoc
Allow
2010
(w.e.f.
01.07.10)
8500
2,349
2720
9000
4000
15660
1000
2610
8500
2,349
2720
9000
4000
15660
1000
8500
2,349
2720
9000
4000
15660
8500
2,349
2720
6000
4000
15660
10000
2,727
5000
9000
4000
10000
2,727
5000
9000
10000
2,727
5000
10000
2,727
10000
Adhoc
Relief
2011
(at
initial
level)
Adhoc
Relief
2012
(at
initial
level)
Adhoc
Relief
2013
(at
initial
level)
Grand
Total
(Gross
Pay &
Allowances)
783
1700
850
49172
2610
783
1700
850
49172
1000
2610
783
1700
850
49172
1000
783
1700
850
43562
18180
1000
3030
909
2000
1000
56846
4000
18180
1000
3030
909
2000
1000
56846
9000
4000
20600
1000
3030
909
2000
1500
59766
5000
9000
4000
18180
1000
3030
909
2000
1000
56846
2,727
5000
9000
4000
18180
1000
3030
909
2000
1000
56846
10000
2,727
5000
9000
4000
18180
1000
3030
909
2000
1000
56846
10000
2,727
5000
6000
4000
18180
1000
909
2000
1000
50816
16000
4,433
5000
15000
5000
29550
1478
4925
1478
3200
1600
87664
16000
4,433
5000
15000
5000
29550
1478
4925
1478
3200
1600
87664
16000
4,433
5000
15000
5000
32400
1478
4925
1478
3200
2400
91314
16000
4,433
5000
15000
5000
29550
1478
4925
1478
3200
1600
87664
16000
4,433
5000
15000
5000
29550
1478
4925
1478
3200
1600
87664
16000
4,433
5000
15000
5000
29550
1478
4925
1478
3200
1600
87664
16000
4,433
5000
10000
5000
29550
1478
1478
3200
1600
77739
20000
5,810
5000
18000
5000
38730
1937
6455
1937
4000
2000
108869
20000
5,810
5000
18000
5000
38730
1937
6455
1937
4000
2000
108869
20000
5,810
5000
18000
5000
40500
1937
6455
1937
4000
3000
111639
20000
5,810
5000
18000
5000
38730
1937
6455
1937
4000
2000
108869
20000
5,810
5000
18000
5000
38730
1937
6455
1937
4000
2000
108869
20000
5,810
5000
18000
5000
38730
1937
6455
1937
4000
2000
108869
20000
5,810
5000
12000
5000
38730
1937
1937
4000
2000
96414
31000
8,856
6000
21000
8000
59040
2952
9840
2952
6200
3100
158940
31000
8,856
6000
21000
8000
59040
2952
9840
2952
6200
3100
158940
31000
8,856
6000
21000
8000
57700
2952
9840
2952
6200
4650
159150
24
W.P. No.5406/2011
Utility Allow
Spl. Judl.
Allow
Sr. Post
Allow
Medical
Allow
22
Judicial
Allow
21
Conveyance
Allow
20
Basic Pay
(at initial
stage)
House Rent
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Sindh High
Court
Balochistan
High Court
Peshawar
High Court
Islamabad
High Court
Federal
Shariat
Court
Supreme
Court of
Pakistan
Lahore
High Court
Pay Scale
Court /
Employees
of
50 %
Adhoc
Allow
2010
(w.e.f.
01.07.10)
31000
8,856
6000
21000
8000
59040
2952
9840
31000
8,856
6000
21000
8000
59040
2952
31000
8,856
6000
21000
8000
59040
31000
8,856
6000
14000
8000
59040
36000
10,505
21000
8000
36000
10,505
21000
36000
10,505
36000
10,505
36000
Adhoc
Relief
2011
(at
initial
level)
Adhoc
Relief
2012
(at
initial
level)
Adhoc
Relief
2013
(at
initial
level)
Grand
Total
(Gross
Pay &
Allowances)
2952
6200
3100
158940
9840
2952
6200
3100
158940
2952
9840
2952
6200
3100
158940
2952
2952
6200
3100
142100
70035
1275
3502
11673
3502
7200
3600
176292
8000
70035
1275
3502
11673
3502
7200
3600
176292
21000
8000
70450
1275
3502
11673
3502
7200
5400
178507
21000
8000
70035
1275
3502
11673
3502
7200
3600
176292
10,505
21000
8000
70035
1275
3502
11673
3502
7200
3600
176292
36000
10,505
21000
8000
70035
1275
3502
11673
3502
7200
3600
176292
36000
10,505
14000
8000
70035
1275
3502
3502
7200
3600
157619
40000
11,646
21000
8000
77640
1350
3882
12940
3882
8000
4000
192340
40000
11,646
21000
8000
77640
1350
3882
12940
3882
8000
4000
192340
40000
11,646
21000
8000
78200
1350
3882
12940
3882
8000
6000
194900
40000
11,646
21000
8000
77640
1350
3882
12940
3882
8000
4000
192340
40000
11,646
21000
8000
77640
1350
3882
12940
3882
8000
4000
192340
40000
11,646
21000
8000
77640
1350
3882
12940
3882
8000
4000
192340
40000
11,646
14000
8000
77640
1350
3882
3882
8000
4000
172400
43000
12,456
21000
8000
83040
1750
4152
13840
4152
8600
4300
204290
43000
12,456
21000
8000
83040
1750
4152
13840
4152
8600
4300
204290
43000
12,456
21000
8000
85850
1750
4152
13840
4152
8600
6450
209250
43000
12,456
21000
8000
83040
1750
4152
13840
4152
8600
4300
204290
43000
12,456
21000
8000
83040
1750
4152
13840
4152
8600
4300
204290
43000
12,456
21000
8000
83040
1750
4152
13840
4152
8600
4300
204290
43000
12,456
14000
8000
83040
1750
4152
4152
8600
4300
183450
25
W.P. No.5406/2011
27.
Judicial Allowance
Adhoc Allowance-2010
2010-11
69888000
114960000
2011-12
75312000
116580000
2012-13
80326000
124795000
2013-14
82723000
127532000
2014-15
Total
Grand Total
129649000
308249000
613516000
26
W.P. No.5406/2011
Budget Statistics
Ratio
Percentage
677166.083
2419.653
0.0036
0.36
921.765
0.0014
0.14
28.
27
W.P. No.5406/2011
Before
parting
with
the
judgment
gratefully