Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Williams
Page 1
Christopher B. Williams
Page 2
Introduction
I am a future music educator. It will soon be my job to work with children who have a passion
for world of music, and those who might just be curious to see what music can bring to them.
More important than teaching music, my goal as a music educator will be to teach life lessons
through the performance of music. I wish that every student will leave my program a better
person. The purpose of this Developmental Standards project is to demonstrate my
understanding of InTASC Standard #1, the Indiana Department of Education All-Grade
Standards, and the Ball State School of Musics approach to being a comprehensive music
educator.
InTASC Standard #1 States:
The teacher understands how learners grow and develop, recognizing that patterns of
learning and development vary individually within and across the cognitive, linguistic,
social, emotional, and physical areas, and designs and implements developmentally
appropriate and challenging learning experiences.
Concepts in development:
1. Structured After-School Activities as A Moderator of Depressed Mood for
Adolescents with Detached Relations to Their Parents.
2. The Role of Arts Participation in Students Academic and Nonacademic
Outcomes: A Longitudinal Study of School, Home, and Community Factors
3. Motivation and engagement in music and sport: Testing a multidimensional
framework in diverse performance settings.
4. Conceptions of Adolescent Friendship Quality in Sport and Music Domains.
Christopher B. Williams
Page 3
Developmental Research #1
Structured After-School Activities as A Moderator of Depressed Mood for Adolescents
with Detached Relations to Their Parents.
It is well known that extracurricular activities can be beneficial to adolescent students in
numerous ways. Structured after-school activities are highly looked upon and encouraged in
middle and high school settings for this reason. A 2002 study of 539 Swedish 8th grade students
show just exactly how important these activities can be concerning mental health and depression.
The study looked at a sample of Swedish students who were both involved and not involved in
structured after-school activities, also considering the factor of whether or not they were close to
their parents. The study began with showing that there was a strong correlation between a poor
relationship with parental figures, and level of depressed feelings. Parental relations were rated
by level of communication, level of knowledge/interest in childs activities, and the amount of
time performing shared activities. It was shown that children with high levels of detachment to
their parents showed higher levels of depressed moods, especially in females (Mahoney,
Christopher B. Williams
Page 4
Schweder, & Stattin 2002). It was then shown that in this same distribution of students, when
sorted by 1.) No Participation 2.) Participation and 3.) Participation, High Leader Support,
students who were involved in structured after-school activities with a high level of support from
the groups leader showed considerably lower levels of depressed mood (Mahoney et al., 2002).
The results were especially notable in males. It should be noted that in addition to mental health
benefits, these extracurricular activities also provide lifelong lessons in teamwork, problem
solving, assertiveness, and competition (Berk, 2008).
Christopher B. Williams
Page 5
Christopher B. Williams
Page 6
will not perform academically to his or her potential, and the child will not have a healthy mental
state or social life. It is my goal as an instructor to give my students tools to help them feel like
they not only matter in this world, but that they can accelerate in whatever they choose to do
(AG 1.1, 1.3). As a music teacher, I will mainly focus on these tools being based around music
performance, and the goal setting and achievement that comes along with it. Group building
exercises and games will help students feeling of self-worth by helping to feel like they are a
part of something bigger than themselves. For example, a band I used to work with would do an
annual scavenger hunt around the school in an effort to get more familiar with the area. Students
would be placed into groups, and have to take pictures at all of the different places the clues
eluded to. When they got back together, they made a big silly slideshow of all the pictures that
were taken, and it seemed to bring the group a bit closer as a whole.
Developmental Research #3:
Motivation and engagement in music and sport: Testing a multidimensional framework in
diverse performance settings.
The following study looked at 224 classical musicians and 239 athletes in Australia, and tested
each participant based on their multidimensional model of motivation and engagement. Both
musicians and athletes are considered performers in the most basic of forms, but the type of
performance varies drastically when looking at the specific needs of each activity. This study
wants to see if both performance settings showed above average results in the areas of
motivation and engagement. They found that data confirms in both music and athletic settings,
performers have higher levels of self-efficacy, planning, task-management, and persistence to
achieving goals (Martin, 2008). They also found in these performance settings more constructive
forms of anxiety, and failure avoidance. Most people who came to say these traits play a major
Christopher B. Williams
Page 7
part in their lives, say that it is used a motivation rather than a possible consequence. It is of
relevance that the results between music and sports samples were predominately invariant
(Martin, 2008). It can be noted that these performers more than likely found their success
through positive reinforcement during the mastery process. When looking at achievement based
goals in the education world, it is always important to address failure with positive
reinforcement. For example, I believe that you can do better than that, versus That was not
very good at all (Berk, 2008).
Instructional Decision #3:
As a music educator, I would be working against myself if I was teaching students who didnt
want to achieve goals together. An effective music educator should be able to give any student a
reason to want to achieve excellence. It is the teachers responsibility to get to know each
student, and learn what motivates them all individually, and as a group. Positive reinforcement is
a great way to keep students motivated when going through a particularly tough time mastering a
concept. Creating a culture where students feel they are all responsible for each others success is
also key in achieving team-based excellence (AG 5.2). The key to succeeding as a group is to
have everybody accountable for their own individual work, and aware that the individual is the
only thing each student truly has control of (AG 3.16). A teacher has to always believe in his
students, and be their biggest cheerleader in constructive ways. Most importantly, if a teachers
students are not achieving at the level they are expected to, it is never their fault. The first thing
you must do is assess what you can do better for them as a teacher. You can have motivation
without achievement, but never achievement without motivation. A music department that has a
culture to work toward a common goal together is the only way you will ever truly reach out to
students and show them what they can learn past the music.
Christopher B. Williams
Page 8
Christopher B. Williams
Page 9
can provide all kinds exposure to cultural diversity (AG 1.4). All interactions between students in
my classes will in one way or another help develop social skills, decision making, involvement
in risky behaviors, and goal setting (AG 1.3). This is such a unique kind of learning that is not
involved in any other kind of in-school curriculum. Students often dont have opportunities to
learn from one another in other core classes like math and science. Peers that are in groups like
sports teams and musical ensembles not only benefit from these same principles, but also share
bonds through the achievement of a common goal. The closest relationships in humans are those
who have experienced adversity together (Berk, 2008). For example, members of my marching
music ensembles will face long hours of rehearsal, through extreme weather, and physical strain
all in an effort to have the best last performance possible. The bonds between these students are
extremely strong when together having put in hundreds of hours just to perfect an 8 to 12-minute
performance. The culture between these students, especially when put into a competitive setting,
sparks and interest to motivate individual achievement. In other words, every person in the team
is working towards supporting everybody elses individual success, a trait that is often reversed
in the real world.
Developmental Research #5:
Bullying at Elementary School and Problem Behavior in Young Adulthood: A study of
bullying, violence and substance use from age 11 to age 21.
This study took place over 11 years, looking at the correlation between students in grade 5 who
reported being bullied, and those same students at age 21. The study measures the relation to
early childhood bullying and drug/alcohol abuse. The study subsequently found that those
students who were bulled in elementary and middle school a had a statistically significantly
higher chance of being at-risk to fall victim to abuse of illegal drugs, and heavy drinking (Kim,
Christopher B. Williams
Page 10
Catalano, Haggerty, & Abbot, 2011). It was also shown that these same subjects had higher rate
of incarceration for violent crimes than those who didnt report bullying in elementary school. It
was even shown that after accounting for other unrelated risk factors, these results still were
found to be significant (Kim, 2011). At the end of the study, the authors suggest that early
intervention to prevent childhood bullying may reduce chances of these negative outcomes later
in life (Kim, 2011).
Instructional Decision #5:
As a music educator I have a unique opportunity to help prevent bullying. As I said before, my
overall goal as a music teacher is to reach out to students and use what they are learning in my
class to leave the program better people. I believe that music programs can save lives, and give
direction and self-meaning to students who are at risk of becoming something they dont
necessarily want to become. Children who grow up in homes that dont support social
development will look for this support in other places like school (Berk, 2008). Just making
myself available for my students to come to for help and guidance, and by leading by example
while teaching can make the difference between a student who is getting bullied falling into or
staying out of bad habits. I also have the power in my own ensembles to control bullying that is
already happening. For example, I can set aside time in my lessons to bring in guest speakers to
discuss the social consequences of bullying. These guest can include clinicians or police officers,
and even supplemental informational videos. While I might be able to help tame bullying and
hazing within my own classrooms, I will not be able to eradicate it from the world. As an
educator it is my responsibility to provide a safe place for victims of bullying to come when they
need guidance or shelter, and teach them the skills needed to help defend themselves from
Christopher B. Williams
Page 11
getting into risky situations (AG 5.1, 5.4). We will discuss healthy classroom environments in
the next study.
Developmental Research #6:
'A Home away from Home': The World of the High School Music Classroom.
This study interviewed 60 high school music students extensively on why they joined musical
ensembles, what motivates them to stay, and the value that these programs give to the students
that partake in them. When students were asked why they joined, answers included a range of
general interest in music, family history, influence from friends, and even career aspirations in
the music industry (Adderly, Kennedy, & Berz, 2003). When talking about how other classmates
in the school look upon music students, it was said that music students are generally viewed as
intelligent, but felt underappreciated (Adderly et al., 2003). When asked what they got out of
performing in programs, they answered with both academic and non-academic reasons. Students
mentioned how they felt they were better off in school because of their involvement in music,
but that they also got a lot of life skills out of being involved in music (Adderly et al., 2003).
Students also noted that performing in music ensembles offered an emotional outlet for people to
express themselves in ways unique only to music. Finally, when asked about social benefits from
music, students answered that they looked forward to going to music classes, as it was a place
where they could get away from traditional school work and interact with their peers. They said
they made many friendships through their participation in music, and felt it was a welcoming
environment to those who decide to participate (Adderly et al., 2003).
Christopher B. Williams
Page 12
Christopher B. Williams
Page 13
Christopher B. Williams
Page 14
Christopher B. Williams
Page 15
Christopher B. Williams
Page 16
depression and anxiety are common outcomes for students effected (Berk, 2008). However, it
has been shown that exposure to group activity can lower the adverse effects of bullying (Berk,
2008).
Reflections:
To me, expertise means that a person has done all that they could in their power to attain
knowledge of a subject, and can effectively use this specific set of knowledge/skills to engage
and empower others to do the same. In a sense, all experts are educators. Be it an expert
musician, athlete, or teacher, experts are always showing and inspiring others to be a better
version of themselves. It is important that teachers especially get to this level of mastery because
your students will only ever realistically learn a fraction of the things you can give them. For this
reason, if you want your students to achieve goals that you and the state have set for them, you as
a teacher must be better than the state and better than yourself in the past. It is important for
professionals to understand how learning occurs because when you have had a high level of
knowledgeable for a long time, you may find yourself having difficulty relating to the vast
majority of the students you will be reaching out to. If a professional understand how people
develop and learn, they will be able to easier adapt their teaching to a way that will best resonate
with the age group/skill level of the students they are teaching. Instructional strategies that
promote student learning have to be self-motivating. You cannot teach children who are not
interested in reaching a goal from their education. It is important for a professional to understand
physical, social and emotional development because students may not be in a place where they
can learn effectively. Broken homes, depression, low self-esteem, and physical disabilities can
create huge hurdles a professional will need to tackle before they can expect students to reach
their potential (AG 2). This kind of preventative classroom management expertise takes time and
Christopher B. Williams
Page 17
a keen awareness of your students, but can pay dividends in the end when students know you
care about them as people, and can help ease distractions that take place outside of the
classroom. Expanding off of this, it is important a for a professional to understand students'
ranges of individual learning styles, because not every student learns the same (AG 2). Expertise
of concepts is crucial when realistically you will need to teach those same concepts 4 or 5
different ways, making sure the concept resonates with visual learners, active learners, literary
learners, etc.
My biggest weakness right now is being able to put together lesson plans that suit learning styles
other than my own. Once I get to know my students better, I will be able to gauge the type of
learners they are and find ways to reach all of them individually. I have plenty of resources
including other teachers and education professionals that I can consult and brainstorm ideas with.
My bag of tricks will become bigger with more teaching experience, and until I have my own
arsenal of pedagogical resources for all learning types, consulting other music educators will be
my most effective way of continuing this education.
All students need to be engaged during class in order to have effective lessons. To me,
engagement means that a student is invested in the educational progress, and is attentive and
eager to obtain information from the sources they have. It is the teacher's responsibility to find
ways to keep all of their students engaged. To do this, teachers will have to accommodate the
learning styles and needs of all their students. Experienced teachers will also be able to create
connections to concepts students have learned in previous classes, and use their curriculum to
build off of that. Doing this will be more effective in helping students retain knowledge by being
able to relate it to something they already know. New knowledge is forgotten easier without
embedding it through personal experience. Going along with this, getting kids excited to learn in
Christopher B. Williams
Page 18
the first place will take care of most classroom engagement issues (AG 5). Sometimes the best
way to get your students to care about learning, is to show them just how much you care about
teaching them. A lot of times, students just don't care about the content they are being exposed
to, simply because they don't have a personal connection to it. This can also be done by making
connections to things being taught in other subject areas. This is harder to do in some subject
matters than others. Finally, it is important for teachers to start a curriculum with getting to know
each student individually through verbal and written accounts of their previous knowledge and
learning styles. This will set a teacher up to best connect content to different students, and relate
content to previous knowledge.
In my previous teaching experiences, I have always had difficulty seeing my students through
the lesson I was teaching. As a music teacher, I often find myself thinking about how and what
I'm going to say during rehearsals that I can get lost in what my students are actually taking out
of my words and comprehending at a deeper level. I find myself looking over of through my
students instead of giving them direct eye contact. The best way I can further develop myself to
fix this fundamental issue and move on to more important things, is to work things one step at a
time. I can walk into a lesson with one goal, to simply make more eye contact, or pay more
attention to students' body language while I'm giving information. As an educator I can help in
the early stages of a year to create an environment where students feel comfortable expressing
inquiries. NAfME and IMEA programs made specifically for teachers in their first 5 years of
practice will be able to help me with some of these issues I am having, as well as articles posted
quarterly by the Music Educators Journal.
Christopher B. Williams
Page 19
Using context in relation to a student is to be able to see that student and the complete situation
that they live within, and be able to form a relationship with the student that will best set them up
for success in the classroom. The context of a student's situation includes everything from
gender, race, sexuality, family background, peer relation background, SES, and religion, to
mental, emotional, learning, and physical disabilities. For example, if I had a student who comes
from a low SES family that explain to me she can't pay band fees on time, I would have to
approach that situation differently than I would a student who has no money issues but refuses to
pay. Getting to know your students is important for every interaction you have with them inside
and out of class. Knowing which students need more emotional support, and which students have
certain disabilities, is crucial when interacting with them in a classroom setting. Creating a
culture from the beginning that is accepting of people from all different background is going to
play a big role in preventing social issues (AG 1). Students must also understand that there
should be no judgment for people who differ from themselves.
Using individual strengths and learning from errors can help to develop resilience in their being.
For example, if a music student is strong in one area of performance, you can pick repertoire that
shows off that student's strong suit, while they work towards becoming a more well-rounded
musician. Music is almost exclusively about learning from mistakes, so it is important to let
students know from the beginning that every mistake that they make is an opportunity to learn
and turn that mistake into a strength that can be shown off.
Something I can improve on as an educator is learning about every student's life context and not
just the ones that are the most engaged in class. It is often easy to overlook students who never
have conversations with, however, these are the students that are usually at the highest risk for
needing situational support. An example of a way that I can include all student's backgrounds is
Christopher B. Williams
Page 20
to have them submit to me a small autobiography of themselves from a set of questions I assign
to them. This will give me a basis to which I can see what students need what attention from the
start. I can also have students reflect on concepts we learn in class and relate it to their own
personal life, in an effort to see how what we are doing in class is affecting their lives outside of
class.
Christopher B. Williams
Page 21
References
Adderley, C., Kennedy, M., & Berz, W. (2003). 'A Home away from Home': The World of the
High School Music Classroom. Journal of Research In Music Education, 51(3), 190-205.
doi:10.2307/3345373
Berk, L., & Meyers, A. (2008). Infants, children, and adolescents. (6th ed., p. 124, 145, 367, 368,
369, 457, 484, 486, 534, 567, 568, 569), Boston, Massachusetts: Pearson Education Inc.
Kim, M. J., Catalano, R. F., Haggerty, K. P., & Abbott, R. D. (2011). Bullying at elementary
school and problem behaviour in young adulthood: A study of bullying, violence and
substance use from age 11 to age 21. Criminal Behaviour And Mental Health, 21(2), 136144. doi:10.1002/cbm.804
Mahoney, J. L., Schweder, A. E., & Stattin, H. (2002). Structured after-school activities as a
moderator of depressed mood for adolescents with detached relations to their parents.
Journal Of Community Psychology, 30(1), 69-86. doi:10.1002/jcop.1051
Martin, A. J., Mansour, M., Anderson, M., Gibson, R., Liem, G. D., & Sudmalis, D. (2013). The
role of arts participation in students academic and nonacademic outcomes: A
longitudinal study of school, home, and community factors. Journal Of Educational
Psychology, 105(3), 709-727. doi:10.1037/a0032795
Martin, A. J. (2008). Motivation and engagement in music and sport: Testing a multidimensional
framework in diverse performance settings. Journal Of Personality, 76(1), 135-170.
doi:10.1111/j.1467-6494.2007.00482.x
Christopher B. Williams
Page 22
McPherson, G. E., Osborne, M. S., Barrett, M. S., Davidson, J. W., & Faulkner, R. (2015).
Motivation to study music in Australian schools: The impact of music learning, gender,
and socio-economic status. Research Studies In Music Education, 37(2), 141-160.
doi:10.1177/1321103X15600914
Phillips, A. C. (2016). Conceptions of adolescent friendship quality in sport and music domains.
Dissertation Abstracts International, 77.
Christopher B. Williams
Page 23
Christopher B. Williams
Page 24
Knowledge of the important roles of play, social interaction, and hands-on experiences in
young children's learning, and the ability to use these processes to help children construct
knowledge and develop problem-solving and other skills.
2.10
Knowledge of how various individual factors (e.g., prior learning and experiences,
interests, talents) and factors in the home, school, and community influence learning
processes, and the ability to use this knowledge to improve teaching effectiveness and
learning outcomes.
3.16
Knowledge of factors and situations that tend to promote or diminish student engagement
in learning, and the ability to apply skills and strategies for promoting students' active
engagement and self-motivation.
5.1
The ability to create safe, healthy, supportive, and inclusive learning environments,
including indoor and outdoor environments, that encourage all students' engagement,
collaboration, and sense of belonging.
5.2
The ability to apply skills and strategies for establishing a culture of learning that
emphasizes high expectations for all students, promotes self-motivation, and encourages
students' sense of responsibility for their own learning.
Christopher B. Williams
Page 25
5.3
The ability to plan and adapt developmentally appropriate learning environments that
reflect cultural competency; are responsive to the characteristics, strengths, experiences,
and needs of each student; and promote all students' development and learning.
5.4
Knowledge of the characteristics and benefits of virtual learning environments, online
environments, face to-face environments, and hybrid environments, and the ability to
work effectively in different types of environments to ensure student learning and
growth.