Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
In todays competitive world corporates and businesses are struggling to maintain profits and
healthy bottom lines .Cost of production, fuel, raw material and human resources is rising
each year .These developments has prompted people to look for Cost reduction Ideas
&methods. Those who have opted for focused cost reduction strategies have survived those
who could not managed have perished.
In recent economic down turn it becomes more important to make cost reduction program a
major initiative in industry .Companies are finding it difficult to retain people and are laying
off people which is unprecedented in recent history of industrial recession .Companies
have to develop its own cost reduction program for savings without cutting jobs .
This chapter will discuss the complex subject of the impact of tension between cost
minimization and quality maximization in organisations. Beside the recent cost reduction and
quality improvement strategies, hidden elements of people issues, short term verses long
term endeavours and the failures of organisations out of complacency due to leaning on past
glories will be discussed.
Your objectives
In this chapter you will learn about the following:
5-1
Figure 5.1
Figure 5.2
1.3 Total Cost Of Ownership TCO (Figure 5.3)
The purchase price of an asset plus the costs of operation. When choosing among
alternatives in a purchasing decision, buyers should look not just at an item's shortterm price, which is its purchase price, but also at its long-term price, which is its total
cost of ownership. The item with the lower total cost of ownership will be the better
value in the long run. For example, the total cost of ownership of a car is not just the
purchase price, but also the expenses incurred through its use, such as repairs,
insurance and fuel. A used car that appears to be a great bargain might actually have a
5-3
total cost of ownership that is higher than that of a new car, if the used car requires
numerous repairs while the new car has a three-year warranty.
Figure 5.3
1.4
Figure 5.4
5-4
Figure 5.5
2 Techniques Of Cost Reduction
The following are the widely used techniques of cost reduction:
2.1 Just-In-Time (JIT) System
The main aim of JIT is to produce the required items, at the required quality and
quantity, at the precise time they are required. JIT purchasing requires for the items
where too much carrying costs associated with holding high inventory levels.
purchasing system reduces the investment in inventories because of frequent order of
small quantities.
2.2 Target Costing
Target costing refers to the design of product, and the processes used to produce it, so
that ultimately the product can be manufactured at a cost that will enable the firm to
make profit when the product is sold at an estimated market-driven price. This
estimated price is called target price.
2.3.Activity Based Management(ABM)
Activity based management is the use of activity based costing to improve operations
and to eliminate non-value added cost. The main goal of ABM is to identify and
eliminate non-value added activities and costs.
5-5
5-6
Figure 5.6
DEFINITIONS
Cost Savings: A cost reduction that can be specifically identified and will be made to a
budget or program, resulting from implementing a specific alternative in lieu of continuing the
present system.
Cost avoidance: Financial or economic benefits that result from an initiative but do not permit
a monetary reduction to a funded activity or budget.
Cost containment: The process of maintaining organizational costs within a specified budget;
restraining expenditures to meet organizational or project financial targets.
Value enhancement: Value which affects the whole-life costs or whole-life income and its
required functionality.
5-7
ACTIVITY 1
(20 MINS)
In the set scenario, the six operational divisions have a total budget as shown below. The
company is becoming very quality conscious and has asked the Operations Managers of
each of the divisions to submit a one-line financial statement to the Director of operations
showing the percentage of POC (Price of Conformance) and the percentage of PONC (Price
of Non-Conformance) for their divisions last year. These POC and PONC percentages are
shown in the table below.
The Director already knows from the company accountant the overall total budget spent by
each division. This is also shown in the table below.
5-9
Total Budget($M)
POC
PONC
30
10
10
250
10
15
20
10
60
25
15
Customer Services
50
35
50
Corporate Services
10
10
$420M
100%
100%
30
250
20
60
Customer Services
50
Corporate Services
10
$420M
COP ($M)
POC ($M)
5-10
PONC ($M)
5-11
A management structure that takes over during a crisis is shadow management. During
a crisis, decisions must be made rapidly. There is little time for extensive discussion or
to form a committee/task force to study the problem. Certain actions need to be
implemented immediately. There should be an organizational mechanism in place that
can take such action during a crisis. When the crisis is over, this management returns
to the shadows. The organization should be able to operate in two modes, one for
normal operations and one for crisis situations. Shadow management becomes
operative in the latter. CQI does not lend itself well to crisis management. CQI can help
prevent the crisis through careful planning, but it is not a quick response system.
Shadow management may be necessary for a crisis.
6.12 Ad-Hocracy
An organization run by project teams or task forces. Teams and task forces are formed
to achieve the current goals of the company. They are given the authority to achieve
those goals. When the task is completed, they are disbanded or reduced to
maintenance. The team or task force working on a more current project replaces them.
This provides a more democratic distribution of power due to the changing nature of the
task forces.
6.13 Analysis Paralysis
CQI can provide a tremendous amount of data on an organization. This can be
overwhelming and lead to no action. So much time can be spent discussing and
diagramming problems nothing gets done. This is analysis paralysis.
6.14 Intelligent Error
Errors that only hindsight could have prevented. A correct thought process and decision
was made prior to the action producing the error. The organization accepts the fact that
risks must be taken for innovation to occur. This attitude will result in intelligent errors.
In contrast, an organization that penalizes such errors will have few innovations.
7 Other Alternative House of Quality
Every successful company has always used data and information to help in its planning processes. In
planning a new product, engineers have always examined the manufacturing and performance history
of the current product. They look at field test data, comparing their product to that of their
competitors product. They examine any customer satisfaction information that might happen to be
available. Unfortunately, much of this information is often incomplete. It is frequently examined as
individual data, without comparison to other data that may support or contradict it. By contrast,
Quality Function Deployment (QFD) uses a matrix format to capture a number of issues that are vital
to the planning process. The House of Quality Matrix is the most recognized and widely used form of
this method. It translates customer requirements, based on marketing research and benchmarking
data, into an appropriate number of engineering targets to be met by a new product design. Basically,
it is the nerve center and the engine that drives the entire QFD process. According to Hauser and
Clausing, it is a kind of conceptual map that provides the means for inter functional planning and
communication.
There are many different forms of the House of Quality, but its ability to be adapted to the
requirements of a particular problem make it a very strong and reliable system to use. Its general
format is made up of six major components. These include customer requirements, technical
requirements, a planning matrix, an interrelationship matrix, a technical correlation matrix, and a
technical priorities/benchmarks and targets section.
5-13
ACTIVITY 2
(10 MINS)
Explain how improving quality can lead to reduced costs.
Cost analysis in terms of overall value chain of which the firm is a part
Strongly external focus
The design of cost management systems changes dramatically depending on the
basic strategic positioning of the firm
o Cost leadership or
o Product differentiation
Cost is a function of strategic choice about the structure of how to compete and
managerial skill in executing the strategic choices
o Structural cost drivers and
o Executional cost drivers
Figure 5.8
5-15
ACTIVITY 3
(20 MINS)
Draw a fish-bone chart detailing reasons why an airline customer might be dissatisfied.
ACTIVITY 4
(20 MINS)
In the perspective of the tension of cost reduction and improved quality, what roles do
operations managers play in addressing the major aspects of service quality?
QUICK QUIZZ
1. The Balanced Scorecard is a useful tool for helping managers translate their strategy
into action in the following areas:
A.
Sustainability; Flexibility; Efficiency; Technology
B.
Customers; Financial; Internal Business Processes; Learning and Growth
C.
The Environment; The Community; Suppliers; Other Stakeholders
D.
Strategy; Tactics; Productivity; Profitability
Reliability
Responsiveness
Competence
Access
Courtesy
Communication
Credibility
Security
Understanding/knowing the customer
Tangibles
5. If one adopts a definition of quality based upon satisfying stated or implied needs, it
is difficult to imagine any product that would not be required to be of high quality.
ANSWERS TO ACTIVITIES
1
a) TCOP is total cost of product. TCOP = COP (Cost of Product) + COQ (Cost of
Quality); COQ includes (POC & PONC)
b) TCOP = COP + COQ; COQ = (POC + PONC)
c) As table below:
TCOP
($M)
Sales and Marketing
Manufacturing and
Assembly
Logistics and Distribution
Research and
Development
Customer Services
Corporate Services
POC ($M)
PONC
($M)
COQ
($M)
COP($M)
30
3.0
6.0
24.0
250
20
25.0
2.0
37.5
1
62.5
3.0
187.5
17.0
60
50
10
$420.0
15.0
17.5
1.0
$63.5
9
25
0.5
$76.0
24.0
42.5
1.5
$139.5
36.0
7.5
8.5
$280.5
Higher quality leads to greater demand, to greater market share, to greater economies of
scale. Additionally, higher quality leads to less scrap, rework, and warranty cost, hence to
less input required for same output.
3
5-17
The design and delivery of service can make a difference on the tangible
components of service, containing the determinants of service quality in the
process design, managing expectations, and having alternate plans for exceptions
and taking a long term approach.
CHAPTER ROUND UP
Total Cost Of Ownership is the purchase price of an asset plus the costs of operation.
Quality, is a term that means different things to different people. We define quality as
"the totality of features and characteristics of a product or service that bears on its
ability to satisfy stated or implied needs." Defining quality expectations is critical to
effective and efficient operations.
The House of Quality functions as a living document and a source of ready reference
for related products and future upgrades. While it is a great communication tool at
each step in the process, the matrices are the means and not the end. Its purpose is
to serve as a vehicle for dialogue to strengthen vertical and horizontal
communications.
SCM gives a clear understanding of the firms cost structure in search of sustainable
competitive advantage and be effective use to circumvent the tension of cost and
quality endeavours.
5-18
REFERENCES
1. Operations Management by Schroeder, Contemporary Concepts and Cases
Publisher : McGraw Hill
2. Operations Management by Russell,& Benard W. Taylor, Crating Value Along the
Supply Chain 7th edition , John Wiley and Sons
3. Operations Management by Chase. Richard B. & Nicholas J. Aquilano., Operations
Management for competitive advantage, 11th edition, McGraw Hill
4. Total cost of ownership :
http://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/totalcostofownership.asp#ixzz3ehM1E8NC
Follow us: @Investopedia on Twitter
5. Tools and Techniques of cost reduction:
http://accountlearning.blogspot.in/2011/02/tools-and-techniques-of-costreduction.html
6. Continuous Quality Improvement - Methods And Tools:
http://www.rcecs.com/MyCE/PDFDocs/course/V7029.pdf
7. Quality Elements for Product:
https://www.google.com.sg/search?
q=Quality+Elements+for+Product&rlz=1C1CYCW_enSG632SG632&oq=Quality+Ele
ments+for+Product&aqs=chrome..69i57.4697j0j4&sourceid=chrome&es_sm=0&ie=U
TF-8
5-19