Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
O. Bouilliez
J.C. Perez Quesada
Foreword
The author disclaims all responsibility subsequent to incorrect use of
information or diagrams reproduced in this document, and cannot be held
responsible for any errors or oversights, or for the consequences of using
information and diagrams contained in this document.
Reproduction of all or part of a "Cahier Technique" is authorised with the
prior consent of the Scientific and Technical Division. The statement
"Extracted from Schneider Electric "Cahier Technique" no. ....." (please
specify) is compulsory.
no. 128
Design and use of MV
current-limiting fuses
Olivier BOUILLIEZ
Having graduated from the Ecole Centrale de Lyon in 1976 with a
degree in engineering, Olivier joined Merlin Gerin in 1977.
He has held several management positions in the engineering
department of the Switchgear Division, most notably as a research
engineer before moving on to become Group Manager and finally
head of New Product Development. His career has taken him from
participating in to managing the development of Fusarc, Merlin
Gerin's range of medium voltage fuses.
He is currently working as Marketing Director in Schneider Electrics
Building and Infrastructures Division (France). Prior to this
appointment, he was in charge of vacuum switching technology, then
Strategic Business Director for Medium Voltage and head of the
Equipment Division.
Lexicon
I1
I2
I3
IN
Ip
Irms
Uline
UN
Up
Table of contents
1 Basic characteristics
3 Application
4 Appendices
1.1 Reminder
1.2 UN rated voltage
p. 4
p. 4
p. 5
p. 5
p. 5
p. 6
p. 6
p. 7
p. 8
p. 8
p. 9
p. 10
p. 11
p. 11
p. 13
2.6 Striker
p. 13
3.1 General
p. 14
p. 14
p. 16
p. 18
3.5 Summary
p. 21
p. 23
p. 24
p. 26
1 Basic characteristics
1.1 Reminder
Standard IEC 60282-1 defines three currentlimiting fuse categories based on the type of
application in which the fuse is to be used:
Associated fuse
For applications in which the improbability of low
fault current values can be proven, either by
means of calculation or on the basis of past
experience. However, it must be ensured that
the minimum rated breaking current of the fuse
link is less than the minimum short-circuit current
that may appear upstream of the low-voltage
safety device.
General purpose fuse
If experience or calculation indicates that there
may be very low overcurrents on the line (i.e.
Most fuses are designed for use on a threephase system. In this case, the recovery voltage
applied to them following a short-circuit is equal
to:
Uline
x 1.5
3
The coefficient 1.5 is due to the phase-shifting of
the current zero points. In a three-phase system,
this causes the neutral point to slip when the first
fuse blows.
In single-phase operation (see fig. 2 ), a fuse
with a rated voltage of UN is therefore tested at:
UN x
1.5
= 0.87 UN
3
UN
2
/3
UN u
Uline
0.87
1.5UN/e
/e
UN
UN/e
UN/e
Up
I
Ip
Fig. 3: diagrams showing disconnection at I1.
t (s)
100
10
0,1
0.01
102
103
104 I (A)
tv =
t1 2
i (t) dt
t0
= tv Irms prospective2
S =
I dt
I rms prospective
This duration is close to the duration of the prearc that would be obtained with a direct current
with a value of lrms (see fig. 5 ).
Caution should be exercised when applying
these charts for an alternating current. In a zone
between 0 and 0.1 s, for a given current, the prearc durations may vary by a ratio of 1 to 3
depending on the frequency, the power factor of
the circuit and the instant at which the shortcircuit occurred.
By way of example, figure 6 illustrates the
actual (a) and virtual (b) pre-arc durations of a
Fusarc-CF 25 A on a circuit with power factor =
0.1 for various angles of the initiation of a shortcircuit of 500 A.
i2 (t)
Ip
i (t)
t0
Irms prospective2
Prospective
current
wave
t1
a
5
b
= make angle
(rd)
I
60
Prospective wave
(Irms = A)
B
Limited wave
Cut-off current
(peak value)
t
40
30 B
20
15
10
8
6
4
3
2
250 A
200 A
160 A
125 A
100 A
A
4 6 10 20 40 60 Isc
Fig. 7: value Ip of the limited cut-off current as a function of the prospective current.
1. contacts
2. case
3. core
4. fuse elements
5. extinguishing agent
6. striker
6
3
4
5
4
Contact
The end caps also ensure that the current - be it
the rated current in continuous operation or the
fault current - can flow between the fuse link and
its fuse base.
Traditionally, in the manufacture of electrical
products, the surface coatings applied to currentcarrying components such as caps have been
selected with a view to minimizing contact
resistances, which are the primary source of
overheating.
This explains the widespread use of tin and
silver. Nickel is also used although it has been
abandoned by many manufacturers due to its
contact resistance.
The fuse assembly is a specific exception in this
field. In effect, overheating is generated not by
the contact but by the fuse element itself.
k=
2r
R + 2r
k(%)
3
UN = 12 kV
r
17.5 kV
24 kV
1
36 kV
IN (A)
Fig. 9: contact resistances.
Mechanical stress
A fuse link must offer mechanical resistance to:
c sudden internal pressure caused by gases
released in the event of a break at I2,
c slow pressure rise caused when the sand
expands in the event of a break at I3,
Thermal stress
In addition to the stress in continuous operation
at IN, the case must be able to withstand very
rapid temperature rises in the event of a break at
I2 and very slow temperature rises in the event
of a blow at I3.
Dielectric stress
Once the fuse has blown, the case must be able
to withstand the recovery voltage. This stress,
which is less severe due to the dimensions of the
fuses and the lapse of time (a maximum of
several hours in all but the most extreme cases)
during which the voltage is applied, can be
tolerated easily by all materials used.
2.3 Core
Serving as a spindle around which the fuse
element is coiled, the core simply supports the
fuse. Some types of fuse do not have a core.
Made of ceramic or similar material, the nature of
the core must be as similar as possible to the
extinguishing agent. It is usually cylindrical in
shape and ribbed (see fig. 10 ).
Often installed at its center, the striker, with its
control wire, is also isolated from the fuse
elements.
t (s)
t (s)
P = 10
100
100
P = 20
10
10
P=5
1
e = 0.9
e = 0.7
0.1
0.01
102
103
Effect of p (e = 0.7)
0,1
10 I (A)
e = 0.5
0.01
2
10
103
Effect of e (p = 10)
104 I (A)
c
Fig. 13: different types of notching.
a. regular
b. progressive
c. mixed.
2.6 Striker
This is a mechanical component that indicates
that the fuse assembly has blown and is able to
supply a certain amount of energy stored in a
spring in order to activate a breaking device.
Fuses with strikers are therefore designed for
fuse combination units.
Fig. 14: example of a thermal trip unit incorporated into the striker system of all Merlin Gerin brand fuses.
A. striker released
B. striker in normal untripped position
C. spring
D. thermal trip for striker
E. electrical trip for striker
F. main fuse element.
3 Application
3.1 General
I rms
= 0.125 I C
a
t
(1 e
2t
where:
IC = maximum peak current
a = time constant for current damping in
seconds (time at the end of which the current will
have fallen to 37 % of its initial value).
t = time (in seconds) at the end of which it is
estimated that the current will have reached its
normal operating value
Usually, t = 3 a.
The table in figure 16 contains standard values
for IC/IN and a depending on the power rating of
the transformers for devices meeting the
requirements of standards UTE C 52-100,
C 52-112 and C 52-113.
IC / IN
10
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.1
t (s)
P
(kVA)
IC / IN
50
15
0.1
100
14
0.15
160
12
0.20
400
12
0.25
630
11
0.30
800
10
0.30
1 000
10
0.35
1 250
0.35
1 600
0.40
2 000
0.45
(s)
Rating
(A)
IN max.
= Imin(0.1) / 12
IN max.
= IN fuse / 1.4
I3
0.1 s
IN min
= I3 x 5%
Transformer IN
must be between
IA
and
IB
14.3
1.1
2.8
20
1.1
6.3
29.9
2.4
4.5
36
1.8
1.8
2.4
10
59.2
4.9
7.1
34
1.7
1.7
4.9
16
84.7
11.4
46
2.3
2.3
20
103.8
8.6
14.2
55
2.7
2.7
8.6
25
155.5
12.9
17.8
79
3.9
3.9
12.9
31.5
207.5
17.2
22.5
101
17.2
40
278.5
23.2
28.5
135
6.7
6.7
23.2
50
401.7
33.4
35.7
180
33.4
50 (36 kV)
385
32
35.7
200
10
10
32
63
499.8
41.6
45
215
10.7
10.7
41.6
63 (36 kV)
489.6
40.8
45
250
12.5
12.5
40.8
56.6
80 (7.2-12 kV)
680
56.6
57.1
280
14
14
80 (17.5-24 kV)
694.6
57.8
57.1
330
16.5
16.5
57.1
862
71.8
71.4
380
19
19
71.4
862
71.8
71.4
450
22.5
22.5
71.4
125
1 666.1
138.8
89.2
650
32.5
32.5
89.2
160
2 453.4
204.4
114.2
1 000
50
50
114.8
200
3 256.3
271.3
142.8
1 400
70
70
142.8
4 942.4
411.8
178.5
2 000
100
100
178.5
4 942.4
411.8
178.5
2 200
110
110
178.5
Fig. 17: table summarizing the possibilities of the Fusarc-CF (Merlin Gerin) range, with a short-circuit voltage of 5 %.
t (s)
100
10
5
1
0.1
0.01
10
40
100 200
103 I (A)
c Overload
A motor is always protected by an interlock
circuit, which, in the event of an excessive
overload, will send an opening instruction to the
relevant breaking device. This means that the
fuse is never required to disconnect low currents
and the value of its current (I3) is of little importance.
Line-induced stress
c Rated voltage
The maximum rated voltage of MV motors does
not usually exceed 11 kV. Therefore, only fuses
with ratings of UN i 12 kV are affected.
Is (A)
100
10
100
1000
10000
100
2 x 250 A
2 x 200 A
Ts (s)
10
Ts (s)
250 A
200 A
III
10
50 A
160 A
63 A
125 A
P (kW)
1650 kW
1000
100
C
1000
10
11 kV
x 12
x 10
In (A)
10 kV
6.6 kV
6 kV
5.5 kV
II
x8
In (A)
10
80 A
100 A
10000
x6
100
100
x4
B
167 A
A
4.16 kV
3.3 kV
3 kV
1000
100
1000
P (kW)
10000
10
100
1000
1000
10000
Is (A)
Fig. 19: chart illustrating the time/current characteristics of fuses in the Fusarc-CF (source Merlin-Gerin) range.
IN =
P (kW)
UN (kV ) x
3 x
x cos
IT =
L
R2
1
LC
4L2
R
t
2L
R2
1
x sin
LC
4L2
R2
4L2
Rt
IT = V
C
t
x e 2L x sin
L
L
3
As with transformers, the fuse selection can be
validated by checking the relationships between
the peak current and the rated current IT / IN as
well as the rise time constant.
Therefore, if:
UN =
U x C ,
3
I T / IN = U x
2C
3
1
x
=
3L
UC
2
LC
2L
R
Experience has shown that it is absolutely vital
that the fuse does not blow for a current IT
during time tT.
and
T =
L
R1
R2
D
C
R
I
L1
L2
L3
Ln
R1
R2
R3
Rn
C1
C2
C3
Cn
I = U
C
2
x E x e 2LE x sin
LE
3
t
CE x LE
where
CE
Cn Cs
Cn + Cs
n 1
Ci
where Cs =
LE = Ln + Ls where Ls =
i=1
1
n 1
i=1
RE = R + Rs where Rs =
1
Li
1
n 1
i=1
1
Ri
IN fuse
I2 t fusing
125 A
160 A
200 A
64 x 103 A2 s
76 x 103 A2 s
140 x 103 A2 s
2
C
x E
3
LE
L
LE
CE
v record the point (IT, T) on the time/current
characteristics,
v if necessary, select a different rating, calculate
a new RE value and start the verification process
again.
v calculate
T = 2 x
L1
L2
L3
C1
C2
C3
IT = 2 900 A
Assuming a fuse with a rating of 200 A,
(R1 = 2.5 x 10-3 ) where R2 = 14.5 x 10-3
(see above) T = 54 x 10-3 s
3.5 Summary
Type of load
Transformer
Motor
Order of magnitude
of fuse rating
Selection rules
4 to 100 A
100 to 250 A
IA < IN transf.< IB
Ip
No specification
Fixed by Ip and tD
IN motor x 1.2
Low
I fusing 0.1 s
High
No specification
High ( 0.1 s)
I fusing 10 s
High
I3
UN
Capacitors
Single bank
100 to 250 A
1 ms
No specification
No specification
0 to 36 kV
0 to 12 kV
0 to 36 kV
t (s)
t (s)
t (s)
a
100
b
100
100
IN
I3 low
100 to 250 A
high-speed fusing
10
10
I 10 s
10
high
IN 0 to 100 A
1
0.1
I 0.1 s
0,1
0.1
103
104 I (A)
0.01
102
IP low
103
high-speed fusing
= 1 ms/0.1 s
high
0.01
102
I3 low
104 I (A)
0.01
102
103
high
peak
104 I (A)
c For transformers
It is likely that developments in standards
designed to standardize time/current
characteristics will in the future enable users to
forego selection rules for transformers and
consider only the rated current of the transformer
when making their selections.
Until then, a step in the right direction would be
for every manufacturer to provide the operating
limits IA and IB for the fuse links they produce.
c For motors
Unfortunately, this is an entirely different case,
as the rating of the load is not the only
characteristic required in order to select an
appropriate fuse link.
Although standards set out criteria to be
observed and require precise indications from
manufacturers (K factor, time/current
characteristic), users still have to select fuses
themselves on the basis of the motor to be
protected, with the assistance of aids (charts,
tables) provided by fuse manufacturers.
c For capacitors
It has been shown that it is even more difficult to
select fuses for capacitors as the system
4 Appendices
3.6 kV
4A
7.2 kV
12 kV
17.5 kV
24 kV
36 kV
762
1 143
1 436
1 436
2 109
6.3 A
205
319
402
485
750
10 A
102
158
203
248
380
16 A
68.5
106
132
158
252
20 A
53.5
82
103
123
197
25 A
36.4
56
71
85
133
31.5 A
26
40
51
61
103
40 A
18
28
35
42
70
50 A
11.7
17.4
22
31.5
47
63 A
8.4
13.8
19.4
23.6
35
80 A
6.4
10
13.5
18
100 A
5.5
11
13.5
125 A
3.4
5.3
160 A
2.2
3.5
200 A
1.8
2.7
250 A
0.6
0.9
4.2 Appendix 2: Time/current characteristics in the FusarcCF range of fuses (Merlin Gerin)
t (s)
10 000
8
6
5
4
3
250 A
160 A
200 A
125 A
40 A
50 A
6363A A
80 A
100 A
10 A
16 A
20 A
25 A
31.5 A
6.3 A
1 000
8
6
5
4
3
4A
100
8
6
5
4
3
2
10
8
6
5
4
3
2
1
8
6
5
4
3
2
0.1
8
6
5
4
3
0.01
10
3 4 5 6 8 102
3 4 5 6 8 103
3 4 5 6 8 104 I (A)
t (s)
10000
8
6
5
4
3
2
50 A
63 A
80 A
1000
8
6
5
4
3
2
100
8
6
5
4
3
2
10
8
6
5
4
3
2
1
8
6
5
4
3
2
0.1
8
6
5
4
3
2
0.01
10
3 4 5 6 8 102
3 4 5 6 8 103
3 4 5 6 8 104 I (A)
IN / 2
IN / 2
K x IN / 2
K x IN / 2
IN
Fig. 26: balancing using current transformers.
c Example
Take 2 links rated at 200 A, with a short-circuit
current Isc of 50 kA
Ipo = I breaking if Isc = 25 kA or 22 kA peak
(point A).
Ia = 1.8 Ik r
Ipeak (kA)
Is = Ik r
100
9
8
7
6
2x250A
5
44
B 2x200A
250A
4
3
22
200A
160A
125A
A
2
100A
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
2
6 7 8 9
5 6 7 8 9
5 6 Isc kA rms
10
Fig. 27: current limitation curves according to rating (Fusarc-CF, Merlin Gerin brand).
Schneider Electric