Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
A) brief summary
o Nancy, whilst holding a box of poison in a bus, is confronted by other passengers. She
explains to them that the poison does not affect 95% of people and is non-lethal. She also
explains that it is imperative that she travels to where she needs to be and that the bus is
the only form of transportation should could take.
Barometer.
o
Comparing thoughts to the Morality barometer, I, firstly, think that Nancy should be
allowed to get on the bus, and also, that people dont have the right to insist that other
people never do anything that might cause us (mild) harm. My thoughts are similar to the
A) brief summary
o In this hypothetical situation, a Time Traveler argues with his wife about whether his wife
thinks that it is morally acceptable to be sorry for the holocaust or rather be sorry her own
existence.
accepting of their own existence. (Its not directly thier fault, for example)
There, generally, was no choice in the matter of existing, or of historic events taking
place. It really boils down to whos life do you value more, the millions of jews who
died, or the millions of people who exist now. People who dont exist as a result of
something happening or not happening will exist in a different form; you cannot reclaim
does not matter. I exist or I do not. If I dont exist there is nothing to worry about.
C) Explain how your intuitive response compares to moral theories via Morality
Barameter
o
I do not regret my existence; I also am sorry that tragedies in this world occur. This
mental reasoning is more in line with example B, Im sorry that you suffered. However,
if the tragedy did not occur and I dont exist, I wouldnt know that I didnt exist.
D) make and defend a claim about the consistency of your moral reasoning
A) brief summary
o In Stangrooms hypothetical situation, he imagines a situation in which a radical
organization, of which has commited many atrocities, is confronted and trapped by their
opponents, namely law enforcement. The organization members, cannot escape and will
face death if they dont defend themselves, however if they do defend themselves, they
o
matter. If you take away the ability for someone else, then that is wrong and evil.
If the organization members fight
C) Explain how your intuitive response compares to moral theories via Morality
Barameter
D) make and defend a claim about the consistency of your moral reasoning