Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
informative preparations
pre-operative education
cognitive behavioral approaches
empowerment and self-efficacy
individual and social self regulation
biopsychosocial
As shall be seen, there is a great deal of overlap amongst these models. The list
presented here progresses from the least to the most comprehensive
interventions. Therefore, the approaches presented at the beginning of the list
are generally contained within those near the bottom.
Informative Preparations
The idea that providing patients with realistic information about their surgery
(compared to those less informed) will improve outcome can be traced to Janis
(1958; 1971). Subsequent studies have generally demonstrated a positive
correlation between preoperative surgical knowledge and postoperative outcome
(see Prokop et al, 1991; Shuldham, 1999 for reviews). Studies have identified
two different types of information that might be provided procedural and
sensory. Procedural information consists of basic information about the surgery
experience including preoperative activities, events that would occur during the
hospital stay, and postoperative recommendations. Sensory information has
often been added to the procedural information in an attempt to enhance the
outcome. Sensory information describes what sensations the patient can expect
throughout the surgery experience, including what he will feel, hear, taste and
see.
Individualized information
Although the provision of procedural and/or sensory information has usually been
found to enhance surgical outcome, this is not a consistent finding. Researchers
have speculated that the reason for these inconsistencies may to due to the
patients individual coping styles in response to a stressor such as impending
surgery. Studies have focused on a coping dimension of information-seekers
(also called sensitizers, copers, or monitors) versus information-avoiders (also
called repressors, avoiders, or blunters). Information-seekers typically respond to
a stressful situation by gathering detailed information about it, while informationavoiders will do just the opposite (see Miller, 1987; 1992; Miro & Raich, 1999;
Prokop et al, 1991, for reviews).
A number of studies have investigated how a patients coping style (informationseeking vs. information-avoiding) affects preparation for surgery (see Miro &
Raich, 1999 for a review). It has generally been found that patients do best when
the amount and detail of pre-surgical information provided matches their
individual coping styles. There is some indication that providing information in a
manner that is inconsistent with the patients coping style (e.g. providing detailed
information to an information-avoider) can actually have deleterious effects (see
Prokop et al. 1991 for a review).
Preoperative Education
Preoperative education is an expansion of the simple information provision
approach to surgery preparation. Preoperative education or teaching is defined
by Devine and Cook (1986) as providing the patient with health related
information, psychosocial support, and the opportunity to learn specific skills in
preparation for surgery. Preoperative education programs might include a
number of components: provision of information, interactive education done
either individually or in groups, inclusion of family members, and teaching of
specific skills helpful for recovery. Several meta-analytic reviews have
demonstrated the beneficial effects of preoperative education on surgery
outcome (Hathaway, 1986; Devine & Cook, 1986; Devine, 1992; Shuldham,
1999).
Cognitive-Behavioral Approaches
Depending on the definition used, preoperative education approaches may or
may not include cognitive-behavioral (CB) techniques. For the purposes of this
discussion, CB approaches will be treated separately and formulated as an
expansion of the preoperative education techniques. CB preparation for surgery
programs are primarily designed to teach patients self-control strategies that will
decrease the stress, anxiety, and pain associated with the surgery experience
(see Contrada et al., 1994; Prokop et al., 1991 for a review). CB approaches use
a variety of techniques such as cognitive restructuring and deep relaxation
training. The cognitive interventions are based upon the premise that a patients
thoughts about the surgery will determine the amount of emotional and physical
self-efficacy (and the related idea of empowerment) has been applied to the area
of surgical preparation in an effort to explain positive outcomes. These concepts
have also guided the expansion of the preoperative education and CB
approaches.
Self-efficacy
Self-efficacy has been researched in the psychological literature for quite some
time since originally formulated by Bandura (1977). According to this theory,
expectations of personal efficacy determine whether coping behavior will be
initiated, how much effort will be expended, and how long it will be sustained in
the face of obstacles and aversive experiences (Bandura, 1977, p. 191). Selfefficacy is a belief that one can effectively perform a given behavior and that the
behavior will result in desired outcomes. Importantly, motivation and
perseverance in performing specific behaviors is dependent on the individuals
evaluation her self-efficacy. If the individual does not believe that the behavior
can be performed, motivation and perseverance decrease. Thus, self-efficacy
mediates the relationship between knowledge and action. In the simplest terms,
there are three basic tenants of self-efficacy theory: 1) self-efficacy is situation
specific; 2) self-efficacy can be altered through various means such as
education, practice, and role modeling; and 3) increased self-efficacy can
improve outcomes relative to specific behaviors.
Bandura (1977) postulates that an individuals self-efficacy for a situation comes
from four sources of information. Performance accomplishments are behaviors
that the individual has actually performed or practiced. This source of information
is the most influential for self-efficacy since it is based on personal mastery
experiences. Verbal persuasion occurs when an individual is guided by
suggestion into believing that he can perform the activity. Verbal persuasion is
usually provided by someone who is perceived as an authority or expert in the
area. Vicarious experience, or modeling, is obtained by seeing others similar to
oneself perform the activity. Physiological states are information the individual
receives from his level of arousal in response to the specific situation. For
instance, if you experience a high level of physical arousal (e.g. anxiety) when
thinking about a stressful situation you are facing (e.g. the surgery process), then
you may be more likely to conclude that your ability to cope with it is low
(diminished self-efficacy).
There is a substantial body of research demonstrating that enhancing selfefficacy (e.g. through educational programs) is related to improved health
outcomes (See Bandura, 1991; Oetker-Black & Taunton, 1994; Pellino et al.,
1998 for reviews). Perceived self-efficacy has specifically been found to improve
coping with pain (Pellino & Ward, 1998) and compliance with recommendations
after surgery (Bastone & Kerns, 1995; Mahler & Kulik, 1998). It has been
hypothesized that many of the benefits of psychological preparation for surgery
programs are actually due to the enhanced self-efficacy (Mahler & Kulik, 1998;
Oetker-Black & Taunton, 1994; Pellino et al., 1998).
Empowerment
Although patient education programs for surgery have been investigated and
implemented for many years, there has been a recent shift from the traditional
medical model of patient education to more of an empowerment model (Pellino
et al., 1998). Early preparation for surgery programs were based upon a
traditional medical model, or disease-based model in which the healthcare
provider is the expert who decides the content, amount and detail of the
information that is provided to the patient relative to her surgery. In this model,
the provider is the primary decision-maker and problem solver (see Pellino et.
Al., 1998 for a review).
The empowerment model of patient education is based on the idea that health
educators can assist patients in gaining knowledge, developing skills, and
identifying resources relative to the surgery experience. Empowerment has been
described as a process of enabling others to take control of their own lives
(Pellino et al., 1998). In this process, patients are also taught to actively reassess
various issues in an ongoing manner and modify their coping strategy
accordingly. Thus, the patient will be taught to take appropriate charge of her
own care on a daily basis (Anderson, 1995). In the empowerment approach, the
teaching is interactive and the patient helps to determine the content of the
surgery preparation program.
The concept of empowerment is closely related to the construct of self-efficacy;
the differences are subtle. Self-efficacy is a belief that one can effectively perform
a behavior and the behavior will result in the designated outcome. However,
someone other than the patient might determine the designated outcome or
goal. In contrast, empowerment encourages the patient to become an active
participant in identifying and choosing healthcare related goals. Once these goals
are established, the probability that they will be achieved is increased through
enhancing self-efficacy. As portrayed by Pellino et al (1998), empowerment
directly influences self-efficacy, which in turn, affects outcome.
The concepts of self-efficacy and empowerment are especially important given
the increase in outpatient surgery that makes patients much more responsible for
implementing their own preoperative and postoperative care.
Individual and Social Self-regulation
As discussed by Contrada et al. (1994), two interrelated sets of theoretical
principles derived from research in the areas of psychological stress (Lazarus,
1966; Lazarus & Folkman, 1984), illness cognition (Leventhal & Johnson, 1983)
and social support (Cohen, 1988) can provide a conceptual framework for
understanding how psychological interventions enhance surgical outcome. These
are the principles of individual self-regulation and social self-regulation.
Individual Self-regulation
The amount of threat experienced by a patient is related not only to his or her
appraisal of the danger implications of the surgery, but also how much the threat
Although it is possible that this upward comparison could result in the patient
emulating successful coping strategies, it seems that negative consequences are
more likely. Family members and patients may tend to select unrealistically
successful models for social comparison purposes such as those who are
younger, have had a less serious surgery, or have a less significant medical
history (Taylor 1983). This type of upward comparison has the potential for the
patient and family members to set unrealistic criteria for evaluating coping efforts
and overall progress. Clinically, this is certainly seen in the area of postoperative
spine rehabilitation. It is not uncommon for patients to begin making comparisons
once they are released to begin postoperative physical therapy. In the spine
rehabilitation setting, there are ample opportunities for this type of upward
comparison and the negative effects are not infrequent.
The surgical experience can be divided into different phases, each of which has
its own unique challenges and coping issues that will influence individual selfregulation. According to Contrada et al. (1994), the four general phases of the
surgery experience include (I) the decision to have the surgery; (II) the
preoperative testing, admission to the hospital and surgery; (III) the acute
recovery either in the hospital or immediately postoperative at home; and (IV) the
longer term postoperative rehabilitation issues. Across these four phases, there
are four major issues related to adaptation to the surgical experience (Contrada
et. Al., 1994, p.230):
1. The immediate physical danger represented by the surgery itself that
includes such things as the threat of general anesthesia, the incision,
resection, reconstruction, catheterization, and immediate postoperative
complications.
2. The aftereffects of undergoing these procedures, including such things as
pain, discomfort, disorientation, fatigue, and a reduced capacity for
physical activity and ambulation. These are essentially the subjective and
functional effects of the surgery itself on the patient. These threats begin
just after surgery (the middle of phase II) and decrease through phases III
and IV.
3. The patients potential inability to enact valued social roles including such
things as engaging in family, occupational, and leisure activities. The
threat to social roles begins in phase III and increases through phase IV.
4. The long-term management of a possibly chronic medical condition. Longterm management issues might include such things as the need to diet,
exercise, take medications, and undergo follow-up visits. This threat
occurs in phase IV.
These issues will vary in relative salience through the surgery experience. The
physical danger and subjective/functional effects dominate during the period
immediately surrounding the surgery while social role issues and long-term
management issues become increasingly salient after the acute phase of
postoperative recovery and over the long term. Each of these issues, within each
the patients health status, health habits, medical condition, and type of
surgery
the patients psychological status and coping resources
the healthcare professionals involved in the patients treatment and all of
the other subsystems,
family members behavior towards the patient and amongst themselves in
response to the surgery,
the patient and familys interaction with extra-familial systems such as
relatives, friends, and coworkers
The open system model describes how changes in any of the subsystems (e.g.
the relationship between the patient and partner) may reverberate within all
systems (e.g. the patients own health status, the emotional status and behavior
of family members, etc.).
Figure 2-1. The biopsychosocial conceptual model of the surgery
experience. Adapted from Chapman et al. (1999, p. 43).
These are very general categories of patient assessment. The preparation for
surgery intervention actually represents a process of ongoing assessment and
adjustment of intervention strategies, as dictated by the biopsychosocial model.
Other important areas of assessment will be discussed under the various
treatment components.
In a recent study, the effects of patients external health locus of control (EHLC)
and self-efficacy (SE) on surgery preparation for surgery outcomes were studied
in a group of patients facing coronary artery bypass graft surgery (CABG)
(Shelley & Pakenham, 2007). As discussed by Shelley and Pakenham (2007),
and reviewed in this course, two general strategies have been used to improve
surgical outcomes information instruction and cognitive coping. The authors
were interested in how a patients coping style might affect the successfulness of
surgery preparation. EHLC refers to the belief that outcomes in ambiguous
health-related situations, such as CABG, are the result of powerful others,
including doctors, other care providers, family and friends (Shelley & Pakenham,
p. 184). EHLC has been found to be a predictor of outcomes to CABG; lower
levels of EHLC were associated with improved health outcomes. SE refers to the
patients confidence in her ability to behave in ways that will lead to desired
outcomes. Studies have related SE to improved patient participation in health
care. Given these findings, Shelly and Pakenham (2007) hypothesized that
patients who were matched on SE and EHLC (high on both, or low on both)
would show improved outcomes in response to a surgery preparation program.
Conversely, the researchers hypothesized the unmatched patients (one high
and the other low) would be better off with standard care (no surgery
preparation). The results are complicated but generally supported the hypothesis.
This study, and others to be reviewed later, underscores the importance of
matching the surgery preparation program to the coping style of the patient. If a
patient is an information-avoider with high EHLC (believes outcome is in the
hands of the doctors) and low SE (low confidence that his own behavior can
impact the treatment outcome), doing an intensive preparation for surgery
program with a high level of education has a great likelihood of actually making
the patient more distressed about the surgery.
Understanding and Remembering Medical Information
Research has consistently demonstrated that surgical patients are dissatisfied
with the amount of preoperative information that they receive (see Deardorff &
Reeves, 1997; Pizzi, Goldfarb, & Nash, 2001; Webber, 1990 for reviews). In
addition, even if information is provided, several problems have been found
including the readability of the written information, patients level of
understanding, and their recall for medical information.
Although the situation has improved somewhat since the Webber (1990) review,
surgical consent forms often contain highly detailed information written at a level
that is far beyond that which most patients can understand (Pizzi et al., 2001).
Generally, it has been found that surgical informed consent documents are
written at the level of a scientific journal or specialized academic magazine.
Clearly, this is beyond the readability capacity of most laypersons facing a
surgery. As concluded by Webber (1990), in summary, written materials are
desired and appreciated by patients; however, more attention needs to be given
hospital? What is the best way to manage these complications if they arise?
With whom should I discuss these issues?
Will I need assistance at home after I am discharged from the hospital? Should I
arrange for that now? Will I go directly home after discharge or is there the
possibility of going to a rehabilitation or transitional care unit/facility?
Once I go home, what will my level of functioning be and for how long?
Blood Transfusion
Is it possible that I may need a blood transfusion during the surgery? YES NO
Can I give blood in advance in case I need it during the surgery? YES
NO
surgical opinions, can reach a point of information chaos for the patient.
Alternatively, patients might be guided to websites that are known to contain
accurate information. Most of the Websites that are associated with University
Medical Centers (e.g. ending in .edu), are maintained by governmental
institutions (e.g. through the National Institute of Health, ending in .gov), or are
associated with a professional organization (ending in .org) can be trusted as
reliable sources of information. Also, those of professional organizations related
to surgery are generally reputable and the information can be trusted. Examples
include:
Cognitive Restructuring
Basic Tenets
The philosophy of cognitive restructuring is guided by observations that were
made in the very remote past. For instance, William Shakespeare in Hamlet
stated, there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so. Ages
before the time of Shakespeare, in the first century, the philosopher Epictetus
stated, Men feel disturbed not by things, but by the views which they take of
them. These principles have recently been rediscovered and refined (Beck,
1979; Ellis, 1975; Meichenbaum, 1977). Several basic tenets guide the cognitive
restructuring approach:
1. It is not the situation that causes a specific emotional response, but rather
an individuals thoughts or cognitions about the situation.
2. Thoughts influence how we behave including what we choose to do or not
do, and the quality of our performance.
3. Thoughts can be considered behaviors that are susceptible to change.
4. Changing cognitions to be more positive or coping-oriented can influence
the surgical patients coping abilities and, therefore, enhance outcome.
Preparing the Patient for the Cognitive Behavioral Approach
Steps for preparing the pre-surgical patient for the cognitive behavioral approach
include:
1. Dispel the myth that the patient has been referred for surgery preparation
because of any type of weak will or other negative reason.
2. Explain that surgery preparation is commonly done with all patients in
order to normalize the experience.
3. Discuss that psychological preparation for surgery can enhance the
patients outcome and make the entire surgery process proceed much
more smoothly. Review the research on the findings that surgery
preparation will produce actual physical changes that facilitate healing and
recovery.
4. Discuss the rationale behind the various interventions (e.g. cognitive
behavioral, relaxation training).
The more the patient accepts the rationale behind surgery preparation, the more
likely she will embrace and practice the techniques.
Many of the cognitive researchers have observed that individuals under stress
have a tendency to engage in negative automatic thoughts. Negative automatic
thoughts, or self-talk, have the following characteristics:
power in using this approach comes from changing the negative automatic
thoughts to "realistic, coping, and nurturing" thoughts. By changing the thoughts
about the surgery experience, the patient can change her emotional responses
and behaviors throughout the process.
The Three-Column Technique
The ABCDE model can be utilized in a three- or five-column technique. A threecolumn worksheet can be seen in Table 3-4. This allows the patient to begin to
carefully identify negative automatic thoughts. Once this is mastered, the
technique is expanded to a five-column technique to be reviewed subsequently.
Table 3-4: The Three-Column Technique
Activating Event
Beliefs
Consequent
Emotions
Fear
Anxiety and
Hopelessness
Depression and
Hopelessness
Frustration, Anger,
Guilt, and
Helplessness
Anger and
Hopelessness
In catastrophic thinking, the dire predictions are not based on facts but rather
pessimistic beliefs.
Filtering
This thinking style involves focusing on only the negative aspects of a situation to
the exclusion of any positive elements or options. This type of negative self-talk
has also been termed tunnel vision since it causes the patient to look at only
one element of a situation to the exclusion of everything else. This style will
commonly include searching for evidence of "how bad things really are" and
discounting any positive or coping focus. Examples include:
This type of thinking undermines any small steps towards improvement, severely
limits one's options, and filters out any positive aspects of a situation.
Overgeneralization
This is the process of taking one aspect of a situation and applying it to all other
situations. It involves generalizing reactions to situations in which such reactions
are not appropriate. For instance:
As can be seen, this style of negative self-talk will take one incident and make it
apply it to many other situations, resulting in the person reaching an incorrect
conclusion. Overgeneralization is often indicated by such key words as all, every,
none, never, always, everybody, and nobody.
Mind Reading
This negative self-talk "trap" involves making assumptions about what other
people are thinking without actually knowing. The person will then act on these
assumptions (which are usually erroneous) without checking them out for
accuracy. Examples of this would include:
If the patient accepts these assumptions as facts, then her behavior will follow
accordingly, and will likely to create a self-fulfilling prophecy. For example, a
patients spouse might ask, "How do you feel today?" Instead of taking his
comment at face value, the patient believes he really means, "Are you still letting
that problem bother you?" So the patient responds, "How do think I feel today?
The same as always, that's how!" One can easily guess how this scenario would
be completed.
Shoulds
"Should" statements are key elements in negative self-talk. In this style of
negative self-talk, the patient operates from a list of inflexible and unrealistic rules
about their own actions as well as those of others. Examples of such thinking
include:
Should thinking also includes terms like ought, must, always, and never. Should
thinking is judgmental and often involves an individual measuring his
performance against some irrational perfect standard. It has the effect of making
the patient feel worthless, useless, and inadequate. When directed at others, it
will have the effect of making the patient feel angry and resentful in those
relationships. As discussed in the previous chapter, the process of the upward
comparison phenomenon in social self-regulation is the finding that patients may
have a tendency to compare themselves with other patients who are doing
better. This process might involve should irrational thinking (I should be
recovering as fast as he is).
Blaming
In blaming, the person makes something or someone else responsible for a
problem or situation. There is some comfort in being able to attach responsibility
for ones suffering to someone else. Unfortunately, blaming can often cause a
person to avoid taking responsibility for his own choices and opportunity for
improvement. This type of negative thinking is very often seen in cases of
industrial injury, automobile accidents, or other such trauma. Examples include:
Having the patient subject his self-talk to these questions will help identify
negative versus positive (or coping) messages. After helping the surgical patient
identify and challenge any negative self-talk, it is important to facilitate the
process of substituting positive, realistic, or coping self-talk. These coping
thoughts can be written down by in the thoughts and feelings diary and then
practiced through rehearsal. Bourne (1995) has developed the following rules to
help patients write positive coping self-talk statements.
Avoid negatives
When having patients write positive coping statements, teach them to avoid
using negatives. For instance, instead of saying, I cant be nervous about going
to the hospital, a patient can say, I will be confident and calm about going to the
hospital. The first type of statement can be anxiety-producing in and of itself,
which will defeat the purpose of the coping thought.
Keep coping thoughts in the present tense
Since most negative self-talk occurs in the here-and-now, it should be countered
by coping thoughts that are in the present tense. Instead of a patient saying, I
will be happy when this surgery is over she might say, I am happy about _____
right now. Teaching surgery patients to begin self-statements with, I am
learning to... and I can... is very beneficial for cognitive restructuring.
Keep coping thoughts in the first person
Whenever possible, have patients keep their thoughts in the first person. This
can be done by having patients begin coping thoughts with I or by being sure
that I occurs somewhere in the sentence.
Make coping thoughts believable
Coping thoughts should be based in reality. This will ensure that the patient will
have some belief in his own coping self-talk. As a patient practices the positive
self-talk, it becomes more and more believable. A persons coping thoughts
should not be broadly positive, Pollyannaish, and unrealistic; otherwise, the
patient will completely discount them as untrue. For instance, the coping thought
of I cant wait to have surgery. Im sure I will completely enjoy the entire
experience is unrealistic and not believable. Rather, the thought, I will be able
make the surgery experience as positive as possible, and I will be looking
forward to beginning the recovery process is much more tenable.
Coping Self-Talk
Examples of positive or coping self-talk, which can challenge each of the
negative styles, follow. These examples can be reviewed with patients to help
them understand how the thought reframing process works. Also, see Table 3-5
for an example of how these coping thoughts directly combat negative self-talk:
Catastrophizing
For catastrophizing, the patient should be reminded that no one can predict the
future. Tell the patient that it is probably in his best interest to predict a realistic or
positive outcome rather than a catastrophic and What if outcome. Explain to
the patient that acting as if things will turn out OK is usually the best course of
action.
Filtering
If a patient is filtering out everything except the most negative aspects of a
situation, she needs to learn to shift focus. First, teach the patient to redirect her
attention to active strategies that can be used to make the situation more
manageable. Help the patient look at the situation realistically rather than
magnifying the negative aspects. Then, have the patient focus on the positive
aspects of the situation. Patients should be encouraged to avoid the negative
thought, I cant stand it.
remind the patient there are always different options, not just the two extremes of
black and white.
Overgeneralizing
In overgeneralizing, the patient is taking one element of a situation and applying
to everything else. A patient can stop overgeneralizing by being reminded to
evaluate each aspect of a situation realistically and independently.
Ive been able to get through a lot of situations and Ill get through this one
Just because my last hospitalization was unpleasant doesnt mean this
one has to be
Mind Reading
Nobody can read another persons mind although individuals often have the
tendency to act as if it is possible. This causes a person to act and feel towards
others based upon inaccurate conclusions. For instance, a patient might think, I
know my doctor doesnt like me based simply on mind reading. Remind
patients that nobody can read another persons mind and it is important to check
it out.
Shoulds
If a patient has a propensity towards using the words should, ought, or must,
then he is either self-discounting or is judging others by standards that are
unrealistic. These types of statements seek to lower a patients self-confidence
and self-esteem. To help patients evaluate when this is happening, teach them to
ask themselves, Is this standard realistic?, Is this standard flexible? and Does
this standard make my life and situation better?
Blaming
If patients are tending towards self-blame, they should be reminded that they
tried to make the best choice at the time and can continue to make healthy
choices from now on. If they are blaming others, have them assess realistically
how they went about making their choices and remind them of what aspects of
the situation are in their control and realm of responsibility.
As can be seen from the previous examples, as well as the common surgical
patient fears listed in the previous chapter, presurgical automatic negative
thoughts are not uncommon and there are specific coping thoughts to address
this aspect of surgical preparation.
Table 3-5: The Five-Column Technique
Activating
Event
Beliefs
Preparing for
a major
My body is
surgery after
weak and
a chronic
fragile.
disability
Consequent
Emotions
Disputing
Thoughts
Fear
I can strengthen
my body after
surgery. There Less Fear and
are techniques I more confidence
can use to help
with the pain.
Evaluation
My pain is
going to get Anxiety and
worse and
Hopelessness
worse.
I will strive to
become as
functional as
More sense of
possible. No
control
one can predict
the future
I cant
handle this
surgery. I
hate the
hospital.
Fear and
Anxiety
I can get
through this. I
can look
forward to
discharge and
recovery.
Less Anxiety,
less hospital
stress
My family
is going to
leave me.
Depression
My family will
help me
especially if I
help myself.
More feelings of
comfort/support
I should be
better by
now.
I will continue
Hopelessness to work on
getting better.
Less
Hopelessness,
more
Hopefulness
The surgery Frustration
didnt work and Anger
I will begin to
move and
exercise
slowly.
Less Frustration
I should
I did what I
never have
Hopelessness thought was
allowed this
right.
to happen.
More Optimism
There is
nothing I
can do
Helplessness
during the
surgery and
recovery.
I can
participate in
my own
recovery.
More Confidence
What if the
surgery
doesnt
work? I bet
it wont.
No one can
predict the
future.
Anger
Im either
Small steps will
More
cured or Im Hopelessness lead to bigger
Hopefulness
not
ones.
There are
The future
things I can do More
looks awful. Hopelessness
to lead a quality Hopefulness
I feel awful.
life.
Relaxation Techniques
Some of the correlates of the stress response that have been found to impede
wound healing have been discussed previously. A common component of a
preparation for surgery program is teaching patients the relaxation response. It is
important to distinguish between the relaxation response and simply relaxing.
Engaging in an enjoyable and sedentary activity may be relaxing, but this does
not necessarily induce what researchers have termed the relaxation response.
The relaxation response is a specific physiological state that is essentially the
opposite of the bodys condition when it is under stress. The relaxation response
was first described in the early 1970s (Benson, 1975). Learning to elicit the
relaxation response can only be achieved through regular practice of some type
of relaxation exercise. Table 3-6 demonstrates the physiological difference
between the stress response and the relaxation response. As can be seen, the
Stress
Response
Relaxation
Response
Metabolism
Increases
Decreases
Blood Pressure
Increases
Decreases
Heart Rate
Increases
Decreases
Rate of Breathing
Increases
Decreases
Increases
Stable
Muscle Tension
Increases
Decreases
Decreases
Increases
It is important to have patients practice the breathing exercises once or twice per
day. Practicing at least once per day is mandatory in order to learn to elicit the
deep relaxation response. As they practices regularly, patients may find that the
amount of time required to elicit the relaxation response decreases.
Quiet location
It can be useful to give to have the patient give other family members a fiveminute warning when he begins breathing exercises. This can help a patient take
care of "loose ends" prior to practicing the deep breathing. For instance, if a
patient tends to be worried about a number of things "to do," it can be helpful to
have him her make a short list prior to doing the relaxation exercise. This will
help the patient be able to focus on the deep relaxation exercise rather than
"trying to remember" what "needs" to be done after relaxing.
Practice at regular times
It is important to have patients set up regular practice times, as this will increase
the likelihood or followthrough on deep relaxation exercises. These times should
be when a patient is most likely to follow through on completing the exercises.
The regular practice times should not be when the patient is so tired (for
instance, right after a big meal or just prior to bed) that he is likely to fall asleep.
Practice on an empty stomach
As discussed above, practicing deep relaxation after a big meal increases the
likelihood that a patient will fall asleep in the middle of trying to relax. In addition,
the process of digestion after meals can disrupt deep relaxation. Therefore, it is
recommended that patients try to practice on an empty stomach if possible.
Assume a comfortable position
It is useful to have patients loosen any tight clothing and take off such things as
shoes, watch, glasses, jewelry, and other constrictive apparel when practicing
relaxation. Again, the object is to have the patient be as comfortable as possible
while practicing.
Assume a passive attitude
Complaints about not having enough time to practice the relaxation are probably
one of the most common obstacles encountered in a preparation for surgery
program. In this case, it is important to help the patient prioritize the relaxation
practice. This issue is especially salient presurgically since patients sometimes
feel overwhelmed by the number of issues they have to address prior to the
operation. Helping patients schedule a specific time for relaxation practice can
help in this regard. In addition, they should be reminded that the relaxation
practice session takes less than 30 minutes, and even less time after regular
practice.
It is boring
Some patients have trouble completing the relaxation exercises stating that they
are boring. These patients will typically deal with stress by becoming quite
busy and, in general, have trouble being still as a personality style. When this
type of obstacle occurs, it is important to remind the patient that the relaxation
response skill is critical to the success of the preparation for surgery program.
These patients will often need to be convinced of the value of relaxing and not
see it as simply wasting time. In more extreme cases, it might be useful to have
these patients practice a more active type of relaxation exercise. This might
include something like imagery or some other similar procedure that requires the
patient to do something during the relaxation exercise. For patients with this
personality style, the act of doing something versus being passive may be more
appropriate.
No place to relax
This obstacle presents itself when the patients complain that they dont have any
quiet place to practice the relaxation exercises on a regular basis. Again, when
this issue is explored more thoroughly, it is often related to the patient not making
relaxation practice a priority. As discussed by Deardorff and Reeves (1997), the
following patient recommendations can be helpful to overcome this obstacle.
Put the phone on an answering machine and unplug the phone in your
bedroom.
Give your family the "five-minute warning" that you will be unavailable for
the next 20 minutes while you practice the exercises.
Close the door to the room in which you are going to practice and place a
"Do Not Disturb" sign on the doorknob.
During the five-minute warning period, be sure the family demands are
placed on hold or managed by another household member.
If there is not room enough to "get away" from these distractions, you
might have to practice when the other people in the household are out of
the house.
Hypnosis
Hypnosis has been extensively used as a component of preparation for surgery
programs (Blankfield, 1991; Lynch, 1999; Kessler and Dane, 1996; Wood and
Hirschberg, 1994). In fact, one of the early known uses of hypnosis was as an
anesthetic agent with a surgery patient in the United States in 1836 (Wood and
Hirschberg, 1994). There are a variety of techniques for hypnotic induction and
these will not be reviewed here. Reviews of the literature show that hypnosis
training for surgical patients might include a single session or multiple presurgical consultations (see Wood and Hirschberg, 1994 for a review). One
important finding that has implications for the cost effectiveness of this procedure
is that many of the programs consist of audiotaped hypnosis exercises that can
be practiced by the patient on her own.
The content of the hypnotic suggestions can be quite variable from inducing
simple relaxation to suggestions for enhanced wound healing. Some of the more
common hypnotic suggestions used in helping patients cope with the surgical
experience can be found elsewhere (Deardorff and Reeves, 1997; Wood and
Hirschberg, 1994). Similar to developing the relaxation response, patients must
practice the hypnotic exercises prior to using them to manage pre- and
postoperative situations. Again, if the patient practices these on a regular basis,
the hypnotic state can be induced quite rapidly and in almost any stressful
situation related to the surgery.
If hypnosis is part of the preparation for surgery program, misconceptions about
hypnosis should be discussed with the patient. Due to common misperceptions,
patients are often fearful of term hypnosis. Some of these popular erroneous
beliefs about hypnosis follow (adapted from Deardorff and Reeves, 1997).
Hypnosis is a state of deep sleep or unconsciousness
A person is not asleep when under hypnosis. In fact, hypnosis is a state of
relaxed attention in which the person is able to hear, speak, move around, and
think independently. The brain waves of a hypnotized person are similar to those
of someone who is awake; reflexes, such as the knee jerk, which is absent in the
sleeping person, are present when hypnotized.
Hypnosis allows someone else to control the patients mind
Books, movies, and stage hypnotists have capitalized on perpetuating this myth
and it is perhaps the biggest misconception that keeps people from pursuing and
benefiting from hypnosis. A patient cannot be hypnotized against his will and
once hypnotized, a person cannot be forced or coerced into doing something he
finds objectionable or do not want to do.
A hypnotized person might not be able to come out of a trance
It is actually more difficult to become hypnotized than it is to slip out of hypnosis.
Patients frequently become alert when a hypnotherapist stops talking,
inadvertently says something inconsistent with the persons beliefs, leaves the
room, or is otherwise distracted. If left alone when hypnotized, most people
reorient, alert themselves, and awaken naturally.
A hypnotized person will give away secrets
When hypnotized, a person is aware of everything that happens both during and
after hypnosis, unless he wants to accept and follow specific suggestions for
amnesia. Thus, secrets cannot be forced from a person who is unwilling to
divulge them.
The patient believes that he probably cannot be hypnotized
Some people are more responsive than others to hypnosis, but nearly everyone
can achieve some level of hypnosis and can benefit from it with practice.
Obstacles to hypnosis include trying too hard, fears or misconceptions about
hypnosis, and unconscious desires to hang on to troublesome symptoms. A
licensed psychologist, physician, or dentist experienced in hypnosis can help a
person overcome these stumbling blocks.
As can be seen from these examples, there are many ways in which imagery can
be used for health issues, including the surgery process. The imagery discussed
subsequently will focus on its use specifically for surgical issues and healing.
Guidelines for Practicing Imagery
The following are guidelines for developing an effective imagery exercise. It is
important to remind the patient that imagery is a natural process and she is
always in complete control.
Record an imagery exercise
It is best to develop an image with which the patient is quite familiar. Generally,
people have an easier time conjuring up all aspects of the image if it is something
that they have actually experienced in the past. For instance, a patient may
choose a beach or forest scene, which is a place that they have visited (and, of
course, had a pleasurable time). There are standard imagery exercises, some of
which are presented in the following section. These can be modified to fit with the
patients own personal experiences. The use of images developed from the
patient's memories and experiences does not have to contain the entire memory.
The patient can draw from bits and pieces of different memories in order to form
a complete image.
It is most powerful if the patient utilizes all five senses (sight, sound, touch, smell,
and taste) in developing the image. For instance, in a beach scene for relaxation,
the image should include the view of the ocean and beach, the smell of the salty
sea air, the sounds of sea gulls and the waves, the salty taste of the ocean air,
and the feel of bare feet walking on the warm sand.
Use an image that is pleasing to the patient
The old adage that one persons feast is another persons poison applies to
imagery as well. Imagery is a very personal and individualized experience. It is
important to be sure that the patients imagery is pleasing to her (and not as
defined by the clinician).
As an example of the importance of individualized images, consider the standard
relaxation image called "The Beach Scene." While this may be relaxing to most
people, other people may find it quite distressing. I was very much reminded of
this while leading a group relaxation/imagery exercise with a colleague. We
chose the beach scene as a standard image to have the group develop. At the
end of the exercise, we asked the group members to comment on their
experience with the image. Although most everyone found it very relaxing and
pleasant, one woman felt it was quite distressing and anxiety producing. She
discussed that she absolutely hated going to the beach. For her, going to the
beach meant not being able to find a place to park, suffering through sunburn,
eating sandwiches with sand and ants in them, and listening to the radio with bad
reception. There was no part of the beach scene that she found relaxing.
This example underscores that structured imagery exercises such as the beach
scene serve only as examples from which you can develop the patients own
personalized image.
Sneak up on the image
of sneaking up on the image helps ensure that the imagery is relaxing and that
you adopt an attitude of "letting it happen," rather than trying too hard.
Use one image at a time
It is best only to try to imagine one total image at a time. Trying to maintain
several images at once is stressful and usually does not accomplish the goal of
imagery.
Precede the imagery with a relaxation exercise
Using a deep relaxation exercise, prior to doing the imagery can greatly facilitate
the use of imagery. Although not required, it is highly recommended approaching
an imagery exercise in this fashion. This process includes choosing one of the
breathing exercises as discussed previously. Have the patient practice with the
breathing exercise until he is skilled at eliciting the deep relaxation response.
Once this is mastered, the patient can then add an imagery exercise as
suggested in this section. Each session of deep relaxation and imagery should
total about ten to twenty minutes. All of the guidelines for practicing the
relaxation exercises also apply to the imagery experience.
Practice the Image
The patient can get the beneficial effects of imagery even if the image does not
have a great amount of detail or is not particularly vivid. As discussed above, the
more the patient practices, the more likely the details of the images will emerge
and the patient will notice a sense of actually being there. It is not helpful for the
patient to judge his performance, or to make this in any way stressful.
Incorporate affirmations or prayer into the imagery
For all of the following exercises, it is assumed that the patient will have already
completed a breathing exercise to elicit the relaxation response. If a tape is made
for patient use, put the breathing exercises at the beginning of the tape and then
incorporate the imagery sequence after the breathing exercises. It is also
important to end the image as discussed previously. In the first example, all of
these phases (breathing exercise, imagery, ending the imagery) are presented.
As you feel ready, allow your eyes to slowly closeTake in a full, deep breath
through your nose, allowing your lungs to fill completely. Let the air go all the way
in, breathing down into the bottom of your lungs. Notice the cool sensation in
your nose as the air rushes inThen, breath out through your mouth while
slightly pursing your lipsNotice that the air you exhale is warm and
moist....Release all of the air in your lungs as you exhale completelySlowly
repeat this cycle several timesBreathing in through your nose and out through
your mouthRemember, there is nothing else to think about except becoming
completely and deeply relaxed
[Pause 3 to 5 minutes here for the breathing]
You may have noticed the healthy breathing exercise has already helped you
become quite relaxedAs you allow yourself to relax more and more fully, begin
to focus your attention on your fingers and handsAs you mentally focus your
attention on your fingers and hands, I would like you to notice the sensations that
are coming from that part of your bodyYou may notice your hands resting on
another part of your body or elsewhereSimply focus on the sensations coming
from your fingers and handsImagine what it would feel like for your hands and
fingers to become more and more relaxedLet go of any excess tension you
may feel in your fingers or hands.
As you continue to relax and breath peacefully, slowly move your mental
attention to the sensations coming from your forearms and upper armsAs your
fingers and hands continue to relax, allow that feeling of relaxation to move into
your forearms and upper armsYou might notice your hands or arms feeling
warm or heavy as they relaxOr you may notice them feeling cool and
lightSimply focus on what the relaxation response feels like for you.
As your arms continue to relax with every breath, allow the feeling of relaxation to
move into your head, neck, and shouldersNotice what it would be like for your
forehead to relax completelyAllow the muscles around your eyes to relaxAs
you relax the muscles of your jaw you may notice that your lips separate
slightlyAllow your shoulders to relax completelyMentally scan these parts of
your body, and imagine letting go of any tension that you notice...Just allow the
wave of relaxation to extend throughout your arms and upper body.
When you are ready, focus your attention on the sensations coming from your
stomach and back...Again, notice the relaxation response move slowly down
your body as you let go of any tension in your stomach and backImagine what
it would be like for all of the muscles in your stomach and back to unwind and
loosen up completelyIt is as if you are inhaling relaxing and exhaling tension
with every breathThere is nothing else for you to focus on right now except
enjoying the feelings of relaxation throughout your upper body.
and more content as you enjoy the surroundings of this beautiful beach...As you
continue to walk, you notice a place where it would be quite comfortable to
simply sit down and relax against a sand duneAs you sit, you are look out over
the beach, the waves, and the sun on the horizon...The sun has started to set,
causing the sky to turn many colors including scarlet, pink, gold, orange, amber,
and crimson. You allow yourself to settle deeply into the comfortable sand dune
as you enjoy the sun's reflection off the water. The sand forms perfectly to your
body as you settle inAs you sit, you allow yourself to relax more and more. You
find yourself relaxed, peaceful, and content.
Breathing out pain
Continue to breathe comfortably and slowly, feeling your body relax more and
more each time you breathe outIf you wish, the next time you breathe in,
imagine that your breath goes to that part of your body in which you are
experiencing pain or discomfortImagine your inhaling brings with it valuable
oxygen and nutrients your body needs...Your deep breath also brings with it a
sense of calm and comfortAs you slowly exhale, you might imagine that just a
bit of the pain and discomfort is exhaled along with your breathing outAs you
exhale some of this pain and discomfort, the tissues left behind seem to be more
relaxed, healthy, and comfortableThis reduction in pain may be only slightly
noticeable at first, but it seems to become more and more powerful with each
breathEach time you breath in, imagine the air flowing to that area of pain and
discomfortIt brings with it a sensation of health and comfortThen, each time
you breathe out the air, notice the area of pain and discomfort becoming smaller
and smallerAs you breathe out, you are exhaling discomfort and painBreathe
in the relaxation and breathe out the pain.
Healing energy
As you continue to relax, focus once again on your breathing. Notice how you are
slowly breathing inFeel the air going into your lungs...Notice your lungs filling
completely with air as you inhaleThen, notice the air rushing out of your lungs
and mouth as you exhaleEnjoy the experience as you become more and more
relaxed each time you inhale and exhale...As you continue to relax, you may
begin to imagine a ball of white light forming in the area of your chest and
lungs...This is a ball of healing energyIt may not be particularly clear or distinct
and that is perfectly fineWhatever its shape and texture, simply notice what
your ball of healing energy looks like...Focus for a few seconds on this ball of
healing energy in your chest areaWhen you feel ready, you may begin to
notice this ball of white healing energy move to an area of your body which is
feeling pain or discomfortNotice the ball of healing energy moving slowly to
that part of your bodyImagine that ball of healing energy settling in that part of
your body...As it settles there, imagine it helping the tissues becoming more and
more healthyImagine the white ball of healing energy bringing with it valuable
nutrients and healing power...As the power of the healing ball of energy begins to
work, you might notice a warming or cooling sensation in that part of your
Effective communication between doctor and patient has been found to enhance
patient recall of information, compliance with treatment recommendations,
satisfaction with care, psychologic well-being, and overall treatment outcomes
(see Levinson & Chaumeton, 1999; Stewart, 1995 for a review). Certainly,
research indicates that patient concerns about obtaining appropriate information
are not unfounded. For instance, it has been found that general practice
physicians and surgeons spend an average of between 7 and 13 minutes per
patient visit. In addition, it is likely that a patient will be interrupted by their doctor
within the first 18 seconds of their explanation of symptoms (Beckman & Frankel,
1984). However, the entire doctor-patient communication problem cannot be
placed with the physicians. There are research findings that suggest that patients
share some of the responsibility for not getting what they need from their
healthcare providers. For instance, Kaplan and Greenfield (1989) determined
that the average patient asked fewer than four questions in a 15-minute visit with
the doctor. In addition, one of the more frequently asked questions was, Will you
validate my parking?
Medical Errors
Unfortunately, medical errors are more common than is generally realized by the
patient population (See Doing What Counts for Patient Safety: Federal Actions to
Reduce Medical Errors and Their Impact, a Report to the President). Medical
errors range from mistakes in hospital meals to blatant surgical mistakes (See
the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality report, Medical Errors: The
Scope of the Problem. Fact sheet, Publication No. AHRQ 00-P037).
One of the more common mistakes in the hospital is medication error (Leape,
Bates, Cullen et al, 1995). The Journal Of The American Medical Association
estimates that doctor- or hospital-related mistakes could be at least partially
responsible for 180,000 deaths annually (Leape, 1994). A recent 2006 report
(Preventing Medication Errors, available from the National Academies Press)
by the Institute of Medicine found that medication errors are surprisingly
common.
Probably two of the most important medical errors for a patient to monitor during
an inpatient stay are medication interaction and infection. The hospital setting is
one of the most likely and most risky places to get infected. According to the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, approximately 5-10% of hospitalized
patients pick up an infection; this translates to 1.75 and 3.5 million cases per year
(see Benson, 1996; Cohen, 1995). CDC officials estimate that failure to follow
standardized infection control practices causes at least one-third of hospitalacquired infections. These procedures include such simple tasks as healthcare
professionals washing their hands prior to performing any type of physical
contact with the patient. In a comprehensive review of 37 studies on hand
washing, it was found that doctors and nurses typically wash their hands only
40% of the time prior to physical contact with the patient (Griffin, 1996).
Unfortunately, the hospital setting is the one place where the patient is more
prone to be infected with an antibiotic resistant bacteria, or super bug (Cohen,
1995).
Table 4-1: Patient handout for avoiding medical errors
1. The single most important way you can help to prevent errors is to be an
active member of your health care team.
2. Make sure that all of your doctors know about everything you are taking.
This includes prescription and over-the-counter medicines, and dietary
supplements such as vitamins and herbs.
3. Make sure your doctor knows about any allergies and adverse reactions
you have had to medicines.
4. When your doctor writes you a prescription, be sure you can read it.
5. Ask for information about your medicines in terms you can understandboth when your medicines are prescribed and when you receive them.
6. When you pick up your medicine from the pharmacy, ask: Is this the
medicine that my doctor prescribed?
7. If you have questions about the directions on your medicine labels, ask.
8. Ask your pharmacist for the best device to measure your liquid
medicine. Also, ask questions if youre not sure how to use it.
9. Ask for written information about the side effects your medicine could
cause.
10. If you have a choice, choose a hospital at which many patients have the
procedure or surgery you need.
11. If you are in the hospital, consider asking all health care workers who
have direct contact with you whether they have washed their hands.
12. When you are being discharged from the hospital, ask your doctor to
explain the treatment plan you will use at home.
13. If you are having surgery, make sure that you, your doctor and your
surgeon all agree and are clear on exactly what will be done.
14. Speak up if you have questions or concerns.
15. Make sure that someone, such as your personal doctor, is in charge of
your care.
16. Make sure that all health professionals involved in your care have
important health information about you.
Cognitive Behavioral
o Information Gathering
o Cognitive Restructuring
o Relaxation Exercises/Cue Controlled Relaxation
Psychosocial
o Communication and Assertiveness
o Family, Friends and Work
o Spirituality
o Pain Control Plan
Implementation Strategy
Self-Guided
o Individual
o Group
o Blended
Postoperative Follow-up