Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Upp)
Flow meter type
Orifice Plate
(CONCENTRIC)
Orifice Plate
(ECCENTRIC)
Orifice Plate
(SEGMENTAL)
Orifice Plate
(QUADRANT EDGE)
Type of
measurement
Typical Rangeability
(Turndown Ratio)
Accuracy
(of Full Scale)
Straight Pipe
Requirements
3:1 to 4:1
0.25% to 1%
> 10,000
60% to 65%
2" to 40"
2" to 40"
3:1 to 4:1
0.5% to 2%
> 10,000
60% to 65%
2" to 40"
2" to 40"
Sq Root
Volumetric
Sq Root
Volumetric
Sq Root
Volumetric
Sq Root
Permanent
Pressure Loss
Pipe Sizes
Pipe Sizes
Inches (Liq)
Inches (Gas)
3:1 to 4:1
0.5% to 2 %
> 10,000
60% to 65%
2" to 40"
2" to 40"
3:1 to 4:1
0.5% to 2%
> 10,000
60% to 65%
2" to 40"
2" to 40"
3:1 to 4:1
0.25% to 1%
> 10,000
60% to 65%
< 2"
< 2"
Volumetric
Square Root
Volumetric
Venturi Tube
Sq Root
Volumetric
3:1 to 4:1
Flow Nozzle
Sq Root
Volumetric
3:1 to 4:1
Sq Root
Volumetric
3:1 to 4:1
Elbow meter
Sq Root
Volumetric
3:1 to 4:1
0.5% to 4%
Dall Tube
Sq Root
Volumetric
3:1 to 4:1
0.5% to 1.5%
UP: 5D to 30D
DOWN: 2D to 5D
Target Meter
Square Root
Volumetric
1% to 3%
3:1 to 20:1
0.5% to 1.5%
> 100,000
30% to 35 %
0.5% to 1.5%
> 10,000
Low
1% to 5%
> 4000
Very low
Linear volumetric
10:1 to 20:1
Velocity Meter
Magnetic Flowmeter
Linear volumetric
Velocity Meter
Turbine Flowmeter Linear volumetric
20:1 to 100:1
10:1 (Liq)
50:1 (Gas)
Positive
Displacement Meter Volumetric Meter
Ultrasonic
Coriolis Type
Thermal Dispersion
Variable Area
(Rotameter)
Velocity Meter
Volumetric
Mass Meter
Linear
Logarithmic
Mass Meter
Linear Volumetric
Note:
1. Special materials required
2. The Guru says it should be from 2" to 30" for both liquid and gas.
20 :1 (Liq)
250 : 1 (Gas)
0.5% to 1.5%
UP: 25D
DOWN: 5D
2" to 30"
> 1"
2" to 60"
> 1"
> 10,000
Very low
2" to 30"
2" to 42"
Very low
2" to 60"
(note 2)
2" to 60"
(note 2)
> 100
Low
1/2" to 4"
Low
1/2" to 8"
No limit
0.1 to 2% o.r.
0.1 to 2% o.r.
UP: 3D
DOWN: 2D
>100 or
>1000
High
No limit
None
No limit
High
1/16" to 6"
5000
None
Up to 100"
0.1% to 3%
None
100:1
1% to 5%
0.5% to 5%
None
Temp
Pressure
Limit (C)
Limit (Bar)
(Note 1)
500
None
High
2" to 30"
Same as
Orifice
Plate
(Note 1)
(Note 1)
2" to 30"
1/8" to 24"
Good
1/2" to 8"
AGA3
600
(Note 1)
(Note 1)
(Note 1)
(Note 1)
ANSI/ASME MFC 6M
ISO 6817
400
250
250
150
500
3000
2" to 12"
250
50
200
200
1/16" to 6" Available up to 6" only; If volume measurement Can be used on liquids, slurries, gases and
400
400
Up to 100" Useful for research applications.Not practical yet. Performance can be affected by build-up on
sensors; requires frequent cleaning
300
Ambient
2" to 30"
desired, conversion via analysis or density at 2-phase liquids and gas flows. Can handle
base condition required; Pressure loss high
highly varying density or phase mixtures
High maintenance cost; on gas, sensitve to Wide temperature and pressure operating
density and friction effects; on liquid, sensitive to
range; high frequency readout; linear
viscous effects
calibration
1/8" to 24"
Standards or
Recommended Practice
Electrodes must be in
horizontal. Flow should be
upward in vertical installation
Gas
100
Low
Low
Other Considerations
Service
Same as
Orifice
Plate
Requires straightening vane / long, straightpipe, Installation is simple and costs moderate,
Not available in sizes above 8". Pulsetrain is Able to perform at low or high Reynolds
irregular, proving requires a long test time to number (effects of viscosity, pressure, temp
obtain average pulse rate
are minimal)
0.04" to 120" Up to 120" Power required for operation; high initial cost
Recommended
Orientation
Preferred Meter
1/2" to 4"
3000 (Liq)
10,000 (Gas)
20:1 to 60:1
10:1
> 10,000
Same as Venturi
Advantages
UP: 5 D to 10 D
DOWN: 3 D
1% to 5%
> 100,000
0.2% to 2%
Velocity Meter
Vortex
Limitations
Integral
Pitot Tube
(Impact Meter)
Reynolds #
Flowmeter Selection (Ref: Fluid Flow Measurement - A Practical Guide to Accurate Flow Measurement by E.L. Upp (a.k.a. "guru" of flow)
Flow meter type
Type of
Typical
Accuracy
Straight
Reynolds
Permanent
Pipe Sizes
Pipe Sizes
measurement
Rangeability
Pipe
Number
Pressure
Inches
Inches
Loss
(Liq)
(Gas)
(Turndown Ratio)
Orifice Plate
Requirements
Limitations
Advantages
Temp
Pressure
Preferred Meter
Recommended
Limit (F)
Limit (psig)
Orientation
Service
0.25% to 1%
foreign particles(dirty fluid and two phase flows Pressure and/or temperature
to upstream conditions
(CONCENTRIC)
Orifice Plate
0.5% to 2%
(ECCENTRIC)
Sq Root
Orifice Plate
3 : 1 to 4 : 1
Volumetric
> 10,000
60% to 65%
2" to 40"
2" to 40"
DOWN: 2D to 6D
(SEGMENTAL)
(Note 1)
Sq Root
No limitation on remote seal elements Useful for fluids containing solid materials
required
Orifice Plate
0.5% to 2%
(QUADRANT EDGE)
Venturi tube
Sq Root
Volumetric
Flow nozzle
UP: 5D to 30D
3:1 to 4:1
0.5% to 1.5%
DOWN: ???
3:1 to 4:1
0.5% to 1.5%
DOWN: 2D to 6D
Sq Root
Volumetric
Pitot tube
1% to 5%
Sq Root
Dall tube
Vortex
0.5% to 4%
3:1 to 4:1
0.5% to 1.5%
DOWN: ???
3:1 to 20:1
1% to 3%
DOWN: 2D to 6D
Displacement (PD)
> 10,000
Low
2" to 30"
2" to 60"
> 4000
Very low
> 1"
> 1"
DOWN: 5D
> 10,000
Very low
> 100,000
Very low
> 100
Low
2" to 30"
2" to 42"
2" to 60"
2" to 60"
(note 2)
(note 2)
1/2" to 4"
1/2" to 4"
0.5% to 1.5%
orifice plate
> 10,000
???
1/2" to 8"
1/2" to 8"
Velocity Meter
15 :1 (Liq)
Volumetric
150 : 1 (Gas)
Upsteam
0.5% to 1%
Meter
expensirve
expensirve
Average accuracy
???
Velocity Meter
flowmeter
Linear
>100 or >1000
High
2" to 30"
2" to 12"
0.2% to 2%
DOWN: 3 D
Sq Root
(Note 1)
Sq Root
are minimal)
flowmeter
None
0.1" to 100"
???
Velocity Meter
10:1 (Liq)
Linear
50:1 (Gas)
0.25% to 3%
UP: 5 D to 10 D
3000 (Liq)
DOWN: 3 D
10,000 (Gas)
(Note 1)
Sq Root
(Note 1)
Sq Root
Thermal
2" to 30"
2" to 30"
Ultrasonic
(Note 1)
Sq Root
(Note 1)
Sq Root
750
3600
N/A
N/A
Linear Volumetric
area
360
750
vertical position
off
3000
20:1 to 60:1
0.1% to 3%
None
No limit
High
1/16" to 6"
1/16" to 6"
1% to 5%
DOWN: ???
None
20,000:1
1% to 5%
DOWN: 5D to 10D
No limit
None
Up to 120"
Up to 120"
??? (Gas)
0.5% to 5%
???
???
1/8" to 24"
1/8" to 24"
???
???
???
???
???
< 2"
< 2"
10:1 (Liq)
Gas
calibration
yet.
3000
(Note 1)
as in calibration
with flow up
Integral
Note:
1. Special materials required
2. The Guru says it should be from 2" to 30" for both liquid and gas.
???
???
designs
(Rotameter)
???
Available up to 6" only; If volume measurement Can be used on liquids, slurries, gases and
Velocity Meter
Volumetric
consideration
density and friction effects; on liquid, sensitive range; high frequency readout; linear
to viscous effects
Logarithmic
Mass Meter
Used for control with stable flow rates Clean liquids, dirty liquids, slurries
Mass Meter
Linear
installation
volumetric
Coriolis
volumetric
Turbine
straighteners.
UP: 5 D to 10 D
20:1 to 100:1
(Note 1)
required
Magnetic
Good
Same as
10:1 to 20:1
More used for cases where high repeatibility is Low DP for normal flow; high repeatibility
volumetric
Positive
(Note 2)
UP: 5D to 30D
Velocity Meter
Linear
DOWN: ???
3:1 to 4:1
Square Root
Volumetric
(Note 2)
UP : 10 D
Sq Root
Target meter
2" up to 60"
30% to 35 %
Elbow meter
2" up to 60"
> 100,000
Sq Root
(Impact Meter)
Variable
Other Considerations
???
???
Standards or
Recommended Practice
AGA3
ISO 5167
ANSI/ASME
MCF 3M
ANSI/API 2530
ANSI/ASME MFC 6M
ISO 6817