Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
PREPARED BY NET-WORK 5
NET- WORK
SECTION
1. MEBRAHTOM
MEMBER
AYELGN
IDNO
RET1025/06
1
2. MEDIHN
KIDANE
3. MELKAMU
ADDIS
RET1051/06
1
RET1074/06
1
4. NEBYAT
H/SLASIE
RET1187/06
1
5. NUGUS
RET1215/06
DEGU
1
1
Abstract
This technical paper presents design, and analysis of pres-sure vessel. High pressure rise is
developed in the pressure vessel and pressure vessel has to withstand severe forces. In the design
of pressure vessel safety is the primary consideration, due the potential impact of possible
accident. There have a few main factors to design the safe pressure vessel. This writing is
focusing on analyzing the safety parameter for allowable working pressure. Allowable working
pressures are calculated by using Pressure Vessel Design Manual by Dennis Moss, third edition.
The corruption of the vessel are probability occur at maximum pressure which is the element that
only can sustain that pressure. Efforts are made in this paper to design the pressure vessel using
ASME codes
& standards to legalize the design.
Chapter - one
1.Introduction
Tanks, vessel and pipelines that carry, store or receive flu-ids are called pressure vessel. A
pressure vessel is defined as a container with a pressure differential between inside and outside.
The inside pressure is usually higher than the out-side. The fluid inside the vessel may undergo a
change in state as in the case of steam boiler or may combine with other reagent as in the case of
chemical reactor. Pressure vessel often has a combination of high pressure together with high
temperature and in some cases flammable fluids or highly radioactive material. Because of such
hazards it is imperative that the design be such that no leakage can occur. In addition vessel has
to be design carefully to cope with the operating temperature and pressure. [1]
Pressure vessels are usually spherical or cylindrical with dome end. The
cylindrical vessels are generally preferred because of the present simple
manufacturing problem and make better use of the available space. Boiler,
heat exchanger, chemical reactor and so on, are generally cylindrical.
1.1.
Background
The design of pressure vessels is an important and practical topic which has
been explored for decades. Even though optimization techniques have been
extensively applied to design structures in general, few pieces of work can
4
be found which are directly related to optimal pressure vessel design. These
few references are mainly related to the design optimization of
homogeneous and composite pressure vessels.
1.3.Objective
1.3.1. General objective
To optimize the pressure vessel designs.
The objective of design optimization of pressure vessels is cost reduction by reducing
weight withadequate strength and stiffness. Optimization is the act of obtaining the best
result under given circumstances. Conventional design aims at finding acceptability
design which merely satisfies the functional and other requirements of the problem. In
general, there will be more than one acceptable designs and the purpose of design
optimization is to choose the best.
Most people perceive that the cylindrical tanks describe the appearance of a pressure
vessel. While this shape is an accepted form, this is not the only possible shape for
pressure vessels. In addition to cylinders, many manufacturers have made pressure
vessels likened to a sphere and cone shapes. Of all the other shapes that can be
created, experts say that sphere is the most protective one. Sadly, many manufacturers
and designers tell that sphere is difficult and costly. Consequently, most of businesses
and people have used the cylinders instead.
Chapter- two
2. Literature review
2.1. General pressure vessel design considerations
2.1.1.Design pressure
A vessel must be designed to withstand the maximum pressure to which it is likely
to be
Subjected in operation.
For vessels under internal pressure, the design pressure is normally taken as the
pressure
At which the relief device is set. This will normally be 5 to 10 per cent above the
normal
Working pressure, to avoid spurious operation during minor process upsets. When
deciding
The design pressure, the hydrostatic pressure in the base of the column should be
added
To the operating pressure, if significant.
Vessels subject to external pressure should be designed to resist the maximum
differential
Pressure that is likely to occur in service. Vessels likely to be subjected to vacuum
Should be designed for a full negative pressure of 1 bar, unless fitted with an
effective,
And reliable, vacuum breaker.
2.1.2.Design temperature
The strength of metals decreases with increasing temperature, so the
Maximum allowable design stress will depend on the material temperature. The
design
Temperature at which the design stress is evaluated should be taken as the
maximum
Working temperature of the material, with due allowance for any uncertainty
involved in
Predicting vessel wall temperatures.
2.1.3.Materials
Pressure vessels are constructed from plain carbon steels, low and high alloy steels,
other
alloys, clad plate, and reinforced plastics.
Selection of a suitable material must take into account the suitability of the material
7
For fabrication (particularly welding) as well as the compatibility of the material with
the
Process environment.
The pressure vessel design codes and standards include lists of acceptable
materials;
2.1.7.Design loads
A structure must be designed to resist gross plastic deformation and collapse
under all the condition of loading.
2.1.8.Minimum practical wall thickness
There will be a minimum wall thickness required to ensure that any vessel is
sufficiently
Rigid to withstand its own weight, and any incidental loads.
Chapter-three
t =
PiDi
2 fjPi
PiDi
2 fj0.2 Pi
PiRcCs
2 fj+ Pi(Cs0.2)
stress
D2
2
A=
m
Wp = 1.7KN/
plate arae , plate arae =
4
, where D = internal
diameter
10
gv
,v=
v = volume
Mx =
Hv
2
Fw
Step11.analysis of stress
11
h=
w=
PiDi
2t
Wv
( Di+t ) t
l=
PiDi
4t
Di
2
Mx +t)
Iv
z=l + w b
where
w (ve ) is compressive
Iv =
Step12.
( Do 4Di 4 )
64
, Do = Di+2t
z ( upwind ) =lw+ b
z ( downwind )=lwb
t
Do
)
c=2104
Step14.calculate reinforcement
3.2.METHODOLOGY
3.2.1 .DESIGN SPECIFICATION
The design specification of a sieve plate column is given below.
Properties
Length of cylindrical section, L
Internal diameter, Di
Heads
Number of sieve plates, n
Design temperature, T
Design pressure, Pi
Corrosion allowance, C
Specifications
37 m
1.5 m
Standard ellipsoidal
50
150 0C
1200 KN/m2
2 mm
Specifications
At mid-point
Vapour out
Bottom
Product
200 mm inside
diameter
250 mm inside
diameter
200 mm inside
diameter
200 mm inside
diameter
Specifications
0.6 m
2.5 m
50 mm thick
13
3.3.
ASSUMTIONS
CHAPTER-FOUR
4.RESULT & DISCUSSION
SOLUTION:
Step 1.determine the minimum plate thickness to resist the internal pressure
t=
PiDi
2 fjPi
1.21500
213011.2
t=7 mm+2 mm =9 mm
Step2.determine the minimum thickness of the two heads.
The minimum thickness of ellipsoidal is given
t=
PiDi
2 fj0.2 Pi
t=
1.2(1500)
(
2 130 ) ( 1 )0.2(1.2)
t=6.93 mm
round off to 7 mm
PiRcCs
2 fj+ Pi(Cs0.2)
Rc = Di = 1.5 mm = 1500 mm
15
Rc
Rk
1500
90
= 16.67
Cs =
1
4 (3+
16.6
) = 1.77
= 12 mm ,
Step4. For stability of the shell the column is divided into five parts and thickness
is increased from top to bottom of the shell, as 7 mm, 9 mm, 11 mm, 13 mm and 15
mm respectively.
7
9
11
13
15
16
For all other calculations, the average thickness is used. The average thickness
= ts=11 mm .
m3
WV = 175.3KN
WP=150.45kN
Win=22.224KN
W Total=347.96KN
Fw
Hv
2
Hv
37
Mx=
=1421131.52Nm
2 =
2
Fw
2076.16
18
Longitudinal stress,
PiDi
L= 4 t (N/mm2) =
1.2 x 1500
4 x 15
30 N/mm2
1.2 x 1500
2 x 15
60 N/mm2
Circumferential stress,
h=
PiDi
2
2 t (N/mm ) =
175.310 3 N
( 1500 mm+15 mm ) 15 mm
Wv
w= ( Di+t ) t (N/mm2) =
2.4566 N/mm2
64
Iv =
b =
M Di
+t
Iv 2
4
o
-Di4) =
64
1010 mm
1421131.52103 N . mm 1500mm
+15 mm
10
2
2.048 10 mm
= 53.08
N/mm2
step 13 .Resultant longitudinal stress is given by,
19
z = L+ w
80N/ mm
20
, the Therefore greatest difference between the principal stresses will be on the
down-wind side.
Since the upwind stress (80 N/mm2) and downwind stress (25.5N/mm2) are less
than the allowable design stress (130 N/mm2), therefore the design metal thickness
(tb = 15 mm) is satisfactory.
Step 14: Check elastic stability (buckling).
Critical buckling stress can be
calculated as
4
c=210
4
10
tb
( Do ) = 2
15
=196.07N/
( 1530
mm
z=b+ b
= 53.08+2.4566=55.54N/ mm
21
Since the maximum resultant compressive resultant stress (55.54 N/mm2) less than
2
vessel is correct.
Design 0f Skirt support and base ring calculation
Hvs
Ms = 2
FW
Hvs=Hs+Hv
22
x=Hs+Hv
Where,
MS= Bending moment at the base of the skirt
FW = Load per unit length
HS= Height of skirt
H V =Height of the vessel
x=37.75+2.5=40.25 m
23
Ms=
Fwx
2
2076.1640.25
=
2
=1681754.48Nm
bs= 4Ms/(Ds+ts)Dsts
Where,
Ds =Internal column diameter, =1.5m
ts = Thickness of the skirt = Thickness of the bottom section, =15mm
bs=Bending stress in the skirt
Thus,
41681754.481000
Step 4: Determine the dead weight stress for the test and operating conditions.
For test condition,ws:
Formula given by,
ws(test)=Wwater/(Ds+ts)ts
Where,
ws(test)=Dead weight stress in the skirt for test condition
Wwater= dead weight of the vessel with contents (water).
D 2Hvwg
1.523710009.81
Wwater=
=
=640442.25N=640.44KN
4
4
24
Thus,
640442.25
=
ws(test)= (1500+15)15
8.975N/mm2
For operating condition, ws(operating):
The formula given by,
ws(operating)=Wvessel/(Ds+ts)ts
Where,
ws(operating)=Dead weight stress in the skirt for operating condition
Wvessel= dead weight of vessel with heads.
Thus,
175.31000
ws(operating)= (1500+15)15
=2.45668
N/mm2
=90
fs= 115 N/mm2
E = Youngs modulus (Sinnott. and Tower., 7.3.7. Effect of Temperature onthe
Mechanical Properties 1999) =200,000 N/mm
For the maximum:
Given the formula,
s(compresive)0.125E(ts/Ds)sins
2
71.825 N/ mm
71.825 N/ mm
15
250 (Fulfilled)
For minimum:
Given the formula,
s(tensil)fsJsins
65.31151sin90
2
65.3N/ mm
115 (Fulfilled)
Since all the calculations and comparison above shows that the all design criteria
were fulfilled,add 2 mm for corrosion, gives a design thickness of new skirt
thickness, ts:
New skirt thickness, ts:
ts= (Old thickness of the skirt) + (Corrosion allowance)
=15mm + 2mm= 17mm
Base ring/flange and anchor bolt design
For DS = 1.5 m
Step 1 .Determine the number of bolts required, N bolts
26
Since the measurements for the pitch diameter were not given, it was
assumed that the measurement of column diameter would be used to make
an assumption for the pitch diameter. An estimation of 10% allowance was
then added to the pitch circle diameter column.
Number of bolts required N bolts given by the formula:
N bolts=
Dp
600
Where;
Ds = Internal column diameter = 1.5 m
Dp = Pitch circle diameter
= Ds + (10% Ds)
= 1.5 + 0.1 x 1.5
= 1.65 m
= 1,650 mm
Thus, Nbolts=
1650
=8.635mm 9mm
600
By taking the nearest multiple of 4, 12 is the nearest value to the number of bolts
required, Nbolts.
Step 2: Determine the required bolt area, Ab
The required bolt area, A given by the formula:
Ab= Nboltf b (
4 Ms
Dp -Wv)
Where,
Nbolt=Number of bolts required = 12 Bolts.
fb= Bolt design stress = 125 N/mm2
27
4 Ms
Dp - Wvessel)
Ab= Nboltfb (
1
41681754.48
(
12125
1650
=2601.12 mm
175.3 1 000)
4 Ab
=
42601.12
=57.56mm
With the addition of base rings, the bolt should be sufficient enough to distribute the
total compressive load to the foundation.
Step 4: Determine the total compressive load on each base ring per unit length,
Fbolt.
Given the formula:
Fbolt=
4 Ms
2
Ds
Wv
DS
Where,
Wvessel=dead weight of vessel with heads = 175.3 KN
Ms=Bending moment in skirt = 1681754.48Nm
Ds=Internal column diameter = 1.5m
28
Fbolt=
41681754.481000
2
1500
175.31000
=989.38N/mm
1500
Fb
fc103
Fbolt=Total compressive load on the base ring per unit length = 1,196.40N/mm
fc=Maximum allowable bearing pressure on the concrete foundation pad bearing
2
pressure 5 N/ mm
Lb=
989.38
510 3 =0.1978mm
Due to the large base ring width, a flared skirt shall be used as an alternative to the
design.Therefore, the requirements and assumptions for the new skirt are:
Flared skirt bottom diameter, Ds = 2.5 m = 2500 mm
Bolt circle diameter, Dolt= Ds+ (10% of Ds)
= 2.5 m + (1.5 0.1 = 2.5 m + 0.15 m
= 2.65 m (Assumed)
= 2,650 mm
Dp
Number of bolt, Nbolts= 600
= but , D'p=D's+(10% D s)
D'p=2.5+(10%2.5) = 2.75 m
= 2,750mm
29
N bolt=
2750
=14.4mm
600
For Ds = 2.5m
Step 1: Determine the skirt base angle, s.
Skirt base angle, s (With Ds =2.5 m) given by,
sDs
D
Ds
s= 0.5()
1
tan
2.5
0.5(2.51.5)
s=
= 78.7
tan1
Step 2: Determine bolt spacing.
Bolt spacing given the formula:
Dbolt
Bolt specing =
Nbolt
Where,
Dbolt'=Bolt circle diameter = 2650 mm
Nbolt'=Number of bolts =14.39
2650
bolt specing=
=577.8 mm (satisfactory)
14.4
30
1
4 Ms
Wvessel
Ab= Nboltfb
( Dbolt
)
Ab= 14.4125
41681754.481000
( 175.31000 )) = 255.2 mm2
2650
Step 4: Determine the total compressive load on each base ring per unit length,
Fbolt.
Given the formula:
4 Ms
Fbolt= Ds
2
Wv
+ Ds
Where,
W vessel= dead weight of vessel with heads =175.3 KN
Ms= Bending moment in skirt = 1681754.48Nm
D's=Flared skirt bottom diameter=2.5m =2500mm
Fbolt
=
41681754.48
2
2500
175.3
2500 =365 N/mm
Fbolt
Lb= fc103
fc=Maximum allowable bearing pressure on the concrete foundation padBearing
pressure = 5 N/mm2
365
Lb= 5103 = 0.073mm
Step 6: Determine the actual bearing pressure on the concrete foundation,
Given the formula:
f'c=Fbolt'/(Actual width)
33
34
ADU
35
36