Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Introduction
1.1 Background:
1.1.1 Freeform structures:
There has always been an exciting trend of transparent freeform architecture
which allows architects to make organic forms close to nature. Constant
development of software programs has made it possible to easily generate desired
freeform shapes. The 3-dimensional (3D) designing tools and numerical tools have
simplified the steps of producing such complex surfaces which involve defining
parameters, geometry algorithms and logic. But the construction of these complex
structures in reality can be challenging and can involve risk factors such as cost of
manufacturing and buildability issues. The freeform shape generated using
software programs are geometrically processed by dismantling the surface into
discrete parts and individual panels so that regular elements and standardized
building components can be used to build the structure in reality. If the surface is
not processed this way, then the construction components required to build the
surface need to be bent or twisted to assume the intended shape which may in turn
rule out the functionality of the building envelope. Therefore, the complex
freeform design is rationalized so that the surface can be divided into a fine mesh
in such a way that standard parts can be used in the construction. After
rationalizing the complex design, a geometry is defined which is the closest
interpretation of the main design, but consists of straight segments in place of
curves. Some notable examples are mentioned as follows:
a. Zlote Tarasy Warsaw
Fig 1 Main entrance at the ground level, approaching from the station
[17]
The structure is a freeform roof which encloses the central shopping area in
Warsaw, Poland. The area of the surface is 10,200m 2 consisting of several spheres,
with convex and concave transitions. The form was discretized into triangular
mesh, and the mesh design was fine-tuned so that the roof appears as a uniform
mesh with constant sized members. The fine-tuning resulted in the development of
continuous triangulated grid structure of hollow rectangular steel sections which
were 200mm deep and 100mm wide. Their thickness varied from 5mm to 17.5mm
depending on the forces in the member.
and node geometry was attempted, only a small level of standardisation was
achievable and had negligible advantage in terms of cost. The node was the most
complex part of the mesh design as it had to transfer unique combination of axial
forces, shear forces and bending moments from one side of itself to the other.
b) British Museum
The Great Court at the British Museum, London is a good example of freeform
structure. The area of the roof at the Great Court is around 6000m 2 with the
circular Old Reading Room in the middle of the Great Court. It has a dome shaped
geometry which is particularly optimized to fit the constraints of the existing
museum building from which it derives support. To develop the net geometry, a
special form-finding process was used by structural engineers. The maximum
possible glass panel with respect to size and weight of the steel support structures
dimension was the determining factor of the nets geometry.
The net is made of 4878 welded hollow edge section members and 1566
nodes which are all unique depending on their offset position from the Reading
Room. Also, all of the 3312 glazing units are of different sizes. The boundary of
the structure is a ring beam that rests on the existing stone wall of the surrounding
building.
Fig 8 shows the close up view of one of the nodes which were used. Fig 11 shows
the fabrication process of a node.
High performance insulated glass panels are installed directly to the steel
members. All computer modeling data could be applied to the fabrication process
without human intervention.
Fig-13 Interior view of autogenerated mesh(left) and result with scripted tools
(right) [19]
The resulting average member length was 2.30m and the connection between the
members were defined by 6-member nodes which was star shaped. The node to
which the beam members are welded was burned out of a thick steel plate. The
thickness of the plates was adapted to different loading condition.
The structure was supported by scaffolding during erection which allowed to
adjust the position of nodes according to required tolerances.
1.2 Motivation
The use of Point Fixed Glazing system has shown to increase the transparency of
the glass structure as the glass panes are held only at a few points unlike the edge
support provided by the frames. The point fixed glazing can also cover very large
areas without the need for interference of slab edges and columns for support
which is another reason for the increase in transparency. There can be huge
advantage when such a structure is used to cover large areas like atriums,
exhibition halls, canopies etc. where light and transparency are quite important
factors. There could also be a possibility of using doubly curved panels as the
support is offered at points unlike the edge support and thus bending or twisting of
frame will not be necessary. In this case, the surface would have a much closer
resemblance to the original design. But when the Point fixed systems are used in a
free form structure, there could be a need for customization of the components
used in the system due to the complexity of the surface. The standard available
components of the point fixed systems may not be suitable to be applied to the
panels in the freeform structure. Therefore, there is a need for customization of the
point fixing systems according to the shape of the structure. And to manufacture
these customized components by traditional methods will be tedious and thus there
is a need for investigating other manufacturing methods which will be more
feasible in the case of mass customization. And as there has been tremendous
development in the field of additive manufacturing, the solution to the
customization problem could be solved. A research conducted at Loughborough
university titled Development in Construction-Scale Additive Manufacturing
Processes clearly shows us the relationship between unit cost per production and
the number of parts produced, for the case of AM and Injection Molding.
How can a possible change in the shape of a spider bracket occur when used
in an irregular structure?
Chapter 3:
How is a spider bracket traditionally manufactured?
How can the conventional manufacturing procedure prove to be a
disadvantage when mass customization of the spider brackets is required?
Chapter 4:
What is Additive Manufacturing?
How is Additive Manufacturing categorized based on technology used?
How is Additive Manufacturing categorized based on application levels?
Which is the best way to use Additive manufacturing to produce the spider
brackets?
Fig-16
Fig-17
There are many types of Point Fixed Glazing Systems which consist of four main
basic components as follows:
a)
b)
c)
d)
Glazing Panels
Bolted Fixings
Glazing support attachments
Main Support structure
Fig 18
These components are discussed briefly in the following sub-chapters.
2.1.1 Glazing Panels
As a safety measure, the most commonly used glass panels in the Point
Fixed Glazing systems are toughened glass or laminated glass. The reason to use
safety glass panels is due to the high stress concentrations caused by the point
supports. The stress tends to be greater at the mid pane or mid edge stress due to
in-plane loads like self-weight of the panel, and out of plane loads like wind load.
The stresses at the holes or the deflection of the glass pane are often considered as
main factors when the thickness of the glass is decided. The joints between the
glass panes are made watertight by the use of sealants like silicone.
2.1.2 Bolts
Bolts act as connection devices which transfer the loads from the glass panel
to the glazing support structure, usually by bearing. They provide support to the
glass panes by transferring the self-weight of panes to the glazing support
structure. The basic types of bolted fixings available are listed as follows:
a) Fixed Bolts:
These types of fixings transfer both the in-plane loads and out of plane loads
directly through bolt and glass interface. These fixings rely on the inherent
strength of the glass panes, and will not allow for rotation under out of plane
loads, which results in transfer of varying amount of moment into the glass.
The fixing can be either countersunk or straight. However, the countersunk
bolts allow the bolt head to be in the same line as that of the outer surface of
the glazing. Fig 19 shows the fixed countersunk bolt and glass connection
[5].
Fig-20 Fixed ball joint for countersunk glass holes (Faraone R92) [22]
Fig-21 Fixed ball joint for straight glass holes (Faraone R93) [22]
The above Fig-20 and Fig-21 are the examples of the fixed bolts produced
by the Italian company named Faraone. As mentioned, the joint R92 shown
in Fig-20 is a fixed joint for countersunk glass holes, and the joint R93
shown in Fig-21 is a fixed joint for straight glass holes.
b) Articulated Bolt Fixings:
These types of bolts have a spherical bearing surface which is able to
accommodate rotation of the fixing to glazing support structures. The head
of the fixing can rotate freely on its stem. The bolt assures no bending load
is applied to the glass, unlike the fixed bolts. Due to this property, these bolts
can be used with large glass panes to be fixed with flexible support systems
like cables. Fig-22 shows the fixing of the articulated bolt to the glass [5].
Fig-23 Articulated ball joint for countersunk glass holes (Faraone R10) [22]
Fig-24 Articulated ball joint for straight glass holes (Faraone R20) [22]
Above Fig-23 and Fig-24 are examples of the articulated bolts produced by
the Italian company named Faraone. As mentioned, the joint R10 is an
articulated joint for countersunk glassholes, and the joint R20 is an
articulated joint for straight glass holes.
Fig-25 Edinburgh Festival Theatre faade system (left) and its element detain
(right)
(Use of truss support system) [4]
Fig-26 Atria Mall Mumbai glazing system (left) and its faade detailss (right)
(Use of cable support structure) [4]
Fig-27 Glass Faade of the history museum, Luxemburg(left) and its faade details
(right) [4]
(Use of Glass fin support system)
2.1.4 Glazing Support Attachments
The glazing support attachment provides mechanical support to the glazing
panels and transfer loads to the main support system. They also provide relative
adjustment of the panels in position. The structural function of the glazing support
attachment is to transfer applied loads like wind, snow etc. acting on the glass
panels to the support structure and also resist the moments due to internal forces.
Glazing support attachments can be of many forms like angle brackets, Spiders,
Pin brackets and clamping devices. However, the most common types of Glazing
support attachments are the spider brackets.
2.1.4.1 Spider Brackets
A spider bracket is usually a four arm fitting system which supports four
glass panes at adjacent corners on the glazing grid and ties them back to the
support structure. Spider brackets can also be of one, two or three arms depending
on the number panels it is required to support.
bracket is fixed to the support structure using suitable fittings which allow depth
adjustment and therefore compensate any possible dimensional differences and
thus assure perfect coplanarity of different glazing panels.
P
As it can be seen in Fig-30, the slots marked as P and Q have circular slots which
are slightly oversized to allow movement in two directions. The slots marked as R
and S are provided with horizontal slots so that they can support the weight of
vertical or sloping glazing, while allowing horizontal movement.
In order to generate the spider design for an irregular glass structure, the following
conditions were followed:
a) The guide for a spider glazing system supported on a steel tube structure
provided by Faraone SRL was used as a reference.
Fig 33
Fig 34
Fig 35
d) The spider bracket is assumed to be fixed to a steel tube structure by means
of a steel accessory as shown in Fig-36.
Fig-36
The slots at the end of the spider arms are oriented in such a way that they
face the part of the glass which they have to support.
e) An algorithm is generated in such a way that when the point 1 which is the
point of meeting of all the four panels(fig) can be moved in Z-direction
while the points 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 remain in the same position. Three
different positions of point 1, and the shape of the spider bracket obtained
due to these three positions were considered for this study. The three
orientations as follows:
Orientation 1:
f) When all the points remain on the same plane, then the spider will assume
the standard shape which can be called as a standard orientation and is
shown in the below figure:
1
6
9
8
7
Fig-42 Orientation 1
Fig-43 Orientation 2
Fig-44 Orientation 3
X-dimension
(mm)
352.0
341.7
311.8
358.3
Y-dimension
(mm)
352.0
345.4
315.1
354.8
Z-dimension
(mm)
50.0
87.1
69.2
199.5
In the above comparison, we can clearly see the possible differences in dimensions
among the different orientation of spider brackets resulting due to the change in the
surface geometry of glass. In the following chapter, the traditional way of
manufacturing of the above spiders will be discussed. In all the following chapters,
the terms Orientation 1, Orientation 2, Orientation 3 and Normal Orientation will
be used to refer to the above spider brackets mentioned in Table-1.
3.3 Producing the spider brackets using the Lost-wax casting process
In this section, the manufacturing of the 3 orientations of the spider brackets
obtained in the section 2.2 along with the normal orientation of the spider is
discussed based on the steps mentioned in the section 3.2.
1. In order to produce the wax pattern of the spider brackets, a master die is
produced using preferably a low melting point metal. This can be done by
machining, or by deriving it from a master pattern, which is the replica of
the Spider bracket to be manufactured. The following figures show the 3D
models of the master die for the different orientations of spider brackets
created using the software Inventor by Autodesk.
Fig-46 Mold pattern for the normal orientation of spider created using
Autodesk Inventor
Fig-47 Mold pattern for Orientation 1 of the spider created using Autodesk
Inventor
Fig-48 Mold pattern for Orientation 2 of the spider created using Autodesk
Inventor
Fig-49 Mold pattern for Orientation 3 of the spider created using Autodesk
Inventor
2. Wax pattern of the different orientations of spider brackets are produced by
injecting wax into the master dies. The generated wax pattern is fixed to a
sprue and runner system pattern using heated tools. The sprue is a channel
which will funnel the molten metal into the runner which will in turn guide
the molten metal into the cavity of mold.
4.
Fig-51 The wax pattern after being coated with refractory material and sand
(rendered in Rhinoceros)
4. Once the investment hardens, the ceramic covered wax assembly is kept
upside down in an oven and the wax is allowed to melt and run out. Thus the
ceramic mold is created whose cavity is in the shape of the spider bracket
required to be manufactured.
Fig-52 The investment mold after the wax is melted out (rendered in
Rhinoceros)
5. The ceramic mold is heated to a certain temperature so that the cracking of
the ceramic mold when coming into contact with molten metal is prevented.
The molten metal is then poured into the cavity and allowed to cool and
harden at room temperature.
Fig-53
6. Once the metal is solidified, the ceramic mold is broken off using techniques
like mechanical chipping or vibration, high pressure water jet or sand
blasting.
Fig-54
7. The sprue and runner system which is attached to the cast metal is sawed off
and machining may be required to eliminate any irregularities. The spider
brackets are then polished so that a shiny surface can be obtained.
Fig-55
3. Transfer to AM machine and STL file manipulation: The STL file which
describes the part is transferred to the AM machine, where some general
manipulation of the file is made so that it is of the correct size, position and
orientation for building.
4. Machine setup: AM machine is properly set up to the build process with
settings relating to build parameters like material constraints, energy source,
layer thickness, timings etc.
5. Build: This is mainly an automated process which the machine can carry on
without supervision. Superficial monitoring of the machine is needed to
ensure no errors occur.
6. Removal and Cleanup: The part is separated from the build platform.
Depending on the AM process used, removal of excess building part
surrounding the material or removal of support structures is required.
7. Post-Processing: This step involves stages of finishing the parts for
application purposes. Depending on the AM process used, this step may
involve abrasive finishing, infiltration, surface coating etc.
8. Application: The part is ready for use.
4.3 Process based Categorization
The categorization of different AM technologies is based on the different
methods by which a solid layer is generated and how the adjacent layers are filed
and bonded to form a part. The AM machines differ from each other on how each
layer is made, how they are merged and what material is processed. Different
physical effects are used to generate layers and bond them to the adjacent layer.
Based on these physical effects, the AM methods can be categorized as follows:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Polymerization
Binder Jetting
Material Extrusion
Powder bed fusion
Sheet Lamination
Direct Energy Deposition
Brief explanations about the above processes are discussed in the following
chapters.
4.3.1 Polymerization
another layer of powder is spread. This process is continued till the part iss built
completely. This method can be classified into the following categories:
a) Selective Laser Sintering: This process requires a temperature controlled
build chamber with a laser source. The temperature of the build chamber is
usually a few degrees lower than the melting point of the material which
reduces the dependency of laser to fuse layers together. The laser beam
contours each layer, and a roller spreads new material on the previous layer.
Whenever the beam touches the surface of the powder particles, they are
molten. The material solidifies due to thermal conductivity into the
surrounding powder, and thus a solid layer is achieved. The chamber is often
filled with nitrogen to maximize oxidation and end quality of model. Models
require cool down to ensure quality of fusion. Plastics or metals are used as
materials. The process of sintering metals is called Direct Metal Laser
Sintering (DMLS), where a wiper system is used to deposit metal powder
instead of rollers. Metal parts require mechanical removal from base and off
the support from the parts.
in a fully dense part after re-solidification. Shielding gas is used in the build
chamber to handle inflammable materials like Titanium or Magnesium. Built
in Auxiliary heating devices help prevent warping and distortion of parts.
c) Electron Beam Melting: In this process, the melting of the layers is achieved
by electron beam instead of laser. A completely sealed construction is
needed as the processing requires vacuum. The electron beam penetrates
very deep and the setup allows a very high scan speed. This process allows
high quality finish which makes it suitable for manufacture of high standard
parts used in aeroplanes and medical applications. The process also provides
models with very good strength properties due to an even temperature
distribution during fusion (Chua et al., 2010). The post processing involves
removing of excess powder and further cleaning and CNC work.
PROTOTYPING
TOOLING
MANUFACTURING
AM Processes
Direct
Processes
Rapid Prototyping
Rapid Manufacturing
Rapid Tooling
Indirect Processes
Indirect Prototyping
Indirect Manufacturing
Indirect
Tooling
epoxy is filled which will in turn assume the required shape after hardening.
The AM pattern is then removed.
c) Indirect Manufacturing: Indirect Manufacturing is a method where AM
patterns are directly used to produce Mold patterns from which the final
parts can be cast.
4.6 Selection of AM technology to manufacture customized spider brackets
As mentioned in section 4.5, AM technology can not only be used to directly
produce parts and prototypes but also can be used indirectly to assist the traditional
manufacturing processes. The traditional method of manufacturing the spider
brackets can be compared with the application based categorization of AM to
investigate on which categories can be used to manufacture the spider brackets.
The step by step lost wax casting of spiders is compared with the applicable AM
technologies as follows.
Steps involved in Lost-Wax casting of Comparable AM processes
Spider Brackets
Production of Master Die
Direct Tooling
Production of Wax Pattern
Indirect Manufacturing
Production of Ceramic Mold
Direct Tooling
Production of final Spider Brackets
Direct Manufacturing
4.6.1 Production of Master die using Direct Tooling:
a. How can it be done?
b. Does it have an advantage compared to traditional process?
4.6.2 Production of Wax pattern by Indirect Manufacturing:
a. How can it be done?
b. Does it have an advantage over traditional process?
4.6.3 Production of Ceramic mold by Direct tooling:
a. How can it be done?
b. Does it have an advantage over traditional process?
4.6.4 Production of spiders by Direct Manufacturing:
a. How can it be done?
b. Does it have an advantage over traditional process?
4.6.5 Comparison of all the above methods