Home Politics

Last Modied: Fri, Jul 08 2016. 09 55 PM IST

Five charts that explain the crisis in Keralas economy

A white paper released by state nance department says the nances of Kerala are in dire straits

Enter your email

Go Subscribe to our newsletter.

Nidheesh M.K.

The expectations are unusually high from Kerala nance minister Thomas Issac, who will present the rst budget of the Left Democratic Front
on Friday.

Bengaluru: The stark reality about Kerala is that there are no funds left in the state treasury for capital expenditures like
construction of roads or bridges, Kerala governor P. Sathasivam said, while addressing the maiden session of the 14th state
assembly on 24 June.
In this context, the expectations are unusually high from economist-turned-politician and Kerala nance minister Thomas
Issac, who will present the rst budget of the Left Democratic Front, which won the May assembly election in Kerala, on
Friday.
Ahead of the budget, the minister tabled before the house a white paper on the state economy last week, which says the
nances of Kerala are in dire straits. A close look at the white paper shows what went wrong in the economy of Kerala, a state
that is otherwise known for high levels of prosperity in many ways.
Slow pace of revenue growth

Like any other state, Keralas revenue comes from three major streamstax revenue, non-tax revenue and central funds. The
white paper notes that the pace of growth of the states revenue has been fallingthe ve-year average growth rate of total
state revenues was 17.2% in 2006-11, compared with 14.20% in 2011-16, as the above chart shows.
Interestingly, this is despite the signicantly higher Central funding the state received in the last few years because of the
devolution of funds for states as per the 14th Finance Commission. Receipts from the Centre to the state grew by 40% in 201516 when compared to the previous year, as per the nance department.
The reason why the total revenue receipts are not forging ahead at a relatively greater pace is because of the sluggish growth
of the states own revenue, as per the white paper. The share of the states own tax revenue in total revenue receipts fell from
64% in 2006 to 58% in 2016 after having peaked to an all-time high of 70% in 2011, it said.
Slow growth of commercial taxes receipts

High levels of tax collection are actually what sustains the coffers of Kerala, as per the nance department. They constitute
the lions share of the states own revenue mobilisation. However, after steadily increasing between 2008-09 and 2012-13 (in
2012-13, almost 51% of the states total revenue was from commercial taxes), it has been on a declining curve, so much so that
the 17.75% growth in this head in 2006-11 period has dropped to 14.26% in 2011-16.
Huge increase in non-plan expenditure

Despite the inability to generate high levels of revenue, Kerala seems to be spending way out of its pocket. The white paper
points out the high levels of non-plan expenditure as an indicator of this trend. Between 2013 and 2016, the non-plan
expenditure of the state, after leaving out salaries, interest and pensionwhich are committed liabilitieswas at the highest
levels in the last decade, it said.

Evidently one of the factors that aggravated the nancial crisis during the tenure of the previous Government has been the
failure to control avoidable Non Plan Revenue Expenditure, said the paper.
Cash reserves in the treasury

Kerala chief minister Pinarayi Vijayan admitted in an earlier interview to Mint that the state is scally weak.
Weak would be too modest a descriptor, if cash reserves in the treasury is any indicator of a states scal health.
Between 2011 and 2015, the treasurys closing balance has nosedived from Rs.3,514.22 crore to Rs.142.65 crore, the last decades
lowest level. The treasury balance has been recorded as Rs.1,643.99 crore in 2016, but this, the white paper argues, is a result of
payments of approximately Rs.1,800 crore blocked at the treasury and the government levels. Issac has argued in the ongoing
assembly that former nance minister K.M. Mani showed a positive cash balance through this way, while in reality the state
was maintaining a negative balance in 2016. Mani has denied this accusation.
An almost empty treasury is worrying for the new government also because the state has about Rs.10,000 crore immediate
liabilities to meet in the short term, said the white paper.

Missing the bus on scal goals

As per the scal responsibility frameworks implemented both at the state and the Central levels, Kerala was supposed to
manage its revenue decit (RD) and scal decit (FD) to gross state domestic product (GSDP) at 0% and 3% respectively, said
the white paper.
While RD is the difference between the net income generated, and the net income projected, FD is the difference between a
governments expenditure and revenue, excluding its borrowings.
Successive governments in Kerala were trying to achieve these scal goals but after 2011 such efforts seem to have lost track,
said K.N. Harilal, former planning board member and economics professor at the Center for Development Studies.
This is the most worrying aspect about the economy right now, he said. Both FD and RD had shrunk to their lowest levels in
this millennium in 2011, but are expanding after that, Harilal said.
The particularly low numbers of 2016 are because the government was really short of cash and could not nance any
expenditure, he said. So, it should be seen as the enormity of the problem rather than as no sign of relief, said Harilal.
Nidheesh M.K.

TOPICS: KERALA ECONOMY

MORE FROM LIVEMINT

KERALA BUDGET

WHITE PAPER

P. SATHASIVAM

THOMAS ISSAC

MORE FROM LIVEMINT

What the Donald Trump intelligence dossier controversy is all about
Kerala nance minister Thomas Issac unveils book on demonetisation
Davos elites struggle for answers as Donald Trump era dawns
How Aryabhata got the earth's circumference right
GST timeline derailed, but direction unchanged
READ MORE
Paul McCartney sues Sony/ATV for Beatles music rights
Where does India stand on individual tax rates?
A comedy about classical music nally nds its metre

First Published: Fri, Jul 08 2016. 11 31 AM IST

EDITOR'S PICKS

Has Amazon overestimated the size of Indias e-commerce market?

Chandras true test will be shutting down Tatas loss-making businesses: Aswath Damodaran

Urjit Patels brieng leaves MPs no wiser about demonetisation

FROM THE WEB

Sponsored by Revcontent

I Make Rs 7560 Daily! Working

From Home

How to Make Rs.45000 Per Week

Without a Job in Chennai

A Couple from Chennai Makes Rs.

300000/month

CareerTimes

CareerTimes

CareerTimes

Chennai Girl Gets 4 Shades Fairer

In Just 2 Min by Using This 1
Crazy Method!

Fast Weight Loss! 30kg Decrease

In 1Month Is Easy! No Diets Or
Sport Are Needed!

Investing In Mutual Funds

Without Online Financial Advisor?

Dr. Ankur Walia

Thehealthsite

ArthaYantra

HOME | COMPANIES | OPINION | INDUSTRY | POLITICS | CONSUMER | LOUNGE | MULTIMEDIA | MONEY | SITEMAP

Subscribe | ContactUs | MintCode | Privacypolicy | TermsofUse | Advertising | MintApps | AboutUs | Syndication | MintonSunday | RSS |
HindustanTimes | Desimartini
Copyright 2017 HT Media Ltd. All Rights Reserved