Author's Accepted Manuscript

Subtypes of psychotic-like experiences are

differentially associated with suicidal ideation, plans and attempts in young adults
Carina Capra, David J. Kavanagh, Leanne Hides,
James G. Scott

www.elsevier.com/locate/psychres

PII:
DOI:
Reference:

S0165-1781(15)00248-6
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.psychres.2015.05.002
PSY8877

To appear in:

Psychiatry Research

Received date: 30 July 2014

Revised date: 30 April 2015
Accepted date: 2 May 2015
Cite this article as: Carina Capra, David J. Kavanagh, Leanne Hides, James G.
Scott, Subtypes of psychotic-like experiences are differentially associated with
suicidal ideation, plans and attempts in young adults, Psychiatry Research, http:
//dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.psychres.2015.05.002
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for
publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of
the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and
review of the resulting galley proof before it is published in its final citable form.
Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which
could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal
pertain.






 























 
  
a

Institute of Health and Biomedical Innovation and School of Psychology and Counselling,
Queensland University of Technology, Kevin Grove, Qld, 4059
b
Metro South Addiction and Mental Health Service, Rehabilitation Academic Clinical Unit PAH,
Woolloongabba, Qld, 4102
c
The University of Queensland Centre for Clinical Research (UQCCR), Herston, Qld, 4029
d
Metro North Mental Health RBWH, Herston, Qld, 4029


 

 !"#

$#!# %#%
"##&"#'%

(#%&#)*+,


 
 
 %-#./0 12 3.
"#% ""#3##.3% 1
-##"%3# %454*"%"6
#
"% %1/-4+0
 1- 4+2 1
" # "# #0 2 "%!0 !2$7
1/0$12"## %
"#%%#3#
8"###3"/"9"#
"#%%%02"##02%
##%"#%#%  !
"9" "".#

$133%" #

."#%3%%-#./ "#
 #"%" %
 1- 4+ 1
3.#"#%


Highlights

" # 1provide significant unique contributions to the prediction of lifetime suicide
risk in young people.

PA and PI subscale were associated with suicidal risk, BE was not, demonstrating the
."#%3%%-#./

Youth who endorse PLEs should have a thorough risk assessment for suicidality.
#%
3".%"# 1"## ".
(""%"
 1- 4+3##""



 
%-#./"# "" #%"
 1- 





  



! 



"# "#"3#3:
  """# # "0;.#
<**=> #.8"<**?2
3"##"
"#.#/ ##

%#### ""#%0$"

#<*44>;.#<**=2!%"#"#%"
###" ""# 
##
# #"####%0$"#
<*44>;.#<**=> #.#<**?2 (#%
%"
".
%""#"
#

 
$%!&'
#

()*


 
$%!!+


%-#./0 12" ###"#"#
" #%""3%%
 1"##"#"##%#%
##"#34<-#5<=@"%
##%""#0##
<*44>A#<**,2
1.####"%
/%" "0
#<**<>B#<*4?>
C##<**=2
#"3" ####"
#" 3."##
0B#<*4?>###<*4)>8#<*4+>;#<**=>
#<*442B""3-#
3."#% 13##% 1
 3#### #0
#<*4*>C#<*44>D"#<**,2#0<*4*23
3$71/0$12 "%!0 !2" #

"% %1/%#0
 1- 2

#%##%##"

3 "# #%0 2#B"
3 3%### #
(3#"%3 13%
#### # ".3#/
% 1##%3##".
#%""%/# 3 1" %
#"#%3%##.
"#%%###/" "C#3
##" #3#0<*4*23
%## 13"# 3"##
:""

$

,


$ !



-

3" 3 "<*44 "<*4<"#

&"#'%(#%"#3## %3 ##"

3#3"%
"##0 .#2##'%#3
"#"#9"#"%E
"""#"/F!% ""#
#"%%#.
#"%3

(%39"!%##3

#". / #"%024G
02 #"1#>02 #>02
 %## 3
33 <H1##3 
'%F"61
0;44*****4=G2


$ $

,





(
"% %1/I #0
 1- 2<*-

#"# 1#""# #"%

 7/#.%)-.
#0JKJKJKJ#%#3%K20$#<**G>D"#
<**,2!#%-#."#)<-

 10#<**<2I" 3#%0C#
#<**=23"#%8#(.%
" #3## 3 #3#
"0#<*4*>
#<*4?>C#<*442(
"4+-
 1- 4+3#%# %"0
#
<*4?2(
 1- 4+3#%0LM*G,2 ##
""" # !0+2$10G2 0?23
#""<*-
 1- 0$#<**G2(
"""#%( #4

&""#;#"%8##C## 

0"#$""<**=2"#%(9"3J
%"0%"#202"#%" ""N02#
"N02"N("%#. "#
/""
" "3"GD"6.$""%
0D$6>0$#<**<22(#""9"% 

 %"0?*%2##
 %"


0#"#%2

3# B"#"#"02#02
0202"#%
#"02O+*'
02+*-4**'
024**-4+*'
02P4+*'
B#%%
## #3 %#9"9""
E%QE%%"#% ###NF
("%##"#
#04*>##<**<2 "
3#"#% #3 """

$&


 

#%"!$8 <<H(9"%"##

0( #423#3#%%#%"%

"#%#.# #3"#%
3"#%#%#"#%3
/# #302"#%02"#

#0 "202"!3#%

#"#%"" "#%%
 %"3/
"4-<?-,4*-4,<*-?,R)*(#
3#"#%/%"#"#%
%####%#""
 1- 4+#
" #3/"
."" #
# #"###3"
3 #33#%#3#"#%
 "###".## #3
"#"#%"##%;#".3"
 #;#.. "-6<3"/#
3
 #0E"##F2!*02402

&

- 

& !


 

A4G,43"."%454*0,*@2"#%

(3<<40
M+42%G5@04<4=23#;#%##
04+=?,,@2#4<%":"#%
0=4++<@2"##3
# "#%4+@0<)2%/"?*%0( #
42( #<"#" %

#44-?+@#"##" 3

  9"
SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
!( #4< "
SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
& $

*



8 # "###3#

"#%0( #?2(
 1- 4+" ###%  !

#3#"#%/"#"3
"##33
"#%3 "9"/3"#%
"3"#
SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
!( #? "
SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS


& &

,









"###/#%%###

#%# %"$1 

 !
 1- 4+" #;#..6-9"4G5@0O**42( #)
3#%%###  !
 %"# "

"#. #0#."

/2

###
0""#%2#3( #)B"
  ! "3"##0
"#%2 %?*@<5@#%!
"  ! %54@?)@#%
 " "#%9" 
# " ##%.3#%
"#%%####% "#B#%
" 7/
 1- 4+3
3.#"##


SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
!( #) "
SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS


.

  


("% 3%-#./

"# #"%#"#%3

#:"/#%%#
###%#""
%"%##
 13"# 3"##
:"" 7/ "".

(""%F"#33" 1

""
 10#<*4*>C#<*44>D"#
<**,23"#" ##3"
/""#%3" #
#33B/# 
#0<*4*2D"#0<**,2" !$133
"3"%"
 1- 4+F ! 
" #33#".
A""%" 1"#% #
.%#" "3"## 3 1
"#% "%"#3
"#"# 13".
"##%3%-"3%##%#%Q
-/"#%0##
##<*4)>##
#
<*4?>8#<*4+2(3(3"%
##
#
0(

>;M<<5?2"45-4G%3"#
-"%/3#/.
"#%##3"3
-" 10###<*4)2##%"%444<
# ""?)@3%/
%#% #"" 9"4<0A6
?<5G>,+@
!4*)?-4*<)420###<*4?2C##"#
"%4=,5#" 1#."""#%

4%##3"#3  1%##3

#%.."0A64<=4,+@
!)*<)*==2
""04*2""33" #
 "#". 
##%# "#% 1!# #
#"%% "
 1- 4+" # 
##%3
3" #%3##
" #0$1 ! 2"" # 
3%#%3" #
#
 1-<*0#.Q%Q# #20#<*4*>
C#<*44>D"#<**,21/3 1
3". "#3"#9"
" 1#B"""#"
"
 1- 4+## 3" 1
"
("%"#"%#%""# "3
#-#"0
#2".383
#"%3#####4<%"
# "#"6##
3 #%#"%3"#
"#B"""%F#%
%####""
"%#-"%
% 

 %# %%""#3

"0###<*4)>8#<*4+2
" "3 " 3 1
"# "0B#<*4?>;#<**=>#<*442
!###%"#3%/3"
 ."# "#""##3
####"# %0##
##<*4)2 %
/ .."# "%"#
3##("# 3"
"%-""%""."#% 
"."#3 1
#%3".
%"# 1"## "#%".

(""%
"
 1- 4+3##""

/

-

8;#$D"668$38 B; 

<*4* %-#./#3
%"%##%""#7
644,<+=-<5+
"#$""<**=<**G#"%##3## 
"%"#!$012
 

$;
88"(" 1
6 <**<
6# #%4,,,%". "%9" "#
##?4??5-?)<
$7; 3#".;B##B  6
<**G
T#1#B"%
%/0
 1238#"%#7
6,+=5-,+
$"6
%3!
"C-(;#6
#
$#6B#"":A"
1
3.;%".-8%T

8 -T## 68
 ((T
8
;.8<*44("##"3#($
"# %%( "#8#4,,5)-G*



 <*4?$%-#.
/764),4*)-4*G

# . "##6
## " .<*4?8

""##-
%"#
( "#
!"
?)<<?-<?<


B6T
1 8$T"#B<**<

"#-##""%##
%##8?<54,-5<G
B
 "#688"6"#
8(1<*4?%#%%

7 %?=% "% %##8)?

<*GG-<*=5
##!
8<*44 %-#./#"#
7-."% %##8)44-5
##!
#8 <*4) %/
"#""#3"%C# %%4?4=)4==
##!
 #%C (
#;6%C

#T
8
C

8<*4? %%
"#.""% 8 %%
G*,)*-,)=
##!
#;C (C8"B7.

8
<*4) %/#####
"#%"# %" %##8))454+-45<)
#63
#187.
;C#1U#.%
<**<#"##%## %##8?<,+,-,G5
8(3(.  <*4+ %##
%/"""-"##-:"%
"#"##- #
%##8)+)<,-)?G
;.(;"D(;!"D((.(
!.38".;A.7.D<**= %-#./

3"### #- 

#4<-4+% %4<4?*4-?*G
;.8$$1 

$#6
<**="
"# 1#63?*4??-+)
#.88"8<**?
##"#%.
 
"+<)?-<5+
  #(T

8 <*44(
 3#"#-#./"#"
"764?<4,G-<*<;
8;
"#
1.!
;<**<1
% "#"# %##
8?<?)G-?+=
B#7-
#
88 "TT#.
#6."
(
#T8

A
68/3##8! #"T
"
.8"6#'<*44$
#"###"3%3

( "#
!" ?<?4,-???
A 6 8%-%!
#"#  <**,%
3-#%%""%
VV#% %##
8?,4G,-4,+
C#  C##;: $CAW
##88 <**=
1# "#%""#3-

%<4-% #"% %##8?,5<+5?)

C (CT## C86:.&C! 
#
A# T"#B
A <*44(""/%
%#%#---##7$"##
?G=+*-=5*
D";#$$.$". % $.
18<**, %#./"%##!#
""#%7"#;3
U# "# %%)?44=-4<=

0

( #4#

T #

80
20@2

B#%%##

G)40)5@2

"##%0'
2

OX+*

)=?0<G@2

X+*-4**

5*40?G@2

X4**-4+*
PX4+*

 1- 4+
(##

?)=0<<@2
<4404?@2


5=*0)?42

" #

*)50,?)2

!" #

)<G0<4G2

$1" #

<*=0<?=2

"#%

;

44*=05,@2

! #

?=+0<)@2



44G0G@2

?*-%"#%

;

4+=G0,,@2

! #

4,04<@2



+0*?@2






( #<;" # %"


3% 
;"

4-<
?-,
4*-4,
<*-?,
P)*




 
;0@2
4*)*05+@2
4,,04<@2
4=<044@2
5<0)@2
))0?@2
=?0+@2

1%
;0@2
4<,<0=*@2
4*G0G@2
=50+@2
)=0?@2
??0<@2
))0?@2

8
;0@2
4)5*0=,@2
=)0+@2
)40?@2
<)0<@2
4<04@2
4G04@2


( #?
#3#"#%4

F

 



*+

/

-*)

D"

-*)

6#"

*G

B#%%###

4+

-*5

B#%

 "

4+

%"

4G

"

45

 1- 4+(#

<)

$1" #

4<

 " #

<4

 !" #

<5

4
# #"#"#

"


















<
<
<

,?)
5+5
*5+

<G=
<+++
5,?G

$1" #
 " #
 !" #

<),
1
%%!

1
%%!

%%3




%&2

G<<

*+,

),*



%!2

1
%%!






***0**?2
*<50**G2
*<?0**?2


4**0*,)-4*52
4?*044<-4+*2
4<5044=-4?+2

44*04*4-4<42
4<?04*)-4)+2
*,40*G<-44+2

44G0*G5-4=*2
4?40*=G-4,G2
44<0*G<-4G+2

*450*<<2
*<G0*<42
*440*<?2

*4*0**+2
*<*0**,2
-*4*0*4<2




-?*40*)<2
***0**42
*4=0*4+2
*+=0*4?2

***
4<5<
)+)G

)==
+++
*5)

*+<
45,
*<+

"#Q#


 

!"

+4?4


4**0*,=-4*?2
**+
4<*0*=,-45<2
4)*
4G,04?=-<?42
4,+,

,,+
1 %%!

1 %%!

%$4




%!2

)<)


)G<
4,?
54=



1 %%!

=<<
<?G
1 %%!

-**=0**+2
*)=0*4*2
*??0**+2

*4=0**G2
*<<0*4?2
-**?0*452

*)*0*?)2
-**=0*?+2
-*540*)42




-+540*5G2
**?0**<2
*G50*<,2
*?<0*<<2

*,<0*=)-4*<2
45404?<-4,G2
4?)04<5-4+)2

<)+
<4,+
)*,,

44,04*+-4?52 G),
4<+0*,G-4542 <=)
*,G0*G*-4??2 **)

4),0*GG-<==2 4?,
,?0*)=-4=<2 **+
++0*<)-4<?2 <4)

"#

 

!"

5+4G


4*<0*,,-4*G2 4+5
<4)04<4-?G,2 5=+
4?G0*=,-<4<2 <*4

A###
0<)2M<<?4<
O**4>;#.. "6<M4G5

$"###
1"#
A6 
4
# #"#"#"
!$8 <<H%/;A861"#%0$1B!6(A6
16
1;
!;2$D/B#%!B#%%C!(
 1%8

 14+$1
 14+ 
 14+ !Q
6!(16!
!;0,+2
1(0*28Y!(1604**28Y(1 0+2
1 0<*2
A;T1610*2
A;T1610******42
!;'60********42Q8A
1Q(1 C!1 !;0*+2 A'(0*428!;1BB1
(0*26'10!;121;(6D81(A
062618AT81(A
062
Q!;(16
1 (!;
'
1Q 6!;(B!( 681(16'886D6(
(1 8B!

<
<
<

5

4<4<



<
<
<

4)?
=*4
4,,,



!

/0#2
B#%%
###0%2
B#%
O+*
+*-4**
4**-4+*
P4+*02
"

 
1%
8

 1- 4+

( #)("####"#%4

44=
1 %%!

1 %%!

%%5

*,<
=)*


<?=
=<,
4)?



1 %%!

<4<


%%3

4+5

"#%( #4
 1- 4+9"" #0
#<*4?2


&"
" #

 1- 4+
%"## "%"%
!
3" #N
%"##3% N
!

%"#%" "%3%N

%"#%%"N
%"###.%"#% "%"
N
%"###""#"
3%%".N
%"#"%" .3%
%"N
%"#"%"%"3N
%"" %"33#
3"#N
%"%""  .%"N
%"#%""#3
%"#N
%"#" #.##% 
9"N
%"3%"#N
%"#.3%"#N
%" :###FN

!"%>$1 7/> "# #


!
!
!
$1
$1
$1
$1
$1
$1
$1




"#%( #<'##"#%



/
8#
B#
B#%%
8###
D
;
6#"
#
 

"#%;Q(#0@2
;#
!


#

)?,Q4*G)0)4@2 <4,Q?=+0+G@2




?*5

<

<45

<4Q44G04=@2
,5Q44G0=<@2










?)*<

<

1 %%!

5+Q44G0+5@2

<G,Q44*=0<+@2 ,<Q?=+0<)@2
=<,Q44*=0G+@2 <,?Q?=+0G5@2

Z< 










+5?

5

)55

++,Q4*,<0+4@2 4,+Q?G+0+<@2

54Q44)0+)@2

))+Q4*,<0)4@2 4+?Q?G+0)4@2

)+Q44)0)*@2







8

=4Q4*,<0G@2

<4Q?G+05@2

=Q44)0G@2




GQ4*,<04@2

5Q?G+0<@2

*Q44)0*@2

4)?G

5

%$5

B#%
OX+*

<=5Q4*,,0<5@2 4*+Q?=?0<G@2

)GQ4450)4@2

X+*-4**

)44Q4*,,0?G@2 4+4Q?=?0?,@2

?,Q4450?)@2

X4**-4+*

<+<Q4*,,0<?@2

=4Q?=?0<4@2

4+Q44504?@2

PX4+*

4+*Q4*,,04)@2

)5Q?=?04<@2

4+Q44504?@2










+*44

4*

1 %%!

)GQ4*)0)+@2
4+Q4*)04)@2
4)Q4*)04)@2
=Q4*)0=@2
5Q4*)05@2
4)Q4*)04)@2















54,<

4*

1 %%!

G<Q44G05<@2
4+Q44G04?@2
44Q44G0,@2
5Q44G0+@2
5Q44G0+@2
GQ44G05@2















55)5

4*

1 %%!






















"

 
;"
4-<
?-,
4*-4,
<*-?,
R)*
1%
;"
4-<
?-,
4*-4,
<*-?,
R)*
8
;"
4-<
?-,
4*-4,
<*-?,
R)*

5=+Q4*?5055@2 <*<Q?5)0+5@2
4?+Q4*?504?@2 ),Q?5)04)@2
44GQ4*?5044@2 +4Q?5)04)@2
)*Q4*?50)@2
4)Q?5)0)@2
4,Q4*?50<@2
4,Q?5)0+@2
)*Q4*?50)@2
<,Q?5)0=@2

,*)Q4*G)0=)@2 <=<Q?=+0G?@2
5*Q4*G)05@2
?<Q?=+0=@2
)5Q4*G)0)@2
<,Q?=+0=@2
<GQ4*G)0?@2
4+Q?=+0)@2
<<Q4*G)0<@2
+Q?=+04@2
4+Q4*G)04@2
<<Q?=+05@2

,=GQ4*G)0,<@2 ?<)Q?=+0=)@2 =GQ44G0G)@2

)?Q4*G)0)@2
?4Q?=+0=@2 4*Q44G0,@2
<*Q4*G)0<@2
4?Q?=+0?@2
=Q44G0G@2
4?Q4*G)04@2
+Q?=+04@2
5Q44G0+@2
+Q4*G)04@2
GQ?=+0<@2
*Q44G0*@2
5Q4*G)04@2
+Q?=+04@2
5Q44G0+@2