Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
the most important function of law; hence, a law, or judgment or contract that is
obviously unjust negates the fundamental principles of Conflict of Laws.
Clearly then, English Law is not applicable.
SBMA v. Universal International Group of Taiwan
September 14, 2000, Panganiban, J.
Facts:
UIG and SBMA entered into a Lease and Development Agreement (LDA)
wherein SBMA leased to UIG the Binictan Golf Course and appurtenant facilities
thereto to be transformed into a world-class 18-hole golf course/resort. The LDA
contained pre-termination clauses which authorizes SBMA, after due notice to
UIG, to terminate the lease and immediately take possession of the property if
UIG commits a material breach of any of the contracts conditions.
SBMA wrote UIG, calling its attention to its failure to deliver its various
contractual obligations. UIG imputed the delay to the default of its main
contractor, FF Cruz, but committed itself to comply with its undertakings. The
following month, SBMA declared UIG in default. Six months later, UIG still failed
to satisfy its obligations so SBMA served a letter of pre-termination to UIG.
Shortly thereafter, the golf course was formally closed and SBMA took
possession of the subject premises.
UIG filed a complaint against SBMA for Injunction and Damages with prayer for
TRO and preliminary injunction. Trial Court granted UIGs prayer and ordered
SBMA to restore possession of the golf course to UIG. In a subsequent order, Trial
Court denied SBMAs motion to dismiss.
CA upheld UIGs capacity to sue, holding that SBMA is estopped from questioning
its standing. It also held that UIGDC1 and SBGCCI2 were real parties in interest
because they made substantial investments in the venture and had been in
possession in property when SBMA took over.
Issue:
Whether or not IUG has the capacity to sue.
Ruling:
As a general rule, unlicensed foreign non-resident corporations cannot file suits
in the Philippines. A corporation has legal status only within the state or territory
in which it was organized. For this reason, a corporation organized in another
country has no personality to file suits in the Philippines. In order to subject a
foreign corporation doing business in the country to the jurisdiction of our courts,
it must acquire a license from the SEC and appoint an agent for service of
process. Without such license, it cannot institute a suit in the Philippines.
However, after contracting with a foreign corporation, a domestic firm is
estopped from denying the formers capacity to sue. In this case, SBMA is
1 UIG International Development Corporation
2 Subic Bay Gold and Country Club, Inc.
estopped from questioning the capacity to sue UIG. In entering into the LDA with
IUG, SBMA effectively recognized its personality and capacity to institute the suit
before the trial court.