Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1
Although cost-effective, multi-tenant, Lower on-going reoccurring expenses In this paper, we will:
cloud-based disaster recovery (DR) such as co-location charges, power, and
solutions are available in the market- maintenance 1. Define the challenges that enterprises
place, many large enterprises have not yet face in adopting public cloud solutions
Increased efficiency for recovery time for disaster recovery.
adopted them. Limited adoption rate is and recovery point objectives
primarily due to concerns about security, 2. Describe the value that large enterprises
reliability, and performance. Greater speed to market does not can gain by adopting cloud-based DR
restrict growth in primary facility with services such as Amazon Web
Enterprises can reap the following benefits Entryway for organizations to gain Services (AWS) for disaster recovery.
from cloud-based disaster recovery vs. familiarity and skills with AWS and cloud
traditional. 3. Provide recommended disaster recovery
computing architecture patterns.
Save up to 85% in reduced infrastructure
capital expenditure for servers, storage,
networking, and physical data center
costs
2
ENTERPRISE CHALLENGES AND REQUIREMENTS
Enterprises face specific challenges in Rapid Spin-up of Standby Increasing Business Continuity
designing, deploying, and managing
cloud-based DR solutions that satisfy
Machine Images: Expectations:
their risk profile and business continuity Minimizing business disruption in the Enterprises are increasingly expected to
requirements. Specifically: event of a disaster requires an architecture provide round-the-clock service. High
that enables deployment of infrastructure availability demands are pushing enterprises
resources reserved for rapid recovery. to blur the lines between disaster recovery
Handling Large Oracle and Selection and management of reliable and uninterruptible business continuity,
SQL Databases: technologies for this purpose is critical for which demands more innovative and
business continuity and cost management. challenging solutions.
Deploying, replicating, and managing
large databases over long distances Facing these challenges, an enterprise-
presents a challenge in cloud computing. Change Management: level DR system must have the following
Enterprises must exercise care in characteristics and capabilities:
designing their DR architecture and Maintaining systems, software, and
selecting database deployment locations, services becomes a complex task for large 1. Ability to handle large, complex
replication technologies, database designs enterprises. Moving infrastructure to the enterprise-scale databases.
optimized for cloud computing, and data cloud does not remove this requirement
2. Robust network connectivity between DR
deduplication strategies for minimizing and change management must still be
and production infrastructure, as well as
database sizes. coordinated.
other critical data sources.
3. Ability to rapidly scale to facilitate
Network Integration: Lack of Cloud Computing testing and accommodate fluctuations in
Expertise: business activity.
One of the greatest challenges in cloud
4. Automated orchestration of systems to
computing is the need to minimize latency The rapid evolution of cloud technology
minimize human error and increase speed
between internal and cloud-based servers. outpaces availability of in-house subject
of deployment.
Integration usually involves deployment matter experts who can assist enterprises
of network optimization tools to monitor in solutions architecture, SLA negotiations, 5. Capability to provide large, permanent
and manage both internal traffic and and deployment. In addition to acquisition storage for both data and server images
traffic between in-house infrastructure and development of internal capabilities, in multiple zones to protect against the
and data centers. External bottlenecks enterprises often need external experts effects of regional outages.
are particularly difficult to manage since with much broader and in-depth 6. Access to expertise in designing,
they may be beyond the control of internal capabilities in cloud computing and deploying, and operating high-availability
IT staff. IP addressing and network data center optimization to develop and DR systems in the event of wide-scale
convergence is another challenge that implement solutions. regional disasters.
enterprises face. Network woes have been
eased with several AWS solutions such as
Elastic IP addressing, Virtual Private Cloud Recovery Model:
(VPC), and Route 53, which have made it Businesses will need to scrutinize all
easier to manage internet addressing across aspects of their disaster recovery approach
data centers and the cloud. even testing and overseeing all aspects of
the recovery scenario as a fully proven and
valid recovery event is difficult to achieve.
3
DISASTER RECOVERY ARCHITECTURES
Enterprises have different levels of leading service provides a cost-efficient enterprise backup software. Several vendors
tolerance for business interruptions and optimized DR capability. Smart DR are developing and optomzing backup
and therefore a wide variety of disaster offers three design methods which meet software integration with AWS such as
recovery preferences, ranging from the recovery needs of most enterprises Commvault, Veritas, Backup Exec, etc.
solutions that provide a few hours of using combinations of AWS services: Environments that are already virtualized
downtime to seamless failover. Accentures provide the best RTO with AWS due to ease
deep expertise with infrastructure design These solutions provide great versatility of integration.
and DR architectures along with AWS as they facilitate integration into current
environments by leveraging current
Internet
Optional Recovery
with EC2
VPN Connection
S3 Bucket
Scaling
with Objects
EC2 Recovery
Instances
AWS Import/Export Recovery/
Fail-Over Zones
5
DISASTER RECOVERY PILOT-LIGHT
The Pilot Light method satisfies most Figure 2: DR Pilot-Light
enterprise environments that require
comprehensive back-up, relatively fast On-Premise Infrastructure AWS Accenture/AWS DR
recovery, and redundancy. A Pilot Light
solution consists of an up-to-date core If failure is Request/ Recovery/Fail-Over Zones
detected Receive
infrastructure configured in AWS with Not running but
active when
the ability to quickly provision a full scale DNS/Proxy/Query Server triggered during
environment during a recovery process. Static Static failover event
DNS/Proxy/ Application
This method entails replication of tier Query Server
1 systems to AWS, as well as creation Application Server
Server
6
Network Layer:
Multiple AWS services and features
can address the challenges of network
integration and maximize business
continuity:
Mirror Replication
Actively Replicated
Database & Server
Database
7
Each layer builds upon the Management Layer:
respective Pilot Light layers and Although AWS has built many tools and
adds certain features, as well management features for disaster recovery
as limitations, that exist when scenarios, a warm environment adds several
layers of management and automation
building a comprehensive DR complexity that are solved by using third
environment. party tools such as Puppet Labs.
8
ENTERPRISE READINESS
A critical step toward successful adoption understanding of virtualization technology Finally, enterprise-readiness must include
of cloud-based DR is getting the enterprise also enables better planning and decision- acquisition of cloud computing skills
ready for disaster recovery in a multi- making in preparation for migrating to through training of internal staff and
tenant cloud environment. Preparedness cloud-based DR. Furthermore, being able to acquisition of cloud computing experience
involves developing experience in utilize computing capacity more effectively through hiring and contracting of external
virtualization technologies, optimizing both through virtualization potentially drives expertise. In addition to technical
internal network and external connection(s) centralization and efficient provisioning of expertise, the enterprise should develop or
to cloud resources, optimizing database computing resources as services to business acquire strong capabilities in defining and
implementations for cloud computing, units. Such a change usually requires careful negotiating enterprise-worthy SLAs for
aligning cloud security with internal planning and change management support. cloud-based services.
security policies and groups, and acquiring
deep cloud computing expertise. Optimizing network connectivity includes AWS allows you to test a DR scenario
procuring more robust connectivity both more often and at a lower cost than the
Successful adoption of cloud-based DR to the Internet and to internal network traditional model as there is no physical
solutions starts with aligning the enterprise resources, minimizing latency-inducing hardware to purchase, configure, and
IT infrastructure and functions with the bottlenecks, implementing dedicated maintain.
infrastructure services offered by AWS. connectivity to public exchanges, and using
Migrating to a virtualized computing content delivery services. Leveraging Accentures knowledge will
environment prepares the enterprise enable enterprises to prepare their
for cloud computing and also enables Minimizing the volume of data that needs decision-makers, environment, support
realization of the cost-saving benefits of to be transmitted through deduplication staff, and users for successful adoption of
virtualization technology, which include to remote DR resources is likely to result in public cloud-based disaster recovery.
flexibility, scalability, and more efficient cost savings, faster recovery speeds, fewer
utilization of computing capacity. Deep bandwidth bottlenecks, and lower chance
of data loss.
9
NetApp: Corporate AWS Direct AWS Simple
Data Center Connect Facility Storage Service
Private Storage for AWS is an enterprise
storage solution that optimizes data
replication between on-site systems and AWS Direct AWS Direct
Connect Connect
AWS. It uses an on-site storage appliance
to replicate via a dedicated connection
to NetApp Private storage within a Direct
Connect location. NetApp is leading in this
area with similar products from competitors
expected in the near future. NetApp Private Storage
10
Application Domain vendors for use. Services such as SAP Management Domain
RDS take management to another level
Zadara has created a separate private by automating and making a deployment Technologies within this domain attempt
storage cloud though AWSs Direct much quicker. to automate and simplify orchestration
Connect. It enables an enterprise to build a of cloud-based resource management to
Virtual Private Cloud Array (VPCA) within Oracle RAC is not supported by AWS minimize human error and maximize speed.
the Zadara private cloud and connect and would entail placing the RAC system
it to the enterprises AWS computing in an AWS direct connect facility to RightScale enables an enterprise to
environment. integrate with AWS services. deliver applications in public and private
Oracle Cloud Backup Integarating clouds that are resilient to scheduled
Technologies within this domain optimize RMAN with AWS S3, Oracle Cloud maintenance, unpredictable hardware
application performance to maximize user Backup module enables enterprises to failures, and occasional disasters, with
experience stream database backups to AWS S3 the ability to clone entire environments
using Oracle RMAN commands and and stage in another data center with
Riverbed Technologies: The Stingray one click.
Traffic Manager is an example of programs. Compared to on-site tape
cloud-based software designed to backup, this solution is more reliable Puppet Labs & Chef both offer IT
vastly improve application performance. since it is based on disk instead of tape, automation software solutions that
Stingray provides Web Content which is more accessible for restore help system administrators manage
Optimization (WCO), load balancing, operations, and cheaper in terms of infrastructure throughout its lifecycle,
improved scalability through offloading upfront capital costs. from provisioning and configuration to
TCP and SSL connection overhead, and Avnet Cloud Backup for Oracle patch management and compliance. These
built-in performance monitoring and Databases uses Oracle Recovery Manager solutions can easily automate repetitive
scripting. (RMAN) to enable database backup to tasks, quickly deploy critical applications,
AWS S3. and proactively manage changescaling
from 10s of servers to 1000s, either on-
Database Domain Zmanda For MySQL databases, a reliable premises in the cloud or both.
solution is provided by AWS partner
Safe and efficient replication of databases OpsWorks and CloudFormation
Zmanda through Amanda Enterprise
is a particular challenge for cloud-based automate the deployment for a VPC
backup and recovery. This solution
implementations. Solutions in this domain based stack on AWS. OpsWorkds is an
enables an enterprise to use AWS S3 as a
attempt to simplify and speed up database application management solution with
backup target from on-premises backup
backup and replication processes to automation tools that enable modeling
infrastructure using a browser-based
minimize risk of data corruption, network and control of applications and the
management console.
latency, and user experience degradation. supporting infrastructure. Both Opsworks
and CloudFormation integrate with Chef
Riverbed Technologies By caching and Network Domain and Puppet.
managing replication of databases from
in-house to cloud-based resources, Solutions within this domain attempt to
Riverbed Technologies Whitewater Cloud maximize access to, and efficient utilization
Storage Gateway appliance attempts to of, network bandwidth in order to maximize
mitigate these risks and ease adoption of application performance in the cloud
cloud-based DR. environment.
11
EXAMPLE
Company X has a combination of Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3 business applications. They can choose from the following options:
For Tier 1 with RTO and RPO For Tier 2 with RTO and RPO of For Tier 3 with RTO and RPO of
of <1 hour, the business would <4 Hours, the business would <8 hours, the business would
choose Warm DR and will have choose Pilot Light DR and will choose Cold DR and will have
the following: have the following: the following:
EC2 instances for all services running at Critical core elements of system already All data replicated into S3 bucket.
all times. configured. Initial data synchronization using in
In-house and cloud infrastructure EC2 instances running for critical house backup software or file transfer
load-balanced and configured for services. protocol via the web or AWS Import/
auto-failover, which is facilitated by Pre-configured AMIs for Tier-2 apps that Export feature.
AWS Route 53, Elastic IP addresses, and can be quickly provisioned upon failure. Pre-configured AMIs for Tier 1 and Tier
Elastic Load Balancing. 2 apps that can be quickly provisioned
Cloud infrastructure load-balanced and
Initial data synchronization using in- configured for automatic failover which upon failure.
house backup software or file transfer is facilitated by AWS Route 53, Elastic IP Incremental data replicated/synchronized
protocol. addresses, and Elastic Load Balancing. using storage gateway.
Incremental data replicated/synchronized Initial data synchronization using in- EC2 instances are spun-up from objects
using storage gateway. house backup software or file transfer within the s3 buckets.
Automation used for rapid failover and protocol.
spin-up of environment using Puppet Incremental data replicated/synchronized
Labs software. using storage gateway.
Automation used for rapid failover and
spin-up of environment using Puppet
Labs software.
As enterprise needs for disaster recovery progress toward a need for complete business
continuity, and while IT budgets for DR remain stagnant, enterprises can no longer avoid
considering cost-effective, multi-tenant, cloud-based disaster recovery solutions like AWS.
Enterprises must, however, appreciate and navigate the challenges presented in enterprise-
level cloud computing. Managing risks by partnering with Accenture to implement Smart
DR with AWS gives enterprises the opportunity to significantly improve disaster recovery
while taking advantage of the potentially significant cost savings. Accenture can help
enterprises transition to the cloud with our best practices and expertise along with market
leading AWS partners.
12
FURTHER INFORMATION
For further information or Written in collaboration with AWS solution
architects and business development leads.
comments on this article,
contact: Special thanks to:
Alejandro Flores
Emerging Technology & Innovation
alejandro.flores@accenture.com
Keith Linnenbringer
Application Modernization and
Optimization
keith.linnenbringer@accenture.com
Chris Scott
Emerging Technology & Innovation
chris.scott@accenture.com
Footnotes
1. Timothy Wood, Emmanuel Cecchet, K.K. 5. Jacob Gsoedl, Disaster recovery in the cloud 10. Henrik Rosendahl, Is Enterprise Cloud Backup at
Ramakrishnan, Prashant Shenoy, Jacobus van der explained, Storage Magazine-Vol. 10 Num. July 5, Economy Prices forReal?, accessed January 22, 2013,
Merwe, Arun Venkataramani, Disaster Recovery as 2011. http://www.wired.com/insights/2012/08/enterprise-
a cloud Service: Economic benefits & deployment cloud-backup/
6. Timothy Wood, K.K. Ramakrishnan, Prashant
challenges, University of Massachusetts Amherst,
Shenoy, Jacobus van der Merwe, Enterprise-Ready 11. Brandon Butler, Disaster recovery in the cloud:
AT&T Labs.
Virtual Cloud Pools: Vision, Opportunities, and Vendors jump in; Enterprises wade, Network
2. Disaster Recovery, Amazon Web Services LLC, Challenges, Gearge Washington University, AT&T World, accessed January 22, 2013, http://www.
accessed November 27, 2012, http://aws.amazon.com/ Research Labs, University of Massachussets Amherst. networkworld.com/news/2012/092712-disaster-
disaster-recovery recovery-cloud-262818.html?page=3
7. T. Wood, A. Gerber, K. Ramakrishnan, J. Van der
3. Glen Robinson, Ianni Vamvadelis, and Attila Narin Merwe, and P. Shenoy.The case for enterprise ready 12. Jim Cooke, Cloud Readiness for the Enterprise,
Using Amazon Web Services for Disaster Recovery, virtual private clouds. In Cloud Computing Journal, accessed January 22, 2013,
Amazon Web Services LLC, accessed November 27, http://cloudcomputing.sys-con.com/node/2086147
8. Proceedings of the Usenix Workshop on Hot
2012, http://aws.amazon.com/disaster-recovery
Topicsin Cloud Computing (HotCloud), San Diego, CA, 13. Announcing Amanda Enterprise 3.1, Radically
4. Karen Dye, Do Your Disaster Recovery Time June 2009 simple, intelligent and robust network backup and
Objectives Meet Your Business Requirements? , recovery, Zmanda, accessed January 22, 2013, http://
9. Rob Livingstone, When Disaster Thunders Through
Sun Microsytems, accessed April 24, 2013, http://i. www.zmanda.com/backup-Amazon-S3.html
the Cloud, accessed January 22, 2013, http://www3.
zdnet.com/whitepapers/BizContWP.pdf?tag=mantle_
cfo.com/article/2012/1/the-cloud_cost-of-disaster-
skin;content
recovery-in-cloud?currpage=1
13
14
ABOUT ACCENTURE
Accenture is a global management consulting, technology services and outsourcing
company, with approximately 275,000 people serving clients in more than 120 countries.
Combining unparalleled experience, comprehensive capabilities across all industries and
business functions, and extensive research on the worlds most successful companies,
Accenture collaborates with clients to help them become high-performance businesses
and governments. The company generated net revenues of US$27.9 billion for the fiscal
year ended August 31, 2013. Its home page is www.accenture.com.