Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Economics
Ethics
Session 5
1
Kerviel
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vf06zZi
Kvc0 Until 310
Virtue Ethics
6
Roots of virtues: Artistotle
7
Virtue Ethics
8
At work vs. at home
10
Rights, care and virtues
Rights: Care:
Individuals entitlement Special relationship
Legal, moral; positive, Question impartiality
negative
Reversability, Virtues:
universability Historical context
Conflicts of right Good virtues, vices
Eudaimonia
11
Comparison
12
From theoretical frameworks to..
philosophies or religions
On example: Buddhism
13
Short introduction to buddhism
Buddhist Belief and Living Ethics: Challenging
Business Ethics
by Case & Bhrom (2012), in readings
15
Ethics & Buddhism
17
Lay Buddhists, by contrast, agree to abide by five
precepts. These are rules of training to refrain
from: killing or harming living beings, stealing or
taking that which is not given; harmful speech;
sexual misconduct; indulgence in intoxicating drink
or drugs which confuse the mind.
Ethical conduct
18
Right action is not related to a moral absolute but
depends on the circumstance. It promotes non-harming
and compassion.
wrong
speech' would
include lying
(if intention to
deceive,
deception
etc.),
slandering,
Eightfold path harsh speech
and 'frivolous'
talk or gossip
19
From virtue ethics to Buddist ethics
20
Buddhist ethics & business
Formal (rigor)
Sincere,
procedural
22
Source: Fisher and Lovell, p. 100
Five Moral Principles
1. Utilitarianism
2. Rights
3. Ethics of Care
4. Virtue Ethics
23
Financial crisis: Winners and losers..
26
VRT
5. Distributive Justice
27
How to distribute wealth
or burden?
Tax the rich and better target the multinationals: The IMF has set off shockwaves
this week in Washington by suggesting countries fight budget deficits by raising
taxes. Tucked inside a report on public debt, the new tack was mostly eclipsed by
worries about the US budget crisis, but did not escape the notice of experts and
nongovernmental organizations (NGOs). ()
Guardian of financial orthodoxy, the International Monetary Fund, which is holding
its annual meetings with the World Bank this week in the US capital, typically calls
for nations in difficulty to slash public spending to reduce their deficits.
But in its Fiscal Monitor report, subtitled Taxing Times, the Fund advanced the
idea of taxing the highest-income people and their assets to reinforce the
legitimacy of spending cuts and fight against growing income inequalities....
The IMFs Copernican revolution is still in the twilight stage. In its report, the IMF
continued to push for a wider scope for value-added tax (VAT), a tax consumption
tax that some say is inherently unfair, and on reductions in public spending. 29
Case study: Caltex (3): What else?
Shareholders Managers
resolution
* Activities help
* Break relations Black workers
with SA (income increase, other
government or benefits)
Who benefits??
30
5. Distributive Justice
31
Distributive Justice (Fairness)
32
How Define Justice (Fairness)?
33
How to Define Justice (Fairness)?
1. (Strict) Egalitarianism:
Standard: people need same level of respect
equal benefits and burdens; same level of
material goods and services
Elaborations: political equality or economic
equality
34
Criticisms:
Moral: Needs, ability differ; unequal in
many respects;
Technical : Timing (when); Index
problem (how to measure) Solution:
bundle of goods or money
2. Welfare:
3. Resources (Dworkin):
Contribution (capitalism by
Velasquez) to social product
Effort
Free choice ;
Entitlement theory:
Object taxation (or any
imposed redistribution)
(1)
(2)
Voluntary
liberty of conscience
freedom of association,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZ7LzE3u7Bw
Criticism or questions to Rawls
46
GENERAL WELFARE
Utilitarianism
JUSTICE
Will the act lead to a
fair distribution of Who benefits from
benefits and burdens? the act? Who are
If it will cause burdened? Does the
inequality, will it act maximize the
improve the situation total net benefit to
of the least advantaged everyone concerned
persons? (stakeholders)?
RIGHTS
48