Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
OF :;f
f .,,"i
~":I
~
TABLE OF CONTENTS '~;i
"oz,
"
VOLUME 57, NUMBER 5 MAY 1984
'~
<;?;~J{': LETTER FROM THE EDITOR ..601
"')~~;l APA BOARDMEMBERSAND NATIONAL OFFICESTAFF. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 602
,z:;:f::'
"'!':;;~ PHILOSOPHYINTHESCHOOLS-ReportonaNationaISurvey-1982 5-i
;~";
";i, PROCEEDINGS 603
"C A. NewsfromtheNationaIOffice 603
~;;"
APAPublishesNewNewsletter 603
SpecialAnnouncement
ConcerningAPA Committees. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 615
APA FundDrive 616
Membership
Statistics. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 616
,; Second Eastern Division Ballot ...616
~ Philosophical Shopping List - July Edition. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 616
PhilosophyDepartments I nternshipProgram. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 616
Summer Mailing to Chairpersons ..617
PROCEEDINGSXeroxingProject. 617
B. MemoriaIMinutes 621
AlbertPerleyBrogan 621
HankSkoglund.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 622
BULLETIN.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 623
A. Conferences 623
B. Announcements.
...................................... 629
LETTERTOTHEEDITOR.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 699
INDEXOFPROCEEDINGS
VOLUME57 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 701
APAT-SHIRTINFORMATIONANDORDERFORM 707
~ ~ ("') ~ ~o-n~"o-::so"""~n~'" """r:.n~"'~o ~~... ~"'or:,"" 0\
~v ~ ~
- ~ z- ,. ~ 0 =r
~ ::s
~ '< ~ n ~ '< 0 ~ '< ;.;-
"',J:)< _. 0
-,...,,"~ - =r =r::s
0 0 0 ~'<~- =r ~ '0 ::s n 0
~n ~=r 0 ,.
0 =r... -
~ <'Ot;;".. "'~~... ~==r;J'" ~OQ::S::S ...~.'O -o~ ~=~::s~ 0
~~ ~ .B, g,~. :- a g, So~. ~ [ ~ ~!" ~ ~ g ~~' s. ~ ~ ~ 9:3.~ ;- -;:;~ ~ ~
:
'< ~ ~ Q ~ 5' 3 ] ~ '<
~. ~~ g~ ~ ...' e:: ~ ~ '"
~ ~ S~=r[]~.g ~
~ g ~ '0 ~ = go'l e.~ Q ~ ~ g 0" ; E. '0
5' ~ r-- ~ a~ ~ Soeo.,go3 ... ;:;; 5" ~,~ ~ ~ ~.?; =: ~ ~ ~ '0 ~ ~ g, ~ g ~.- ~
< ., ~ '0
... ~ ~o ~~ ~~=r"""""'::S 0"'-'='" .,OV;:r- "'::S
-<~-""=r: ... ~ '0 <...0
0 ... ... .., '0 '00 -' ~ ~ ... ~ n ... '" '" ~ ~ In' ... =-OQ ::s ~ ~ ., = ~ 0 ~
o ~OQ -, ~ OQ po =r ~
~ ~ _. ... ~ 0 ~ =r'" ..' ~ = S' ... =;. < ... OQ n '< ~::s ~ ,.
c::: ... 'iD'< e;
-,.3 ;;<: ~ ::s0:
3 ~,o ~,J:) ::s ... ~, '" ~ 3 '< ~ 0'0 Sog, =r 5" 0- ~ ~~ ..
g.~ g 5 0 g =r 0
~
~ ... _.,,_,~n=r...O ~ ~ ~ -~.,o~~oo~...~~o::s ...~.""
~ 0 ~ -,
=~0 =r ~ 0 ;J '" ~ ~ 0 =r n '" = '" Q. ~ ... <; -- ... ~ = ~ =r < 0
::s.., "'" < '" ~. = ~ '0 ~ 0- '" (6' 0 ... 0 ... ., ~ 0 ~ '0 == =r.. ~ '" ~ ...
'0 Q.0- 0-
~ ~o ... ~=r-'~~"""!::,"'So<; =rQ. ~ 0~ '<0 ::S
~~~5'r:'~="O5'o;';-". < S 0 ~a~::.
~... So ~ ~.'go g;: ~ ~ ~ ~ g~~ ['< ~ ~ ~ ~ a. 5 ~, .. ~ oa ~ s:~ g.OQ 0" ~ ~ g,~ ~ ... ~ ~..
~~ .". '<,< ~s~~~o~5"F=-'<@'O'~g."'~~s~...,~~s,:<'O~~ o o=:::.~
OQ ~ ... 0'" 0 .., 0 '" .. "'... <; ~ ~ ::s ... _. ~ - ~ -'" ... - 0
g'::sQ'O'..
::s 0 '-' 0' .., ~' = =::s ~ =r =- S ... '" ?; =r~ n == ~ _. ::s~ - '" Q.::s'... ~ ~... ~... So...
~ eo. ::s ~ ~ :=I n =r o ~ 0 ~ s: ~ -. 0 ';::;.;-~. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. !?; = [ OQ ';:: < S =r tic
'" '" '--.I ~ ~ ., po _. Q. '. co '" ~ ~ =r '.';:: ~" =r
~
~ <:5
. ~:=I -. -
'" ~ ~ ., 0 < ~ .. -"'.
-.., ..,,. = =- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 '"0 '" ~< ='~.- _._.~ - ;J "
no ~ ~<::s ~~-
3 ""<bo"
0.., ..", e, 6:::. ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ =' '"
~ 5' 5' ~ So~~-n~"""-
::sOQ .'" ... g ~ n' ~ <", g g: 0 ~...
; 3"'"
::s ~ ... "'--'0 -~- n-",n- ~~ ... -0n~ -;J OQ..<=r
~'O ~ ~ ~ 0 '" 0 ;.;- ~.. <:>.., ... 0 '" n' ~ ~ ~ 0'"
~ =r ~ '< r:, ... ~ ~ '" ~ 0 &;. '0 O!?; ".; =r = '< ~ 0 So
0 =r
~ =r~, o' 0 ~
=r=r'"~ ==... - - r: 0: ~~...~
-< ~ ~ ~ ~ -.. ...'< =r ~ ... 0- 3 -, ~ E.~'::s ~ = ~ .. ~ n ::s p. 0 ~ 0 ~. OQ '0
~ ~ ~ '-- =r1)Q 0 ~ 3 ~ 0 =r ~ ~ ~ ~ =r ~~ n~ ~ 0 OQ~ '0 -, ::s...'" r:, ~ > 0
'" 0 "J ~ ~' ~ ~ 3 ::s 0'" ~ ~ '0 =r ~ ~ ~ O::s 0 -, S' 0 Q. = <
g,- '" < 3 ~ '" ~ =r .. '0 OQ ~~ '00 nnO-,~ ~ 0 '" ~ N"'OQ '0
_v '-' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~
~
-... ... =r ... ~. to. 0" ~ N '" "'" ... ::s v -
0 =r t'i, =r _. ~ ~ ... ~ -, =;' -, = _. ... ;J.. '" ~ '< ~ ~ - ~... - =r ~ 0--
0'<
- -
~ ~n~ ~ '0
... "'=r<;"'~.
~ ~ ~
-
- _. '0"n::S~ OQ ~ ~ ~
...~~to. 0 0
... '0
- -... '"
~ ~ = ~><o
'" '<~~ ~
. ~
::so~...
~ '0 ... =r
.'" ~
~ "CI
~ ... -, '0
::s.. .. v ...
~ n ~ '< =r ~'" ..
~ ~ G"">< ~ O-OQ'"
;J ~ po
- ~
... ~ O' ~
~ ~ v~Q.OQ
~ ... '" -, ~ ... ~
~ 0
::s ~
;.;-
g~ ~ ~ ... 2 ~ g !?;'0 g So.1.Q ~ ~ ... g ... So g'!?; Q. '<
'0 ~' ~ g, =:~ ~ ~ '< ~ ~
OQ~ ...
=r ~
~ _';::n'. =r
,. -~::s~" o"'o~
... o ...~~~ =r",o .., 0"""~ ~. -. ,<""",:<
_. <;
...
...= 0' ><
!?;~~0- ~ ~.. eo.
~(6'~p:Z):!?;'<~n'8So~~n s. '" ... ~ 0 ",' '0 =r So ~. < ~ ~ '" ... -.' ~ ~... ~ = ~
~ ~.,' "'~33~~::s::.
=r,. 0 ~-3'~.. -~g:3 oga~
0 '"" n ~ ... "'. 5 =" =;' ~ =r po ~ ~ '< ~ - - ~ ~ ~ ~ '"
~ ~ ~. =r "'...~OQ"';J~~::S",
=r 0.. ~ <... '" ~~...~ _.0 ~ Q. -"'~;';-
'g" -; ~ ~ ~ go go ... ~ ~ ~ s::, 'iD ~ 0 ~ 5' e: '< go... So e: g ~ ... '0 ~ ~ ~ ... g.
... = So ~ G' =... g ~ ~ ~ '0
In' g, a: g.-;:;8:. g ~ ::. ~ ~ ~. =r ~ e:~ 8~. ~ So >
;- ~ ~ ~ '" ,goSo ~ '" ~'O ~ 0-0 8 ~ g ~ 3 '" . ~ "C
>
< ::s;s. ~ ~ '0 .. _. ... ... ~ ~ 0~ ~ po ~ ~
~ -,So ... ~ ~ ~
~ g,
... S?:
,. g
'0' ~ - ~ ~ -'< o..g So'0 ... ...
g ~ g. ~ ... ... '0~ go '" ~ ~::s
~ g.- ~ ~ '" ~ ~ '0 ,J:)!?; ~ ;J~ "C
",'" go ~ 0~5'O"'-'::s~ (;"=r~... -, ~~o~'<~ ~'O=r",.. ~
'iD.0-
.. <~.=
~ = n ~~."'0"g'3"'~~~8'"
S' .. .." '" ~ ~ ~ ~ . -, ~ ~ ~
=r ."']n""8"'~S: =r t;;" ...;.;-
~O"~~ gs;-g.~.
... '< ~ g. 0
("')
5' ~ ~ ~, 0 OQ ~ '"&;'~ So ~ = ~ ::s eo.... 3 '< 0 ~ n' ~. So -<!?; 5' n tT1
OQ '0 ~ ~ '5 ~
~ 2 Q-< ~
Q ~ e. ~ ~ '0 : 'i?'So ~ 0" ~ 5" 2 n 5' ~ 5' ~ ~
-~ ~ '0 'l g a- '" oa g ~
0 ~ n 0 ~ ... ...
~ r:.=r ~ 0 '" '0 '" 0 3 go '0' ~ < ~ ~ '--. ~"';J ~ ~';J '-'
.., So ~. So ~ n r:, 0 ~ ~ :=I ~ 5' 0 ::s So ~ z ~ .::s..!?; g. ~ ~ ~ ~ 5' =r 8 0 g z
So~ o-~ PO::s~ ::s::s~...n~o~oOQ -n3 <=... -OQo 9~~= C)
~ ~ g. ~ g, =-go~' '0 ~ g.;; g.~' ~ ~ !';' ~ go g. ~ ~ g, g. g g. ~ JJ; ~ ~ ~ s: ~ ~ t/)
.I
", ' .. 0' ~ " ~ ~ ~ ~ ::. 0 ... =r .e- ~,~ ~ ~,'" ~ n 5' --, g, tT1
g- -, '<
::s'g" -, ;J... - '0 0..,',:" ;3, ~ ... In' ~
Q '"a .. :==r~ ;;'" ~~ n.. ~ ~~ =
~~"'",::S' ;;OQ~So~~", "'0 '0 ~
=~ ~...~_,=r~~::sn n
~.. ~ OQ=r ~ n " ~ ~ ~... (6' e; ~ ... !n' 9 -:=-,J:)~ 'g" = g'::s ~ !?; ~' '" r:, ~ '0 ;3,
=r
~
O "~","'"
~"""- <; to' ~
... '< ~ .,~... ",...",~
' ~ ':! ~
-'~O
0 OQ <
=rc:-
~ ~ - n ~ 0 ... "" o~=r...
~ c: ::s .. ~_.
.. 0 =r ~ ~ In' 0 !n' c: ~
~. -< ~ =r~ ~ ~.. ::s.. ~ ... ~ 0
~ ~ .. ~ 0 ~ ~ =r" '" ~ ~... '" -, ~ ~ 0 '" '"
'- . '"~ ~ .. So, s:~ .~ 9 n C:. ~
~ n0 ::;:-
=r -
'" : co"~ 3 '" '" <: 'iD::s.~ .. eo ~ .'" -;:; :. 9 0 2 ... g ~ ~ ~< '5
~ 5' a ~ ~.g ...
'iD ~=rQ~2 "'~""iD~-~ '" ~ ~~So ~."'So ~...Sos..g~Z):.",...~=r~
~
""'..~'< 0 ...
=r ~ 0-
~ ~~ ~
::s =r
~ ::s
~ ~n ~,J:)
== c: ~ ~
~ ("')
0 ';!
=; .. '"
::s s.~, ::S"'!n'
In' =r 'g.. ~.. =='<
~
=:r~, '" . 9 = ::s ~' ~ !::, ~
~ to'~ OQ ~ 0
~'.. = ~ n cs ::s ""'.0 =r '" ~ c: ::s ~ 5' ~ ~
9 ~ '-'
. ~ '"
'a
~
::s=;~=r
~ ~ n ::s ~'Oo "'-.. =-::s '"
.a'<~"'o ,'" ~"'",!?;9~~ ~=:I~ OQ
v~
- ... 9 '" 3 ~
.." < '" -,
0 -'. ,. -,
~ n'"
OQ ,--, - OQ . '" ~ 0-
o '<,<~OQ
0
-, - '"
'"
~~gog
~ ~ n 9...0
0 0 ~ '"
.'"
.. g ;.;-g,= s.
~ ~ 5 n =r '"
=...~
... 0- ~
0 ; ~~~
OQ
:=I =r -, 'iD 'g"
~:~~o~ ~"'~So[
N 0 C".::s' ~ S 9 ~ 8 ~ ~ t;;"
"~';::::S"",, ~-, .,-~~, =r~~ ::s...~ "'~- ~~OOQ~ "'~OQ... '
"'-..J ,. ~ """..<~"'!n ""'", ~~ n-' "::S ~"'.' =~~
0 ~;3 ~ 0 =r '" -, '" ~ . ... ... =r ~ '0' ~ - =r ~ -, ~
a ..
... '-'OQ' =...~ eo.
0 !?; ~ C:.
So ~, go
3 ~
... ~ n ""
=r~::s 0 ~ ri 0 ~ ~ ~ ::s ... r:, ~ ~
~'
S' ... ~=r o
~ ~ =r =
~ OQ
... -, . 0<
=rg ... ~.. -<.1 g ~
_. g == ~;- ~
~
~"...
~~' =r
~, ~ ~ -..J~ ~ 0 ~
... po c: 0 ""
'0 'g ~
.. '"
;.;- -..a ~ ~
~ '"~ e;C:. = ... n' C:.
-.!" ~ ~ 0' ~ In' "
-, ;J
...::s.... t/) ~
0 ",' n - - v~ - no ~ =r ::s
.. - ... .. ~~. 9_' 0 '0' ~,. Q
o~ -'n=r"" '" ""-PO... ~ =r
-"'~"'-'O~<"'o-'
~ ~.~ [ g ~a ~ ~gig ~ g. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ [ 5' @ '0 ~~~g [ 8' ~ !
0 0 ~ -, ;.;- g. ~'S: ~~,"';J n .. '< ~ 9 =
'ig.~ ~ '< eo. ~, - ~':' c", ~ ~ 9 0"~ 8
~ ~ ~ ... ... 5' 0 to' to' ~ 0 0 ~ ~ '" 5" '" 'iD OQ ~ 0 -'.. ",' g " OQ~ ~. ~" ~
=r_, ~, """
~.
~ ",,= ~ ...=r ::s ~ ",~ =r.." ::s~ """~.=n~;J
. "'::s ~"'~, OQOQ, '" '" Q.~ . ~~ ,~, ~ ~ ~'" ~, ~ , '" ~
~~'~:':~~"'c"
(")~~ ~PO;l>~ ~s.o,;;- on ::r~-ooPOo
~::~~:~~::=:::::-="C~
g. ~'Og:::!1 ~-'--:~'".:::;-'
'::: ~ ~
",po
~ '" '"Po'" &;' (D
o.r-' Ao o po", o ~
=. <'10' ~ a a (") 0 ~ ::r ...' ... (").,r <'1 (")
CT 00 00 0 '< Po 0 (D (D Po (D
= Po = ... ~ ~::r(D ~ ~ a to'&;'~~. ~ '" '<
- '" g.e:::r Z
Po (D (D 'fZ (D 0' ~ ~ o. ",'~~ ~ < a '< == = '" -<'0 ~ (") = ~ = 0 ~ .::r 0= t11
"'.
< ~ 5" ., ~ = ~ a = ~ ~ ~.;I> po~' :s a (D :I: 0 ~ -.E '0 Po 'tj. '" '" ::r 0. (") Z): n' (D t/J a- 'CO ~
~
~ 00 <: ... t/J ~ - '" ... 0 ~ == ,. v~ ~ _. '" PO...'" = '" (D' >< t/J
~ ... ~ s g.,-;:;,0 (D ';' ~ ~ R. ~ to'd6:0 ~ ~.~~ ~ 3 i ~ 50 ~~ ~ ~'oo ~: ~ 8 ~... 'tj
. ~O~(")-=.'-'-='-' O", v (") V
~ n"'=p-
::r" ... po (") o.oE;"~,~.-E
~.-",po~' =
0 -0000'" (")"",,='00
~ ~
~po . sg:po g. a. :;;. ~ 0 (D po::r::r~ ~~ ="'~ =.' '$ ~s.O:ig ~&p.'O Po 7'
0
~~(D ~ ~. ") 'O(D00~(D~~ 0 ~
a po
... '...
", 0 ..."'... ~ =- ~"O< ~~.~-:=:. ",.. Po "'.0 - ="' ~"O0. (D
-.
(D~0.
"'OQa~~'< ,-.. ,-.. t11 ~o. (D e:'<...ooo", o."'VI,D ...,
~ a = ~ g ~
... g'-C:--'+'(D ~ .!:;.., ~ E:3 go :;;' ~ ~ ~ POo.PO~= n~ ~.
- ; :;'< ~ ~ ~= ~. 0 0 ~ ~ ~ ':""~ "'.4.'< :I:
.-, ... ~ ... ~ = '" ... po '" ::r Po . 0. (") ... ~. :;; '0 ::r 0 VI... t11
... 'fZ (D '" 0 5' =::co ~ Po N (D Z
g,g =- = ::r 0 '-':;;'~~. 0~ .. :;;. ~ '0 ~ ~ '" n. s:
0 ... 0 = 0' ~ ~ '< S' ~ ~ Po ~ = 00 0.
g. == (")
00 ~ g... o. ~ h ~ ~ '" 0' ~ ~ ;I>
S' 0 ~g ~a ~::r 2.
n ~ 0a a -
'0 "0 ~ (D ~ -< ~ 0 ~ -< ::r ~ g~ ~ ~ ~ a- 0., ~ 'fZ 'to" ~ = ~ ~ 00 n. (") ~ = ~ ~ ~" ~ 0 Po .3 ~ ~ ...,
"'~(D(D... 0"" "fIo '" ~<:po ~ =0 '" ~ v~-'O -
o. Po ~ 0. (") <'1 ~ ~'" a d (D ~ 0 a Po ~ ~ ~ Po ~ a- 'CO~ g. ~. .- ~ '< (D '2 ~ 8 ~
Q ~."'.,
g- <:~ ~ ~ o.~ <'1] 0
~ : = 5 gog ~ g. .-+.g: ~ oS?;: ~ (") ~ s.."6. ':"" = S'
~ ~ '" ~ ~~ "'~ 0. >~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 -< Eo ~ Q ~
'0' ... ~ ~
~:~ 0 ~ 'CO ~ 'to" ~~ ~ ~. N a a ~..g ~0;~. s: &;'&f 50 Q;".!" ~ a. o.g. ... \0 ~ 1'"'
~ ~. ~
'"'
~ S' 'to" = ~ 4. '" go ':. ;:sO~, '0..."" 0 '0 = ~ fjg ~ og = '" (D Po '" <"" '" 0 0' '0 5'
~ - 0 =:: 0
~ :;;'... 0,9, ~ - c ~ Oq a. ~ 0 ;:s ~ ~ '< ~ 0po a ,<' '" ~ '" .(D ~ ~ 8. ce. '0 ~ - ., 0. ";;j 'tj
'" =. Po ~ ~ '" ~ 'CO ... 0 (D
< '< g .2 ~ s: '" '" CT ~ ~ ~ 'tj
~
= =,;0' o.~ ~~~Po ~~ Po g" Po g... ~ ::r ~ :!
::r 3 a ~ ~~ ~ 0' =~;:J ~ 0" ~ ~ ...
::r=~.'< 0 n' '-'-oJ 0. 0~
~,"'~' ~
(D -",. = Po
... 0 '" (D ,,(D 0 ~ ~. '" (D '" '< '< '" (j9'" (D 0. ... 0 ~ \ .I
g.00'...'
g: 'CO~. E;" ... g~ "" = 8 ~ (D;: Po (")' Po ",' ~ (D 50 t11
~ ~ a 0. s: 3 ..., a ~ S' 6 ~ . S' ~ ~ ~ cr ~ ~
~ ~
;>< g, ~ = 3' go.o ~ go ~ . = g. ~ ~~. 5, ~ a:;: ~ 2 ~ ~ ~ ~ 0,9 00 '" 2 ~ ;I> s:g" g = ~ g, ~