Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
SANTOS
GEMMA F. TIAMA
Page 1 of 3
V. STATEMENT OF THE CASE
Respondents filed a complaint for the sum of money and damages against
PNB before the Regional Trial Court of Marikina City questioning the
release of the deposit amount to Manibmo who had no authority from them
to withdraw their fathers deposit and who failed to present to PNB all the
requirements for such withdrawal. PNB and Aguilar denied that the
deceased had two separate accounts (premium deposit account and time
deposit account) with PNB. They alleged that the deceaseds deposit
account was originally a time deposit account that was subsequently
converted in to a premium savings account. Also, they alleged that Aguilar
did not know about Angel C. Santoss death in 1991 because she only
assumed office in 1996. Manimbo was able to submit an affidavit of self-
adjudication, required surety bond, certificate of payment of estate tax
dated 31 March 1997. All documents appeared to be regular.
The trial court found PNB and Aguilar negligent in releasing the deposit to
Manimbo as they failed to notify the depositor about the maturity of the
time deposit and the conversion of the time deposit into a premium savings
account. Subsequently, Aguilar filed a motion for reconsideration which was
denied by the RTC.
Upon appeal to the Court of Appeals, Aguilar contended that she merely
implemented PNBs Legal Departments directive to release the deposit to
Manimbo. PNB, on the other hand, argued that the release of the deposit to
Manimbo was pursuant to existing policy. CA sustained the trial courts
findings of negligence in both parties.
PNB and Aguilar filed their separate petitions for review before the
Supreme Court.
VI. ISSUE
VII. RULING
Yes, PNB and Aguilar were negligent in handling the deposit of Angel C.
Santos.
GEMMA F. TIAMA
Page 2 of 3
a deposit of his money to the bank, he is considered to have lent the bank a
money. The bank becomes his debtor, and he becomes the creditor of the
bank, which is obligated to pay him on demand.
GEMMA F. TIAMA
Page 3 of 3