PlP Pg

dP Pt ES, DAiPg Pbj, vAU g, AUg-560001

E-Mail: prydirector.edu.sgkar@nic.in
AS: 7(8) Dg.n.E/.U/2016-17 AP:01-02-2017.
: : e : :

Ai: PlP W GZ AiiAi AP: 18.01.2017 g jm Cf

AS: 4825/2015 v Evg PgtUU rg w CAi
AAz U Pt P Pz (Dg.n.E) U
Mr Pjv.
GR: 1. PlP W GZ AiiAi jm Cf AS:4825/2015 v
Evg PgtUU AAzAv AP: 18.01.2017 gAz rg
w.
2. zPg, Gz v Evg CASv s U zAi,
DAiPg Pbj, AUg F PbjAi v AS JA9/Dg.n.E./
P.GZ..w/1/2016-17 AP: 23.01.2017. v 01.02.2017.
3. F PbjAi e AS 7(8) Dg.n.E/.U/2016-17
AP: 30.01.2017
* * * * *
Aq AiP AAzAv PlP W GZ AiiAi j.. AS : 18270/2016,
20603-20604/2016 23984-986/2016, 8577/2015, 45161/2015, 15205/2016, 3489/2016,
3529/2016, 22143/2015, 15587/2014, 4163/2015, 10359/2015, 10124/2016, 13190/2016, 13508-
13512/2016, 16198/2016, 44968-44969/2012, 2702/2014, 8894/2015, 10836/2015 v
14145/2015 P g tU U AAz Av AP: 18.01.2016 gAz w rgvz. w
wAi ES m PnVz.

jm Cf AS: 4825/2015 v Evg PgtUU AP: 16.01.2017 gAz rg

wAvAi F PgtUU P Dzgvz. F w wAi
AP: 01.02.2017 gAz ES m PnVz.

zj w CAi, j.. AS : 18270/2016, 20603-20604/2016 23984-986/2016,

8577/2015, 45161/2015, 15205/2016, 3489/2016, 3529/2016, 22143/2015, 15587/2014,
4163/2015, 10359/2015, 10124/2016, 13190/2016, 13508-13512/2016, 16198/2016, 44968-
44969/2012, 2702/2014, 8894/2015, 10836/2015 v 14145/2015 F P g tU U jm Cf
AS: 4825/2015 v Evg PgtUU AP: 16.01.2017 g wAvAi P
ag Ai GR-3 g grg ez DzgAv P az.

/-
zPg(xP Pt)
dP Pt ES
gjU,

1. zPg, Gz v Evg CASv sU zAi,

DAiPg Pbj, AUg gjU iwUV.
2. AAz GzPg(Dqv), dP Pt ES, EjU iwUV v P
PPV.
3. AAz J Pv PuPjU, dP Pt ES, GzPg (Dqv)
gg SAvg.
4. AAzsl U Dqv AqU/UU DAii fU GzPg (Dqv)
gg SAvg P PPV.
5. jAi AiP zPg, E-Dqv sU, dP Pt ES, DAiPg Pbj,
AUg EjU iwUV v P PPV.
6. Pig, jAi PAlg Ug, Pt CAii gjU iwUV
v P PPV.
7. Pbj w.
 ftq5lnv
--__-
Crtfr-

IN THO F'tICi,H COURT OIIJKARNATAKA, BtrI\IGALURU

(

1li\T'[]il THIS TFIE tBTn DAY OF JANUAIIY" 2OI7

E]trFORE

"fHit IlOll\f'B{-E lvf R".lUtiTTCtr L. NARAYANA SWAMY

\ryx1,.IT- PI!T'I"rIO i\t N|QL. 1 8 27O Or 20 16 (ED N

BBIUTE;tr1\r.

ORANGE EDUCATIOI{AL SOCIETY

SUP'\'EY ltrO. 39, TIGALACHOWDENAHALLi
VARTHUR FICBLI, NEAR DOI\4MASANDRA C]IRCLtr
SARJAPUR I-IOBLI, AN]fI(AL T.ALUI{
BANGALORII _ 562 I2I.;
REPFItrStrN']'trD BY IT'S;
AD N,{INISTR\TIVtr OIIF ICtrR.
MR. JAYAN VUAY,qN
s/o K. VTJAVAN IrArR
AGtrI] 35 YTiARS
. ".PBTITIONER

(BY S}RI" IIASA\/ARA.I.l.;", 1\DV.)

AND I

1. STA.T'II O] I(AR:I\ATAI{A
BYTHtr SBCRIIT'ARY
DBPARTMtrNT O F trDUCATION
lVI. S. B UILDING
D R-"AI,{BtrDKA]R VtrtrD HI
IIAhTCALORE - 560 001

J'nlr eerrifhll r',r it.]'/

{,r : C\ \:U14 r/ i. ., i:- .

i lr r' l'i I r.'il i1

 2

2. THtr COMMISSION]'IT FOI{

PUBLIC INSTRUCTIOI,I
DBPAR'TMtrNT OF
PUBLIC INSTRUCTION
OF'FICE OF THE COMMISSIOI\ER
FOR PTIBLIC INSTRUCTION
NRUPA'TUNGA ROAD
BANGALORE _ 560 OO1

3. THtr BI,OCK trDUCATION

OFFICER" ANEIG.L
BANGALORE _ 562 125

4. NATIOI\IAL COMIVIISSIOII FO]R

MINORITY EDUCATIONAL
INSTITiJTIONS
GATE N[O.4, lST FLOOR
JEtrVAIV TARA BUILDIIVG
PATtrL TCHOWI(, Si, SANSAD tuIlRG
NEW DELHI _ 110 OO1
BY ITS RtrGISTRAR
". .I{F;Sp0hTDFiNTS

(BY SRI. H.T. NARtrNDIRA PRASjAD, ,a,GA, F.OF:

R.t T,C) 3)

THIS WRIT PtrTITION IS FILtrD UNDIIR AI{TICI,B 226

OF THtr CONSTITUTION OF I]:dDIA, F)RI\"/ING TO
QUASHING THtr GOVtrR}\IVIEI\T ORDEJR AS PtrR
ANNBXURtr-- N DATtrD 18.05.20I4 ISSUETJ EV TI-Itr R_i
AS BEING VIOLATIVtr O}T ARilCLtr :IO OF' THtr
CONSTITUTI(f i\I OF INDIA AS IT \NOLA]T'trS THE
ITUNDAMENTAL ITIGI-ITS oF 'rl-Ifil UNAIDhID n{iNoRITy
IIDUCATIONT\L INSTITUT'IONS;,AND |ITC.
"
 T'HIS PF]TI''"ION CON{INCi ON
DA'Y, TI.[II COI.IRT VIADF; FOR (f RDERS THIS
TFIE trOLLOWING:

aer}e&
Itretitic'''er-InstIrr-rrion is befbre
this cou.rt praying to
quaslr {,he Ciovernmrenl_ Orcler
clated 18.06.2014 vide
Anne><un,: - N ;rncl for otherconseql-tentia_l
reliefs.

2' 'r'hc question raisecl

in this wr:it petition is
sir*ilar t' i.rre o'e r,ai*iecr and considered
by. this court in
w'P' l\c'' 4t325/2015 a.d co'nected
writ petitions. This
cor'rrt on rtb"[]1 .20tr'7, clisposed of the ab've said writ
petitions.

tn [erms of t,he obseruations

made in W.p.
No"4g25/ 2c'r6 and c'nrier:ted .nraLters,
this petition a'so

-'' ' ''-."\,

/,",';t- '"'
,' / rr i".".. :-,_
I <-' S*.:,':.;,
{

n i i: ;.,'r!j -,
-\
--, ',
\':.;..."=,
: 1.j. . 'r
)

H.i..''
. ,'

I JUDGtr

'-"--Jiftt;.'i I]:"0"," on r,,,.i,.h

Lh
b) n

:it'lii:,:i:ili#L:rox
,,lj;-,,I:,1;':,i,;i:;i:il*ii,;:&"
li,
\ff r::#;.,,(,.(,,
]*"S),"b'#:.: 'i:s-.1
;;1'"',';;l[il;il::'i''"*.nin'i/,
ri. r-i,*c....*,.'.
Ij'rrr
"QF'couftorfarn"r..o
.,-, ?:y*,id}/$ I tz- \*nstt*t'-$fo oor
J;*
,,"
u' +i,iil:'-:' '';' "';'l :'
l' i,: iry\"I ft/.
-
;'ll;,,i;;" "',.,,;:,i',,i1,1,-Z.r,.,
t-t)lt l\../--
,".1__"**ffi
 IN "THtr FIJGI{ COLIR]' OF' I(ARNATAKA,-BF]NGALURU
-./
])ATtrD T'{_IIS I'F.Ir' IBTH DAY OF.JANUARY, 2OI7

BI,FORE

TI{E HON'IJLE IVIR".,IUST]CE L. NARAYANA SWAMY

nrRri{'PrDTI (EpN _ RESI

BETWtrEI.{:

1. VIDYANTT)HI EDUCA'rION TRUST. (REGD.)

].IAVIN(} ITS OFFICE AT
TIO .64'J7, SHIVANAHALLI
.TtrLAHANKA
HOBLI
]]IINGALI.JRU _ 560 064

I{EPRESENTED T]Y I'TS

'IRUSTEE _ SRI. ASFI\MIN PAI

2. VIDYASHILP ACADEMY
I-IAVING I'1'S OF'FICT.] AT
]{O. 6437, SI{IV,{NAHALLI
.IIiLAHANKA HOBLI
]]I'NGALURU _- 560 064

ITBPRESENTED I3Y ITS

VICE PRINCIPAL
MS. KALAI SELVI
...PETITIONERS
(BY SI{I" c.L. VISHWANATH, ADV")

@!\., ,','

\
1.r
\lI'

I t'1!.. /
,.''' / -J t
r:7 t'hrs Certif iccl cepv .nnr.tnr.'....?...' t"s
And CoPYinI 'i:l' li;:'r:,
Recciverl
 AND:

1. NAT]ONAL COMMISSION FOR

MINORITY trDUCATIONAL
INIJTITUTIONS
GC)VtrRNMENT OF INDIA
GATE NO.4, 1S1'FLOOR
JI]DVAN TARA BUILDI}\G
5, ISANSAD MARG, PAT'TJL CHOWK
NEW DELHI _ 110 OOl
RBPRtrSENTED BY I]'S
DEPUTY SECRETARY

2. THE DIRECTORATtr OF URDU

& OTHER LINGUISTIC
MII.IORITY EDUCATIONAL
INSTITUTIONS,. NRUPATI.]NGA ROAI)
BE]VGALURU _ 560 OO l
REPREStrNTED BY ITS DIRtrCTOR

3. THI' DtrPARTMtrNT OF
PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS
NRIJPATUNGA ROAD
BEI{GALURU _ 560 OO l
REI'RESENTBD BY
ITS COMMISSIONER
.. " RESP(-)NDENTS
(By sRI. It.T. NARENDRA PRASAD, AGA FOR
R3;
R2 SFTRVED)

THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE ITILBD UNDER

ARTICLESJ 226 AND 227 OF TFIB
INDIA, PRAYING TO QUA,SFI CONSTITU'IION
THE
OF
I]MPUGNED
trNDORSIDMENT DATED TS"OO.ZO14 ISTJUtrD
B}' R-l AT
ANNEXUFIE F AS BEING ILLtrGAL, AF:BITRARY
UNCONS]'ITUTIONAL AND E'IC. AND
"
 _-t

.IFIIISI;
PBTI'I'[OI\S CON/IING ON FOR (]RDtrRS
DAY, fFIFI COURI. NiADtri THE THIS
F'OLLOWING:

0I3UgE
Petitionel,_Instii utions are before this court praying
to qurash irrtpugned endorsement
dated l.O(t.2O 14 issued
by respondernt No.I vicle Annexure
F etnd for other
consequentirr I I.eliefs.

). The question raised in these wrir: petitions is

simila' Lo ttre one raisecr and considered
by tiris court in
w'P' No. 4g2s/2o,r ernrl connected writ petitions. This
court on 1b.01.2017, disposecl of
the above said writ
petitions.

Ln terms of l-he observations made

in W.p.
No'4825/20r6 and colrnected matters,
these petitions also
stands disposed of .

sd/-
JUDGE
w-'-
rr "lhe (latc on u'4trr:tr the aPpllcatlon
nrade ll)- ll f
,l -ftr (1:rre cn "r!-11r'!r
cltd:{1iliiO'iOltt"rttt
rll ' -l lor
j
Clta r r:r::' "r "'
:
i
T'I?.UE COPY
c[r::, ,:;,r,'.
.r r ;-,]:'::ttj'ootttl:"'
r '' ,.,"-i, ), f
:l l' ; '. 'rP! rS "),
''id, . Lru:"p,V#.',4,,-,
r:,.
; -..,,,,, ' ''lr 'r'r't
, -f.D)l+ Higlt Co, r rt of Xarnatakr
0 rlri 't'Ti]]Tttt. I-rengduru-56tJ 001
i'i:p'r t-l'r; '!Jt
g ln. ':.',i,-'1f 1""""'rl:c 't 'l''T;1""O=
I!tt1 .:"Pl-'lir"rllt
-r j !:;i,vrrri ri -.rY
l,i.ol"*)r5
b"
 \r
:r. I( u"
' .t'rft
IN THB HIGH COURT OF
KAIdNIAT-AKA, Btr]\GAI,URI,I

DATtrD THIS THB IBTrI DAY

Or..I{ilUA,R'1" 20L'/
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSIIICE L. NARAYA^IA.
SWAIVIY

,_[tlpN _ REsl
BETWEEN:

I. SRI. SUDHA BHAMA

EDUCATION SOCIETY
NO.s/A, HAL 2ND STAGtr
INDIRANAGAR
BANGALORE _ 560 O3B
REPRBSENTtrD BY ITS SECRtrTARY
MR. J. PATRICK
s/o MR. JOSEPH
AGED ABOUT 42 YtrARS

2" S.S.B. BNGLISH HIGH SCHOOL

NO. 5/A, HAL 2ND STAGE
INDIRANAGAR
BANGALORB _ 560 O3B
REPRESBNTBD BY ITS SECRI]TARY
MR. J. PATRICK
s/o MR. JOSBPH
AGED ABOUT 42 YBARS

3. S.S.B. INTERNATIONAI, SCHOOI,

NO. 5/A, HAL 2ND S'IAGE
INDIRANAGAR
BANGALORE - 560 O3B
REPRESENTED BY ITS SJtrCR]ITARY

\$d Cr-rr)v''l!
Ilet:'i" '1
 L

MR. .J. PATRICI{

s/o N{tr. JostrPFr
AGE)I) ABOUT 42 YIIARSI
. ".PETITIONERS
(BY SRLBIIUVANENDRI\ BABU, ADV.,)

ANII.
1. THE; STATtr OF KARNATAI(A
DEF,I\R'TMENT OF trDUCATION
PRI}ilARY & SECONDARY
VIDITjiAltrA SOUDHA
BtrNtGhLURU - 560 001
RIDPFItrSENTED BV ITS SECRETARY

2. TFIE; COM\4ISSIO}Itr]1 FOR

PUB; [,IC) INSTRIJCTIoNS
NRLIPA'IUNGA ROAD
BtrNI(}ALURU _ 560 OO i

3. TFIE; DIiPUTY DIRECTOR

ADIUINXSTRATION
DIIFY\RTMBNT OF
PIIBI,IC INSTRTJCTIONS
BANGALORE SOUTH DISTRICT
KALA.SIPALYAM, BA}IGAI,ORE _ 560 OO2

4. TFIE, DIRECTORATtr OF URDU

& O]]HTDR LINGUISTIC
]VIINC)RITY EDUCATIONAL
INST]TTJTIONS
NRLIPA'IUNGA ROAD
BENGALURU _ 560 OO1
RI'PIi:EI]ENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR
 3

5" THE BLO^CK EDUCATIOIV

BANGAL9^RE souiH OFF]CER
z"or,rn _ c,s
BTM LAyour, r.. sraCa
BANGALORE _ SOO
OZg
(AMENDM_ENT CARRIED
couRT oRDER r,nron OUT VIDE
i B.a4.2o16)
6. COUNCIL FOR THtr INDIAN
scHoot- cERTrFrcni.e
BXAMINATION
PRAGATHI HOUSE, 3RO
-FLOOR
47_48, NEHRU PALACtr
NEW DBLHI _ 110 Org

7. NATIONA-L
-COMMISSIONtrR FOR
MINORITY BDUCATTOTV'
INSTITUTIONS
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
GATE NO.4, r", PLOOR"'
JtrtrVAN THARA BUTI,DTNC
SANSAD MARG, NtrW NEr.rrI .*
REPRtrSENTED EY TTS -' 110 OO I
DEPUry SBCRBTARY
...REfJ PONDENTS
(BY SRI. H.T. NARENDRA
PRASAD, AGA FOI.. F:]
sRI. p.B. AIeAIAH, TO Ii;
novoCAT,tr FoR R6)
THBStr WRIT PE'TIT'IONS
ARTICLES 226 & ZZZ Oi;iffi ARE FILED UNDER
pRAyrNG To DEcLARn --rua CONSTITUiiO:I. OF INDIA,
RESPONDENTS acrloiv oF THE
NOT CONSIDENTruC- P]]:IITIONERS
.IS
AppLrcATroN DATED ti.o+.zoto
REFUSING TO GRANT rErVrII nNri. THERBB'
r,r^rCUISiiC
'-ISA,INORITY
STATUS TO PBTITIONBN-' iNSrI'rUrTOU
T{IGHLY
 Ll

ARRITRAFIY ILLtrGAL AND CONTRARY TO ARTICLE 14,

19(1)(g) Al\lD 30(1) OF THII CONSTITUTION oF INDIA AT
ANNEXUF:O "'A AND A1 AND trTC.,

TFIE[]E, PETI]'IONS COMING ON FOR ORDtrRS THIS

DAY" TFItr COURT MADE THE F'OLLOWING:

=ryBpER

Petitioner-Institutions are before this court praying

to declare, thr: action of the respondents in not considering

petitioners application dated 13.04.2016 and thereby

refusing to grant "lamil Linguistic Minority status to
petiiioner institution is highly arbiLrary illegal and contrary

to Article 14, 19(1)(9) and 3O(1) of the Constitution of India

at A.nnerrl'e-- A and Aland for other consequential reliefs.

2. The question raised in these writ petitions is

similar to the one raised and considered by this court in

W.P. No. ,+825/2OI5 and connected writ petitions. This

court orr 16.01.2017, disposed of the above said writ

petitions.

;llj
,j:;,,
 J

In terrns of the obser_val.ions rrLacle

in W.p.
No'4825/ 2016 and c'nnected
martters, thes,: pretiti''s
also
stands disposed of.

Srt/-
JLtDr-liE

Bsv

TRUE copv,

'T*"jfiHn^.\'(,,

IU

bl

cl

!.|

:)

6)

t}t
lr)
",1
't-i"
c,e()>
 .t \)-
li
1\
t)l
r.!r I

t"A
IN THO HIGH (]OURT OF KARNATAKA, BBIVGALURU

Dril'trD ."].HIS THB lB]'H DAY OP.6TVUARY" 2OI7

BEFORtr

TFI}' HON'BI-E MR.JUSTICE I.,. NARAYANA SWAMY

IITRIT P}}Truqry-

BETWBEN.

KODAGU ACADEMY FOII

EDUCAT{ON & CULTURtr,
COORG ]trUBLIC SCHOOL,,
POST BOX NO.14, GOI\iIK.OPPALU 57L 213.
VIRAJPET TALIJK, KODAGU DISTRICT.
REP. BY ITS PRtrSIDB}IT
MR. M. N" BELLIAPPA.
".. PBTITIONER
(BY SRI A. I(. SUIIBAIAH, ADV.,)

AND:

1. TH]I STATE OF KARNATAKA

RBP. BY ITS SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF BDUCATION
M. S. BUILDINGS, DR. AMBtrDKAR VEBDHI
BANGALORB- 560 OO1.

2. COMMISSIONER O}I'
PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS
K.R" CIRCI-IJ, BANGALORE _ 560 OOl

I-hls Certif
ierl cnnv
{odCor,.r,r,-r- .....frges
:::ll'1.'nt'.......k
Recerved'D'" ",,,r/tlcs cf t.-...........if./"-;il-
 ,2

3. DIREC)TOR, DIRBCTORATTi OF URDU & O'TI{ER

LINGUISTIC SCHOOLS,
DEPAITTMBNT OF PUBLIC INSTRUC'IION "

K .R. CIRCLE" BANGALORI - 560 OO1.

4" THB DEPUTY DIRECTOR

OF PUBLIC INSTRTICTION
DtrPAIRTMBNT OF BDUCATION
MADIFIERI. KODAGIJ DISTRICT.

5. THE BLOCK trDUCATION OF'FICBR

PRIMA.RY & SECONDARY BDUCATION,
VIRAJPET, VIRAJPBT TALUK,
SOUTI] KODAGU, I(ARNATAKA- 571 218.

" RESF'ONDBNTS

(By sRI H.T.NARENDRA PASAD, AGA FOR R*l

SRI T.A.KAR.UMBAIAH, ADV., FOR IMPLBADING I\PPLICANT)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILBD UNDB]R ART{CLES 226

& 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
DECLARE THAT THE PBTITIONER INS'IIITUTION IS A
LINGUISTIC MINORITY INSTITUTION TO DISPOStr OF THE
PBTITIONEFI'S APPLICATION DTD.3. TI.2A14 VIDtr ANNEX-V
& V1 WITFT OTHBR SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS IN THIS
PETITION, ,A.ND ALSO THtrRBBY DECLARING f'FIAT THB
PROVISIONfJ OF THE RTE ACT ARE NOT APPLICABLE TO
THE PETITIONER.QUASH THE COMMUI{ICATIOI{ ISSUBD
BY TIJE R-5 DTD.16.2.2015 VIDtr ANNEX-Y HOLDI}\G THAT
THE SAME IS NOT ENFORCEABI-E, BEING II,LBGAL.
 3

THIS F,E]'ITION COT4ING ON F'OR ORDI'RS THIS DAY,

THE COIJRT MA]-)B ]'FIE FOLLOWING:

{}RPEB
PetL[ioner-lnstitution is belbre this cour.t praying to
direct the
'esponderrts to clispose of tlee petitioner,s
applicati,rn dtct.3"rr.2or4 vi<-le Annexures-v and v1 with
other supporting clocuments in tlris petition, and also thereby

declaring that the provisr.ons of the RTE Act are not applicable

to the pe:titioner and to cluash the communica,tion issued by

the R-5 datecl 6.2"20 "LS vide Annexure-y hold,ing that the
same is not enforr:eable, being illegal.

2. The question'aised in this writ petition is simiiar

to the one raisecl and considerec{ by this court in w.p. No.

4825/201"5 and connected writ petitions. f.his court on
16"01.2o17, disp.sed of the above said writ petitions.
 'fA

In t.,rrn.s; of thr: observatio.ns made in W.P"

No.4B25 l'2O16 arrd conrter:ted rnatters, this petition also

stancls disposed o[.

sd/-
JUDGE
Bsv

TRUE COPV;
I r 44 1-1,/\
\Sfciiorr
rrrJl!4/i'u
(r:fic,'. )_ z {l
llirtr Cr.'r':i ,{ Karnateke
Bengduru-560 ml

lf.r

b)

CI
 :11 2-
')\ "\\>'-
-,--?
I ----t'\,., d\

IN THE HIGH COURT OF'

KARNATAKA, FIE]VGALT,TRU
DATtrD THIS THE l BTH DAY
OII JANfAR\,, 20 1'l

BEFOR},
THE HON'BLB MR.JUS,UCE
L. NARAyANT\ SWAM'

QF2o1s (Eriu[1]U-{gl
BETWEEN:

SARASWATHI BDUCATION TRUST

ryg _1 733 /44,9rH CROSS,
ASHOKNAGAR, BANGALORB _
560
BY ITS SBCRETARY SRI.A.SATTTTSH, 055.
60 YEARS, s/o sRI.A.S.CUprn
RtrsIDING AT NO.7/8, lsr PHAflE,
1:1cRoss, NBHRU ROAD,
GIRINAGAR, BANGALORE- 560
OB5. "". PETI'I]ONBR
(BY sRI M.P.SRIKANTH, ADV.,)

AND:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

BY ITS SECRETARY T'O GOVBRNMBNT
PRIMARY AND SECONDAI?Y EDUCATION
M. S. BUILDING, DR. AMBBDKAN VBBN}Ti,,
BANGALORE-560 OO 1.

2. THE COMMISSIONER I.,-OR PUBLIC

INSTRUCTIONS.

Ihrs []erti f ied c"rpy con?arn(..-..

.h..r,r\Fag3es
r'rrd Celryrng c.l rr.,tt,.s
cf ,.........:1../:*_i*
Qecei"ed
 ,)

NIEW I]UBLIC OFF'ICES],

NRUP,\'IFIUNG,i\ ROAL), t(" R. CIRCLtr,
t.rANGALORtr-550 0{l1.
a T.Htr DIRI|CTOIR OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS
PI?IMAITY EDUCAIION,
NEW ]]IJBLIC OFFICtrS,
NRUPAIFIUNGA ROAD, K .R. CIRCLtr,
BANGALORE-560 OO 1.

4" THB DIRIICTOR OF PI.JBLIC INSTRUCTIONS

SE.COI\ DARY EDUCATIOI'tr,
I\.IEW PIJBLIC OFFICES"
NRUPATFIUNGA ROI\D, I(. R. CIRCLtr,
TJANGALORE-560 OO 1.

5. THB DIRIDCTORATtr OF URDU AND

C)THER MIINORITY I.,ANGUAGtr SCHOOLS,
K . R, C]|RCLB, NRUF'ATHLINGA ROAD,
EJANGALORB-560 OO 1,

6. THtr DIiP{JTY DIRECTOR. OF PUBLIC

I]\STRLIC'TIONS
BANCIALORE SOTITI-I DIS'TRICT,
KALASIP,AiLYAM, BANGALORtr-560 0S2.

7. THE ]3[,OCK EDUCATION OFFICtrR

SOU]'H RANGE-, SI-IANKARPURAM,
BANCIALORE-560 OO4"
" RESPONDBNTS

(By sRr It.:t"t,tARENDRA PRASAD, AGA FOR Rl TO R7)

t'
 3

THIS WRIT PtrTIT.IoN

IS FILtrD UNDBR I\R,TICLE S
& 227 OF THE CONSTITUT,ON OF IT,INTA,
226
DIRECT CONSIDERATION OF' PRAYING TO
THE PNOPOi,{LIS STJBMITTED
DATED 2o.r.2015 ANNX-M sv rHg Ir{tAN.A(iEMBNf.
FOR DECLARING'IDB
THI' INSTI,I'LI"IIONL RIJ^I
PBTITIONER SOCIETY EtY THE
INSTITUTION.
AS N,ITiVONTTY IIDUC,,\TIONAL

THIS PETITION COMING OI* FOR

THE COURT MADE THE FOI.,LOWING: ORDE]*S "'.FIIS DAY,

OR.DER.

Petitioner-rnstitution is before this cot*.t pr.irJ/ing to

direct consideration of the proposars dated
20.or.2or5 vide
Annexure-M submitted by ttre JManagement
for: decrnring the
institution run by the trreti.tione,r society a.s minority
educational education.

2. The question raised in this writ petition

ir,; similar
to the one raised and considered by this
in w.p. c,:_rurt No.
4825 /2ors and connected petitions. ,r-his
c*urt on
16.0L-2oL7, disposed of the above said writ petitions with
some observations.

4, .-\^. eF
'...i'-,.'
r.r-)
-\
-
 A
a-

IN trs I'IT}S of the ohrservations made in W"P.

No.4B25 l20l6 and connectecl matters, this petition also

stands clisposed of"

sd/-
JUDGE
Bsv

TRUE CCITY'

7r [mf**futJ;,,1
Hrgh Corrrt of Knrnatal,ia
Jrt
Berrgaluru-s6o OOI
{r,

,lU 'l'he d:tt.: on u'htch thc ai)Pllcauoll wa-

n'aclr rl: lrl-
tUlt The rlari. ,', \..r.t, h .l-\.i:nes aricl addltlond
(.ha;..er il i.,'"'iior
Cll l:r . t, I '
-f ,,,;,,,:j:: And edditicmaj
I ,, : I, :: ,:,.'l;'i'atd
dr I :''-{'rdv;l>lff
:l .. , i irrr ,'t)pV ts feadi

' ,tJ.,' ;nl

)l>-lr
l9 rC(lUlfa!
I
ii
It)
,:.
l: :
-i,t .l: l , r.''
. :
' ol>lrr
.-,, il;.f \c,lry rs oelivtrq. il .
rJ
^
l;l?.rlIjii::,cant ..o la 1t '+-
r) iixainln<rl lw -
'
+_.-
'rll,,;e5
:ili-i4t.*.

lLe",:>
 b\":y
LnA

IN 'I]TI' F:[IC,H COUI(T. tftr I(ARNATAKA, BI,NGALURU

D,,\TTiD THIS TFTF] l BIh DAY OF JANUARY,
2OT7

BIlF'ORE

IFIE IJOi\,f'BLtr [4Ir.JUSTICtr L. I{ARAYANI\

SWAMY
luRm q_ETITIQILxEl.ls
s/w
!q&tr E$rITIaUJ9_E qagg_oq 2gJ5_& 35?s azuar
ul_!u_,]'. [E -L5 2Q5l?Q I (ii

BEr!{QQg:

GtrA R INIIOVATIVE II{TIIRNATTONAL

SCHOOL
MANAGED B'T GtrAR ITOUNDA'IION,
gPl'R Ro/\D, OFF SARJAPTJR ROAD,
DO[)DAKANI.IALI,I,
BtrNG,AI.UIILI _ 560 O35.
RtrPFIITSENTICD BY ITS (]FIAIRMAN
SRI.M. SRI},IIVASA}J.
AGtrD ABCrU't.63 ytrARS.
S/O MUTHUSWAMY GOUNDAR
...PETITIONER
(BY iSFlI. G.lt.t/IoHAN, ADV.)

ANDi
1. ].HB isTA"TE oF I(ARNAIAKA
PRIVI AI,:Y AND SECON DARY
EDUCATION
--' t r I VI I
UI. S. }}U ILDINGS , '

f hrs Certiliel copy contarns ...- ...!*....1^f*

And Cupying ci alges o{ t...........W/.-:i;-
-t'
. --- R ece i ved
 2

BBNGALURU _ 560 OO 1
REPFIESENTED BY IT'S
PRINCIPAL SBCRETARY

2. THE COMMISSIONtrR
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCT.I{)hIS
K.R.CIRCLtr,
BENGALURU _ 560 OOl

3. THE BLOCK trDUCATION OFF'ICtrR"

BENGALURU SOUTH DIVISION-4,
K.R.F'URAM, MINI VIDHANA SOUDHA
BtrNGALURU - 560 103.

4, THE UNION OF'INDIA

REPIIESENTtrD BY ITS SECRI]TARY
MINISTRY OF HUMT\N RESoURCE
DEVI]LOPMENT"
NEW DtrLHI
.."tilEfiPotiDENTS

(BY SRI.H.T.NARENDRA PRASAD, AGA FOR Rl TO R3;

SRI.KFIISHNA S. DIXIT, ASG IIOR it4 (MA NIOT IIII,ED))

THIS WzuT PETITION IiJ F'ILBD UNDEIT ART]CLES

226 &, 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF I}ID]A, PI?NYING
TO DIRI'CT TO CONSIDER THtr D OCLIM ENTS
FURNISHED ALONG WITII TI]tr COVtrRI}{G ]L!]TTER
DATED T8i.O2.2O16 TO THE R-3 BY THE PETTIIONI1R AS
PER ANNBX-E SINCB THE PIITITIONER INS'IITUTION
BBING A MINORITY BDUCATIONAL IN{JTTTUTION IS
PROTECTIID UNDER ARTICLE 30 OF THE CONS'IITTJTION
OF INDIAAND ETC..
U{ _lV_J?. NAE i!4ge/aq rc_s eE?ry?AI 6:

BEI'[-QQ$:

1. I\I\{AJTA JYOTHI BIJUCATIONAL TRUST,

O/A .BASAVANAPLIRA MAIN ROAD,
DI'VI\S,\NDRA, K. Ii. P UIL{X{
I]IDNGALURU _ 560 036"
IREPF:trfitrNTtrD B\' ITS
lvIAN,\CiING TRUSTtrE
SRINIVASA
IVI]R.I{ .N"
ri/ o
l_A'rE K. P. NAFLAYANAPPA"
I\GEI) ABOUT 55 ]'EARS"
2. I\I\{AIIA JYOTHI PI.]BLIC SCHOOL,
O/A ]3ASAVANAPURA MAIN ROAD,
DEVI\SANDRA, ](. R. PURAM
"
I]ENGAI,URU-560 035.
IItrPF:trfJtrNTtrD BY ITS
IyIANr\GING TRUSUEE)
I{I?. K .N"SRINIVAS./\
.s/ o I.A'IE K.P.NAFIAYANAPPA
I\CiED I,BOUT 56 YEARS.
...PETITIONERS
(BY MlS.FARAH FATHII\,IA, ADV.;

AI[P-

1. ]'HB |JTIATE OF IG]RNATAKA

DEP,A.RTMENT OF EDUCATIO},I
T'RIMARY & StrCO]VDARY.
\/IDHAI{A SOUDIJI\,
 4

BtrNGALURU - 560 OO1.

REPRtrSENTED BY IT'S SECRETARY

2. THE COMMISSIONER FOR

PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS,
NRUPATUNGA ROAD,
BENGALURU _ 560 OO1.

3. THE DIRECTORATE OF T]RDLI

& OT'HtrR LINGUIST'IC
MINORITY BDUCATIONAL INSTI]'UTIOI\Si
NRUPATUNGA ROAD,
BENGALURU _ 560 OO1.
REPRBSENTtrD BY ITS DIRBC'IOR.

4. THtr BLOCK trDUCATION OFtriCER.

SOUTHtrRN ZONE - 04,
TAHSILDAR'S OFFICE,
MIN] VIDHANA SOUDHA.
K.R.PURAM
BBNGALURU - 560 036.

5. NATIONAL COMMISSIONtrII FOR

MINORITY EDUCATIONAL I NSTRUCTION S
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
GATD NO.4, I FLOOR,
JEEVAN THARA BUILDING- 5,
SANSAD MARG, PATBL CHOCK.
NE\IIr DELHI - O1
REPRESENTED BY DEPUTI' SI]CRBTAI?\'

. ".REIJPO}{DBNTS
(BY SRI.I{.T.NARENDRA PRASAD, AGA FOR Rl T(f R.l
SRI.K]RISHNA S DIXIT, ASG FOR R5)
 ,IIFItrSitr
WRIT PtrTITIONS ARtr FILED UNDtrR
ARTICLtrs 2irer & 22,'T oF TFIE CONSTITUTION
PRAYING T() QUASH THE trNDORStrMF}NT oF INDIA,
1I.OB.201i; ISSUED tsY THE R-3 IS HIGHLY DATED
ARBITRARY
ILLEGAL AND CONTRARY To ARTTCLtr
14, rg(r)(e)
OF 'IFItr CCI\ISTITLTTIOI{ OF INDIA (ANNtrXU]RE _ & 3o(1)
ETC., A) AND

TFIES;E PtrTITTONS; COMING ON FOR

DAY, TFIE CC)URT I\4ADII THID FOLLOWING:
ORDtrRS THIS

o&EER
f:'}eLi1-ioner-Institrrti.ns are before this court praying
to direcr t<> r::o'sicrer Lhe doc.ments furnisherl
along wittr
the c.veri'g letter dated 1g.02.2016 to
the R-3 by the
petitioner as per: /\nnexure
-tr since the petitioner
institu,tion being a nrinority educational
institution is
protected trnr:ler Article ,30 of .he
c'nstitution of India and
for other consequentiar. reriefs in w.p
No. rs2os/2or6
and to quash the enclorseme'l.
clated 11.0g.2015 issued by
the I?-3 is highly arbitrary illegal
and contrary to Article 14,
19(1)(51) & 30(1) of *re constitution oF India
vide
 6

Annexure - A and other reriefs in w.p"N.s.'4sgr2ol6 &

3529 /2016"

2' The question rtrised i' these writ peti.ti'rrs is

similar to the one raised and considerect by l,his court in
w.P. No. 4825/2ors and connected writ pe titions. This
court on 16.01.2017, disposed of the aborre saicl writ
petitions.

In terms of the observations made in W.p.

No.4825/'2016 and connected nratters, thesc pretiLions also

stands disposed of.

t$d/-
JU D(iE
Bsv

,THUE COPY' i
\ ,/.,vJltt ir t'lt(. :')'t '2'1')' .-
1\ i;,-u tic'. '' I
au l{i4i: rt,"', , ,i Kartntakr
;-',

ll. t.6*it t u-560 ml

,l

cl
e)

tri

gJ

;rl
 IN 1.[IE HI(}FI COUIITOF KARNATAKA, BtrNIGALURU
a"
IJAf.EII TFIIS ]]IE 18th DAY oF JANUAR.F, 2oI7
BtrF'ORE)

"TI{E I-ION'EJLE MR..IUS]'ICE I-,. NARAYANA, SWAMY

wlRrT Prws -"'

o_F.2Qr5lEDN - RESI
BETW]IEN:

VANI ODUCITIION CEN RB

REPROStrNT'ED BY I"I'SJ
MANA GING RUST'trF]
SRI.R,S.USF{A
W /A ]-ATE R.S.HANUNIAI'IT1\ RAO
AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
RAMA.VAI{A, RAJAJIN/\GAR 1 ST BLOCI(
BANGALORtr ,_ 560 O 1O.
...PETITIONtrR
(BY Siil.AMI',r DESHPAf,tDtr, ADV.)

ANry

1. Sj'I'ATtr OF' IiARN.A'IAI(A

ITtrPRBSITNTED BY PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
r{IGHER AND SF]CONDARY EDUCATION
VIDHANA SOUDHA, BANGALORtr _ 560 OO1.

2. COMMISSIONER OF PRIMARY AND

SECONDARY EDUCATION
l(R CIRCLE, BANGALORE _ 560 OO1.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. H.T. NARENDIT\ PRASAD, AGA)

l'nr5 f 6,; irf i-d ron,,, ..(ri,?rn(

.qn|J (-o;r.vrr.r
{,: il:htl tif ?.-
I)ccp'vpd
 THIS WRIT PtrTITTON IS FIL,ED T]NDER AI?TICLtrS
226 &" 227 OF THtr CONSTITUTION OF iI'{DIA, PRAYING
TO DIRECT THE R- 1 TO ADMIT CHILDITEN IN
GOVERNNIENT SCHOOLS FIRS:I AND THtrN I]I'ON THE
COMPLE:IION OF' ADMISSIOhI IN GOVERNMENT
SCHOOI,IJ TO ALLOT StrATS UNDXIR RIGHT TO
EDUCA']]ION ACT IN SO FAR AS THI' PtrTITIONER'S
INSTITUTION IS CONCtrRNBD.

THI|S PtrTiTION CON{ING ()1\ FO]l PRtrLIMINARY

HtrARING THIS DAY, THII COURT h4ADI' THE
FOLLOWING:

aBp&&
Petil-ioner-Institution is before this court praying to
direct the respondent N'.1 to acl.rit childi:en in
Government schools first and tLren tlpon tfie completion
of
admission in the Government schoors, to *ilot seals
under
RTE Act in so far as the pelitioner's,; instit'tion is
concerned.

2' The question raised i. this writ petition is

similar to the one raise<l and considered by this c,lrrt
in
w.P. No. 482s/2ors and connectecr writ petitions. This
 a)
")

court on 1 6.0 L2O I T clisposed of the above said writ

petiti<-lns.

ln te,':rrrs of ttre obsr:rvations ma,Ce in W.p"

No.4825/ 2O16 ancl crtnnecled nratters,
this petition also
stands disposL:d of.

sd/-
JUD13tr
Bsv

TIRUE COPY'
(
^-.
\l,.ht.\4)tr) 111
;eetrc'n ()iiiL."c, ) .>.
Hrgh Court of Xarnatake
/-l
[Jerga.luru-sdo OOI

wzi'
rf,
rvlttch lite a1>Pltca$on

frf
.,'r. r,'|1 6rr iir(.. ;L'^ll'X"""
:' r .rllryl for
r):1!,r 'i and addttionar
cl rr: .r' tl/[)atd
..pr r rcadv ,-)Zr)f I
c)
... " tt:t coPY ts reCcN'
el
)-l>lt'+
;)rl\ :il rl is requrre)
ll
.,,,,,. ..ti".{t1.fit"r
' '
,.,, ,, ,t," J,Py rs
i>. lrl e
(,

r)
-''t:'-rr:!ii#'
^ , ,*-\
? ,l -c,-wtr---/
 IN ]'Htr HI.]FI COURT'OF KARNATAKA, BtrNGALURU
/"
DAl'trT) THIS ]]IE, 1BTH DAY OF JANUAR:Y, 2OI7
BEFORE

T}LE HON']3LE MR.JUS'IC.o L. NARAYANIT

SWAMY

N - RESI

EEIWEEI{i

SRI.GURU GRIJH ]'RUS

NO.6C)5, 15rr{ CROSS, 6ru pHASB.
J.P. NAGAR
BANGALORB - 560 O78,
BY IT{J MANz\GING TRUS,TEE.
MRS..TAYA SUPTI,
w/ o rvrR. SURYANARANAN.
AGED ABOUT 74 YtrARS.
... PBTITIONER
(BY SI?I.BASAVARAJ S, Ailv.)
AND:

1. IJlATB O]I KARI\ATAKA

]3Y ITS PRINCIPAL SI'CRtrTARY,
]f BPARTMENT OF EDUCATION.
M ULTISTORIED TsUILDING.
VIDHANAVEEDHI,
]]BNGALURU-550 OO 1"

2. THE CON4MISSIONtrIR FOR

PUBLIC INSTRUC]TION,
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTION.
OF'FICB OF THtr COMMISSIONER

l'h r s Cer
r i f i ed copy
conrar ns..........i.r,.rrr.,
-\nd Copying
r(eceived
ciarges of t...........;O.:*1,-
 '),

FOI? PUBLIC INSTRUC'I'ION,

NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BEIqGI\LURU-560 OO ] .

3. THE BLOCK trDUCATIO]\ OFF]C}fR,

SHANKARAPURAM,
BANGALORE-560 OO 1.

4. NAT] ONAL COMMISSIOII ]TO}T MINORI']]Y

trDUCATIONAL INSTITUTI ONS,
GATD No.4, lsr FLOOR,
JtrI'VAN TARA BUILDING,
PATI'L CHOWK, NO.s,
SANSAD MARG, NEW DEI,HI- 110 OO 1,
BY I'IS RBGISTRAR
". "RESPOI\DENTS

(BY SRI. FI.T.NARENDRA PRASA.D, AGA FOR R-1 'fO 3,

SRI.KRISHNA S.DIXIT, ASG FOR R-4)

IS ITILED L]ND]'R ARTICt,tr 226

THISJ WRIT PETITION
OF THtr CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO QUASH
THtr GOVERNMENT ORDER AS PEFi ANNI'XURE-N
DATED .2OI2 ISI]UtrD I]Y THB R- I. AS BEING
VIOLATIVE OF ARTICLE 30 OF T'F{E COI{STIT'UTION OF
'24.7
INDIA AS IT VIOLATtrS THE FUI{DAMEI\TAL RIG}{TS OF
THE UNI\IDED MINORITY BDIJCATIOI\ ]NSTII*{JTIONS
AND ETC.

THIIJ PtrTITION COMING ON FOR ORDBRS THIS

DAY, THE COURT IVIADE THE FOI,LOWING:

OR,DBR.

Petitioner-Institution is before this court pr:ayirrg to

quash the Government Order as per Annt3xllre-l{ dated

\1
I
I
 24.7.',2or2 ir;stLed by the ttr-1 as being violative oi'Article
30
of ther consiitrrtion of tnclia as it violates the fundarnental
rights of [he Unaicle,l ]vlinority Education Institulions:
and
for otiler corrsequential relief's.

2" l'he questi.n raisecl in this wriLt petition is

simil:ir to the one r:rised a'd conside'ed by this court in
w'P" l\o. 4tJ2s/2ors ancr con.ected writ pr:titions. This
cou't on 16'01.2017, disposed of the above said writ
petitions.

In terms of the observations macle in W.p.

No.4B25l2016 and connected rrratters, this petition
also
stands disposed of.

sd/-
JUDGtr

'I'RUE COPY'
()n v.'rllctl th: appltcatlolr !ra-
I rl> lr ''\ 1"5]t t4'rt'f r , ,,/-
rr u*,1r h ch,rrges ald arlriitidnal
.r:rlled for'
Y.)t d.,' 6, ;'.",-I5.
Hgh Cotrr.i of Karnatah
i ;
.., r,.,: r).:i ilir'l additlona.r
Brrygrr.luru-S{0 OOI
'...
^rg.i,'l-'airi
 1,>:E
L^0

IN ]'HE HIGI.I COUIR'I'O}.- IU\RNATAKA. BEI\IGALURU

.r'
DATtrT) 1'FIIS TI{E IB'TII DAY- OF JANUATTY, 2OT7

I]F)F'ORI'

THE HCIN'BLE 1\,TR"JIJSTICB L. NARAYAN.A SWAMY

-/'
:ME!T_!'E'UI[(|

BETV/EEN:

SHIKSFIANA GANGA. trDUCATION TRUST (R)

BELL,ARII _ 57II 2I2,
SULI,IA'IALUI(
DAKIJFIINA KANNAL]A DI STRICT,
REPFIBSBNTtrD BY {TSi
COIRI?I'SPONDENT'
SRI.I'4"P.UMltljH.
"..PBTITIONtrR
(BY SRI.AJOY KUMAR P;\T.IL, ADV.)

AND:

1. THE STATtr O]] I{AITNATAKA

REPREStrNTED I]Y ITS
PRINCIFAL SECREI ARY TO GOVERNMENT,
HIGHER EDUCATION DtrPARTMENT,
M.S. BUILDINGS,
DR.AMBEDKAR VIDEDHI,
BENGALURU-560 OO 1 .

2" THE COMMISSIONER FOR

PUBLIC INSTRUCTION,
NRUPATUNGA ROAD,
BtrNGAI.URU-560 OO I.
 2

3. THE DBPUTY DIRECTOR OF

PUBLIC INSTRUCTION,
DAKSHINA KANNADA DISTRI(]'I.
MANGALURU-s7s 006.

4. THE BLOCK EDUCATION OtrF'ICtrR"

SULLIA- 574 32,7 "
DAKSH INA KANNADA DISTRICT.
. ".RtrSPONDtrNTS
(By sRI. H.T.NARtrNDRA PRASAD, AC}A FOR
R_4
SRI.G.B.{JHASTRY, ADV. FOR IMPI,trADI]{G
APPLICANTS)

THIS WRTT PtrTITION IS FILtrD TJNDtrR ARTICI-I|

OII THE COI{STITUTION OF' INDIA, PRAYING TO 226
THE IMPUGNED PUBLIC NOTICB ISSUED BY QLTASH
(WHICH DOBS NOT BEAR AN\'DI\TE THII R-4
PRODUCED \/IDE ANNtrXI]RB-K AND BTC.
OR NUMBER)

THIS PETITION COMING ON FOR PRBLIMIITARY

HEARING IN 'B' GROUP TI{IS DAY, THE COIJRT
THE FOLLOVIrING: IIADtr

gnDEe
Petitioner-Institution is before rhis court
Jrrayi'p to
quash the impugned public notice issued
by the
respondent N'.4 produced vide Annex're-K
and for otrrer
consequential reliefs.

1gF Kr.^.\
___:1
Z_
rr,:.ffi
rI"Jq
i';
i"Jq IL
i:t _r^i:
./,
 ,1

2' Ttie questio. r'aised in *ris vrrrit

petitio' is
sinrilar ro thr-: one raised a'd considered by this court in
w'P' NcL' 48'25/2015 and connected
writ petitio's. This
corrrt on t6"01.2OI,7, disposecl
of the atrove said writ
petitions.

lri tr:n Lrs of. thr: observations mia.de in W.p"

No.a825l201(j ancl connected
rnatters, this, petition also
stantls dislto*;ec{ oi.

*cid/-
Bsv JUDGE

<,to);r TRIJE COFry'

\ ,.. \rt^/V{d( 2t,l,(,'>''
\r\
It
\1.\--"'ofticcr
Hrg.li Cuurt o[ Karnnbla
-B.,tg*itl^-560 00t
11

lol
,/, ,/
rvirtcrt the aPPrtcaiT;l
0l
actbittbnd
ill
:.'hl':f , cirarf,es and
bl
.,^llec for
' ' :",'' -,. rrrd additional
'''.
c'l :,',../p:xcr i f. f, -.Y
i.,,, r .cadv ) l) ll
d)
' | '" \'[)Y ls readvl
el ) l> lt>
. '. ;iit"lrt is requlreo r

al >'- ir+
'): :. irrt euPy ts ociiverg'' t9
't)
d \a \r>_
1:If' 'j'':-g3t . n, ,1

\k'n4*)
 IN Ti{E HI(iFI COU]?]'OII KARNAT'AKA, BENGALURU

I)ATED T'IIIS T'I{E 18IH DAY OF JANUARY, 2OT7

FJEFOITE

TTIE HC]\'EILE MR.JUSTICE L. NARAYANA. SWAMY

\ilnrT_B$TXTIon_ N _ RESI

BtrTwEEI[
BHAN,DYA EDUCATIONAL TRUST (R)
1ST FLOOR, ILq.JAL,\XMI COMPLEX.
CHURCH ROAD.
KUNDAPURA-576 2QI,
UDUP{ DISTIRICT,
REPRI'SBNTED BY ITS
MANAGING TRUSTtrE
SRI. K. SUBHASCHAND RA SHBTTY BHANDYA
... PETITIONBR
(BY SFil. AJOY I{UMAR PATIL, ADV.)

AND:

1. I]FIB S]ATE OF KARIVATAKA

IIBPRESENTED BY ITS
PRINCIPAL StrCRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
I{IGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMBNT,
l{.S. BUII,DINGS, Dr. AMBBDKAR VBEDI{I.
I]ENGALLIRU-560 OO l

2. ]]I_IE COMMISSIONER FOR

PUBLIC II{STRUCT'ION,
}{IiUPATUNGA ROAD,
RTINGALURU-560 OO 1 "

I
[.,
fhrs Certi f i:rl crov conrrtns..... ..1....r4;gx
\ And C,rp;,ing ci'ar gi:s
,'{ I
of 1............]..:...{.;:;ls-
Q ece r,r ed
 ,2

3. THE DEPUTY DIRtrCTOR OF'

PUBLIC INSTRUCTION.
RAJ,ATHADRI, MANIPAL,
UDLIPI DISTRICT-576 101 "

4. THtr BLOCK BDUCATION OITFICER.

KUNDAPURA- 576 2OI,
UDTIPI DISTRICT.
. ..RI'SPOIVDtrNTS
(By sRI. I I.T.NARENDRA PRASAD, AGA F()R R1 TO 4
(MA NOT FrLED))

THIS WRIT PBTITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226

OF THE CONSTITUTION OIT INDIA, PRAYING TO QUASH
THE IMPIJGNED NOTIITICATION ISSUtrD BY T'FIE R-4
DTD.12,OI.2O15 VIDtr ANNEXURtr_.J AND trTC.

THIS PETITION COMI}IG ON FOI? PRBLII\4INARY

HEARING IN 'B' GROUP THIS DAY, TH[] COURT T{ADE
THE FOLLOWING:

oRpE&
Petitioner-Institution is befcrre this couit praying to
quash tlre impugned notificat_ion 12.O1.2011; vide
Annexure - J and for other consequential reliefs"

2. The question raisecr .'[n this rvrit petition is

similar to the one raised and considered lry this court in
w.P. No. '+825/2o1s ancr connectecr writ petition,s. This
 J

court on 1(r.01.201 f , disposerl of the above said writ

petiti.ons.

In termt; o[ the observations nracle in W.p.

No.48125/2Ol6 ancl connected matters, this petition
also
standsr disposecl of.

sd/-
JUDGE
Bsv

TRUE COPY'
t..
\W.'t.E LWJu',
. '''
A"$LL41 2 -.>'' lJ
d Karir.ri.
H4qh Corrri r{ri
Ehngaluru-560 O0l

iJ?:
'\'('atlol
I ) l-l^i
"i' '! '
. . r.'!:rc,.' "lrc'ar'rl\it^-'
rr TIr,'.(1J"(: ,r.,Td ^o't':t"::
t'-",r.d
*t.!'., r...- e<]d\tronar,
I ^
,r \1.'',.,',,,
t.-
.,.g(\. I >l{l-
f
i l,Jt ,, . ir , it(\v ."a.dt
.

.:\',' : .r,rfYttt"r-lult+
,J\ !, ,\c.Jnr
i',re(lu6
i" 1 f.}^
e\ il
i,, .< oe\rv(r -of t"! \,J-
t\ ..,. tt L'PY ''
'r l(rr
,,.
-,[ , ,.. '
U ,,,e]jl* .,.'-'t - .a:.:flhrrr^sk!l;
''l t-'*';urur'"*
 n\\1
)'
t t- intr'
IN ]'[IE HI(iFI COUR:I' OF' KARNATAI(A, BI'NGALURU
I-IATtrtI ]'HIS T'FIL] 1i]TH DAY OF 6NUAF]Y. 2017

tstrFORE
"I}{B I-{ON'I]LE MT{".-IIJSTICE I,. NARAYANI\
SWAMY
wglr PIlu
BErwlitrIL
THE S.A. S/\MAD EDUCAT]ONAL TRUST
RUNNING CAPSTON HIGFI SCHOOL
AT HOSKOT]','SAMAD FIOUSB' NO.59.
HOSPITAL ROAD, BENGALURU _ 560 OO1
REPR]'SBN'IED BY I1]S J\4ANAGING TRUSTEE
SRI.N],/\Z AHMI'D, AGED 45 YEARS.

...PtrTITIONER
(BY SI{t.c.R.MOHAN, ADV,)

AND:

1. :THE S]'ATE OF' KARNATAKA

DEPARTMENT OF' EDUCATION
(I'RIMARY AND HIGHtrR PRIMARY)
1!{.S. BUILDINGS, BENGALURU-560 OO 1,
I?,I'PRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY.

2. :THE DBPUTY DITTBCTOR OF

I]UBI,IC INSTRUCTION,
BENGALURU ITURAL DISTRICT,
](.G. ROAD, BtrNGALURU-560 OO2.

f hrs Certif ierl copy .nnr.,nr....-f- ...r.4rryg-

Ancl Cop,vri.B c: :1.1,,c, ;r,' - .. .LtS. .l<:...r,
R r:ceived
 3. THE BLOCK trDUCATIOIN OIIF'ICER"
EDLICATION DtrPARTMtrNT
HOSKOTE - 562 710.
... RESPONDENTS

(By sRI. FI.T.NARENDRA PRASAD, AGA FOR R_1 T.O 3)

THISJ WzuT PETITION IS FILBD U]\DtrR ARTICLtrS

226 AND :227 OF THtr CONSTIT'UT'ION OF INDIA, PRAYING
TO ISSUE WRIT OF MANDAN,TUS "TO THTJ RESPONDENTS
TO ISSUE RtrLIGIOUS MINORITY STAT{IS CtrRT'{FICATE
AND ETC..

THIS PETITION COMING OI\ FOR PRBLIMINARY

HEARING IN 'B' GROTIP THIS D,\Y, THB COURT MADE
THE FOLT,OWING:

AED_EE

Petitioner-Institution is before this court prilyillg to

direct the respondents to issue r.erigiousi nrinoritlr status
certificate and for other consequeni.ial reliefs.

2- The question raisecl in this writ petition is

similar to the one raisecl and considered by this r:ourt in
w.P. No- 4825/2ors and connectecl writ petitiorus. This
court on 16.01.2or7, disposed of the .bove saicl writ
petitions.

\ an- fiti
,, \ sD-'
.-_*._- -.
\---
 3

in terrnt; of the clbsenations nrii,le in W"p

No.48125/2010 anct connected rnatters,
this petition also
standl; clisposed of"

Srt/-
JUT}Gtr
Bsv

TRU-E CC]:T\''
. n-\l\./\/,
\ /\t^-)
r ,r nr| L rLl^
^Sciti.on o;:. ).,-2. l-l
hfih Coun o[ Kr.rlirit-',te
&ergaluru-5'60 0Ol

al I'ire ,Jate on
m t.Je
ttltrch tfre
rpp&cttton
bf ?h(. .t .,, ,.-. ar_
I.i':t", :, .l

'' l*;1ioo1''',
$:,.;,(rv 7)>[rl
. r.LI,r rs ,,t
aaad"
:,. ri,r i,s ,&"{iJrx
' ' ',, tu[-)' ," orr,r.d , i , +
or I a'f ,?-
,;-7o, )"-y:4
 IN THE HI(}FI COURT'OII KARN,ATAKA, BENGALURU

r)ATtrD THrs rr-rE l8r' DAy o" rf*uARy. 2or7

[}EF'OTTE

TI IE I{O]V'T]LE N/IR.JUSTICE L. NARAYANA SWAMY

\rr{rrrlIiurloN No.rsrbii or zoro tppN - RESI/

AND
!qeI]t.eETuIq
BETwEE_l{i

1. ]'FItr ARCHDIOCF]f]AN BOARD

OF EDiJCATION
I\RCHDIOCEStr OIT BAIVGALORE
I'AALANA BHAVAN
I\RCHDIOCESAN PAST'ORAI., CBNTRE
AFTCHBiSHOP'S FIOIJStr
I,IO.5, I\ANDIDUITGA ROAD
JAYAX{AHAL trXTtrNSION
I]BNSON TOWN POST
I]ENGALURU - 560 045
2. CHRIST THtr KING F,UBLIC SCHOOL
BTH MAIN ROAD, MALLtrSFIWARAM WBS:I
I]ENGALURU _ 560 055

3. ST. ANTONY'S PUBLIC SCHOOL

62, SACRtrD HEART'S ROAD
]'C PALYA, K.R. PURA]VI
BENGALURU _ 560 036

4. SiI" PETtrIt'S NTM SCHOOL

DORESA}IIPALYA

'j

lhrs Cert i f i ecl copy ceFrarns.......Y.....,1p.sa,

,I
4nd Copyir j r-. :,^,s;c j of i..........5. ./.a....r,
il c'ceived
 /,

BANNtrRGHATTA ROAD
BENGALURU SOIJTH _ 560 O75

5. BALAYESU VIDYALAYA ENGI,ISH

PRIMARY SCHOOL
INFANT JESUS COMPOUNI)
VIVIIKANAGAR
BENGALURU _ 55O O47

6. ST. ,FRANCIS XAVItrR HIGHF]R

PRIMARY SCHOOL
CHIKKAMMANAHALLI
GOTTIGERE POST
BENGALURU SOUTH _ 550 OB3

THE PETITIONBR NO.2 TO 6 ARtr

REPRESENTED BY TI]E
SECRETARY OF'
PtrTXTIONER NO.:I _ FR..JOFI}I ROStr
.. "PBTITIONERS
(BY SRI.NISCHAL DEV, ADV.)

AND:

1. UNION OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF HUMAN RBSOTj}?CES
DEVELOPMENT
DEPARTMENT OF SCHCOL
EDUCATION & LITERACY
SHASTRI BHAWAN
NE\AI DELHI _ 1 10 OO 1
REPRESENTtrD BY ITS SBCREIhRY

2. STA:IE OF KARNA'TAKA
DEP.ARTMENT OF PRIMARY
AND SECONDARY EDUCATION

:r\
 ,]
J

I{S ]3U{LDING, BENCiALURLT _ 560 OO1

iTtrPRtrStrNTED BY ITS
ITRII{CIPAL StrCRtrTARY

3. DtrPART'NfBN OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS

I{EW I]UBLIC OFFICF'
h]RUPATHUNGA ROAD
Ii.R. CIRCLE, BANGALORE -- 550 OOl
ITEPRtrSE;NTED BY ITS
(]OMMNSSIONEIR

4. DDPARTNIEN'T OF PRIMARY EDUCATIOIV

I'IRUPATF{UI\GA ROAD
I(.R. CIRCLI', BAI{G1\I,ORE -. 560 OO1
ITEPRESENTBD BY ITS DIRBCTOR

5. I)I'PART'NIENT OIT MINORITY

IDDUCATION
l'lRUPA'IHUNGA IIOAI)
I(.R. CIRCLE, BANGALORE _ 560 OO1
ITEPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR

6. DEPARTMEN.I OF EDUCATION (PLANNING)

NRUPATI{UNGA ITOAI)
I(.R. CIRCLE, BANGALORE -. 560 OO1
ITEPRBSENTED T]Y ITS
SPECIAL OFFICBR AND trX - OFFICIO
...RBSPONDBNTS
(BY SRI. BIRDY AIYAPPA, ADV. FOR Rl:
SRI.IJ.T. NARENDRA PRASAD, AGA FOR R:2 TO 6)

THESB WRIT PE'IITIONS ARE FILBD UNDER

ARTICL]]S 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF
INDIA, PRAYING 'TO QUASH THE IMPUGNBD
GOVERNMENT ORDER DATED 18.06.20T4 PASSED BY
THE R-6 [ANN]rxuRtr -- z\l AS uNCoNSTrrurroNAL AND
ETC.,
 A
-r

THEStr PtrTITIONS COMING ON FOR PRTLiMINARY

HEARING IN 'B' GROUP THIS DAY, THEI COUR-I MADtr
THE FOLL,OWING:
ORDER

Petitioner-Institutions are b,-=fore this court praying

to quash the impugned Government Order dated

18.06.2014 vide Annexure - A and for other consequential

reliefs.

2. The questions raised irr these writ pe1-itions are

similar to the one raised ancl considered brr this court in

W.P. No" 4825l2Ol5 and connected wrjt petitioirs. This

court on 16.01.2OI7, disposed oL the above s;aid. writ

petitions.

In terms of tl:e observations :made ir:r W.P.

No.4825/2016 and connected rnatters, these petitions also

stand disposed of.

sd/-
"]TIDGF]
Bsv
IU

I, bl
I .?RUE
{.- cl
COFY,
j ct
cl
,1 "-^
\
l-i ,,ltg*!,|14,,
;"",;;;;;l;T;l* '
 \
/l
\t
b \\\ \

L^A
IN'I}.IE HI(iH COUR]' OII K\RNATAKA, BENGALURU
,-"'
I)ATBD T1{IS Tf]E IS H DAY OF'JANUARY. 2OI7

EIEFORE

TI Itr HOiV'LJLtr MR.JUSTICtr L" NARAYANA. SWAMY

-r/
wqllrjliryrlQrir_N()"r61e8 OF 2016 (EpN _ RESI
BtrTWtrEiTI:

H O SA]VIAN E ALAM ELAIVI IVIA

RAMASWAMY IYENGAR
TRUST (HARI TRUS])
NO.77, "VAISHNAVI", 2ND CROSS
2ND ST'AGtr, GANGOTHRI I-.AYOUT
MYSOP.B _ 5'ZO OO9
BY ITS; SECRtrTqRY
SRI. I-I.R. BHAGAVAN
".. PETITIONBR
(BY SRI. M.P, SRIKANTFT, ADV.)

AND:

1. I.]NION Oir INDI.A

}iIINISTRY OF HUN{AN RESOURCES
DnvtrLoPMtrNT' (MFTRD)
SFIASTRY BHAVAN
NEW DELTII _ 110 OO1
T]Y ITS SECRtrTARY

2. UNION OF'INDIA
N/IINISTRY OF I-IUMAN RESOURCtrS
DBVELOPMENT (1\{FIRD)

fhrs Cerrifierl
66p1, I
4nd copyin, .,
t<ecelvc,1
.,r.il,lt* """'.1.; fr*--
""""'...1.'.../........ is
 L

MINISTRY OF MINORITY AFFAIRS

17TH ]TLOOR, PARYAVARAI.I Bi{AVAN
CGO COMPLtrX, LODHI ROAL)
NEW DtrLHI _ 110 OO3
BY ITS StrCRtrTARY

J. THtr IJTATE OF I(ARNATAKA

BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMBIqT
PRIMARY AND SBCONDARY
EDUCATION, M. S.BUILDING
DR.AMBtrDKAR VtrEDHI
BANC}ALORE - 550 OO 1

4. THE DIRECTOR OF PUBI-IC

INSTI?UCTIONS
PRIMARY trDUCATION
NtrW PUBLIC OFFICES
NRUI'ATHUNGA ROAD
K.R. CIRCLE, BANGALORE _ ]-;60 OO]

5. THE .DIRECTOR OF PUBI.IC

INSTIRUCTIONS
SECONDARY EDUCATION
NEW PUBLIC OFFICBS
NRUPATHUNGA ROAD
K.R. CIRCLE, BANGALORE - 1560 001
6. THE DIRtrCTOR
DIRECTORATE OF URDU
& OTHER MINORITY
LANCIUAGE SCHOOLS
K.R. I]IRCLE, NRUPATUNGA I?OAD
BANGALORE _ 560 OO1

7. DEPI-TTY DIRECTOR OF
PUBL,IC INSTRUCTIONS
 J

I'{'TSOFIII DIST'RICT
IvIYSOFItr - 570 001

8. I]LOCK EDUCAIION OFF'ICIIR

IvIYSOF,:B TALUT(
IvTYSOFIE -. 570 001
...RESPONDENTS

(By slr.l. KRIISHNA .S"DIXIT, ASG, l-OR R1 & 2l;

SF:I.H"T. NARENDRA PRASAD, AGA FOR F'3 TO 8)

]-.FIIS WRIT PtrTI]ToN IS ITILED UNDE;R ARTICLES

226 AJVD 227 OF THII CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING
TO DIRECT 'IFIE R- 1 & 2 TO CONSIDER THtr PROPOSALS
SUBMII-TED BY THE MANAGtrMENT DATED 12.O3.20T6
VIDE ANNEXUP,.B _ D & D1 AND IDTC.,
,ITIIS PE'IITION
CO}/IING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HtrARING IN 'T}' GROUP T'HIS DAY, THB CISURT MADE
THE FOLLO\,WI,trG:

OR.DER,

Petitioner-[nstitut.io. is before this court. praying to

direct the responclents to consider the proposals
submitted by the Nlanagemenr dated 12.03.2076 vide
Anne>cures - D and D1 anr:l for other consequential reliefs.

t). The question raised in this writ petition is

similar to the r-rne raised and considered by this court in
 4

W.P. No. '4825/2015 and connected writ petitions. This

court on 16.01.2OI7, disposed oi' 1.he above said writ

petitions.

In 1-erms of the observations rnade in W.P.

No.4825/2016 and connected rnertters, this petition also

stands disposed of.

sd/-
.IIIDGE
Bsv

"1RUE
Cn)q , ,y 1(/,
1\ r\t' \1\\''lt' l-') ll
rr if.-t'c f
i':"1',,i 1"*.**
'f.ts!" ('" ".,,-560 O0\
Be t14atu"-

L ftta datc orl rvht<'h ttr'' aPpllc-atrilorrr !"-d'

me<l. Il) ll)
hl Th. .lat. ^n "'irr' :1 ch:rrqee arxi addltlo'ral

cl

ei

t,

.-l
 II{ THtl) FIIGTI C(IIJRT'oF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

.D,\T'IID THIS'rHE ISTH DAY OF JANUARY. 2077

BEFORtr

TH tr IIO N'I]I-E \411. J USl'ICtr L. NARAYA,NA SWAMY

a''
Wnl r lurulaNnqs.l 49 68-449 69 of 20 12

Etr'l'wlrEll:

l. Karna.Laka ltegional Cornnrission

for trducation Bangalore (Regd),
2'd cross, Da Costa Layout,
St.'Ihomas Town.
Ba.ngalore-560 084
Rep. by its Secreta.ry
Dr.Sr"M.Genevieve,
aged 70 years,
D/o late P.M.Aseervadarn.
2. KarnaLaka State Minorities Educational
Institr-rtions Managements Federation (R),
No. 126 / 125, I{.K.P Roacl,
Broadway Shivajinagar,
Bangalore-560 051,
Represented by Its President
Mr. C. R.Moharned Irrrtiaz.
Aged 65 years
S/o.[,ate Mr.C.Abdul Rahim ...Petitioners

(By Sri G.R.Mohan, .Adv.)

AND

1. Union of India Ministry of Human

Resource Development (HRD), Department,
Of School Erlur:ation and Literacy,

\y

: lr''.. \ t-h r s (lert i f i ed r:opv cA nra r ns........[l.."..,.p.*..

Arrr,l C'p;,ir)g c: r,.\cs of {...........-li.,l:;;
t( eg1 ; \'1, f,
 z,

New Delhi-11O 001 Represented Lry its

Secretary to Government. of India.

2. State of Karnataka, Education Dept.,

Represented by its Secretary, NLS.BT-rildings,
Bangalore-560 001.

3. The Commissioner,
Department of Public Instructions,
K.R.Circle, Bangaiore-560 O0 l.

4. The National Comrnission for

\ltinority Educational Institutions,
1,'t Floor, Jeevan Tara Building
5 Sansad Marg Patel Chorvli,
New Delhi- i 10 00 1
By its Secretary
...Respondents
(By Sri N.R.Bhaskar, Adv. tor R- 1 ,
Sri.lV[.T.Narendra Prasad, AGA for R-2 & R-3
Sri.Krishna.S Dixit, ASG, lbr R-1 & R-4
Sri.Jayana Kothari Adv. For irnpleading Applic;ant)

These Writ Petition is filed under Artic:les 226

and 1227 of the Constitution .f India, pi:aying to issue
a writ of Mandamus to the respondents not t. harass
the members of the petitioners Educational
Instil-utions by insisting on submitting agzun the
minoritSr status particulars vide G.O" Ed 2,1 trdahiti
2012 (Vol.l) dated 24.7'.12 vide Annexure-ll in the
light of the law declared by the l{o'"ble siupreme
court about the act is not applicable to inaided
minorit5r Educational Institrrtions in reration to right
of chrildren to free ancl corrpr-rlsory Frrlucation Act,
2OO9 as per Annexure-B, etc.,
 3

'l'he';e w.it petitions coming on

fo' hearing this
day, ttre t:ourt orcler the following:

Q_RDER
F'eti.tioner-r'.'stitutions are before this courr
lrraying. Lo issue a writ of mandarnus to the
responcleliLs not to rrarass the members of the
lretitio*er'-Educationar Institutions by insisting upon
subrnitting again the mino.ity status par.ticurars vide
(;'o. No.IfD 2'T NIAFIITI 20i2 (vor.1) dzrted 24.7.r2
vicle Anmr'-D irr ttre light of the law decrared by
the
l{onble suprer'e courrt thaL the Right to Free and
Cornpulsory Education Acl is not applicable to
unaided }zlinoriry llclucational Institutions in relation

to adrnission of children sponsored by the

governme't und.er RTII Act, 2o0g as per A.nexure
-B
and lbr ot.her co.nsequential reliefs.

2. The q'estion raised in these writ petitions

is similar to th. one raised and considered by this

ccrurt irr w.P. r\o" 4s2s/2CIrs and connected writ
 4

petit.ions. This court on 16.A'r"2A1"i, dispc-rsed of the

abol'e said writ petitions.

2. In the lines of observations made in Writ

Petition No"4B25 of 201fr and cortnected lletitions,

these petitions also stand clisposeri of.

sid/-
JUDGE
Bsv

'TRt In cofY
U -i -4'o,oKA',-,
Hglr t)c -:; r Llr :(itrlilriakr
Bcr4ali.,ru-550 00 t

6rj

bt

cf

dl
ti

t
t

b)
 r\1.\,\ f l
)l

I ---(A
IN THtr HIGH COUR"I OF KARNATAKA,
BD}IGALURU
DATED THIS T.HB 18.rr{ DAy Ot_.larfirA.r.ry,
20tT
t3trt-ORu
THE HON'BLE .VIR.JUSTICE L. NARAYA}'I\
SiWAMY
wRrr pETrrroN No. zzg.{pe?o14-(upN:epe /
*** **rrro * no * -3&a*. rr,_tlEps/ 2ate,
r+r+slzors (ppn-nBst -_
IN W.P. NO.2702l20L4:

BETWEEN:
GAN G O LLI SARASW,T\,IH I
VTDYALAYA SCHO OL EDUCA]ION (r?)
GANGOLLI _ 576 216
KUNDAPURA TALUK
UDUPI DISTRICT 576 TO4
ITS BY SECRETARY.
.. "PF]]'I'TIONER
(BY SRI. M.P. SRIKAN'|H, ADVOCA,ftr)

AND:

1. THB STATE OF I(ARNATAKA

BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVEITNMEN]"
PRIMARY AND SBCONDARY BDUCATII] ITt,
M S. BUILDING, DR. AMBEDKAR VBepn,i,
BANGALORE _ 560 OO1"

2. THE COMMISSIONER,
PRE-UNIVERSITY BD U CATI OIV D EPARTNI ENT"
1 BTH CROSS, MALLESWARAM"

BANGALORtr _ 560 OO3.

3. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,

o r F.RQ-_U ry VE RSITY tr D U CATr o r\ D EpAR-f
,-----'-t

/a1 -..-_qEU,RI DISTzuCT, UDLIPI _ 576 i04.

rv I BNT.,
/ /^.,\.-
-'- .' --- \ ',r\
t\\
i) "ti-i\
f ,(
I ;:..' ' i).a.':,.1.,'-i\
,l
l":
1'
\ \';\
r
\\ . .,i..'
-'i'.'t, |
/.1
I
!

"'i / 'let
'" "' _., / n rllr\v co'tnlns""";7""1'r'
r',,nv L'
rtit lerl ,,,,,1r,,::,,,
Ce--rr{,,}rr
I irrs cerrit,.,,
:..\r\
.,r,.-.
.. _ ' ''. /
/ rirrs
,........o..t___^l_
"'^-\--.--'
'- r,lrJ C';!rvtrr!,'
:'e
---l
-_. ,.rt
[]Pq6'vr'rl
 /
h

4. THE DIRECTOR,
PRtr. U hIIVTRSITY ]fDUCATION DBPARTMtrNT.
I BTIi CIROSS, \IIALLtrSHWARAM.
BAN(IALORE _ 560 003.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRi. Fr.T. NARtrNDRA PRASAD, A"c.A. FOR Rl TO 4)
THI[} V/RIT PtrTIlTON IS FILED UNDER ARTICLtr 225
OF THB C),C}ISTITUTIOT,I OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
QUASH THE
ORDBR DT\T]DD 24"07.2012 PASSBD BY THE R-1 VIDtr ANNX-
D AND ET'r1.,

${_I&P. NO=SseslE(u5;

E-DI-IUQp[{i

THE CITI2itrTI'S EDUCATION SOCItrTY

RLTNNIIVG CI'TIZEN SCHOOL AT HOSKOTtr,
NO.18, COFF'EE BOARD COT,ONY.
BE}'IGALLI.RU _ 560 045
REPRESEI,ITIED BY ITS
StrCRETAIIY-. CUM -TRtrASURBR,
SRI. G. AJI,{ZULLA K]IARi"
AGED 53 \'['ARS"
...PETITIONER
(B\a sRI. Ci.R. MOHAN, ADVOCATE)

asJl:
1. TFIE STATtr OF KA.RNATAI(A
DI}PITRTMtrNT oF EDUCATION
(PRI]\{ARY AND HIGHER PRIMARY),
MS I],U]LDINGS,
BF]NGALURU _ 560 OO 1
REP,FitrSENTED BY ITS SECRIITARY

2. ,IFIE
DN;PUTY DIRFDC'I'OR
OF F'IJBLIC INSTRUCTION
BBNGALURU RURAL DISTRICT.
BENGAI,URU _ 560 OOl
 J

3. THtr BLOCK trDUCATION OFF]CF]R.

EDUCATION DEPARTMBNT
HOSKOTE - 573 tO2(t^
.. " RES|I}ONDF)NTS
(BY SRI. H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD, A.G.A
FOFI R1 TO R3)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDEI;: I\IITICLtrS
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OII INDIA, PJfu\ ING 226 &
OF MANDAMUS TO THE RIDSPONDtrNf.S I\OT' T0 IO WRIT
INSIST
UPON THE REQUIREMENT' OF'T'FItr PETITIO},II,R'S
S]CHOOLS
TO ADMIT 25o/" OF CHILDREN FOR 1sr gl,{lirDARt)
THE RTE ACT AND QUASH THI' DIRECT]Oi! VIDE UNDER
DATED 3.2.2015 VIDB ANN-I{, ISSL]BD BY "I'FIE LtrT"TER
tR..3 AND
ETC.,

IN W"P. NO.r.0836/20tr 5:

BETWEEN:

SREtr SARASWATHI TRUST"

NEW NO.6 (OLD NO.33)
CLINE ROAD, COOKE TOWN,
BANGALORE _ 560 OO5.
REPD. BY ITS MANAGING TRTISTEI'.
,..PE]TTIONER
(BY SRI. M.P. SzuKANTH, ADVOCA]TT)

AND:

1. THE STATE OF I(ARNATAKA

BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMEN:I'
PRIMARY AND SECONDARY EDUCATI(fNI
M.S. BUILDING, DR. A]VIBBDKAR VEBDTJI.
BANGALORE _ 560 OO1"

2. THE COMMISSIONtrR FOR

PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS,
PRIMARY AND SECONDARY BDI.JCATI()I\I.
4oF Karq; PUBLIC OFFICES"
?'./'
 4

NRUPA'IHUNGA ROAD, K"R. CIRCLtr"

BAl,ltfALORE - 560 OO1.

3. THE DIRECTOR. OR PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS,

PRIIVTAI1Y EDUCATION,
NBW PtrJBLIC OFFICBS,
NRIJPATHUNGA ROAD, K.R. CIRCLtr,
BAN(IALORE - 560 001"

4. 'IHI'DFJPUTY DIRtrCTOR OF
PUBI,IC INSTRUC'TIONS
BAN(iALORtr SOIJTFI DISTRICT"
IC\LASIPALYAM,
tsAN(]ALORE _ 560 052"

5. TFTN BI,OCK EDUCATTON OFIIICER,

|SOIJ'IH RANGtr-IV,
,2ND
I-'[,OOR, MII\[I VIDHANA SOUDHA.
lK.R. PLTRAM, BANGALORFi - 560 036.

6. TTItr CT-IIEF trXBCUTTVE SECRtrTARY,

COUNC)IL FOR THtr INDIAN SCHOOL
CEPJ t'I ]TI CATE trXAMINATI ON,
PRAGATHI HOUSE, 3RN FLOOR,
]\IO.4 7-.48, NEHRU PLACE"
l\Ew DBLHI _. 110 505"
(DF]I-trTED V]DE COIJRT ORDER DATED
22.04.20151

"..RESPONDENTS
(By sRI H,T" NARENDRA PRASAD, A.c.A FOR
R1 TO 3)
WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE S
1TFIIS
AND 226
OI,' THE CONSTITUTIO}I OF INDIA, PRAYING
TFIE NOTIFICA'IION DATED Z+.OZ.iJZ PASSED TO
'22,7
QUIiSH
THE R-N VIDD ANNEX-J AND E'IC., BY

Eryr'
 .)

IN W.P" NO.14145/2015:

BETWEEN:

AACHIEVE EDUCATIONAL T'RUS'I,

NO. 52l 1, I, II AND ru pr.oons
K.R. ROAD, BASAVANAGUDI.
BANGALORE _ 560 OO4.
BY ITS SECRETARY.
PETIT'IONER
(BY SRI. M.P. SRIKANTH,
ADVOCATB)
AND:

1. THB STATtr OF I(ARNATAKA

BY ITS SECRETI\RY TO GOVERNMEN]"
PRIMARY AND SECONDARY TDUCATIdXI
L'L I2
M.S. BUILDING,
DR. AMBEDKAR VEtrDHI.
BANGALORtr _ 560 OO1"

2. THE COMMISSIONER FOR

PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS.
PRIMARY AND SBCONDARY BDT]CATI(f
Ni,
NEW PUBLIC OF'FICES,
NRUPATHUNGA ROAD. K.R. CIRCLtr,
BANGALORE _ 560 OO1"

3. THE DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC) INSTRUCI'IC

]\ S,
PRIMARY EDUCATION.
NEW PUBLIC OF'FICES.
NRUPATHUNGA ROAD, K.R. CIRCLE,
BANGALORE _ 560 OO1.

4. THtr DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC INSTRUCT'ICI!S,

SBCONDARY EDUCATIOIV.
NEW PUBLIC OFFICES,
NRUPATHUNGA ROAD, I(.R. CIRCLE,
BANGALORtr _ 560 OO1"
 6

5. 'IHE DIRECTORA']'E OTI URDIJ AND

O'IFIIOR MINORITY" I.ANGUAGtr SCHOOLS.
K"I{. CIRCLtr,
NIR.TI]PATHUNGA ROAD"
IB1\N[(]ALORE - 550 001 .

6. 'IHE DIIPUTY DIRECTOR OF'

I,IC INSTRUCT'IO NS,
]PT]EI
]BA}IGALORE SOUTI I DISTRICT,
LtC\L,IiSIPALYAM, BANGAI-ORtr - 560 052.

7. THE BT,OCK EDUCATION OFFICER,

|SOU'IFI RANGE - I, SHANI{ARPURAM.
lBt\i\tcAl-oRtr - 560 004.
"..RBSPONDENTS
(BY SIRr. rr.T. NARENDRA PRASAD, A.c.A FOR Rl TO 7)
'IHIS \A/RIT PETITIOI\I IS FII,ED UNDBR ARTICLES 226
AND :227 OI]' THE COIVSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
QUASH ]'FItr NOTIFICIffION DATI]D 24.O7.2O12 PASStrD BY
THE FI- I VIDT' ANNEX-W AND F]TC.,

'IF{IIIJE PtrTITIONS COMING ON FOR HEARING

THIS
DAY, 'IF{I| COURT N{AD]I THE FOL,LOWING:

qBeEB
lPetitioner-Institrrtions a'e before this court praying to
quastr thre nr:rtification dated 24.07.2012 vide Annexures _ D,
K, J a:nd w'respectively ancl for other consequential reliefs.

2" The question raisetl in these writ petitions is

similar to 1.he one raisecl and consiciered bv this court in
W.p.
 (

No. 4825/2015 and connected rnrril- petitio*s This court on

16.01'2or7, disposed of the above saitl writ g-retrti.ns.

In terms of the observations made irr Vi.P No.4825/ 2016

and connected matters, these petitions alst-' lrtancl disposed

of.

$irll -
JI-IDC}F)
Bsv

TRI-IE C:OPY'
\f,/.-;n.'flt.t .'fr d '( +A ,.-
iii', oiiii.. 2- '2-' 1
|

Higlr Colrrt o{: Ko,rnateke

Bt:nlioJuru-5{YO @ I

r, e'l-1 r {' ii I hr aPpl.tcatt,or)r wa-

bl
r/rfr)
l1r'lr r' i,.i.ges andl adrlttirlrral
.: ,: d l(rr
c) , ,.. r:; rut..l eclditrona.r
' .: / l,1ld
,{l
s...,ctr,))rlr)
rJ . ) t1.. ..,_.t sf tS readV,
> l) ))'>
. ,1 i,.iti is lcquir@
il ,1 ,.. rpy rs oellvdre 1 ir,
c[> [r>
1

|rl R \> l'""-

- v4t-r.r-Yr
^rY\-r:-or

: (' c,J1'2
| 6-