Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Researchers:
September/2014
i
APPROVAL SHEET
This is to certify that we have supervised the preparation of and read the research directed
study entitled THREE-STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING WITH ROOF DECK WITH
RECYCLED GLASS AS CONCRETE ADMIXTURE THAT CAN WITHSTAND THE
WIND LOAD OF TYPHOON YOLANDA, Prepared by JAKE ANDREW BONGALOS,
JOHN CARLO APIT, and JOHN PAUL LAGGUI, that the said research directed study has
been submitted for final examination by the Oral Examination Committee.
As members of the Oral Examination Committee, we certify that we have examined this
research directed study, presented before the committee on September 11, 2014, and
hereby recommend that it be accepted as fulfillment of the research directed study
requirement for the degree in Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering.
This research directed study is hereby approved and accepted by the School as fulfillment
of the research directed study requirement for the degree in Bachelor of Science in Civil
Engineering.
______________________________
DR. FRANCIS ALDRINE A. UY
ii
Executive Summary
The researcher will present this project to design a residential building using
alternative structural materials or rather recycled materials which saves space, cost and
energy. The design is a three-storey building that uses a recycled glass aggregate as
concrete admixtures in column pedestal and beam girders. The project also concentrates on
enhancing the capacity of the structure to withstand upcoming typhoons which the recent
one is Yolanda that swept the Visayas region.
iv
Table of Contents
Chapter 1 Introduction 1
Chapter 10 Recommendations... 75
Chapter 11 Acknowledgements.. 76
Chapter 12 References.. 77
Appendices 78
vii
FIGURES:
Figure 43 Test Results of Concrete with Glass Aggregates for 20th Day Compressive
Strength 78
Figure 44 Test Results of Concrete with Glass Aggregates for 7th Day Compressive
Strength. 79
TABLES:
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Global cement industry contributes a large percentage of greenhouse gas emission to
Earth. Concrete and cement production requires 700 and 1750 kW-hour of energy. The
energy is somehow smaller than the aluminum, steel and PVC production (141,500, 46,000
and 24,700), but concrete and cement are widely used in construction. Hence, producing
these materials definitely requires a large amount of energy which affects the environment
due to CO2 emissions (Bacani, 2013).
Because of this, efforts have been made to introduce coarse or fine aggregate waste
materials. In this study the group focused on recycled waste glass material to determine if
this could be used as an admixture for concrete.
Glass waste is increasing year by year in shops, factories and construction areas. Glass
is a common material used as bottles, glass wares and sheet glass. Glass is an ideal material
for recycling and using recycled glass would definitely help the environment and will save
energy. The increasing awareness of glass recycling facilitates the use of waste glass into
different forms in various fields. One of these fields is construction, where waste glass is
recycled and reused for concrete production. In addition, using waste glass in the concrete
production is advantageous, because it lessens the production cost of concrete.
For the design parameter of the structure, the researchers considered the recent calamity
that hit eastern Visayas, Super typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda). Typhoon Haiyan devastated the
province of Samar and Leyte resulting to a damage cost of 12-Billion with a death toll of
4,011. This serves as an inspiration for the researchers to introduce a higher Wind Load in
considering the design parameters of the building.
2
CHAPTER 2
This also includes the design of a three-storey residential building with roof deck on
which the researchers will apply the waste recycled glass as an admixture and to adopt a
new maximum wind load based on the recent calamities. The objective also includes
estimation of the overall cost of the building and research on glass as construction material.
In addition, the group would also like to address what engineers should reconsider in
light of Typhoon Yolanda, that is using glass as a wall for structures, since glass is very
brittle and the effort is to introduce a new approach in which the glass can be used. Finally,
the study aims to provide additional research on the use of recycled glass aggregates here
in the Philippines.
The major area of engineering here is mainly structural engineering, which include
forming the calculations on design and the estimation of the building cost. The minor areas
where other fields of engineering are required are electrical engineering for wirings,
architectural engineering for the aesthetic of building, and water engineering for the water
pipes and pressure.
Reinforced concrete design principles and design were done by taking into
consideration the provisions from the National Structural Code of the Philippines (NSCP
2010) and the Uniform Building Code (UBC 1997). Earthquake loads and wind loads were
also taken into consideration for a more conservative and safe design. Different load
combinations were used and applied to the design of the reinforced concrete members in
accordance to both the National Structural Code of the Philippines (NSCP 2010) and the
Uniform Building Code (UBC 1992). The designs of the structural members were made
using STAAD Pro V8i, excluding the design of the isolated footings. The isolated footings
were designed using Microsoft Excel.
DEAD LOADS
As stated in Section 204 of the National Structural of the Philippines: Dead loads
consist of the weight of all materials of construction incorporated into the building or other
structure, including but not limited to walls, floors, roofs, ceilings, stairways, built-in
partitions, finishes, cladding and other similarly incorporated architectural and structural
items, and fixed equipment, including the weight of cranes.
From Table 204-2 (Minimum Design Loads), the researchers determined the
superimposed dead loads incorporated in the structure.
LIVE LOADS
As stated in Section 205 of the National Structural Code of the Philippines: Live loads
shall be the maximum loads expected by the intended use or occupancy but in no case shall
be less than the loads required be this section.
From Table 205-1 (Minimum Uniform and Concentrated Live Loads), the group
determined the superimposed live loads into the structure.
WIND LOADS
Section 207 of the National Structural Code of the Philippines states that: Buildings,
towers, and other vertical structures, including the Main Wind-Force Resisting System
(MWFRS) and all components and cladding thereof, shall be designed and constructed to
resist wind loads as specified herein. In the design wind loads for the MWFRS and for the
components and cladding for buildings, the algebraic sum of the pressures acting on
opposite faces of each building surface shall be taken into account.
The researchers used Microsoft Excel to solve and calculate for the wind loads that the
structure is experiencing.
Wind Considerations
Wind Velocity is taken from the recent data from PAG-ASA and NDRRMC. The
following datas are used for the design of the residential building.
COMBINATION OF LOADS
As defined on the National Structural Code of the Philippines, Buildings, towers and
other vertical structures and all portions thereof shall be designed to resist load
combinations specified of Section 203 of this code. In the designing process, all design
loads were considered including earthquake loads and wind loads on the roofing. Basic
load combinations were employed from Section 203.3.1 of the code.
Four major load combinations were considered in designing the structural members of the
project:
Load Combination 1: DL + LL + WL
Load Combination 2: 1.2DL + 0.5LL
Load Combination 3: 1.2DL + 0.5LL + 1.6WL
Load Combination 4: 0.9DL + 1.6WL
The researchers chose the construction method engineering as one of the minor fields
of the study because the researchers promotes the use of waste glass aggregate as an
admixture in concrete. Using recycled glass waste as concrete admixture could not only
lessen the amount of increasing glass waste in our country but it could also improve the
compressive strength of concrete.
As an innovation of the project, the proponents went with the growing list of alternative
aggregates being substituted to concrete. Some alternatives that had already been touched
upon were using fly ash, blast furnace slag, quarry dust, brick bats, and broken glass waste.
Glass is being used as a structural material. The most recent developments have seen
glass used as beams and columns. These new applications present a series of design
problems that need to be addressed. Addressing these shortfalls has been a primary object
of this thesis. In this thesis, the researchers studied the effect of waste glass on concrete.
6
Laboratory experiments were conducted to further explore the use of waste glass as
coarse and fine aggregates for both ASR alleviation as well as the decorative purpose in
concrete. This study presents the latter aspect, in which study, both fresh and hardened
properties of architectural concrete were tested. The results demonstrate that the use of
waste glass as aggregate facilitates the development of concrete towards a high
architectural level besides its high performances, thereafter, the increasing market in
industry.
According to studies about the use of glass wastes as fine aggregate in concrete, this
material can significantly enhance the concrete. By substituting up to 10% of recycled glass
wastes in concrete aggregate shows a marginal increase the compressive strength of the
concrete. They also concluded that the optimum replacement percentage of the glass to the
fine aggregate is 10%. There are also other researches and related literatures which claims
the same conclusion that the use of glass wastes as a fine aggregate affects the compressive
strength of the concrete.
Even though the researchers prove that using glass wastes as a fine aggregate produce
a minimal increase in concrete, the use of this recycled glass aggregate admixture for the
concrete still needs to be studied further. Because thing material could revolutionize the
conventional concrete mix in such a way that recycling wastes material into a more useful
product.
ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING
Through recycling of glass as an admixture, the environment would be save from waste
materials because recycling is a process to change waste materials into new products to
prevent waste of potentially useful materials, reduce the consumption of fresh raw
materials, reduce energy usage, reduce air pollution (from incineration) and water pollution
(from landfilling) by reducing the need for conventional waste disposal, and lower
greenhouse gas emissions as compared to plastic production. Recycling is a key component
of modern waste reduction and is the third component of the "Reduce, Reuse and Recycle"
waste hierarchy.
By recycling, this act to improve the natural environment, to provide healthy water, air,
and land for human habitation and for other organisms, and to clean up pollution sites are
the basic principles of environmental engineering.
The crushing of glass is an act of recycling which not only helps the community get rid
of the waste materials but also to help the environment clean and to help the other people
making a profit from it. There are so many people selling glass bottles to be recycled in
glass plants which these factories will then use high powered machine to remolded these
glasses. These machine uses produces heat from incineration and thus polluting the air
through the production of carbon dioxide and the chemical solutions used to disinfect the
materials which is then dropped to a nearby rivers and lakes and thus polluting the water.
7
The figure shows the sample of the crushed glass sieve in the sieve # 100. The size of
aggregate is 4.75mm. It will be used as a concrete admixture which covers the 10% of the
total volume of the ASTM standard concrete cylinder for material testing.
In this research silicate glass is used. This type of glass generally has the property of
being transparent, because of this it has many applications; bottles for alcoholic beverages,
light bulbs, and etc. Therefore making this type of glass as an abundant waste material.
Silica (SiO2) is the common fundamental constituent of this glass type. The property of
Silica has been used to advantage by grinding it into a fine glass powder (GLP) for
incorporation into concrete as a pozzolanic material. Pozzolanic material like Silica does
not contain cementing property but in a finely divided form and in the presence of moisture
and chemically react to calcium hydroxide at ordinary temperature to form compounds
possessing cementitious properties.
8
AutoCAD
This software will provide mostly the architectural and structural plans of the
structure.
Staad PRO V8i
This software will help in designing the structure frames. It uses mainly on
beams, columns, foundations, and trusses. It also checks the stability of the
structure and its adequacy.
Google SketchUp
This is used to create better perspective view on the structure.
Superstructure
Design of beams
Design of columns
Design of slabs
Design of walls
Design of trusses
For the environmental protection and conservation, the materials to be used for the
construction of the said project will meet the norms for green design and will help in
reducing the emission of carbon dioxide as much as possible. Improved ventilation design
will be incorporated with the structure so that power consumption will be minimized.
10
Chapter 3
The three-storey residential building will be situated at Lot 14 Block 2 Newton Street
Filinvest 2-Heights Quezon City.
Figure 1 Location where the project will be constructed with existing infrastructure
11
This project is a design of a three-storey residential building with roof deck is located at
Lot 14 Block 2 Newton Street Filinvest 2-Heights Quezon City. The materials used in the
structure will be economical and the added admixture will enhance the strength of the
concrete thus making the structure safe and compliant.
3.1.6.2 Excavation
Excavation and cut/fill of land.
Finishing
Since this is a residential building; the structure will only be operational right after the
beneficiary occupied/take-over the said building.
Unless the beneficiary ceases to fund the said project, abandonment phase is not
expected. Because the project is a residential building, therefore the structure will be built
to be occupied.
13
The project is located where there are lots of grasses. There are houses on the left and
the rear when facing the road. The project location is located inside a subdivision. The lot
area of the site is estimated to be 280 square meters.
The project location can sustain life since there are grasses and likely a plant since the
owner planted a plant on two corners of the lot area at the rear. Theres no animals sighted
on the project site.
The effect of this project to the socio-cultural and economic is insignificant since it is a
residential building that will be occupied by more or less 4 people but on political term its
on a different matter. It will affect the home owners organization and also their decision
making system.
The effect of this project being undone is also insignificant, even without the completion
of the project; the area will remain as it was before.
14
The environmental issues are noise generated, air quality, and water quality. Noise
generated in the site greatly affects the surrounding area, since it is a residential
subdivision, people might complain about it. Other factor like air and water quality also
affects the area. The air is quite critical because of the dust and debris that could lead to
accidents. Water quality needed to secure for the workers and the removal of water during
rainy season in the site.
3.4.1 Summary Matrix of Mitigation and Enhancement Measures, Estimated Cost and Responsibilities
Table 2. Summary Matrix of Mitigation and Enhancement Measures, Estimated Cost and Responsibilities
Significant Mitigating/Enhancement
Environmental Impact Possible Impacts Measure Responsibilities
2. Solid waste Causes pollution and spread of disease By employing a good solid Association
waste management program
4. Ecological Existing plants will almost likely to be Planting plants on every Developer
completely wiped out available space will
compensate the plants and
trees that was removed
17
Construction Stage
CHAPTER 4
Research Component
4.1 Abstract
The terms global warming and climate change has been commonly used and hear
recently. This is due to the erratic weather the planet Earth has been undergoing lately. It
can be attributed to the growth of population, and the subsequent destruction of the
environment. Super Typhoons are beginning to reach never-before-heard-of speeds
surpassing the 250kph mark wind velocity, which greatly affects the structural integrity as
the NSCP codes for wind velocity. As a possible response to this, the proponents thought
that a residential structure with roof deck for additional spaces and for safety purposes
seemed like a viable project to do. Coupled with the innovation of using substitute
aggregates in a form of recycled glass, it also keeps within the theme of being
environmental-friendly, and economical by helping to reduce waste that damages the
surrounding environment.
Refrain from using glass cladding for your structure (Engr. Cervantes, 2013).
From the above statement; the researchers gained the inspiration to present a new field
on where the glass material can be used. Since the recent typhoon that hit the Visayas region
results to devastating damages to residential structures, specifically in windows and glass
structures. The researchers will try to promote the awareness in the society that nowadays
normal glass structures may not be able to withstand the future typhoon wind loads, and
for the authorities to consider revising the structural codes of the Philippines.
There has been much work on out-of-plane loading of glass, and in-plane loading of
traditional materials is well described. In reality engineers have been borrowing design
concepts from the two former areas to try and satisfy the latter. It was shown that the current
design methods for glass, based predominantly on design against transient lateral loading
for windows, do not adequately account for the behavior of glass when used in these new
applications. In this thesis it is demonstrated that this is not satisfactory.
21
A new design method was then developed, based on the principles of fracture mechanics
and incorporating limit state design concepts. This new Crack Size Design method was
as an alternative to the allowable stress method currently used in structural glass design
(Porter, 2001).
This reports mainly on laboratory tests conducted on crushed concrete and demolition
debris to examine the potential use of these materials in new construction. Other tests were
conducted to check the compliance with the Specification for Highway Works (1986) and
more detailed tests conducted with regard to CBR. Frost susceptibility where the influences
of moisture content, density and particle packing on these properties were investigated.
From the frost susceptibility results, further work would be required in this area to
determine the main factors which influence the frost heave of recycled aggregates. The
comparison of recycled aggregate and natural aggregate concrete appeared to be of superior
quality than that produced in other research.
During the study, the recycled aggregates could perform as well as limestone and can
be considered for many potential uses. It only involved physical properties of recycled
materials therefore their ability to perform as construction aggregates could be enhance
further (O'Mahoney, M.M., 1990).
Glass cannot be made to conform to a design method created for ductile materials. The
so-called plastic design theory of structures applies therefore to steel and to reinforced
concrete frames but not to materials like cast iron and glass which are brittle(Heyman
1995). The multi-ply beam shows that statistically two or more beams are always better
than one equivalent thickness. This method reduces the thickness of glass beams without
affecting its probability to failure.
This is not about face-loaded glass elements where designs are governed by deflection
but about edge-loaded elements where strength governs and more rigorous design rules is
required. The strength of multi-ply beams are predicted from the strength distribution load
found for single beams (Crompton, P.R., 1999).
The glass blocks must be laid in type S or N mortar with both vertical and horizontal
joints being and 3/8-in. thick and completely filled. Exterior glass block panels have to
be provided with in. expansion joints at the sides and at the top, and must be entirely
free of mortar so that the space can be filled with resilient material to provide for needed
in-plane movement. The expansion joint must also provide for lateral support while
permitting expansion and contraction of the glass panel (Schneider, R.R. and Dickey, W.
L., 1994).
This study presents the latter aspect, in which study, both fresh and hardened properties
of architectural concrete were tested. The results demonstrate that the use of waste glass as
aggregate facilitates the development of concrete towards a high architectural level besides
its high performances, thereafter, the increasing market in industry (Liang, H et al., 2007).
4.3 Methodology
In order for the researchers to obtain all their objectives for material testing, the research
framework should be followed
START
LITERATURE
REVIEW
DATA OF
DATA TECHNICAL CONCRETE
GATHERING DATA WITH GLASS
AGGREGATE
END
The first step is to propose their topic to the panels so that the researchers could get an
approval for them to start their study about their chosen topic. After the approval, the
researchers are to collect data and to review literatures that are connected to their study. In
order to collect the data that will be used for their chosen topic, the researchers will be
using a wide variety of sources available. One of the most important materials to be used
in the study is the internet. The internet provided easier access for the related literatures
and other innovative methods and designs that were suitable in the design of the three-
storey residential building with roof deck. In addition to this, the researchers also go to
libraries to gather more related literatures that may add more ideas to their project.
The researchers are also required to have beneficiaries in which their designs will be
given to. In addition, the beneficiaries were consulted to provide details for the design of
the structure. The beneficiaries for this study would be Juan B. Apit. The researchers were
to provide them the design of a three-storey residential building with roof deck in which
the researchers will apply the use of recycled glass as a concrete admixture and also a
building that would resist a strong wind load similar to the wind load of the recent typhoon
Yolanda.
25
The next step is for the researchers to now gather technical data for their study and one
of it is by material testing since their topic is about waste glass admixture for concrete. The
soil bearing capacity test will be also conducted in the lot.
After some thorough discussions and design analysis, the proponents of the project have
come up with a full design of a three-story residential building thats constructed with the
use of 28th day compressive strength from the test results of the recycled glass as a concrete
admixture.
The use of computer software such as STAAD was observed to analyze the structural
design of the building including its foundation. On the other hand, the architectural or
aesthetic design was created using AutoCAD and SketchUp to be able to illustrate the
supposed outside appearance of the structure.
The structural design of the building is done with the recent onslaught of disasters in
mind. Since several super typhoons have been hitting the Philippines in the recent years,
the researchers considered to enhance the capacity of the structure to withstand wind loads
just like the recent Super Typhoon Yolanda that swept the Visayas region. With these
factors, the design of the residential building is made to conform to building codes that take
in consideration the effects of forces of nature.
For the design wind load; the researchers considered the highest wind velocity that hit
the Visayas region during the Super Typhoon Yolanda which is 275 KPH. By using the
Bernoullis energy equation and considering air flow with a density of 1.225 Kg/m, the
researcher came up with the equation;
1 2
=
2
0.6125 2 =
Where: V = wind velocity (m/s)
P = Equivalent pressure (N/m) (Pa)
26
Substituting the wind velocity of 76.889m/s to the conversion of wind speed to free
stream dynamic pressure, the equivalent pressure that the Super Typhoon Yolanda
produced is 3.621 KPa. Take note that this computation is to compare what is the effect of
this wind velocity converted to pressure and it is not included in the NSCP, thus the purpose
of this research is to introduce a higher wind velocity as compared to the NSCP and to
examine the effects of this wind velocity to the structure. As of NSCP 2010, figure 207-24
Referenced Wind Zone Map of the Philippines; the highest wind velocity is at Zone 1
which is 250KPH but the recent calamities that stroked the Philippines bearing a wind
velocity of 275KPH.
According to the studies of S.P. Gautam, Vikas Srivastava and V.C. Agarwal which are
all about the use of glass wastes as fine aggregate in concrete, this material can significantly
enhance the concrete. They concluded that by substituting up to 10% of recycled glass
wastes in concrete aggregate shows a marginal increase the compressive strength of the
concrete. They also concluded that the optimum replacement percentage of the glass to the
fine aggregate is 10%. There are also other researches and related literatures which claims
the same conclusion that the use of glass wastes as a fine aggregate affects the compressive
strength of the concrete. But the study of S.P. Gautam, Vikas Srivastava and V.C. Agarwal
is not reliable in a sense that the concrete sample used did not conform accordingly to the
ASTM standards of testing of materials, because they use a cubical sample to dimension
of 100mm which is should be a cylindrical sample with a height which is twice of the width
of the sample.
Even though the researchers prove that using glass wastes as a fine aggregate produce
a minimal increase in concrete, the use of this recycled glass aggregate admixture for the
concrete still needs to be studied further. Because thing material could revolutionize the
conventional concrete mix in such a way that recycling wastes material into a more useful
product.
27
Proof of Work
Chapter 5
Detailed Engineering Design
5.1 Structural Design
5.1.1 Introduction
The assumptions, analysis and design of the three-story structure conform to code
provisions found in the National Structural Code of the Philippines (NSCP) 2010 Volume
1: Buildings, Towers, and other Vertical Structures. Tables of loads were taken from the
minimum loads indicated on the codes; live loads, dead loads, and for the wind load is
taken from the recent data of the PAG-ASA (Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical, and
Astronomical Service Administration) and also from NDRRMC (National Disaster and
Risk Reduction Management Council)
Software such as STAAD V8i is used in designing the beams, columns, and slabs. This
particular software was chosen because of its ease of use in analyzing the said structural
elements.
Beam Design:
Slab Design:
Soil properties are important so that the researchers may determine the proper type of
footing to be used. According to the soil investigation report, the soil bearing capacity of
the land in Quezon City is 125KPa. The soil bearing capacity is said to be strong therefore
the researchers used an isolated square footing for their project.
Isolated
Square
F-1 500 2000 2000 20 20 Footing
45
2-16mm bar
The table show the percentage of recycled glass aggregate that can be substituted to
enhance the concrete properties in relation to the results provided by the studies. The
final mix used was 1:2:3; which is almost similar with the computations using ACI
method.
Table 10: Concrete Mix
CONCRETE MIX
Conventional Recycled Glass
90% 10%
Through the ACI method the amount of conventional concrete were estimated thus
providing also the amount recycled glass aggregates to be used.
Elevation plan:
The major area of engineering here is mainly structural engineering, which include
forming the calculations on design and the estimation of the building cost. The minor areas
where other fields of engineering are required are electrical engineering for wirings,
architectural engineering for the aesthetic of building, and water engineering for the water
pipes and pressure.
Reinforced concrete design principles and design were done by taking into
consideration the provisions from the National Structural Code of the Philippines (NSCP
2010) and the Uniform Building Code (UBC 1997). Earthquake loads and wind loads were
also taken into consideration for a more conservative and safe design. Different load
combinations were used and applied to the design of the reinforced concrete members in
accordance to both the National Structural Code of the Philippines (NSCP 2010) and the
Uniform Building Code (UBC 1992). The designs of the structural members were made
using STAAD Pro V8i, excluding the design of the isolated footings. The isolated footings
were designed using Microsoft Excel.
DEAD LOADS
As stated in Section 204 of the National Structural of the Philippines: Dead loads
consist of the weight of all materials of construction incorporated into the building or other
structure, including but not limited to walls, floors, roofs, ceilings, stairways, built-in
partitions, finishes, cladding and other similarly incorporated architectural and structural
items, and fixed equipment, including the weight of cranes.
From Table 204-2 (Minimum Design Loads), the researchers determined the
superimposed dead loads incorporated in the structure.
LIVE LOADS
As stated in Section 205 of the National Structural Code of the Philippines: Live loads
shall be the maximum loads expected by the intended use or occupancy but in no case shall
be less than the loads required be this section.
61
From Table 205-1 (Minimum Uniform and Concentrated Live Loads), the group
determined the superimposed live loads into the structure.
WIND LOADS
Section 207 of the National Structural Code of the Philippines states that: Buildings,
towers, and other vertical structures, including the Main Wind-Force Resisting System
(MWFRS) and all components and cladding thereof, shall be designed and constructed to
resist wind loads as specified herein. In the design wind loads for the MWFRS and for the
components and cladding for buildings, the algebraic sum of the pressures acting on
opposite faces of each building surface shall be taken into account.
The researchers used Microsoft Excel to solve and calculate for the wind loads that
the structure is experiencing.
Wind Considerations
Wind Velocity is taken from the recent data from PAG-ASA and NDRRMC. The
following datas are used for the design of the residential building.
COMBINATION OF LOADS
As defined on the National Structural Code of the Philippines, Buildings, towers and
other vertical structures and all portions thereof shall be designed to resist load
combinations specified of Section 203 of this code. In the designing process, all design
loads were considered including earthquake loads and wind loads on the roofing. Basic
load combinations were employed from Section 203.3.1 of the code.
62
Four major load combinations were considered in designing the structural members of
the project:
Load Combination 1: DL + LL + WL
Load Combination 2: 1.2DL + 0.5LL
Load Combination 3: 1.2DL + 0.5LL + 1.6WL
Load Combination 4: 0.9DL + 1.6WL
People have constructed buildings and other structures which includes bridges,
amphitheaters, dams, roads and canals. Building materials in present use have a long
history and some of the structures built thousands of years ago are regarded as remarkable.
The researchers chose the construction method engineering as one of the minor fields
of the study because the researchers promotes the use of waste glass aggregate as an
admixture in concrete. Using recycled glass waste as concrete admixture could not only
lessen the amount of increasing glass waste in our country but could also improve the
compressive strength of concrete.
As an innovation of the project, the proponents went with the growing list of alternative
aggregates being substituted to concrete. Some alternatives that had already been touched
upon were using fly ash, blast furnace slag, quarry dust, brick bats, and broken glass waste.
Glass is being used as a structural material. The most recent developments have seen
glass used as beams and columns. These new applications present a series of design
problems that need to be addressed. Addressing these shortfalls has been a primary object
of this thesis. In this thesis, the researchers studied the effect of waste glass on concrete.
Using different materials that can substitute various parts of a concrete mix are slowly
getting recognized. In this project, recycled glass would be used as a substitute aggregate.
Concrete mix substitutes are advantageous in a number of ways. Also, production of glass
waste is said to be increasing every year and by utilizing these trash can eliminate glass
waste production. In construction, recycled glass is also a reliable substitute to the
conventional aggregates provided that only a certain percentage will be replaced.
63
Waste glass is one of the major components of the solid waste stream. It can be found
in many forms, including container glass, flat glass such as bulb glass, windows and
cathode ray tube glass. The increasing awareness of glass recycling speeds up inspections
on the use of waste glass with different forms in various fields. One of its significant
contributions is to the construction field where the waste glass was reused for value-added
concrete production. Literature survey indicates that the use of waste glass as aggregates
in concrete was first reported over 50 years ago. The concomitant alkali-silica reaction
(ASR) by using glass in concrete and its unique aesthetic properties have been investigated
since then. However, no complete solution to ASR has been found and the application of
glass in architectural concrete still needs improving.
Laboratory experiments were conducted to further explore the use of waste glass as
coarse and fine aggregates for both ASR alleviation as well as the decorative purpose in
concrete. This study presents the latter aspect, in which study, both fresh and hardened
properties of architectural concrete were tested. The results demonstrate that the use of
waste glass as aggregate facilitates the development of concrete towards a high
architectural level besides its high performances, thereafter, the increasing market in
industry.
According to studies about the use of glass wastes as fine aggregate in concrete, this
material can significantly enhance the concrete. By substituting up to 10% of recycled glass
wastes in concrete aggregate shows a marginal increase the compressive strength of the
concrete. They also concluded that the optimum replacement percentage of the glass to the
fine aggregate is 10%. There are also other researches and related literatures which claims
the same conclusion that the use of glass wastes as a fine aggregate affects the compressive
strength of the concrete.
Even though the researchers prove that using glass wastes as a fine aggregate produce
a minimal increase in concrete, the use of this recycled glass aggregate admixture for the
concrete still needs to be studied further. Because thing material could revolutionize the
conventional concrete mix in such a way that recycling wastes material into a more useful
product.
For the design of concrete mix, the researchers used the ACI concrete mix design
method. With this type of design method, the researchers were able to determine the
amount of cement, sand, gravel, water and the amount of the glass that will be used as an
admixture for the concrete sample.
64
Weight (kg)
Cement 13.97
Sand 24.72
Gravel 40.41
Glass 2.747
Water 6.49
The researchers used 7 concrete cylinder samples in which all will be tested for its 7th
and 28th day compressive strength. The amount of the glass admixture would be 10% of
the volume of the concrete. Using the ACI concrete mix design, the researchers were able
to compute weight of each of the materials needed to create a concrete cylinder. Using this,
the researchers could also estimate how many sacks of cement, sand and gravel is needed
to create 7 concrete cylinder samples.
Through recycling of glass as an admixture, the environment would be save from waste
materials because recycling is a process to change waste materials into new products to
prevent waste of potentially useful materials, reduce the consumption of fresh raw
materials, reduce energy usage, reduce air pollution (from incineration) and water pollution
(from landfilling) by reducing the need for conventional waste disposal, and lower
greenhouse gas emissions as compared to plastic production. Recycling is a key component
of modern waste reduction and is the third component of the "Reduce, Reuse and Recycle"
waste hierarchy.
By recycling, this act to improve the natural environment, to provide healthy water, air,
and land for human habitation and for other organisms, and to clean up pollution sites are
the basic principles of environmental engineering.
The crushing of glass is an act of recycling which not only helps the community get rid
of the waste materials but also to help the environment clean and to help the other people
making a profit from it. There are so many people selling glass bottles to be recycled in
glass plants which these factories will then use high powered machine to remolded these
glasses. These machine uses produces heat from incineration and thus polluting the air
through the production of carbon dioxide and the chemical solutions used to disinfect the
materials which is then dropped to a nearby rivers and lakes and thus polluting the water.
65
The use of secondary materials would not create a major source of aggregate but the
quantity of natural aggregate required by the construction industry would be reduced
significantly.
During the study, the recycled aggregates could perform as well as limestone and can
be considered for many potential uses. It only involved physical properties of recycled
materials therefore their ability to perform as construction aggregates could be enhance
further.
Glass is being used as a structural material. The most recent developments have seen
glass used as beams and columns. These new applications present a series of design
problems that need to be addressed.
Glass is the most perfectly brittle materials that exist. Glass also demonstrates linear
elastic behavior right up to the point of failure. This study reviews the current design
methods tracing their development through the century. Current code formers are keen to
bring all materials under the umbrella of Limit State Design. This philosophy is somewhat
inappropriate for materials where the main design criterion is not ultimate strength.
Waste glass is one of the major components of the solid waste stream. It can be found
in many forms, including container glass, flat glass such as bulb glass, windows and
cathode ray tube glass. The increasing awareness of glass recycling speeds up inspections
on the use of waste glass with different forms in various fields. One of its significant
contributions is to the construction field where the waste glass was reused for value-added
concrete production.
The use of sheet glass powder (SGP) in concrete leads to a greener environment. In
shops, many sheet glass cuttings go to waste, which are not recycled at present and usually
delivered to landfills for disposal. Using sheet glass powder in concrete is an interesting
possibility for economy on waste disposal sites and also for the conservation of natural
resources.
66
The figure shows the sample of the crushed glass sieve in the sieve # 100. The size of
aggregate is 4.75mm. It will be used as a concrete admixture which covers the 10% of the
total volume of the ASTM standard concrete cylinder for material testing.
In this research silicate glass is used. This type of glass generally has the property of
being transparent, because of this it has many applications; bottles for alcoholic beverages,
light bulbs, and etc. Therefore making this type of glass as an abundant waste material.
Silica (SiO2) is the common fundamental constituent of this glass type. The property of
Silica has been used to advantage by grinding it into a fine glass powder (GLP) for
incorporation into concrete as a pozzolanic material. Pozzolanic material like Silica does
not contain cementing property but in a finely divided form and in the presence of
moisture and chemically react to calcium hydroxide at ordinary temperature to form
compounds possessing cementitious properties.
67
Chapter 6
Cost Estimates
Budget Estimation
The researchers provided the budget estimation using the conventional method of
construction. The budget estimation was broken down to 7 main components:
1. General Requirements
2. Earthworks
3. Civil and Structural works
4. Architectural works
5. Waterproofing
6. Electrical works
7. Sanitary works
These 7 components were summed up as the total material cost. The researchers also
included the labor cost for each of the 7 components.
The computation of the general requirements includes the mobilization and
demobilization cost consisted of the mobilization of materials from the manufacturers of
suppliers to the project site, cost of temporary facilities, permits, licenses and other required
papers, and also the water and power supply.
The computation of the civil and structural works included concreting, rebar works,
masonry works, formworks and also the labor cost.
The computation of the architectural works included the cost of the interior and exterior
walls, flooring and ceiling.
The total project cost for the conventional design is 6,178,500.00
68
IV ARCHITECTURAL
69
A. Walls
Partition Walls 203.76 sq.m 500.00 102,000.00
Exterior Walls 255.56 sq.m 500.00 128,000.00
Labor 70,000.00
B Floorings 336q.m
Tileworks
Polished Tiles (300mmx300mm) 2800 pcs 30 84,000.00
Labor 70,000.00
C Ceiling
Gypsum board (0.60mx0.60m) 700 pcs 110.00 77,000.00
Others
ABC Tile Adhesive 50 bags 970.00 49,000.00
Labor 70,000.00
Sub-total 650,000.00
V WATERPROOFING
Cement waterproofing solution
gallons 5 5,000.00 25,000.00
(Integral type)
Cementicious water proofing
gallons 5 5,000.00 25,000.00
compound (Top Coat)
Labor Cost 1,000.00
Sub-total 51,000.00
Chapter 7
Project Schedule
The researchers proposed three-storey residential building with roof deck with recycled
glass as concrete admixture has a duration of 167 days or roughly six (6) months. The first
stage of the project includes the permit acquisition which includes the barangay and
municipal permit. After it, sourcing and purchasing of the needed materials and
construction equipment is done. The next stage is the implementation of the project which
includes the foundation works (20 days), substructure construction (10 days) and the
superstructure construction (120 days). The last stage of the project includes the testing and
commissioning, and the awarding of final acceptance tests and certificates.
Once all major construction works are done, finishing works will follow including tile
and welding works, schedule of doors and windows, hardware, electrical, plumbing, and
lastly painting works.
71
Chapter 8
Promotional Material
Chapter 9
Conclusion and Summary
This project, Three-story residential building with roof deck using recycled glass as
aggregates and designed in fulfillment of the course CE Project, is a type of residential
building that is designed to withstand a huge amount of wind load such as the wind load of
the recent Super Typhoon Yolanda. This project is also for the benefit of residents of
Quezon City in case such typhoon with a high wind load hit the place.
Using different materials that can substitute various parts of a concrete mix are slowly
getting recognized. In this project, recycled glass would be used as a substitute aggregate.
Concrete mix substitutes are advantageous in a number of ways. Also, production of glass
waste is said to be increasing every year and by utilizing these trash can eliminate glass
waste production. In construction, recycled glass is also a reliable substitute to the
conventional aggregates provided that only a certain percentage will be replaced, in this
case, 10% of the volume of the concrete.
In this research silicate glass is used. This type of glass generally has the property of
being transparent, because of this it has many applications; bottles for alcoholic beverages,
light bulbs, and etc. Therefore making this type of glass as an abundant waste material.
Silica (SiO2) is the common fundamental constituent of this glass type. The property of
Silica has been used to advantage by grinding it into a fine glass powder (GLP) for
incorporation into concrete as a pozzolanic material. Pozzolanic material like Silica does
not contain cementing property but in a finely divided form and in the presence of moisture
and chemically react to calcium hydroxide at ordinary temperature to form compounds
possessing cementitious properties.
The datas from the test results showed that substituting glass as an aggregate does affect
the compressive strength of the concrete though further research is still needed. The effect
of 10% mixture with the 28th day compressive strength of concrete is not very evident. It
is advisable to try a different percentage in the mixture for other researchers in using waste
glass as a concrete admixture.
The objective of the group is to disseminate the idea of using substitute aggregates in
further constructions as it brings benefits to the structure, and the environment. More
people ought to learn of these innovations as to be able to contribute for the greater good
of the gradually disintegrating nature.
74
Overall, the construction of the residential building is a big gain not only for the people
who will live there but also for the environment because by knowing the fact that recycled
glass waste could be used as a substitute aggregate would lessen the increasing number of
glass waste and also lessen the use of traditional gravel and sand, which is usually sourced
from mining and quarrying sites that in turn can be a hazard to the environment.
Also, in lieu of increasing frequency of natural disasters, the said residential building is
designed to resist a huge wind load up to 275KPH. All said, the 3-storey residential project
aims to be a big contribution to the people and to the city it belongs to.
75
Chapter 10
Recommendations
The Philippines is a disaster-prone country. Super typhoons hit every year causing
massive devastations on structures and lives of people, not only in National Capital Region
but on the whole country. These disasters are caused by nature, and thus cant be prevented,
but the people should learn from past experiences and adopt to be prepared for the future
although accidents cant be helped to happen but it can be minimized.
Appropriate measures in response to these disasters are a different matter though. With
proper preparations and facilities, casualties and fatalities can be prevented, or at least
toned down to acceptable values. Having a residential structure that can withstand a super
typhoons should now be considered, and also the researchers would like to recommend a
structure with roof deck instead of having a GI roof of metal sheet roof because it is more
prone to get blown up by the wind pressure on the other hand roof deck is more logical
concept in residential structures.
Roof deck is made of concrete, the weight itself is enough to prevent suction due to
wind pressures and it has no inclination compared to conventional roofing with trusses
therefore it is not affected by the wind pressure directly and the wind pressure will be
carried by the wall around the roof deck. And lastly here in metro manila, space is very
important due to increasing number of structures and occupants, but providing roof decks
will give the owner additional space for recreational activities or for any other means.
The wind load that is used to design the said structure still needs to further analyze by
the experts. Though the purpose of this research is to spread awareness that the wind
velocities listed in the NSCP 2010 needed to be evaluated and to update as per the current
calamities are having a much greater velocities compared to the design criteria of the NSCP
2010. The researchers used the same wind velocity that stroked the Tacloban area to
investigate the effect of this increased wind load to the structure. And it is found out that
using higher wind velocity to the structure with Fc = 30.19MPa and having a roof deck
instead of GI roof would definitely increase the structures capacity against disasters.
For the concrete to be used in the structure the use of admixture is also a gradually
growing concept, though there are many more tests and experiments needed to find more
suitable materials that can qualify as concrete mixtures. Recycled glass is just some of
many available alternates to aggregates for concrete. Though the researchers cannot
conclude that using glass admixture would definitely enhance the concrete, it is advisable
to conduct further analysis and investigation to the said admixture. The 10% by volume
addition of glass aggregates results only to a very minimal increase compared to the design
mix. And it is recommended for other researchers to try a different percentage in the
concrete mix.
76
Chapter 11
Acknowledgements
This CE Project entitled Three-Storey Residential Building with Recycled Glass as
Concrete Admixture That Can Withstand the Wind Load of Super Typhoon Yolanda
would have not been accomplished without the efforts of each and every member. Three
people in a group sometimes cant really be enough, and so external help from friends,
schoolmates, advisers, and various sources are well appreciated.
To our thesis adviser, Engr. Bienvenido Cervantes, we are truly grateful for your help
and supervision. We thank you for answering our every question and inquiry and your
numerous effective advices that helped us improve our work.
Wed also like to thank our beneficiary who backed us up and showed his support for
our cause despite being occupied with his own duties and responsibilities to serve his
constituents.
We offer our gratitude to our families who never tired in supporting us in every endeavor
we underwent in the process of completing this project. And we thank God above all for
none of this is possible without His will, His wisdom, and His guidance bestowed upon us.
77
Chapter 12
References
Bacani, L. (2013). 'Yolanda' death toll jumps to 4,011; Damage cost pegged at P12-B
Retrieved from http://www.philstar.com/headlines/2013/11/20/1258841/yolanda-death-
toll-jumps-4011-damage-cost-pegged-p12-b
Porter, M.I. (2001). Aspects of Structural Design with Glass
Retrieved from http://www.eng.ox.ac.uk/civil/publications/theses/porter.pdf
O'Mahoney, M.M. (1990). Recycling of Materials in Civil Engineering
Retrieved from http://www.eng.ox.ac.uk/civil/publications/theses/o_mahony.pdf
Crompton, P.R. (1999). Assessment of Design Procedures for Structural Glass
Beams Retrieved from http://www.eng.ox.ac.uk/civil/publications/theses/crompton.pdf
Schneider, R.R., & Dickey, W. L. (1994) Reinforced Masonry Design, third edition
Liang, H., Zhu, H. & Byars, E. A. (2007) Use of Waste Glass as Aggregate in
Concrete University of Edinburgh, UK
M. Mageswari, & Dr. B. Vidivelli (2010). The Use of Sheet Glass Powder as Fine
Aggregate Replacement in Concrete The Open Civil Engineering Journal
McCormac J. Design of Reinforced Concrete, Seventh Edition, ACI 318-05 Code
Edition.
Gillesania, D.I.T., (2003). Fundamentals of Reinforced Concrete Design, Second
Edition. Cebu: GERTC.
Sekar, T., Ganesan, N., Nampoothiri, N.V.N., (2011). Studies on strength
characteristics on utilization of waste materials as coarse aggregate in concrete.
International Journal of Engineering Science and Technology, Vol. 3, No. 7.
Fajardo, M., (2000). Simplified Construction Estimate. 5138 Merchandising
Publisher
78
Appendices
Figure 43 Test Result of concrete with Glass aggregates for 28th day compressive strength
.
79
Figure 44 Test Result of concrete with Glass aggregates for 7th day compressive strength.
80
For each batch of concrete, seven cylindrical samples of 150mmx300mm size were
tested to determine its 7th and 28th compressive strength.
From the test results, it is observed that the recycled glass can be used as conventional
fine aggregate. It can be observed from Figure 20 that the strength of concrete increases
with a minimal value due to the usage of recycled glass as fine aggregate. In Figure 21,
though the strength increases, some sample materials failed due to some possible
experiment errors. The use of recycled glass can be used as fine aggregate but it requires
proper handling.
81
Alternative Aggregates
Even though aggregate usually accounts for 70% to 80% of the concrete volume, it is
commonly thought of as inert filler having small effects on the finished concrete properties.
However, studies have proven that aggregate plays an important role in determining the
workability, strength, dimensional stability, and durability of the concrete. It is also evident
that aggregates can have a significant effect on the cost of the concrete mixture.
Installation
Benefits
Use of any recycled material helps to keep that material out of landfills. Recycling
practices also can decrease the environmental impact of obtaining / manufacturing
the material from virgin resources.
New concrete made from recycled concrete aggregate generally has the same
properties as stone or gravel aggregate.
May result to boosting or creating secondary markets around recycling and selling
such materials.
Concrete unit cost is decrease
Freight cost is lowered.
Landfill costs are avoided and waste generation reduced.
And it makes maximum use of the energy already contained in the waste
Together, these factors constitute one of the basic cornerstones of sustainable development.
83
STATISTICAL DATA
FOR SMALL SAMPLE NORMAL DISTRIBUTION:
(From Appendix: Test results of 28th day compressive strength)
X1 = 29.87 MPA
X2 = 28.91 MPA
X3 = 31.29 MPA
X4 = 30.73 MPA
X5 = 29.49 MPA
X6 = 30.56 MPA
X7 = 30.48 MPA
Project By
APIT, JOHN CARLO T., BONGALOS, JAKE ANDREW T., LAGGUI, JOHN PAUL M.,
ENGR. BIENVENIDO A. CERVANTES
SEPTEMBER 2014
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
ABSTRACT
The terms global warming and climate change has been commonly used and hear recently.
This is due to the erratic weather the planet Earth has been undergoing lately. It can be
attributed to the growth of population, and the subsequent destruction of the environment.
Super Typhoons are beginning to reach never-before-heard-of speeds surpassing the
250kph mark wind velocity, which greatly affects the structural integrity as the NSCP codes
for wind velocity. As a possible response to this, the proponents thought that a residential
structure with roof deck for additional spaces and for safety purposes seemed like a viable
project to do. Coupled with the innovation of using substitute aggregates in a form of
recycled glass, it also keeps within the theme of being environmental-friendly, and
economical by helping to reduce waste that damages the surrounding environment.
Acronyms / Abbreviations
ASR Alkali-Silica Reaction
CAD Computer Aided Design
CBR California Bearing Ratio
NCR National Capital Region
NDRRMC National Disaster Risk Reduction Management Council
NSCP National Structural Code of the Philippines
PAG-ASA Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Service
Administration
PVC Polyvinyl Chloride
SGP Sheet Glass Powder
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
1 Introduction
Global cement industry contributes large percentage of greenhouse gas emission to
Earth. Concrete and cement production requires 700 and 1750 kW-hour of energy. The
energy is somehow smaller than the aluminum, steel and PVC production (141,500, 46,000
and 24,700) but concrete and cement are widely used in construction so therefore,
producing these materials definitely requires a large amount of energy which affects the
environment due to CO2 emissions.
Because of this, efforts have been made to introduce coarse or fine aggregate waste
materials and in this study; the group will focus on recycled waste glass material and also
to determine if this could be used as an admixture for concrete.
It has been recognized that glass waste is increasing year by year in the shops, factories
and construction areas. Glass is commonly used in our lives because of products such as
bottles, glass wares and sheet glass. Glass is an ideal material for recycling and using
recycled glass would definitely help the environment and will save energy. The increasing
awareness of glass recycling makes the use of waste glass into different forms in various
fields. One of this is in the construction field where waste glass is recycled and reused for
concrete production. In addition to this, using waste glass in the concrete production is
advantageous, because this would lessen the production cost of concrete.
And for the design parameter of the proposed structure the researchers consider the
recent calamity that attacked the eastern Visayas; Super typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda).
Typhoon Haiyan devastated the province of Samar and Leyte resulting to a damage cost of
12-Billion with a death toll of 4,011. This serves as an inspiration for the researchers to
introduce a higher Wind Load in considering the design parameters of the proposed
building. [1]
In this study, the group focused on recycled glass material and also to determine if this type
of material could be used as an admixture for the concrete that is going to be used in a
residential structure that can sustain the wind load of Typhoon Yolanda. Other problems
that are connected in this project includes analyzing whether the recycled glass aggregates
will affect the compressive strength of a concrete mixture, and determining if using
recycled glass aggregate would be more economical than using normal aggregate.
___________________
1 Bacani, L. (2013). 'Yolanda' death toll jumps to 4,011; Damage cost pegged at P12-B Retrieved
from http://www.philstar.com/headlines/2013/11/20/1258841/yolanda-death-toll-jumps-4011-
damage-cost-pegged-p12-b
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
1.2 Project Objective
This study aims to first research on the strength of the concrete using waste recycled
glass as an admixture. Material testing will also be conducted to determine the 28th day
compressive strength of the concrete. The data that will be gathered from the material
testing will be compared to the data of commercially available and widely used concrete.
This also includes the design of a three-storey residential building with roof deck on
which the researchers will apply the waste recycled glass as an admixture and to adopt a
new maximum wind load based on the recent calamities. The objective also includes
estimation of the overall cost of the proposed building and research on glass as construction
material.
In addition, the group would also like to address what engineers should reconsider in
light of Typhoon Yolanda, that is using glass as a wall for structures, since glass is very
brittle and the effort is to introduce a new approach in which the glass can be used. Finally,
the study aims to provide additional research on the use of recycled glass aggregates here
in the Philippines.
The design of the substructure will depend on the strength or soil bearing capacity
of the site. Included here is the conduct of soil investigation of the site. This will shows
what kind of footing is needed for the said building.
The environmental issues are noise generated, air quality, and water quality. Noise
generated in the site greatly affects the surrounding area, since it is a residential
subdivision, people might complain about it. Other factor like air and water quality also
affects the area. The air is quite critical because of the dust and debris that could lead to
accidents. Water quality needed to secure for the workers and the removal of water during
rainy season in the site.
3.1 Introduction
Refrain from using glass cladding for your structure.
From the above statement; the researchers gained the inspiration to present a new field
on where the glass material can be used. Since the recent typhoon that hit the Visayas region
results to devastating damages to residential structures, specifically in windows and glass
structures. The researchers will try to promote the awareness in the society that nowadays
normal glass structures may not be able to withstand the future typhoon wind loads, and
for the authorities to consider revising the structural codes of the Philippines.
A new design method was then developed, based on the principles of fracture
mechanics and incorporating limit state design concepts. This new Crack Size Design
method was proposed as an alternative to the allowable stress method currently used in
structural glass design. [2]
Britain is one of the countries which have many sources with regards to the natural
aggregate and its approvals to develop new quarries are running at about half the rate of
extraction. The use of secondary materials would not create a major source of aggregate
but the quantity of natural aggregate required by the construction industry would be
reduced significantly.
During the study, the recycled aggregates could perform as well as limestone and
can be considered for many potential uses. It only involved physical properties of recycled
materials therefore their ability to perform as construction aggregates could be enhance
further. [3]
___________________
2 Porter, M.I. (2001). Aspects of Structural Design with Glass Retrieved from
http://www.eng.ox.ac.uk/civil/publications/theses/porter.pdf
3 O'Mahoney, M.M. (1990). Recycling of Materials in Civil Engineering Retrieved from
http://www.eng.ox.ac.uk/civil/publications/theses/o_mahony.pdf
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
Assessment of design procedures for structural glass beams
This is about the structural use of glass. Glass is the most perfectly brittle materials
that exist. Glass also demonstrates linear elastic behavior right up to the point of failure.
This study reviews the current design methods tracing their development through the
century. Current code formers are keen to bring all materials under the umbrella of Limit
State Design. This philosophy is somewhat inappropriate for materials where the main
design criterion is not ultimate strength.
Glass cannot be made to conform to a design method created for ductile materials.
The so-called plastic design theory of structures applies therefore to steel and to reinforced
concrete frames but not to materials like cast iron and glass which are brittle. The
multi-ply beam shows that statistically two or more beams are always better than one
equivalent thickness. This method reduces the thickness of glass beams without affecting
its probability to failure.
This is not about face-loaded glass elements where designs are governed by
deflection but about edge-loaded elements where strength governs and more rigorous
design rules is required. The strength of multi-ply beams are predicted from the strength
distribution load found for single beams. [4]
Glass Masonry
Glass masonry units are used in the openings of typical masonry exterior or interior
walls. These non-load bearing filler panels must be at least 3 inch thick and the mortared
surfaces of the blocks have to be treated to provide an adequate mortar-bonding effect. The
glass panels should also be restrained laterally to resist lateral force effects of winds or
earthquakes. The sizes of the exterior panels are limited to a maximum vertical or
horizontal dimension of 15feet and an area of 144ft2 of unsupported wall surface. For
interior glass block panels, these limits are increased to 25ft and 250ft2.
The glass blocks must be laid in type S or N mortar with both vertical and horizontal
joints being and 3/8-in. thick and completely filled. Exterior glass block panels have to
be provided with in. expansion joints at the sides and at the top, and must be entirely
free of mortar so that the space can be filled with resilient material to provide for needed
in-plane movement. The expansion joint must also provide for lateral support while
permitting expansion and contraction of the glass panel. [5]
___________________
4 Crompton, P.R. (1999). Assessment of Design Procedures for Structural Glass Beams Retrieved from
http://www.eng.ox.ac.uk/civil/publications/theses/crompton.pdf
5 Schneider, R.R., & Dickey, W. L. (1994) Reinforced Masonry Design, third edition
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
Use of waste glass as aggregate in concrete
In many countries, waste glass is one of the major components of the solid waste
stream. It can be found in many forms, including container glass, flat glass such as bulb
glass, windows and cathode ray tube glass. The increasing awareness of glass recycling
speeds up inspections on the use of waste glass with different forms in various fields. One
of its significant contributions is to the construction field where the waste glass was reused
for value-added concrete production. Literature survey indicates that the use of waste glass
as aggregates in concrete was first reported over 50 years ago.
The concomitant alkali-silica reaction (ASR) by using glass in concrete and its
unique aesthetic properties have been investigated since then. However, no complete
solution to ASR has been found and the application of glass in architectural concrete still
needs improving. Laboratory experiments were conducted to further explore the use of
waste glass as coarse and fine aggregates for both ASR alleviation as well as the decorative
purpose in concrete. This study presents the latter aspect, in which study, both fresh and
hardened properties of architectural concrete were tested. The results demonstrate that the
use of waste glass as aggregate facilitates the development of concrete towards a high
architectural level besides its high performances, thereafter, the increasing market in
industry. [6]
The use of sheet glass powder (SGP) in concrete leads to a greener environment. In
shops, many sheet glass cuttings go to waste, which are not recycled at present and usually
delivered to landfills for disposal. Using sheet glass powder in concrete is an interesting
possibility for economy on waste disposal sites and also for the conservation of natural
resources. This study examines the possibility of using sheet glass powder as a replacement
in fine aggregate for a new concrete. Natural sand was partially replaced with SGP (10%,
20%, 30%, 40% and 50%). The Compressive strength, Tensile strength (cubes and
cylinders) and Flexural strength up to 180 days of age were compared with those of
concrete made with natural fine aggregates. The water absorption, fineness modulus,
moisture content, specific gravity, bulk density, percentage of porosity, percentage of voids
(loose and compact) state for sand (S) and SDA were also studied. The results indicate that
it is possible to manufacture concrete containing Sheet glass powder (SGP) with
characteristics similar to those of natural sand aggregate concrete provided that the
percentage of SGP as fine aggregate is limited to 10-20%, respectively. [7]
___________________
6 Liang, H., Zhu, H. & Byars, E. A. (2007) Use of Waste Glass as Aggregate in Concrete University
of Edinburgh, UK
7 M. Mageswari, & Dr. B. Vidivelli (2010). The Use of Sheet Glass Powder as Fine Aggregate
Replacement in Concrete The Open Civil Engineering Journal
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
3.3 Methodology
The first step is to propose their topic to the panels so that the researchers could get
an approval for them to start their study about their chosen topic. After the approval, the
researchers are to collect data and to review literatures that are connected to their study. In
order to collect the data that will be used for their chosen topic, the researchers will be
using a wide variety of sources available. One of the most important materials to be used
in the study is the internet. The internet provided easier access for the related literatures
and other innovative methods and designs that were suitable in the design of the proposed
three-storey residential building with roof deck. In addition to this, the researchers also go
to libraries to gather more related literatures that may add more ideas to their proposed
project.
The researchers are also required to have beneficiaries in which their designs will
be given to. In addition, the beneficiaries were consulted to provide details for the design
of the structure. The beneficiaries for this study would be Juan B. Apit. The researchers
were to provide them the design of a three-storey residential building with roof deck in
which the researchers will apply the use of recycled glass as a concrete admixture and also
a building that would resist a strong wind load similar to the wind load of the recent
typhoon Yolanda.
The next step is for the researchers to now gather technical data for their study and
one of it is by material testing since their topic is about waste glass admixture for concrete.
The soil bearing capacity test will be also conducted in the proposed lot.
Statistical Treatment
The gathered data will be analyzed and interpreted in order to come up with an
accurate and a well-engineered structure and provide a new horizon in structural
engineering. The books, articles and previous researches about recycled glass aggregates
will be used as a basis and reference in the design of the structure and come up with a more
thorough understanding of using recycled glass in structures. The researchers also uses
statistical formulas to verify the small sample testing and the validity of the study.
The use of computer software such as STAAD was observed to analyze the
structural design of the building including its foundation. On the other hand, the
architectural or aesthetic design was created using AutoCAD and SketchUp to be able to
illustrate the supposed outside appearance of the structure.
The structural design of the building is done with the recent onslaught of disasters
in mind. Since several super typhoons have been hitting the Philippines in the recent years,
the researchers considered to enhance the capacity of the structure to withstand wind loads
just like the recent Super Typhoon Yolanda that swept the Visayas region. With these
factors, the design of the residential building is made to conform to building codes that take
in consideration the effects of forces of nature.
For the design wind load; the researchers considered the highest wind velocity that
hit the Visayas region during the Super Typhoon Yolanda which is 275 KPH. By using the
Bernoullis energy equation and considering air flow with a density of 1.225 Kg/m, the
researcher came up with the equation;
1 2
=
2
0.6125 2 =
Where: V = wind velocity (m/s)
P = Equivalent pressure (N/m) (Pa)
Substituting the wind velocity of 76.889m/s to the conversion of wind speed to free
stream dynamic pressure, the equivalent pressure that the Super Typhoon Yolanda
produced is 3.621 KPa. Take note that this computation is to compare what is the effect of
this wind velocity converted to pressure and it is not included in the NSCP, thus the purpose
of this research is to introduce a higher wind velocity as compared to the NSCP and to
examine the effects of this wind velocity to the proposed structure. As of NSCP 2010,
figure 207-24 Referenced Wind Zone Map of the Philippines; the highest wind velocity is
at Zone 1 which is 250KPH but the recent calamities that stroked the Philippines bearing a
wind velocity of 275KPH.
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
According to the studies of S.P. Gautam, Vikas Srivastava and V.C. Agarwal which
are all about the use of glass wastes as fine aggregate in concrete, this material can
significantly enhance the concrete. They concluded that by substituting up to 10% of
recycled glass wastes in concrete aggregate shows a marginal increase the compressive
strength of the concrete. They also concluded that the optimum replacement percentage of
the glass to the fine aggregate is 10%. There are also other researches and related literatures
which claims the same conclusion that the use of glass wastes as a fine aggregate affects
the compressive strength of the concrete. But the study of S.P. Gautam, Vikas Srivastava
and V.C. Agarwal is not reliable in a sense that the concrete sample used did not conform
accordingly to the ASTM standards of testing of materials, because they use a cubical
sample to dimension of 100mm which is should be a cylindrical sample with a height which
is twice of the width of the sample.
Even though the researchers prove that using glass wastes as a fine aggregate
produce a minimal increase in concrete, the use of this recycled glass aggregate admixture
for the concrete still needs to be studied further. Because thing material could revolutionize
the conventional concrete mix in such a way that recycling wastes material into a more
useful product.
This project, Three-story residential building with roof deck using recycled glass
as aggregatesproposed and designed in fulfillment of the course CE Project, is a type of
residential building that is designed to withstand a huge amount of wind load such as the
wind load of the recent Super Typhoon Yolanda. This project is also for the benefit of
residents of Quezon City in case such typhoon with a high wind load hit the place.
Using different materials that can substitute various parts of a concrete mix are
slowly getting recognized. In this project, recycled glass would be used as a substitute
aggregate. Concrete mix substitutes are advantageous in a number of ways. Also,
production of glass waste is said to be increasing every year and by utilizing these trash
can eliminate glass waste production. In construction, recycled glass is also a reliable
substitute to the conventional aggregates provided that only a certain percentage will be
replaced, in this case, 10% of the volume of the concrete.
In this research silicate glass is used. This type of glass generally has the property
of being transparent, because of this it has many applications; bottles for alcoholic
beverages, light bulbs, and etc. Therefore making this type of glass as an abundant waste
material. Silica (SiO2) is the common fundamental constituent of this glass type. The
property of Silica has been used to advantage by grinding it into a fine glass powder (GLP)
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
for incorporation into concrete as a pozzolanic material. Pozzolanic material like Silica
does not contain cementing property but in a finely divided form and in the presence of
moisture and chemically react to calcium hydroxide at ordinary temperature to form
compounds possessing cementitious properties.
The datas from the test results showed that substituting glass as an aggregate does
affect the compressive strength of the concrete though further research is still needed. The
effect of 10% mixture with the 28th day compressive strength of concrete is not very
evident. It is advisable to try a different percentage in the mixture for other researchers in
using waste glass as a concrete admixture.
The objective of the group is to disseminate the idea of using substitute aggregates
in further constructions as it brings benefits to the structure, and the environment. More
people ought to learn of these innovations as to be able to contribute for the greater good
of the gradually disintegrating nature.
Overall, the construction of the residential building is a big gain not only for the
people who will live there but also for the environment because by knowing the fact that
recycled glass waste could be used as a substitute aggregate would lessen the increasing
number of glass waste and also lessen the use of traditional gravel and sand, which is
usually sourced from mining and quarrying sites that in turn can be a hazard to the
environment.
The Philippines is a disaster-prone country. Super typhoons hit every year causing
massive devastations on structures and lives of people, not only in National Capital Region
but on the whole country. These disasters are caused by nature, and thus cant be prevented,
but the people should learn from past experiences and adopt to be prepared for the future
although accidents cant be helped to happen but it can be minimized.
Roof deck is made of concrete, the weight itself is enough to prevent suction due
to wind pressures and it has no inclination compared to conventional roofing with trusses
therefore it is not affected by the wind pressure directly and the wind pressure will be
carried by the wall around the roof deck. And lastly here in metro manila, space is very
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
important due to increasing number of structures and occupants, but providing roof decks
will give the owner additional space for recreational activities or for any other means.
The wind load that is used to design the said structure still needs to further analyze
by the experts. Though the purpose of this research is to spread awareness that the wind
velocities listed in the NSCP 2010 needed to be evaluated and to update as per the current
calamities are having a much greater velocities compared to the design criteria of the NSCP
2010.
The researchers used the same wind velocity that stroked the Tacloban area to
investigate the effect of this increased wind load to the structure. And it is found out that
using higher wind velocity to the structure with Fc = 30.19MPa and having a roof deck
instead of GI roof would definitely increase the structures capacity against disasters.
For the concrete to be used in the structure the use of admixture is also a gradually
growing concept, though there are many more tests and experiments needed to find more
suitable materials that can qualify as concrete mixtures. Recycled glass is just some of
many available alternates to aggregates for concrete. Though the researchers cannot
conclude that using glass admixture would definitely enhance the concrete, it is advisable
to conduct further analysis and investigation to the said admixture. The 10% by volume
addition of glass aggregates results only to a very minimal increase compared to the design
mix. And it is recommended for other researchers to try a different percentage in the
concrete mix.
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
7 Acknowledgment
This CE Project entitled Proposed Three-Storey Residential Building with
Recycled Glass as Concrete Admixture That Can Withstand the Wind Load of Super
Typhoon Yolanda would have not been accomplished without the efforts of each and
every member. Three people in a group sometimes cant really be enough, and so external
help from friends, schoolmates, advisers, and various sources are well appreciated.
To our thesis adviser, Engr. Bienvenido Cervantes, we are truly grateful for your
help and supervision. We thank you for answering our every question and inquiry and your
numerous effective advices that helped us improve our work.
Wed also like to thank our beneficiary who backed us up and showed his support
for our cause despite being occupied with his own duties and responsibilities to serve his
constituents.
We offer our gratitude to our families who never tired in supporting us in every
endeavor we underwent in the process of completing this project. And we thank God above
all for none of this is possible without His will, His wisdom, and His guidance bestowed
upon us.
CEGE Journal
ISBN ___________________
References
Bacani, L. (2013). 'Yolanda' death toll jumps to 4,011; Damage cost pegged at P12-B
Retrieved from http://www.philstar.com/headlines/2013/11/20/1258841/yolanda-death-
toll-jumps-4011-damage-cost-pegged-p12-b
Porter, M.I. (2001). Aspects of Structural Design with Glass Retrieved from
http://www.eng.ox.ac.uk/civil/publications/theses/porter.pdf
Crompton, P.R. (1999). Assessment of Design Procedures for Structural Glass Beams
Retrieved from http://www.eng.ox.ac.uk/civil/publications/theses/crompton.pdf
Schneider, R.R., & Dickey, W. L. (1994) Reinforced Masonry Design, third edition
Liang, H., Zhu, H. & Byars, E. A. (2007) Use of Waste Glass as Aggregate in
Concrete University of Edinburgh, UK
M. Mageswari, & Dr. B. Vidivelli (2010). The Use of Sheet Glass Powder as Fine
Aggregate Replacement in Concrete The Open Civil Engineering Journal
McCormac J. Design of Reinforced Concrete, Seventh Edition, ACI 318-05 Code Edition.
Sekar, T., Ganesan, N., Nampoothiri, N.V.N., (2011). Studies on strength characteristics
on utilization of waste materials as coarse aggregate in concrete. International Journal of
Engineering Science and Technology, Vol. 3, No. 7.
DESIGN OBJECTIVES:
To determine the strength of concrete
with admixture through material testing
Sieving of Glass
Mixing of Concrete materials
Building Facade
Borehole Log
STUDENT REFLECTION
REFLECTION
All in all I am happy that now we are almost done with our thesis and I
am also glad that all of our hard work pays off. I would like to thank our
adviser, Engr. Bienvenido Cervantes for helping us out in our thesis and also
to my group mates, John Paul Laggui and John Carlo Apit for working hard
to finish this thesis.
When I think about what would happen to me after 5 years, I think
positively that I become a successful working person, I also know that it will
take some time for me to be a project manager and I know that it would happen
someday because that is one of my dreams. So since we only talk about after
5 years, I hoped that after 5 years I do have a job and finally, I could give
money to my parents and finally pay them all their hard works just for me to
finish my course. Even though we have so many problems financially, they
still make solutions just only to pay my tuition fee. Honestly, I also hoped that
I will have my own car after 5 years because I love to have one. Even though
it is not a luxury car, I would love to have any car that I will buy with my own
money because of my hard work. I hoped that I would make my parents, my
other relatives and my friends proud to me after 5 years thats all.
LAGGUI, JOHN PAUL M.
BS CIVIL ENGINEERING
2009107754
STUDENT REFLECTION
OBJECTIVE:
EDUCATIONAL BACKROUND
SKILLS
Personal Qualifications
Computer literate (M.S. Word, PowerPoint, Excel, AutoCAD, Sketch Up, STAAD)
Highly trustworthy, discreet and ethical
Can work properly under time pressure
Can establish good relationship with others
Adaptable with working environment
With good analytical skills
Educational Background
Tertiary
Level: College Degree
Degree: Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering
Name of Institution: Mapua Institute of Technology
Location: Intramuros, Manila
Secondary
Name of Institution: Lorenzo Ruiz de Manila School
Graduation Date: Location: March 2009
Vista Verde, Cainta, Rizal
Other Information
Seminars Attended
Personal Information
Objective
To be able practice and enhance my ability as a Civil Engineering student and
develop my personality towards my career through hands on experience.
Education
TERTIARY: MAPUA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY, INTRAMUROS, MANILA
BACHELOR OF SCIENCE IN CIVIL ENGINEERING
2009 - 2014