Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Julie A. Quackenbush
Viterbo University
Jquack62438@viterbo.edu
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 2
Abstract
Learning is something that humans do throughout their lives. We learn about ourselves, our
strengths, and weaknesses on a daily basis. While we are in school we have the opportunity to
not only learn about ourselves, but to also learn about those around us. While we are students, it
is the perfect opportunity to learn about the culture not only of our peers but also of others in the
world in which we are a part of. Efforts by teachers to be more sensitive and consciously aware
of the different backgrounds of their students and community members are needed in order to
help breed students whom grow to be culturally responsive, motivated learners. (Mims, 1999).
Knowledge is the catalyst that accelerates change; the changes in life experiences, our life styles,
subcultures, and the quality of our lives. Children need honest, straightforward, age appropriate
discussions about the world around them, where they can ask questions and engage in respectful
dialogue. (Michael, n.d.) This field experience report has been prepared basing on the
When I asked some of the teachers of West Salem Elementary what issues the district
has faced concerning various aspects of multiculturalism and diversity I was quite surprised by
the various answers I received to the question. It appears that what is regarded as being
diverse depends upon the interpretation of the word by the individual. Multicultural education
is learning about the respect and inclusiveness for the national heritage of all cultural groups.
(Fowers, 2006)
According to the teachers at West Salem Elementary School the biggest issue the district
is facing concerning various aspects of multiculturalism and diversity, is the lack of diversity
among the districts population of students and staff members. (Appendix B). It is my
experience that there is no diversity at West Salem. The only issues that we face is a lack of
diversity. There isnt much of a diverse crowd, we dont do anything about it and it has always
While there may not be much adversity among the faces in the crowd in attendance at the
school district of West Salem, that hasnt stopped the staff from trying to educate their students
regarding various ethnicities and backgrounds. When opportunities arise they have not backed
down from the challenge and use the opportunities to educate the students and staff. They also
feel as though they use the idea of a subtle integration and try to make diversity education a daily
occurrence.
When I asked a fifth grade teacher about what issues of diversity she thought the school
faces, she looked scared of the question and cringed. Her answer appeared to be that of
avoidance. We shouldnt try to isolate or discriminate any of our students based on their
ethnicity or race. (Long, 2016). This teacher has a new student to the district within her class this
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 4
year. Her new student recently moved to the district from Uganda, Africa. The student was
Caucasian and had a hearing impairment. This student sat right in front of the room and didn't
really need much assistance from me for the exercise they were doing, therefore I did not have
much interaction with her. This young girl was dressed in a head scarf and a long dress that
appeared to be from her time in Africa. Other students were staring at her and appeared to be
talking about her. She went out to recess and seemed to be alone. At no point on that first day
did this teacher introduce this young girl or explain about her manner of dress.
I later went back and discussed my observances from that first day of school with this
teacher. She said, I did not want to point out controversy or make a display of difference in any
of my students. It is my goal to have everyone see each other as a friend and not pass judgement.
I felt (this girl) was very shy and already isolated. I didnt want to make her standout as being
I was able to briefly speak with the Guidance Counselor at the elementary school. She
told me that West Salem Elementary School has many opportunities throughout the year to
teach about culture and diversity. Teachers do take the opportunity to discuss cultural
While in a 4th grade classroom first year Teacher C, taught a daily reading lesson. On the
particular day I observed her class, she was having her students read a story about Jackie
Robinson and the role of African Americans in the1940s. While the story she read centered
mainly on Jackies contributions to baseball, it discussed what it was like for African Americans
during this time in America. It was a very natural discussion. The students were asked thought
provoking questions, What was it like for Black Americans in the 1940s and how would you
handle your feelings if you were in Jackies place? The textbook she was using for her ELA
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 5
lessons had several stories about historical figures from diverse backgrounds. With a brief skim
of the text, I saw there were stories about Gandhi, Anne Frank, Rosa Parks, etc After the
students read the story Teacher C discussed how ideas throughout the story related to a theme the
fourth grade is using, Stephen Coveys The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People. Teacher C said
regarding diversity and multiculturalism, I dont make a point of saying we are learning
diversity today. I like to naturally integrate discussions on multiple topics and cultures to go
along with lessons. I feel it is something that should be incorporated naturally every day, not just
In another fourth grade classroom, Teacher D, said that in her class there are many
opportunities to learn about diversity. Students are given the opportunity to pick a famous
person from Wisconsin and report about them to the class in the form of both a paper and a
presentation. They can choose any person (from Wisconsin) they want. One year a student
chose to speak about the first African American police sergeant from Milwaukee. The class also
does lessons on Martin Luther King junior, Rosa Parks, and other famous African Americans
during February for Black History Month. Half way through the year we do a heritage
research project. (Flottmeier, 2016). Teacher Ds class does a lot of studying about Native
Americans and their culture. Following the lesson on Native Americans the students will go on a
field trip to Madison where they will visit the Wisconsin Historical Museum and see first-hand
Next, I spoke with a Special Education Teacher, whom has been practicing in the district
for 9 years. He said while there are not many students of different demographics in the
elementary school, he does have the opportunity to work with several of the students of multiple
backgrounds whom are here in the Elementary School. Many of the minority students whom
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 6
are in our district are here because we have a Special Education Program that is more extensive
than those of other schools in our area. We also have a few families in the district whom have
adopted minority children. Many of these students have special needs of some type and they are
here for the help we can provide them. (Aleckson, 2016). Teacher E said that he doesnt feel
that there are any real issues regarding clashes between diverse backgrounds of students. No
one is fighting because they have a problem with another students race. (Aleckson, 2016).
Teacher E said, he sees struggles of the student body to be more in regards to financial
background and general misunderstands. We do have struggles among students. But what I see
has more to do with misunderstanding. Someone has a disagreement when another student
brings in a toy that they want, but that isnt necessarily to do with a difference in financial
Teacher E stated that these days diversity issues arent just about ethnic backgrounds but
are also in regards to sexual orientation. He said, while he doesnt know of any issues that the
elementary school or middle school have faced regarding this issue, there have been some at the
high school. At least one of his children still attends the high school and there have been issues
in the recent past regarding bullying due to sexual orientation that have come about, but not
Next, I polled a few community members on their opinions of what issues regarding
ethnicity or diversity the school district or area has faced. One family, who no longer had
students in the district, but whom have been lifelong members of the community said, said that
they couldnt recall any specific teaching or lessons their children had while in school regarding
multicultural education. They could remember one interracial family who had talent with
I asked another family about their opinion of the diversity in both the area and school
district. We are a very Norwegian community. If you dont like Lutefisk, then you probably
A third family, I asked in the area brought up an issue not related specifically to the
school district, but to the community in general. They recalled that a while back there had been
some prejudices in relation to persons of Hmong heritage. The Hmong culture has a very
extensive ceremony when it comes to funerals. During the time of passing all family members
are expected to celebrate in a lengthy remembrance of an individual. One Hmong family had put
decorations and strong smelling food at the gravesite of some deceased family members.
Community members, not of Hmong heritage, protested this. (Quamme, 2016). I tried to find
any record of this event, but failed to locate any in papers. The community member I polled
couldnt recall if the negative reaction towards the event had more to do with situations occurring
at the gravesite or in relation to the students of the deceased family member having missed a
to newspapers about the West Salem School District in general. In recent news, there was a
dispute at the high school regarding freedom of speech. In total five students displayed
confederate flags on their cars. They were requested to remove the flags, but chose to still fly
them. One student stated that flying the flags was a gesture of individualism and rebellion,
(Mann, 2016). The school eventually had to consult with an attorney to have the boys take down
the flags. Instruction on the true nature, significance, and meaning of the flag was provided to
the students. Eventually the students began parking off campus until the flags were stolen.
I had the opportunity to help out in the elementary school library. On this particular day a
group of third grade teachers asked for a series of texts that would discuss folktales, fables, and
tall tales. As I worked with the library paraprofessional to find these texts she said folktale
exploration is a unit that is studied every year among third graders. They look at several texts
from around the globe and study their similarities and differences. (Schneider, 2016) She
showed me a copy of a Cinderella story book. Then she showed me how they have copies of the
Cinderella story from many different cultural perspectives. These are from different cultures
around the globe. (Schneider, 2016). There were versions of the Cinderella story from: a
Italian, etc There was even a book called Cinderella Stories Around the World: 4 Beloved
Tales. There were several texts like this, not just all regarding Cinderella. (The Tortoise with a
Pretty Daughter, The Magic Cask, etc...) Annually the fourth grade classrooms study these texts
and discuss their similarities and differences. The books are placed throughout their classrooms
and the students are encouraged to read and discuss several of them, looking for certain
elements.
A middle school student told me about a lesson she discussed in her English Language
Arts class. Her class studied what racism means. They watched a video on a program called
Channel One regarding racism and were instructed to take notes on the program. Their task was
to find the main idea of the program and to determine what the show provided as supporting
details to prove the main idea. They were simply to discuss their findings with their peers
West Salem is a school district that values education. They pride themselves on
educating their students about the history, culture and the world around them. They do not draw
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 9
attention to issues of difference. They try to integrate matters of multiculturalism in a very subtle
manner. When issues arise regarding a disagreement, staff members take the time to discuss
concerns with the student population. Students at the high school are expected to participate in
the Senior Exit project initiative, where students are required to present, plan and execute a
graduating seniors intellectual, academic, and community experiences. Students are encouraged
to research and expand upon a hobby, interest or talent. They research and showcase it. The
plan is to bring it into the community for a shared learning experience that anyone can be a part
of. Examples in the past have been: dance instruction, sports instruction, public speaking,
blanket making instruction, first aid training, health care expos, drunk driving simulations, etc
On occasion there have been public speakers brought in to the district to discuss financial
situations and parenting issues. The Heider Center of Performing Arts is a bridge between the
community and the student population. At various times numerous acts of music, performance
and speakers have been brought in to the community to promote a diverse learning experience to
be had by members of any age. Some of these acts have been: Mexican Brass band, a Dixieland
Jazz Band, musical parodies, childrens theatre, American Folklore Theatre, Street corner
Symphony, etc The location has also hosted political debates, positive parenting solutions and
art shows.
Based on the information that I have gathered through interviews and observations, the following
list describes issues regarding diversity and multiculturalism from view point of various staff and
community members. (See Appendix B). There seems to be a connection indicating education
and culture are related. It seems as though a societys culture, their thoughts and ideas, play a
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 10
role in telling how lessons are given and how students are taught. Because culture is an
important part of the education system, the education should reflect it. The lesson has to be an
appropriate for students and their cultures. When a teachers directions, in the classroom, are in
aligned with the thoughts of students cultures, the instructions may enhance the students
achievement and confidence because the students are comfort working in an environment they
can relate to. Teachers are people with thoughts, opinions and personalities. Like it or not, these
There have been very minimal changes in demographics within the area of West Salem
over the years. The main race within the area, is, and has been that of white individuals. That
remains to this day to be true that more than 90 percent of the population remains Caucasian
(white). There has not been much fluctuation in the change in demographics within the area.
This is also true of the schools populations. West Salem is predominantly a small rural farming
community and have continued to remain this way since its inception. Over the last few years,
as farmers pass on and less of the families choose to remain in farming, much of the farm lands
has been sold off for housing development. This trend has led to a growth in housing
development in the area. While population numbers have increased, they still remain
predominantly Caucasian.
Over the years the student population at the school district of West Salem has
been predominantly Caucasian or white American. In its beginnings, the Village of West Salem
Caucasian demographic, there are a few minority families beginning to make the Village of West
Salem home. The population has remained relatively unchanged. Because of a lack of diversity
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 11
in the demographics, there have not been many real issues to face regarding a clash among
ethnicities. The district is still making sure that there is some education of various ethnicities and
See Appendix A
The School District of West Salem is not a multiethnic representation of Wisconsin schools. It is
a slowly growing area, but the diversity among its population has remained relatively unchanged
throughout the years. (See Graph 1). West Salem is a village located within La Crosse County,
Wisconsin. It has a population of roughly 4,895 people, 90% of which is Caucasian. (GraphIQ
(formerly FindTheBest), 2009) There is a large number of children and teenagers (under 20
years of age) whom make up the population. Families generally speak English in their homes.
Approximately 96.5% of the workforce is employed. Families generally have two cars. The cost
of living is 8% higher than the National Average. (GraphIQ (formerly FindTheBest), 2009). The
school districts population of students reflects that of the community and has remained
relatively unchanged for a number of years. The West Salem School District is considered to be a
large public school for the state of Wisconsin. There are approximately 1,812 students enrolled
in the district. (GraphIQ (formerly FindTheBest), 2009). The major factors concerning diversity
are more in regards to a lack of it community wide, according to interviews. There are not any
large companies or jobs present in the community outside of farming and the school district. La
diversity and ethnicity is the lack of it in the area. There are not many big businesses or
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 12
attractions to the area. The biggest businesses in the area are: the Farming Co-Op, a bakery, two
Subways and two auto dealerships. The auto dealerships service multiple locations around the
numbers. The median household income in West Salem village is $51,987 per year. This city's
median income is above the eligibility threshold for reduced price lunch, which may have an
impact on the proportion of students eligible under the National School Lunch Program.
(GraphIQ (formerly FindTheBest), 2009) In 2013 the state average spending per student was
approximately $11,900. (Anderson, 2013). West Salem spent approximately $10,969 per
student, just slightly below the average. West Salem also has some of the lowest paid teachers in
the region. They pay about $4,103 less than LaCrosse and about $3,000 less than the state
average. Their max salary for teachers was about $50,000, nearly $17,000 less than LaCrosse
and about $11,000 less than the state average. (Anderson, 2013). A comparison of the local
School District spent the third lowest amount of money per student during the 2012-2013 school
year. (Anderson, 2013). See Table 1. West Salem Elementary was assessed compared to the
other 2,319 schools in Wisconsin on different areas from state testing scores to size, etc The
average rating for elementary schools in Wisconsin was a 5 and West Salem Elementary received
West Salem Elementary is a relatively large school serving Pre-K through 5th grade, with
Wisconsin is 355. (GraphIQ (formerly FindTheBest), 2009). The teacher to student ratio is
1:15. In the 4th grade, standardized test scores were at 45% accuracy compared to a national
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 13
average score of 40%. Reading scores were at 37% accuracy, when compared to the national
West Salem Middle School. The average number of students in attendance at middle schools
(grades 6-8) in Wisconsin is 364 and West Salem Middle School has 357; 93% of which is
(formerly FindTheBest), 2009). The student to teacher ratio is 13:1, which is significantly lower
than the average for all US middle schools (15.6) and significantly lower than the average for
On standardized tests West Salem Middle School 8th graders scored higher on both reading and
math scores, where compared to scores of the nation. Math scores were 41% (compared to 33%)
and Reading scores were 39% (compared to 35%). (GraphIQ (formerly FindTheBest), 2009).
West Salem High School. The average number of high school students in Wisconsin is 301, but
West Salem High School (grades 9-12) has 572. 92% of those students are Caucasian and the
national average for Caucasian students is 72%. There are approximately 15 students for every
one teacher at the high school and that is right with the national average. (GraphIQ (formerly
FindTheBest), 2009).
On standardized tests West Salem high school students fare well. 14% of the students at the high
school take the SAT or ACT exams. See Graph 2. This 14% tends to only be Caucasian
students. The national average combined score for the SAT is 1552. (GraphIQ (formerly
FindTheBest), 2009). West Salem High School students average score is 1771. On the ACT the
national average composite score is 21.1 and West Salem students average 22.2. (GraphIQ
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 14
(formerly FindTheBest), 2009). West Salem High School averages a 53% male population and a
47% female population. Most schools in Wisconsin are split closer to 50%/50%. Three percent
of students at West Salem High are enrolled in Advanced Practice, or AP courses. Of those 3%,
all tend to be Caucasian students. (GraphIQ (formerly FindTheBest), 2009). See Graph 3.
West Salem High School has a significantly lower rate of students who play on interscholastic
sports teams. On average 21% of West Salem High School students participate athletics at the
high school. The average for all Wisconsin high schools is a 64% participation rating. (GraphIQ
(formerly FindTheBest), 2009). The average across the United States is 43% for participation in
interscholastic sports teams. What this study may not have taken into consideration is that the
Park and Recreation Department has a strong support in this area. They have many sports teams
and leagues from throughout the year. There are also year round softball, baseball and soccer
clubs, nit associated with the local school districts. These clubs have participation from students
as well. Hockey is also a sport that sees high participation number sin the area. However, West
Salem usually combines with the neighboring town of Sparta to form a hockey team. These
There are 38% of students at West Salem High whom are chronically absent from school.
Students are considered to be chronically absent if they are missing 15 or more days from school.
Of the 38% of the chronically absent students at West Salem High School, 100% of those
students are white / Caucasian students. See Graph 4 for further details.
Suggestions. While I feel that West Salem is dealing with their lack of diversity the best they
can, I would say that there is always room for improvement. Unless a large company moves into
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 15
the area or farming becomes a big trend, I do not see much change occurring in the school
If they sought out more diversity to the area (invited a Native American tribe to dance at the
school, invited speakers in to the area from diverse backgrounds African Americans or Chinese
Americans), maybe more people would see the area as welcoming and want to make West
Salem their home. The district has been renovating and I think that makes them a more
welcoming location. People tend to be attracted to new and thriving locations. That is a step in
the right direction to attracting more of a population to the area. I think West Salem is doing the
best with what they have. They are teaching some diversity, but more as a reaction. I feel that
more school wide initiates would be beneficial (perhaps a foreign language taught or a
community wide reading event where different texts area read by community members). I think
if the District perhaps, raised their teachers salaries than they may attract more employees from
outside the area to apply. This might attract more minorities to the area as well. I can see how
the few minorities currently here may feel uneasy in the area and not make West Salem their
home for very long. I think a big emphasis, regardless of ethnicity is to begin implementing
more subject based language per class; an emphasis on content literacy. This could lead to
adding a foreign language and opening up perhaps more exchange programs to the area in hopes
of creating an interest in West Salem. One way the Community is currently trying to attract an
interest to the area in by remodeling the pool. They have been raising funds to expand the pool
and build an aquatic center. A fun pool with slides is exciting during the summer months and
Conclusion. Learning is something that anyone can do. Everyone is capable of learning
something. Although West Salem is not a very diversely populated area, it is devoted to the
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 16
education of its inhabitants. The community and the district could do a little more to encourage
more of a diverse demographic and education. Academic language and texts that include other
ethnicities is a start. Attracting new businesses to the area could be another suggestion, along
with increased salaries. Offering more language classes and ethnic studies, is another
opportunity. This could lead to more foreign exchange programs. If teachers demonstrated
behaviors of how to be more sensitive, accepting, and aware of the different cultures and
backgrounds of their students and community members maybe the area would in turn become
more diversified. West Salem is very young demographically speaking. There is always room to
grow.
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 17
References
Aleckson, K. (2016, September 19). CDS Teacher at West Salem Elementary School (J.
Quackenbush, Interviewer)
Anderson, P. (2013, December 23). Per-student spending numbers highlight differences between
Coulee Region school districts. La Crosse Tribune
Buisman, B. (2016, September 9). Fourth Grade Teacher at West Salem Elementary School. (J.
Quackenbush, Interviewer)
Crow, D. (2016, September 21). Second Grade Teacher at West Salem Elementary School. (J.
Quackenbush, Interviewer)
Covey, S. R. (2004). The 7 habits of highly effective people: Restoring the character ethic. New
York: Free Press.
Flottmeier, A. (2016, September 9). Fourth Grade Teacher at West Salem Elementary School. (J.
Quackenbush, Interviewer)
GraphIQ (formerly FindTheBest). (2009, May unknown). West Salem. (B. Taylor, Editor, K.
O'Connor, Producer, & Kleiner Perkins Caufield Byers and the Pritzker Group) Retrieved
October 12, 2016, from Start Class: http://school-districts.startclass.com/l/16324/West-
Salem-School-District
Hickey, J. (2016, October 6). Kindergarten Teacher at West Salem Elementary School. (J.
Quackenbush, Interviewer)
Lassen, G. (2016, September 19). Guidance Counselor at West Salem Elementary School. (J.
Quackenbush, Interviewer)
Long, K. (2016, September 1 & 19). Fifth Grade Teacher at West Salem Elementary School. (J.
Quackenbush, Interviewer)
Mann, Tobias (March 3rd, 2016). West Salem students force freedom-of-speech showdown with
display of Confederate Flags. La Crosse Tribune accessed September 19, 2016 from
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 18
http://lacrossetribune.com/news/local/west-salem-students-force-freedom-of-speech-
showdown-with-display/article_5591ccfa-6520-5a09-89ea-e947c115c06d.html
McKinney, J. (2016, September 20). Community Member in the Village of West Salem. (J.
Quackenbush, interviewer)
Meister, C. (2015). Cinderella stories around the world: 4 beloved tales. United States: Picture
Window Books.
Michael, N., Thomas, M., Starch, R., Loeb, L., & Hendrickx, M. (n.d.) accessed 2016, October 6.
Retrieved from Our History. Retrieved from Amaze:
http://www.amazeworks.org/about/history.html
Mims, Nancy & Robert C. Morris. (1999). Making Classrooms Culturally Sensitive. Education
and Culture. Accessed September, 2016 from
https://moodle.viterbo.edu/pluginfile.php/662466/mod_resource/content/1/Making
%20Classrooms%20Culturally%20Sensitive.pdf
Quackenbush, M. (2016, September 14). Sixth grade student at West Salem Middle School. (J.
Quackenbush, interviewer).
Quamme, B. (2016, September 10). Community Member in the Village of West Salem. (J.
Quackenbush, interviewer).
Unknown. (n.d.). West Salem Wisconsin Demographics. Area Vibes. West Salem , Wisconsin,
USA. Retrieved September 28, 2016, from http://www.areavibes.com/west+salem-
wi/demographics/
Wallace, C. (2016, September 11). Community Member in the Village of West Salem. (J.
Quackenbush, interviewer).
Graph 1
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 19
Graph 2
SAT/ACT Exam scores by Ethnicity
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 20
Graph 3
Graph 4
Table 1
(Anderson, 2013)
[CASE STUDY OF WEST SALEM] 24
Appendix A
What types of issues is West Salem facing as a district (or have they faced) regarding
What issues regarding diversity, ethnicity, or multiculturalism has your classroom faced
What opportunities (experience) have you had working in a diverse, multicultural settings
In what ways have you integrated multicultural issues as a part of your classroom
instruction?
ethnicities/cultures within the world? How are you preparing them to function in a multicultural
What are some examples of multicultural education initiatives taking place at West
Can you explain or elaborate on the specific ways in which you teach about
How does the staff respond to issues regarding diversity? What do they do to step in?
Appendix B
Avoidance of difference
school, or district