Sie sind auf Seite 1von 75

STUDYING UTILITY OF

CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

INTRODUCTION

Study of homoeopathic remedies needs a good memory and it has


become increasingly useful to see remedies collated into groups or
families of substances that in their homeopathic medicinal form
show common characteristic.

These characteristics when seen in cases, many a times the remedies


prescribed are from plant or mineral kingdom leaving animal
kingdom bit aside.

We see that plant families and mineral groups are studied at a large
number compared to animal familiesand so when I see animal
kingdom, Ophidia group caught up my mind.

When most of us talks about snake remedy the first remedy comes
up in our mind is Lachesis and then Naja and/or Crotalus. Whereas
there are many remedies in Ophidia group which are neglected. One
of the neglected remedy is Cenchris contortrix. In the description of
this remedy it was written that this drug is similar to Lachesis.

Then some questions came in my mind like-if this remedy is


similar to Lachesis then how is it similar and if so, why is it not
prescribed more often?

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 1
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

To know the answer of the questions popping in my mind I studied


this drug from various sources. The information that I acquired from
these sources are compiled in this research. We hope it will also help
researchers to gain information at one stop.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 2
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

AIMS AND ODJECTIVES

Aims:
To study the utility of Cenchris contortrix as a Homeopathic remedy

Objectives:
1. To study the source of the remedy Cenchris contortrix.
2. To review the available data on the remedy Cenchris
contortrix from its source book and various MateriaMedica.
3. To study the remedy Cenchris contortrix from the latest
repertories.
4. To derive comprehensive understanding of the remedy.
5. To study cases successfully treated with the remedy to learn its
utility.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 3
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

METHOD AND MATERIAL

Method:

1. To study about the source of the remedy and reviewing various


literature of Cenchris contortrix with regards to:
a. Taxonomy
b. Living pattern
c. Venom: Constituents and their effects
d. Toxicology
e. Homeopathic use
2. Compilation of Materia Medica of Cenchris contortrix
3. To study the remedy Cenchris contortrix from the latest
repertories.
4. To derive comprehensive understanding of the remedy.
5. To analyze the data and derive statistics.
6. To study cases which are successfully treated with the remedy
to learn its utility.
7. To derive conclusion from comprehensive study of Materia
Medica, repertory and Clinical cases

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 4
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Material:

To study from Homeopathic proving, other available literature and


clinical cases.

REVIEW OF LITERATURE

We have seen in the profile of snake remedies a quality of the actual


family is often attributed to one snake, namely Lachesis, probably
the best proven snake remedy. This is the reason that most of the
symptoms seem to be similar.

In Kents Lecture of Homeopathic Materia Medica mental


symptoms such as absent mindedness, anxiety about death and
vivid, lascivious dreams predominates. Mentally Cenchris is
different from Lachesis, as the former is all about sexual abuse
whereas Lachesis is all about sexual organs. Also Cenchris is chilly
whereas Lachesis is thermally hot.

In Kents Lecture of Homoeopathic Materia Medica and Boerickes


Materia Medica, it is seen during proving that it has loss of memory

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 5
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

which is further qualified in Homoeopathic Recorder (1917 edition)


it is given that it is mental exhaustion which leads to inability in
recalling mental impression.

In Kents proving, Clarkes Dictionary of Practical Materia Medica


well as in Boerickes Materia Medica it is stated that there is
absentminded with dreamy state. Likewise, in Homoeopathic
Recorder it is mentioned that there is not only dreamy state but also
mind becomes blank.

Dreams of rape which was seen during proving has been confirmed
by many authors,and Dr. Vikas Sharma in his website
www.drhomeo.com also says that Cenchris has dreams of
committing rape whereas in The Spirit of Homeopathic Medicine
book by Dr. Didier Grandgeorge in the primitive scene it is given
that Cenchris dreams of witnessing a rape.

From the cases given in NATIONAL JOURNAL of


HOMOEOPATHY (NJH) it is seen that the majority of symptoms
are coming in mental, respiratory and female reproductive system.

Although during proving other systems are also shown symptoms


but in clinical prescription it is still to be discovered.

We also find this remedy in Kents repertory under disputes from


jealousy (Lachesis, Nux vomica).

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 6
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

This remedy is known among homeopaths for its similarity to


Lachesis with symptoms occurring on the right side instead of left.

Also respiratory system is characteristically explained in the form of


symptoms like Recurrent tendency to develop paranasal sinusitis &
allergic rhinitis.

Symptoms of alimentary system are very characteristic of Cenchris


such as sensation of bands around the abdomen, nausea > by ice,
loathing of food. Also Intolerance of tight clothing is mentioned by
Dr. Kent as well as Dr. J.H. Clarke in their respective Materia
Medica.

Snake group Introduction

A considerable part of Homoeopathic MateriaMedica consists of


medicines taken from animal kingdom. As the name implies, the
Ophidia group consists of medicines taken from snakes.
Ophidia comes under Class Reptilia, which comes under Phylum
Chordata, under metazoa. The other Classes in Phylum Chordates
includes Pisces, Amphibia, Aviens and Mammalia.

Classification of Snake Group

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 7
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

C
T
P
E
V
H
N
B
IL
Y
O
A
P
D
IN
L
S
P
E
R
D
U
IS
R
O
P
A
B
N
ID
P
O
E
R
O
A
D
IH
F
U
E
IA
S
D
S
E
D
O
A
S
A
N
E
N
E
O
A
U
K
S
E
S

Effect of Snake Toxins:

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 8
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 9
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Common Effects of Ophidia Poison:

1. Paralysis

2. Constriction of throat larynx & sphincters

3. Haemorrhages of dark, non-coagulable decomposed black


blood oozing from all orifices of the body with
ecchymosed.

4. Inflammations and fevers of low destructive type


e.g.gangrene cellulitis, malignant ulcerations, diphtheria,
typhoid etc.

5. Nerves usually get affected

6. Action on heart-Produce palpitation, dyspnoea and


valvularlesions.

7. Alteration of spinal reflexes

8. Initial anxiety, mental excitability and over sensitiveness

9. Periodicity

10. Swelling

11. Sleep aggravation

12. Dysarthria

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 10
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 11
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX: INSIGHT

Taxonomy

Family : Viperidae

Genus : Agkistrodon

Scientific name : Agkistrodoncontortrix

Common name : Copperhead snake

Living Pattern

Semi-aquatic

It is a shy snake,tries to hide away from strangers, will bite


only when disturbed

The species name is from Latin contortus meaning


twisted, referring to the pattern on the snake back.

Life span: 18 years

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 12
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

About 2-4 feet long

Bites are uncommon from these snakes, and death due to it


is very rare, fatal only in children

Venom: Constituents and Their Effects


Constituents: Cenchris venom is the modified saliva. The
poison is taken from the snake. Chemically, the poison
iscyan hydrates of soda and other salts.
Alcohol is a natural solvent and an antidote for these
poisons.
Effects: Highly hemolytic; Massive haemorrhages.

Toxicology Effects

Pain

Swelling

Weakness

Giddiness

Breathing difficulty

Hemorrhage

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 13
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Alteration in pulse: increased or decreased

Nausea, vomiting

Gangrene

Ecchymosis

Unconsciousness

Stupor

Fever

Sweating

Headache

Intestinal discomfort.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 14
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Homeopathic Use
Mind: Nightmare: cannot be shaken off during even waking
hours.

Headache dull aching pain.

Eyes:
a. Amaurosis Insensibility of cornea leads to dim vision
b. Eyes, swelling over.

Respiratory System:
a. Catarrh - Discharge of yellow mucus, sometimes tinged
with blood.
b. Throat, affections of dry cough with sensation of choking.
c. Bronchial asthma

Heart, affections of
a. Strongly conscious of heart.
b. Angina pectoris - Sudden, sharp stitching pain in the heart,
followed by dull pain, which gradually subsided< lying
down
c. Supraventricular tachycardia

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 15
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 16
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Female Genitalia:
a. Leucorrhoea yellow & thin.
b. Menorrhagia light blood with dark clots.
c. Ovary, pain in right sided.
d. Vulva, throbbing in; eruption on herpetic eruptions on
labia.

Rectum:
a. Colitis
b. Irritable bowel syndrome
c. Ulcerative colitis

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 17
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Compilation of Materia Medica of


Cenchris contortrix

Source book: Kents Lecture on Homoeopathic Materia Medica.

Reference books: Clarkes Dictionary of Practical Materia


Medica, Snakes To Simillimum by Dr. Farookh Master,
Boerickes Homoeopathic Materia Medica

Mind

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 18
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Loss of memory, dreamy and absent minded.

Concentration
difficult or they just sit and stare into space.
- Sensation of intoxication in evening.
- The horror remains after horrible dreams.
- Thought sickening anxiety, all over the body, but most at
the heart and through the chest, exclaiming, "I shall die! I
shall die!" This soon passed into profound sleep, whichwas
not interrupted until morning, but full of horrible dreams.
- No inclination to attend to her usual duties, which are
pleasant. The person is nervous but not duty conscious.
- Restless, self-centered.
- Anticipation of sudden problem.
- Suspicious of everybody, thinks her family plotting to
place her in an insane asylum.
- Melancholy with desire to be alone.
- Angry when disturbed< 6pm.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 19
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Crying and very frequent sighing, as if very sad.


- Painful procrastination, indecision, just cannot get started
to do anything.
- Alternation of opposite moods and desires.
- Conflict of sexuality after some incidence of rape or
multiple partners in parents.

Head
- Sensation of fullness about the head.
- Dull, aching pain in the forehead, which finally extended
to the occiput, leaving forehead.Dr. J.H. Clarke in his
Dictionary of Practical Materia Medica mentions similar
head complaints.
- Feeling as if all the blood in the body rushed to the head.
- Violent headache in both temples in forenoon. < warmth,
menses>eating

- Aching in the frontal sinuses, nose, and throat, as though


she had taken a severe cold, but no discharge of mucus.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 20
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Hard, aching pain commenced in left frontal eminence and


spread down left side to teeth, then spread to right frontal
eminence, then to teeth on right side.
- Hard pain over left eye.
- Sore feeling in the scalp after the headache passed away.
- Itching of scalp, better by scratching.
- Transient sensation of prickling in the scalp, like a gentle
current of electricity.
- One large, dry, scabby pimple on scalp, long and narrow,
oval shaped.

Eyes
- Eyes ache, and there is dimness of vision.
- Lachrymation from left eye; left eyelid red on edges.
- Twitching in left eyelid.
- Dull ache in eyes, with sense of weakness.
- Itching of eyes; begins in left eye and extends to right.
- Margins of eyelids red, especially at night.

- Swelling above and below eyes like bag of water.


- Dr. Boericke and Dr. J.H. Clarke in their Materia Medica
also tell about marked swelling around the eyes, aching and
itching in the eyes.

Ears
- Itching of ears at night.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 21
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Itching of ears during the day.


- Burning of left ear.
- Dull pain in and around the left ear.
- Sensation of heat yet cold to touch.

Nose
- Recurrent tendency to develop paranasal sinusitis &
allergic rhinitis.
- Sickening odor in the nose with copious flow of mucus,
thin and watery.
- Aching in left side of nose as though in the bones, with dull
headache.
- Tickling sensation in the nose with sensation as if much
discharge would flow but very little comes out when
blowing.
- Violent sneezing occasionally and eyes filled with water in
morning when waking.

- Nose sore & burning sensation inside as though full of


pepper, worse left side.
- Discharge of yellow mucus, sometimes tinged with blood.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 22
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Dry mucus in nose, cannot breathe through it.

Face
- Flushes of heat about the face and head.
- Bloating of face, as if intoxicated.
- Bloating above and below eyes. Besotted, face sallow.
- Expression bloated, and blue circle around the eyes.
- Mottled skin; purple, deep, dark red face.
- Dry parched lips in evening, with fever that began at 3pm.
- Great burning of the face, worse at night and about 2pm, it
keeps growing hotter and redder until she goes to sleep
at10pm. Burning begins in left cheek and ear, spreads to
right cheek 6:30pm.
- Very small red pimples in little clusters, between the eyes,
on the upper lips and on the end of nose.
- Dr. J.H Clarke also mentions of bloated expression, face
sallow, burning face and blue circle around the eyes.
Mouth
- Dry mouth in evening.
- Profuse saliva, running out of mouth on pillow in sleep
- Metallic, coppery taste in mouth.

Throat
- Gagging from coughing, constantly hawking up thick,
tough, stringy mucus, difficult to raise.
- Throat full of mucus, thick and yellow, slightly tinged with
blood from posterior nares, in the morning on waking. Dr.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 23
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

J.H Clarke mentions of thick, glossy and tough mucus in


his Practical Dictionary of Materia Medica.
- Sore throat; painful, empty swallowing, but water
swallowed without pain.
- Right side of throat red and swollen with sticking pain in
throat. > warm drinks

Stomach
- Intense thirst for small quantity of cold water in the
evening.
- Loathing of food.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 24
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Craves salt bacon.


- Vomiting of white gruel-like substance, with mucus and
undigested food. Nausea > by ice.

Abdomen
- Constant uneasy feeling & dullness just below the thorax in
the region of diaphragm.
- Dull pain in two spots directly over pubic arch, 10 A. M.,
passing off after two hours.
- Sensation of bands around the abdomen.
- Dull pain in abdomen when coughing.

- Sensation of a hard lump in left side of abdomen.


- Bloating or abdomen after small amount of food, with
diarrhea.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 25
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Intolerance of tight clothing is mentioned by Dr. Kent as


well as Dr. J.H. Clarke in their respective Materia Medica.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 26
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Rectum
- Itching and soreness of the anus with hemorrhoids.
- Urging to stool, which passes away before the closet can
be reached.
- Unsuccessful urging to stool, strain until rectum feels as
though prolapsed, but have no stool morning.
- On waking in the morning, had to hasten to the closet; stool
watery, dark with a black sediment like coffee grounds;
stool intermits, have to sit a long time,passing small
quantities every minute or two.
- Stool gushing and frequent, watery, with dark sediment at
first without pain; after several hours great pain before
stool.
- Flatus at termination of stool. Painless and involuntary
stool when passing flatus.
- Stools profuse, each seems as if it would empty the bowel,
but soon full again.
- Sensation of intestines filled with water.
- Dr. J.H Clarke in his Practical Dictionary of Materia
Medica says that there is diarrhea early in the morning, on
waking and also gushing stool, frequent, watery at first,
without pain, and after several hours, great pain before the
motions.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 27
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Urinary organs
- Loses her urine when coughing.
- Desire to urinate at night, just after getting in bed: must get
up and press a long time before a few drops pass.
- When doing mental work, frequent desire to urinate, pass
large quantities of colorless urine.

Male sexual organs


- Both Dr. Kent and Dr. J.H. Clarke talk about violent sexual
desire in males.

Female sexual organs


- Yellow leucorrhoea, never had any leucorrhea before.
- Sexual desire strong, in a widow who had long been free
from such sensations.
- Sharp, shooting pain in right ovary. Similar symptom is
also mentioned by Dr. J.H. Clarke in his Materia Medica.
- Herpetic eruption on labia majora.
- Laborlike pains in uterus during menses.

Respiration
- Slight hoarseness, worse at night
- Arrested respiration on going to sleep.
- Stops breathing unless she sits up and bends forward.
Dyspnoea as if dying from anxiety.
- Sensation of suffocation and choking, must lie with head
drawn backwards.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 28
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Dry, hacking cough, coming on at 3pm, continuing through


the evening and at night after retiring.
- Expectoration dark, bloody and at times bright red.

Heart and chest


- Anxiety about the heart in evening after lying down.
- Anxiety about the heart with palpitation.
- Audible palpitation when lying on right side.
- Feeling as though the whole chest was distended and the
heart very sore.
- Feeling as if the heart was distended, or swelled to fill the
chest.
- Anxiety in the region of the heart all night
- Sudden, sharp stitching pain in the heart, followed by dull
pain, which gradually subsided< lying down
- Dr. Kent as well as Dr. Boericke mentions in their literature
that the Cenchris patient feels as if heart were distended, or
swelled to fill whole chest, as if it fell down in the
abdomen; sharp stitches, fluttering under left scapula.

Neck and Back


- During the day, constriction about the neck, clothing
disturbed her, choking feeling.
- Throbbing under the scapula, dull aching in small of back.
- Transient aching feeling in sacrum
- Throbbing carotids when lying down

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 29
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Sore aching feeling below the left scapula,>rubbing


(lasting many days).

- Awoke at night with pain in region of left kidney, worse


lying on left side, better by turning on right side and
drawing up limbs.

Extremities
- Hands vary, one minute hot and dry, then cold, then
sweating in palms.
- Hand chapped, hot & cold, get numb at times.
- Dull ache in metacarpal bone of thumb, in cushion of right
and left thumbs &in the left palm.
- Awakes with dull aching in four lesser toes of right foot,
acute pain when stepping or moving foot, gradually
subsided after bathing in hot water.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 30
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Want to put feet up; unconsciously cross the limbs


especially when sitting.
- Profuse foot-sweat, can almost wring the stockings, neither
acrid, nor offensive.
Sleep and dreams
- Dreams are full of aggressive and animalistic sexuality that
is raw and wild like :
1) Being chased by wild animals.
2) Indecent conduct of men & women.
3) Male animals following her in the field to injure her.
4) Naked people; of wild animals pursuing her.
5) Rape
6) Seeing animals copulating.
7) Snakes.
8) Plotting to fire the town or any building.
9) Teeth being pulled out.

- Wakeful with horrible anxiety and feeling that she must


die,wakeful until 3am.
- Tongue dry, saliva running upon pillow during sleep.
- Dr. Boericke and Dr. J.H. Clarke mention dreams of
Cenchris as having vivid, horrible and lascivious dreams,
cannot be shaken off during waking hours.

Chill, fever and perspiration


- Chill at 3pm, icy cold hands and feet.
- Flushes of heat to face and head.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 31
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Fever at 3 P. M., lasting until midnight. Dr. J.H. Clarke says


chills or fever beginning in afternoon.
- At 3pm, dry mouth and lips, mouth feels parched, intense
thirst, pulse 105, choking and sensation as if chest was
filling up, causing constriction and difficult breathing.
- The body feels flushed, but the contact of cold things is
disagreeable, causing chills.
- Inclined to be chilly all day and more so at night, must
keep wrapped warmly, even when feeling feverish
- Chilly, shaking and trembling with cold at night in bed.
- Shivering in bed, during evening and night, though (10 P.
M.) loaded with blankets.
- Heat and chilly sensations alternate from 6 to 10pm
- Chilly, yet face is burning.
- Chilly, yet heat gives a dull headache and makes them feel
smothered.

Skin
- Spot on the right calf became red, then copper-colored; it
seemed deep in the skin.
- Itching all over the body; flying over the body.
- Excessive swelling, oedema & cellulitis.

Generalities
- Aggravation from pressure, lying down, on waking,
afternoon 3pm, evening upto midnight.
- Chilly > warm covering.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 32
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

- Increased sexual desire in both sexes.


- One sided symptoms, right sided.
- Periodicity very marked, complaints occur every day at the
same time.
- Spring aggravation of colitis, bronchitis, neuritis and
angina pectoris.
- Tendency to faint.
- Waking invites many problems like cough, diarrhea,
headache, palpitation.

Relationship
- Chamomilla antidotes its uterine haemorrhage & Amon
carb antidotes its general symptoms.
- Cenchris antidotes Pulsatilla.

Prescriptive points

Fear of sudden death-fear of sudden attack


Anxiety all over body mainly in chest region
Suspiciousness
Increased sexual desire
Aversion to domestic duty
Absent mindedness/memory weakness
Chilly
Right sided
No appetite
Bacon desire
Lying agg
Aversion to tight clothing

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 33
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Comparative Materia Medica Study

Comparison with Lachesis

The common symptoms with Lachesis include: coma, delusion she


will be sent to asylum, fear of going to sleep, forsaken feeling,
jealousy, quarrelsome, choking on going to sleep, clothing
aggravates, respiration difficult and, bending forward ameliorates.

Differentiation from Lachesis

CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX LACHESIS MUTA

1) Right sided 1) Left sided

2) Thermals-chilly 2) Thermals-hot

3) Fear of sudden
death. 3) Fear of death.

4) Quarrelsome from 4) Mocking with


jealousy. jealousy.

5) Morals, want of
5) Indifference to
duties

6) Can swallow solids


6) Difficulty in empty

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 34
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

but not liquids.


swallowing.

7) Throat pains are better 7) Throat pains are


by warm drinks worse by warm
drinks

8) Symptoms come on after 8) Symptoms come on


lying down during after sleep

9) Aggravation from 3pm


to 8pm, gradually 9) Aggravation at night
disappearing towards and after midnight.
midnight.

Comparison with Arsenic Album

The common symptoms with arsenic include: presentiments of


death, fear of death, suspiciousness, bluish discolouration of face
and respiration difficult.

Differentiation from Arsenic alb


CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX ARSENIC ALBUM
Fear of sudden death-sudden fear. Fear of sudden death-but
Fear of sudden attack/harm gradual fear.
Fear due to despair of
recovery.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 35
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Restlessness must constantly Restlessness at mental level


move physically weak
Anxiety in chest. Anxiety of conscience.
Anxiety physical. Anxiety of family.
Anxiety with sleeplessness,with Anxiety about future
difficult respiration. Anxiety about health.
Fainting after anxiety.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 36
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Repertorial Study of Cenchris Contortrix

Prominent Rubrics Cenchris

Mind

Mind; death; pres Mind; dreams; rape; seeing, of: CENCH(3)


entiment of; sudden death, of a: CENCH(3)
Mind; anxiety; chest, in; lying, while: CENCH(3)
Mind; dreams; rape; pursued for the purpose of: CENCH(3)

Abdomen
Abdomen; constriction; band sensation; intolerable: CENCH(3)

Heart
Heart & circulation; falling down, as if, heart; abdomen, in:
CENCH(3)
Heart & circulation; enlarged sensation, heart; too large for cavity:
CENCH(3)

Extremities
Extremities; coldness, chilliness; buttocks, nates; night, in bed:
CENCH(3)

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 37
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Skin
Skin; ulcers; spring: CENCH(3)

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 38
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Rubrics having only Cenchris as remedy

(Single Symptom Rubrics)

Mind

Mind; afternoon; agg.; three pm.; eight pm., until:cench


Mind; anger; evening; agg.; six pm.: cench
Mind; anger; evening; agg.; eight thirty pm.: cench
Mind; anxiety; chest, in; night; lying down, on: cench
Mind; cheerfulness; alternating with; suspiciousness: cench
Mind; death; presentiment of; lying, while: cench
Mind; death; presentiment of; sudden death, of a: CENCH(3)
Mind; dreams; animals, of; copulating: cench
Mind; dreams; animals, of; pursued by; male, to injure her: cench
Mind; dreams; family, own; plotting against her: cench
Mind; dreams; rape; seeing, of: CENCH(3)
Mind; dreams; terrapin, water turtle: cench
Mind; helplessness; cough, during: cench
Mind; suspiciousness, mistrustfulness; afternoon; three pm. - eight
pm.: cench

Vertigo
Vertigo; afternoon; agg.; four pm.; seven pm., until: cench

Head

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 39
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Head; pain, headache; forehead; eminence; extending; right side:


cench
Head; pain, headache; forehead; eminence; extending; teeth, to:
cench
Head; pain, headache; temples; breakfast; amel.:cench
Head; pain, headache; dull; forehead; m Head; pain, headache; dull;
forehead; extending to; teeth, to: cenchenses, during: cench
Head; pain, headache; dull; forehead; eminence; left; right, to: cench
Head; pain, headache; violent; temples; forenoon: cench

Eyes
Eyes; redness; lids; margins, edges; night: cench

Ears
Ears; itching; daytime: cench

Nose
Nose; tingling, prickling inside; extending to; eyes: cench

Face
Face; heat; flushes; night: cench
Face; pain; burning, smarting; left; extending to right: cench

Mouth
Mouth; dryness; afternoon; three pm.: cench

Teeth

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 40
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Teeth; pain, toothache; dull; upper; right: cench

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 41
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Throat
Throat; discoloration; right: cench
Throat; fullness; swallowing; amel.:cench
Throat; mucus, discharges; bloody; bright: cench

Neck
Neck; constriction, contraction; daytime: cench
Neck; constriction, contraction; three pm.: cench

Stomach
Stomach; nausea; ice cubes amel.:cench

Abdomen
Abdomen; constriction; diaphragm; cough, during: cench
Abdomen; constriction; hypogastrium; morning, on waking: cench
Abdomen; constriction; diaphragm; cough, during: cench
Abdomen; constriction; hypogastrium; morning, on waking: cench
Abdomen; constriction; band sensation; intolerable: CENCH(3)
Abdomen; contraction; diaphragm; cough; during: cench
Abdomen; contraction; umbilical region; cough, during: cench
Abdomen; distension; room, warm, amel.:cench
Abdomen; hardness; sides; left: cench
Abdomen; pain; hypochondria; morning; breakfast; during: cench
Abdomen; pain; spleen region; breakfast, during: cench
Abdomen; pain; cutting; spleen; breakfast, during: cench
Abdomen; pain; cutting; spleen; extending to; downward: cench

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 42
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Abdomen; pain; stitching; hypochondria; morning; breakfast,


during: cench
Abdomen; shaking, internal; spleen region: cench
Abdomen; shaking, internal; water, as of, spleen region: cench

Rectum
Rectum; constipation; stool; intermits: cench
Rectum; pain; pulsating, throbbing; waking, on: cench
Rectum; pulsation; waking, on: cench

Bladder
Bladder; urging to urinate, morbid desire; night; lying down, after:
cench
Bladder; urination; frequent; mental exertion, after: cench

Kidney
Kidney; pain; lying; agg.; side, on; left: cench
Kidney; pain; region of; night; waking, on: cench
Kidney; pain; region of; drawing up legs amel.:cench
Kidney; pain; region of; lying; agg.; side, on left: cench

Female
Female; knotted sensation; ovaries: cench
Female; pain; pulsating, throbbing; waking.on: cench
Female; menses; pale, watery; clots; dark, with: cench
Female; pain; ulcerative; ovary, right: cench
Female; pulsation; waking, on: cench

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 43
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Respiration
Respiration; gasping; talking, while: cench

Cough
Cough; afternoon; three pm.; bedtime, until: cench
Cough; diaphragm, seems to come from: cench
Cough; hard; four pm.: cench
Cough; racking; three pm.: cench
Cough; short; afternoon; four pm.: cench

Chest
Chest; anxiety; night; lying down, on: cench
Chest; coldness; night, ten pm.: cench
Chest; pain; night; lying agg.; side, on right: cench
Chest; pain; muscles; motion of hand to opposite shoulder
agg.:cench
Chest; pain; drawing; night, lying on right side: cench
Chest; pain; dull; pressure agg.:cench
Chest; pain; pressing; transient, lower sternum: cench
Chest; pain; transient, lungs: cench

Heart
Heart & circulation; falling down, as if, heart; abdomen, in:
CENCH(3)
Heart & circulation; fluttering sensation, heart; three pm.: cench

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 44
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Back
Back; fluttering; dorsal region, under left scapula: cench
Back; pain; sitting; agg.; feet, on his, while: cench
Back; pain; dorsal region; scapulae; left; rubbing amel.:cench
Back; pain; dull; lumbar region; night: cench
Back; pain; dull; lumbar region; menses, during: cench
Back; pain; dull; sacral region; night: cench
Back; pain; dull; sacral region; walking amel.:cench
Back; pain; sore, bruised; dorsal region; scapulae; below; left: cench
Back; pain; sore, bruised; dorsal region; scapulae; below; rubbing
amel.:cench
Back; pain; sore, bruised; coccyx; night: cench
Back; pain; transient, sacral region: cench

Extremities
Extremities; coldness, chilliness; hands; afternoon; three pm.; about:
cench
Extremities; coldness, chilliness; buttocks, nates; night, in bed:
CENCH(3)
Extremities; corns; burning, smarting; weather, damp, wet,
agg.:cench
Extremities; corns; painful; weather, damp, wet, agg.:cench
Extremities; crossing; unconsciously, lower limbs: cench
Extremities; heat; dry; hands; alternating with perspiration of hands:
cench
Extremities; pain; sore, bruised; buttocks, nates; night: cench

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 45
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Extremities; pain; sore, bruised; buttocks, nates; menses, during:


cench
Extremities; pain; transient, forearms, outer, radial: cench
Extremities; put feet up, desires to: cench

Sleep
Sleep; disturbed; fright, fear agg.; die, she must: cench
Sleep; sleepiness; dark, in: cench
Sleep; sleeplessness; thoughts, from; dreams from previous night,
from: cench

Chill
Chill; motion; during; fingers, of: cench

Skin
Skin; cicatrices; studded with veins: cench

Generalities
Generalities; enlarged sensation; bursting, to: cench

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 46
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

CASE STUDY

CASE 1

This is a 28 year old female complaining of no motivation (3). She


cant really seem to change her life even though she wants to
because she cant get started. Most of that revolves around a
difficulty focusing (3). She doesnt really know what she wants. She
has difficulty on a day to day basis in keeping focused and getting
things done.

She has a profound depression (3), which dates from her teenage
years. It occurs every couple of months. At these times she has
intense weeping (3) and can be suicidal (3). But even during the rest
of the month there is a feeling of hopelessness (3), that nothing will
ever work out and that something terrible is going to happen in her
life (3). It makes her quite fearful for her day to day survival with a
lot of the fears being based around money and the lack of it. Each
day she is very anxious about her health and about whether she will

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 47
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

survive due to the crises which constantly occur and drain her
financially. She never seems to be able to get ahead since something
happens each time she gets ahead to wipe her out financially.

Im a pessimist. You have to expect the worst. Something will


come and take it away from me. Im very vigilant. I go to bed with
my clothes on. Im afraid something will happen to me. Im sad.
There is nothing to live for; nothing to look forward to.

She has extremely low self-confidence (3). Even though she is quite
attractive she sees herself as unattractive, unable to compete with
other women.

I feel like I let my family down. I just couldnt be the way they
wanted me to be. I need a lot of recognition. I want people to like
me but I dont make the effort to initiate it. She is very critical of
herself (3), of how she walks, talks and looks.

She finds that she is bossy (3), like her mom. She is irritable and
bitchy (3) and can get into arguments with her husband that can
lead to out and out physical battles, with verbal aggression and can
even lead to striking and hitting (3). Shes aggravated she cant fix

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 48
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

things on her own. She can be vindictive and spiteful (3). She can
also be extremely weepy over nothing.

If someone says something to me, Ill cry. I feel ready to explode.

She didnt get along well with her husband who was very passive
and let her do all the work and planning. She wouldnt leave him
because she has an intense fear of being alone (3).

Ive been hurt a lot and just cant think about being alone and on
my own. She eventually did leave, had a series of quick
relationships, and then got into a relationship with a man who is
physically abusive to her.

It is important for me to feel needed. I took care of my mom who


died of cirrhosis. Im afraid I am so nitpicky that my husband will
leave me or Ill push him too far and hell leave. I like to look
different so Im the center of attention. Im fussy and mothering but
carefully push people away.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 49
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

People say Im too confident, that Im stuck-up and snotty. I stand


back with crossed arms and look around the room and watch people.
Im nosy. I see whos looking at me.

Basically, I just dont trust people (3). My parents were alcoholic


and I couldnt trust my dad who would abuse me when drunk. I am
extremely jealous (3); not of them looking at other women, but more
of being left out, of people talking about me. What are they saying
about me?

Physically she has palpitations (3). They can occur any time. It
makes her very afraid that she has some horrible disease. They are
worse when she lies down to go to bed. At one point she was on
Inderal for them.

They give me a sharp pain like someone sticking a knife in my


chest and they take my breath away. I have them daily and they last
for about 5 minutes. I cant control them. Im wondering if Ill die
from them.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 50
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

I have a low sex drive (2). Im a disappointment to my husband. He


might leave.

I used to get hives (2) from age 9 14. Theyd come on the back of
my neck, back and chest. Id scratch them a lot, since they were so
itchy. They made me feel so ugly. They were humiliating. They
made me less self-confident. I couldnt control them or make them
go away.

I have severe arthritis of the knees and back (2). The knees swell
above the kneecaps. It is a sharp pain when going up stairs. There is
a stiffness of the knees. I have spinal bifida and scoliosis. I can get
spasms of the back (3) and sciatica, which is a prickling pain down
both legs. I get an ache and a pressure in my back, like an elephant
standing on it. There is also some twitching of the muscles of the

back. The arthritis bothers me every day. My muscles feel tight (3).
There is also tightness of chest (2). I get another type of pain in my
knees which make them feel like they are going to explode (3).

I have severe headaches (3) in back of my neck and head. The head
feels like it is in a vice grip. I have to go lie down and rest in a dark
room with no noises. These are worse with motion of her head.
They occur mainly around menses (3). The headaches are of two

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 51
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

types. The first is a constricting type mentioned above. The second


is a feeling like the head is going to explode (3).

She has severe menstrual cramps (3). They are debilitating. She has
to go lie down (3). They occur on the second day of the bleeding.
There are lots of clots with dark red blood, associated with nausea.

My sleep is poor. My mind is racing. Did I do this right? Is my


husband cheating on me?

She is chilly, has low energy of three to four on a scale of one to ten,
and craves cheese and milk, which upset her stomach. She has
aversion and aggravation from eggs.

Remedies given: Arsenicum album, Lachesis, Ignatia, Platina,


Hyoscyamus, and Anacardium.

Most relief was with Lachesis. The emotional states were


ameliorated by 50-60% with some symptoms even going away, but
the physical complaints got worse. Then she began to develop a
series of bronchitis-like symptoms with sneezing, fevers, cough, and
muscle aches all the time. She felt completely fatigued and burned

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 52
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

out. The joint pains got so severe that she was crying from the pain.
I was constantly giving her prescriptions for Tylenol (3).

Lets look at the analysis of the case.

The segments broke down like this:

1. Difficulty focusing

2. Hopeless/fear something bad will happen

3. Fear of being alone

4. Holding on / constrictive pains

5. Jealous and suspicious

6. Abusive, violent/explosive pains

I chose the following rubrics, which I combined to give the fullest


repertorization possible. Each of the combined rubrics represents the
segment listed above.

1. Mind, concentration difficult; Mind concentration difficult,


studying.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 53
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

2. Mind, fear something will happen; Mind, ailments from


anticipation; mind, despair of recovery.

3. Mind, fear, alone; Mind, forsaken feeling; Mind, delusions of


being alone in the world; Mind delusions, she is always alone in the
world.

4. Head, constriction, band or hoop; Back, spasmodic drawing,


cervical region; Female genitalia, sex, menses, painful; Head,
constriction; mind, company desire for.

5. Mind, suspicious; Mind, jealousy.

6. Mind, abusive; Mind, censorious; Mind, striking; Mind, violent;


head, pain, bursting.

When I repertorized these segments, 22 remedies came up in all 6


segments. 11 small remedies or nosodes came up in 5 segments.

So in September 1998 I gave her Cenchris 200C, based on the above


repertorization and everything got better. All the emotional problems
went away. The headaches and menstrual cramps stopped. The
arthritis went away. The palpitations had gone away with
the Lachesis. The muscle aches all went away. I repeated
the Cenchris 200C once in June 99. She was asymptomatic after
that except for mild occasional headaches and occasional mild

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 54
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

menstrual cramps, but nothing like the debilitating headaches and


menstrual cramps of the past.

Cenchris is a remedy in between Lachesis and Hyosyamus. It is as


though Cenchris is stuck in a constant PMS state and has a lack of
logic. The suspiciousness makes them angry. The mate did the
wrong thing, they drove him away and then they are alone. In a
woman who has fear of being alone and treats her husband badly,
consider Cenchris.

Repertorization:

Discussion:
Cenchris remedy was selected based on these symptoms like:-
1.Suspicious / Jealous;
2. Arguing/irritability/nastiness; (If person explodes quickly it is
more likely Cenchris rather than Lachesis who tries to control
themselves).

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 55
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

3. Fear of death, of night, of exposure; In Lachesis it happens as


they are falling asleep. For Cenchris, there is just a feeling that
something is going to happen to them. Fear of death at night.
4. Alone, Forsaken.

In the above case we learn new clinical symptom of Cenchris such


as forsaken feeling which did not appear in the initial proving.
Also we see similarities between Lachesis and Cenchris in the given
case and learn the differentiating points between them.
In the given case, even though Lachesis was initially indicated, it
was Cenchris which resulted in complete cure of the patient thus
asserting that Cenchris can effectively treat cases if it matches the
totality.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 56
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

CASE 2

Mrs. H, tall, frail.

Dec. 6, 1887. After being married for three years, complained of a


pain in the right ovarian region, like an ulcer, with a thrusting in
pain; that she cannot move her leg two days before menstruation.
Flow black, dirty discharge, followed a few days later with
coagulated blood; later leucorrhoea of large brown and yellow
lumps. Also she had a chill a month ago, with sore throat and
retching. Under the use of Apis and Sepia, high and highest
potencies, she considered herself well by January 4, 1888. But the
trouble came back in form of cramps in the right ovary. Apis high
did good service again, but did not cure.

Dec. 30, 1889. The menses had come two days earlier. First day,
bright red, then dark, lasting four days; not much. After it, pain in
the right ovary, like a jumping toothache, for a day. The size of the
painful spot had tapered down from three or four inches in diameter
to about that of a fingertip. Cenchris cm was given.

Jan. 13, 1890. Had for the first time in her life a normal
menstruation. There was only a slight intimation of pain in the right
ovary. She feels good everywhere, and has gained.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 57
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

The ovarian trouble came probably from injecting cold water


immediately after coitus, which the ignorant young thing did,
according to the advice of her mother-in-law, who thought her unfit
to bear children.

Repertorisation

Discussion:-
As per this case the patient complained of severe pain with soreness
in the Right ovary region initially she had sore throat followed with
chill in 3pm with night aggravation this are the symptoms which are
markedly seen in this remedy previously this patient was treated by
Apis due to the symptom of sore throat with chill but the patient
came up with soreness and severe pain in the right ovarian region
she was better with highest potency of Apis but she did not get
completely cured after Cenchris 45 she was not better for 2 days but
then the pain started reducing with marked improvement in overall
health of the patient. We also learnt a new clinical symptom of
Cenchris which was retching with cough.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 58
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 59
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

CASE 3

Name:-Mrs.U.S. 35yrs/f
Address:-31,Bhawan Bhawan, B.S. Road,Dadar,Mumbai-400028
Tel no.:-24378048
Religion: - Brahmin
Occupation: - Housewife
Marital status: - Married since 15yrs
Physician In charge:-Dr.Nimish Mehta
Chief complaints:-
She complains of recurrent bouts of breathlessness since the last 14
years. The attacks were much more severe earlier but in the last 8yrs
the severity is about 50% less. Since then she has not been
improving further.
She suffers from frequent attacks. Every time she gets an attack it
starts with cold and cough to start with and then breathlessness in
the next 24 hrs.
She is unable to lie down with the attack. She feels cold along with
the breathlessness,but at the same time wants fan. She gets a lot of
eructation along with the breathlessness.
During the attack she takes Asthalin inhaler 4-5 times a day and
steroid inhaler 2 times a day.

Associated complaints:
1. She complains of aches and pain in different parts of the body.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 60
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Not a singleday,in last 14yrs,she has been without these pains.


Whatever medication she takes gives her temporary relief.

2. She has been suffering from fever one year back. It has lasted for
a long time. The diagnosis was suspected to be typhoid. She says
that she has become extremely weak after this attack of fever. She
gets tired very easily. Within 30-40 minutes of work the tiredness
comes up.

Patient as a person (physical characteristics):


The patient is tall, average built, well nourished.
There are no abnormalities noted with the skin hair or the nails.
Mouth: tongue - moist, posterior white coating.
Veg/non veg: - Vegetarian
Appetite: - Good, except during the attack where due to the
difficulty in breathing she is unable to eat comfortably.
Likes: - Sweets 3+ right from start.
Papaya
Dislikes: - N.S.
Thirst:-Takes about 3-4 liters in a day. She usually prefers to have
water at room temp. Avoids taking cold water as she feels that it
might precipitate the attack though it does not.
Food / drinks / </> : At times if she has a lot of spicy food it leads to
mild retrosternal burning which settles down if she has a glass of
cold milk.
Stools: - 1-2 times a day,well formed. No episode of bleeding,
infection in the past.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 61
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Urine:-6-7 times a day. No complains of burning, itching or any


infection in the past.
Perspiration:-Moderate, all over the body.
It stains yellow and the stains remain even after washing
Sleeps: - 6 - 7 hours, refreshing, always sleeps on left side.
Dreams :- of snakes 3+ (sees very often since last 10yrs,vividly) in
latter part of the interview she also said that she had recurrent
dreams of being chased and of being raped 3+(no relation with any
similar events personal or vicarious)
Gynaec/Obs h/o:-
F.M.P: at 13yrs
L.M.P:-03/03/2000
The cycle is of 28-30 days lasting for 4-5 days.
Quantity: - moderate, staining indelible , non-offensive.
No complains before, after, during menses.
G1 P1 A0 L1.
Nausea 2+ in the 1st 2 months of pregnancy. No significant changes
in mental state during pregnancy.

Child development and growth:-


Nothing significant.
General Reaction (including thermal modality)
She is very sensitive to cold .she cannot tolerate the fan at all except
during the attack of breathlessness.
Bath: - Hot water (throughout the year)
Covering:-Wants throughout the year
Thermal: - Chilly 2+

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 62
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

No motion sickness

Mental characteristics (relevant to life situation to be depicted)


The patient comes from the interiors of India, from a small village in
Maharashtra.
Her father is a farmer by profession (not very well financially)
She is illiterate and her husband is an advocate.
Her marriage was decided according to the prevailing customs of the
community and a particular amount of dowry was to be given. The
parents were unable to pay that amount and so had decided to pay it
off by giving the returns of their cotton crop of the year. Due to the
failure of the crop that year the father was unable to pay the dowry
amount as decide. Within 6 months of her marriage quarrels started
in the family. The in - laws would constantly fight over the issue that
her parents had failed to pay the dowry money. They would use
abusive language and would harass her in various ways.

F/H
Father:-Pulmonary Tb
Knee Joint Pains? O.A
P/H
Fever 1 year back??Typhoid

General examination:-
Pulse-99/min; BP-120/80mmhg R.R:-20/minutes; Temp - Afebrile
Cold2+ palms; tremors hands 1+ (due to bronchodilators); trembling
of tongue 3+ on protruding

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 63
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Weight:-58kg

Systemic examination:
R.S. - Scattered Ronchi ++
C.V.S - NAD
G.I.T - NAD
G.U.T - NAD
C.N.S - NAD

Provisional Clinical Diagnosis:


Bronchial asthma (episodic) + functional muscular rheumatism.

Investigation advised:-
Cbc, S.uric acid, X-ray chest PA view , L F T , Spirometry before
and after bronchodilators.

Remedy (with reasons):


From the above understanding we arrive at the following drugs:
Cenchris, Sepia, Lachesis, Kali-c, Silicea and Pulsatilla.
The indicated remedy is Cenchris because of the following reasons:
1) A/F: Fright
2) Dreams of being chased and raped.
3) Dreams of Snakes.
4) Passionate.
5) Vivacious.
6) Chilly
7) Desire - Sweets.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 64
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

8) Throat Cold Ascending

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 65
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Repertorisation

Posology (With Reason):


Potency 200 1 Dose

Reasons:
1. Source - animal kingdom but toxic venom so cannot be used in
low potency --->high potency.
Prognosis: - Good

Prescription:-
Mrs. U.S
Rx
Cenchris 200 (1P) H.S. x 1 day
SL 30 tds x 7 days

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 66
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Follow -up
12-05-2000
1)Moods / Thoughts / Overall Well Being - >- Rx SL 30 tds x 7days
2) General condition -->35%--
3)Bodyache-->20%---
4)Severity, frequent , duration of breathlessness-->--
5) Expectoration - easy, whitish

Discussion:-
Considering the selected symptoms other remedy that came up were
Sepia and Lachesis on repertorisation it was seen that Sepia is a
remedy with marked indifference towards loved one. In Sepia A/F is
due to grief, disappointment in love but in this case A/F is from
fright which is markedly seen in Cenchris. Lachesis also has A/F
fright, anger but the difference is Lachesis is thermally hot whereas
Cenchris is knows as chilly Lachesis.
Lachesis has nightly delusion of fire whereas Cenchris has vivacious
lasicivous and dreams of being raped Cenchris has dreams of snakes
but Lachesis has fear of snake complaints aggravates after taking
cold in Cenchris.
Also we learn new clinical traits and symptoms of Cenchris in the
above case such as passionate and vivacious in mental symptoms
and desires sweets in physical generals which did not appear in the
initial proving of Cenchris.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 67
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

OBSERVATION

From the cases available the following statistics is seen:-

SYMPTOMS
MENTALS (11) DREAMS (2) GENERALS (2) THROAT (2)

FEMALE GENITALS (2)

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 68
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

2 FEARS FRIGHT JEALOUSY ABUSIVE

1
VIVACIOUS PASSIONATE DULLNESS FORSAKEN

0
NO. OF SYMPTOMS

MENTALS

2
CHASED
RAPE
1 SNAKES

0
NO. OF INCIDENTS

DREAMS

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 69
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

2
COLD
ASSCENDING
FEELING
1
SORENESS

0
NO. OF SYMPTOMS

THROAT

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 70
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

RIGHT SIDED
CHILLY
1

0
NO . OF SYMPTOMS

GENERALS

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 71
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

2
SEVERE PAIN
DARK MENSES
YELLOW
1
LEUCORRHEA

0
NO. OF SYMPTOMS

FEMALE GENITALIA

CONCLUSION

As this remedy is not repeatedly proved on large scale as compared


to Lachesis, that is why there is limited amount of data present. This
has being the prime reason in missing out the prescriptions and
hence less number of cases. And so it is seen that only in some
systems the symptoms are marked.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 72
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

It has been observed in some cases that there are traits of Cenchris
which were not seen while proving of this remedy but appeared in
clinical cases:-
Case 1: Forsaken feeling
Case 2: Retching with cough
Case 3: Vivacious, Passionate, Desire sweets
Hence from the points mentioned above we can conclude that, these
symptoms/traits can help in differentiating the remedy and
considering these symptoms belonging to Cenchris.

The cases given above has showed us that when symptoms are
entered for repertorization gives Lachesis as first choice remedy
because there are similar traits. From various clinical findings and
further differentiating the symptoms, Cenchris traits are seen and
when this remedy is prescribed, there are cures that had taken place
thus confirming the symptoms.

The cases given above mentions diagnosis like Asthma, ovarian


cysts and also deep rooted mental disturbance. These are very
different diseases affecting a person at different planes of life, but
Cenchris is helpful in curing them all showing its curative power
and also showing that there are curing taking place using this
remedy which was not seen till now.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 73
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Lectures on Materia Medica by Dr.J. T. Kent

Clarkes Dictionary of Practical Materia Medica,

Boerickes Homoeopathic Materia Medica

Homoeobook

Snakes to Simillimum by Dr. Farookh Master

Homoeopathic Recorder 1917 edition by George Dienst

The Spirit of Homeopathic Medicines ByDr. Didier


Grandgeorge.

Dr.Homeo All About Homeopathy

(Website:-http://www.drhomeo.com/homeopathic-
treatment/20-best-homeopathic-medicines-for-nightmares/)
BY Dr.Vikas Sharma.

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 74
STUDYING UTILITY OF
CENCHRIS CONTORTRIX AS A HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY

Case 1: New England Journal of Homeopathy

(Website:-http://www.nesh.com/the-new-england-
journal-of-homeopathy/vol-8-no-2-fallwinter-
1999/difficult-cases-frustrating-ordeals-or-
learning-experiences/)

Case 2: New remedies, clinical cases, lesser writings,


aphorisms and percepts by Dr. J. T. Kent

Case 3: Dr. Nimish Mehta

Smt. Chandaben Mohanbhai Patel


Homeopathic Medical College
Page 75

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen