Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
First Thoughts
Counseling
1
This lecture does not specifically address the role of regular exercise in
either the treatment or management of diseases or pathologic conditions (such
as hypertension), or rehabilitation, although many of the basic principles for
helping any patient to become a regular exerciser would hold true.
Epidemiology of Exercise
Research has demonstrated that virtually all individuals will benefit from
regular physical activity . Moderate physical activity can reduce substantially
the risk of developing or dying from heart disease, diabetes, colon cancer, and
high blood pressure. Physical activity may also protect against lower back pain
and some [other] forms of cancer (for example, breast cancer). On average,
physically active people outlive those who are inactive. Regular physical activity
also helps to maintain the functional independence of older adults and
enhances
the quality of life for people of all ages.
There are no known clinical trials of different approaches to the nuts and
bolts of regular leisure-time exercise. Controlled research comparing the
effectiveness of one particular leisure-time exercise program versus another in
fostering an ongoing pattern of regular exercise would be difficult to design and
very expensive to conduct.
2
disorders. Therapeutic exercise regimens (and there are many very useful ones)
are beyond the scope of this lecture.
Patients who are subject to extreme tachycardia should take their pulse
while exercising. To assure that exercise intensity remains at a safe level, the
pulse rate should remain below 85% of the person's theoretical maximum age-
adjusted heart rate (220 age).
Although the evidence to date shows that exercise must be aerobic for it
to be beneficial in reducing long-term risk for coronary artery disease, exercise
at any level above the sedentary state is helpful for weight loss and for
producing the mental benefits associated with regular physical activity.
3
Regardless of the accumulated data about the long-term health benefits
of regular exercise, most regular exercisers engage in the activity because of
the immediate benefits of feeling good and feeling better about themselves.
When patients ask about the benefits of regular exercise, the clinician
should stress the short-term gains: feeling good, improved personal
appearance, and increased self-esteem.
The clinician should point out though that most but not all sedentary
people who become regular exercisers experience these gains. Long-term
benefits will also motivate some patients and should be noted.
The latter is the most common cause of injury in most of the activities
and sports used for regular exercise, such as running, fast walking, cycling, and
swimming.
Intrinsic injury can be prevented by the use of proper equipment and
correct technique.
4
Therefore moderation and gradual change, if changes are to be made, are as
always, good counsel.
Regular exercise requires more than just the temporary extra expenditure
of time required to establish most other positive lifestyle changes such as
engaging in healthy eating, achieving weight loss, and stopping cigarette
smoking. For example, all people spend time food shopping, cooking, and
eating. After learning about what changes to make, healthy eating requires only
that the time be spent differently.
Although the USPSTF does not endorse them, these tests may be clinically
indicated for men older than 40 years with two or more risk factors for coronary
artery disease other than sedentary lifestyle. Coronary artery disease risk
factors include elevated serum cholesterol, history of cigarette smoking,
hypertension, diabetes, or a family
history of early-onset coronary artery disease
5
Furthermore, the clinician should conduct a thorough clinical evaluation of
patients for whom regular exercise presents a definite risk, before advising
these patients to start exercising. These high-risk patients may have a history
of one or more of the following diseases or conditions:
Previous myocardial infarction
Exceptional chest pain or pressure, or severe shortness of breath
Pulmonary disease, especially chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Bone, joint or other musculoskeletal diseases or other limitations
These conditions are not necessarily contraindications to regular exercise,
but each patient's risk must be assessed on an individual basis.
Patients for whom regular exercise presents a possible risk may have a
history of one or more of the following diseases or conditions:
Hypertension
Cigarette smoking
Elevated serum cholesterol
Prescription medication used on a regular basis
Abuse of drugs or alcohol
Any other chronic illness, such as diabetes
Family history of heart disease
Overweight in excess of 20 lb
Current sedentary lifestyle
Goal Setting
In most cases, the first subject to discuss with patients is goal setting:
why is the patient thinking about regular exercise? It may be because the
clinician suggested it, but virtually no one becomes and remains a regular
exerciser simply because they are told to do so.
The same list can be used in the process of motivational interviewing with
patients who are not yet prepared to make health-promoting lifestyle changes.
For patients currently in the precontemplation or contemplation stages of
change, addressing the questions mentioned earlier may be helpful to patients
in advancing to the next stage.
Realism
6
The clinician should counsel patients to set realistic goals and define
success for themselves. A good formulation of this concept is to explore your
limits and recognize your limitations. Consider the example of endurance
versus speed. After some reasonable period of training, say 34 months, most
people can improve endurance, but they may not be able to improve their
speed. Speed is the product of speed-specific training plus natural ability.
Many people will be able to train fairly easily for endurance, because for
most people endurance is not simply the product of natural ability. On the other
hand, because natural ability is such an important element in speed, many
exercisers will not be able to improve their speed no matter how hard they try.
Clinicians should stress this point to their patients in order to avoid frustration,
injury, and quitting. On the other hand, if patients are encouraged to explore
their limits gradually and carefully, they may discover abilities they never knew
they had.
Inner Motivation
The literature regarding positive lifestyle and behavior change clearly
shows that the only kind of motivation that works in the long run comes from
within. The patient says, I want to do this for me, because I want to look
better, feel better, and feel better about myself, not for anyone else. In
contrast, a patient who is externally motivated says, I'm doing this to make
my [spouse, boy/girl friend, children/parents, employer/coworkers] feel better,
but I don't anticipate getting much out of it for me. External motivation almost
invariably leads to guilt, anxiety, anger, frustration, and, quitting, and possibly
even injury.
Taking Control
Taking control is an important concept to stress with patients. In this
formulation, patients decide to engage in physical activity on a regular basis,
perhaps in a physical activity that they have never done before or even
contemplated doing. Many people find that taking control of the process for
themselves, thinking yes I can, because yes, I can do this is an important
motivator, both in starting a regular exercise program and sticking with it.
Gradual Change
Gradual change leads to permanent changes is another basic element
leading to success in becoming a regular exerciser, losing weight, and making
other lifestyle changes. It is recommended that the previously sedentary person
should start with ordinary walking, at a normal pace, for 10 minutes or so, three
times a week. After a couple of weeks, the patient can increase the length of
each session.
After several more weeks, the patient can increase the frequency of
sessions and the speed with which the exercise is performed. The hardier soul
may move through this program more quickly, but all should be counseled
against going out for an hour, at full tilt at the beginning. Too much, too soon
may lead to muscle pain, injury, and an increased likelihood of quitting. Once
7
again, a gradual increase in time spent, distance covered, and speed are the
proven formula for adherence.
The correct first step for many patients who are motivated to start
exercising is to discover that they can indeed find and make the time in their
lives for exercise on a regular basis. For most people, the focus of the first 24
weeks of an exercise program should include making the time to exercise and
walking instead of learning a new sport or athletic activity.
As previously noted, since the early 1990s it has been recognized that
physical activity, even at a moderate level of intensity, can also be beneficial to
health. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the ACSM
recommended that, for persons not engaging in regular aerobic exercise at the
ACSM standard, an accumulated 30 minutes daily of moderate-intensity
physical activity (below the aerobic level) should be performed on as many
days of the week as possible.
8
The so-called lifestyle approach to exercising regularly includes such
activities as ordinary walking, gardening, and housecleaning for a minimum of
10 minutes per session. The lifestyle approach can help some people get
started exercising regularly. Counting and recording short sessions and trying to
figure what does and does not count as exercise can become confusing and
time consuming.
There is a wide range of activities or sports that can be used for regular
exercise, whether aerobic or nonaerobic. There are the tried and true sports,
such as running, fast walking, bicycling, and aerobic dance. These are sports to
which most people have ready access at home, where they may even exercise
to the accompaniment of a video or television show.
Less widely available are activities that often require an athletic facility,
such as running and walking on a treadmill or indoor track, swimming, and
group aerobic dance classes. Exercise machines such as treadmills, stair
climbers, ellipticals, and stationary bicycles can be purchased for home use.
For cycling, there are also indoor trainer devices on which road bicycles
can be mounted for riding in place. Certain individual and team skill sports are
often played at aerobic intensity and are useful for regular exercise.
As contrasted with weight training for strength and bulk, aerobic routines
stress
lighter resistance, more repetitions and sets (groups of repetitions) of each
program component, and less time between sets to keep the heart rate in the
training range. Some health clubs feature circuit training, utilizing a set of
machines and stations offering different muscle resistance levels.
9
Aerobic exercises are performed by participants in a series, following a
timed schedule established by a prerecorded set of instructions broadcast in
the circuit training room over the loudspeaker.
The heart and muscles do not know what sport the exerciser is
performing. If the activity increases heart rate and muscle oxygen uptake to a
given level, the benefit will be the same, regardless of the sport. For example,
pace walkingfast walking with a strong arm swing is equivalent to running if
each is done to the same level of aerobic intensity.
Pace walking with a strong arm swing at a rate of 1112 minutes per mile
is usually as demanding on the cardiovascular system as running 89 minutes
per mile.
10
Set nonexercise-related goals like getting an errand or two completed in
the course of a workout.
Periodically, reward oneself with a new piece of clothing or a long-denied
snack treat.
Enjoy the rhythm, being outdoors, and the seasonal variation that is part
of many of the sports done for aerobic exercise.
Many regular exercisers find that a very useful way to stay on a program
and enjoy it is to engage occasionally in racing, not for speed but for
participation and feelings of personal achievement in terms of distance covered
or time spent.
Be sure to take a week or two off when needed, at least one to two times
per year.
The benefit of focusing on time is that the workouts can be used for any
sport or activity the patient decides to undertake. The minutes formula allows
the person to easily mix and match sports or activities in a single program. The
periodicity and duration of the sessions comprising the program recommended
in these tables are based on the assumption that the person will be engaging in
a regular exercise program, at a level of intensity eventually reaching the
aerobic range.
Technique
The clinician need not be a technical expert in the sports or activities
suitable for regular exercise. There are many good books written for the layman
on the subject. If exercise counseling becomes a regular part of the practice,
the clinician may benefit from periodic visits to local bookshops and/or the
popular web-based booksellers for an update on available books.
The technique for pace walking, the recommended starting sport, is very
simple.
Your shoulders should be dropped and relaxed, your head up. Swing your
arms forward and back, strongly, with your elbows comfortably bent. (The
elbow bend prevents the accumulation of fluid in the hands, which will happen
if you swing your arms strongly while keeping them straight.) At the end of the
back swing, you should feel a tug in your shoulder. On the fore swing, your hand
should come up no further than mid-chest level. To stay in balance and
maintain a smooth forward motion from the hips down, concentrate on the back
swing, not the fore swing.
12
For most people, it is the strong arm swing that makes pace walking
aerobic. If a person has been completely sedentary for some time, just walking
quickly without the strong arm swing will most likely raise the heart rate into
the aerobic range. When the exerciser has been working out more regularly
though, walking fast alone will not be sufficient to raise the heart rate into the
aerobic range. That is why if walking is to be used as the aerobic exercise on an
ongoing basis (and many regular exercisers do so use it), a second major
muscle group must be brought into play (i.e., swinging the arms strongly as in
pace walking).
Equipment
The design should be suited to the sport for which it will be used: that is,
shoes for pace walking or running should facilitate forward motion, shoes for
tennis or aerobic dance should facilitate lateral motion. Referral to a sports
medicine orthopedist or podiatrist may be necessary for orthotics or special
shoes in patients with a lower extremity disorder or a known foot deformity
such as hallux valgus. In general, a person should be advised to buy equipment
in a pro shop rather than in a department store.
The cost of equipment for the regular exerciser can range from nothing
(the person decides to pace walk or jog, and their wardrobe already includes an
adequate pair of shoes and the necessary clothing), to hundreds or even
several thousand dollars for a health club membership, high-performance
athletic shoes, or a top-of-the-line bicycle. The best recommendation for
beginners is to spend as little as possible, except on buying a good pair of
shoes if they lack a pair, until they are convinced they are going to stay with
the sport.
Office and Clinic Organization
13
These principles must be reduced to a counseling package that can be
used successfully in clinical practice. First, of course, clinicians must decide
whether exercise counseling is important for some or all of their patients. To do
that, the clinician should follow the same goal-setting process that the potential
exerciser undertakes as his or her first step.
How should the practice use community resources (e.g., classes offered
by health systems and community centers, health clubs, sports clubs, gyms,
pools, tracks, bicycle routes, walking or running trails, courts, and pro shops), if
at all?
Are there other resources, such as Internet or telephone coaching
services, which can be used in concert with the clinician?
Is role modeling important?
How should I learn the specifics of regular exercise counseling and
incorporate them into my own knowledge base and skills?
How much time am I willing to invest in developing an exercise promotion
component in my practice?
It should be noted that asking and answering these questions for oneself,
with certain variations to be sure, applies to the consideration of adding any
health behavior counseling program/protocol to one's practice. In particular the
list applies to weight management efforts for which a regular exercise
component should surely be included. In many practices, group programs for
promoting both regular exercise and healthy weight management will be at
least in part integrated. Practices face opportunity costs in setting up a group
class for every behavior, and therefore some parsimony is required.
Although a practice would likely run separate group classes for smoking
cessation or healthy sexual practices, an integrated program for exercise and
weight management might come naturally because regular exercise is so
central to effective weight management and because so many persons who
first seek help with regular exercise are trying to lose weight. Indeed it would
make sense for a practice to have an integrated approach to the triad of
exercise, diet, and weight management, at least for beginners. More
advanced classes that focus on exercise might be considered for patients going
on to higher levels of regular exercise for its own sake and perhaps competitive
sports (e.g., racing).
14
Further, if it is decided to incorporate exercise promotion into one's
routine clinical practice, it is worth spending time to learn about and evaluate
the various community resources for promoting both regular exercise and
weight management. This will save time and provides substantive assistance to
patients. The clinician can consider setting up a formal referral relationship with
respected community facilities and establishing convenient in-office systems
(e.g., fax referral forms, automated referrals using an electronic health record)
to facilitate the process (see Chapter 21 for more details on making use of
these resources).
15