Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
BRAIN Make
You GAY?
An Argument for the Validity and
Importance of Biological Correlates of
Sexual Orientation
by Madeline Thompson
Since modern homosexual biological causes of sexual orientation.
behavior came under attack as a deviant The question still remains: what makes
lifestyle in the 1860s, people have oered someone attracted to a person of the
a range of theories to explain attraction same sex? Is it a conscious choice? An
to the same-sex13. Theories ranged from unconscious result of a trauma during
poor parenting, early sexual abuse, childhood? Or is it genetically
single-parent families, allowing boys to determined before we are even born?
play with dolls, and a host of other even While there have been studies that
less plausible explanations. For a time, present research in favor of other
doctors even advised against women explanations, the biological argument is
riding astride a horse (meaning that they most convincing. Research since the
had to ride sidesaddle) because they 1980s has shown that birth order, genes,
thought the movement of the horse hormone levels, and more all correlate
would sexually stimulate the woman and with sexual orientation. Although
make them so excited they would have correlation is not causation, the many
sex with other women in the absence of a overlapping findings and replications
man 29 . Today, these theories sound make biological predispositions the most
ridiculous, but it has only been relatively convincing argument for the origin of
recently that researchers have explored homosexuality.
Did Your Brain Make You Gay? 2
Studies of twins show that if one seen in gay men27. These disorders
monozygotic (identical) twin is gay, then account for the increased number of
the other twin has a 52% chance of also stillbirths and miscarriages, particularly
being gay (as opposed to the 5-10% of male children, which explains the lack
chance in the general population)3. If the of maternal uncles (since the gene is
twin is fraternal, meaning that they are carried on the X chromosome, inherited
no more related than a normal sibling yet from the mother). In fact, the number of
shared the same in utero environment, male babies in these families is low
the chance of the other twin being gay is enough to suggest that 50% of the males
26%2. This is seen even when the twins conceived died27. Because these disorders
and lack of uncles are seen in
No Relation Fraternal Twins Identical Twins families of gay individuals, then
5%-10% 27% 52% perhaps it is these variations of
the Xq28 region that also
influence same-sex attraction.
H o w e v e r, t h i s i s a b r o a d
conclusion to make from just a
few correlations, so lets take a
look at a stronger relationship
Figure 1: The chance that a person is gay based on their
b e t w e e n h o m o s ex u a l i t y a n d
biological relationship to a gay person.
genetics.
The human body produces
are raised apart, such as in adoption, so
antibodies in response to foreign
it cannot be explained by the parenting
molecules, such as germs. These
style or childhood environment. So
antibodies stay in your body long after
genetics are definitely at play, but what is
the sickness is gone, which is why you
it about your biology that might
usually dont get the same illness twice.
determine your sexual orientation?
If a woman has a male child, the
Researchers have found that gay men
t e s t o s t e r o n e a n d o t h e r y - l i n ke d
have significantly fewer maternal uncles
molecules present in her womb may be
than would be expected by chance and
seen as a foreign product that the body
are more likely to have family members
needs to protect against7,9. The maternal
who have experienced multiple stillbirths
immunization eect says that the
or miscarriages 27 . Male semilethal
mothers body produces anti-
conditions, which are conditions that
testosterone antibodies, but not enough
aect males and sometimes result in
to aect the first baby. However,
death, may be the culprit. Quite a few of
researchers have documented that the
these male semilethal conditions are
more older biological brothers a male
located in region Xq28 on the X
has, the more likely he is to be gay
chromosome and anomalies here are also
now referred to as the FBOE, or the
Did Your Brain Make You Gay? 3
Fraternal Birth Order Eect7,9. For each through adoption, so the babying the
successive boy born the odds of being youngest theory is very unlikely9.
gay increase by 33% and the maternal But why would attacking
immunization theor y provides an testosterone be correlated with more
explanation 5 . Because antibodies babies being gay? The theory lies in the
critical developmental period. Critical
developmental periods are times in a
persons life when certain stimuli have
impacts on development that cannot be
easily changed later. That is, if you
miss the critical development, it will
be hard to alter any eects. One of these
critical periods is the period for sexual
dierentiation, or the development of an
embryo into a male or female baby4,31.
Table 1: The chance that a man is gay based on This is caused by sex hormones present
the number of older brothers he has5. in utero. For males, a certain level of
androgens (male sex hormones, which
continue to be present in the mothers include testosterone) is required to form
body long after the object of attack (in sex organs, a penis, and other secondary
this case a male fetus) is gone, the more sex characteristics23,31. Researchers now
y-linked proteins the mother has been theorize that these androgens are
exposed to via previous male important for developing an attraction to
pregnancies, the better the mothers females as well4. This slight reduction in
body is at attacking testosterone. This
attack on testosterone might result in
a male child lacking in testosterone,
w h i c h m a y i n fl u e n c e s e x u a l
attraction4. When these findings first
came out, some argued that the
younger sons might be more likely to
be gay not because of biological
factors, but because parents baby the
youngest child. However, the FBOE is Figure 2: Illustration of the Maternal Immunization
not seen in families with stepchildren Hypothesis2.
who did not share their mothers
womb, and is seen even in men whose androgen levels due to the mothers
older biological brothers had been antibodies attacking testosterone would
stillborn or were raised apart from them explain the increased likelihood of her
son being gay. A persons facial
Did Your Brain Make You Gay? 4
structure, which is also aected by tilted back, and more convex cheeks in
prenatal hormone levels, is also comparison to straight men25. What
correlated with sexual orientation. makes this finding all the more
Have you ever heard someone say compelling is that when FaceGen, which
that they have great gay-dar, or the analyzed the hundreds of faces reported
ability to tell if someone is gay just by in the study, was also asked to look at
looking at them? Most people consider it the faces after the primary facial
to be a joke, or at best a guess based on structure analysis and guess the
someones fashion style, but it turns out sexuality, FaceGen was correct over 70%
that gay men and gay womens faces of the time in men and 80% of the time
actually do dier from straight men and in women (the reason for the dierence
women. Gay women have more puckered in accuracy is unknown)25. Because facial
Figure 3: What does gay look like? This figure shows the probability that FaceGen would classify female
(a) or male (b) face as heterosexual based on the structural characteristics of the face25.
problem is that these findings come from population of Finland, which may
a study that used only white participants, eliminate these confounds, found a
and therefore it has yet to be determined strong eect of 2D:4D ratio for both
if this applies to the general population. women and men, but not in the way they
The 2D:4D ratio is the the length expected16. They found that gay men did
of your second finger (your second digit, indeed have more feminized digit
or 2D) divided by the length of your ratios, but they also found that gay
fourth finger (4D). Because prenatal women had more feminized digit ratios!
androgens make the fourth finger grow, Unfortunately, even though using a
men often have smaller 2D:4D ratios homogenous population removes some
than women 16 . Therefore, if lower confounding variables, it also means that
a n d r o g e n ex p o s u r e i s r e l a t e d t o it is questionable whether these results
homosexuality, we would expect gay generalize to gay individuals in the rest
males to have higher 2D:4D ratios than of the world. The authors in the Finnish
straight males and gay women to have study also found that gay people were
lower 2D:4D ratios than straight women. more likely to have a larger number of
This is exactly what many researchers older siblings, male or female, than
straight people, and they
hypothesized that this is due to
a depleted womb environment
after several children have
occupied it before, similar to
the FBOE theory16.
Another line of evidence
that points to variations in
womb environment aecting
sexual orientation is the
amount of asymmetry found
among gay people.
Developmental instability (DI)
is a term used to describe the
results of stress in utero that
Figure 4: Average 2D:4D ratio in heterosexual and non-
can cause an organism to
heterosexual men and women16.
develop atypically. DI results in
have found, but it should be noted that fluctuating asymmetry (FA),
other factors such as race, nutrition, which is a measure that assesses the
measuring techniques have resulted in extent to which bilateral features dier
some of the reported correlations being from each other 15 . The bigger the
insignificant 16 . However, one study dierence between the two halves of
looking at the ver y homogenous someones body (one ankle, elbow, or
Did Your Brain Make You Gay? 6
knee bigger than the other; fingers on scope of this paper. But lets turn to the
one hand longer than another, etc), the additional evidence for eects of sex
more developmental instability was hormones in humans.
present in the womb. Gay women and Do you know any gay men? Are
men are both more likely to have higher their birthdays in May? If so, it might not
FA than straight people, indicating that be a coincidence: gay men are more likely
they were exposed to more in utero to be born in May, and less likely to be
stress such as smoking, certain born in October and November, though
medications, or simply having an older the latter finding only approaches
than average mother, and thus more significance20. Gay women appear to have
developmental instability 15 . These birthdays clustered around October and
results are supported by other studies November, although the statistical
that show that other developmental significance has not been tested20. But
stressors such as smoking during why would this be? The answer involves
pregnancy are correlated with the both melatonin and testosterone. The
likelihood of having a lesbian daughter, largest amount of testosterone in
and that gay men are more
likely to be born prematurely
and have lower birth weights,
pointing to the presence of
developmental instability6,8,26.
Furthermore, perinatal (after
birth) disruptions in
testosterone levels can aect
the size of a part of the
hypothalamus called the Post-
Optic Area nucleus. The POA
has also been implicated in
same-sex attraction, where
studies using rats found that
higher levels of testosterone
correlated with a smaller POA
nucleus, and a smaller POA
nucleus was associated with
greater same-sex behavioral Figure 5: The percentage that the amount of gay men and
10
tendencies . However, that womens birthdays deviate from the U.S. average in a certain
begs the question are rats a month20.
comparable model for human
sexuality? the complicated answer of pregnant mothers is generally present at
which is, unfortunately, beyond the the end of the fourth month of gestation,
Did Your Brain Make You Gay? 7
individuals. We do not yet know if the respond to the odors of their potential
reverse is seen in gay women, but since partners? The answer is actually yes!
gay women are also more likely to be left Electroencephalograms, or EEGs,
handed, it is unclear whether or not their provide readings of dierent electrical
corpus callosa would appear more like a potentials in the brain, allowing us to
straight man or a left-handed person. measure responses to certain stimuli in
Genetics might also influence real time. Greater P3 amplitudes (which
social behaviors related to sexual means a positive electrical spike seen
orientation. Further research found 300 milliseconds after a stimuli) are
dierences in a region of 8q12 in often observed in response to scents of
addition to the Xq28 region described people with which the individual should
24
previously . A type of vasopressin not mate 19 . This would have the
receptor (Arginine Vasopressin Receptor beneficial eect of preventing you from
2) is also coded for at Xq28, and mating with someone who is genetically
Neuropeptides B/W Receptor 1 is found closely related to you, because you will
on 8q12 both receptors have been not be attracted to their smell. In this
implicated in social behaviors . 24
case, gay men and gay women would be
Therefore, the dierences at Xq28 and expected to respond with greater P3
8q12 in gay people could result in amplitudes in response to scents of the
dierences in certain receptors, which in opposite sex. Indeed, gay women
turn could result in dierent
social responses to dierent
genders. Additionally, the
receptor Cyclic Nucleotide
Gated Channel Alpha 2
(CNGA2) is also located on
Xq28 and this particular
receptor is important in
responses to odors of potential
mates in mice24. While a simple
linkage between these genes
and sexual orientation are not
proof of functional connection,
it provides a reason to now Figure 6: The strength of the P3 amplitude seen in women in
carry out genome wide response to dierent body odors. Blue represents weaker
association studies to look for amplitudes and red represents stronger amplitudes19.
these specific connections.
Researchers found that the respond more strongly to the scents of
CNGA2 is important for responding to men, and gay men respond more
odors in mice, but do humans really strongly to the scents of women even
Did Your Brain Make You Gay? 9
though they did not know which gender men18. On the other hand, gay men have
they were smelling19. So gay men seem a higher CMRglu in the prefrontal
to have automatic physiological association cortex and the cingulate
responses against mating with women cortex compared to straight men18. This
and vice versa. There have been other is seen even in men who have had no
functional brain dierences described as history of psychiatric disorders or
well. medications, which is important because
Gay men not only have, on it means that, unlike the size of brain
average, larger corpus callosa than areas, their dierential CMRglu is
straight men, but their hypothalamus probably not due to experience. One
also processes a drug called fluoxetine important criticism of some of the
dierently. Gay men, when given correlations described earlier in this
fluoxetine (a selective serotonin reuptake paper is that behavioral dierences
inhibitor, or SSRI, often given as an between people can result in brain
antidepressant), show a smaller dierences. This would mean that
reduction of their cerebral metabolic rate perhaps dierences in the way gay and
of glucose (CMRglu) in the straight people act result in dierent
hypothalamus, cuneate gyrus, and lateral brain scans, but there is no actual
anterior cingulate gyrus than straight biological underlier of homosexuality.
For example, perhaps gay men and
straight women speak more because
of societal expectations, and thus their
corpus callosum forms more
connections between the two
hemispheres, rather than the size of
the corpus callosa resulting in better
hemisphere communication. The
dierences seen in CMRglu, however,
cannot be explained by behavior and
thus provide evidence of a pre-existing
biological anomaly. This finding then
provides evidence that there are
neurochemical dierences between
gay and straight men probably before
they even identify with one sexual
orientation or the other.
Figure 7: Dierences in CMRglu in gay and straight I have provided strong evidence
men. Red represents an area where straight men for in utero sex hormones,
showed a greater increase in CMRglu. Blue represents d e v e l o p m e n t a l i n s t a b i l i t y, a n d
an area where gay men showed a greater increase in structural and functional brain
Did Your Brain Make You Gay? 10
including gender, they are likely to pick population, because the sample was not
men because of the lack of estrus cycle representative of the larger population. If
hormonal variations. Even though we a study finds that white gay males have a
now know that men and women can polymorphism at the Xq28 region, that
have dierent expressions of diseases, does not mean that, for example gay
dierent reactions to drugs, and dierent women of color have the same
functionality of their brain, men are still polymorphism. By excluding people of
sometimes seen as a neutral human to
use as a participant. Lastly, as you can
see from the results of the study in the
previous paragraph, female sexuality has
been consistently found to be more
complicated than male sexuality. Straight
women are physically aroused by both
male and female pornography12,21. Gay
women have more feminized hands than
than straight women16. And significantly
more women than men report their
sexuality as fluid17. These variations
make it harder to study gay women and
suggest that more variables are involved
in female sexuality than in male
sexuality. However, because we cannot
infer that findings about gay males
sexual orientation applies to gay women,
more eort must be made to incorporate
them into future studies.
Additionally, non-white women Figure 9: A recent cover of The Advocate that
and men are missing from many of these explored the experiences of queer black people in
studies, which also strongly aects the America14.
generalizability. Similar to the missing
gay women in studies, researchers color, researchers ignore a huge portion
sometimes try to make participants as of the population. Future studies need to
similar as possible to control for possible include people of all races and genders; if
confounds (as in the Finnish digit ratio they re worried about confounding
and facial structure studies). However, variables, they can perform statistical
this means that the studies have less analyses after to look at between group
external validity, or generalizability, dierences, rather than ignoring entire
meaning that we dont know if the populations.
findings actually apply to the larger
Did Your Brain Make You Gay? 12