BELTRAN, Czarina Veeya Faye C
AR 420B 9:30-10:30 MWF HD301
6 FEBRUARY 2016
STANDARD POST-POSITIVISM
TRUTH INTERNAL VALIDITY. "A Bamboo
VALUE Building Design Support Tool"
by Fitri Madjorno, 2002. There is
a part in the manuscript where
the researcher did a demonstration of how culture
verification, validation, and test
of the building material. The
process of verification starts by
checking the knowledge
contents and the hierarchy
patterns applied in the tool,
then analyzing the design-
decision making of the tool. The
validity was done by detecting
whether the system contains
incompleteness or
inconsistencies.
APPLICABILI EXTERNAL VALIDITY. "Bamboo
TY Design and Construction in
Thailand" by Thana
Uthaippattrakoon, 2015. Ten
species of bamboos were
selected to test in this study,
regarding their physical and
mechanical properties. This ten
species ensured generalizability
the researcher proved her
findings in the study in other
circumstances, in this case, in
other species.
CONSISTENC RELIABILITY. "Seismic
Y Performance of Bamboo
Structures" by Bhavna Sharma,
2010. Investigation of various
test methods was explored by
the researcher to determine the
factors related to bamboo
material properties and
particularly splitting failure in
bamboo culms. And these
varying test methods resulted
NATURALISTIC
CREDIBILITY. "Cultural
Influences on Architecture" by
Stephen F. Kenney, 1994. A
influences architectural form
was conducted through the
design of a new Roman
Catholic Church. In addition,
the works of sociologists as
well as requirements put forth
by the Roman Catholic Church
will be used to describe the
cultural values and needs of
the users to the structure. The
researcher used a variety of
stakeholders to cross-check
data and interpretations.
TRANSFERABILITY. "The Role of
Culture in Promoting
Architectural Identity" by
Sheida Ettehad, et al., 2014.
The researchers made clear in
the manuscript that they
considered a global
perspective. Meaning, even if
the study was based in Israel,
if we are to use it, it is still
reliable even if we are in the
Philippines.
DEPENDABILITY. "Cultural
Issues in Architecture - Case
Study of Esan in Edo State -
Nigeria" by J.E. Ahianba, 2009.
Aside from the questionnaires
gathered by the researcher, he
also used video recorders to
capture the whole interaction.
This way, he can track the
inconsistency of the data if
ever it happens.
 to consistend findings.
NEUTRALITY OBJECTIVITY. "Bamboo: An CONFIRMABILITY. "Evaluation
Alternative Building Material for of the Relationship Between
Urban Ethiopia" by Bewketu Z. Culture and Traditional
Kassa, 2009. This thesis has Architecture and its Effects on
shown bamboos potential as Design Quality Improvement"
an alternative building material by Gholamali Hessam and El-
that could alleviate the high Din Sotoue, 2016. The
cost of housing in urban conclusion presented in the
Ethiopia. The proposed bamboo study was more of the
framed structure can be easily assumptions of the
assembled and seamlessly researchers. They also used
integrated into the urban triangulation relating culture,
landscape. And since this was a architecture and design quality
quantitative and fully scientific improvement.
research, there was no room for
opinions by the researcher.
Thus, rendering the manuscript
to be fully objective.