Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Finding Smart Money. Small businesses usually need more than just cash:
they need smart money. By smart money we mean financing where the
financier provides not only capital, but support and expertise to the business.
Smart money could be an SBA guaranteed loan that allows one to keep their
ownership interests intact until the business reaches the stage at which they
may want to sell shares of the business.
The problem in locating "smart" money is that the capital market for small
businesses is imperfect and consists of a great variety of under publicized
and poorly organized financing sources. Whether one is trying to locate a
bank that is willing to lend money to a small business or whether one is
looking for a business "angel" who will contribute needed equity capital, the
quest for financing will require the owner to devote the same attention to
obtaining capital as given to decisions involving the business's basic product
or service.
The discussion in this module is designed to help one identify relevant traits
about the business's financing profile and understand the various financing
sources that may be available.
Debt vs. equity shows how the two basic forms of financing differ, and
how one can combine them to their best advantage.
1
2
A Business's Financing Profile
Most entrepreneurs consider their resource pool to consist of whatever
personal assets they are willing to sink into the business, and whatever
money they might be able to get through a local bank loan. Yet, a number of
alternative (or additional) financing options may be available.
Whether insider financing can fill the gap between what it has and
what is needed
3
Aging businesses tend to be cash-rich because new investment is not
taking place. Owners are often searching for the best way to sell out.
4
Startup Small Businesses
Startup businesses often begin with only ideas and enthusiasm. One of the
many issues that every entrepreneur must address in starting a small
business is the financial reality involved in deciding exactly what he or she
wants to do, when it can be done, and how it's going to be done.
This cash crunch puts a tremendous focus upon inventory turnover, and the
need for immediate revenue often becomes a daily crisis that takes priority
over financing for sustained growth or development of new products.
Perseverance and a willingness to investigate all sources of financing from
angels to government loan programs are invaluable at this stage.
Acquired Businesses
In many respects, the financing options available when one purchases an
existing business are similar to the options for raising capital in a growing
business that is already own. Debt and equity vehicles are typically more
available than if it were starting a similar business from scratch. Because the
target business has a credit history, existing assets, an established operating
cycle and business goodwill, lenders and investors can be approached in the
5
same manner as if one is seeking to expand a business which is already
owned.
The existing assets of the business are often the exclusive collateral for
the financing. In contrast to the common practice of conventional
lenders, additional or personal assets of the buyer are rarely pledged
as additional collateral on a seller-financed loan. Moreover, a seller's
valuation of the business's assets (collateral) tends to be higher than
that of a conventional lender; a low valuation might appear
inconsistent with the asking price for the business.
6
The use of a gradual buyout may be acceptable to the seller. For
instance, the business name and goodwill, and perhaps some tangible
assets, could be sold upfront; other equipment or property could be
leased by the buyer with an optional or mandatory buyout at a future
time. The seller may be willing to accept an earn out arrangement,
where a portion of the purchase price is depending on the future
success of the business.
7
through private transfers of ownership interests, by using venture capital
firms, or by selling ownership interests through formal limited private
offerings or an initial public offering.
Aging Businesses
Many businesses never reach this stage of the business life cycle because
they either fail at an earlier stage or they remain healthy, growing entities.
An aging business is characterized by a conservative philosophy aimed at
maintaining the business's internal bureaucracy and its market status quo.
Some companies reach the point where innovation and creativity are limited
to tinkering with current products and existing markets. Investment into new
product lines and emerging markets represents a financial risk that a
complacent ownership is unwilling to assume. Aging businesses tend to be
cash-rich because less investment is being undertaken.
The financial concerns for owners of aging businesses often involve selling
the business and retirement planning .
8
questions may be answered by data contained in the business's financial
statements and projections; however, lenders and investors also make more
subjective evaluations of the promoter and the company. These assessments
may affect the financing requests even more than the objective numbers.
Additional evidence of future success for the business can sometimes take
the form of contract commitments from existing or prospective customers,
industry or professional opinions, and market research even if it's informal
testimonials. In a business plan or loan application, make a note of any
advantageous market trends, consumer appeal, management experience,
retention of skilled employees, and availability of any special resources, e.g.,
a valuable patent.
While making a case that the business is a worthy investment, keep in mind
that most lenders and investors are followers, not leaders, and the best
evidence of a good investment will be the promoters prior success in raising
capital.
9
personal resume, as well as letters of reference from community
professionals and business persons, to help project themselves as a
reputable, reliable, and creative business person.
The financier would want to know the amount of money that is needed from
the beginning to the maturity of the project, details on how the money will
be used, and most importantly, how the money will either be repaid or result
in a profit. All of this information should be included in the business plan and
confirmed in the financial projections.
The Promoter or owner should be aware that the reasons behind the capital
needs may raise some lender concerns about the management and future
success of the company. If, for instance, the business is growing and a need
for additional working capital may be a result of managerial shortcomings
that are causing slow sales, high inventory, slow collections, or unmet short-
term debt. In situations where additional funds are necessary because
unanticipated sales volume is creating greater needs for inventory or
collection of accounts receivable, management may need to show that the
business can expect continued success.
10
Whether the financing is for a new or existing business, a well-thought-
out business plan is essential.
Initial setup costs. Prepare an itemized estimate of how much it will cost to
get the business set up. These will all be pre-opening expenses.
11
For manufacturing concerns, there may be additional costs related to raw
materials, storage, and shipping.
Planning to Succeed
In order to successfully obtain a mortgage, real estate must have three
legendary ingredients: location, location, and location. But it also helps if the
building looks inviting, has an interesting history, and is surrounded by a few
elegant trees.
Personal Financing
"Save a little money each month and at the end of the year you'll be
surprised at how little you have." Ernest Haskins
12
Most small startup business is initially funded by the personal assets of the
entrepreneur. Some funding for the small business is likely to come from the
direct contributions of personal savings or assets to the business (e.g., an
early retirement incentive payout). Additional personal funds are often
contributed after the entrepreneur borrows money through a personal
(consumer) loan and then contributes that money as an equity investment
into the business.
Home as Collateral
There is a great variety of personal assets that can be used as collateral to
obtain cash from a lender, but perhaps the most common source is a
residence. This asset can be used to obtain a first or second mortgage, to
refinance an existing mortgage, or to secure a home equity loan or line of
credit. The major disadvantage to using the house as collateral is that default
on the loan can mean forfeiture of the home.
Nearly all commercial banks and residential lending institutions will have
options available for home-backed financing. The period and computation of
the rate of interest, upfront points, closing costs, administrative costs and
burdens, the length of loan, loan conditions, and default terms all affect the
real cost of a loan. Whether or not the local lender will sell the mortgage to
another creditor may also be a consideration.
For second mortgages or lines of credit, the owner should anticipate that
lenders will allow a maximum total mortgage debt, including preexisting
mortgages, of approximately 70 to 80 percent of the current market value
of the residence at best. Gone are the days financing up to 100% of the
home's current market value. Interest rates are low now but unlikely to
remain so. The risk of losing the home if the business fails make these loans
a last-ditch choice for most budding entrepreneurs.
Also, be aware that second, or even third, mortgages will typically have
higher interest rates than first mortgages because the lender is subordinate
to a prior mortgagor. (In other words, if there is a default on the loans, the
first-mortgage lender will be paid off first, and the second-mortgage lender
may not be paid at all.) In instances where the interest costs would not be
significantly increased, it is better to refinancing the existing mortgage for an
increased loan amount rather than taking a second or third mortgage.
13
Other Collateral
Other than the residence, other commonly used collateral for secured
consumer loans include other real estate, life insurance policies, any existing
machinery or other business equipment, stock, and pension plans.
For instance, one can usually borrow the cash surrender value of an ordinary
life insurance policy. You are not obligated to repay the loan principal, only to
pay interest on the loan. The rate of interest charged depends upon when
the policy was purchased; rates on older policies might be very favorable. Of
course, borrowing against own policy means the eventual death benefit of
the policy will be diminished by the amount of the loan, plus the loss of
interest.
There are also other assets in the personal portfolio that permits the owner
to borrow from them or that can be used as collateral in a conventional loan.
For example, if one have an employee retirement plan, it may be able to
borrow against those savings up to a certain percentage of the total plan
value. Marketable securities can also be pledged to a bank as collateral for a
loan.
Insider Financing
"The richer your friends, the more they will cost you." Elisabeth Marbury.
After considering the personal resources, the next place most entrepreneurs
look for additional financing is to "insiders" like family, friends, or business
associates. Borrowing from insiders is attractive because it's private, often
informal, usually unsecured, and often includes favorable terms, and
because legal default proceedings are seldom invoked. In addition, this kind
of financing can often be incorporated into a family's estate plan to assist in
minimizing estate and income tax liabilities.
14
Insider Financing via Equity
If an insider wants to become an owner of the business in exchange for
financing, documentation of the arrangement is again important, but the
paperwork will vary according to the type of ownership interest is being
transferred.
15
Inventory management Is there really a need for all that
inventory? It ties up cash, takes up expensive space, ups insurance
costs, and often "shrinks" so if not absolutely needed for immediate
shipping or manufacturing purposes, keep it lean and mean.
Expense control Make every rupee count. Does the company van
need to be washed at the fancy place down the block or can it be done
at a place which is simple and cheaper? Thrift applies to fixed assets,
too. Will a used computer, purchased off-lease, do the job or there is a
need to buy that an expensive, leading edge PC?
A little frugality and sensible use of available resources will pay big dividends
in the long run. The old cliche "watch the pennies and the dollars will take
care of themselves" is the bootstrapper's fight song.
Startup Business
Primary Sources
Long-term financing Short-term financing
16
Angels Credit cards
Secondary Sources
Long-term financing Short-term financing
Franchising
Asset-based financing
Growing/Mature Business
Primary Sources
Long-term financing Short-term financing
17
Venture capital (and SBIC) Commercial finance companies
Secondary Sources
Long-term financing Short-term financing
Angels
Insurance companies
Commercial finance
companies
ESOPs
Debt and equity financing provide different opportunities for raising funds,
and a commercially acceptable ratio between debt and equity financing
should be maintained. From the lender's perspective, the debt-to-equity ratio
measures the amount of available assets or "cushion" available for
repayment of a debt in the case of default. Excessive debt financing may
impair the credit rating and the ability to raise more money in the future. If
there is too much debt, then the business may be considered overextended
and risky and an unsafe investment. In addition, one may be unable to
weather unanticipated business downturns, credit shortages, or an interest
rate increase if the loan's interest rate floats.
Conversely, too much equity financing can indicate that one is not making
the most productive use of the capital; the capital is not being used
advantageously as leverage for obtaining cash. Too little equity may suggest
the owners are not committed to their own business.
19
business to take on excess debt, thereby impairing the business's ability to
subsequently obtain needed capital for growth.
Equity Financing
"It is time I stepped aside for a less experienced and less able man."
Professor Scott Elledge, on retiring from Cornell University
Equity financing requires selling of an ownership interest in the business in
exchange for capital. The most basic hurdle to equity financing is finding
investors who are willing to buy into the business; however, the amount of
equity financing that you undertake may depend more upon the willingness
to share management control than upon the investor appeal of the business.
By selling equity interests in the business, one sacrifices some of the
autonomy and management rights.
Here are the most common small business options for equity financing:
Angels private investors who want to make money and also help
small businesses
20
Initial Public Offerings going public can mean big gains, but it's not
for everyone
Which form is best for you? No formula exists for making the
determination of which entity is best for your business.
21
Business combinations are a way of leveraging the business's assets
through contractual arrangements with other companies.
Simple (and often favorable) tax treatment : All income and expenses
of the business are included on the personal tax return. In addition,
because startup businesses often operate at a loss during an initial
period, the losses can be deducted on the personal tax return to offset
income earned from other sources.
22
Personal liability: The business is not a separate legal entity and all
business debts and liabilities are the personal obligations. Sole
Proprietor is personally responsible for the business's contracts, taxes,
and the misconduct of employees or co-owners who create legal
liabilities while acting within their employment. Although personal
liability is a risk for sole proprietors, several considerations should be
kept in mind. First, insurance may be available to minimize the effects
of personal exposure for some of these liabilities. In addition, personal
liability for business contracts is common in any form of small business
the situation is not necessarily worse for sole proprietors. To
minimize the risks associated with small businesses, customers,
landlords, suppliers, and others will often require that the owner
assume personal responsibility (sign a personal guarantee) for the
business's contract, regardless of the form of the business enterprise.
23
Financing General Partnerships
A general partnership is an association of two or more parties to operate a
business for profit. The partners raise equity funds through their own capital
contributions, by adding a new partner, or by restructuring the relative
ownership interests of the existing partners to reflect new contributions.
Debt financing for general partnerships is similar to financing for sole
proprietorships, because the individual creditworthiness of the owners
largely determines the business's creditworthiness.
24
Limited transferability of ownership: Most partnership arrangements
restrict a partner's rights to withdraw from the partnership or to
transfer the ownership interests.
Financing Corporations
A corporation is a separate legal entity that can be created only by
registering it with the Registrar of Companies (ROC).
For many small businesses, incorporation provides the easiest method for
raising capital from multiple investors, particularly those investors who are
not necessarily interested in actively participating in the business. In some
instances, it may be easier to persuade 15 people to invest $5,000 than to
convince one person to contribute $125,000, and a corporation permits this
kind of widespread ownership.
25
variety of different types and, depending upon the negotiating strength and
the interests of the investors, a small business can limit the extent of
ownership control being sold by limiting the number of shares for sale and/or
the rights associated with each class of stock. Nonvoting shares, preferred
shares, redeemable shares, and a variety of hybrid shares are possible.
26
On the other hand, if the business will have employees (creating potential
personal tort liability for owners), poses relatively high risks, and/or needs to
attract equity financing, the business may benefit from beginning as a
corporation. Among the more specific principles to consider are:
Control. Any entity that has more than one owner involves compromising
the exclusive control over the business. The willingness to dilute the
27
ownership control, and the need to obtain outside equity financing, will
govern this factor.
Business Combinations
Mergers, joint ventures, consolidations, acquisitions, strategic alliances,
associations, and other combinations of business entities can also be
employed to raise new funds for the business. The business climate of the
'90s has encouraged the use of joint ventures and alliances between
businesses as a means of reducing costs and ownership dilution. Most of
these arrangements are contractual, but no standard contract terms exist for
all industries. The advantages of these joint ventures and alliances is that
the business can finance certain services or production functions by sharing
expertise, assets, expenses, and risk without necessarily incurring cash debt
or trading equity.
28
Venture Capital
Venture capital ("VC") firms supply funding from private sources for investing
in select companies that have a high, rapid growth potential and a need for
large amounts of capital. VC firms speculate on certain high-risk businesses
producing a very high rate of return in a very short time. The firms typically
invest for periods of three to seven years and expect at least a 20 percent to
40 percent annual return on their investment.
High cost. The price of financing through venture capital firms is high.
Although the investing company will not typically get involved in the ongoing
management of the company, it will usually want at least one seat on the
target company's board of directors and involvement, for better or worse, in
the major decisions affecting the direction of the company. The ownership
interest of the VC firm is usually a straight equity interest or an ownership
option in the target company through either a convertible debt (where the
debt holder has the option to convert the loan instrument into stock of the
borrower) or a debt with warrants to a straight equity investment (where the
warrant holder has the right to buy shares of common stock at a fixed price
within a specified time period). An arrangement that eventually calls for an
initial public offering is also possible. Despite the high costs of financing
through venture capital companies, they do offer tremendous potential for
obtaining a very large amount of equity financing and they usually provide
qualified business advice in addition to capital.
29
Private Investors/Business Angels
A less-formal source for external equity financing is through private
investors, called "angels," who are seeking new business investments for a
variety of economic and personal reasons. Angels can be a very good source
of money if you are looking for outside investors but you are not interested
in, or not a likely target for, a venture capital firm. Although angels tend to
be less demanding in their financing terms than venture capital firms, you
should still exercise great caution in ensuring that the "angel" financier
doesn't turn out to be a devil in disguise.
What do angels look like? Frequently they are other small business
owners, or former owners, in the community.
Angel networks can put you in touch with potential investors around
the country.
Some angels may offer loans at very low interest rates simply to help a new
business or the community; others may expect specific rates of return on an
equity investment. Some deals involve a debt instrument that allows the
30
investor an option to convert the debt into an equity investment at either a
specified time or if certain conditions are met. The investor can thereby
protect himself or herself by retaining a debt claim if the business does not
do well or can profit by converting the interest into equity ownership if the
business succeeds.
Most commonly, however, angels will want an equity interest in the business
and some guaranteed "exit" provisions, such as a mandatory buyout, a "put"
option requiring the business to repurchase the stock at the investor's
option, or a public offering of stock . In a five-year period, angels might
expect a return on investment of three to five times their initial investment,
while a venture capital firm might want a return of five to 10 times its
original investment.
Angel Networks
In addition to the own efforts at finding interested investors in the
community, one can take advantage of a growing cottage industry of "angel
network" firms that will match up prospective investors with small
businesses.
Whether or not the investor elects to contact the business, and the terms of
any investment relationship, is left to the parties to determine. For investors,
the most important factor typically is the relevant work experience of the
entrepreneur. They want to know if this person has a track record that may
allow him or her to pull off the difficult task of making a big success out of a
small business. Startup businesses have been funded through these
networks, but many angels prefer that you have at least a minimal operating
31
history before they'll be willing to risk their personal funds in a small
business.
Private Equity
Private equity, in finance, is an asset class consisting of equity securities in
operating companies that are not publicly traded on a stock exchange.
Private equity is also often grouped into a broader category called private
capital, generally used to describe capital supporting any long-term, illiquid
investment strategy.
The strategies private equity firms may use are as follows, leveraged buyout
being the most important.
Leveraged buyout
Leveraged buyout, LBO or Buyout refers to a strategy of making equity
investments as part of a transaction in which a company, business unit or
business assets is acquired from the current shareholders typically with the
use of financial leverage. The companies involved in these transactions are
typically mature and generate operating cash flows.
32
Leveraged buyouts involve a financial sponsor agreeing to an acquisition
without itself committing all the capital required for the acquisition. To do
this, the financial sponsor will raise acquisition debt which ultimately looks to
the cash flows of the acquisition target to make interest and principal
payments. Acquisition debt in an LBO is often non-recourse to the financial
sponsor and has no claim on other investment managed by the financial
sponsor. Therefore, an LBO transaction's financial structure is particularly
attractive to a fund's limited partners, allowing them the benefits of leverage
but greatly limiting the degree of recourse of that leverage. This kind of
financing structure leverage benefits an LBO's financial sponsor in two ways:
(1) the investor itself only needs to provide a fraction of the capital for the
acquisition, and (2) the returns to the investor will be enhanced (as long as
the return on assets exceeds the cost of the debt).
33
Diagram of the basic structure of a generic leveraged buyout transaction
Mezzanine capital
Mezzanine capital refers to subordinated debt or preferred equity securities
that often represent the most junior portion of a company's capital structure
that is senior to the company's common equity. This form of financing is
often used by private equity investors to reduce the amount of equity capital
required to finance a leveraged buyout or major expansion. Mezzanine
capital, which is often used by smaller companies that are unable to access
the high yield market, allows such companies to borrow additional capital
beyond the levels that traditional lenders are willing to provide through bank
loans. In compensation for the increased risk, mezzanine debt holders
require a higher return for their investment than secured or other more
senior lenders. Mezzanine securities are often structured with a current
income coupon.
34
Other strategies
Other strategies that can be considered private equity or a close adjacent
market include:
Real Estate: in the context of private equity this will typically refer to
the riskier end of the investment spectrum including "value added"
and opportunity funds where the investments often more closely
resemble leveraged buyouts than traditional real estate investments.
Certain investors in private equity consider real estate to be a separate
asset class.
35
Superior fund selection by high-talent fund of fund
managers/teams
The use of IPOs had increased in popularity before the market meltdown of
2008, but despite the IPO hype, most small companies are not going to "go
public;" IPOs largely remain a financing option limited to rapidly growing,
successful businesses that generate over a million dollars in net annual
income.
The use of IPOs is limited primarily because: (1) there is a very high
cost and much complexity in complying with SEBI, Companies Act & Stock
Exchanges rules and regulations governing the sale of business securities;
(2) Offering the business's ownership for public sale does little good unless
the company has sufficient investor awareness and appeal to make the IPO
worthwhile; and
36
Securities laws are complicated. The sale of "securities" to the public is
regulated by SEBI in its Disclosure for Investor Protection Guidelines and the
listing agreement of the stock exchanges that have two primary objectives:
(1) to require businesses to disclose material information about the company
to investors, and (2) to prohibit misrepresentation and fraud in the sale of
securities.
37
1. it must have a pre-issue net worth of not less than Rs. 10,000,000 (Rupees
ten million) in three (3) out of the preceding five (5) years, with a minimum
net worth to be met during the two (2) immediately preceding years;
2. it must have a track record of distributing dividends for at least three (3) out
of the immediately preceding five (5) years; and
3. the issue size, i.e., the offer through the offer document, the firm allotment
and the promoters contribution through the offer document, should not
exceed five times the pre-issue net worth as per the last available audited
account, either at the time of filing the draft offer document with the
Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) or at the time of opening of
the issue. (Clause 2.2.1 of the DIP Guidelines)
If the above conditions are not satisfied, then the IPO can be made only
through a book-building process, provided that sixty percent (60%) of the
issue size must be allotted to Qualified Institutional Buyers (QIBs). (Clause
2.2.2 of the DIP Guidelines)
QIBs, inter alia, includes public financial institutions, scheduled commercial
banks, mutual funds, venture capital funds registered with the SEBI (VCFs),
foreign venture capital investors registered with the SEBI (FVCIs), etc.
Net worth means the average of the value of the paid up equity capital
and free reserves (excluding reserves created out of revaluation), minus the
average value of the accumulated losses and deferred expenditure not
written off (including miscellaneous expenses not written off). (Clause
1.2.1(xixa) of the DIP Guidelines)
For the purpose of calculating the track record of distributing dividends,
profits emanating only from the information technology (IT) business or
activities of the company will be considered in the following cases:
1. for companies in the IT sector or proposing to raise money for projects in the
IT sector; and
2. for companies whose name suggests that they are engaged in IT activities or
business, i.e., names containing the words software, hardware, info, infotech,
com, informatics, technology, computer, information, etc.
38
Promoters Contribution
In an IPO, the promoters must contribute at least twenty percent (20%) of
the post issue capital.
The term promoter includes:
1. person(s) in overall control of the company;
2. person(s) who are instrumental in the formulation of a plan or program
pursuant to which the securities are offered to the public; and
3. persons named in the prospectus as promoters.
39
The following will not be eligible to be considered for computation of the
promoters contribution:
1. equity acquired by promoters of a company during the three (3) years
preceding the filing of the offer document with the SEBI, if it:
a) is acquired for consideration other than cash and revaluation of assets or
capitalization of intangible assets is involved in such transactions; or
b) Results from a bonus issue, out of revaluation of reserves, or reserves
without accrual of cash resources (Clause 4.6.1 of the DIP Guidelines);
2. securities that have been issued to the promoters, during the preceding
year, at a lower price than at which they are being offered to the public,
except if the promoters bring in the difference between the offer price and
the issue price for the shares and all the requirements under the Companies
Act, 1956 are fulfilled, i.e., passing of revised resolutions by shareholders or
Board filing of the revised return of allotment with the ROC, etc. (Clause
4.6.2 of the DIP Guidelines); and
3. securities for which a specific written consent has not been obtained from
the shareholders for inclusion of their shares in the minimum promoters
contribution subject to lock-in. (Clause 4.6.7 of the DIP Guidelines) The
ineligible shares mentioned in 1 and 2 above, acquired pursuant to a scheme
of merger or amalgamation approved by a High Court, will be eligible to
compute the promoters contribution. (Clause 4.6.4 of the DIP Guidelines) A
minimum contribution of Rs. 25,000 (Rupees twenty-five thousand) per
application from each individual and Rs. 100,000 (Rupees hundred thousand)
from firms and companies will be eligible for consideration to calculate the
minimum promoters contribution. (Clause 4.6.5 of the DIP Guidelines) The
promoters must bring in the full amount of contribution at least one (1) day
before the issue opening date, to be kept in an escrow account with a
scheduled commercial bank, which will be released to the company along
with the public issue proceeds. If the promoters contribution has been
brought before the public issue and has already been deployed by the
company, the company must give a cash flow statement in the offer
document, disclosing how the promoters contribution was used. If the
minimum promoters contribution exceeds Rs. 10,000,000 (Rupees ten
million), the promoters must bring in Rs. 10,000,000 (Rupees ten million)
before the opening of the issue and the remaining amount on a pro rata
basis before the calls are made on the public. (Clause 4.9.1 of the DIP
Guidelines)
The companys Board must pass a resolution allotting the shares or
convertible instruments to the promoters against the amount received. A
copy of the resolution and a certificate from a chartered accountant
40
indicating receipt of the promoters contribution must be filed with the SEBI.
A list of the names and addresses of friends, relatives and associates who
have contributed to the promoters quota and their subscription amount
must also be attached to the chartered accountants certificate. (Clause
4.9.2 r/w Clause 4.9.3 r/w Clause 4.9.4 of the DIP Guidelines) The promoters
contribution will not be required in case of companies where there is no
identifiable promoter or promoter group.
Lock-in Requirements
The DIP Guidelines specify the minimum lock-in period and lay down the
other requirements relating to the lock-in period. The minimum promoters
contribution, i.e., twenty percent (20%) of the post-issue capital, is required
to be locked-in for a period of three (3) years, starting from the date of
allotment in the proposed issue and ending three (3) years from the date of
commencement of commercial production or the date of allotment in the
public issue, whichever is later. (Clause 4.11.1 r/w Clause 4.11.2 of the DIP
Guidelines) Promoters contribution in excess of the required minimum
percentage must be locked in for a period of one (1) year. The securities
forming part of the promoters contribution and issued last to the promoters
must be locked-in first, except in the case of financial institutions appearing
as promoters. (Clause 4.12.1 r/w Clause 4.13.1 of the DIP Guidelines) The
entire pre-issue capital, other than the promoters contribution, must be
locked in for a period of one (1) year from the date of commencement of
commercial production or the date of allotment in the public issue, whichever
is later. This provision is not applicable to the pre-issue share capital:
1. held by VCFs and FVCIs, which must be locked-in according to the SEBI
(VCF) Regulations, 1999 and the SEBI (FVCI) Regulations, 2000; and
2. held for a period of at least one (1) year at the time of filing of the draft
offer document with the SEBI and being offered to the public through an offer
for sale, i.e., an offer by existing shareholders of a company to the public.
(Clause 4.14.1 r/w Clause 4.14.2 of the DIP Guidelines) Locked-in securities
forming part of the promoters contribution may be pledged only with banks
or financial institutions as collateral for loans, if the pledge of shares is one of
the terms of the loan. (Clause 4.15.1 of the DIP Guidelines) Further, the
transfer of securities, inter se, amongst promoters is also subject to the lock-
in applicable to transferees for the remaining lock-in period. (Clause 4.16.1 of
the DIP Guidelines) The face of the security certificate of locked-in securities
must contain the inscription non-transferable and specify the period for
which it is not transferable. (Clause 4.17.1 of the DIP Guidelines)
41
Prospectus Requirements
The offer document must contain true and sufficient information to enable
the investor to make an informed decision while investing in the offered
securities (Clause 6.1 of the DIP Guidelines) The prospectus must, inter alia,
provide information relating to risk factors, project costs, means of financing,
appraisal, issue schedule, details of the managerial personnel, capital
structure of the company, terms of the issue, financial information of
company and group companies, basis for issue price and details of the
products, machinery and technology.
The SEBI the power to pass directions as mentioned below, for any violation
of the DIP Guidelines, including misstatement in the prospectus. In addition,
under the Companies Act, 1956, every person who authorizes the issue of a
prospectus that contains any untrue statement is liable to be punished with
imprisonment of up to two years or with a fine of up to Rs. 50,000 (US $
1040). (Section 62 of the Companies Act, 1956)
Before issuing any of the above directions, the SEBI may give the person
concerned a reasonable opportunity to show cause against the direction. The
Board may also initiate action against intermediaries who fail to exercise due
diligence or to comply with any obligation under the DIP Guidelines. (Clause
17.2 of the DIP Guidelines)
Conclusion
42
The DIP Guidelines provide detailed regulations that must be complied with
in all public issues by listed and unlisted companies. These guidelines set out
the criteria for IPOs, including, the minimum percentage of promoters
contributions, the lock in periods and the prospectus requirements. The SEBI
has the discretion to pass directions and take other actions against persons
who did not comply with the DIP Guidelines. The DIP Guidelines, therefore,
help in achieving greater transparency in the capital market and in
protecting the interest of the investors.
These bonds assume great importance for multi-nationals and in the current
business scenario of globalization where companies are constantly dealing in
foreign currencies.
43
business development during the last 15 years. While traditional franchise
businesses such as gasoline stations, auto dealers, and soft drink bottlers
continue to grow, the most rapidly expanding industries for franchises are
service businesses involving recreation and leisure activity and business
services.
44
valuable if there is lack of experience in the type of business that is being
started.
Franchise and other fees. The costs of franchising include a variety of fees
and contributions typically required by the franchisor in exchange for the
assistance and experience of the franchisor.
Usually an initial franchise fee or license fee will be required. The fee may be
a lump sum or may be payable in installments. Interest varies and is often
nonrefundable.
Other fees may be assessed for training costs (tuition, room, board, and
transportation) and on-site startup assistance and promotions, advertising (2
percent to 8 percent of gross sales), periodic royalties (4 percent to 6 percent
of gross sales), or fees. These fees are typically tied to a percentage of sales
and payable weekly or monthly. Royalties usually represent the cost of using
trade names and commercial symbols, as well as any trade secrets, patents,
or other intellectual property rights, and advertising contributions (often
45
payable monthly or weekly, based upon a percentage of sales). If
bookkeeping is centralized, separate accounting and processing fees may be
assessed.
46
to the plan. Either way, the company's contribution results in the cash price
of the stock being returned to the company. The company gets a tax
deduction for the ESOP contribution while effectively retaining the cash.
Some ESOPs are also used as leverage for borrowing additional funds for the
business. An ESOP can borrow funds from lenders in order to purchase
additional securities in the employer's business. Alternatively, the employer
can borrow from a lender and re-lend the funds to the ESOP; the ESOP would
then purchase company stock with the cash. In both scenarios, the employer
ends up with the cash price of the stock. ESOPs are sometimes used in this
manner for large stock purchases when funding is necessary to finance
mergers, acquisitions, or buy-outs.
47
due diligence has to be carried out by the investor. The following are the
aspects should be kept in mind while conducting the due diligence of the
company/business.
Legal Due Diligence
Financial Due Diligence
General Due Diligence
48
14. Note on planning and control systems prevalent in the organization
including controls over non-financial systems such as Loss Prevention
(including shrinkage management), Material sourcing planning, quality
control, inventory management, sales etc.
15. Details of statutory records maintained under the Companies Act and
other applicable statutes
16. Transaction documents (agreements) for any prior acquisitions done by
the company
3. Management Accounts
1. Copies of monthly management accounts since April 2004 till date
2. Breakdown of above by profit centre / business unit
3. Reconciliation of management accounts to statutory accounts for the year
ended.
Trading Results
4. Customer and Marketing
1. Write up on the pricing policy followed by the company for various
product lines
2. Write up on selling and distribution network (Number of outlets, since,
products available, sea ports, air ports etc), schemes (systems and
procedures followed, etc), factors affecting prices, margins, periods of
peak and low revenue, etc
3. Details on marketing and pricing strategies of the Company especially all
arrangements for long term supply of products from major vendors and
brands.
49
4. Average price realization (monthly) per unit for major product lines
categories of the Company in the last two years
5. Details of sales by key products and their average realizations in last
three years
6. Write up on the club membership scheme of the Company
7. Details of any market survey /research carried out by the target to
understand the market potential, profile of customers and buying patterns
8. Details of the current customer segment in terms of profile, daily walk-ins,
average sales per walk in
9. Details of the current Marketing and sales plan
10. Details of all sales promotions for last 6 months
11. Details of all marketing tie-ups (airlines, hotels etc.)
5. Suppliers
1. Purchase policies and procedures
2. List of major suppliers (including related party separately identified) in the
period ended showing nature of purchase, quantity purchased and
amount of purchases
3. Pricing policy for purchases from related companies
4. List of all significant contracts with the suppliers and big brands
5. Details of purchase at forward prices and forward purchase, if any
6. List of any claims / disputes with suppliers giving amounts and
background
50
7. Purchases and Consumption Costs
1. Material expenditure with the respective supply contracts
2. Details of average purchases made for major category of goods- both
quantitative and amount wise from major suppliers.
3. Details of volume discounts if any received from suppliers
4. Consumption costs for individual products; details of actual consumption
with standard
5. Details of the agreement /contract between the target and the airport
/seaport authorities/SEZ /Private Airport Operator and all payment details
for the last one year
6. Details of all disputes / claims with the airport /seaport authorities with
the amount and background
8. Expenditure
1. Details of any royalties paid to airport, seaport or cruise port authorities,
as relevant; please provide copy of any agreement for the above
2. Personnel cost including perquisites and retirement benefits
3. Details of repairs, rent, carriage and freight, goods handling expenses,
other expenses, etc
4. Details of the inventory write-offs in the last three years
5. Administrative and other expenses
6. Details of the selling and marketing costs
7. Details of financial costs including interest, lease rent and hire charges
Balance sheet
9. Fixed Assets
1. Summary showing principal categories of assets at last year end and most
recent accounting date showing cost, accumulated depreciation, net book
value and depreciation charge for the period
2. Details of capex by outlet, breaking up into different categories of assets
3. Details of charges or lien created against any fixed assets through
guarantees or loan arrangements
4. Details of insurance policies and coverage of fixed assets
5. Details of capital work in progress, if any
6. Contracts for pending capital commitments at last year-end and most
recent date - contracted for and authorized but not contracted
7. Copies of leasehold agreements (lease and sub-leases) and tenancy
rights, title deeds and other agreements giving amounts and terms
involved (renewal options for the lease period)
8. Fixed assets ledger/register and supporting documents for fixed assets
9. Physical verification reports and its periodicity
51
10. Terms and accounting practice for leased / hired assets; details of
financing arrangements and payments thereof and details of future
commitments, if any
11. List of all properties owned or operated that are connected to the
business with details of their book values, usage, title/ lease and rent
details
10. Inventories
1. Details of inventory / stock as on the latest date
2. Quantitative reconciliation of opening stock, purchases, sales and
wastage, etc.
3. Note on the method used for inventory valuation
4. Inventory valuation workings and its basis. Details of overhead and other
costs included in stock values
5. Age wise details of inventory as on latest date.
6. Provisioning policy of inventory and details of provision against inventory
as on latest date
7. Procedure for identification of slow moving and obsolete / unusable
inventories(expired and near expiry stocks)
8. An overview of the Supply chain cycle for the target
9. Details of all forward contracts and open purchase orders
11. Receivables
1. Party-wise break-up of Sundry Debtors balances if any as on the latest
date together with ageing and policy for provisioning for bad debts.
52
7. Nature and details of transactions with related company and accounts
ledger of these receivables
8. List of all bank guarantees and letter of credit open as on date.
17. Contingencies
53
1. Significant contracts, correspondence with solicitors, tax offices,
shareholders register
2. Details of claims against the Company not acknowledged as debt
3. Details of outstanding bank guarantees and bill discounted
4. Details of capital commitments, non-cancelable operating lease and other
commitments and contingencies
5. Details of litigation disputes against the company, promoters and group
concerns on the company
6. Confirmation from the lawyers about the list of legal issues and current
status of the same
20. Forecast
1. Details of the forecast for FY 2007 (reflecting actuals YTD) and FY 2008
along with detailed assumption on growth assumed in quantity sales,
prices, product-wise sales and margins, customers , sales and marketing
54
costs, customer returns, raw material mix-quantity and prices, other
administrative costs, interest cost, etc
2. Details of new licenses expected to be received in future for new outlets
3. Details of new stores to be opened in new future
4. Details of any licenses which are due for re-tendering in next 3 years
TAXES
Direct Taxes:
21. Summary Information
1. Year-wise summary chart for income tax and wealth tax for past seven
years, detailing the following:
a. Current assessment/ litigation status
b. Key disallowances/issues raised by the authorities
c. Amount of demands raised by the authorities and paid by the
Company
d. Level of settlement of dispute (ie CIT(A)/ ITAT/ HC/ SC)
e. Taxable profit/ carried forward loss for the year and set off in future
years
2. Status of brought forward losses/ allowances, if any
Indirect Taxes:
23. Customs
1. Details of bonding created for storage and sale of goods and report on
compliance with obligations therewith
55
2. List of goods which are imported along with tariff classification and rate of
duty
3. Bills of Entry for all imports assessed provisionally
4. Licenses received for operations in all airports and seaports
5. Licenses granted (for import )
6. Licenses granted (under Duty Exemption Scheme)
7. Status on discharge of legal undertaking/ bonds including details about
the goods stored in bonded warehouses
8. Status of show cause notices (SCN) issued; submissions made,
adjudication thereon and appeals
56
Conclusion
Thus from the above report we can conclude that there are various methods
of raising finance through the equity route to both the new start up business
as well as a totally established business. We also come to know why there is
a need for equity finance when already a cheaper source of finance is
available i.e. debt.
Also we come to know about the various regulatory issues and the procedure
of raising funds through equity. We can also conclude that valuation & proper
due diligence is very essential while investing through equity in any
business.
57