Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Dear Sirs
resume). I have reviewed the Request for Proposal (RFP #09-40) and am writing
services of the County and/or the City of Stockton. I would emphasize that,
though I am writing this letter to support the Friends of the Stockton Public
opinions and have neither sought nor been given remuneration for writing to you.
Economics. Public libraries are a service for all and of benefit to all but there is no
escaping the fact that those who depend most heavily on library services are those
with little or no economic means—these include children and young adults, the
financially disadvantaged, the disabled, the house bound, the unemployed, and
those on the wrong side of the “digital divide,” i.e., those who cannot afford
private access to the internet and the world wide web. This last is a very important
point as studies have shown that public libraries are doing more than any other
service to these parts of the community is the responsibility of the community and
it makes no economic sense to have that service run by a private, “for profit”
Given that a “for profit” company cannot both make profits for its
stands to reason that such profits can only be made by cutting staff, cutting
materials expenditures, cutting library hours, reducing access to the internet and
the web, charging fees for currently free services, and/or increasing fees or fines.
While the contractor’s proposal was not available for review at the time of
this writing, I understand from the sample contract in the RFP that the County is
other payments to the company running a privatized library service. Since the
budgets of all California public libraries have been sharply reduced in real terms in
the past years, the amount of money for library services and materials will be only
91.7% of those reduced budgets. It is not clear whether, under this payment
scenario, the company will have any incentive to increase revenues by charging for
currently free services or to cut costs by decreasing services to make the profit that
2
running a company demands. In any event, payment of 8.3% of the library budget
to a private company for public services under current reduced budgets makes no
to the public, there is no way for the public or decision-makers to evaluate whether
the company is more “efficient” than City employees at providing library services.
What is clear is that a private company is in no way beholden to those who use the
library system, and therefore has no incentive to provide top quality library
services.
they use those dollars that are expected of public employees and public bodies. As
a result, the public are unable to monitor their expenditures, budget priorities, etc.,
or gain the full information required by the California Public Records Act.
Professional library service. A colleague of mine has written: “The public library is the only
place in America where you can walk in off the street and get advice from someone with an
advanced degree without paying for it.” Adequate library service to all members of the
community can only be assured if the library has a staff with an appropriate
accredited masters’ program. Since qualified librarians earn larger salaries (if by no
3
means large salaries) than other library workers, reducing the number of librarians
and knowing the cost, if not the value, of professional library service. A library is
much more than a building with collections of books and other materials and
computer terminals. It only becomes a library service when qualified librarians are
available to assist in the use of those collections for research, study, and leisure
purposes (including helping and advising in the use of digital resources) and to
apply their expertise in the selection of library materials. The logic of the situation
dictates that privatizing libraries will decrease the amount of professional service to
the community.
The ethics of library privatization. Privatization of library services makes no sense from
the economic or professional points of view. I believe the reasons for that lack of
coherence lie in the clash of outlook and purpose between those who render
public service with a commitment to the common good and those who offer to
provide such services in order to make a profit for shareholders. These two
for the first, the bottom line is the betterment of communities, the advancement of
literacy and learning, and using expertise to improve people’s lives; for the second,
the bottom line is profit and loss. These two world views are antithetical and any
attempt to marry them is bound to end badly when the community lacks the
4
services they need and when the privatizing company fails to profit from what
I urge you to abandon this privatization initiative and work with the library
staff and the community to give your citizens the best public library service that
Sincerely yours,
Michael Gorman
Michael Gorman
5
Michael Gorman
University Librarian Emeritus
California State University, Fresno
Professional Education:
Ealing College (now Thames Valley University) School of Librarianship, London, 1964-
1966
Elected FLA (Fellow of the [British] Library Association) , 1979
Offices Held:
Highsmith Award 2001 for Our enduring values presented by American Library Association
1997 Blackwell's Scholarship Award presented by ALCTS, for Future libraries: dreams, madness,
and reality by Walt Crawford and Michael Gorman
Margaret Mann Citation in Cataloguing and Classification, 1979, presented by the American
Library Association, Resources and Technical Services Division
The concise AACR2. 4th ed. Chicago: ALA, 2005 (translated into a number of languages,
including, Italian, Arabic, Spanish, and Vietnamese)
Our own selves: more meditations for librarians. Chicago: ALA, 2005
The enduring library: technology, tradition, and the quest for balance. Chicago: ALA, 2003
Our enduring values: librarianship in the 21st century. Chicago: ALA, 2000 (translated into Italian,
Serbo-Croatian)
"Seymour Lubetzky: man of principles." In The future of cataloguing: insights from the Lubetzky
Symposium. Chicago: ALA, 2000. pp. 12-21
Library trends. Human response to library technology, edited by Janice L. Kirkland and Michael
Gorman, University of Illinois, Graduate School of Library and Information Science. v.47,
no. 4 (Spring 1999)
Technical services today and tomorrow, 2nd edition, Littleton, Colorado: Libraries Unlimited, 1998
Anglo-American cataloguing rules. 2nd ed. Revised. Editor. Chicago: ALA, 1988
Selected Articles:
RDA: imminent debacle. American libraries, v. 38, issue 11, pp. 64-65.
“Metadata dreaming: keynote speech at the Canadian Metadata Forum. Serials librarian
(2006) v.61, issue 2, pp. 47-52.
"The literature of the book: libraries and librarianship." LOGOS, v. 15,
issue 3, (2004), pp. 137-141.
“Authority control in the context of bibliographic control in the electronic environment.”
Cataloging and classification quarterly (2004) v. 38, issues 3&4, pp. 11-22.
"Whither library education?" New library world, v. 105, nos. 1204/5, pp.
376-380.
"Google and God's mind." Los Angeles times, Dec. 17, 2004.
"Revenge of the Blog People." Library journal, February 15th , 2005.
Book review of Matthew Battle. Library: an unquiet history, LOGOS, v. 15,
issue 4 (2004), pp. 221-222.
"Human values in a technological age: a librarian looks 100 years forward and backward,"
LOGOS, v.12, n.2, Quarterly 2001.
"Faculty status? A definite maybe," California libraries, June 2001.
"Technostress and library values," Library journal, April 15, 2001.
"The value and values of libraries." Bodleian Library record, v XII, no.6 (October 2002), pp.
449-463
“Why teach cataloguing and classification?” Cataloging & classification quarterly, v.34, nos. 1/2,
pp. 1-13.
"A love affair that has lasted fifty-five years." LOGOS: the journal of the world book community,
v.13, issue 2 (2002), pp. 88-89.
"Do librarians with tenure get more respect?" Mark Y. Herring and Michael Gorman.
American libraries, June/July 2003. pp. 70-72.
“The people of the book?” California libraries (July 2002), pp. 6-7.
“The library shall endure: a conversation with Michael Gorman.” The book and the computer
(e.journal) www.honco.net/os/gorman.html February 2003.
“The 21st century library.” Cleveland Area Metropolitan Library System, Cleveland, OH,
June 24th, 2003.
“Cataloguing today.” Montana Library Association, Butte MT, April 24th, 2003.
"The value and values of libraries," 68th IFLA General Conference and Council, Glasgow,
Scotland, August 2002.
"Values for future libraries," Mexican Library Association, Monterrey, Mexico, June 2002.
"Our enduring values: librarianship in the 21st century," and "Metadata: old and new story,"
British Columbia Library Association Conference, Vancouver, Canada, May 2002.
Teaching:
Courses taught at: Dominican University, University of California Los Angeles, University of
California Berkeley, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, University of Chicago,
North-Western Polytechnic (London)
Michael Gorman