Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
The Royal Society is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Notes and Records of
the Royal Society of London.
http://www.jstor.org
by
PAULELLIOTT
SUMMARY
INTRODUCTION
Announcing the discovery of the pile in 1800, Alessandro Volta (1745-1827) paid
tributeto threeBritishelectricianswho had stimulatedhis work;these were William
Nicholson (1753-1815), TiberiusCavallo(1749-1809) andAbrahamBennet.1Bennet
remains by far the least known of the three despite the fact that contemporaries
includingDavy andErasmusDarwinrecognizedhis importance.This neglecthas been
due in part to the fact that Bennet was based in the small Derbyshire town of
Wirksworth.Yet in the later18thandearly 19thcenturies,therewas a vibrantscientific
culturein the Englishprovincesexemplifiedby the LunarSociety of Birminghamand
the Manchester and Derby Philosophical Societies. Bennet had connections with
both the Derby Society and the Lunar Society. Provincialism did not mean
parochialismor irrelevanceand a reappraisalof Bennet's position in the history of
science is long overdue.
59
ABRAHAMBENNET,CURATEOF WIRKSWORTH
Figure 1. Portraitof Abraham Bennet by an unknown artist kept in the vestry of St Mary's
Church, Wirksworth, showing him with copies of his works. Reproduced from Ann. Sci. 1,
plate v, pp. 98-99 (1936), with the kind permission of Taylor & Francis.
THENEWEXPERIMENTS
ONELECTRICITY
Figure4. Nicholson'srevolvingdoubler.
further-the wires also moving with it by means of the same insulating axis-the
plates were again insulatedtill the plate B was opposite to C. Then the wire at H
touchedthe pin on C, earthingit and giving the same kind of electricityas thatof A.17
By moving the handle still further,B was again brought opposite to A with the
connectingwiresjoining A andC. Theseboth actedon B, which was earthedas before
hence nearlydoubling'its intensity'.Simultaneously,the electricityof C was absorbed
into A because of the increasedcapacity of A while opposed to B. This was capable
of acquiringa contrarystatebecauseit was earthed'sufficientto balancethe influential
atmospheresof both plates'. By continuingto revolve the plate B the process was
performed'in a very expeditiousand accuratemanner'.18
Nicholson's doublerwas found by Bennet to still retain its spontaneouscharge,
which he thoughtwas due to 'the increasedcapacity'of approximatingparallelplates
that 'might attractand retaintheir chargetho' neitherof them were insulated'.19The
idea that substancesalways containeda residual charge either positive or negative,
regardlessof whetherthey were insulatedor not, proved to be a very fruitfulline of
research. Bennet tried various methods to deprive the doubler of all spontaneous
charge, such as earthing and rapidly rotating it before any experiment. In one
experimenta copperplatewas appliedto plate A while A andB were parallel(so that
B was earthed).After only five revolutionsof B the gold leaf divergednegatively by
a quarterof an inch. But where was this electricitycoming from?Bennet concluded
that different substances had different 'adhesive affinities' to the electrical fluid.
They could be eitherpositive or negative, the chargebeing attractedby the position
of differentplates in parallel.20
After findingthatdifferenttypes of flower on the plates
could change the chargeproduced,he drew the following pregnantconclusion:
It easily occurred,that if the spontaneouselectricityin the beginningof the processwas
sufficientlyweak,themerecontactof metalsor othersubstanceshavinga differentadhesive
affinitywith the electricalfluidmightalso changeit.2'
plates A, C and the crosspiece, positive electricity was registered. Zinc produced
negative charge,so the 'adhesive affinity' was positive for lead ore and negative for
zinc. Gold, silver, copperandbrasswere also foundto be positive, while tin and zinc
were negative. Bennet widened his theoryto includenon-metalsubstanceswith pure
antimony,bismuth,tutenag,anddifferentwoods andtypes of stoneproducingpositive
charge.He proved thatthe shape of the substanceaffectedthe strengthof the charge
registered,with thin plates of zinc being strongerthan a large lump.22
BENNET'S PHILOSOPHICAL
CIRCLE
The original members of the Lunar Society included: Darwin; John Whitehurst;
MatthewBoulton (1728-1809), mechanical engineer;William Small (1730-1775),
physician, chemist and machinist;Josiah Wedgwood (1730-1795), industrialistand
chemist;RichardLovell Edgeworth(1744-1817), authorandphilosopher;andJames
Watt (1736-1819), chemist and engineer. Other members included Thomas Day,
JamesKeir and Joseph Priestley (1733-1804). Most of these subscribedto Bennet's
New Experimentsand supportedhis election to the Royal Society in 1789. Priestley
was an English UnitarianministerfromLeeds who attendeda Dissenting academyin
Daventry,later teaching at the WarringtonAcademy. A meeting with Franklinand
other London electricians inspiredhis electrical work culminatingin the History of
Electricity(1767). He moved to Birminghamin 1780, wherehe continuedto work on
airs and wrote controversialphilosophicaland theological books. The LunarSociety
Figure 5. Electrical pattern made with an electrophorus and formed from powdered resin.
William Stukeley and repeated by Priestley. Evidence for the electric origins of
earthquakeswas said to include the appearanceof fireballs-one of which had
reportedlybeen seen at Derby-wind direction,the fact that vegetables grew more
quickly, the sight of a bright auroraborealis and even medical complaints.Bennet
wrote for more descriptionsof the earthquaketo his Derbyshirefriends including
ReverendPeachof Edensor,JohnChattertonof DerbyandWhiteWatsonof Bakewell.
The Chattertons,John I (1742-1800) and John II (1771-1857), were plumbersand
glaziers living in Derby.JohnII, presumablyBennet's correspondent,was a chemist,
inventor,friendof Darwin and memberof the Derby PhilosophicalSociety.5'White
Watson (1760-1835) was a geologist, fossil dealer and lecturer who supplied
specimens to Darwin, Wedgwood, Strutt,AlexandreBrogniartin Paris and Joseph
Banks (1743-1820), the President of the Royal Society, who had an estate in
Derbyshire.Watsonproducedstratigraphical sectionsof Derbyshireinlaidwith actual
rock and mineral samples. He was a corresponding member of the London
MineralogicalSociety and the authorof A Delineation of the Strata of Derbyshire
(1811).52
In TheEconomyof Vegetation,Darwinhad describedthe earthas a 'largemass of
burninglava' in 'basaltic caves imprisn'ddeep' with 'vaulted roofs of adamantine
rock'.53He arguedthatthe evidence for the existenceof the 'billowy lavas' came from
the heat found in mines andhis own observationson warmspringssuch as St Anne's
Well at Buxton, which he contributedto Pilkington'sViewofDerbyshire.Whitehurst
held that volcanic activity deep in the Earth's crust caused many geological
phenomena.Stratawere thrustup into mountainsand the size and depth of oceans,
riversandvalleys were the resultof pressurefromthese forces.54 Darwinacceptedthis
position and following Whitehurst saw evidence in the geology Derbyshire.It was
of
these 'centralfires' of fluid lava that caused earthquakes,like a strokeon liquid in a
bladderwhich would be felt on the otherside. ThusBennet andDarwinhad different
views of the causes of earthquakes,with Bennet suggestingelectricityto be involved
while Darwin saw heat from fluid lava to be important.Relatedto this, the two had
different theories about the cause of the Earth'smagnetism, Darwin holding that
molten iron in the Earth'score causedthe field, while Bennetthoughtthata magnetic
atmosphereexisted over the Earth,being rarifiedat one pole and condensed at the
other.55An electricaltheory for earthquakeorigin was less ideologically challenging
than a gradualisticdevelopmentalgeological theory based on centralvolcanic fires
which challengedthe Mosaic account.
CONCLUSION
family, the local Wirksworthgentry of Hopton Hall. Bennet also managedto obtain
the supportof other provincial philosophers, notably the Derby philosophers and
membersof the LunarSociety. The Royal Society servedas the official forumfor the
announcementof his discoveries and sanctionedtheir authenticityin the scientific
community.However, Bennet's researchesended abruptlyby the mid-1790s due to
ill healthand possibly because the balancingact between supportfrom radicalssuch
as DarwinandPriestleyand 'establishment'figures such as Banks andRichardKaye
was no longer tenable.Britishprovincialscience sufferedin the 1790s because of its
associationwith radicalism.This had been heightenedby the FrenchRevolutionand
forcedthe only Anglicanmemberof the DerbyPhilosophicalSocietyto resignin 1791.
Bennet was among those who signed a loyalist petition againstJacobinismwith his
patronsthe Gells in 1795.56Two years before, an address of the Derby Society for
Political Information,whose membershipincluded some of his erstwhilesupporters
such as Darwinandthe Strutts,had been condemnedby the Governmentas seditious
and libellous.57
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
NOTES
1 A. Volta, 'On the electricity excited by the mere contact of conducting substances of different
kinds', Phil. Trans.R. Soc. Lond. 90, 403-431 (1800), English translationfrom, W. Ostwald,
Electrochemistry;History and Theory, (Leipzig, 1896), translatedby N.P. Date, pp. 115-141
(Washington, 1980).
2 D.C. Witt, 'Abraham Bennet', Dictionary of National Biography, Missing Persons, p. 58
(Oxford University Press, 1993), written with the assistance of Michael Handley.
3 Derby Mercury (5 July 1826), Derby Reporter (6 July 1826).
4 D.C. Witt, op. cit., note 2.
5 No record of Bennet has been discovered in the registers of Cambridge, Oxford, Dublin,
Aberdeen or Glasgow universities.
6 A. Bennet, memoranda miscellania, mss., Derby Local Studies Library.
7 Derby Mercury (23 May 1799). The bicentenary of Bennet's death is to be commemorated
by a special service on 6 May 1999, at St Mary's Church, Wirksworth.
8 A. Bennet, New Experiments on Electricity Wherein the Causes of Thunder and Lightning
are Explained... Also, A Description of a Doubler of Electricity... (Drewry, Derby, 1789),
prefaced by a list of over 400 subscribers; A. Bennet, 'Description of a new electrometer',
Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. 76, 26-34 (1786); A. Bennet, 'An account of a doubler of
electricity', Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. 77, 288-296 (1787); A. Bennet, 'A new suspension
of the magnetic needle invented for the discovery of minute quantitiesof magnetic attraction',
36 Schofield, op. cit., note 8, pp. 252-253; D. King-Hele (ed.) The Letters of Erasmus Darwin,
lettersto Wedgwood,pp. 169, 170-171 (CambridgeUniversityPress, 1981).
37 Musson and Robinson, Science and Technology In the Industrial Revolution, pp. 126-127
(Manchester,1969); E. Robinson,'R.E. Raspe,Franklin'sclub of thirteenand the Lunar
Society',Ann.Sci. 11(1955);S. Lilley,'Nicholson'sJournal',Ann.Sci. 6, 78-101 (1948-50).
38 E.L. Griggs (ed.), The Collected Letters of Samuel Taylor Coleridge, vol. I, p. 99 (London,
1956-59);forDarwinsee, D. King-Hele,Doctorof Revolution(London,1977);McNeil,op.
cit., note 33; D. King-Hele, Erasmus Darwin and the Romantic Poets (London, 1986); D.
King-Hele (ed.) The Essential Writingsof Erasmus Darwin (London, 1968); D. King-Hele,
Erasmus Darwin: a life of unequalled achievement (de la Mare, 1998).
39 E. Darwin,letterto Franklin,29 May 1787, King-Hele(ed.) op. cit., note 36.
40 E. Darwin,Zoonomia,or theLawsof OrganicLife,vol. I, p. 120 (Johnson,London,1794).
41 E. Darwin,'Remarkson the opinionof HenryEeles Esq.,concerningthe ascentof vapour',
Phil. Trans.R.. Soc. Lond.. 50, 240-254 (1757).
42 Darwin,op. cit., note 27, additionalnoteXII,pp. 46-79; E. Darwin,'Frigorificexperiments
on the mechanicalexpansionof air', Phil. Trans.R. Soc. Lond. 78, (1788); King-Hele,
Doctor of Revolution, op. cit., note 38, p. 184.
43 E. Darwin, The Botanic Garden: a poem in two parts: Part I: the Economy of Vegetation
(Johnson,London,1791);Bennet,'An accountof a doublerof electricity',op. cit., note 8,
p. 289.
44 Bennet, 'An accountof a doubler',op. cit., note 8, p. 289; Darwin,Phytologia:or the
Philosophy ofAgriculture and Gardening, p. 194 (Johnson, London, 1800).
45 Darwin,op. cit., note 44, p. 312.
46 Bennet,memoranda miscellania,136;Darwin,op. cit., note43, noteXIII,p. 25; Darwin,op.
cit., note 27, additionalnote XII, p. 52.
47 In 1775GregorioFontanahadsuggestedthatspider'sthreadbe usedas a substituteforwires,
Mottelay, A Bibliographical History of Electricity and Magnetism, p. 290.
48 A. Bennet,'A new suspensionof themagneticneedle',Phil Trans.R. Soc.Lond.82, 81-82,
92-96 (1792);King-Hele,op. cit., note 36, letterto ThomasBeddoes,pp. 173-174.
49 J. Whitehurst,Enquiry into the Original State and Formation of the Earth, 1st edn (London,
1778); J. Pilkington, A Viewof the Present State ofDerbyshire, 2 vols (Drewry, Derby, 1789).
50 E.W.Gray,'Accountof an earthquakefelt in variouspartsof England,November18, 1795:
with some observationsthereon',Phil. Trans.R. Soc. 86, 361 (1796).
51 S. Glover, History and Gazeteer of the Townof Derby, vol. II, p. 601 (Derby, 1833); Derby
Mercury(2 October1832);DerbyPhilosophicalSocietycashledger(1813-1845)mss. 7625,
DerbyLocal StudiesLibrary;DerbyLocal StudiesLibrary,queriesanswered153 (1966).
52 T. D. Ford,'WhiteWatson(1760-1835) andhis geologicalsections',Proc. Geol.Assoc. 71
(1960).
53 Darwin,op. cit., note 43, cantoI, 1. 137-142, additionalnote VI.
54 J. Whitehurst, Enquiry (1778).
55 Gray,op. cit., note 50, pp. 353-381; Darwin,op. cit., note 27, additionalnote XII, pp.
68-72; Bennet,'A new suspensionof themagneticneedle...', op. cit.,note 8, p. 92. Forlater
researchesin Palaeomagnetism, notablyevidenceforthereversalof theearth'smagneticfield,
see, P. Bowler, The Fontana History of the Environmental Sciences, pp. 413-416 (London,
1992).
56 DerbyMercury(3 December1795);A letterfromRichardFrenchto WilliamStruttapparently
datedAugust 1792,urgedStruttto persuadeDarwinthata local clergyman'Mr.B' should
not be recommendedfor prefermentto Sir FrancisBurdettas he was 'not even a Whig in
politics', 'superstitiouslyreligious'andhad signedan addressin supportof the warwhilst
urginghis scholarsto do likewise. Given that Bennet signed a loyalist address,sought
prefermentandwas a schoolmaster,this may havebeen him,but this cannotbe confirmed
as the letteris now missingfromthe Struttcorrespondence in Derby.
57 Address to the Friends of Free Enquiry and the General Good, Derby Society for Political
broadsheet(Derby,December1791);D. King-Hele,'The 1997WilkinsLecture:
Information,
Erasmus Darwin, the Lunaticks and evolution', Notes Rec. R. Soc. Lond. 52, 153-180
(1998).