Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
A
mbulatory blood pressure monitoring (ABPM) has
Given the increasing use of ambulatory blood pressure become a subject of considerable scientific interest
monitoring (ABPM) in both clinical practice and with over 10 000 articles listed on PubMed by 2012.
hypertension research, a group of scientists, participating In 2001, the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services in
in the European Society of Hypertension Working Group the United States approved ABPM for reimbursement for
on blood pressure monitoring and cardiovascular the identification of individuals with white-coat hyperten-
variability, in year 2013 published a comprehensive sion, and in 2011 the National Institute for Health and
position paper dealing with all aspects of the technique, Clinical Excellence in the United Kingdom recommended
based on the available scientific evidence for ABPM. The that ABPM should be offered as a cost-effective technique to
present work represents an updated schematic summary of all people suspected of having hypertension. In recognition
the most important aspects related to the use of ABPM in of the importance of ABPM in clinical practice and research
daily practice, and is aimed at providing recommendations on hypertension, the Working Group on Blood Pressure
for proper use of this technique in a clinical setting by Monitoring and Cardiovascular Variability of the European
both specialists and practicing physicians. The present Society of Hypertension (ESH) held a consensus conference
article details the requirements and the methodological on ABPM in Milan in 2011. Arising from this meeting, a
issues to be addressed for using ABPM in clinical practice, position paper was published in 2013 incorporating the
The clinical indications for ABPM suggested by the opinions of 34 international experts in hypertension and
available studies, among which white-coat phenomena, blood pressure (BP) measurement [1]. This position paper,
masked hypertension, and nocturnal hypertension, are running to 38 pages, is a comprehensive state-of-the-art
outlined in detail, and the place of home measurement of review on ABPM and draws on the evidence from over 600
blood pressure in relation to ABPM is discussed. The role papers on the subject published until 2013.
of ABPM in pharmacological, epidemiological, and clinical The ESH 2013 ABPM position paper will serve as a
research is also briefly mentioned. Finally, the reference source for ABPM, but it was recognized that a
implementation of ABPM in practice is considered in shorter guideline is needed for clinical practice, and in this
relation to the situation of different countries with regard concise guidelines paper the main conclusions that are
to the reimbursement and the availability of ABPM in directly relevant to clinical practice are presented and
primary care practices, hospital clinics, and pharmacies. updated.
Keywords: ambulatory blood pressure monitoring, arterial
hypertension, clinic blood pressure measurement, clinical
indications, guidelines, home blood pressure measurement,
practice recommendations Journal of Hypertension 2014, 32:13591366
Author affiliations are listed on the Journal website, http://links.lww.com/HJH/A366
Abbreviations: AASI, ambulatory arterial stiffness index; Correspondence to Gianfranco Parati, MD, Department of Cardiovascular, Neural and
ABP, ambulatory blood pressure; ABPM, ambulatory blood Metabolic Sciences, IRCCS S. Luca Hospital, Istituto Auxologico Italiano. Piazza Brescia
pressure monitoring; BP, blood pressure; BPM, blood 20, Milan 20149, Italy. Tel: +3902619112949; fax: +3902619112956; e-mail: gian
franco.parati@unimib.it
pressure monitoring; ESC, European Society of Cardiology;
Gianfranco Parati, George Stergiou and Eoin OBrien contributed equally to the
ESH, European Society of Hypertension; HBPM, home writing of this article.
blood pressure monitoring; NICE, National Institute for Received 21 March 2014 Revised 21 March 2014 Accepted 21 March 2014
Health and Clinical Excellence; OBPM, office blood J Hypertens 32:13591366 2014 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams &
pressure measurement Wilkins.
DOI:10.1097/HJH.0000000000000221
Copyright Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Ambulatory blood pressure monitoring
Box 4 DEFINITION OF WHITE-COAT AND MASKED HYPERTENSION Role of home blood pressure monitoring
PHENOMENA ABPM and HBPM provide complementary information, and
White-coat (or isolated office) hypertension their use should be rationally combined in clinical practice.
Untreated individuals with elevated office BP 140/90 mmHg In most hypertensive patients, out-of-office assessment of
and 24-h ABP < 130/80 mmHg BP with HBPM is recommended according to the procedure
and Awake ABP < 135/85 mmHg
and Sleep ABP < 120/70 mmHg indicated in the 2008 ESH Home BPM guidelines, by having
or Home BP < 135/85 mmHg duplicate morning and evening self-measurements for
Masked hypertension
Untreated individuals with office BP < 140/90 mmHg
7 days and calculating the average BP for 6 days after
and 24-h ABP > 130/80 mmHg discarding measurements on the first day [4]. HBPM is
and/or Awake ABP > 135/85 mmHg particularly suited to long-term follow-up of treated
and/or Sleep ABP >120/70 mmHg
or Home BP >135/85 mmHg patients because it is cheap and may improve treatment
Masked uncontrolled hypertension adherence. On the contrary, ABPM is particularly appro-
Treated individuals with office BP <140/90 mmHg priate for the initial evaluation of elevated BP, because it
and 24-h ABP 130/80 mmHg
and/or Awake ABP 135/85 mmHg provides standardized and unbiased information within
and/or Sleep ABP 120/70 mmHg 24 h and without need of training, skills, and commitment
or Home BP 135/85 mmHg
Diagnoses require confirmation by repeating ambulatory or home BP monitoring
from the patient, as required for HBPM. It may also be more
within 36 months, depending on the individuals total cardiovascular risk useful, if possible in association with HBPM, in those cases
Ambulatory BP values obtained in the office during the first or last hour of a when BP control by treatment appears unstable (labile BP
24-h recording may also partly reflect the white-coat effect (white-coat
window) values and nocturnal hypertension), in order to ensure
Patients with office BP<140/90 mmHg, 24-h BP<130/80 mmHg, awake BP adequate 24-h BP control and promote better adherence
<135/85 mmHg but sleep BP 120/70 mmHg should be defined as having to prescribed treatment.
Isolated Nocturnal Hypertension, to be considered as a form of masked
hypertension. A comparison of the different BP measurement methods
is shown in Table 1.
Blood pressure variability
Masked hypertension might be attributed to isolated BP is a highly dynamic parameter characterized by con-
nocturnal hypertension, which may be present in 7% of tinuous fluctuations that include both short-term and long-
hypertensive individuals and can at present only be diag- term variability. While short-term BP variability within 24 h
nosed with ABPM (Box 4). can be readily assessed with ABPM, long-term variability
The Position Paper recommends that ABPM should be requires repeated BP measurements over days, weeks, or
performed whenever possible in individuals with sus- months with repeated measurements of office, HBPM, or
pected hypertension in whom it is necessary to confirm ABPM. On the basis of the available evidence, short-term
the diagnosis of sustained hypertension, (i.e. to exclude BP variability within 24 h might be considered for risk
white-coat hypertension), to assess the severity of hyper- stratification in population and cohort studies. However,
tension throughout the 24-h period, to detect nocturnal at present it does not represent a parameter for routine use
hypertension, to detect patterns of BP behavior, such as in clinical practice.
nondipping and alterations in BP variability (Figs 14 and
Box 5). ABPM should be performed whenever possible also HOW TO APPLY AND INTERPRET
in already treated hypertensive individuals, to assess effec- AMBULATORY BLOOD PRESSURE
tive 24-h BP control with treatment. MONITORING IN DAILY PRACTICE ?
When to repeat ambulatory blood pressure Devices and software
monitoring in clinical practice Most devices available for ABPM have been validated
The recommendation as to when to repeat ABPM is influ- independently according to the internationally accepted
enced by so many factors that the issue largely becomes one validation protocols, which is essential for clinical use.
of clinical judgment and availability of ABPM. For example, Specific validation may be required in special patient popu-
severe or apparently resistant hypertension, the presence of lations.
target organ damage, the existence of comorbidities, such With regard to the software presentation and analysis of
as diabetes, and a positive family history of premature ABPM data, a standardized single-page report should be
cardiovascular disease should prompt frequent ABPM in provided by all types of monitors, which should present a
the quest for 24-h BP control, whereas, mild hypertension BP plot with different windows of the 24-h period identified
and the absence of target organ involvement and other and normal bands clearly demarcated showing the individ-
features of cardiovascular disease, might call for less fre- uals awake and asleep time intervals, summary statistics for
quent ABPM and the use of HBPM. BP and heart rate separately for the 24 h, the daytime, the
Specific situations, which may require repeating night-time, and the white-coat window periods, the raw BP
ABPM at relatively short intervals (36 months or even data, and, optionally,a software-generated interpretative
less) include: the need to confirm the diagnosis of report indicating normal or abnormal BP patterns. The
white-coat or masked hypertension; confirmation of provision of a trend report is useful for follow-up, and
nocturnal hypertension; follow-up of high-risk patients, the system should store the ABPM data for audit or research,
especially in the period when optimal treatment is being while also facilitating the establishment of registries. ABPM
sought (Box 6). Software requirements are summarized in Box 7.
240
200
160
BP (mmhg)
120
80
40
0
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Hours
FIGURE 1 Normal daytime and night-time BP with preserved dipping, and with BP increase only in the white-coat windows at the beginning and the end of the ABP
recording. Clinic BP at 160/100 mmHg. Diagnosis: white-coat hypertension.
240
200
160
BP (mmhg)
120
80
40
0
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Hours
FIGURE 2 Increased daytime BP particularly during working hours (bus driver) and increased night-time BP with preserved dipping. Clinic BP at 138/88 mmHg. Diagnosis:
masked hypertension.
240
200
160
BP (mmhg)
120
80
40
0
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Hours
FIGURE 3 BP constantly elevated during daytime (awake) time, with low night-time (asleep) BP. Clinic BP at 146/86 mmHg. Diagnosis: daytime hypertension with preserved
nocturnal BP dipping.
240
200
160
BP (mmhg)
120
80
40
0
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Hours
FIGURE 4 Elevated 24-h ambulatory BP with reverse BP dipping at night (BP rising pattern) in a patient with moderate form of obstructive sleep apnea. Clinic BP at 152/88
mmHg. Diagnosis: non-dipping hypertension.
Copyright Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Ambulatory blood pressure monitoring
Ambulatory blood pressure monitoring such as patients with diabetes mellitus or obstructive sleep
thresholds for clinical practice apnea. ABPM is often required in these individuals and
There is a general agreement on ABPM threshold values technical difficulties, such as miscuffing, should not
for diagnosing hypertension as presented in (Box 8). exclude them from such a valuable technology. In such
These levels may be regarded as conservative, and it is cases, conically shaped cuffs might be used, when avail-
acknowledged that further studies are needed to define able. In patients with very obese arms in whom ABPM
thresholds more precisely, particularly in high-risk cannot be performed, ABPM carried out with the cuff
patients. Reference percentiles for ABPM values in chil- placed on the forearm may be the only means of obtaining
dren and adolescents are still in need of further investi- a 24-h recording, with an instruction that the wrist must be
gation, some indications being shown in Table 2, with the kept at heart level during measurement, although this
95th percentile representing the threshold for hyper- possibility requires further investigation.
tension diagnosis [1].
Patients with atrial fibrillation
Obtaining a satisfactory ambulatory blood BP measurement in patients with atrial fibrillation is
pressure monitoring less precise as this type of arrhythmia is accompanied
The requirements for obtaining a satisfactory ABPM are by increased beat-to-beat BP variability due to variations
summarized in Box 9. in ventricular filling time, stroke volume, and contrac-
There are no firm data on which to base recommen- tility. Unfortunately, published evidence regarding the
dations for the number of measurements necessary for a role of ABPM in patients with arrhythmias and, specifi-
satisfactory ABPM recording. Having considered what evi- cally in patients with atrial fibrillation, is scarce. In
dence is available and the practical issues related to repeat- spite of these limitations, and although larger trials in
ing ABPM in practice, it was considered acceptable to have patients on atrial fibrillation are needed, there is no
a minimum of 20 valid daytime (awake) measurements and reason at present to exclude such patients from ABPM
seven measurements at night (asleep), based on the procedures.
requirement to have at least 70% of measurements being
obtained at least every 30 min, or more frequently, through- Children and adolescents
out the entire 24-h period (Box 10). Both European and American recommendations now rec-
ognize ABPM as being important for the diagnosis and
management of hypertension in children and adolescents,
Conditions in which ambulatory blood pressure
especially for the detection of white-coat and masked
monitoring may be difficult to perform hypertension and for the evaluation of nocturnal hyperten-
sion, which is often reported in children and adolescents
Obese patients with type-1 diabetes. However, in children, at variance from
Obesity is a well established major risk factor for hyperten- adults, it is very difficult, if not impossible, to validate
sion with higher prevalence in specific population groups, diagnostic reference values based on morbidity and
mortality. Therefore, reference values for normal and high
office and ambulatory BP have been developed from the
Box 5 PATTERNS OF DISRUPTED DIURNAL BP VARIATION IDENTIFIED distribution of BP readings. Although only scanty data are
BY ABPM available on this issue, and further research is needed,
Dipping: Nocturnal systolic and diastolic BP fall >10% of daytime values or an example of such thresholds is provided in (Table 2).
Night/day systolic and diastolic BP ratio < 0.9 and > 0.8 Cuff dimensions are most important, and the appropriate
Normal diurnal systolic and diastolic BP pattern
Reduced Dipping: Nocturnal systolic and/or diastolic BP fall from 1 to 10% of
cuff size should be used according to arm length
daytime values or (48, 612, 918, and 1024 cm, to cover 80100%
Night/day systolic and/or diastolic BP ratio <1 and >0.9 of the individuals arm circumference) and width (40% of
Reduced diurnal systolic and/or diastolic BP pattern
Associated with increased cardiovascular risk the arm circumference).
Non-dipping and rising: No reduction or increase in nocturnal systolic and/or
diastolic BP or
Night/day systolic and/or diastolic BP ratio 1
Associated with increased cardiovascular risk
Extreme dipping: Marked nocturnal systolic and/or diastolic BP fall >20% of Box 6 WHEN TO REPEAT ABPM IN CLINICAL PRACTICE
daytime systolic and/or diastolic values or
Night/day systolic and/or diastolic BP ratio <0.8 Recommendations on when to repeat ABPM are based on many factors,
Debatable association with cardiovascular risk including clinical judgment and ABPM availability.
Nocturnal hypertension: Increased absolute level of night time systolic and/or Indications for ABPM repetition to evaluate 24-h BP control:
diastolic BP ( 120/70 mmHg) Severe or apparently resistant hypertension
Associated with increased cardiovascular risk - may indicate obstructive sleep Presence of target organ damage
apnoea Existence of comorbidities (e.g. diabetes)
Morning surge: Excessive systolic and/or diastolic BP elevation rising in Positive family history of premature cardiovascular disease
the morning Indications for ABPM repetition at short time intervals (36 months or less):
Definitions, thresholds and prognostic impact debatable To confirm the diagnosis of white-coat or masked hypertension
The classic definition of non-dipping (nocturnal systolic and/or diastolic BP fall Confirmation of nocturnal hypertension
<10% or Night /day ratio > 0.9) may be criticized because it includes reduced Follow-up of high risk patients when optimal treatment is sought
dipping as a form of non-dipping. Although imprecise, this definition may be In cases of mild hypertension and low cardiovascular risk, ABPM may be
clinically justified, however, as both conditions are associated with increased repeated at 1 or 2-year intervals, while regular implementation of HBPM
cardiovascular risk may better suit the needs of long-term follow-up.
TABLE 1. Characteristic features of, and information provided by different blood pressure measurement techniques
Characteristic features
of measurement OBPM HBPM ABPM
General features
Cost Inexpensive More expensive than OBPM More expensive than OBPM or
but cheaper than ABPM HBPM but cost-effective
Medical requirements Conventional technique in Should be used under medical Must be used and interpreted
clinical environment (medical supervision (often this is not under medical supervision
supervision) the case)
Need for training Doctors and nurses should be Minimal medical training Training required but software
trained and tested for com- required but patients should can facilitate process
petence receive instructions
Duration of procedure Brief depending on number of Home BP should be measured Usually 24-h BP measurements
measurements recorded as average of 2 morning at 1530-min intervals
and evening readings for 7 during day and night with
days, first day discarded minimal requirements of
70% successful readings and
20 daytime and 7 night-time
measurements
Validated accuracy Automated devices replacing Many devices on the market Most ABPM devices on the
mercury sphygmoman- have not been independently market have been success-
ometers validated for accuracy fully independently validated
for accuracy
For accuracy of all devices see: www.dableducational.org, www.bhsoc.org; www.pressionearteriosa.net, www.ESHonline.org
Identification of BP patterns
Systo-diastolic hypertension Commonest diagnosis Better assessment of severity Allows assessment of severity
over 24 h
Isolated systolic hypertension SBP 140 and DBP SBP 135 and DBP 24-h ABPM SBP 130 and
<90 mmHg <85 mmHg DBP <80 mmHg
Isolated diastolic hypertension SBP <140 and DBP SBP <135 and DBP 24-h ABPM SBP < 130 and
90 mmHg 85 mmHg DBP > 80 mmHg
Prediction of outcome
Target organ damage, cardiovascular Has been the measure of Superior to OBPM Superior to OBPM and stronger
morbidity and mortality outcome in the past evidence than with HBPM
Nocturnal hypertension may be
sensitive predictor
Provision of indices of 24-h BP and HR behavior
Not applicable Not applicable Can be computed from ABPM
recordings
Measures of BP and HR variability
Visit-to-visit BP and HR variabil- Day-to-day BP and HR variabil- 24-h BP and HR variability
ity ity
Guide to drug prescribing
Efficacy of treatment over time Poor guide because of Moderate guide to daytime Allows assessment of efficacy
white-coat response and efficacy that can be readily over 24-h period
limited BP readings repeated
Nocturnal BP control Not applicable Preliminary data with ad hoc Allows assessment of nocturnal
HBM tools lowering of BP
Reduction of morning surge Not applicable Not applicable, but morning BP Allows assessment of treatment
can be assessed effect on morning BP surge
To improve compliance to treatment May have a minor influence Major documented advantage Provision of ABPM record to
of HBPM patient may be helpful
To evaluate drug resistant hypertension Poor guide because of white- Provides better assessment Removes white-coat effect
coat response and limited BP than OBPM but limited evi- and shows if BP elevation is
readings dence persistent
Identification of hypotensive patterns
Overall Limited because of infrequency Better than OBPM Allows detection of hypoten-
of measurement sive episodes throughout the
24-h period
Postural hypotension Difficult to diagnose Fall in standing HBPM Time, duration and relationship
to hypotension can be docu-
mented
Postprandial hypotension Difficult to diagnose Fall in HBPM after meals Fall in ABPM after meals
Drug-induced hypotension Difficult to diagnose Can be detected if HBPM after Time, duration and relationship
drug ingestion to drug intake can be docu-
mented
Idiopathic hypotension Difficult to diagnose Can be detected if HBPM Best diagnosed with ABPM
related to hypotension
Autonomic failure Difficult to diagnose Not detectable Daytime hypotension and noc-
turnal hypertension,
increased BP variability
ABPM, ambulatory blood pressure monitoring; BP, blood pressure; HBPM, home or self-blood pressure monitoring; IDH, isolated diastolic hypertension; ISH, isolated systolic
hypertension; OBPM, office blood pressure measurement. Many of the above features of ABPM become of even greater relevance in high-risk patients, such as diabetic patients and in
the elderly, who may have complex patterns of 24-h BP and nocturnal hypertension. Modified from [1], by permission.
Copyright Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Ambulatory blood pressure monitoring
TABLE 2. Tables of percentiles for ABP (systolic/diastolic) values in children and adolescents
Boys Girls
Day Night Day Night
Height (cm) 90th 95th 90th 95th 90th 95th 90th 95th
120 122/80 125/82 103/61 106/63 118/80 120/82 103/63 106/65
125 122/80 125/82 105/61 108/63 119/80 121/82 104/63 107/66
130 122/80 126/82 106/62 110/64 120/80 122/82 106/63 108/66
135 123/80 126/82 108/63 111/65 120/80 123/82 107/63 109/66
140 123/80 126/82 109/63 113/65 121/80 124/82 108/63 110/66
145 124/79 127/81 111/64 114/66 123/80 125/82 109/63 112/66
150 125/79 128/81 112/64 116/66 124/80 126/80 110/63 113/66
155 127/79 130/81 113/64 117/66 125/80 128/82 111/63 114/66
160 129/79 133/81 114/64 118/66 126/80 129/82 111/63 114/66
165 132/80 135/82 116/64 119/66 127/80 130/82 112/63 114/66
170 134/80 138/82 117/64 121/66 128/80 131/82 112/67 115/71
175 136/81 140/83 119/64 122/66 129/81 131/82 113/63 115/66
180 138/81 142/83 120/64 124/66
185 140/81 144/84 122/66 125/66
Copyright Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.