Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Hispaniola Island
An Integrated View of Haiti and the Dominican Republic
Port-au-Prince
! Santo Domingo
!
Purpose
Ethnic composition Ethnic composition
(The World Factbook, 2012) (The World Factbook, 2012)
GDP - composition by sector (2013 indexmundi) GDP - composition by sector (2013 indexmundi)
This document represents the results of a Rapid and Preliminary National Assessment (RPNA) of the island of Hispaniola,
which includes the countries of Haiti and the Dominican Republic. This RPNA aims to provide a characterization of the
human development and economic conditions and disparities between the two countries, as well as an overview of Services
56%
Agriculture
24.1%
Industry
19.9%
Services
64.9%
Agriculture
6%
Industry
29.1%
the existing natural and infrastructure-based assets of the region. The goal of this rapid assessment is to identify critical
factors that have contributed to the current socio-economic status and ongoing conflicts between the two nations.
Through further comparative geospatial evaluation of Haiti and the Dominican Republic, their relative strengths and
weaknesses can be assessed at a subregional scale, which will inform more targeted strategies for improving conditions
across the island. While the results presented here reflect a preliminary review based on an accelerated research and
data collection process, this RPNA illustrates GeoAdaptives well-established capabilities working in data-poor regions,
and integrating products from government agencies, NGOs, open data repositories, and the private sector. Each section
of the document provides a research-based perspective on one of five key topic areas, as well as highlighting the need for
more comprehensive analysis of specific indicators and geographic patterns to pinpoint gaps in development and provide
a basis for future policy and investment decisions. The main topics are organized as follows: Natural Natural Demographic & Economy & Infrastructure &
Resources Disasters Socioeconomics Productivity Social Services
Natural Resources: specifically forest cover, protected areas, and the hydrology of the island
Natural Disasters: highlighting past impacts from a range of hazards, with a focus on Hurricane Matthew
Demographics and Migration: focused on trends in population distribution and socioeconomic indicators
Economy and Productivity: identifying the major economic sectors and distribution of productive areas
Infrastructure and Social Services: accessibility across the island, especially to health and education facilities
Summary
Perceived
Challenges
Haiti and Dominican Republic: How this summary is organized
This document presents an overview of the two countries
4 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | Mar 2017 Mar 2017 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | 5
Natural Resources
Both Haiti and the Dominican Republic have a wide range of of the islands forests and soil resources, particularly on the Haiti
natural resources, thanks to the geological setting of the island side. Wood is a valuable commodity, as charcoal is the main fuel
and the humid tropical climate of the Caribbean Sea. Many source; however, deforestation has increased the rate of topsoil
endemic flora and fauna exist in the remaining forests and coastal loss, which has secondary effects on the agricultural sector. In
and marine ecosystems support fisheries and aquatic mammals, addition, the ongoing erosion increases areas of landslides
which provide both a tourist attraction and important economic susceptibility and increases sedimentation of rivers and the
resource to the people of each country. More protected areas islands two largest lakes, which has led to flooding issues along
have been established, particularly conserving forested areas major roads and in lakeshore settlements.
in the Dominican Republic, with more protection allocated
towards coastal marine areas in Haiti. Years of poverty and Water resources in the two countries are not equally distributed,
overexploitation of resources have led to dramatic degradation and there are some transboundary issues, particularly where
watersheds span the national border. The distribution of rainfall In the drier valley where the saline Lago Enriquillo and Lac Azui
varies throughout the year and across the island. Both countries are located, water flows into the lakes, but has no outlet. Water
generally receive more rainfall in the early summer and during levels have been rising due to changes in rainfall, as well as
the hurricane season, particularly October. Haiti receives more sedimentation, forcing some residents to relocate. As climate
rainfall on average during these periods, although the Dominican change threatens to increase extreme events and change the
Republic has slightly higher monthly rainfall from November to annual temperature and rainfall patterns, both countries must
January. There are 5 major river basins across the island, with continue to consider how to maintain their vulnerable land and
most on the Dominican side, and the Artibonite River watershed water resources.
spanning the border, with a majority of its surface area in Haiti.
Figure 2. Hispaniola average annual rainfall 1960 - 2012 Source: WorldClim, 2015
6 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | Mar 2017 Mar 2017 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | 7
Natural Disasters
Both Haiti and the Dominican Republic are highly vulnerable the most susceptible island to hurricanes in the Caribbean.
to natural hazards. Although the Dominican Republics relative In 2008, for example, four hurricanes affected nine of Haitis 568 7
2 !
natural hazard exposure is higher, Haiti is ranked as the 10th most ten departments within one month, impacting an estimated 8 !
11.000
Jean-Rabel
Cap-Haitien
2.840 3.856
!
Puerto Plata
vulnerable to natural hazards having a higher vulnerability due to percent of its population (about 800,000 people) and causing 20.000
! 19.165
its high susceptibility, and lack of coping and adaptive capacities. major damages in all sectors. Santiago De Los Caballeros 274 6
!
This means that Haiti can significantly reduce its natural hazard - Hait
i
1
!
Moca 1.370
173
Cuba 1.350 128
vulnerability by improving its public infrastructure, economic Disaster data from the Dominican Republic indicatesEarthquake
73 natural 12.300 640
2 888
Wildre
capacity, governance, and public services. The key natural hazard events for the period 1900 to 2014, 2.3% which2.3% affected 1
1
hazards for both countries are: 4.75 million people with total economic damages estimated at 0
Flood 22
Hurricanes and associated major floods and landslides US$2.93 billion (EM-DAT). Tropical storms and floods have had 46.5%
1 2 0
Tropical storms and associated flash floods the greatest impact in the country, causing respectively US$2.86 Jrmie
9 1 166
0 !
Higuey
Earthquakes billion and US$97.7 million dollars in damage. The number of 141
! 197 Port-au-Prince
184 Santo Domingo
35 1
^ ^27 0 La Romana
Droughts people killed is estimated at 5,792, of whom 77.5% were killed 1.698 22.000 !
Petit-Gave
0 28
!
For both countries tropical storms and floods are the more by storms, 15% by floods and the remaining 6.2% by epidemics. 39.730
Les Cayes
58.467
Jacmel
0
20
301
! ne
frequent natural hazards (accounting for about 95%). In terms of Average Annual Losses for both countries, ! 1
ai t
i
137
0
as
eli
-H ic
B ! Major Cities
earthquakes and cyclone wind Storm have the highest value: for 57 2 blic 352 House damaged
lag
2.835
ep
n R 24
u
ch
ipe People affected ^ Capital Cities
In Haiti, statistics show that a major disaster (such as a tropical Haiti earthquakes have the most 48.8%
relevant potential value of 71.009 i nic
a
bli
cA
r
Road collapsed
Boundaries
om pu Primary Roads
storm, flood, or drought) occurs every 5-7 years and an damage and for Dominican Republican, cyclonic wind causes D Re Bridge collapsed Miles
12 an Secondary Roads 0 12.5 25 50
1
nic
mi
internationally recognized disaster hits it every 2 years. Overall, the most infrastructure damage. Combining the AAL with the
Heavy rains Rivers
D o
190
Landslides Districts affected
between 1900 and 2014, around 250,000 people died in Haiti Shelters
Cyclone
Hazard frequencies
Heavy Rains
Haiti is also the country with the highest relative vulnerability to Wildre Earthquake
2.3% Other Drought Figure 5. Hurricane and Flood impacts on Hispaniola in 2016 (Source ECHO 2016)
2.3% Flood
tropical cyclones among Small Island Developing States, followed 1.5% 46.5%
4.5%
48.8%
Gustave 2008
Earthquake 76 222,576 Source: EM-DAT (1900-2016) 85 deaths
100
119.53
100.83
mi
nic
an
pu
bli
c ^ Capital Cities tropical storm: >= 39mph
strong tropical storm: >= 58mph
Hurrican mpacts
Do
Earthquake 2,015 3,700,000 Re Pressure (millibars)
40.65 40.19 32.76 n Miles
hurricane: >= 74mph
10.51 ca 0.00 - 950.00 0 12.5 25 50
30 social expenditures, earthquakes in Haiti also result in a very levels. The flood peaks, which can last from hours to a few days,
Drought 5,000 1,000
25 high percentage (around 33%), followed by cyclonic wind in breach river banks and impact settlements in and adjacent to the
Earthquake 0 8,020,000 20 Dominican Republic (12%). flood plains. This is a nationwide problem in Haiti and a problem
Epidemic 0 0
15
11.06 11.93 in some specific areas in the Dominican Republic.
8.53 8.91
10 Related to floods, the phenomenon of flash flooding in Transboundary flooding is a very localized subset of the larger
Flood 97,725 51,959 5 2.86
0.94
2.36
Hispaniola is well understood. High rainfall events in the upper problem of flooding in Hispaniola. In select cases, rainfall in one
0.03 0.01
8 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | Mar 2017 Mar 2017 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | 9
Demographics & Migration
The two countries have similar population growth trends. Many Haitians migrate to the Dominican Republic primarily to
However, due to the deficiencies in health and social services, escape the poverty in Haiti. Almost 75% of the Haitians living
Haitians face a lower life expectancy rate and higher infant in the Dominican Republic have been residing in the country
mortality rate than Dominicans, and more than 25% of Haitis for less than 10 years (ENI, 2012). However, immigrants face
population lives under extreme poverty. potential deportation under the Dominican Republics new law.
Figure 7. Population growth of Haiti and Dominican Republic (1980 - 2014) Figure 8. Life expectancy rate and infant mortality rate of Haiti and
Source: World Bank, 2014 Dominican Republic (1980 - 2014) Source: World Bank, 2014
Figure 11. Migration and distribution of Haitians living in the Dominican Republic
Source: UNDP, 2013; UNDP, 2014
Haiti Dominican Republic Figure 14. Agricultural land cover in Haiti and Dominican Republic
Source: ESACCI, 2010
Exports $876.8 million $9.9 billion
apparel,
manufactured gold, tobacco, jewellery,
Export goods goods, cocoa, cocoa, sugar, apparel,
mango, coffee, manufactured goods
orange
Main export
United States United States
destination
Imports $2.67 billion $16.9 billion
Figure 12. GDP per capita of Haiti and Dominican Republic
Source: OEC, 2013; OEC, 2015
Source: World Bank, 2014
Figure 15. Accessibility to industrial parks and free trade zones in Haiti and the Dominican Republic
Source: UN,2014
Figure 13. Mining concessions and protected areas in Haiti and the Dominican Republic
Source: Recursos del Caribe, S.A, 2014
12 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | Mar 2017 Mar 2017 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | 13
Infrastructure & Social Services
Haiti is the third most populated country in the Caribbean Dominican Republic is a country with high levels of inequality.
with an estimated population of over 10 million, but it is also Even though the country has experienced sustained economic
one of the most unequal societies in the world (OXFAM, 2017). growth over the past forty years, it has still produced very little
Although, most of the country is accessible within 1 hour of improvement for the most disadvantaged group of society
major roads, Haiti still lacks a high quality road network. Haiti (OXFAM, 2017). The country has expanded the coverage of health
also reports some of the worlds lowest health indicators and facilities in recent years in order to improve social safety. The
lacks a modern health system. Roughly 40% of the population literacy rate is 92% in Dominican Republic. However, it is worth
has access to essential health and nutrition services, and there noting that approximately 2% of youth have no formal education
are approximately four health professionals per 10,000 people. and 30% of them have not completed primary education, most
Haitis literacy rate is about 61% (64% for males and 57.3% for of whom are from the poorest population group (World Bank,
females) with 15,200 primary schools (World Bank, 2015). 2014).
Figure 16. Literacy rate in Haiti and Dominican Republic Figure 17. Access to Healthcare in Haiti and Dominican Republic
Source: UNDP, 2013; UNDP, 2014 Source: UNDP, 2013; UNDP, 2014
Accessibility Analysis
The concept of accessibility in the context of regional key locations within and outside of the region, using all
planning refers to the ability to effectively move people available modes of transportation. After performing a
and materials between critical locations, using existing spatial assessment of existing transportation networks, the
transportation infrastructure. Cost distance analysis provides results can be used to establish regional and sector-specific
an indication of accessibility for the region at multiple levels accessibility thresholds, which allow comparison between
(national, regional, and local). different supply chains, as well as the identification of
Figure 18. Literacy rate in Haiti and Dominican Republic (by department and province) An accessibility analysis considers the time to travel between infrastructure gaps or bottlenecks.
Source: UNDP, 2013; UNDP, 2014
14 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | Mar 2017 Mar 2017 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | 15
Summary Perceived Challenges
1. NATURAL
RESOURCES
Perceived Challenges Potential Next Steps
Percentage Forest cover (FAO, 2010) Percentage Land Cover as Protected Areas (FAO, 2010) Wide range of natural resources in both countries but Identification of most vulnerable natural resources
41% 25%
Haiti Haiti overexploitation is causing serious degradation of (anthropogenic and climate change pressures)
1. Natural
land and water resources. Particularly in Haiti there is and prioritization of measures and initiatives that
DR DR Resources
4% 0.3% an urgent need to protect forests and reduce topsoil can better enable local authorities to protect and
erosion. monitor them.
2. NATURAL AAL Value [million US$] Develop a national probabilisti crisk assessment for
DISASTERS Considering how both countries are exposed to
(UNISDR GAR, 2015) complex countries like Haiti and DR could require time
different risks and are vulnerable in different ways,
2. Natural and also data that are difficult to collect. It will be very
it will be critical to develop national probabilistic
Hurricane Earthquake Flood Disasters important to coordinate with different institutions that
risk assessments that can better estimate
have these data, as well as building off of any previous
potential economic and human losses.
hazard and risk assessments.
DR 509.16 DR 363.87 DR 100.83
Haiti 40.65 Haiti 119.53 Haiti 32.76 Lack of updated census data in Haiti, which creates the
Develop inequality assessments for both countries
3. Demographic difficulty on comparing social conditions for the two
in order to understand socioeconomic trends and
3. DEMOGRAPHIC and Socioeconomic countries, identification of causes of income inequality
the spatial pattern of current disparities.
AND SOCIOECONOMICS in the Dominican Republic.
Unemployment rate
There is a huge difference in economic performance Create a cross-island value-chain and human
Population below poverty line (2003 Haiti -2010 DR)
Haiti DR Source: CIA Factbook
Haiti DR between Haiti and the Dominican Republic. Human capital analysis for major sectors and products to
4. Economy and
Source: CIA Factbook
80% 34% 40% capital, infrastructure, and logistics issues are limiting help detect problems in current production and
15% Productivity
Haitis ability to expand and diversify its economic improve the efficiency for future production, as
sectors. well as identifying new areas for growth.
4. ECONOMY Lack of precise data about public infrastructure (hospital, Develop accessibility and level of service analyses
AND PRODUCTIVITY 5. Infrastructures clinic, health facility, schools, etc.), which inhibits the to understand current service gaps (roads, health
Export (Source: www.trademap.org) Import (Source: www.trademap.org)
and Social Services ability to accurately analyze service gaps and correlate facilities, education facilities). This can help point
human development indicators with access to facilities. out potential locations for public investment.
Access to Healthcare Paved roads Access to Secondary school Access to Secondary school Paved roads Access to Healthcare
40% 18% 22% 80% 50% 65%
16 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | Mar 2017 Mar 2017 | Rapid Baseline Assessment for the Hispaniola Island | 17
GeoAdaptive is a development planning and strategy company that specializes in the use of geospatial
technologies to solve complex economic, environmental, urban and social problems in a variety of
Global Experience
territories, scales and industries. We deploy and integrate advanced techniques in spatial economics, risk
analytics, socio-ecological modeling, and place-based design, to create robust strategies for our clients
worldwide, reducing their risk and maximizing their opportunities for sustainable and inclusive growth.
Our list of clients includes multilateral organizations, national and regional governments, infrastructure
banks, and foundations in more than 17 counties. Our experience expands across 6 practice areas:
Economic and Development Planning; Urban Sustainability; Environmental and Conservation; Climate
Change Risk and Resilience; Public Health, Food Security and Social Development; Land Analysis and
Tourism Strategy and Planning. Within these practice area our team offers multiple integrated and
interdisciplinary services.
Contact:
250 Summer Street, 1st Fl
Boston, MA 02210. USA
phone +1 617-227-8885
www.geoadaptive.com info@geoadaptive.com
GeoAdaptive LLC
@GeoAdaptive
This document was produced as a sample of GeoAdaptives work and should not be reproduced. The use of images or information
contained herein is prohibited except with the explicit written permission by GeoAdaptive. Some work is ongoing and the
information regarding these should not be considered final or official results. Any questions or concerns regarding the contents of
this document should be directed to GeoAdaptive