Peer Evaluation suggested template (not mandatory)

Name of evaluator: Skye Haks Name of person being evaluated: Gabrielle

Rothery

Brief overview of the designed product, environment or service: Constructing a

boat out of recycled materials

Process and Presen Quality of Comment

Production ted communicatio
Skill /Not n and design
presen process
ted

Satisfactory

absent Lacking or
Excellent

Evidence is Presente X Excellent

Investigating and Defning

presented that d understanding of the

demonstrates problem at hand
the critique of pollution within our
existing environment
solutions however, lacking
through detail in how the task
research and will be a solution
exploration of overall for our climate.
their nature.

In light of what Presente X Youve shown great

is known about d research into how our
existing environment has been
solutions, and effected by pollution.
through survey,
observation
and/or
questioning, the
designer show
evidence of
comprehensive
research and
analysis of
user/consumer/
audience/partici
pant needs.

Evidence is Presente X Evidence has been

presented that provided of the
 demonstrates d implications that
evaluation of pollution has on our
implications for environment now in
individuals, the present however
society and the you havent spoken
local and global too much about future
environment, impacts this could
now and in the have on the world.
future. Overall, great research
done!
The design is
shown to
respond to these
needs.

The design of Presente X There is a brief

the d explanation of the
solution/product/ design of the product,
environment is however there is lack
presented as a of detail as to how it
design brief. will relate to the
problem at hand.

An evaluative Presente X You have explained

Generating and designing

selection of d well how you will

options and make the boat water
alternative resistant and if it will
design choices push and pull
is evidenced in however you have no
the students included alternative
documentation. design choices and/or
This is achieved sketches to further
through an show your design
examination of process. Overall, it is a
specifications given that you are
and confident and have a
assumptions strong structure of the
that may include plan ahead.
the
manufacturing
process and risk
assessment, as
well as cultural
considerations,
workability,
materials,
aesthetics etc.
 Design choices Presente X You have described
demonstrate d well what materials
innovative and will be involved
creative thinking however there is no
and ideas. evidence of creative
thinking through
sketches and
production planning

The design is of Presente X This is a great design!

high quality and d However it would be
clearly great if it could backed
responsive to up professionally with
the needs sketches and more
identified in the planning.
first phase of
investigation.

A final design Presente X Your final design is

specification is d brilliant Gabby! So
presented that simplistic yet effective
outlines for students of a
purpose, younger age. No
aesthetics, mention of
characteristics, considerations for
target market, price and value for
cultural money was
considerations, mentioned, however it
price and value was not highly
for money etc. necessary as this was
made from recycled
A final design is materials.
presented.

A production Not X No production plan

Producing and implementing

plan and Presente timeline was evident

timeline is d
presented, with
any ad hoc
modifications
that were
necessary
during the
production
process.

A reflective, Presente X Three weeks worth of

production d blogging and
journal is reflection was evident
 presented, and well written.
documenting
the stages in the
production
process and its
management.

A product, Presente X The product has been

process, d constructed very well,
environment or and the steps have
service is been labelled clearly
presented and and is well written.
evaluated. (However there is no
evidence of evaluation
during the design
process, only within
the evaluation sub-
section itself).
Overall, the design
was well-thought out
and also creative!

Evidence is Presente X You have outlined

ng Evaluati

presented of d spectacularly the

insightful positives, negatives
evaluation and and overall learning